CD8/CD4 lineage commitment occurs by an instructional/default process followed by positive selection

A novel gene essential for the development of single positive thymocytes

A critical step during intrathymic T-cell development is the transition of CD4(+) CD8(+) double-positive (DP) cells to the major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I)-restricted CD4(-) CD8(+) and MHC-II-restricted CD4(+) CD8(-) single-positive (SP) cell stage. Here, we identify a novel gene that is essential for this process. Through the T-cell phenotype-based screening of N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU)-induced mutant mice, we established a mouse line in which numbers of CD4 and CD8 SP thymocytes as well as peripheral CD4 and CD8 T cells were dramatically reduced. Using linkage analysis and DNA sequencing, we identified a missense point mutation in a gene, E430004N04Rik (also known as themis), that does not belong to any known gene family. This orphan gene is expressed specifically in DP and SP thymocytes and peripheral T cells, whereas in mutant thymocytes the levels of protein encoded by this gene were drastically reduced. We generated E430004N04Rik-deficient mice, and their phenotype was virtually identical to that of the ENU mutant mice, thereby confirming that this gene is essential for the development of SP thymocytes.

Centromeric repositioning of coreceptor loci predicts their stable silencing and the CD4/CD8 lineage choice

The differentiation of CD4⁺ CD8⁺ double positive (DP) thymocytes requires the irreversible choice between two alternative lineages, distinguished by the mutually exclusive expression of either CD4 or CD8. Differentiating DP cells transiently down-regulate both CD4 and CD8, and this has complicated the debate whether the mechanism of CD4/CD8 lineage choice is instructive, stochastic/selective, or more complex in nature. Using fluorescence in situ hybridization, we show that the stable silencing of coreceptor loci, and ultimately lineage choice, is predicted by the spatial repositioning of coreceptor alleles to centromeric heterochromatin domains. These data provide evidence that lineage-specific developmental programs are established early during the transition from the DP to the single positive stage.

Soluble factor-mediated differentiation of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes to single positives in vitro

Although the thymic microenvironment provides the necessary elements for T-cell differentiation, the precise role of individual components remains to be determined. In this paper, attempts were made to address the possibility that CD4 or CD8 single-positive (SP) thymocytes could be developed from immature CD4+CD8+ (double-positive; DP) thymocytes in a suspension culture in the presence of soluble factors. We observed that IL-4 and IFN-gamma weakly induced DP cells to differentiate to CD4 cells, but not to CD8. In contrast, IL-2 weakly induced differentiation to CD8. Interestingly, Con A sup strongly induced differentiation to CD8 SP from the purified DP thymocytes prepared from C57BL/6 or LCMV TCRtg mice. In particular, it was found that thymocyte culture with Con A sup generated CD69+DP cells, and the CD69+DP differentiated to CD8 SP under the suspension culture with soluble factors. Thus, Con A sup or combinations of IL-2, IL-4 and IL-7 strongly induced differentiation of CD69+DP to CD8 SP, whereas individual cytokines did not. These results suggest that soluble factors like cytokines play an important role in the generation of SP thymocytes in the absence of thymic stromal cells, at least from a distinctive subpopulation like CD69+DP thymocytes, and perhaps from those of broader range when in conjunction with TCR/MHC interaction.

New perspectives on a developmental dilemma: the kinetic signaling model and the importance of signal duration for the CD4/CD8 lineage decision

Double-positive thymocytes are short-lived bipotential cells whose developmental fate is determined by the specificity of their TCRs. A relatively small number of double-positive thymocytes undergo positive selection in the thymus and these are signaled to differentiate either into CD4(+) or CD8(+) mature T cells. The mechanism by which double-positive thymocytes determine their appropriate CD4/CD8 fate has been the subject of intense theoretical debate and rigorous experimental analysis. In the last year, 'signal duration' has been offered as a replacement for 'signal strength' as a major determinant of the CD4/CD8 decision, a deceptively minor refinement that requires a major change in our understanding of how signaled double-positive thymocytes differentiate into mature T cells. Indeed, the kinetic signaling model provides a radically new perspective on the mechanism by which the CD4/CD8 lineage decision is made.

Deletion of the CD4 silencer element supports a stochastic mechanism of thymocyte lineage commitment

The mechanism of T cell lineage commitment remains controversial; to examine it we deleted the CD4-silencer element in the germ line of a mouse using a combination of gene targeting and Cre/LoxP-mediated recombination. We found that these mice were unable to extinguish CD4 expression either in immature thymocytes or mature CD8+ cytotoxic T cells (CTLs), which resulted in the development of major histocompatibility complex class II-restricted double-positive CTLs in the periphery. This finding strongly supports a stochastic over an instructive mechanism of coreceptor down-regulation.

