Freeze-fracture of lipids and model membrane systems

Single-Vesicle Assays Using Liposomes and Cell-Derived Vesicles: From Modeling Complex Membrane Processes to Synthetic Biology and Biomedical Applications

The plasma membrane is of central importance for defining the closed volume of cells in contradistinction to the extracellular environment. The plasma membrane not only serves as a boundary, but it also mediates the exchange of physical and chemical information between the cell and its environment in order to maintain intra- and intercellular functions. Artificial lipid- and cell-derived membrane vesicles have been used as closed-volume containers, representing the simplest cell model systems to study transmembrane processes and intracellular biochemistry. Classical examples are studies of membrane translocation processes in plasma membrane vesicles and proteoliposomes mediated by transport proteins and ion channels. Liposomes and native membrane vesicles are widely used as model membranes for investigating the binding and bilayer insertion of proteins, the structure and function of membrane proteins, the intramembrane composition and distribution of lipids and proteins, and the intermembrane interactions during exo- and endocytosis. In addition, natural cell-released microvesicles have gained importance for early detection of diseases and for their use as nanoreactors and minimal protocells. Yet, in most studies, ensembles of vesicles have been employed. More recently, new micro- and nanotechnological tools as well as novel developments in both optical and electron microscopy have allowed the isolation and investigation of individual (sub)micrometer-sized vesicles. Such single-vesicle experiments have revealed large heterogeneities in the structure and function of membrane components of single vesicles, which were hidden in ensemble studies. These results have opened enormous possibilities for bioanalysis and biotechnological applications involving unprecedented miniaturization at the nanometer and attoliter range. This review will cover important developments toward single-vesicle analysis and the central discoveries made in this exciting field of research.

Single particle fluorescence burst analysis of epsin induced membrane fission

Vital cellular processes, from cell growth to synaptic transmission, rely on membrane-bounded carriers and vesicles to transport molecular cargo to and from specific intracellular compartments throughout the cell. Compartment-specific proteins are required for the final step, membrane fission, which releases the transport carrier from the intracellular compartment. The role of fission proteins, especially at intracellular locations and in non-neuronal cells, while informed by the dynamin-1 paradigm, remains to be resolved. In this study, we introduce a highly sensitive approach for the identification and analysis of membrane fission machinery, called burst analysis spectroscopy (BAS). BAS is a single particle, free-solution approach, well suited for quantitative measurements of membrane dynamics. Here, we use BAS to analyze membrane fission induced by the potent, fission-active ENTH domain of epsin. Using this method, we obtained temperature-dependent, time-resolved measurements of liposome size and concentration changes, even at sub-micromolar concentration of the epsin ENTH domain. We also uncovered, at 37°C, fission activity for the full-length epsin protein, supporting the argument that the membrane-fission activity observed with the ENTH domain represents a native function of the full-length epsin protein.

Photoinduced Charge Transfer Studies in Bolaamphiphile-Gramicidin-Porphyrin Membranes

Synthetic ether-linked bolaform amphiphile vesicles and a novel gramicidin-porphyrin “diad” have been prepared. Photoinduced electron transfer properties of the diad were compared in bilayer (dihexadecylphosphate, DHP) and monolayer (2,2′-0-didecyl-1,1′-0-eicosamethylene-racdiglycero- 3,3′-diphosphoric acid, PS20) membrane vesicles with dithiothreitol sacrificial donor and methyl viologen electron acceptor present on both vesicle membrane surfaces. Although the rates of methyl viologen photoreduction varied depending on the mode of diad orientation within DHP bilayer membranes, photoreduction rates were not orientation-dependent in bolaform membrane vesicles containing the gramicidinporphyrin diad. The relevance of these results on vectorial electron transfer processes in closed membrane systems is briefly discussed.

Overcoming rapid inactivation of lung surfactant: analogies between competitive adsorption and colloid stability

