The Effect of Different Metal Cation Binding on the Proton Pumping in Bacteriorhodopsin

Cation Binding to Xanthorhodopsin: Electron Paramagnetic Resonance and Magnetic Studies

Xanthorhodopsin (xR) is a member of the retinal protein family and acts as a proton pump in the cell membranes of the extremely halophilic eubacterium Salinibacter ruber. In addition to the retinal chromophore, xR contains a carotenoid, which acts as a light-harvesting antenna as it transfers 40% of the quanta it absorbs to the retinal. Our previous studies have shown that the CD and absorption spectra of xR are dramatically affected due to the protonation of two different residues. It is still unclear whether xR can bind cations. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy used in the present study revealed that xR can bind divalent cations, such as Mn²⁺ and Ca²⁺, to deionized xR (DI-xR). We also demonstrate that xR can bind 1 equiv of Mn²⁺ to a high-affinity binding site followed by binding of ∼40 equiv in cooperative manner and ∼100 equiv of Mn²⁺ that are weakly bound. SQUID magnetic studies suggest that the high cooperative binding of Mn²⁺ cations to xR is due to the formation of Mn²⁺ clusters. Our data demonstrate that Ca²⁺ cations bind to DI-xR with a lower affinity than Mn²⁺, supporting the assumption that binding of Mn²⁺ occurs through cluster formation, because Ca²⁺ cations cannot form clusters in contrast to Mn²⁺.

Melittin-regenerated purple membrane

We have investigated the character of melittin-regenerated purple membrane. Adding melittin to blue membrane causes the color transition and partial regeneration of the photocycle and the proton pump. The reconstitution of bacteriorhodopsin by melittin is proved to be charge-dependent. In studying the location of melittin binding on the blue membrane, we suggest that melittin anchors on the membrane through both hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions. The electrostatic interaction is dominant. The binding sites for the electrostatic interaction should be on the surface of the membrane.

Proton Transfers Induced by Lead(II) in a Uracil Nucleobase: A Study Based on Quantum Chemistry Calculations

Within the context of metal biotoxicity, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry experiments (ESIMS) have recently been performed by us on the pyrimidine nucleobases (B) uracil and thymine complexed with lead(II) [Int. J. Mass. Spectrom. 2005, 243, 279]. Among the ions detected, [Pb(B)-H]+ complexes, where the base has been deprotonated, have been identified as producing intense signals. In the same study, quantum calculations based on density functional theory (DFT) have assessed the complexation sites and energies of [Pb(B)-H]+ ions. The present DFT investigations aim at giving an understanding on the energetics and mechanisms associated with uracil's loss of a proton. We specifically assess and quantify the role of lead binding in this process. For that purpose, intra- and intermolecular proton transfers have been considered. We have found that uracil (U) 1,3-tautomerization can be exergonic when uracil is complexed with Pb2+, in opposition to the situation without lead. The corresponding intramolecular processes were nonetheless found to occur at geological time scales. In contrast, the addition of a second body to [Pb(U)]2+ complexes, namely OH- or H2O (as found in the initial water droplet of ESIMS experiments), gives exergonic and fast uracil 1,3-proton transfers. Finally, we have shown that intermolecular proton transfers in uracil-H2O, uracil-OH-, or uracil-uracil complexes are able to explain the experimentally detected [Pb(U)-H]+ ions.

