Anticorrelation between Surface and Subsurface Point Defects and the Impact on the Redox Chemistry of TiO2(110)

Effect of Formic Acid on the Outdiffusion of Ti Interstitials at TiO2 Surfaces: A DFT+U Investigation

Ti interstitials play a key role in the surface chemistry of TiO₂. However, because of their elusive behavior, proof of their participation in catalytic processes is difficult to obtain. Here, we used DFT+U calculations to investigate the interaction between formic acid (FA) and excess Ti atoms on the rutile-TiO₂(110) and anatase-TiO₂(101) surfaces. The excess Ti atoms favor FA dissociation, while decreasing the relative stability of the bidentate bridging coordination over the monodentate one. FA species interact significantly with the Ti interstitials, favoring their outdiffusion. Eventually, Ti atoms can emerge at the surface forming chelate species, which are more stable than monodentate FA species in the case of rutile, and are even energetically favored in the case of anatase. The presence of Ti adatoms that can directly participate to surface processes should then be considered when formic acid and possibly carboxylate-bearing species are adsorbed onto TiO₂ particles.

Subtle structure matters: boosting surface-directed photoelectron transfer via the introduction of specific monovalent oxygen vacancies in TiO2

Oxygen vacancies (O_v) are widely considered to play crucial roles in photocatalysis, but how and why they contribute to improved performances remains controversial. In this work, we studied the promotional effect of O_v on photoelectron transfer in TiO₂, using first-principles density functional theory calculations with correction for on-site Coulomb interactions. We explicitly identified three types of O_v with different charge states (i.e., charge-neutral , monovalent , divalent O_v²⁺) via electronic structure analysis. Electron transfer energy calculations revealed that the ionized O_v in anatase TiO₂ are able to collect excess electrons whereas those in the rutile phase are not. The presence of ionized O_v further endows anatase TiO₂ with directional electron transfer along the [100] orientation, in favor of anatase TiO₂(101) for photocatalytic reduction surpassing the (001) termination. After examining various combination modes of ionized O_v involving different charge states and spatial distributions, we demonstrated that the vertical chain in anatase TiO₂(101) is the most catalytically effective O_v pattern in TiO₂. These results signify the importance of subtle defects in photocatalysis and may assist future photocatalyst design toward higher photocatalytic efficiency.

Conversion of methanol on rutile TiO2(110) and tungsten oxide clusters: 2. The role of defects and electron transfer in bifunctional oxidic photocatalysts

The photochemical conversion of organic compounds on tailored transition metal oxide surfaces by UV irradiation has found wide applications ranging from the production of chemicals to the degradation of organic pollutants e.g. in waste water treatment. Here, we present a systematic surface science-based study of the UV photoconversion of methanol on a rutile TiO2(110) surface. Under the used conditions, the dominant photoreaction is the photo-oxidation forming formaldehyde, that is drastically boosted by the presence of adsorbed oxygen as well as (sub-)surface defects such as oxygen vacancies and Ti3+ interstitials. Moreover, a photostimulated and Ti3+ mediated C-C coupling was observed leading to the production of ethene. We have further deposited tungsten oxide clusters on the rutile surface and examined the impact on the methanol photochemistry. In this case, the C-C coupling can be suppressed. Surprisingly, especially for high Ti3+ contents the population of the photochemical pathway is quenched in favor of the population of the thermal reaction yielding more methane from the deoxygenation reaction. So, the common concept that long time charge separation is efficient by combining two photocatalysts with similar band gaps, but different work functions in order to enhance photochemical yields is apparently too naive for certain systems. We attribute the loss of photoproducts with tungsten oxide coadsorption to the "pinning" of Ti3+ centers and a related enhancement of electron density near the oxide clusters which makes a concomitant recombination of the photochemical relevant holes with the excess surface electrons more likely.

