Chemistry-driven structural alterations in short-term retrieved ceramic-on-metal hip implants: Evidence for in vivo incompatibility between ceramic and metal counterparts

Is Surface Metastability of Today’s Ceramic Bearings a Clinical Issue?

Recent studies on zirconia-toughened alumina (ZTA) evidenced that in vivo aged implants display a much higher monoclinic zirconia content than expected from in vitro simulations by autoclaving. At the moment, there is no agreement on the source of this discrepancy: Some research groups ascribe it to the effect of mechanical impact shocks, which are generally not implemented in standard in vitro aging or hip walking simulators. Others invoke the effect of metal transfer, which should trigger an autocatalytic reaction in the body fluid environment, accelerating the kinetics of tetragonal-to-monoclinic transformation in vivo. Extrapolations of the aging kinetics from high (autoclave) to in vivo temperature are also often disputed. Last, Raman spectroscopy is by far the preferred method to quantify the amount of monoclinically transformed zirconia. There are, however, many sources of errors that may negatively affect Raman results, meaning that the final interpretation might be flawed. In this work, we applied Raman spectroscopy to determine the monoclinic content in as-received and in vitro aged ZTA hip joint implants, and in one long-term retrieval study. We calculated the monoclinic content with the most used equations in the literature and compared it with the results of X-ray diffraction obtained on a similar probe depth. Our results show, contrary to many previous studies, that the long-term surface stability of ZTA ceramics is preserved. This suggests that the Raman technique does not offer consistent and unique results for the analysis of surface degradation. Moreover, we discuss here that tetragonal-to-monoclinic transformation is also necessary to limit contact damage and wear stripe extension. Thus, the surface metastability of zirconia-containing ceramics may be a non-issue.

Zirconia Phase Transformation in Zirconia-Toughened Alumina Ceramic Femoral Heads: An Implant Retrieval Analysis

BACKGROUND

Zirconia-toughened alumina ceramic was introduced as a femoral head material for total hip arthroplasty. The material combines the stability of alumina with the toughness of zirconia. Despite inherent benefits for bearing surfaces, concern exists in the medical field that phase transformation of the zirconia grains could worsen wear resistance and lower the strength of the head. We examined these concerns in retrieved and artificially aged ceramic heads.

METHODS

Twenty-eight ceramic composite heads retrieved at revision surgery were combined with 5 pristine heads (as negative controls for phase transformation) and 5 artificially aged pristine heads (as positive controls). The extent of zirconia phase transformation at the bearing surfaces was examined through confocal Raman spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. Burst testing was conducted on all pristine and aged heads and the 4 retrieved implants with the longest lengths of implantation.

RESULTS

Retrieved heads had higher maximum average volume fractions of the monoclinic phase compared to pristine or aged heads. Length of implantation was not correlated to the volume fraction of the monoclinic phase. All the heads achieved a burst load far above the 46 kN Food and Drug Administration acceptance criterion; 3 of the 4 retrieved heads had burst strengths exceeding 100kN.

CONCLUSION

Our results showed that phase transformation occurs in vivo in ceramic composite femoral heads, but the amount transformed did not increase with the length of time the head had been implanted. The negligible effect upon burst strength of the retrieved and artificially aged heads is reassuring. These results support continued clinical use of this alumina-zirconia composite material as a head material.

Mechanisms induced by transition metal contaminants and their effect on the hydrothermal stability of zirconia-containing bioceramics: an XPS study

Zirconia containing bioceramics suffer from low temperature degradation in biological and hydrothermal environments, and the presence of transition metal contamination has been shown to greatly affect the zirconia stability in different materials. In this paper, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy was used to investigate the compositional and structural variations of different zirconia containing hip-joint bioceramics with and without transition metal stains in hydrothermal environments. Non-stained and stainless-steel-stained femoral head samples of 3 mol% Y2O3 doped tetragonal zirconia polycrystals (3Y-TZP) and zirconia-toughened alumina (ZTA) subjected to isothermal treatments in water vapor were investigated with quantifying their respective compositional XP lines. The outputs of these spectroscopic experiments revealed a significant difference in the off-stoichiometric reactions taking place at the surface of zirconia-containing ceramics in the presence and absence of transition metal contamination. The complex off-stoichiometric chemistry that occurred in the presence of metal contaminants could be interpreted in terms of defect-related chemical reactions among metal, water vapor, and oxide lattice, with a crucial contribution of the alumina phase in the transformation kinetics of ZTA.

