Benchmarking Water Oxidation Catalysts Based on Iridium Complexes: Clues and Doubts on the Nature of Active Species

Single-Site Iridium Picolinamide Catalyst Immobilized onto Silica for the Hydrogenation of CO2 and the Dehydrogenation of Formic Acid

The development of an efficient heterogeneous catalyst for storing H₂ into CO₂ and releasing it from the produced formic acid, when needed, is a crucial target for overcoming some intrinsic criticalities of green hydrogen exploitation, such as high flammability, low density, and handling. Herein, we report an efficient heterogeneous catalyst for both reactions prepared by immobilizing a molecular iridium organometallic catalyst onto a high-surface mesoporous silica, through a sol–gel methodology. The presence of tailored single-metal catalytic sites, derived by a suitable choice of ligands with desired steric and electronic characteristics, in combination with optimized support features, makes the immobilized catalyst highly active. Furthermore, the information derived from multinuclear DNP-enhanced NMR spectroscopy, elemental analysis, and Ir L₃-edge XAS indicates the formation of cationic iridium sites. It is quite remarkable to note that the immobilized catalyst shows essentially the same catalytic activity as its molecular analogue in the hydrogenation of CO₂. In the reverse reaction of HCOOH dehydrogenation, it is approximately twice less active but has no induction period.

We report the synthesis of a heterogeneous immobilized catalyst (Ir_PicaSi_SiO₂) and its successful application in aqueous CO₂ hydrogenation and FA dehydrogenation. The information derived from multinuclear DNP-enhanced NMR spectroscopy, elemental analysis, and XAS indicates the presence of cationic iridium sites in Ir_PicaSi_SiO₂. The latter shows essentially the same catalytic activity as its molecular analogue in the hydrogenation of CO₂. In the reverse reaction of HCOOH dehydrogenation, it is approximately twice less active but has no induction period.

Modulating the water oxidation catalytic activity of iridium complexes by functionalizing the Cp*-ancillary ligand: hints on the nature of the active species

A comparative study on the behavior of a series of iridium dimeric WOCs with modified Cp* ligands reveals the key role played by the variable substituent.

Molecular and heterogenized dinuclear Ir-Cp* water oxidation catalysts bearing EDTA or EDTMP as bridging and anchoring ligands

The development of efficient water oxidation catalysts (WOCs) is of key importance in order to drive sustainable reductive processes aimed at producing renewable fuels. Herein, two novel dinuclear complexes, [(Cp*Ir)₂(μ-κ³-O,N,O-H₄-EDTMP)] (Ir-H₄-EDTMP, H₄-EDTMP^4- = ethylenediamine tetra(methylene phosphonate)) and [(Cp*Ir)₂(μ-κ³-O,N,O-EDTA)] (Ir-EDTA, EDTA^4- = ethylenediaminetetraacetate), were synthesized and completely characterized in solution, by multinuclear and multidimensional NMR spectroscopy, and in the solid state, by single crystal X-Ray diffraction. They were supported onto rutile TiO₂ nanocrystals obtaining Ir-H₄-EDTMP@TiO₂ and Ir-EDTA@TiO₂ hybrid materials. Both molecular complexes and hybrid materials were found to be efficient catalysts for WO driven by NaIO₄, providing almost quantitative yields, and TON values only limited by the amount of NaIO₄ used. As for the molecular catalysts, Ir-H₄-EDTMP (TOF up to 184 min^-1) exhibited much higher activity than Ir-EDTA (TOF up to 19 min^-1), likely owing to the higher propensity of the former to generate a coordination vacancy through the dissociation of a Ir-OP bond (2.123 Å, significantly longer than Ir-OC, 2.0913 Å), which is a necessary step to activate these saturated complexes. Ir-H₄-EDTMP@TiO₂ (up to 33 min^-1) and Ir-EDTA@TiO₂ (up to 41 min^-1) hybrid materials showed similar activity that was only marginally reduced in the second and third catalytic runs carried out after having separated the supernatant, which did not show any sign of activity, instead. The observed TOF values for hybrid materials are higher than those reported for analogous systems deriving from heterogenized mononuclear complexes. This suggests that supporting dinuclear molecular precursors could be a successful strategy to obtain efficient heterogenized water oxidation catalysts.

