Heterozygosis in aromatic amino acid decarboxylase deficiency: Evidence for a positive interallelic complementation between R347Q and R358H mutations

An attenuated, adult case of AADC deficiency demonstrated by protein characterization

A case of an adult with borderline AADC deficiency symptoms is presented here. Genetic analysis revealed that the patient carries two AADC variants (NM_000790.3: c.1040G > A and c.679G > C) in compound heterozygosis, resulting in p.Arg347Gln and p.Glu227Gln amino acid alterations. While p.Arg347Gln is a known pathogenic variant, p.Glu227Gln is unknown. Combining clinical features to bioinformatic and molecular characterization of the AADC protein population of the patient (p.Arg347Gln/p.Arg347Gln homodimer, p.Glu227Gln/p.Glu227Gln homodimer, and p.Glu227Gln/p.Arg347Gln heterodimer), we determined that: i) the p.Arg347Gln/p.Arg347Gln homodimer is inactive since the alteration affects a catalytically essential structural element at the active site, ii) the p.Glu227Gln/p.Glu227Gln homodimer is as active as the wild-type AADC since the alteration occurs at the surface and does not change the chemical nature of the amino acid, and iii) the p.Glu227Gln/p.Arg347Gln heterodimer has a catalytic efficiency 75% that of the wild-type since only one of the two active sites is compromised, thus demonstrating a positive complementation. By this approach, the molecular basis for the mild presentation of the disease is provided, and the experience made can also be useful for personalized therapeutic decisions in other mild AADC deficiency patients. Interestingly, in the last few years, many previously undiagnosed or misdiagnosed patients have been identified as mild cases of AADC deficiency, expanding the phenotype of this neurotransmitter disease.

Spectrum of DDC variants causing aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency and pathogenicity interpretation using ACMG-AMP/ACGS recommendations

Pathogenic variants in dopa decarboxylase (DDC), the gene encoding the aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) enzyme, lead to a severe deficiency of neurotransmitters, resulting in neurological, neuromuscular, and behavioral manifestations clinically characterized by developmental delays, oculogyric crises, dystonia, and severe neurologic dysfunction in infancy. Historically, therapy has been aimed at compensating for neurotransmitter abnormalities, but response to pharmacologic therapy varies, and in most cases, the therapy shows little or no benefit. A novel human DDC gene therapy was recently approved in the European Union that targets the underlying genetic cause of the disorder, providing a new treatment option for patients with AADC deficiency. However, the applicability of human DDC gene therapy depends on the ability of laboratories and clinicians to interpret the results of genetic testing accurately enough to diagnose the patient. An accurate interpretation of genetic variants depends in turn on expert-guided curation of locus-specific databases. The purpose of this research was to identify previously uncharacterized DDC variants that are of pathologic significance in AADC deficiency as well as characterize and curate variants of unknown significance (VUSs) to further advance the diagnostic accuracy of genetic testing for this condition. DDC variants were identified using existing databases and the literature. The pathogenicity of the variants was classified using modified American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology/Association for Clinical Genomic Science (ACMG-AMP/ACGS) criteria. To improve the current variant interpretation recommendations, in silico variant interpretation tools were combined with structural 3D modeling of protein variants and applied comparative analysis to predict the impact of the variant on protein function. A total of 422 variants were identified (http://biopku.org/home/pnddb.asp). Variants were identified on nearly all introns and exons of the DDC gene, as well as the 3' and 5' untranslated regions. The largest percentage of the identified variants (48%) were classified as missense variants. The molecular effects of these missense variants were then predicted, and the pathogenicity of each was classified using a number of variant effect predictors. Using ACMG-AMP/ACGS criteria, 7% of variants were classified as pathogenic, 32% as likely pathogenic, 58% as VUSs of varying subclassifications, 1% as likely benign, and 1% as benign. For 101 out of 108 reported genotypes, at least one allele was classified as pathogenic or likely pathogenic. In silico variant pathogenicity interpretation tools, combined with structural 3D modeling of variant proteins and applied comparative analysis, have improved the current DDC variant interpretation recommendations, particularly of VUSs.