Gas-Phase Deprotonation of Uracil−Cu2+ and Thiouracil−Cu2+ Complexes

The deprotonation of Cu2+ complexes with uracil, 2-thiouracil, 4-thiouracil, and 2,4-dithiouracil has been investigated by means of B3LYP/ 6-311+G(2df,2p)//6-31G(d) calculations. The most stable [(uracil-H)Cu]+ and [(thiouracil-H)Cu]+ complexes correspond to bidentate structures in which Cu interacts with the deprotonated ring-nitrogen atom and with the oxygen or the sulfur atom of the adjacent carbonyl or thiocarbonyl group. For 2- and 4-thiouracil derivatives, the structures in which the metal cation interacts with the thiocarbonyl group are clearly favored with respect to those in which Cu interacts with the carbonyl group. This is at variance with what was found to be the most stable structure of the corresponding Cu2+ complexes, where association to the carbonyl oxygen was always preferred over the association to the thiocarbonyl group. The [(uracil-H)Cu]+ and [(thiouracil-H)Cu]+ complexes can be viewed as the result of Cu+ attachment to the uracil-H and thiouracil-H radicals formed by the deprotonation of the corresponding uracil+* and thiouracil+* radical cations. As a matter of fact their relative stability is dictated by the intrinsic stability of the corresponding uracil-H and thiouracil-H radical and by the fact that, in general, the N3-deprotonated site is a better electron donor than the N1. In all complexes, the bonding of Cu both to nitrogen and sulfur and to nitrogen and oxygen has a significantly large covalent character.

Eu3+binding to europium-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin upon delipidation and monomerization

We have studied the effect of monomerization of the purple membrane lattice, as well as removal of 75% of the lipids, on the binding properties of Eu(3+) ions. We found that delipidation and monomerization do not cause the cations to lose their binding ability to the protein. This suggests that the three most strongly bound Eu(3+) cations do not bind to the lipids, but directly bind to the protein. Furthermore, we found that delipidation actually causes a slight increase in the binding affinity. This is likely a result of reduced aggregation of europium-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin (bR) upon lipid removal causing more exposure of the binding sites to the Eu(3+) cations. These results, taken with those from our previous publication [Heyes and El-Sayed, Biophys. J. 85 (2003) 426-434], might suggest that the cations remain bound upon delipidation of bR, but have no effect on the function. This is discussed with respect to the role of cations in the function of native bR.

Proton transfer reactions in native and deionized bacteriorhodopsin upon delipidation and monomerization

We have investigated the role of the native lipids on bacteriorhodopsin (bR) proton transfer and their connection with the cation-binding role. We observe that both the efficiency of M formation and the kinetics of M rise and decay depend on the lipids and lattice but, as the lipids are removed, the cation binding is a much less important factor for the proton pumping function. Upon 75% delipidation using 3-[(cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-propanesulfonate (CHAPS), the M formation and decay kinetics are much slower than the native, and the efficiency of M formation is approximately 30%-40% that of the native. Upon monomerization of bR by Trition X-100, the efficiency of M recovers close to that of the native (depending on pH), M formation is approximately 10 times faster, and M decay kinetics are comparable to native at pH 7. The same results on the M intermediate are observed if deionized blue bR (deI bbR) is treated with these detergents (with or without pH buffers present), even though deionized blue bR containing all the lipids has no photocycle. This suggests that the cation(s) has a role in native bR that is different than in delipidated or monomerized bR, even so far as to suggest that the cation(s) becomes unimportant to the function as the lipids are removed.

The role of the native lipids and lattice structure in bacteriorhodopsin protein conformation and stability as studied by temperature-dependent Fourier transform-infrared spectroscopy

We report the effect of partial delipidation and monomerization on the protein conformational changes of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) as a function of temperature. Removal of up to 75% of the lipids is known to have the lattice structure of the purple membrane, albeit as a smaller unit cell, whereas treatment by Triton monomerizes bR into micelles. The effects of these modifications on the protein secondary structure is analyzed by monitoring the protein amide I and amide II bands in the Fourier transform-infrared (FT-IR) spectra. It is found that removal of the first 75% of the lipids has only a slight effect on the secondary structure at physiological temperature, whereas monomerizing bR into micelles alters the secondary structure considerably. Upon heating, the bR monomer is found to have a very low thermal stability compared with the native bR with its melting point reduced from 97 to 65 degrees C, and the pre-melting transition in which the protein changes conformation in native bR at 80 degrees C could not be observed. Also, the N[bond]H to N[bond]D exchange of the amide II band is effectively complete at room temperature, suggesting that there are no hydrophobic regions that are protected from the aqueous medium, possibly explaining the low thermal stability of the monomer. On the other hand, 75% delipidated bR has its melting temperature close to that of the native bR and does have a pre-melting transition, although the pre-melting transition occurs at significantly higher temperature than that of the native bR (91 degrees C compared with 80 degrees C) and is still reversible. Furthermore, we have also observed that the reversibility of this pre-melting transition of both native and partially delipidated bR is time-dependent and becomes irreversible upon holding at 91 degrees C between 10 and 30 min. These results are discussed in terms of the lipid and lattice contribution to the protein thermal stability of native bR.