The regulation of CD4 and CD8 coreceptor gene expression during T cell development

The two major subsets of T lymphocytes in the peripheral immune system, the helper and cytotoxic T cells, are defined by their expression of either the CD4 or the CD8 glycoproteins, respectively. Expression of these molecules, which serve as coreceptors by interacting specifically with either MHC class II or class I molecules, also defines discrete stages of T cell development within the thymus. Thus, CD4+ and CD8+ single-positive (SP) thymocytes arise from common progenitor double positive (DP) cells that express both CD4 and CD8, during a process known as positive selection. The molecular mechanisms underlying the developmental choice toward the helper or cytotoxic lineage remain poorly understood. Because regulation of coreceptor gene expression appears to be coupled to the phenotypic choice of the differentiating T cell, it is likely that shared signaling pathways direct CD4 and CD8 transcription and the development of an uncommited DP thymocyte toward either the helper or cytotoxic lineage. Therefore, an understanding of how CD4 and CD8 expression is regulated will not only provide insights into transcriptional control mechanisms in T cells, but may also result in the identification of molecular factors that are involved in lineage choices during T cell development. In this review, we summarize recent progress that has been made toward an understanding of how CD4 and CD8 gene expression is regulated.

Visualization of CD4/CD8 T cell commitment

A system to innocuously visualize T cell lineage commitment is described. Using a "knock-in" approach, we have generated mice expressing a beta-galactosidase reporter in place of CD4; expression of beta-galactosidase in these animals appears to be an accurate and early indicator of CD4 gene transcription. We have exploited this knock-in line to trace CD4/CD8 lineage commitment in the thymus, avoiding important pitfalls of past experimental approaches. Our results argue in favor of a selective model of thymocyte commitment, demonstrating a fundamentally symmetrical process: engagement of either class of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule by a differentiating CD4(+)CD8(+) cell can give rise to T cell antigen receptor (TCR)hi thymocytes of either lineage. Key findings include (a) direct demonstration of a substantial number of CD4-committed, receptor/coreceptor-mismatched cells in MHC class II- deficient mice, a critical prediction of the selective model; (b) highly efficient rescue of such "mismatched" intermediates by forced expression of CD8 in a TCR transgenic line, and an explanation of why previous experiments of this nature were less successful-a major past criticism of the selective model; (c) direct demonstration of an analogous, though smaller, population of CD8-committed mismatched intermediates in class I-deficient animals. Finally, we found no evidence of a CD4 default pathway.

CD4/CD8 lineage commitment: matching fate with competence

The outcome of positive selection of T lymphocytes is that there is a close match between the lineage adopted by a particular cell (CD4+ or CD8+) and the specificity of the T-cell receptor for the class of Major Histocompatibility Complex molecule recognized. How this match is obtained has been a matter of debate. We review the evidence, from recent and older experiments, that indicates that the process follows a selective logic, rather than an instructive one.

Thymocyte selection in Vav and IRF-1 gene-deficient mice

T cells undergo a defined program of phenotypic and genetic changes during differentiation within the thymus. These changes define commitment of T-cell receptor (TCR) gamma delta and TCR alpha beta cells and lineage differentiation into CD4+ T helper and CD8+ cytotoxic T cells. T-cell differentiation and selection in the thymus constitute a tightly co-ordinated multistep journey through a network that can be envisaged as a three-dimensional informational highway made up of stromal cells and extracellular matrix molecules. This intrathymic journey is controlled by information exchange, with thymocytes depending on two-way cellular interactions with thymic stromal cells in order to receive essential signals for maturation and selection. Genetic inactivation of surface receptors, signal transduction molecules, and transcription factors using homologous recombination has provided novel insight into the signaling cascades that relay surface receptor engagement to gene transcription and subsequent progression of the developmental program. In this review we discuss molecular mechanisms of T lymphocyte development in mice that harbour genetic mutations in the guanine nucleotide exchange factor Vav and the interferon regulatory transcription factor 1 (IRF-1). We also propose a novel model of T-cell selection based on TCR alpha chain-directed signals for allelic exclusion and TCR alpha-based selection for single receptor usage.

T-cell fate

Recent studies suggest that lineage commitment steps, which occur during T-cell differentiation, follow principles in common with fate specification in simple invertebrates. Here we review T-cell development from the perspective of developmental biology. We present models for alpha beta vs gamma delta and CD4 vs CD8 lineage commitment that are consistent with previously published and newly presented experiments.

