Chromatin structure and imprinting: developmental control of DNase-I sensitivity in the mouse insulin-like growth factor 2 gene

Calling differentially methylated regions from whole genome bisulphite sequencing with DMRcate

Whole genome bisulphite sequencing (WGBS) permits the genome-wide study of single molecule methylation patterns. One of the key goals of mammalian cell-type identity studies, in both normal differentiation and disease, is to locate differential methylation patterns across the genome. We discuss the most desirable characteristics for DML (differentially methylated locus) and DMR (differentially methylated region) detection tools in a genome-wide context and choose a set of statistical methods that fully or partially satisfy these considerations to compare for benchmarking. Our data simulation strategy is both biologically informed-employing distribution parameters derived from large-scale consortium datasets-and thorough. We report DML detection ability with respect to coverage, group methylation difference, sample size, variability and covariate size, both marginally and jointly, and exhaustively with respect to parameter combination. We also benchmark these methods on FDR control and computational time. We use this result to backend and introduce an expanded version of DMRcate: an existing DMR detection tool for microarray data that we have extended to now call DMRs from WGBS data. We compare DMRcate to a set of alternative DMR callers using a similarly realistic simulation strategy. We find DMRcate and RADmeth are the best predictors of DMRs, and conclusively find DMRcate the fastest.

CTCF is the master organizer of domain-wide allele-specific chromatin at the H19/Igf2 imprinted region

A paternally methylated imprinting control region (ICR) directs allele-specific expression of the imprinted H19 and Igf2 genes. CTCF protein binding in the ICR is required in the maternal chromosome for insulating Igf2 from the shared enhancers, initiation of the H19 promoter transcription, maintaining DNA hypomethylation, and chromosome loop formation. Using novel quantitative allele-specific chromatin immunoprecipitation-single-nucleotide primer extension assays, we measured the chromatin composition along the H19/Igf2 imprinted domain in cells with engineered mutations at the four ICR-CTCF binding sites. Abolishing CTCF binding in the ICR reduced normally maternal allele-specific H3K9 acetylation and H3K4 methylation at the H19 ICR and promoter/gene body and maternal allele-specific H3K27 trimethylation at the Igf2 P2 promoter and Igf2 differentially methylated regions (DMRs). Paternal H3K27 trimethylation and macroH2A1 became biallelic in the mutant cells at the H19 promoter while paternal H3K9 acetylation and H3K4 methylation became biallelic at the Igf2 DMRs. We provide evidence that CTCF is the single major organizer of allele-specific chromatin composition in this domain. This finding has important implications: (i) for mechanisms of insulation since CTCF regulates chromatin at a distance, involving repression by H3K27 trimethylation at the Igf2 locus independently of repression by DNA hypermethylation; and (ii) for mechanisms of genomic imprinting since point mutations of CTCF binding sites cause domain-wide "paternalization" of the maternal allele's chromatin composition.

Transcriptional regulation and biological significance of the insulin like growth factor II gene

The insulin like growth factors I and II are the most ubiquitous in the mammalian embryo. Moreover they play a pivotal role in the development and growth of tumours. The bioavailability of these growth factors is regulated on a transcriptional as well as on a posttranslational level. The expression of non-signalling receptors as well as binding proteins does further tune the local concentration of IGFs. This paper aims at reviewing how the transcription of the IGF genes is regulated. The biological significance of these control mechanisms will be discussed.

Epigenetic regulation of the imprinted U2af1-rs1 gene during retinoic acid-induced differentiation of embryonic stem cells

Epigenetic modifications such as DNA methylation and changes in chromatin structure are changes in the chemical composition or structure of DNA that work by regulating gene expression. Their mechanisms of action have been generally studied in imprinted genes. The present work analyzes the involvement of these mechanisms in the expression of the U2af1-rs1 imprinted gene during the differentiation process of embryonic stem (ES) cells induced by retinoic acid. By DNA digestion with methylation-dependent or independent restriction enzymes and consecutive Southern blot, we have found that methylation of the U2af1-rs1 gene increases in differentiated ES cells and in embryoid bodies. However, northern blot and real-time reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction analysis showed a higher expression of the U2af1-rs1 gene in differentiated ES cells and in embryoid bodies than in undifferentiated ones. On the other hand, the sensitivity to DNase-I assay demonstrated an open chromatin conformation for differentiated cells with regard to undifferentiated ES cells. Our results suggest that the expression of the U2af1-rs1 gene would be regulated by changes in chromatin structure rather than by DNA methylation during the RA-induced process of differentiation of ES cells.