Effect of Ligand Chelation and Sacrificial Oxidant on the Integrity of Triazole-Based Carbene Iridium Water Oxidation Catalysts

We report the effect of replacing the pyridine group in the chelating trz Ir-water oxidation catalysts by a benzoxazole and a thiazole moiety. We have also evaluated if the presence of bidentate ligands is crucial for high activities and to avoid the decomposition into undesired heterogeneous layers. The catalytic performance of these benzoxazole/thiazole-triazolidene Ir-complexes in water oxidation was studied at variable pH using either CAN (pH = 1) or NaIO₄ (pH = 5.6 and 7). Electrocatalytic experiments indicated that while CAN-mediated water oxidation led to catalyst heterogeneization irrespective of the triazolylidene substituent, periodate as sacrificial oxidant preserved a homogeneously active species. Repetitive additions of sacrificial oxidant indicates higher integrity of the Ir-complex with a thiazole-substituted triazolylidene compared to ligands featuring a benzoxazole as chelating donor or no chelating group at all. Rigid chelation of the thiazole group was also established from stability measurements under highly acidic, oxidizing, and high ionic strength conditions.

Iridium-Doped Nanosized Zn-Al Layered Double Hydroxides as Efficient Water Oxidation Catalysts

Layered double hydroxides (LDHs) are an ideal platform to host catalytic metal centers for water oxidation (WO) owing to the high accessibility of water to the interlayer region, which makes all centers potentially reachable and activated. Herein, we report the syntheses of three iridium-doped zinc-aluminum LDHs (Ir-LDHs) nanomaterials (1-3, with about 80 nm of planar size and a thickness of 8 nm as derived by field emission scanning electron microscopy and powder X-ray diffraction studies, respectively), carried out in the confined aqueous environment of reverse micelles, through a very simple and versatile procedure. These materials exhibit excellent catalytic performances in WO driven by NaIO4 at neutral pH and 25 °C, with an iridium content as low as 0.5 mol % (∼0.8 wt %), leading to quantitative oxygen yields (based on utilized NaIO4, turnover number up to ∼10,000). Nanomaterials 1-3 display the highest ever reported turnover frequency values (up to 402 min-1) for any heterogeneous and heterogenized catalyst, comparable only to those of the most efficient molecular iridium catalysts, tested under similar reaction conditions. The boost in activity can be traced to the increased surface area and pore volume (>5 times and 1 order of magnitude, respectively, higher than those of micrometric materials of size 0.3-1 μm) estimated for the nanosized particles, which guarantee higher noble metal accessibility. X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) studies suggest that 1-3 nanomaterials, as-prepared and after catalysis, contain a mixture of isolated, single octahedral Ir(III) sites, with no evidence of Ir-Ir scattering from second-nearest neighbors, excluding the presence of IrO2 nanoparticles. The combination of the results obtained from XAS, elemental analysis, and ionic chromatography strongly suggests that iridium is embedded in the brucite-like structure of LDHs, having four hydroxyls and two chlorides as first neighbors. These results demonstrate that nanometric LDHs can be successfully exploited to engineer efficient WOCs, minimizing the amount of iridium used, consistent with the principle of the noble-metal atom economy.

The Influence of the Ligand in the Iridium Mediated Electrocatalyic Water Oxidation