Kinetic Control of Oxygen Interstitial Interaction with TiO2(110) via the Surface Fermi Energy

Atomically clean surfaces of semiconducting oxides efficiently mediate the interconversion of gas-phase O₂ and solid-phase oxygen interstitial atoms (O_i). First-principles calculations together with mesoscale microkinetic modeling are employed for TiO₂(110) to determine reaction pathways, assess appropriate rate expressions, and obtain corresponding activation energies and pre-exponential factors. The Fermi energy (E_F) at the surface influences the rate-determining step for both injection and annihilation of O_i. The barriers range between 0.72-0.82 eV for injection and 0.60-2.34 eV for annihilation and may be manipulated through intentional control of E_F. At equilibrium, the microkinetic model and first-principles calculations indicate that interconversion of O_i species in the first and second sublayers limits the rate. The effective pre-exponential factors for injection and annihilation are surprisingly low, probably resulting from the use of simple Langmuir-like rate expressions to describe a complicated kinetic sequence.

Introducing catalysis in photocatalysis: What can be understood from surface science studies of alcohol photoreforming on TiO2

Mechanisms in heterogeneous photocatalysis have traditionally been interpreted by the band-structure model and analogously to electrochemistry. This has led to the establishment of 'band-engineering' as a leading principle for the discovery of more efficient photocatalysts. In such a picture, mainly thermodynamic aspects are taken into account, while kinetics are often ignored. This holds in particular for chemical kinetics, which are, other than those for charge carrier dynamics, often not at all considered for the interpretation of the catalysts' photocatalytic performance. However, while being usually neglected in photocatalyis, they are a traditional and powerful tool in thermal catalysis and are still applied with great success in this field. While surface science studies made substantial contributes to thermal catalysis, analogous studies in heterogeneous photocatalysis still play only a minor role. In this review, the authors show that the photo-physics of defined materials in well-defined environments can be correlated with photochemical events on a surface, highlighting the importance of well-characterized semiconductors for the interpretation of mechanisms in heterogeneous photochemistry. The work focuses on contributions from surface science, which were obtained for the model system of a titania single crystal and alcohol photo-reforming. It is demonstrated that only surface science studies have so far enabled the elucidation of molecularly precise reaction mechanisms, the determination of reaction intermediates and assignment of reactive sites. As the identification of these properties remain major prerequisites for a breakthrough in photocatalysis research, the work also discusses the implications of the findings for applied systems. In general, the results from surface science demonstrate that photocatalytic systems shall also be approached by a perspective originating from heterogeneous catalysis rather than solely from an electrochemical point of view.

An essential descriptor for the oxygen evolution reaction on reducible metal oxide surfaces

The number of excess electrons (NEE), as a descriptor, perfectly reproduces the OER volcano curve of TiO₂(110) plotted using ΔG_O – ΔG_OH.

The development of a universal activity descriptor like the d-band model for transition metal catalysts is of great importance to catalyst design. However, due to the complicated electronic structures of metal oxides, the correlation of the binding energies of reaction intermediates (*OH, *O, and *OOH) in the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) with experimentally controllable properties of metal oxides has not been well established. Here we demonstrate that excess electrons are the essential factor that governs the binding properties of intermediates on the surfaces of reducible metal oxides. We propose that the number of excess electrons (NEE) is an essential activity descriptor toward the OER activities of these oxides, which perfectly reproduces the volcano curve plotted using the descriptor ΔG_O – ΔG_OH, so that tuning NEE can effectively tailor the OER activities of reducible metal oxide based catalysts. Guided by this descriptor, we predict a novel non-precious catalyst with an overpotential of 0.54 eV, which could be a potential alternative to current Ru or Ir based catalysts.

Interplay between Adsorbates and Polarons: CO on Rutile TiO_{2}(110)

Polaron formation plays a major role in determining the structural, electrical, and chemical properties of ionic crystals. Using a combination of first-principles calculations, scanning tunneling microscopy, and atomic force microscopy, we analyze the interaction of polarons with CO molecules adsorbed on the reduced rutile TiO_{2}(110) surface. Adsorbed CO shows attractive coupling with polarons in the surface layer, and repulsive interaction with polarons in the subsurface layer. As a result, CO adsorption depends on the reduction state of the sample. For slightly reduced surfaces, many adsorption configurations with comparable adsorption energies exist and polarons reside in the subsurface layer. At strongly reduced surfaces, two adsorption configurations dominate: either inside an oxygen vacancy, or at surface Ti_{5c} sites, coupled with a surface polaron. Similar conclusions are predicted for TiO_{2}(110) surfaces containing near-surface Ti interstitials. These results show that polarons are of primary importance for understanding the performance of polar semiconductors and transition metal oxides in catalysis and energy-related applications.