Structural and functional preservation of specific sequences of DNA and mRNA in apoptotic bodies from ES cells

Retinoic acid-induced apoptosis of embryonic stem (ES) cells is an experimental system which resembles the physiological programmed cell death that occurs during differentiation in embryonic development. Our aim was to analyze the involvement of epigenetic modifications such as DNA methylation and chromatin structure in the apoptotic process and to investigate the metabolic activity of apoptotic bodies. We found a relationship between DNA methylation and apoptosis, shown by a dose-dependent induction of apoptosis after treatment with the inhibitor of DNA methylation 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine. Interestingly, we found a slight demethylation of specific sequences of the U2afl-rs1 imprinted gene in those RA treated cells which were specifically undergoing apoptosis. In addition, apoptotic bodies exhibited an unexpected open chromatin conformation accessible to the endonuclease DNase-I. Furthermore, we observed a structural and functional preservation of specific DNA sequences and mRNA. These results suggest that biological activities, such as transcription or protein synthesis, could be maintained even towards the end of the apoptotic process.

Transcription cooperation by NFAT.C/EBP composite enhancer complex

The nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT) group of transcription factors regulates gene expression in immune and non-immune cells. NFAT-mediated gene transcription is orchestrated, in part, by formation of a composite regulatory element. Here we demonstrate that NFAT interacts with transcription factor CCAAT/enhancer-binding protein (C/EBP) to form a composite enhancer complex, to potentiate expression of the peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma2 gene. Formation of a ternary NFAT.C/EBP.DNA complex is required for the transcriptional cooperation. A similar NFAT.C/EBP composite element is found in the regulatory region of the insulin-like growth factor 2, angiotensin-converting enzyme homolog, and transcription factor POU4F3 genes. Thus, the NFAT.C/EBP composite element represents a novel regulatory enhancer to direct NFAT-mediated gene transcription.

Imprinting regulation of the murine Meg1/Grb10 and human GRB10 genes; roles of brain-specific promoters and mouse-specific CTCF-binding sites

The imprinted mouse gene Meg1/Grb10 is expres sed from maternal alleles in almost all tissues and organs, except in the brain, where it is expressed biallelically, and the paternal allele is expressed preferentially in adulthood. In contrast, the human GRB10 gene shows equal biallelic expression in almost all tissues and organs, while it is almost always expressed paternally in the fetal brain. To elucidate the molecular mechanisms of the complex imprinting patterns among the different tissues and organs of humans and mice, we analyzed in detail both the genomic structures and tissue-specific expression profiles of these species. Experiments using 5'-RACE and RT-PCR demonstrated the existence in both humans and mice of novel brain- specific promoters, in which only the paternal allele was active. The promoters were located in the primary differentially methylated regions. Interest ingly, CTCF-binding sites were found only in the mouse promoter region where CTCF showed DNA methylation-sensitive binding activity. Thus, the insulator function of CTCF might cause reciprocal maternal expression of the Meg1/Grb10 gene from another upstream promoter in the mouse, whereas the human upstream promoter is active in both parental alleles due to the lack of the corresponding insulator sequence in this region.

An upstream repressor element plays a role in Igf2 imprinting

The imprinted Igf2 gene is associated with a small upstream region that is differentially methylated on the active paternal allele. We have identified a repressor element within this sequence and shown that repression is probably mediated through a trans- acting factor, GCF2. DNA methylation of this site abrogates both protein binding and repressor activity. Targeting experiments demonstrate that this element plays a role in the repression of the maternal Igf2 gene in vivo.

