Fine specificity analysis of lactate dehydrogenase B-specific proliferating T cell clones: implications for the mechanism of alloreactivity

Alloreactivity: an old puzzle revisited

Alloreactivity, defined as a strong primary T cell response against allelic variants of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules in the species, has been a long-standing puzzle in immunology with some of its details remaining unclear up to now. Here I shall provide a historical overview of how our understanding of alloreactivity has evolved and propose an interpretation that considers alloreactivity to be a mixture of four mechanistically distinct prototypes of T cell response, namely, self-restricted peptide specific, allorestricted peptide specific, alloreactive peptide dependent and alloreactive peptide independent. The relative contribution of each prototype to a given alloresponse is dependent on the extent of disparity (i.e. the number and nature of amino acid substitutions in the docking surface for T cell receptor) between the MHC molecule that the T cell recognizes as self and the stimulating MHC molecule.

Sequence features that correlate with MHC restriction

Identification of common sequence motifs in antigenic peptides restricted to a specific class II molecule has not been easy due to the large variation in length and sequence that is observed in these peptides. The goal of this study is to develop an automated computerized method for the identification of sequence features and structural determinants that play a role in the MHC restriction of helper T-cell antigenic peptides. For this, we compiled an extended database of helper T-cell sites, including the information on MHC restriction, when available. Two groups of peptides are assigned to each MHC type: (1) peptides that bind to that MHC molecule to elicit a T-cell response, and (2) peptides that were shown experimentally either not to bind to or not to elicit a T-cell proliferative response in association with that MHC molecule. We search for common motifs in the group of binding peptides, and identify significant motifs that are frequent among these peptides but almost absent in the group of non-binding peptides. A motif consists of physical-chemical and structural properties that may be responsible for binding specificity and can be extracted from sequence data, such as, hydrophobicity, charge, hydrogen bonding capability, etc. The first search is performed on the non-aligned binding peptides. Next, the sequences are aligned according to an identified motif and a search for additional, conserved, properties is performed. The statistical significance of the motifs is evaluated as well as their compatibility with published experimental results on substitution effects. Here we demonstrate the general scheme of the analysis and results for I-Ek and I-Ak associated peptides.

Collaboration of helper and cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes are major effector cells in response to viral infections and in allograft rejection and are implicated in many other immunological reactions. Efficient induction of cytotoxic activity in these cells in many but not all cases depends upon helper T and antigen-presenting cells so that at least three different cell types have to work together. Here we present an in vitro model for the helper T cell-dependent induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes which allows the investigation of the collaboration of helper and cytotoxic T cells. First results demonstrate that linkage of helper and killer epitopes on the surface of one antigen-presenting cell is a prerequisite for productive interaction between the two T cells that results in induction of cytolytic activity. T helper 1 and T helper 2 cells are equally efficient. The crucial roles of interleukin-2 and interferon-gamma in this process were confirmed. Activated CD4 cells can influence cytotoxic T lymphocytes in such a way that they produce interferon-gamma independent from recognition of cognate peptide. The possibility of direct T-T contacts mediated by adhesion molecules that promote collaboration of the two cells is discussed.

Identification of T-cell epitopes and use in construction of synthetic vaccines

The T cell is central to the immune system response to foreign antigens, and understanding the mechanism of T cell response to antigen is crucial for vaccine development. Short subpeptides of foreign antigen can prime the T cells to respond to the whole antigen, in some cases as well as or better than immunization with the whole antigen itself. Antigenic sites located first in the murine model are also antigenic in the human, suggesting that the structural features of antigenic sites are species-independent. The amphipathic helix hypothesis has proven useful in developing an algorithm that has successfully located immunodominant sites in important proteins, thus reducing substantially the experimental time and effort required to locate those sites. Other algorithms have also been used successfully, but in all cases there are proven T-cell sites not accounted for by the algorithm. A data base showing T-cell response to collections of peptides uniformly distributed along protein antigens would be very useful in subsequent efforts to characterize the physical and chemical properties of T-cell antigenic sites.

Antigen presentation by liposomes as model system for T-B cell interaction

Using the earlier established liposome system for antigen presentation, in which liposomes bearing major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-class II molecules inserted into and protein antigen covalently linked to the membrane were found to be sufficient for an antigen-specific and MHC-restricted activation of T cells, the minimal requirements for T-B cell interaction were investigated. Liposomes carrying MHC class II molecules and antigen-specific monoclonal antibodies were constructed and tested for their ability to present soluble antigen to T cells. With the antigens lactate dehydrogenase B and pigeon cytochrome c, a specific stimulation of T cell clones and hybridomas could be obtained. These results demonstrate the possibility of a direct involvement of the immunoglobulins on the B cell surface in their interaction with T cells.

Two adjacent epitopes on a synthetic dodecapeptide induce lactate dehydrogenase B-specific helper and suppressor T cells

The outcome of an immune response to the enzyme lactate dehydrogenase B (LDH-B) is determined by the interplay between two types of regulatory T lymphocytes, T helper (Th) and T suppressor (Ts) cells. Most mouse strains are capable of generating Th but not Ts cells, and are therefore high responders to LDH-B in terms of both antibody production and antigen-specific T-cell proliferation. However, in strains expressing the b or k allele at the E beta locus of the major histocompatibility complex (Mhc), Ts cells are induced that partly or totally abrogate the proliferative response of Th cells to LDH-B. As a result, these strains are phenotypically medium (E beta b expressors) or low (E beta k expressors) responders. Because the suppression in the LDH-B system is antigen-specific (i.e. it only affects LDH-B-specific Th cells), it is conceivable that the Th and Ts cells use the antigen itself to communicate with each other. To investigate this possibility, we set out to determine which epitopes of the LDH-B molecule are recognized by Th and Ts cells. On the basis of previous studies, a loop structure extending from residue 211 to residue 224 of pig LDH-B appeared to be preferentially recognized by most Th-type (class II Mhc-restricted, proliferating) clones. By using a synthetic peptide, we demonstrate here that both Th and Ts cells are induced by the 211-222 stretch of LDH-B sequence. The use of two further dodecapeptides, each with a single amino-acid substitution in comparison with the pig 211-222 sequence, has revealed that Th and Ts cells have different fine specificities. Thus the loop appears to have two closely linked, if not overlapping, epitopes, one recognized by Th and the other by Ts cells. This finding is consistent with two possible mechanisms of suppression, namely bridging of Th and Ts cells by antigen and subsequent transmission of a suppressive signal, and competition for antigen between Th and Ts cells.