Visualization of Water-Induced Surface Segregation of Polarons on Rutile TiO2(110)

Water-oxide surfaces are ubiquitous in nature and of widespread importance to phenomena like corrosion as well as contemporary industrial challenges such as energy production through water splitting. So far, a reasonably robust understanding of the structure of such interfaces under certain conditions has been obtained. Considerably less is known about how overlayer water modifies the inherent reactivity of oxide surfaces. Here we address this issue experimentally for rutile TiO₂(110) using scanning tunneling microscopy and photoemission, with complementary density functional theory calculations. Through detailed studies of adsorbed water nanoclusters and continuous water overlayers, we determine that excess electrons in TiO₂ are attracted to the top surface layer by water molecules. Measurements on methanol show similar behavior. Our results suggest that adsorbate-induced surface segregation of polarons could be a general phenomenon for technologically relevant oxide materials, with consequences for surface chemistry and the associated catalytic activity.

KPFM/AFM imaging on TiO2(110) surface in O2 gas

We have carried out high-speed imaging of the topography and local contact potential difference (LCPD) on rutile TiO₂(110) in O₂ gas by atomic force microscopy (AFM) and Kelvin probe force microscopy (KPFM). We succeeded in KPFM/AFM imaging with atomic resolution at 1 frame min^-1 and observed the adsorbate on a hydroxylated TiO₂(110) surface. The observed adsorbate is considered to be oxygen adatoms (O_a), hydroperoxyls (HO₂), or terminal hydroxyls (OH_t). After adsorption, changes in the topography and the LCPD of the adsorbate were observed. This phenomenon is thought to be caused by the charge transfer of the adsorbate. This technique has the potential to observe catalytic behavior with atomic resolution.

Self-Limiting Adsorption of WO3 Oligomers on Oxide Substrates in Solution

Electrochemical surface science of oxides is an emerging field with expected high impact in developing, for instance, rationally designed catalysts. The aim in such catalysts is to replace noble metals by earth-abundant elements, yet without sacrificing activity. Gaining an atomic-level understanding of such systems hinges on the use of experimental surface characterization techniques such as scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), in which tungsten tips have been the most widely used probes, both in vacuum and under electrochemical conditions. Here, we present an in situ STM study with atomic resolution that shows how tungsten(VI) oxide, spontaneously generated at a W STM tip, forms 1D adsorbates on oxide substrates. By comparing the behavior of rutile TiO₂(110) and magnetite Fe₃O₄(001) in aqueous solution, we hypothesize that, below the point of zero charge of the oxide substrate, electrostatics causes water-soluble WO₃ to efficiently adsorb and form linear chains in a self-limiting manner up to submonolayer coverage. The 1D oligomers can be manipulated and nanopatterned in situ with a scanning probe tip. As WO₃ spontaneously forms under all conditions of potential and pH at the tungsten-aqueous solution interface, this phenomenon also identifies an important caveat regarding the usability of tungsten tips in electrochemical surface science of oxides and other highly adsorptive materials.

Scenarios of polaron-involved molecular adsorption on reduced TiO2(110) surfaces

The polaron introduced by the oxygen vacancy (Vo) dominates many surface adsorption processes and chemical reactions on reduced oxide surfaces. Based on IR spectra and DFT calculations of NO and CO adsorption, we gave two scenarios of polaron-involved molecular adsorption on reduced TiO₂(110) surfaces. For NO adsorption, the subsurface polaron electron transfers to a Ti:3d-NO:2p hybrid orbital mainly on NO, leading to the large redshifts of vibration frequencies of NO. For CO adsorption, the polaron only transfers to a Ti:3d state of the surface Ti_5c cation underneath CO, and thus only a weak shift of vibration frequency of CO was observed. These scenarios are determined by the energy-level matching between the polaron state and the LUMO of adsorbed molecules, which plays a crucial role in polaron-adsorbate interaction and related catalytic reactions on reduced oxide surfaces.

Modulating the photocatalytic redox preferences between anatase TiO2{001} and {101} surfaces

The surface protonation/deprotonation can change the photocatalytic redox preferences of TiO₂{001} and {101} surfaces.