Compound Heterozygosis in AADC Deficiency and Its Complex Phenotype in Terms of AADC Protein Population

Aromatic amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency is a rare monogenic disease due to mutations in the ddc gene producing AADC, a homodimeric pyridoxal 5′-phosphate-dependent enzyme. The disorder is often fatal in the first decade and is characterized by profound motor impairments and developmental delay. In the last two years, there has been a net rise in the number of patients and variants identified, maybe also pushed by the ongoing gene therapy trials. The majority of the identified genotypes are compound heterozygous (about 70%). Efforts are underway to reach early diagnosis, find possible new markers/new fast methods, and predict clinical outcome. However, no clear correlation of genotype-to-phenotype exists to date. Nevertheless, for homozygous patients, reliable results have been obtained using genetic methods combined with available computational tools on crystal structures corroborated by biochemical investigations on recombinant homodimeric AADC variants that have been obtained and characterized in solution. For these variants, the molecular basis for the defect has been suggested and validated, since it correlates quite well with mildness/severity of the homozygous phenotype. Instead, prediction for compound heterozygous patients is more difficult since complementation effects could happen. Here, by analyzing the existing literature on compound heterozygosity in AADC deficiency and other genetic disorders, we highlight that, in order to assess pathogenicity, the measurement of activity of the AADC heterodimeric variant should be integrated by bioinformatic, structural, and functional data on the whole protein constellation theoretically present in such patients. A wider discussion on symptomatic heterozygosity in AADC deficiency is also presented.

The novel P330L pathogenic variant of aromatic amino acid decarboxylase maps on the catalytic flexible loop underlying its crucial role

Aromatic amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency is a rare monogenic disease, often fatal in the first decade, causing severe intellectual disability, movement disorders and autonomic dysfunction. It is due to mutations in the gene coding for the AADC enzyme responsible for the synthesis of dopamine and serotonin. Using whole exome sequencing, we have identified a novel homozygous c.989C > T (p.Pro330Leu) variant of AADC causing AADC deficiency. Pro330 is part of an essential structural and functional element: the flexible catalytic loop suggested to cover the active site as a lid and properly position the catalytic residues. Our investigations provide evidence that Pro330 concurs in the achievement of an optimal catalytic competence. Through a combination of bioinformatic approaches, dynamic light scattering measurements, limited proteolysis experiments, spectroscopic and in solution analyses, we demonstrate that the substitution of Pro330 with Leu, although not determining gross conformational changes, results in an enzymatic species that is highly affected in catalysis with a decarboxylase catalytic efficiency decreased by 674- and 194-fold for the two aromatic substrates. This defect does not lead to active site structural disassembling, nor to the inability to bind the pyridoxal 5’-phosphate (PLP) cofactor. The molecular basis for the pathogenic effect of this variant is rather due to a mispositioning of the catalytically competent external aldimine intermediate, as corroborated by spectroscopic analyses and pH dependence of the kinetic parameters. Altogether, we determined the structural basis for the severity of the manifestation of AADC deficiency in this patient and discussed the rationale for a precision therapy.

Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase deficiency: a patient-derived neuronal model for precision therapies

Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency is a complex inherited neurological disorder of monoamine synthesis which results in dopamine and serotonin deficiency. The majority of affected individuals have variable, though often severe cognitive and motor delay, with a complex movement disorder and high risk of premature mortality. For most, standard pharmacological treatment provides only limited clinical benefit. Promising gene therapy approaches are emerging, though may not be either suitable or easily accessible for all patients. To characterize the underlying disease pathophysiology and guide precision therapies, we generated a patient-derived midbrain dopaminergic neuronal model of AADC deficiency from induced pluripotent stem cells. The neuronal model recapitulates key disease features, including absent AADC enzyme activity and dysregulated dopamine metabolism. We observed developmental defects affecting synaptic maturation and neuronal electrical properties, which were improved by lentiviral gene therapy. Bioinformatic and biochemical analyses on recombinant AADC predicted that the activity of one variant could be improved by l-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (l-DOPA) administration; this hypothesis was corroborated in the patient-derived neuronal model, where l-DOPA treatment leads to amelioration of dopamine metabolites. Our study has shown that patient-derived disease modelling provides further insight into the neurodevelopmental sequelae of AADC deficiency, as well as a robust platform to investigate and develop personalized therapeutic approaches.

Compound heterozygosis in AADC deficiency: A complex phenotype dissected through comparison among heterodimeric and homodimeric AADC proteins

Compound heterozygosis is the most diffuse and hardly to tackle condition in aromatic amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency, a genetic disease leading to severe neurological impairment. Here, by using an appropriate vector, we succeeded in obtaining high yields of AADC protein and characterizing two new heterodimers, T69M/S147R and C281W/M362T, detected in two AADC deficiency patients. We performed an extensive biochemical characterization of the heterodimeric recombinant proteins and of the related homodimers, by a combination of dichroic and fluorescence spectroscopy and activity assays together with bioinformatic analyses. We found that T69M/S147R exhibits negative complementation in terms of activity but it is more stable than the average of the homodimeric counterparts. The heterodimer C281W/M362T retains a nearly good catalytic efficiency, whereas M362T homodimer is less affected and C281W homodimer is recovered as insoluble. These results, which are consistent with the related phenotypes, and the data emerging from previous studies, suggest that the severity of AADC deficiency is not directly explained by positive or negative complementation phenomena, but rather depends on: i) the integrity of one or both active sites; ii) the structural and functional properties of the entire pool of AADC proteins expressed. Overall, this integrated and cross-sectional approach enables proper characterization and depicts the functional result of subunit interactions in the dimeric structure and will help to elucidate the physio-pathological mechanisms in AADC deficiency.