Homeostasis Limits the Development of Mature CD8+ But Not CD4+ Thymocytes

The involvement of a variety of clonal selection processes during the development of T lymphocytes in the thymus has been well established. Less information, however, is available on how homeostatic mechanisms may regulate the generation and maturation of thymocytes. To investigate this question, mixed radiation bone marrow chimeras were established in which wild-type T cell precursors capable of full maturation were diluted with precursors deficient in maturation potential because of targeted mutations of the RAG1 or TCR-α genes. In chimeras in which the majority of thymocytes are blocked at the CD4−CD8−CD25+ stage (RAG1 deficient), and only a small proportion of T cell precursors are of wild-type origin, we observed no difference in the maturation of wild-type CD4−CD8−CD25+ cells to the CD4+CD8+ stage as compared with control chimeras. Therefore, the number of cell divisions occurring during this transition is fixed and not subject to homeostatic regulation. In contrast, in mixed chimeras in which the majority of thymocytes are blocked at the CD4+CD8+ stage (TCR-α deficient), an increased efficiency of development of wild-type mature CD8+ cells was observed. Surprisingly, the rate of generation of mature CD4+ thymocytes was not affected in these chimeras. Thus, the number of selectable CD8 lineage thymocytes apparently saturates the selection mechanism in normal mice while the development of CD4 lineage cells seems to be limited only by the expression of a suitable TCR. These data may open the way to the identification of homeostatic mechanisms regulating thymic output and CD4/CD8 lineage commitment, and the development of means to modulate it.

An enhancer that directs lineage-specific expression of CD8 in positively selected thymocytes and mature T cells

Positive selection of CD4+CD8+ T cells to the CD4+CD8- helper and CD4- CD8+ cytotoxic lineages is a multistep process that involves complex regulation of coreceptor gene expression. By analyzing expression of a reporter gene in transgenic mice, we have identified a DNA segment, located between the murine CD8beta and CD8alpha genes, that has enhancer activity restricted to CD8 lineage cells. Remarkably, this enhancer functions in thymocytes undergoing positive selection to the CD4-CD8+ phenotype but not in immature double-positive thymocytes. The enhancer also functions in gut intraepithelial lymphocytes that express CD8alpha but not CD8beta, suggesting that it is specific for CD8alpha expression. The tight correlation between activation of this enhancer and the final step in positive selection has important implications for understanding the mechanism of lineage commitment in thymocytes.

The interferon regulatory transcription factor IRF-1 controls positive and negative selection of CD8+ thymocytes

Little is known about the molecular mechanisms and transcriptional regulation that govern T cell selection processes and the differentiation of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. Mice lacking the interferon regulatory transcription factor-1 (IRF-1) have reduced numbers of mature CD8+ cells within the thymus and peripheral lymphatic organs. Here we show that positive and negative T cell selection of two MHC class I-restricted TCR alphabeta transgenes, H-Y and P14, are impaired in IRF-1-/- mice. The absence of IRF-1 resulted in decreased expression of LMP2, TAP1, and MHC class I on thymic stromal cells. Despite decreased MHC class I expression on IRF-1-/- thymic stromal cells, the defect in CD8+ T cells development did not reside in the thymic environment, and IRF-1-/- stromal cells can fully support development of CD8+ thymocytes in in vivo bone marrow chimeras and in vitro reaggregation cultures. Moreover, IRF-1-/- thymocytes displayed impaired TCR-mediated signal transduction, and the induction of negative selection in TCR Tg thymocytes from IRF-1-/- mice required a 1000-fold increase in selecting peptide. We also provide evidence that IRF-1 is mainly expressed in mature, but not immature, thymocytes and that expression of IRF-1 in immature thymocytes is induced after peptide-specific TCR activation. These results indicate that IRF-1 regulates gene expression in developing thymocytes required for lineage commitment and selection of CD8+ thymocytes.

