Ontogeny of seizure incidence, latency, and severity in genetically epilepsy prone rats

Genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPRs) and DBA/2 mice: Two animal models of audiogenic reflex epilepsy for the evaluation of new generation AEDs

This review summarizes the current knowledge about DBA/2 mice and genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPRs) and discusses the contribution of such animal models on the investigation of possible new therapeutic targets and new anticonvulsant compounds for the treatment of epilepsy. Also, possible chemical or physical agents acting as proconvulsant agents are described. Abnormal activities of enzymes involved in catecholamine and serotonin synthesis and metabolism were reported in these models, and as a result of all these abnormalities, seizure susceptibility in both animals is greatly affected by pharmacological manipulations of the brain levels of monoamines and, prevalently, serotonin. In addition, both genetic epileptic models permit the evaluation of pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic interactions among several drugs measuring plasma and/or brain level of each compound. Audiogenic models of epilepsy have been used not only for reflex epilepsy studies, but also as animal models of epileptogenesis. The seizure predisposition (epileptiform response to sound stimulation) and substantial characterization of behavioral, cellular, and molecular alterations in both acute and chronic (kindling) protocols potentiate the usefulness of these models in elucidating ictogenesis, epileptogenesis, and their mechanisms. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled "Genetic and Reflex Epilepsies, Audiogenic Seizures and Strains: From Experimental Models to the Clinic".

Animal models of inherited epilepsy

A significant proportion of the childhood epilepsies have a genetic component. Therefore, animal models that can be bred for seizure expression may provide important information regarding the mechanisms by which molecular defects result in the neuronal hyperexcitability states collectively termed "epilepsy." Because of the rate and ease of breeding, rodent models are the most commonly used. The genetically epilepsy-prone rat has motor seizures in response to auditory stimuli. It is likely that the seizures are generated in the inferior colliculus because of an abnormality in the noradrenergic system. The seizure predisposition is inherited as an autosomal dominant trait. The genetic absence epilepsy rat has age-related spontaneous seizures characterized by motor arrest and head drops that are correlated with generalized spike-wave on the electroencephalogram (EEG). The seizure generating mechanism appears to be located in the lateral thalamic nuclei. The epileptic mongolian gerbil demonstrates behavioral arrest followed by myoclonic, tonic, and tonic-clonic seizures in response to unfamiliar environments. The underlying neuroanatomy involves hippocampal-cortical interactions indicative of a partial epilepsy. The tottering mouse has absence and myoclonic seizures, a 6- to 7-Hz ictal spike-wave EEG, and noradrenergic hyperinnervation that are linked to a mutation on chromosome 8. Hippocampal network hyperexcitability has been found with normal neuronal intrinsic properties. Stargazer is a mouse mutant with almost identical clinical and electrographic features as found in tottering. However, the genetic defect is located on chromosome 15 and no abnormalities of norepinephrine have been discovered. The El mouse demonstrates ictal automatisms in response to vestibular stimulation. Metabolic and structural abnormalities have been found in the hippocampus. Linkage to chromosomes 9 and 2 have been reported recently. The dilute brown agouiti mouse demonstrates motor seizures in response to auditory stimuli. Chromosomes 4 and 17 are linked to seizure expression. Thus, a variety of models exist to study the genetic, biochemical, structural and electrophysiological mechanisms that underlie the predisposition and expression of the inherited epilepsies.