Relationship between DNA methylation, histone H4 acetylation and gene expression in the mouse imprinted Igf2-H19 domain

DNA methylation and histone H4 acetylation play a role in gene regulation by modulating the structure of the chromatin. Recently, these two epigenetic modifications have dynamically and physically been linked. Evidence suggests that both modifications are involved in regulating imprinted genes - a subset of genes whose expression depends on their parental origin. Using immunoprecipitation assays, we investigate the relationship between DNA methylation, histone H4 acetylation and gene expression in the well-characterised imprinted Igf2-H19 domain on mouse chromosome 7. A systematic regional analysis of the acetylation status of the domain shows that parental-specific differences in acetylation of the core histone H4 are present in the promoter regions of both Igf2 and H19 genes, with the expressed alleles being more acetylated than the silent alleles. A correlation between DNA methylation, histone hypoacetylation and gene repression is evident only at the promoter region of the H19 gene. Treatment with trichostatin A, a specific inhibitor of histone deacetylase, reduces the expression of the active maternal H19 allele and this can be correlated with regional changes in acetylation within the upstream regulatory domain. The data suggest that histone H4 acetylation and DNA methylation have distinct functions on the maternal and paternal Igf2-H19 domains.

Deletion of a silencer element in Igf2 results in loss of imprinting independent of H19

Igf2 and H19 are closely linked, reciprocally imprinted genes on mouse distal chromosome 7. The paternally expressed Igf2 encodes a potent fetal growth factor and the maternally expressed H19 encodes a non-coding RNA (refs 1,2). Shared endoderm-specific enhancers 3' to H19 are necessary for transcription of the maternal copy of H19 and the paternal copy of Igf2 (ref. 3), a chromatin boundary upstream of H19 preventing access of the enhancers to the maternal Igf2 promoters. Mesoderm-specific control elements have not been identified, and the role of differentially methylated regions (DMRs) in Igf2 has not been addressed. Two DMRs in Igf2 are methylated on the active paternal allele, suggesting that they contain silencers. Here we have deleted the DMR1 region in Igf2. Maternal transmission of the deletion results in biallelic expression of Igf2 in most mesodermally derived tissues without altering H19 imprinting or expression. Paternal or maternal transmission leads to continued postnatal transcription of Igf2, in contrast to the wild-type allele, which is silenced soon after birth. These results reveal a mesodermal silencer, which may be regulated by methylation and which has a major role in H19-independent expression and imprinting control of Igf2. Our results establish a new mechanistic principle for imprinted genes whereby epigenetically regulated silencers interact with enhancers to control expression, and suggest a new mechanism for loss of imprinting (LOI) of Igf2, which may be important in a number of diseases.

Role of histone acetylation and DNA methylation in the maintenance of the imprinted expression of the H19 and Igf2 genes

H19 and Igf2 are linked and reciprocally imprinted genes. We demonstrate that the histones associated with the paternally inherited and unexpressed H19 allele are less acetylated than those associated with the maternal expressed allele. Cell growth in the presence of inhibitors of either histone deacetylase or DNA methylation activated the silent Igf2 allele, whereas derepression of the silent H19 allele required combined inhibition of DNA methylation and histone deacetylation. Our results indicate that histone acetylation as well as DNA methylation contribute to the somatic maintenance of H19 and Igf2 imprinting and that silencing of the imprinted alleles of these two genes is maintained via distinct mechanisms.

