Hapten-specific responses to the phenyltrimethylamino hapten. II. Regulation of delayed-type hypersensitivity by genetically restricted, anti-idiotype suppressor T cells induced by the monovalent antigen L-tyrosine-p-azophenyltrimethylammonium

Antigen-specific suppressor factor: missing pieces in the puzzle

Few areas of immunologic research have endured such strident criticism or engendered such fainthearted support as the study of antigen-specific suppression of the immune response. Although enjoying a modest resurgence as a means of promoting or maintaining peripheral tolerance to autoantigens, the study of antigen-specific suppression is not mainstream immunology. The field of immune regulation has, in fact, shifted focus toward explaining the data in terms of the Th1/Th2 paradigm. Indeed, the term suppression has been coopted, by those willing to use it, to describe the bioactivity of conventional cytokines, such as IL-4, IL-10 or TGF beta, which can be inhibitory in certain experimental models. In a very real sense, those who performed much of the early work in the field bear responsibility for the outcast status of suppression. With the increasing number of soluble mediators and cascades of interacting T cells, which populated reviews of the subject in the 1980s, the concept of antigen-specific suppression and suppressor factors simply became too complicated and was dismissed as artifact. Several laboratories have in the past few years made significant advances in the molecular characterization of antigen-specific TsF. Their work, as well as that of our own laboratory have established certain minimal molecular requirements for the expression of TsF bioactivity.

Two modes of idiotypic stimulation of T lymphocytes from patients with Chagas' disease: correlations with clinical forms of infection

Patients with chronic Trypanosoma cruzi infections have peripheral auto-anti-idiotype (Id) T cells that proliferate on exposure to immunoaffinity-purified antibodies against T. cruzi epimastigote antigens (EPI). The responses of some patients' (group 1) peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) to anti-EPI antibodies from sera of patients with the cardiac form of Chagas' disease (Id-C) were inhibited by chloroquine, but responses of other patients' (group 2) PBMC to Id-C were not inhibited. PBMC responses of both group-1 and -2 patients to anti-EPI antibodies from asymptomatic (indeterminate) patients (Id-I) were inhibited by chloroquine, as were their responses to the antigens in EPI. Most patients (69%) in group 1 had indeterminate Chagas' disease, and 100% of the patients in group 2 had severe, cardiac or digestive Chagas' disease. Both the direct (chloroquine-insensitive) and indirect (processed) modes of stimulation by anti-EPI antibodies required adherent cells. In group 2 (direct stimulation), this requirement was met by exogenous IL-1, and neither anti-HLA-DR,DP(DQ) monoclonal antibody (mAb) nor sodium azide inhibited T-cell proliferation. Indirect Id stimulation of group-1 cells by Id-I or Id-C, and group-2 cells by Id-I or EPI, was inhibited by anti-HLA-DR,DP(DQ) mAb or sodium azide, and exogenous IL-1 alone did not support this processed, MHC-mediated T-cell stimulation, but live adherent cells did. The mode of activation of auto-anti-Id T cells from patients with Chagas' disease depends on the clinical form of infection of both the cell donor and the donor of the stimulating anti-EPI antibodies.

The use of nonspecific T acceptor cells to overcome the aberrant function of antigen-specific third-order T suppressor cells

Earlier studies in the phenyltrimethylamino (TMA) hapten system demonstrated that under certain conditions idiotype-specific second-order T suppressor (Ts2)-bearing mice fail to suppress TMA-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity. This was due to a functional deletion in the third-order T suppressor (Ts3) subset. In this report we have confirmed and extended these findings to show that only homologous TMA-specific Ts3 can restore suppressor function, both heterologous Ts3 and unprimed T-cell populations failed to do so. Furthermore, attempts to induce Ts3 function in the defective mice after reconstitution with normal precursor Ts3 cells also failed. In contrast, protocols which induce heterologous contact and cutaneous hypersensitivity reactions readily induced cell populations capable of restoring suppression in the Ts3-defective mice. Analysis of the lymphoid populations from the contact-sensitized defective mice revealed that these cells were not the prototypical Ts3 but were similar to the previously reported nonspecific T acceptor cell. The results further indicated that the T acceptor cell functioned as the active terminal-phase Ts subset, and this could be used as an alternative to the TMA-specific Ts3. The importance of multiple suppressor pathways at the terminal phase of immune suppression is discussed.