Ontogenetic study of metaphit-induced audiogenic seizures in rats

Ontogenetic differences in susceptibility to metaphit (1-(1-(3-isothiocyanatophenyl)cyclohexyl)-piperidine)-induced audiogenic seizures were examined in young, developing (ages: 12, 18, and 25 days) and adult (90 days old) Wistar albino rats. Metaphit was injected in a dose of 10 mg/kg i.p. and animals were subjected to intense audio stimulation (100 +/- 3 dB, 60 s) at hourly intervals after administration. Audiogenic seizures (AGS) were scored according to a four point descriptive rating scale (0-3). AGS were elicited in all age groups; they were induced for 12, 15, 15, and 30 h in 12-, 18-, 25-day-old, and adult rats, respectively. Younger animals reached a peak incidence and severity of seizures before adult rats. Twenty-five-day-old rats showed greatest incidence and severity of seizures, and shortest latency. Twelve-day-old animals had longest latencies. Besides audiogenic seizures, we observed convulsions induced by metaphit only in the form of running episodes, forelimb clonus, clonic convulsions, and rearing. Results suggest that young rats develop metaphit-induced sound seizures more rapidly, but that adults have longer period of seizure susceptibility. Different susceptibility to seizures is probably due to changes in excitatory and inhibitory pathways, while maturation of blood-brain barrier is less probable, since metaphit has a lipophilic nature.

Neuroimaging of animal models of brain disease

The main aim of this review is to describe some of the many animal models that have proved to be valuable from a neuroimaging perspective. This paper complements other articles in this volume, with a focus on animal models of the pathology of human brain disorders for investigations with modern non-invasive neuroimaging techniques. The use of animal model systems forms a fundamental part of neuroscience research efforts to improve the prevention, diagnosis, understanding and treatment of neurological conditions. Without such models it would be impossible to investigate such topics as the underlying mechanisms of neuronal cell damage and death, or to screen compounds for possible anticonvulsant properties. The adequacy of any one particular model depends on the suitability of information gained during experimental conditions. It is important, therefore, to understand the various types of animal model available and choose an appropriate model for the research question.

A critical review on the participation of inferior colliculus in acoustic-motor and acoustic-limbic networks involved in the expression of acute and kindled audiogenic seizures

The main goal of this article is to review the key role that the inferior colliculus plays in the expression of acoustic-motor and acoustic-limbic integration involved, respectively, in acute and chronic audiogenic seizures. In order to put this in context, we will review the behavioral characterization of acute and chronic audiogenic seizures, neuroanatomical substrates, neurochemistry, neuropharmacology, electrophysiology, as well as the cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in their expression. Secondly, we will also correlate our results, collected from audiogenic seizures susceptible rats, before and after the genetic selection of our own audiogenic susceptible strain, and from those sensitized by lesions or drug microinjections, with those pertinent from the international literature. In brief, genetic or sensitized animals express acute audiogenic seizures as a wild running behavior preceding the onset of tonic-clonic seizures. The latter can have several presentations including opistotonus and fore- and hindlimb tonic hyperextensions, followed by clonic convulsions of fore- and hindlimbs. Chronic (kindled) audiogenic seizures change this behavioral expression, with similar patterns such as those present in temporal lobe epileptic seizures, intermingled with the original audiogenic seizure pattern, which is known to be dependent on brainstem networks.

Alteration in levels of expression of brain calbindin D-28k and calretinin mRNA in genetically epilepsy-prone rats

Variations in the concentration of free calcium in neurons is believed to play a major role in regulating neuronal excitability. Because calcium-binding proteins such as calbindin D-28k and calretinin help to regulate intracellular calcium, we investigated the possibility that the expression of these proteins may be affected in genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPRs). The mRNA levels of both proteins were compared across several brain regions using in situ hybridization histochemistry and Northern blot analysis with semiquantitation by optical density measures in autoradiograms from two GEPR strains that differ in the severity of audiogenic seizures (GEPR9 and GEPR3) and from Sprague-Dawley rats. Results revealed a lower level of expression in calbindin D-28k mRNA in the in the caudate putamen-accumbens nuclei in GEPR3 (-30%) and GEPR9 (-60%) relative to controls. The calbindin D-28k mRNA level was also lower in the reuniens nucleus of the thalamus (-41% in GEPR3; -34% in GEPR9). The calretinin mRNA level was lower in the substantia nigra compacta of both GEPR rat strains (-31% in GEPR3 and -34% in GEPR9 relative to controls). No changes in mRNA were detected in other brain regions expressing calbindin D-28k or calretinin mRNA. These results indicate that the expression of these related calcium-binding proteins is altered in the GEPRs before the induction of seizures. This initial defect could alter either the calcium-buffering capacity or regulation of calcium-mediated processes by these proteins and thus play a role in the molecular cascade of events inducing the genetic susceptibility to, and the generalization of, seizures in these rat strains.

