High-yield identification of pathogenic NF1 variants by skin fibroblast transcriptome screening after apparently normal diagnostic DNA testing

Facing the challenges to shorten the diagnostic odyssey: first Whole Genome Sequencing experience of a Colombian cohort with suspected rare diseases

Exome and genome sequencing (ES/GS) are routinely used for the diagnosis of genetic diseases in developed countries. However, their implementation is limited in countries from Latin America. We aimed to describe the results of GS in patients with suspected rare genetic diseases in Colombia. We studied 501 patients from 22 healthcare sites from January to December 2022. GS was performed in the index cases using dried blood spots on filtercards. Ancestry analysis was performed under iAdmix. Multiomic testing was performed when needed (biomarker, enzymatic activity, RNA-seq). All tests were performed at an accredited genetic laboratory. Ethnicity prediction data confirmed that 401 patients (80%) were mainly of Amerindian origin. A genetic diagnosis was established for 142 patients with a 28.3% diagnostic yield. The highest diagnostic yield was achieved for pathologies with a metabolic component and syndromic disorders (p < 0.001). Young children had a median of 1 year of diagnostic odyssey, while the median time for adults was significantly longer (15 years). Patients with genetic syndromes have spent more than 75% of their life without a diagnosis, while for patients with neurologic and neuromuscular diseases, the time of the diagnostic odyssey tended to decrease with age. Previous testing, specifically karyotyping or chromosomal microarray were significantly associated with a longer time to reach a definitive diagnosis (p < 0.01). Furthermore, one out of five patients that had an ES before could be diagnosed by GS. The Colombian genome project is the first Latin American study reporting the experience of systematic use of diagnostic GS in rare diseases.

Childhood-Onset Refractory Hypertension Results from Neurofibromatosis Type 1 Caused by a Splicing NF1 Mutation

INTRODUCTION

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF-1) is caused by mutations in the NF1 gene that encodes neurofibromin, a negative regulator of RAS proto-oncogene. Approximately one-third of the reported pathogenic mutations in NF1 are splicing mutations, but most consequences are unclear. The objective of this study was to identify the pathogenicity of splicing mutation in a Chinese family with NF-1 and determine the effects of the pre-mRNA splicing mutation by in vitro functional analysis.

METHODS

Next-generation sequencing was used to screen candidate mutations. We performed a minigene splicing assay to determine the effect of the splicing mutation on NF1 expression, and three-dimensional structure models of neurofibromin were generated using SWISS-MODEL and PROCHECK methods, respectively.

RESULTS

A pathogenic splicing mutation c.479+1G>C in NF1 was found in the proband characterized by childhood-onset refractory hypertension. In vitro analysis demonstrated that c.479+1G>C mutation caused the skipping of exon 4, leading to a glutamine-to-valine substitution at position 97 in neurofibromin and an open reading frame shift terminating at codon 108. Protein modeling showed that several major domains were missing in the truncated neurofibromin protein.

CONCLUSION

The splicing mutation c.479+1G>C identified in a Chinese patient with NF-1 and childhood-onset refractory hypertension caused the skipping of exon 4 and a truncated protein. Our findings offer new evidence for the molecular diagnosis of NF-1.

Deep Intronic LINE-1 Insertions in NF1: Expanding the Spectrum of Neurofibromatosis Type 1-Associated Rearrangements

Neurofibromatosis type 1 is an autosomal-dominant condition caused by NF1 gene inactivation. Clinical diagnosis is corroborated by genetic tests on gDNA and cDNA, which are inconclusive in approximately 3-5% of cases. Genomic DNA approaches may overlook splicing-affecting intronic variants and structural rearrangements, especially in regions enriched in repetitive sequences. On the other hand, while cDNA-based methods provide direct information about the effect of a variant on gene transcription, they are hampered by non-sense-mediated mRNA decay and skewed or monoallelic expression. Moreover, analyses on gene transcripts in some patients do not allow tracing back to the causative event, which is crucial for addressing genetic counselling, prenatal monitoring, and developing targeted therapies. We report on a familial NF1, caused by an insertion of a partial LINE-1 element inside intron 15, leading to exon 15 skipping. Only a few cases of LINE-1 insertion have been reported so far, hampering gDNA studies because of their size. Often, they result in exon skipping, and their recognition of cDNA may be difficult. A combined approach, based on Optical Genome Mapping, WGS, and cDNA studies, enabled us to detect the LINE-1 insertion and test its effects. Our results improve knowledge of the NF1 mutational spectrum and highlight the importance of custom-built approaches in undiagnosed patients.

Functional Assays Combined with Pre-mRNA-Splicing Analysis Improve Variant Classification and Diagnostics for Individuals with Neurofibromatosis Type 1 and Legius Syndrome

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) and Legius syndrome (LS) are caused by inactivating variants in NF1 and SPRED1. NF1 encodes neurofibromin (NF), a GTPase-activating protein (GAP) for RAS that interacts with the SPRED1 product, Sprouty-related protein with an EVH (Ena/Vasp homology) domain 1 (SPRED1). Obtaining a clinical and molecular diagnosis of NF1 or LS can be challenging due to the phenotypic diversity, the size and complexity of the NF1 and SPRED1 loci, and uncertainty over the effects of some NF1 and SPRED1 variants on pre-mRNA splicing and/or protein expression and function. To improve NF1 and SPRED1 variant classification and establish pathogenicity for NF1 and SPRED1 variants identified in individuals with NF1 or LS, we analyzed patient RNA by RT-PCR and performed in vitro exon trap experiments and estimated NF and SPRED1 protein expression, RAS GAP activity, and interaction. We obtained evidence to support pathogenicity according to American College of Medical Genetics guidelines for 73/114 variants tested, demonstrating the utility of functional approaches for NF1 and SPRED1 variant classification and NF and LS diagnostics.

Web-accessible application for identifying pathogenic transcripts with RNA-seq: Increased sensitivity in diagnosis of neurodevelopmental disorders

For neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs), a molecular diagnosis is key for management, predicting outcome, and counseling. Often, routine DNA-based tests fail to establish a genetic diagnosis in NDDs. Transcriptome analysis (RNA sequencing [RNA-seq]) promises to improve the diagnostic yield but has not been applied to NDDs in routine diagnostics. Here, we explored the diagnostic potential of RNA-seq in 96 individuals including 67 undiagnosed subjects with NDDs. We performed RNA-seq on single individuals' cultured skin fibroblasts, with and without cycloheximide treatment, and used modified OUTRIDER Z scores to detect gene expression outliers and mis-splicing by exonic and intronic outliers. Analysis was performed by a user-friendly web application, and candidate pathogenic transcriptional events were confirmed by secondary assays. We identified intragenic deletions, monoallelic expression, and pseudoexonic insertions but also synonymous and non-synonymous variants with deleterious effects on transcription, increasing the diagnostic yield for NDDs by 13%. We found that cycloheximide treatment and exonic/intronic Z score analysis increased detection and resolution of aberrant splicing. Importantly, in one individual mis-splicing was found in a candidate gene nearly matching the individual's specific phenotype. However, pathogenic splicing occurred in another neuronal-expressed gene and provided a molecular diagnosis, stressing the need to customize RNA-seq. Lastly, our web browser application allowed custom analysis settings that facilitate diagnostic application and ranked pathogenic transcripts as top candidates. Our results demonstrate that RNA-seq is a complementary method in the genomic diagnosis of NDDs and, by providing accessible analysis with improved sensitivity, our transcriptome analysis approach facilitates wider implementation of RNA-seq in routine genome diagnostics.