The mechanism of augmentation of natural killer cell activity by syngeneic tumor cells: role of macrophage-derived factor in NK boosting

Natural anti-chondrocyte cytotoxic activity in the mouse: supportive role of macrophages

The role of macrophages (M phi) in natural anti-chondrocyte cytotoxic activity of normal murine splenocytes (SPL) and peritoneal cells (PC) was examined by means of an 18-hr 51Cr-release assay. Removal of M phi by either plastic adherence or carbonyl iron and magnet resulted in significant (P less than 0.01) reduction of SPL-mediated lysis of chondrocytes. It, however, did not influence natural anti-YAC-1 leukemia activity. On the contrary, M phi-depleted suspensions of PC retained their anti-chondrocyte activity at the initial level. Neither adherent SPL nor adherent PC exerted significant anti-chondrocyte cytotoxicity. The activity of nonadherent SPL could be, however, restored by reconstitution with the graded numbers of syngeneic adherent spleen- or peritoneal cavity-derived cells. Restoration of anti-chondrocyte activity of nonadherent SPL to the level comparable with that of untreated SPL was achieved with about 10% of adherent cells. On the other hand, reconstitution of nonadherent PC did not result in an increase of chondrocyte lysis. Potentiation of nonadherent SPL activity was seen only with syngeneic M phi, and the latter could not be replaced by conditioned media which were generated in the 18-hr culture of adherent SPL or PC.

Role of cytokines in the monocyte-mediated augmentation of human natural killer cell activity

Previous work has shown that normal human monocytes can augment natural killer (NK) cell activity both when mixed with enriched null cells in the assay and when precultured with enriched null cells and removed prior to testing. The data presented here show that a 4-hr preculture period is superior to slightly longer periods (10-12 hr) for demonstrating the augmentation. The role of cytokines in the monocyte effect was then investigated using a variety of antibody and recombinant reagents. Both monoclonal and rabbit polyclonal antibodies to IL-1 and IL-2 inhibited the monocyte effect, whereas antibodies against IFN-alpha and IFN-gamma from both sources had no effect. Of these cytokines, only IL-1 could be demonstrated (using a sensitive IL-1-dependent-IL-2 synthesis assay) in the supernatants of 4-hr cultures of monocytes plus null cells or null cells only. The ability to detect IL-1 was specifically inhibited by rabbit antibody to human IL-1 at 1:20 and 1:200 dilutions, but only the greater concentration inhibited the monocyte effect on NK activity. In contrast, the detection of soluble IL-1 was not inhibited by including monoclonal anti-IL-1 (1:20 dilution) in the 4-hr culture, although the same reagent abrogated the monocyte effect under these conditions. Recombinant IL-1 (up to 100 units/ml) did not augment NK activity either when added to the assay or when precultured for 4 hr with enriched null cells, whereas either recombinant IL-2 or monocytes were effective under these conditions. These results provide the first evidence for a cellular, and potentially physiologic, basis for the regulation of NK activity by IL-1 and IL-2, which had been previously known to act at pharmacologic levels in vitro.

The cytolytic and regulatory role of natural killer cells in experimental neoplasia

NK cells are defined here as cells, other than macrophages and polymorphonuclear leucocytes, from non-immunized animals (or humans) which are cytotoxic for neoplastic and non-neoplastic targets in the absence of specific antibody. Though not requiring antibody, they may function as K cells in ADCC. This definition includes cells activated nonspecifically by such agents as IFN and IL-2. Murine NK cells may be subdivided into two types by differences in the kinetics of target-cell lysis. Those we label Type 1 correspond roughly to what others have called NKA, NKL or simply NK cells; those of Type 2 to NKB, NKS and NC cells. Type 1 cells express various antigens, including NK-1, Thy-1 (50%), Ly-1 (25%), Qa-3, Qa-4, Qa-5, Ly-5, Ly-6, Ly-10, Ly-11 and asialo-GM1, not expressed by Type 2 cells, whereas Mac-1 may be expressed by both types. At least some NK cells appear to be pre-thymic cells which, in the presence of a thymus, can differentiate into T cells. The level of NK activity is influenced by the age and genetic background of the mouse, the organ from which the cells are obtained, and a variety of experimental manipulations. Type 1 activity is increased by IFN and IL-2; Type 2 activity by IL-3. IFN appears to be concerned in the development of spontaneous NK activity in young mice. Many experiments have shown that NK cells may inhibit the growth of tumours which are sensitive to NK cells of the same type in vitro. Inhibitory cells which suppress NK activity may play an important regulatory role in vivo. There is still uncertainty about how NK cells recognize their targets. Possibilities discussed are: (1) specific interacting molecules; (2) more diffuse properties of target cell membranes; (3) absence of MHC-coded self-recognition markers. Certainly, the presence of a Class 1 MHC molecule is not necessary. NK killing appears to be mediated by cytotoxins released by NK cells. In vivo, NK cells contribute to limiting the development of transplanted and primary tumours, and metastasis from established tumours. NK cells seem well qualified to act as a first-line defence against neoplasia, and may kill cells not killed by T cells. Transfer of NK cells may be of value in the treatment of cancer.