Idiotype-specific T suppressor factor alternatively interacts with a nonspecific T-acceptor-like cell to mediate immune suppression

The ability of the idiotype (Id)-specific second-order T suppressor factor (TsF2) to interact with a final effector Ts cell type other than the previously reported third-order Ts (Ts3) subset was studied in the phenyltrimethylamino (TMA) hapten system. Hence, mice were primed with unrelated heterologous haptens to induce the nonspecific T acceptor (Tacc) cells following published procedures. When enriched T cell populations containing these nonspecific Ts were briefly incubated in vitro with TMA-TsF2, they produced suppression upon adoptive transfer into cyclophosphamide-treated mice which had been previously immunized for TMA-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity. Despite the fact that the effector population studied in this report also required Id-binding TsF2 for its function, it differs markedly from the Ts3 subset studied previously in the TMA system. First, the cell type studied herein could be easily generated with noncrossreacting heterologous chemically reactive haptens when applied directly to the skin of mice. Furthermore, these Ts effector cells had no detectable intrinsic receptors for homologous haptens and most importantly, unlike Ts3, this population had no affinity for the TMA hapten. Nevertheless, the nonspecifically induced Ts once activated by TsF2 suppresses TMA-directed, but not similar immune responses specific for heterologous haptens. Thus the results indicate that TsF2 can functionally interact with a final effector Ts subset (very similar to the Tacc) other than the well described Ts3 population. The ramifications of these findings are discussed with reference to a generalized view of the cellular basis of terminal phases of immune suppression.

A novel suppressive activity: complementation between a T cell induced with first-order T-suppressor factor and an I-J-restricted antigen-nonspecific T cell

Previous studies demonstrated that the first-order T-suppressor factor (TsF1) requires the presence of antigen to induce idiotype-specific Ts cells which readily suppress phenyltrimethylamino (TMA) hapten-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses when transferred into already immune recipients. In this study we show that TsF1 in the absence of antigen induces a splenic population which limits DTH in recipient mice only when an additional accessory lymphoid population was also cotransferred. Neither of these populations alone was sufficient to mediate suppression and depletion of T cells in either population's abrogated suppression, indicating the T-cell dependency of the complementing cell types. Moreover, suppression was seen only when TMA-TsF1-induced and not normal spleen cell lysate-induced cells were cotransferred with the antigen-induced population, suggesting the requirement for a specific signal to induce the factor-induced population. Further experiments showed that the antigen-induced lymphoid population could be replaced by either heterologous antigen-induced or adjuvant alone-induced splenic populations, indicating the lack of specificity of this secondary population. Further analysis showed that the cell complementation between TMA-TsF1-induced and the nonspecific accessory lymphoid population resulted in antigen-specific and genetically restricted immune suppression. The TsF1-induced lymphoid population was not responsible for the genetic restriction, and furthermore, there was no restriction observed between the two complementing populations. However, matching of the nonspecific accessory cell with the recipient host at the I-J subregion of the H-2 complex was essential for immune suppression. Finally, the activity of complementing cells was found to be independent of cyclophosphamide-sensitive Ts populations of the recipient mice. The ramifications of these findings with reference to the existing suppressor pathways are discussed.

Interaction of idiotype-specific T suppressor factor with the hapten-specific third-order T suppressor subset results in antigen-nonspecific suppression

The interaction between the third-order T suppressor (Ts3) cell and the idiotype (Id)-specific second-order Ts factor (TsF2) was studied in the phenyltrimethylamino (TMA) hapten system. The experimental system which we used allowed the independent analysis of induction and activation requirements of Ts3. The procedure consisted of inducing the Ts3 in vivo and activating the enriched T-cell populations containing Ts3 in vitro with TsF2. The suppressive potential was then tested in mice previously primed for delayed-type hypersensitivity responses which were also treated with cyclophosphamide to deplete Ts3 and other drug-sensitive Ts cell types. Using this experimental system, it was found that the Id-specific TsF2 was required for the in vitro activation of Ts3. Furthermore, the TsF2 activated only the homologous and not heterologous antigen-primed Ts3-containing T cells and moreover, the target of TsF2 was found to be the Ts cells bearing hapten-specific receptors. Once the TMA hapten-specific Ts3 was activated with TsF2, the ensuing suppression was antigen nonspecific. The data demonstrate that the Ts3 represents a final effector Ts cell type in the TMA system.