Fourier transform infrared study of the effect of different cations on bacteriorhodopsin protein thermal stability

The effect of divalent ion binding to deionized bacteriorhodopsin (dI-bR) on the thermal transitions of the protein secondary structure have been studied by using temperature-dependent Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy. The native metal ions in bR, Ca(2+), and Mg(2+), which we studied previously, are compared with Mn(2+), Hg(2+), and a large, synthesized divalent organic cation, ((Et)(3)N)(2)Bu(2+). It was found that in all cases of ion regeneration, there is a pre-melting, reversible conformational transition in which the amide frequency shifts from 1665 to 1652 cm(-1). This always occurs at approximately 80 degrees C, independent of which cation is used for the regeneration. The irreversible thermal transition (melting), monitored by the appearance of the band at 1623 cm(-1), is found to occur at a lower temperature than that for the native bR but higher than that for acid blue bR in all cases. However, the temperature for this transition is dependent on the identity of the cation. Furthermore, it is shown that the mechanism of melting of the organic cation regenerated bR is different than for the metal cations, suggesting a difference in the type of binding to the protein (either to different sites or different binding to the same site). These results are used to propose specific direct binding mechanisms of the ions to the protein of deionized bR.

Specific binding sites for cations in bacteriorhodopsin

The Asp-85 residue, located in the vicinity of the retinal chromophore, plays a key role in the function of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) as a light-driven proton pump. In the unphotolyzed pigment the protonation of Asp-85 is responsible for the transition from the purple form (lambda(max) = 570 nm) to the blue form (lambda(max) = 605 nm) of bR. This transition can also be induced by deionization (cation removal). It was previously proposed that the cations bind to the bR surface and raise the surface pH, or bind to a specific site in the protein, probably in the retinal vicinity. We have reexamined these possibilities by evaluating the interaction between Mn(2+) and a nitroxyl radical probe covalently bound to several mutants in which protein residues were substituted by cystein. We have found that Mn(2+), which binds to the highest-affinity binding site, significantly affects the EPR spectrum of a spin label attached to residue 74C. Therefore, it is concluded that the highest-affinity binding site is located in the extracellular side of the protein and its distance from the spin label at 74C is estimated to be approximately 9.8 +/- 0.7 A. At least part of the three to four low-affinity cation binding sites are located in the cytoplasmic side, because Mn(2+) bound to these binding sites affects spin labels attached to residues 103C and 163C located in the cytoplasmic side of the protein. The results indicate specific binding sites for the color-controlling cations, and suggest that the binding sites involve negatively charged lipids located on the exterior of the bR trimer structure.

Time-resolved Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of the polarizable proton continua and the proton pump mechanism of bacteriorhodopsin

Nanosecond-to-microsecond time-resolved Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy in the 3000-1000-cm(-1) region has been used to examine the polarizable proton continua observed in bacteriorhodopsin (bR) during its photocycle. The difference in the transient FTIR spectra in the time domain between 20 ns and 1 ms shows a broad absorption continuum band in the 2100-1800-cm(-1) region, a bleach continuum band in the 2500-2150-cm(-1) region, and a bleach continuum band above 2700 cm(-1). According to Zundel (G., J. Mol. Struct. 322:33-42), these continua appear in systems capable of forming polarizable hydrogen bonds. The formation of a bleach continuum suggests the presence of a polarizable proton in the ground state that changes during the photocycle. The appearance of a transient absorption continuum suggests a change in the polarizable proton or the appearance of new ones. It is found that each continuum has a rise time of less than 80 ns and a decay time component of approximately 300 micros. In addition, it is found that the absorption continuum in the 2100-1800-cm(-1) region has a slow rise component of 190 ns and a fast decay component of approximately 60 micros. Using these results and those of the recent x-ray structural studies of bR(570) and M(412) (H. Luecke, B. Schobert, H.T. Richter, J.-P. Cartailler, and J. K., Science 286:255-260), together with the already known spectroscopic properties of the different intermediates in the photocycle, the possible origins of the polarizable protons giving rise to these continua during the bR photocycle are proposed. Models of the proton pump are discussed in terms of the changes in these polarizable protons and the hydrogen-bonded chains and in terms of previously known results such as the simultaneous deprotonation of the protonated Schiff base (PSB) and Tyr185 and the disappearance of water molecules in the proton release channel during the proton pump process.