Lung surfactant (LS) is a mixture of lipids and proteins that line the alveolar air-liquid interface, lowering the interfacial tension to levels that make breathing possible. In acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), inactivation of LS is believed to play an important role in the development and severity of the disease. This review examines the competitive adsorption of LS and surface-active contaminants, such as serum proteins, present in the alveolar fluids of ARDS patients, and how this competitive adsorption can cause normal amounts of otherwise normal LS to be ineffective in lowering the interfacial tension. LS and serum proteins compete for the air-water interface when both are present in solution either in the alveolar fluids or in a Langmuir trough. Equilibrium favors LS as it has the lower equilibrium surface pressure, but the smaller proteins are kinetically favored over multi-micron LS bilayer aggregates by faster diffusion. If albumin reaches the interface, it creates an energy barrier to subsequent LS adsorption that slows or prevents the adsorption of the necessary amounts of LS required to lower surface tension. This process can be understood in terms of classic colloid stability theory in which an energy barrier to diffusion stabilizes colloidal suspensions against aggregation. This analogy provides qualitative and quantitative predictions regarding the origin of surfactant inactivation. An important corollary is that any additive that promotes colloid coagulation, such as increased electrolyte concentration, multivalent ions, hydrophilic non-adsorbing polymers such as PEG, dextran, etc. added to LS, or polyelectrolytes such as chitosan, also promotes LS adsorption in the presence of serum proteins and helps reverse surfactant inactivation. The theory provides quantitative tools to determine the optimal concentration of these additives and suggests that multiple additives may have a synergistic effect. A variety of physical and chemical techniques including isotherms, fluorescence microscopy, electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction show that LS adsorption is enhanced by this mechanism without substantially altering the structure or properties of the LS monolayer.

Liposome characterization by quartz crystal microbalance measurements and atomic force microscopy

This chapter reviews liposome characterization by quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) measurements and atomic force microscopy (AFM). In many studies, AFM imaging is simply used to image liposomes with resolution often that does not allow morphological analysis. Although liposome size can be obtained by processing AFM images, it is found that liposomes flatten upon surface adsorption or immobilization. Liposome stability and stiffness have been characterized by using AFM imaging or AFM force measurements, although the latter method, using a microsphere attached on the AFM cantilever, seems more appropriate to limit liposome damage and to obtain more quantitative analysis, such as the Young's modulus. Investigation of liposome layers by QCM revealed that liposomes can be detected from a combined analysis of frequency and bandwidth shifts. However, QCM by itself provides only limited information on liposomes. QCM can be used to assess the presence of a layer and also to discriminate between rigid and viscoelastic ones. Liposome properties have been derived from QCM curves, but often this requires making hypotheses that are difficult to assess. AFM and QCM analyses need to be combined with other techniques to provide complementary information.

Young's moduli of surface-bound liposomes by atomic force microscopy force measurements

Mechanical properties of layers of intact liposomes attached by specific interactions on solid surfaces were studied by atomic force microscopy (AFM) force measurements. Force-distance measurements using colloidal probe tips were obtained over liposome layers and used to calculate Young's moduli by using the Hertz contact theory. A classical Hertz model and a modified Hertz one have been used to extract Young's moduli from AFM force curves. The modified model, proposed by Dimitriadis, is correcting for the finite sample thickness since Hertz's classical model is assuming that the sample is infinitely thick. Values for Young's moduli of 40 and 8 kPa have been obtained using the Hertz model for one and three layers of intact liposomes, respectively. Young's moduli of approximately 3 kPa have been obtained using the corrected Hertz model for both one and three layers of surface-bound liposomes. Compression work performed by the colloidal probe to compress these liposome layers has also been calculated.

Liposome-mediated assembly of receptor signaling complexes

The reconstitution of membrane-associated protein complexes poses significant experimental challenges. The core signaling complex in the bacterial chemotaxis system is an illustrative example: The soluble cytoplasmic signaling proteins CheW and CheA bind to heterogeneous clusters of transmembrane receptor proteins, resulting in an assembly that exhibits cooperative kinase regulation. An understanding of the basis for the cooperativity inherent in the receptor/CheW/CheA interaction, as well as other membrane phenomena, can benefit from functional studies under defined conditions. To meet this need, a simple method was developed to assemble functional complexes on lipid membranes. The method employs a receptor cytoplasmic domain fragment (CF) with a histidine tag and liposomes that contain a Ni(2+) -chelating lipid. Assemblies of CF, CheW, and CheA form spontaneously in the presence of these liposomes, which exhibit the salient biochemical functions of kinase stimulation, cooperative regulation, and CheR-mediated receptor methylation. Although ligand binding phenomena cannot be studied directly with this approach, other factors that influence kinase stimulation and receptor methylation can be explored systematically, including receptor density and competition among stimulating and inhibiting receptor domains. The template-directed assembly of proteins leads to relatively well-defined samples that are amenable to analysis by a number of methods, including light scattering, electron microscopy, and fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The approach promises to be applicable to many systems involving membrane-associated proteins.

