Production of genetically identical sets of mammals: cloning?

Sheep and Goat Genome Engineering: From Random Transgenesis to the CRISPR Era

Sheep and goats are valuable livestock species that have been raised for their production of meat, milk, fiber, and other by-products. Due to their suitable size, short gestation period, and abundant secretion of milk, sheep and goats have become important model animals in agricultural, pharmaceutical, and biomedical research. Genome engineering has been widely applied to sheep and goat research. Pronuclear injection and somatic cell nuclear transfer represent the two primary procedures for the generation of genetically modified sheep and goats. Further assisted tools have emerged to enhance the efficiency of genetic modification and to simplify the generation of genetically modified founders. These tools include sperm-mediated gene transfer, viral vectors, RNA interference, recombinases, transposons, and endonucleases. Of these tools, the four classes of site-specific endonucleases (meganucleases, ZFNs, TALENs, and CRISPRs) have attracted wide attention due to their DNA double-strand break-inducing role, which enable desired DNA modifications based on the stimulation of native cellular DNA repair mechanisms. Currently, CRISPR systems dominate the field of genome editing. Gene-edited sheep and goats, generated using these tools, provide valuable models for investigations on gene functions, improving animal breeding, producing pharmaceuticals in milk, improving animal disease resistance, recapitulating human diseases, and providing hosts for the growth of human organs. In addition, more promising derivative tools of CRISPR systems have emerged such as base editors which enable the induction of single-base alterations without any requirements for homology-directed repair or DNA donor. These precise editors are helpful for revealing desirable phenotypes and correcting genetic diseases controlled by single bases. This review highlights the advances of genome engineering in sheep and goats over the past four decades with particular emphasis on the application of CRISPR/Cas9 systems.

Application of the zona-free manipulation technique to porcine somatic nuclear transfer

The recent demonstration of a successful zona-free manipulation technique for bovine somatic nuclear transfer (NT) that is both simpler and less labor intensive is of considerable benefit to advance the applications of this technology. Here, we describe that this method is also applicable to porcine somatic NT. Porcine cumulus oocyte complexes were matured in TCM-199 medium before sequential removal of the cumulus and zonae. Zona-free oocytes were bisected using a microknife, and the halves containing the metaphase plate (as determined by Hoechst 33342 staining) were discarded. Each half cytoplast was agglutinated to a single granulosa cell (primary cultures grown in 0.5% serum for 2-5 days prior to use) in phytohaemagglutinin-P. Subsequently, each half cytoplast-granulosa cell couplet was simultaneously electrofused together and to another half cytoplast. Reconstructed embryos were activated in calcium ionophore A23187 followed by DMAP and were then individually cultured in microwells in NCSU-23 medium. On day 7 after activation, blastocyst yield and total cell numbers were counted. Of 279 attempted reconstructed NT embryos, 85.0 +/- 2.8% (mean +/- SEM; n = 5 replicates) successfully fused and survived activation. The blastocyst rate (per successfully fused and surviving embryo) was 4.8 +/- 2.3% (11/236; range, 0-12.8%). Total blastocyst cell count was 36.0 +/- 4.5 (range, 18-58 cells). The blastocyst rate and total cell numbers of parthenogenetically activated and zona-free control oocytes propagated under the same conditions was 11.6 +/- 3.9% (35/335 embryos; n = 3 replicates) and 36.8 +/- 5.2, respectively. Developmentally halted embryos that could still be evaluated on day 7 possessed 54.4 +/- 2.3% (53/96 embryos; n = 3 replicates) anucleate blastomeres, the latter representing 53.5 +/- 6.6% of the blastomeres in such embryos. In conclusion, blastocyst yield was independent of activation efficiency and was likely reduced by insufficient nuclear remodeling, reprogramming, imprinting, or other effects. The data also suggest that fragmentation was a considerable problem that could conceivably contribute to halted development in a high proportion of embryos. The results indicate that the zona-free manipulation technique can be successfully applied to pig somatic NT. Although such zona-free early cleavage stage embryos cannot be transferred to recipients at present, this technique permits simplification of the NT technique for application in basic research, until pig nonsurgical blastocyst transfer becomes a realistic option.

Mammalian cloning: possibilities and threats

The cloning of mammals originated with the production of limited numbers of genetically identical offspring by blastomere separation or embryo splitting. In the past few years, remarkable progress has been reported in cloning by nuclear transfer (NT) with donor nuclei recovered from embryonic, fetal or adult cells. Factors that contribute to the successful reprogramming of the transferred nucleus and the normal term development of the newly reconstructed embryo include the cell cycle stage of both the donor nucleus and recipient cytoplast, the timing of fusion and cytoplast activation, and the source of donor nuclei. The possibility of producing live offspring by somatic cell NT carries potential applications in animal husbandry, biotechnology, transgenic and pharmaceutical production, biomedical research, and the preservation of endangered species. However, the low efficiencies of cloning by NT coupled with high embryonic, fetal and neonatal losses may restrict immediate commercial applications in agriculture. These limitations notwithstanding, the greatest benefits and practical implications of this new technology could be in transplantation medicine and therapeutic cloning.

Review: Development of Reproductive Biotechnologies in Domestic Animals from Artificial Insemination to Cloning: A Perspective

There has been a remarkable increase in knowledge resulting in the application of reproductive biotechnologies in animals, with profound implications for human beings. The major accomplishments in domestic animals, particularly with cattle, are reviewed here. An attempt is made to examine these, in perspective, to indicate the steps by which progress was made, and to appreciate that the explosion of new findings today would not have been possible without the careful studies of yesteryears.