Structural, optical tuning, and mechanical behavior of zirconia toughened alumina through europium substitutions

The structural and optical features of zirconia toughened alumina (ZTA) due to the assorted range of Eu³⁺ substitutions are demonstrated. The characterization studies affirm the pivotal role of Eu³⁺ on the improved structural stability of ZTA and associated tetragonal zirconia (t-ZrO₂ ) → cubic zirconia (c-ZrO₂ ) transformation. Eu³⁺ prefers accommodation at the lattice sites of ZrO₂ and their gradual accumulation induces t- → c-ZrO₂ transition. Beyond the substitution limit, Eu³⁺ reacts with Al₂ O₃ to form EuAlO₃ . Optical studies validate typical Eu³⁺ emissions, and further, the emission spectrum also predicts the symmetry of Eu³⁺ coordination at the ZrO₂ lattice. Uniform distribution of ZrO₂ and Al₂ O₃ grains throughout the microstructures are evident from the morphological analysis. Further, the influence of Eu³⁺ on the enhanced mechanical stability of ZTA is ensured from indentation technique. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res Part B: Appl Biomater 107B: 1170-1179, 2019.

Zirconia phase transformation in retrieved, wear simulated, and artificially aged ceramic femoral heads

Zirconia in Zirconia toughened alumina ceramic hip replacements exists in an unstable state and can transform in response to stress giving the material improved fracture toughness. Phase transformation also occurs under hydrothermal conditions such as exist in vivo. To predict the hydrothermal aging that will occur in vivo accelerated aging procedures have been used, but validation of these models requires the study of retrieved hip joints. Here 26 retrievals are analysed to determine the degree of phase transformation in vivo. These were compared with virgin heads, heads that had undergone the accelerated aging process and heads wear tested to 5 million cycles in a hip simulator. Monoclinic content and surface roughness were measured using Raman spectroscopy and white light interferometry respectively. The monoclinic content for retrieved heads was 28.5% ± 7.8, greater than twice that in virgin, aged, or wear tested heads and did not have a significant correlation with time, contrary to the predictions of the hydrothermal aging model. The surface roughness for retrieved heads in the unworn area was not significantly different to that in virgin, aged, or unworn areas of wear tested heads. However in worn areas of the retrieved heads, the surface roughness was higher than observed in wear simulator testing. These results indicate that current testing methodologies do not fully capture the operational conditions of the material and the real performance of future new materials may not be adequately predicted by current pre-clinical testing methods. © 2017 The Authors. Journal of Orthopaedic Research Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of Orthopaedic Research Society 35:2781-2789, 2017.

Raman and Photoemission Spectroscopic Analyses of Explanted Biolox® Delta Femoral Heads Showing Metal Transfer

Biolox^® delta has been widely used in joint replacements thanks to its high strength and wear resistance. In this study, eleven Biolox^® delta femoral head retrievals affected by metal transfer (MT) were analysed by Raman spectroscopy to estimate the tetragonal to monoclinic zirconia phase transformation, whose occurrence may compromise ceramic chemical stability and mechanical strength. The residual stress state was evaluated by both Raman and photoemission spectroscopy. V_m monoclinic zirconia contents were higher near the centre of the articulating surface and in the MT area than in the border control area of the retrievals. In only one retrieval, stress related to MT appeared a more severe condition, able to induce zirconia phase transformation; for all the others, stresses related to loading in the central region and related to MT, were conducive to a zirconia phase transformation of nearly the same extent. V_m depth profiling analyses showed that the transformation involved different thicknesses in different samples. Raman data allowed for the investigation of the mechanism of zirconia phase transformation and confirmed that the growth stage was absent and the nucleation stage was not occurring as freely as it would in unconstrained zirconia.