Liposome layers characterized by quartz crystal microbalance measurements and multirelease delivery

Intact liposomes have been immobilized onto solid surfaces by a NeutrAvidin-biotin link. The construction of these layers has been followed up by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) measurements with energy dissipation monitoring. Also, the simultaneous release of two fluorescent probes from these liposome layers has been investigated with the aim to validate this method in multirelease delivery systems. XPS showed the successful immobilization of the different layers. XPS results also point out the importance of the deactivation method used to reveal the presence of the specific NeutrAvidin-biotin attachment. QCM measurements allowed the buildup of the different layers to be followed in real time and in situ and suggest that biotinylated liposomes stay intact upon surface attachment on NeutrAvidin-covered surfaces and had viscoelastic behavior. QCM experiments also demonstrated that surface-immobilized liposomes were able to resist irreversible adsorption from fetal bovine serum. Release kinetic profiles were studied by monitoring the release of two different fluorescent probes, namely, carboxyfluorescein and levofloxacin, from these liposome layers. These studies showed that it was possible to modulate to some extent the release rates of the two molecules by using different configurations of liposome layers.

Influence of poly(ethylene glycol) grafting density and polymer length on liposomes: Relating plasma circulation lifetimes to protein binding

The incorporation of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-conjugated lipids in lipid-based carriers substantially prolongs the circulation lifetime of liposomes. However, the mechanism(s) by which PEG-lipids achieve this have not been fully elucidated. It is believed that PEG-lipids mediate steric stabilization, ultimately reducing surface-surface interactions including the aggregation of liposomes and/or adsorption of plasma proteins. The purpose of the studies described here was to compare the effects of PEG-lipid incorporation in liposomes on protein binding, liposome-liposome aggregation and pharmacokinetics in mice. Cholesterol-free liposomes were chosen because of their increasing importance as liposomal delivery systems and their marked sensitivity to protein binding and aggregation. Specifically, liposomes containing various molecular weight PEG-lipids at a variety of molar proportions were analyzed for in vivo clearance, aggregation state (size exclusion chromatography, quasi-elastic light scattering, cryo-transmission and freeze fracture electron microscopy) as well as in vitro and in vivo protein binding. The results indicated that as little as 0.5 mol% of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylethanolamine (DSPE) modified with PEG having a mean molecular weight of 2000 (DSPE-PEG(2000)) substantially increased plasma circulation longevity of liposomes prepared of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine (DSPC). Optimal plasma circulation lifetimes could be achieved with 2 mol% DSPE-PEG(2000). At this proportion of DSPE-PEG(2000), the aggregation of DSPC-based liposomes was completely precluded. However, the total protein adsorption and the protein profile was not influenced by the level of DSPE-PEG(2000) in the membrane. These studies suggest that PEG-lipids reduce the in vivo clearance of cholesterol-free liposomal formulations primarily by inhibition of surface interactions, particularly liposome-liposome aggregation.

Freeze-fracture studies on lipids and membranes

Freeze-fracture electron microscopy is especially useful for investigation of lipid structures by the advantageous fracture course within hydrophobic zones. Freezing is, on the other hand, a restriction because the structures of lamellar and non-lamellar phase states with disordered acyl chains (L(alpha), H(II,) cubic) are difficult to preserve. An important aspect of this method is therefore the lipid structure of phase states with ordered acyl chains (crystal, gel), and with a different degree of hydration. Freeze-fracture of pure lipid systems creates a valid representation of the structure of non-lamellar phases and of the general structure of the "lamellar" lipid bilayer, and lamellar phases with characteristic deformations (ripples, curvatures, plane sectors) can be identified. Fracture through the hydrophobic bilayer centre of biological membranes reveals characteristic protein components, the intramembraneous particles (IMPs). The lateral distribution of the IMPs is a helpful marker for fluid and rigid phase states, also without deformation of the lamella. The overall history and the present state of knowledge concerning the different structures revealed by the freeze-fracture and freeze-etch techniques in lipid systems, and to a limited extent in biological membranes, is reviewed, taking into account studies from our own laboratory.