Developmental ability of mouse late 2-cell stage blastomeres fused to chemically enucleated oocytes in vitro

The effects of different concentrations of etoposide and cycloheximide (ETO-CHXM), used for chemical enucleation of mouse oocytes, on polar body extrusion and chromatin expulsion were tested. The developmental ability of blastomeres of late 2-cell stage embryos fused to chemically enucleated oocytes of different ages or cytoplasts from different sources was also examined in vitro. Metaphase I oocytes cultured in different concentrations of ETO-CHXM (10-50 micrograms/ml/each) extruded polar bodies at rates similar to those cultured without ETO-CHXM (58.5-65.9% and 64.6%, respectively). However, low percent of the oocytes (1.7-6.2%) expressed signs of meiotic perturbation, which was manifested by blebbing of the cytoplasmic membrane and extrusion of two or more polar body-like fragments. Twenty-three percent of the chemically enucleated oocytes cultured in ETO-CHXM-free medium spontaneously fused to their polar bodies. The rates of total chromatin expulsion were similar when ETO-CHXM concentrations were 36 and 50 micrograms/ml (93.5 and 98%, respectively). The results also showed that the cleavage rates of reconstituted embryos were significantly (P < 0.001) affected by the age of the chemically enucleated oocytes. Cytoplasts of bisected oocytes that matured in vivo supported the development of 31.7% of the reconstituted embryos to the blastocyst stage. However, both cytoplasts of chemically enucleated oocytes and in vitro matured oocytes did not support the development to the blastocyst stage. A high percentage (85.5%) of the reconstituted embryos with chemically enucleated recipients displayed abnormality of the metaphase plate. These results suggest that concentrations of etoposide between 36 and 50 micrograms/ml are optimum for enucleation of mouse oocytes. Furthermore, increasing the age or reducing the cytoplasmic volume of the chemically enucleated oocytes did not improve the development of the reconstituted embryos to the blastocyst stage.

Nuclear transplantation in the pig embryo: nuclear swelling

The transfer of nuclei from cleavage stage embryos to enucleated activated meiotic metaphase II oocytes results in a reprogramming of the transferred nucleus such that it behaves as a zygotic nucleus. One estimator of nuclear reprogramming is nuclear swelling after nuclear transfer. The diameter of nuclei after nuclear transfer was not found to be dependent upon the amount of cytoplasm transferred with the donor cell or the amount of cytoplasm in the recipient cell. Nuclei from 4-, 8-, and 16-cell stage embryos swelled to a similar diameter after nuclear transfer (26.9, 27.3, and 27.2 microns, respectively) and this was significantly different from the diameter of contemporary donor embryos (18.3, 14.3, and 13.0 microns, respectively). This is a swelling of 47, 91, and 109%, respectively. Since the degree of nuclear swelling does not appear to be related to cytoplasmic volume it is concluded that the components mediating nuclear swelling are not in a limiting supply.

The use of an alginic acid matrix to support in vitro development of isolated murine blastomeres

The present study reports the use of a cross-linked calcium alginate matrix to replace the zona pellucida in supporting in vitro development of isolated two-cell murine blastomeres. The zona pellucidae were enzymatically removed with a 0.5% pronase solution and blastomeres separated with a fine-bore glass pipet. The matrix was created by coating the blastomeres with a 3.5% sodium alginic acid solution, which forms a mechanically stable complex upon transfer to media containing high concentrations of a divalent cation. Blastocyst formation was 55/61 (90.2%) for untreated intact embryos and 61/87 (70.1%) and 27/65 (41.5%) for blastomeres cultured with and without the artificial matrix respectively (P less than 0.001).

The potential use of artificially produced monozygotic twins for comparative experiments

The uniformity of twins has been examined by assembling estimates of the intraclass correlation coefficient (rho(I)) available in the literature for a variety of parameters studied in cattle monozygotic twins and human dizygotic and monozygotic twins. The values of rho(I) vary considerably between parameters. In human monozygotic twins rho(I) is always larger compared to that found in dizygotic twins. There is insufficient evidence to determine whether artificial monozygotic twins are more uniform than natural monozygotic twins. A new measure of twin uniformity, given by T (3) = 1 (1-rho (I)) , is introduced. In practice 2T(3) gives the number of animals chosen at random that one member of a twin pair can replace without loss of statistical efficiency. A useful class of experimental designs for the exploitation of twin uniformity is incomplete block designs. These designs are defined by (v, k, b), where v is the number of treatments to be compared, k = 2, and b is the number of twin pairs. Each design has an associated efficiency (E). Provided rho(I)>1-E, an incomplete block design will be advantageous. In general, when only a few twin pairs are available, this relation will only hold for monozygotic and not dizygotic twins. Suitable arrangements of treatment comparisons for designs (3,2,8), (4,2,9), (5,2,10), (6,2,11) are presented.

Applications of embryo transfer and related technologies to cattle

It is possible to recover embryos from superovulated cows nonsurgically, divide each embryo in half, and routinely obtain pregnancy rates of greater than 50% per half embryo after nonsurgical transfer, which is equivalent to greater than 100% per original embryo. It is also possible to freeze and sex embryos, although the cryopreservation process kills some embryos and the sexing process is so new that efficacy under field conditions is unknown. Embryo transfer techniques are applied to thousands of dairy cows, but in 1982 only about one dairy calf per thousand born in North America was from embryo transfer. Nevertheless, use of this technology is increasing, in part because of simplification of procedures, increased efficacy, and lower costs. It is difficult to predict when additional technologies will become available for commercial use, but it is likely that several additional exciting developments will occur in cattle breeding before the end of the century.