The Effect of Metal Cation Binding on the Protein, Lipid and Retinal Isomeric Ratio in Regenerated Bacteriorhodopsin of Purple Membrane¶

The effect of metal cation binding on bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in purple membrane has been examined using in situ attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopy in aqueous media. It is known that adding metal cations to deionized bR regenerates the purple state from its blue state and recovers the proton pump function. During this process, infrared spectral changes in the frequency region of 1800-1000 cm-1 are monitored. The results reveal that metal cation binding affects the protein conformation, the retinal isomeric composition as well as lipid head groups. It is also observed that metal cation binding induces conformational changes in the alpha 1-helix region of bR, converting the portion of its alpha 1-helical domain into beta-turn or disordered coil. In addition, the influence of Ho3+ binding on the protein and lipid is observed to be larger than that of Ca2+. These results suggest that some of the metal cation binding sites are on the membrane lipid domain, while others could be on the intrahelical domain or interhelical loops where the Asp and Glu are located (binding with their COO- groups). Our results also suggest that the removal of the C-terminal of bR increase the accessibility of the binding site of metal cations, which affects protein conformational structure. All these observations are discussed in terms of the two proposals given in the literature regarding the metal cation binding sites.

Nature of the chromophore binding site of bacteriorhodopsin: the potential role of Arg82 as a principal counterion

The nature of the chromophore binding site of light-adapted bacteriorhodopsin is analyzed by using modified neglect of differential overlap with partial single and double configuration interaction (MNDO-PSDCI) molecular orbital theory to interpret previously reported linear and nonlinear optical spectroscopic measurements. We conclude that in the absence of divalent metal cations in close interaction with Asp85 and Asp212, a positively charged amino acid must be present in the same vicinity. We find that models in which Arg82 is pointed upward into the chromophore binding site and directly stabilizes Asp85 and Asp212 are successful in rationalizing the observed one-photon and two-photon properties. We conclude further that a water molecule is strongly hydrogen bonded to the chromophore imine proton. The chromophore "1Bu*+" and "1Ag*-" states, despite extensive mixing, exhibit significantly different configurational character. The lowest-lying "1Bu*+" state is dominated by single excitations, whereas the second-excited "1Ag*-" state is dominated by double excitations. We can rule out the possibility of a negatively charged binding site, because such a site would produce a lowest-lying "1Ag*-" state, which is contrary to experimental observation. The possibility that Arg82 migrates toward the extracellular surface during the photocycle is examined.

Generation of the O630 photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin is controlled by the state of protonation of several protein residues