Electrochemical water oxidation is the bottleneck of electrolyzers as even the best catalysts, iridium and ruthenium oxides, have to operate at significant overpotentials. Previously, the position of a hydroxyl on a series of hydroxylpicolinate ligands was found to significantly influence the activity of molecular iridium catalysts in sacrificial oxidant driven water oxidation. In this study, these catalysts were tested under electrochemical conditions and benchmarked to several other known molecular iridium catalysts under the exact same conditions. This allowed us to compare these catalysts directly and observe whether structure–activity relationships would prevail under electrochemical conditions. Using both electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance experiments and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, we found that all studied iridium complexes form an iridium deposit on the electrode with binding energies ranging from 62.4 to 62.7 eV for the major Ir 4f_7/2 species. These do not match the binding energies found for the parent complexes, which have a broader binding energy range from 61.7 to 62.7 eV and show a clear relationship to the electronegativity induced by the ligands. Moreover, all catalysts performed the electrochemical water oxidation in the same order of magnitude as the maximum currents ranged from 0.2 to 0.6 mA cm^–2 once more without clear structure–activity relationships. In addition, by employing ¹H NMR spectroscopy we found evidence for Cp* breakdown products such as acetate. Electrodeposited iridium oxide from ligand free [Ir(OH)₆]^2– or a colloidal iridium oxide nanoparticles solution produces currents almost 2 orders of magnitude higher with a maximum current of 11 mA cm^–2. Also, this deposited material contains, apart from an Ir 4f_7/2 species at 62.4 eV, an Ir species at 63.6 eV, which is not observed for any deposit formed by the molecular complexes. Thus, the electrodeposited material of the complexes cannot be directly linked to bulk iridium oxide. Small IrO_x clusters containing few Ir atoms with partially incorporated ligand residues are the most likely option for the catalytically active electrodeposit. Our results emphasize that structure–activity relationships obtained with sacrificial oxidants do not necessarily translate to electrochemical conditions. Furthermore, other factors, such as electrodeposition and catalyst degradation, play a major role in the electrochemically driven water oxidation and should thus be considered when optimizing molecular catalysts.

Novel iridium complexes with N-heterocyclic dicarbene ligands in light-driven water oxidation catalysis: photon management, ligand effect and catalyst evolution

Iridium complexes [IrClCp*diNHC]PF6, with N-heterocyclic dicarbene (diNHC) and pentamethylcyclopentadienyl (Cp*) ligands, have been investigated in light driven water oxidation catalysis within the Ru(bpy)32+/S2O82- cycle (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine). In particular, the effect of different diNHC ligands was evaluated by employing the complex 1a (diNHC = 1,1'-dimethyl-3,3'-ethylenediimidazol-2,2'-diylidene) and the novel and structurally characterised 2 (diNHC = 1,1'-dimethyl-3,3'-ethylene-5,5'-dibromodiimidazol-2,2'-diylidene) and 3 (diNHC = 1,1'-dimethyl-3,3'-ethylene-dibenzimidazol-2,2'-diylidene). The presented results include: (i) a photon management analysis of the 1a/Ru(bpy)32+/S2O82- system, revealing two regimes of O2 evolution rate, being dependent on the light intensity at low photon flux, where the system reaches an overall quantum yield up to 0.17 ± 0.01 (quantum efficiency 34 ± 2%), while being independent of light intensity at high photon flux thus indicating a change of limiting step; (ii) a trend of O2 evolution activity that follows the order 1a > 2 > 3 both under low and high photon flux conditions, with the reactivity that is favoured by the electron donating nature of the diNHC ligand, quantified on the basis of the carbene carbon chemical shift; (iii) an analogous trend also in the bimolecular rate constants of electron transfer kET from the iridium species to photogenerated Ru(bpy)33+, with kET values in the range 4.2-6.1 × 104 M-1 s-1, thus implying a significant reorganisation energy to the iridium sphere; (iv) the evolution of 1a, as the most active Ir species in the series, to mononuclear iridium species with lower molecular weight and originating from oxidative transformation of the organic ligand scaffold, as proven by converging UV-Vis, MALDI-MS and 1H-NMR evidences. These results can be used for the further design and engineering of novel catalysts.

An iridium-based nanocomposite prepared from an iridium complex with a hydrocarbon-based ligand

For the first time, a chlorobis(cyclooctene)iridium(i) dimer with only a simple hydrocarbon-based ligand is investigated as a heterogeneous catalyst for the oxygen-evolution reaction in the presence of cerium(iv) ammonium nitrate.

Ir- and Ru-doped layered double hydroxides as affordable heterogeneous catalysts for electrochemical water oxidation

Doping low-cost LDHs with noble metal atoms represents a promising approach to develop effective heterogeneous Water Oxidation Catalysts.