Delayed-type hypersensitivity and immunity to Salmonella typhimurium

Studies were carried out to correlate immunity and expression of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) in mice of the C3H lineage immunized with an avirulent strain of Salmonella typhimurium (strain SL3235). This strain belongs to a class of aroA- organisms which are being considered as vaccine strains for humans and veterinary use. In a systematic study, the relationship between the mouse strain and the immunizing dose of strain SL3235 on the development of protective immunity and DTH was examined. It was found that in hypersusceptible C3H/HeJ and C3HeB/FeJ mice, several doses of strain SL3235 afforded protection against intravenous challenge doses as high as 1,300 50% lethal doses. Despite these significant levels of immunity to challenge, mice of these two strains never mounted significant DTH responses following immunization with the doses of strain SL3235 tested, which spanned 3 orders of magnitude. Nonresponsiveness was not due to antigen overload, as all of the mouse strains were comparably colonized with strain SL3235 at the time of DTH elicitation. Further, it was found that the ability of responsive C3H/HeNCrlBR mice to display DTH was dependent on the immunizing dose of strain SL3235 and that a dosage could be found that resulted in increased resistance to challenge in these mice without a concomitant display of DTH. Thus, while both induction of protective immunity and DTH were vaccine dosage dependent in the responsive mouse strain (C3H/HeNCrlBR), DTH was a less sensitive measure of protective immunity than survival. Vaccine dosages ranging over three orders of magnitude failed to yield positive footpads to the Salmonella elicitin in the nonresponsive mice. The data suggest that caution should be observed in interpreting Salmonella DTH tests that are used as screens of immune status to typhoid fever in humans, as the extent of discordance between immunity and DTH in humans is unknown.

TMA-specific first-order T-suppressor hybridoma. I. Characterization of the hybridoma-derived single-chain inducer suppressor factor, TsF1

Experiments described in this report will characterize a monoclonal phenyltrimethylammonium (TMA) specific, first-order T-suppressor factor (TsF1) produced by a T-cell hybridoma, 8A.3. The hybridoma expressed the Thy-1, Lyt-1, Lyt-2 antigens as well as cross-reactive idiotypic (CRI) determinants but did not express I-J encoded epitopes. It was also found to bear determinants recognized by a monoclonal antibody raised against single-chain GAT-specific TsF1. The hybridoma-derived factor was capable of suppressing primary in vitro trinitrophenol (TNP)-specific responses induced with the Brucella abortus antigen, conjugated with TMA and TNP haptens (TMA-BA-TNP). In addition, in vivo administration of 8A.3 culture supernatant resulted in the specific suppression of TMA-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses. Analysis of this factor revealed it to be an induction-phase, antigen-binding, CRI+, and I-J+ single chain polypeptide. Our results represent only the second such described single chain, antigen binding, I-J+ suppressor factor derived from a monoclonal T-cell hybridoma.

Hapten-specific responses to the phenyltrimethyl-amino hapten. I. Evidence for idiotype-anti-idiotype interactions in delayed-type hypersensitivity in mice

The delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reaction to the phenyltrimethylamino (TMA) hapten in mice has been investigated. TMA-derivatized syngeneic spleen cells (TMA-SC) administered s.c. in several strains of mice consistently evoked DTH reactivity, as measured by footpad swelling after challenge with the diazonium salt of TMA. DTH could be induced by low levels of anti-idiotypic antisera (anti-Id) in lieu of antigen. The DTH reaction induced by either mode was hapten-specific, could be transferred into naive recipients by viable lymph node cells but not with serum from immune mice and was not influenced by cyclophoshamide pretreatment. Unlike TMA-SC which induced DTH in all of the strains of the mice tested, anti-Id induced DTH only in strains of the Igh-1e allotype. Positive DTH reactions were induced by anti-Id in the C57.Ige strain (H-2b, Igh-1e) but not in its allotype-congenic partner C57BL/6J (H-2b, Igh-1b). Interestingly this reaction could be suppressed if relatively high amounts of anti-Id were inoculated i.v. just prior to antigen challenge. In addition, the administration of anti-Id 1 h prior to antigen challenge in TMA-SC-sensitized mice significantly blocked the DTH reaction only in the Igh-1e strains. These results demonstrate that the induction and abrogation of TMA-specific DTH by anti-Id is linked to the IgCh locus.