The last stages of the photocycle of the photosynthetic pigment all-trans bacteriorhodopsin (bR570), as well as its proton pump mechanism, are markedly pH dependent. We have measured the relative amount of the accumulated O630 intermediate (Phir), as well as its rise and decay rate constants (kr and kd, respectively), over a wide pH range. The experiments were carried out in deionized membrane suspensions to which varying concentrations of metal cations and of large organic cations were added. The observed pH dependencies, s-shaped curves in the case of Phir and bell-shaped curves for kr and kd, are interpreted in terms of the titration of three protein residues denoted as R1, R2, and R3. The R1 titration is responsible for the increase in Phir, kr, and kd upon lowering the pH from pH approximately 9.5 to 7. At low pH Phir exhibits a secondary rise which is attributed to the titration of a low pKa group, R2. After reaching a maximum at pH approximately 7, kr and kd undergo a decrease upon decreasing the pH, which is attributed to the titration of R3. All three titrations exhibit pKa values which decrease upon increasing the salt concentration. As in the case of the Purple (bR570) if Blue (bR605) equilibrium, divalent cations are substantially more effective than monovalent cations in shifting the pKa values. Moreover, bulky organic cations are as effective as small metal cations. It is concluded that analogously to the Purple if Blue equilibrium, the salt binding sites which control the pKa values of R1, R2, and R3 are located on, or close to, the membrane surface. Possible identifications of the three protein residues are considered. Experiments with the E204Q mutant show that the mutation has markedly affected the R2 (Phir) titration, suggesting that R2 should be identified with Glu-204 or with a group whose pKa is affected by Glu-204. The relation between the R1, R2 and R3 titrations and the proton pump mechanism is discussed. It is evident that the pH dependence of Phir is unrelated to the measured pKa of the group (XH) which releases the proton to the extracellular medium during the photocycle. However, since the same residue may exhibit different pKa values at different stages of the photocycle, it cannot be excluded that R2 or R3 may be identified with XH.

Photochemistry in dried polymer films incorporating the deionized blue membrane form of bacteriorhodopsin

The preparation and photochemical properties of dried deionized blue membrane (dIbR600; lambdamax approximately 600 nm, epsilon approximately 54, 760 cm-1 M-1, f approximately 1.1) in polyvinyl alcohol films are studied. Reversible photoconversion from dIbR600 to the pink membrane (dIbR485; lambdamax approximately 485 nm) is shown to occur in these films under conditions of strong 647-nm laser irradiation. The pink membrane analog, dIbR485, has a molar extinction coefficient of approximately 39,000 cm-1 M-1 (f approximately 1.2). The ratio of pink --> blue and blue --> pink quantum efficiencies is 33 +/- 5. We observe an additional blue-shifted species (dIbR455, lambdamax approximately 455 nm) with a very low oscillator strength (f approximately 0.6, epsilon approximately 26,000 cm-1 M-1). This species is the product of fast thermal decay of dIbR485. Molecular modeling indicates that charge/charge and charge/dipole interactions introduced by the protonation of ASP85 are responsible for lowering the excited-state all-trans --> 9-cis barrier to approximately 6 kcal mol-1 while increasing the corresponding all-trans --> 13-cis barrier to approximately 4 kcal mol-1. Photochemical formation of both 9-cis and 13-cis photoproducts are now competitive, as is observed experimentally. We suggest that dIbR455 may be a 9-cis, 10-s-distorted species that partially divides the chromophore into two localized conjugated segments with a concomitant blue shift and decreased oscillator strength of the lambdamax absorption band.

Titration kinetics of Asp-85 in bacteriorhodopsin: exclusion of the retinal pocket as the color-controlling cation binding site

The spectrum (the purple blue transition) and function of the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin are determined by the state of protonation of the Asp-85 residue located in the vicinity of the retinal chromophore. The titration of Asp-85 is controlled by the binding/unbinding of one or two divalent metal cations (Ca2+ or Mg2+). The location of such metal binding site(s) is approached by studying the kinetics of the cation-induced titration of Asp-85 using metal ions and large molecular cations, such as quaternary ammonium ions, R4N+ (R = Et, Pr, a divalent 'bolaform ion' [Et3N+-(CH2)4-N+Et3] and the 1:3 molecular complex formed between Fe2+ and 1,10-phenanthroline (OP). The basic multi-component kinetic features of the titration, extending from 10(-2) to 10(4) s, are unaffected by the charge and size of the cation. This indicates that cation binding to bR triggers the blue --> purple titration in a fast step, which is not rate-determining. In view of the size of the cations involved, these observations indicate that the cation binding site is in an exposed location on, or close to, the membrane surface. This excludes previous models, which placed the color-controlling Ca2+ ion in the retinal binding pocket.