Light-Driven Water Oxidation with the Catalyst and the Ru(bpy)32+/S2O82- Cycle: Photogeneration of Active Dimers, Electron-Transfer Kinetics, and Light Synchronization for Oxygen Evolution with High Quantum Efficiency

Light-driven water oxidation is achieved with the Ru(bpy)₃²⁺/S₂O₈^2- cycle employing the highly active Ir-blue water oxidation catalyst, namely, an Ir^IV,IV₂(pyalc)₂ μ-oxo-dimer [pyalc = 2-(2'-pyridyl)-2-propanoate]. Ir-blue is readily formed by stepwise oxidation of the monomeric Ir(III) precursor 1 by the photogenerated Ru(bpy)₃³⁺, with a quantum yield ϕ of up to 0.10. Transient absorption spectroscopy and kinetic evidence point to a stepwise mechanism, where the primary event occurs via a fast photoinduced electron transfer from 1 to Ru(bpy)₃³⁺, leading to the Ir(IV) monomer I₁ (k₁ ∼ 10⁸ M^-1 s^-1). The competent Ir-blue catalyst is then obtained from I₁ upon photooxidative loss of the Cp* ligand and dimerization. The Ir-blue catalyst is active in the Ru(bpy)₃²⁺/S₂O₈^2- light-driven water oxidation cycle, where it undergoes two fast photoinduced electron transfers to Ru(bpy)₃³⁺ [with k_Ir-blue = (3.00 ± 0.02) × 10⁸ M^-1 s^-1 for the primary event, outperforming iridium oxide nanoparticles by ca. 2 orders of magnitude], leading to a Ir^V,V₂ steady-state intermediate involved in O-O bond formation. The quantum yield for oxygen evolution depends on the photon flux, showing a saturation regime and reaching an impressive value of ϕ(O₂) = 0.32 ± 0.01 (corresponding to a quantum efficiency of 64 ± 2%) at low irradiation intensity. This result highlights the key requirement of orchestrating the rate of the photochemical events with dark catalytic turnover.

Pentanuclear iron catalysts for water oxidation: substituents provide two routes to control onset potentials

The development of robust and efficient molecular catalysts based on earth-abundant transition metals for water oxidation reactions is a challenging research target. Our group recently demonstrated the high activity and stability of a pentairon-based water oxidation electrocatalyst (M. Okamura, M. Kondo, R. Kuga, Y. Kurashige, T. Yanai, S. Hayami, V. K. K. Praneeth, M. Yoshida, K. Yoneda, S. Kawata and S. Masaoka, Nature, 2016, 530, 465-468). However, the development of strategies to decrease onset potentials for catalysis remains challenging. In this article, we report the construction of a series of pentanuclear iron complexes by introducing electron-donating (methyl) and electron-withdrawing (bromo) substituents on the ligand. Two newly synthesized complexes exhibited five reversible redox processes, similar to what is seen with the parent complex. These complexes can also serve as homogeneous catalysts for water oxidation reactions, and the faradaic efficiencies of the reactions were high. Additionally, the onset potentials of the newly developed complexes were lower than that of the parent complex. Mechanistic insights revealed that there are two methods for decreasing onset potentials: control of the redox potentials of the pentairon complex and control of the reaction mechanism.

Molecular water oxidation catalysis by zwitterionic carboxylate bridge-functionalized bis-NHC iridium complexes

Carboxylate functionalized bis-NHC ligands allow for the stabilization of high-valent iridium intermediate species involved in homogeneous water oxidation catalysis.

Electrochemical and Kinetic Insights into Molecular Water Oxidation Catalysts Derived from Cp*Ir(pyridine-alkoxide) Complexes

We report the solution-phase electrochemistry of seven half-sandwich iridium(III) complexes with varying pyridine-alkoxide ligands to quantify electronic ligand effects that translate to their activity in catalytic water oxidation. Our results unify some previously reported electrochemical data of Cp*Ir complexes by showing how the solution speciation determines the electrochemical response: cationic complexes show over 1 V higher redox potentials that their neutral forms in a distinct demonstration of charge accumulation effects relevant to water oxidation. Building on previous work that analysed the activation behaviour of our pyalk-ligated Cp*Ir complexes 1-7, we assess their catalytic oxygen evolution activity with sodium periodate (NaIO4) and ceric ammonium nitrate (CAN) in water and aqueous tBuOH solution. Mechanistic studies including H/D kinetic isotope effects and reaction progress kinetic analysis (RPKA) of oxygen evolution point to a dimer-monomer equilibrium of the IrIV resting state preceding a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) in the turnover-limiting step (TLS). Finally, true electrochemically driven water oxidation is demonstrated for all catalysts, revealing surprising trends in activity that do not correlate with those obtained using chemical oxidants.