The role of the inferior colliculus in a genetic model of audiogenic seizures

Previous studies have shown the functional importance of the inferior colliculus (IC) for the propagation and initiation of audiogenic seizures in several models of epilepsy in rats. A review of the cell types and cytoarchitecture of the IC, including its three major subdivisions, is presented. Significant increases in GABA levels and the number of GABAergic neurons are found in the central nucleus of the IC (ICCN) of genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPR-9s) as compared to Sprague-Dawley rats that do not display audiogenic seizures. Two independent anatomical methods were used to determine the number of GABAergic neurons, immunocytochemistry and in situ hybridization. In both types of preparation, the labeled cells in the ICCN appeared to be of different sizes but the number of small cells with diameters less than 15 microns showed the greatest increase. Nissl-stained sections showed that the total number of neurons in the ICCN was increased in GEPR-9s and indicated that the increase in GABAergic neurons was not due to a change in the phenotype of collicular neurons from non-GABAergic to GABAergic. The number of small neurons in Nissl-stained sections of the ICCN was shown to correlate with seizure severity in the offspring of crosses made between Sprague-Dawley rats and GEPR-9s. Furthermore, the GEPR-3s that display moderate seizures showed a significant increase in the number of small neurons in the ICCN, and the magnitude of this increase was predicted from this correlation. Finally, the use of knife cuts through the midbrain indicated that the ICCN sends an important projection to the external nucleus and that this projection plays a vital role in the propagation of seizure activity from the site of seizure initiation in the ICCN. It remains to be resolved how the increase in small GABAergic neurons in the ICCN is responsible for the known pharmacological defects observed at GABAergic synapses.

The genetically epilepsy-prone rat (GEPR)

Two independently inbred strains of genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPRs) have been developed. GEPR-3s and GEPR-9s have moderate and severe degrees of seizure predisposition as well as expression, respectively. Seizure predisposition is a fundamental distinction between the normal and epileptic brain. Seizure predisposition in GEPRs and in humans with epilepsy includes spontaneous seizures and exaggerated seizure responsiveness and/or abnormally low thresholds to stimuli which also cause seizures in non-epileptic subjects. Activation of brainstem seizure circuitry by auditory input via the inferior colliculus causes electrographic and behavioral responses in GEPR-9s which replicates human generalized tonic/clonic seizures. Activation of brainstem seizure circuitry by input from forebrain seizure circuitry in GEPRs provides a newly discovered model of complex partial seizures with secondary generalization to tonic/clonic seizures. Thus, seizure predisposition in GEPRs offers a unique opportunity to study the human epilepsies that is not offered in studies of normal brain exposed to convulsant stimuli.

Midbrain substrates of audiogenic seizures in rats

Audiogenic seizures (AS) are a rodent model of generalized tonic-clonic seizures, induced in susceptible (S) animals by high intensity (110 dB) acoustic stimulation. Resistant (R) animals do not respond to the sound with any seizure-related behavior, but they display facial automatisms and grooming clusters. Genetic selection and neuroethology are the basic tools used in our laboratory to perform behavioral analysis of AS S and R animals. Based upon selective lesion and microinjection (GABA, clobazam, NMDA) studies of substantia nigra (SN), inferior colliculus (IC), superior colliculus (SC), and on specific knife cuts at midcollicular levels, we have suggested differential roles for these substrates in the origin and spreading of AS. The IC central nucleus is suggested to be the most critical area involved in the afferent pathway whose activation is necessary for AS origin. IC cortical nuclei seem to be the most important structures involved in the transduction of sensory to motor activity. SC, SN and other reticular subnuclei are suggested to be modulators or components of the efferent pathway. Although the midbrain is considered to be the only network necessary for acute AS origin, both emotion-linked acoustic memories and plastic changes linked to audiogenic kindling involve midbrain-forebrain connections. This paper reviews the behavioral manifestations of acute and chronic AS, our contribution to the knowledge of some AS neurobiological midbrain substrates and the suggested implications of midbrain-forebrain interactions typical of AS kindling.