Tunable pH-sensitive liposomes composed of mixtures of cationic and anionic lipids

The pH-dependent fusion properties of large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) composed of binary mixtures of anionic and cationic lipids have been investigated. It is shown that stable LUVs can be prepared from the ionizable anionic lipid cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHEMS) and the permanently charged cationic lipid N,N-dioleoyl-N, N-dimethylammonium chloride (DODAC) at neutral pH values and that these LUVs undergo fusion as the pH is reduced. The critical pH at which fusion was observed (pH(f)) was dependent on the cationic lipid-to-anionic lipid ratio. LUVs prepared from DODAC/CHEMS mixtures at molar ratios of 0 to 0.85 resulted in vesicles with pH(f) values that ranged from pH 4.0 to 6.7, respectively. This behavior is consistent with a model in which fusion occurs at pH values such that the DODAC/CHEMS LUV surface charge is zero. Related behavior was observed for LUVs composed of the ionizable cationic lipid 3alpha-[N-(N',N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl] cholesterol hydrochloride (DC-Chol) and the acidic lipid dioleoylphosphatidic acid (DOPA). Freeze-fracture and (31)P NMR evidence is presented which indicates that pH-dependent fusion results from a preference of mixtures of cationic and anionic lipid for "inverted" nonbilayer lipid phases under conditions where the surface charge is zero. It is concluded that tunable pH-sensitive LUVs composed of cationic and anionic lipids may be of utility for drug delivery applications. It is also suggested that the ability of cationic lipids to adopt inverted nonbilayer structures in combination with anionic lipids may be related to the ability of cationic lipids to facilitate the intracellular delivery of macromolecules.

Cholesteryl hemisuccinate exhibits pH sensitive polymorphic phase behavior

Cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHEMS) is an acidic cholesterol ester that self-assembles into bilayers in alkaline and neutral aqueous media and is commonly employed in mixtures with dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) to form 'pH sensitive' fusogenic vesicles. We show here that CHEMS itself exhibits pH sensitive polymorphism. This is evident from the fusogenic properties of large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) composed of CHEMS and direct visualization employing freeze-fracture electron microscopy. Below pH 4.3, LUV composed of CHEMS undergo fusion as monitored by lipid mixing assays and freeze-fracture electron micrographs reveal the characteristic striated signature of H( parallel) phase lipid. It is suggested that the pH dependent phase preferences of CHEMS contribute to the pH sensitivity of LUV composed of mixtures of CHEMS and DOPE.

RNAs that bind and change the permeability of phospholipid membranes

The RNA world hypothesis presumes that RNA will be competent for varied essential cellular functions. One such indispensable cell function is regulation of membrane permeability. Though this was not a known RNA activity, selection-amplification yielded RNAs that bound phosphatidylcholine:cholesterol liposomes. At least eight distinct, approximately 95-mer sequences bind well to the outside of the lipid bilayer, though randomized sequences had no such activity. No distinct sequence motif for lipid binding was found. However, truncation of one such RNA shows that a smaller, 44-nucleotide irregular RNA hairpin is an active membrane binding domain. Bound RNA increases the permeability of liposomes to (22)Na(+). In addition, using voltage clamp technique, four individual RNAs increase the ion permeability of the plasma membrane of cultured human cells. The existence of multiple sequences that bind membranes and provoke permeability changes suggests that these may be elementary RNA functions that could be selected in vivo.

Cationic lipids, phosphatidylethanolamine and the intracellular delivery of polymeric, nucleic acid-based drugs (review)

Polymeric, nucleic acid drugs must be protected from endogenous nucleases and delivered to target cell nuclei in order to maximize their activity. Constructs expressing therapeutic genes, antisense oligonucleotides and ribozymes can be delivered into cells by viral vectors, but concerns over safety and clinical utility have led to research into the development of alternative, non-viral delivery systems. Antisense and ribozyme drug development has focused upon modifications to the natural oligonucleotide chemistry which make the molecules resistant to nuclease degradation. These novel oligonucleotides cannot be generated by transgenes and must be administered in similar fashion to conventional drugs. However, oligonucleotides cannot cross membranes by passive diffusion and intracellular delivery for these drugs is very inefficient. Here we review the recent advances in forming lipid-DNA particles designed to mimic viral delivery of DNA. Most evidence now supports the hypothesis that lipid-DNA drugs enter target cells by endocytosis and disrupt the endosomal membrane, releasing nucleic acid into the cytoplasm. The mechanisms of particle formation and endosome disruption are not well understood. Cationic lipids are employed to provide an electrostatic interaction between the lipid carrier and polyanionic nucleic acids, and they are critical for efficient packaging of the drugs into a form suitable for systemic administration. However, their role in endosome disruption and other aspects of successful delivery leading to gene expression or inhibition of mRNA translation are less clear. We discuss the propensity of lipid-nucleic acid particles to undergo lipid mixing and fusion with adjacent membranes, and how phosphatidylethanolamine and other lipids may act as factors capable of disrupting bilayer structure and the endosomal pathway. Finally, we consider the challenges that remain in bringing nucleic acid based drugs into the realm of clinical reality.