Aromatic Amino Acid Decarboxylase Deficiency: The Added Value of Biochemistry

Aromatic amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency is a rare, autosomal recessive neurometabolic disorder caused by mutations in the DDC gene, leading to a deficit of AADC, a pyridoxal 5′-phosphate requiring enzyme that catalyzes the decarboxylation of L-Dopa and L-5-hydroxytryptophan in dopamine and serotonin, respectively. Although clinical and genetic studies have given the major contribution to the diagnosis and therapy of AADC deficiency, biochemical investigations have also helped the comprehension of this disorder at a molecular level. Here, we reported the steps leading to the elucidation of the functional and structural features of the enzyme that were useful to identify the different molecular defects caused by the mutations, either in homozygosis or in heterozygosis, associated with AADC deficiency. By revisiting the biochemical data available on the characterization of the pathogenic variants in the purified recombinant form, and interpreting them on the basis of the structure-function relationship of AADC, it was possible: (i) to define the enzymatic phenotype of patients harboring pathogenic mutations and at the same time to propose specific therapeutic managements, and (ii) to identify residues and/or regions of the enzyme relevant for catalysis and/or folding of AADC.

Aromatic L-amino acid decarboxylase deficiency in 17 Mainland China patients: Clinical phenotype, molecular spectrum, and therapy overview

Background

Aromatic L‐amino acid decarboxylase deficiency (AADCD) is a rare, autosomal recessive inherited disorder which is characterized by neurological and vegetative symptoms. To date, only 130 patients with AADCD have been reported worldwide.

Methods

We demonstrated 14 previously undescribed patients together with three reportedly patients in Mainland China. Full clinical information was collected, and disease‐causing variants in the DDC gene were detected.

Results

The common clinical manifestation of patients, including intermittent oculogyric crises, retarded movement development, and autonomic symptoms. Notably, a patient showed bone‐density loss which have not been reported and two mildly phenotype patients improved psychomotor function after being prescribed medication. The most common genotype of Mainland Chinese AADCD is the splice‐site variant (IVS6+4A> T; c.714+4A> T), which accounts for 58.8%, followed by c.1234C>T variant. Three novel compound heterozygous variants, c. 565G>T, c.170T>C, and c.1021+1G>A, were firstly reported. It is important to recognize the milder phenotypes of the disease as these patients might respond well to therapy. Besides, we discovered that patients may presented with milder if found to be compound heterozygote or homozygote for one of the following variants c.478C>G, c.853C>T, c.1123C>T, c.387G>A, and c.665T>C.

Discussion

The clinical data of the cohort of 17 patients in Mainland China broaden the clinical, molecular, and treatment spectrum of aromatic L‐amino acid decarboxylase deficiency.

New variants of AADC deficiency expand the knowledge of enzymatic phenotypes

AADC deficiency is a rare genetic disease caused by mutations in the gene of aromatic amino acid decarboxylase, the pyridoxal 5'-phosphate dependent enzyme responsible for the synthesis of dopamine and serotonin. Here, following a biochemical approach together with an in silico bioinformatic analysis, we present a structural and functional characterization of 13 new variants of AADC. The amino acid substitutions are spread over the entire protein from the N-terminal (V60A), to its loop1 (H70Y and F77L), to the large domain (G96R) and its various motifs, i.e. loop2 (A110E), or a core β-barrel either on the surface (P210L, F251S and E283A) or in a more hydrophobic milieu (L222P, F237S and W267R) or loop3 (L353P), and to the C-terminal domain (R453C). Results show that the β-barrel variants exhibit a low solubility and those belonging to the surface tend to aggregate in their apo form, leading to the identification of a new enzymatic phenotype for AADC deficiency. Moreover, five variants of residues belonging to the large interface of AADC (V60A, G96R, A110E, L353P and R453C) are characterized by a decreased catalytic efficiency. The remaining ones (H70Y and F77L) present features typical of apo-to-holo impaired transition. Thus, defects in catalysis or in the acquirement of the correct holo structure are due not only to specific local domain effects but also to long-range effects at either the protein surface or the subunit interface. Altogether, the new characterized enzymatic phenotypes represent a further step in the elucidation of the molecular basis for the disease.