A genetic, physiological, and biochemical investigation of audiogenic seizures in rats

Two kinds of audiogenic seizures are characteristic of the KM rat strain, selected by Krushinsky and Molodkina in Moscow in the 1940s. This strain is now approximately 100% sound sensitive. Diallel crosses have demonstrated the polygenic nature of this behavior, with most alleles for seizures being recessive. Myoclonic seizures which develop after several sound exposures are a special form of kindling, involving the limbic system. Selection for low and high rates of myoclonic seizures was successful. Several unique, physiological features of the audiogenic seizures in this rat strain are described, as well as data on RNA and protein synthesis inhibition effects on seizure formation.

Noise exposure-induced audiogenic seizure susceptibility in Sprague-Dawley rats

Parameters were evaluated for the optimum induction of audiogenic seizure susceptibility in Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats by noise exposure. The effect of maturation on this susceptibility was also examined. It was found that SD rats are most inducible between neonatal days 13 and 15 and that susceptibility requires a minimum of 2 days to develop. Noise exposure on day 14 results in universal susceptibility by day 20, but seizure severity is not maximal until days 32-36. Although susceptibility persists at high levels into adulthood, seizures in older rats revert to the wild-running-only type. Seizure latency (from stimulus onset to onset of wild running) becomes increasingly shorter during the prepubescent period (days 16-24) but is stable at older ages. The mean shortness of latency in adult seizures depends somewhat on the age when initial noise exposure occurred; day-14 noise exposures result in seizures with shortest latencies. Ontogenetic comparisons were made of susceptibility in these noise exposure-induced rats, genetically epilepsy prone rats (GEPRs, which are SD substrains)29 and noise exposure-induced Wistar (WI) rats28. It appears that epileptogenesis begins at virtually the same age in all four groups of rats but that considerable differences characterize the absolute severity of seizures and the age dependence of maximum seizure severity among the strains.

Effects of age on seizure susceptibility in genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPR-9s)

To study the effect of age on seizure latency, intensity, reproducibility, and mortality in genetically epilepsy-prone rats of the severe colony (GEPR-9s), 472 seizure-naive rats, ranging in age from 14 to 65 days, received a series of three audiogenic stimulations. Both the percentage of rats having one or more seizures and the percentage of seizures that were stage 9 generally increased with advancing age of the animal at the time of the first stimulation. Mean latency to seizure onset decreased while seizure intensity increased with increasing age of the animal. Reproducibility of seizure stage also increased with advancing age of the animal. The effects of senescence on seizure susceptibility were also investigated in an additional 18 prepubescent rats (25-35 days) who received three audiogenic stimulations and were tested again between the ages of 480 and 540 days with identical testing procedures. No significant changes occurred with either latency to seizure onset or seizure intensity in rats tested during prepubescence and again at senescence. Although GEPR-9s provide an excellent model of inherited seizures, latency to seizure onset, seizure intensity, and seizure reproducibility is dependent on age of the animal. Once established, however, audiogenic-induced seizures persist throughout life.

Effects of seizures on learning, memory, and behavior in the genetically epilepsy-prone rat

To determine whether frequent seizures can cause deficits in learning and behavior, immature genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPRs) were subjected to 66 audiogenic stimulations (Group 1). GEPR littermates were handled and placed in the sound chamber but were not stimulated (Group 2). Group 3 comprised genetically epilepsy-resistant rats (GERRs) who received audiogenic stimulations but had no seizures. After 3 weeks of stimulations the rats were tested for learning, memory, and behavior using the T-maze, water maze, open field activity test, home cage intruder test, and handling test. When compared with the control GEPRs and GERRs, Group 1 rats reached criteria less frequently in the T-maze, required longer times to find the platform in the water maze, and were less active in the open field activity test, less aggressive in the home cage intruder test, and more irritable and aggressive in the handling test. This study demonstrates that frequent, brief seizures in immature animals result in significant detrimental changes in learning, memory, activity level, and behavior.