Shape change and physical properties of giant phospholipid vesicles prepared in the presence of an AC electric field

Giant unilamellar vesicles with diameters ranging from 10 to 60 microns were obtained by the swelling of phospholipid bilayers in water in the presence of an AC electric field. This technique leads to a homogeneous population of perfectly spherical and unilamellar vesicles, as revealed by phase-contrast optical microscopy and freeze-fracture electron microscopy. Freshly prepared vesicles had a high surface tension with no visible surface undulations. Undulations started spontaneously after several hours of incubation or were triggered by the application of a small osmotic pressure. Partially deflated giant vesicles could undergo further shape change if asymmetrical bilayers were formed by adding lyso compounds to the external leaflet or by imposing a transmembrane pH gradient that selectively accumulates on one leaflet phosphatidylglycerol. Fluorescence photobleaching with 7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl-labeled phospholipids or labeled dextran trapped within the vesicles enabled the measurement of the membrane continuity in the dumbbell-shaped vesicles. In all instances phospholipids diffused from one lobe to the other, but soluble dextran sometimes was unable to traverse the neck. This suggests that the diameter of the connecting neck may be variable.

Triggerable plasmalogen liposomes: improvement of system efficiency

A photoactivated liposome release system that is generally applicable for triggered release of encapsulated hydrophilic materials is described. This approach to phototriggered release, derived from the known effects of plasmalogen photooxidation on membrane permeability in whole cells and model membrane systems, relies on producing a lamellar phase change or increase in permeability upon cleaving its constitutive lipids to single-chain surfactants using 630-820 nm light to sensitize the photooxidation of the plasmalogen vinyl ether linkage. Semi-synthetic plasmenylcholine liposomes containing encapsulated calcein and a membrane-bound sensitizer, such as zinc phthalocyanine, tin octabutoxyphthalocyanine, or bacteriochlorophyll a, were prepared by extrusion. Irradiation of air-saturated liposome solutions enhanced membrane permeability toward calcein and Mn2+, and promoted membrane fusion processes compared to non-irradiated or anaerobic controls. Bacteriochlorophyll a sensitization produced the fastest observed photoinitiated release rate from these liposomes (100% calcein release in less than 20 min; 800 nm irradiation at 300 mW); the observed release rate was two orders of magnitude slower for egg lecithin liposomes prepared and irradiated under identical experimental conditions. Liposome aggregation, interlipidic particle formation, and membrane fusion between adjoining liposomes was observed by 31P-NMR, freeze-fracture/freeze-etch TEM, and cryo-TEM as a function of irradiation time. The use of near-infrared sensitizers and the capacity of photolyzed plasmenylcholine liposomes to undergo membrane fusion processes make photodynamic therapy with these liposome-borne sensitizers an attractive adjunct to biochemical targeting methods.

Intramembranous particle distribution and filipin binding in dysplastic canine retina

We examined dysplastic canine retina for changes in intramembranous particle (IMP) density and filipin binding to sterols. Differences in IMP density were identified in incipiently dysplastic fetal retina and also in the degree of filipin binding near the onset of the dysplastic process. The data suggest that there are temporal differences in IMPs and filipin-sterol complexes that may be related to the formation of retinal folds and disorganized dysplastic retina proliferation.

Factors affecting solute entrapment in phospholipid vesicles prepared by the freeze-thaw extrusion method: a possible general method for improving the efficiency of entrapment

It is often assumed that the internal solute concentrations of phospholipid vesicles are equal to those in the medium in which they were prepared, particularly when freeze-thaw cycles are employed during the procedure. Conditions are reported here which when used to prepare vesicles by the polycarbonate filter extrusion method, produce approximately 12- and approximately 7-fold higher internal concentrations of Ca2+ and sucrose, respectively, than exist in the external medium. Formation of these large gradients is dependent upon the use of freeze-thaw cycles during preparation, on the presence of tetraethylammonium perchlorate in the medium, and is independent of media pH across the region of pH 5-9. Gradient formation is antagonized by high concentrations of an impermeant solute (NaCl). It is proposed that gradients form because solutes are concentrated by exclusion from ice during freezing but that they are normally dissipated by osmotic lysis during thawing. The presence of a permeant solute such as tetraethylammonium perchlorate provides an alternative mechanism to balance osmotic pressure, thereby preserving the gradients of impermeable species.