A novel compound heterozygous genotype associated with aromatic amino acid decarboxylase deficiency: Clinical aspects and biochemical studies

Aromatic amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency is a rare autosomal neurometabolic disorder caused by a deficit of AADC, a pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP)-dependent enzyme, which catalyzes the synthesis of dopamine and serotonin. While many studies have highlighted the molecular defects of the homozygous pathogenic variants, so far only a study investigated heterozygous variants at protein level. Here, we report a clinical case of one AADC deficiency compound heterozygous patient bearing the A91V mutation and the novel C410G mutation. To elucidate its enzymatic phenotype, the A91V and C410G homodimers were first expressed in Escherichia coli, purified and characterized. Although both apo variants display an unaltered overall tertiary structure, they show a ̴ 20-fold decreased PLP binding affinity. The C410G mutation only causes a ̴ 4-fold decrease of the catalytic efficiency, while the A91V mutation causes a 1300-fold decrease of the k_cat/K_m, and changes in the holoAADC consisting in a marked alteration of the tertiary structure and the coenzyme microenvironment. Structural analyses of these mutations are in agreement with these data. Unfortunately, the C410G/A91V heterodimer was constructed, expressed and purified in rather modest amount. Anyway, measurements of decarboxylase activity indicate that its putative k_cat value is lower than that predicted by averaging the k_cat values of the two parental enzymes. This indicates a negative interallelic complementation between the C410G and A91V monomers. Overall, this study allowed to relate the clinical to the enzymatic phenotype of the patient and to extend knowledge in the clinical and molecular pathogenesis of AADC deficiency.

Aromatic amino acid decarboxylase deficiency: Molecular and metabolic basis and therapeutic outlook

Aromatic-l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency is an ultra-rare inherited autosomal recessive disorder characterized by sharply reduced synthesis of dopamine as well as other neurotransmitters. Symptoms, including hypotonia and movement disorders (especially oculogyric crisis and dystonia) as well as autonomic dysfunction and behavioral disorders, vary extensively and typically emerge in the first months of life. However, diagnosis is difficult, requiring analysis of metabolites in cerebrospinal fluid, assessment of plasma AADC activity, and/or DNA sequence analysis, and is frequently delayed for years. New metabolomics techniques promise early diagnosis of AADC deficiency by detection of 3-O-methyl-dopa in serum or dried blood spots. A total of 82 dopa decarboxylase (DDC) variants in the DDC gene leading to AADC deficiency have been identified and catalogued for all known patients (n = 123). Biochemical and bioinformatics studies provided insight into the impact of many variants. c.714+4A>T, p.S250F, p.R347Q, and p.G102S are the most frequent variants (cumulative allele frequency = 57%), and c.[714+4A>T];[714+4A>T], p.[S250F];[S250F], and p.[G102S];[G102S] are the most frequent genotypes (cumulative genotype frequency = 40%). Known or predicted molecular effect was defined for 79 variants. Most patients experience an unrelenting disease course with poor or no response to conventional medical treatments, including dopamine agonists, monoamine oxidase inhibitors, and pyridoxine derivatives. The advent of gene therapy represents a potentially promising new avenue for treatment of patients with AADC deficiency. Clinical studies based on the direct infusion of engineered adeno-associated virus type 2 vectors into the putamen have demonstrated acceptable safety and tolerability and encouraging improvement in motor milestones and cognitive symptoms. The success of gene therapy in AADC deficiency treatment will depend on timely diagnosis to facilitate treatment administration before the onset of neurologic damage.

A novel DDC gene deletion mutation in two Chinese mainland siblings with aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase deficiency

BACKGROUND

Aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency (OMIM #608643) is a rare and severe disorder of biogenic amine synthesis caused by mutations in the DDC gene. The phenomenology of the movement disorder includes intermittent oculogyric crises and limb dystonia, generalized athetosis, and impaired voluntary movement.

OBJECTIVE

To identify clinical manifestations and DDC gene mutations in two Chinese mainland children who are siblings with AADC deficiency.

METHODS

We used targeted next-generation sequencing and quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) to reveal DDC mutations in these children.

RESULTS

Two DDC gene mutations were found: one missense mutation, c.1040G > A (p.Arg347Gln), is a reported mutation derived from the mother; the other mutation, a whole-exon 11 and 12 deletion, is a novel mutation derived from the father. The index patient and her brother both had poor sucking power and feeding difficulty at birth and episodes of oculogyric crises, truncal hypotonia, limb hypertonia, sleep disturbances, irritability, and motor delay. The siblings both died at 1 year and 10 months due to asphyxia and pneumonia during gaze and hypertonia episodes.

CONCLUSION

This study identified a novel DDC gene deletion mutation in two siblings with AADC deficiency disease in the Chinese mainland population.