Parental allele-specific chromatin configuration in a boundary-imprinting-control element upstream of the mouse H19 gene

The mouse H19 gene is expressed from the maternal chromosome exclusively. A 2-kb region at 2 to 4 kb upstream of H19 is paternally methylated throughout development, and these sequences are necessary for the imprinted expression of both H19 and the 5'-neighboring Igf2 gene. In particular, on the maternal chromosome this element appears to insulate the Igf2 gene from enhancers located downstream of H19. We analyzed the chromatin organization of this element by assaying its sensitivity to nucleases in nuclei. Six DNase I hypersensitive sites (HS sites) were detected on the unmethylated maternal chromosome exclusively, the two most prominent of which mapped 2.25 and 2.75 kb 5' to the H19 transcription initiation site. Five of the maternal HS sites were present in expressing and nonexpressing tissues and in embryonic stem (ES) cells. They seem, therefore, to reflect the maternal origin of the chromosome rather than the expression of H19. A sixth maternal HS site, at 3.45 kb upstream of H19, was detected in ES cells only. The nucleosomal organization of this element was analyzed in tissues and ES cells by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Specifically on the maternal chromosome, an unusual and strong banding pattern was obtained, suggestive of a nonnucleosomal organization. From our studies, it appears that the unusual chromatin organization with the presence of HS sites (maternal chromosome) and DNA methylation (paternal chromosome) in this element are mutually exclusive and reflect alternate epigenetic states. In addition, our data suggest that nonhistone proteins are associated with the maternal chromosome and that these might be involved in its boundary function.

Analysis and identification of imprinted genes

Genomic imprinting in mammals results in the unequal expression of the two parental alleles of specific genes. The existence of imprinting in the mouse emerged from nuclear transplantation studies and from the abnormal phenotypes associated with uniparental inheritance of particular chromosome segments. Over the past 5 years, 20 or so imprinted genes have been identified. This has emphasized the important roles played by some imprinted genes in development, permitted a description of the epigenetic properties associated with imprinting, and provided the first insights into the regulation of imprinting. In this article, we discuss the generation of experimental material in which imprinting effects can be analyzed, review the properties of imprinted genes, and discuss how to examine them using state-of-the-art techniques. Finally, we consider the means by which new imprinted genes can be identified.

Genomic imprinting: a chromatin connection

Images

Parental chromosome-specific chromatin conformation in the imprinted U2af1-rs1 gene in the mouse

The imprinted U2af1-rs1 gene on mouse chromosome 11 is expressed exclusively from the paternal allele. We found that U2af1-rs1 resides in a chromosomal domain that displays marked differences in chromatin conformation and DNA methylation between the parental chromosomes. Chromatin conformation was assayed in brain and liver, in fetuses, and in embryonic stem cells by sensitivity to nucleases in nuclei. In all these tissues, the unmethylated paternal chromosome is sensitive to DNase-I and MspI and has two DNase-I hypersensitive sites in the 5'-untranslated region. In brain and in differentiated stem cells, which display high levels of U2af1-rs1 expression, a paternal DNase-I hypersensitive site is also readily apparent in the promoter region. On the maternal chromosome, in contrast, the entire U2af1-rs1 gene and its promoter are highly resistant to DNase-I and MspI in all tissues analyzed and are fully methylated. No differential MNase sensitivity was detected in this imprinted domain. The parental chromosome-specific DNA methylation and chromatin conformation were also present in parthenogenetic and androgenetic cells and in tissues from animals maternally or paternally disomic for chromosome 11. This demonstrates that these parental chromosome-specific epigenotypes are independently established and maintained and provides no evidence for interallelic trans-sensing and counting mechanisms in U2af1-rs1.

Parental imprinting and human disease

Parental imprinting is a process that results in allele-specific differences in transcription, DNA methylation, and DNA replication timing. Imprinting plays an important role in development, and its deregulation can cause certain defined disease states. Absence of a paternal contribution to chromosome 15q11-q13, due to hemizygous deletion or uniparental disomy, results in the Prader-Willi syndrome. The absence of a normal maternal copy of the same region causes Angelman syndrome. The Beckwith-Wiedemann syndrome is associated with the failure of normal biparental inheritance of chromosome 11p15, and loss of imprinting is observed in several cancers including Wilms' tumor. The study of the molecular basis of abnormal imprinting in these disorders will facilitate the identification and characterization of other imprinted human disease loci.