Commitment of immature CD4+8+ thymocytes to the CD4 lineage requires CD3 signaling but does not require expression of clonotypic T cell receptor (TCR) chains

As a consequence of positive selection in the thymus, immature CD4(+)8(+) double-positive, [DP] thymocytes selectively terminate synthesis of one coreceptor molecule and, as a result, differentiate into either CD4(+) or CD8(+) T cells. The decision by individual DP thymocytes to terminate synthesis of one or the other coreceptor molecule is referred to as lineage commitment. Previously, we reported that the intrathymic signals that induced commitment to the CD4 versus CD8 T cell lineages were markedly asymmetric. Notably, CD8 commitment appeared to require lineage-specific signals, whereas CD4 commitment appeared to occur in the absence of lineage-specific signals by default. Consequently, it was unclear whether CD4 commitment, as revealed by selective termination of CD8 coreceptor synthesis, occurred in all DP thymocytes, or whether CD4 commitment occurred only in T cell receptor (TCR)-CD3-signaled DP thymocytes. Here, we report that selective termination of CD8 coreceptor synthesis does not occur in DP thymocytes spontaneously. Rather, CD4 commitment in DP thymocytes requires signals transduced by either CD3 or zeta chains, which can signal CD4 commitment even in the absence of clonotypic TCR chains.

Signals through CD8 or CD4 can induce commitment to the CD4 lineage in the thymus

Differentiation of thymocytes into mature single-positive T cells is an ordered process involving sequential interactions between T cell receptor (TCR), co-receptors (CD4 or CD8) and their appropriate major histocompatibility complex-encoded ligands. Precisely how these receptor/co-receptor engagements determine lineage commitment is still controversial, but recently it has been suggested that quantitative differences in the signal transmitted by co-ligation of CD4 versus CD8 with TCR might provide the discriminating signal. We examine this hypothesis, using bispecific F(ab')2 antibodies to mimic TCR/ co-receptor engagement during thymocyte differentiation. These bispecific antibodies lack Fc and can engage surface molecules without extensive cross-linking or targeting to Fc receptor-bearing cells. We show that TCR/CD3 co-ligation with CD4 induces efficient differentiation of mature CD4 lineage cells, irrespective of their TCR specificity. Interestingly, TCR/CD3 co-ligation with CD8 also induces maturation of CD4 T cells, although less efficiently, but not of CD8 T cells. Thus, although the signals delivered by co-ligation of TCR and CD8 appear weaker than from co-ligation of TCR and CD4, the outcome from either engagement is the same. These data suggest that differences in signal intensity alone do not determine lineage commitment in the thymus, but that distinct signals are required for CD4 and CD8 single-positive cell differentiation.

Thymosin alpha 1 antagonizes dexamethasone and CD3-induced apoptosis of CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes through the activation of cAMP and protein kinase C dependent second messenger pathways

It is well established that glucocorticoid hormones and anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies induce apoptosis in immature developing thymocytes. This process can be modulated by soluble factors, anti-oxidants and adhesion receptors. Previously we have demonstrated that thymosin alpha 1 (T alpha 1), a 28-amino acid thymic peptide hormone, is a dose and time dependent antagonist of dexamethasone (DEX) and CD# induced DNA fragmentation of murine thymocytes in vitro. To further investigate the mechanism of T alpha 1 action we determined a T alpha 1 sensitive thymocyte population and examined some of the molecular events associated with T alpha 1 anti-apoptotic activity. Phenotypic analysis of the sub-populations of thymocytes, based on CD4 and CD8 expression, revealed that T alpha 1 exerts its effect on CD4+ CD8+ immature thymocytes. T alpha 1 treatment of thymocytes delays the production of free radicals and the subsequent consumption of glutathione, that is observed during both DEX and CD3 induced apoptosis. We further demonstrate that T alpha 1 stimulates the production of cAMP and activates PKC in thymocytes. These data suggest that T alpha 1 exerts an influence on the development of a population of immature T-cells in the thymus by effecting the sensitivity of thymocytes to apoptosis during the pre-selection stages of thymic development. Our studies also suggest that the mechanism of T alpha 1 action involves the induction of both cAMP and PKC dependent second messenger pathways.

Surface molecules that drive T cell development in vitro in the absence of thymic epithelium and in the absence of lineage-specific signals

Differentiation of immature double positive (DP) CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes into single positive (SP) CD4+ and CD8+ T cells is referred to as positive selection and requires physical contact with thymic cortical epithelium. We now have identified "coinducer" molecules on DP thymocytes that, together with TCR, signal DP thymocytes to differentiate into SP T cells in vitro in the absence of thymic epithelium. A remarkable number of different molecules on DP thymocytes possessed "coinducing" activity, including CD2, CD5, CD24, CD28, CD49d, CD81, and TSA-1. Interestingly, in vitro differentiation occurred in the absence of lineage-specific signals, yet resulted in the selective generation of CD4+CD8- T cells. Thus, the present study has identified surface molecules that can signal DP thymocytes to differentiate into SP T cells in the absence of thymic epithelium and has characterized a default pathway for CD4+ T cell differentiation.