Monocyte-mediated augmentation of human natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity

Normal human monocytes can significantly and rapidly augment natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity (NCMC) against K562 target cells. Approximately 50% augmentation was observed after direct mixture of monocytes with autologous null cells in the 4-hr chromium-release assay. This effect was dependent on the number of monocytes, and B cells and granulocytes were not effective. Coculture of null cells with monocytes and subsequent recovery of null cells for use as effector cells also produced significantly elevated cytolytic activity. This effect was dependent upon the number of monocytes, the length of time of coculture, and the cell donor. Augmentation of NK activity was rapid and observed after 0.5-12 hr of coculture, but suppression was observed after 36 hr; augmentation was observed with high monocyte:null cell (1:1, 1:2) ratios, and no effect was generally observed with lower ratios (1:8). At the single-cell level, the augmentation was associated with an increase in the proportion of target-binding cells which were lytically active. The augmentation of NK activity by monocytes required close cellular proximity, was mediated by a factor which was active or induced only in close proximity of the effector and producer cells, and/or was mediated by a soluble factor with a molecular weight greater than 50,000. This new demonstration that monocytes can augment as well as suppress NCMC may represent another avenue by which NK cell activity may be modulated in vivo.

Natural killer cell sensitivity of human lymphoid lines of B-cell origin does not correlate with tumorigenicity or with the expression of certain differentiation markers

Human B-cell lines derived from normal donors (LCL) or from Burkitt lymphomas (BL) were compared for their sensitivity to natural (NK) and interferon (IFN)-activated (IAK) cytotoxicity, mediated by effector cells from normal human blood. In four cases, a BL and an LCL line were derived from the same donor and had been kept in culture for the same period of time. The BL series included both Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-carrying and EBV-negative lymphoma lines. The latter were compared with their own EBV-converted, Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen (EBNA)- and EBV-DNA-positive sublines, established by in vitro infection with two different viral substrains. LCL and BL lines from the same donor were lysed with equal efficiency by both NK and IAK effectors. There was no relationship between the NK sensitivity and the nude mouse tumorigenicity of different EBV-converted Ramos sublines, or the expression of differentiation markers such as insulin receptor, surface IgD, and the B2 surface antigen. Moreover, EBV-converted sublines of BJAB differed in their NK sensitivity, in spite of closely similar expression of these markers. NK-sensitive Ramos and BJAB sublines induced a stronger proliferative response upon confrontation with allogeneic lymphocytes than their NK-resistant counterparts. This suggests that the target cell may play an active role in triggering the lytic interaction. There was no correlation between this property and any of the other parameters studied.

Gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma) produced during effector and target interactions renders target cells less susceptible to NK-cell-mediated lysis

Human mitomycin C-treated PBL were mixed with cells of an NK sensitive hybrid cell line (PUTKO-I). A fraction of tumor cells survived this treatment and could be recovered from the cultures. These surviving cells were completely NK-resistant and this property persisted for 2-3 weeks after cultivation in fresh medium. Treatment of a clone (C13) of PUTKO-I with PBL-PUTKO mixed lymphocyte-tumor-cell culture (MLTC) supernatants resulted in a marked reduction in NK sensitivity after 8-12 h of treatment. The kinetics of induction of NK resistance by MLTC supernatants was similar to that of purified IFN-gamma and was faster than for IFN-alpha. The active component in the supernatants was characterized as a mixture of IFN-gamma and IFN-alpha based on neutralization of activity with specific antisera. The role of mycoplasma contamination was investigated and it was found that cell lines free of detectable mycoplasma stimulated production of NK-protective activity by PBL and this activity was neutralized by anti-IFN-gamma serum. Separation of PBL on discontinuous Percoll gradients demonstrated a correlation between the NK activity of cell fractions and their ability to produce IFN in response to tumor cells. Taken together, the selection-dependent variations in NK sensitivity, the kinetics of IFN production and induction of resistance suggest that tumor cells may be able to escape elimination by NK cells due to protection by IFN produced by the effector-cell-containing population.