Animal models of the epilepsies

The study of mechanisms of the epilepsies requires employment of animal models. Choice of a model system depends upon several factors, including the question to be studied, the type of epilepsy to be modelled, familiarity and convenience. Over 50 models are reviewed. Major categories of models are those for simple partial seizures: topical convulsants, acute electrical stimulation, cortically implanted metals, cryogenic injury; for complex partial seizures: kainic acid, tetanus toxin, injections into area tempesta, kindling, rodent hippocampal slice, isolated cell preparations, human neurosurgical tissue; for generalized tonic-clonic seizures: genetically seizure-prone strains of mouse, rat, gerbil, fruitfly and baboon, maximal electroshock seizures, systemic chemical convulsants, metabolic derangements; and for generalized absence seizures: thalamic stimulation, bilateral cortical foci, systemic penicillin, gamma-hydroxy-butyrate, intraventricular opiates, genetic rat models. The lithium-pilocarpine, homocysteine and rapid repetitive stimulation models are most useful in studies of status epilepticus. Key findings learned from each of the models, the model's strengths and weaknesses are detailed. Interpretation of findings from each of these models can be difficult. Do results pertain to the epilepsies or to the particular model under study? How important are species differences? Which clinical seizure type is really being modelled? In a model are behavior or EEG findings only similar superficially to epilepsy, or are the mechanisms comparable? The wealth of preparations available to model the epilepsies underscores the need for unifying themes, and for better understanding of basic mechanisms of the epilepsies.

Ontogeny of sound-induced seizures in the genetically epilepsy-prone rat

Seizure responsiveness of the adult genetically epilepsy-prone rat (GEPR) is well documented. Much less is known about the ontogeny to seizure activity in the GEPR. In the present study, members of the moderate seizure (GEPR-3) and severe seizure (GEPR-9) colonies were tested for susceptibility to sound-induced seizures at 11 different ages ranging from 13 to 45 days post partum. Running episodes first appeared in GEPR-3s at 15 days post partum. Clonic seizures first appeared in GEPR-3s and GEPR-9s at 15 and 16 days post partum, respectively. Seizure incidence reached 100% by post partum day 21 in both colonies. GEPR-3s exhibited a 100% incidence of their characteristic clonic seizure at day 21. GEPR-9s exhibited a 77.3% incidence of clonic seizure and a 22.7% incidence of their adult characteristic tonic seizure at day 21. Tonic seizures first appeared in GEPR-9s at day 18 and increased in incidence over time reaching 100% by day 45. Two unexpected findings occurred in GEPR-3s. First, secondary rearing seizures were detected in all GEPR-3s exhibiting clonic seizures between day 16 and 21. Second, GEPR-3s exhibited a transient susceptibility between 19 and 27 days post partum to the more severe tonic seizures characteristic of adult GEPR-9s. Peak incidence of tonic seizures in GEPR-3s was 70%, occurring at day 23. The adult GEPR-3 pattern of 100% incidence of clonic seizures was restored by day 45.

Developing genetically epilepsy-prone rats have an abnormal seizure response to flurothyl

Development of clonic-tonic flurothyl-induced seizures was examined in both normal and genetically epilepsy-prone rats (GEPRs). At each age, from 10 to 30 days, clonus occurred at significantly shorter latencies in GEPRs than in normal rats. The latency to onset of clonic seizures did not change with age, however, in either GEPRs or normal rats. A different pattern of response was observed in the progression to tonic seizures. As normal animals matured, the latency to tonic seizures became longer and, by day 30, the duration of flurothyl exposure necessary to induce tonus was almost 70% greater in normal rats than in the GEPRs. In contrast, in GEPRs, tonic extension occurred immediately following the onset of clonus throughout development. A subset of GEPRs failed to have audiogenic seizures in a 40-day posttest. These animals had a flurothyl response identical to their audiogenic-susceptible litter mates. These data suggest that (a) a protective mechanism which develops against tonic seizures in normal rats fails to mature in the GEPR, and (b) seizure inducing gene-linked neural abnormalities occur in the GEPR independent of pathologies underlying audiogenic seizures.