Comparing cytomegalovirus diagnostics by cell culture and quantitative nucleic acid testing in broncho-alveolar lavage fluids

Consensus Definitions of Cytomegalovirus (CMV) Infection and Disease in Transplant Patients Including Resistant and Refractory CMV for Use in Clinical Trials: 2024 Update From the Transplant Associated Virus Infections Forum

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection and disease are important causes of morbidity and mortality in transplant recipients. For the purpose of developing consistent reporting of CMV outcomes in clinical trials, definitions of CMV infection and disease were developed and most recently published in 2017. Since then, there have been major developments, including registration of new antiviral agents. Therefore, the Transplant Associated Virus Infections Forum, which consists of scientists, clinicians, regulators, and industry representatives, has produced an updated version of these definitions that incorporates recent knowledge with the aim of supporting clinical research and drug development. This also includes an update regarding the definition of resistant and refractory CMV infections previously published in 2019. As the field evolves, the need for updates of these definitions is clear, and collaborative efforts among clinicians, scientists, regulators, and industry representatives can provide a platform for this work.

Impact of bronchoalveolar lavage on the management of immunocompromised hosts

BACKGROUND

Respiratory infections are an important cause of morbidity and mortality in immunocompromised individuals. Fiberoptic bronchoscopy with bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) is an important tool to detect infectious agents in immunocompromised patients with low respiratory tract infections (LRTI).

RESEARCH QUESTION

BAL changes the management of immunocompromised patients with suspected LRTI.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Immunocompromised patients with a suspicion of LRTI underwent diagnostic BAL. The primary composite outcome consisted of pre-defined modifications in the management of the immunocompromised patients following BAL. We quantified the impact of bronchoscopy up to 30 days after the procedure.

RESULTS

A total of 2666 visits from 1301 patients were included in the study and immunosuppression was classified as haematological (n = 1040; 544 patients), solid organ transplantation (n = 666; 107 patients) and other causes (n = 960; 650 patients). BAL led to a change in management in 52.36% (n = 1396) of all cases. This percentage, as well as the 30-day mortality differed significantly amongst the three groups. Age, C-reactive protein and aetiology of infection determined significantly the risk of 30-day mortality in all patients. In 1.89% (n = 50) of all cases, a combination of 2 respiratory viral agents was identified and 24.23% (n = 646) were diagnosed with a single respiratory viral agent.

INTERPRETATION

BAL leads to changes in management in the majority of immunosuppressed patients. There is a high prevalence of multimicrobial infections and respiratory viral infections in immunocompromised patients with respiratory symptoms. Individual virus infection is associated with diverse risk of a negative outcome.

Associations between invasive aspergillosis and cytomegalovirus in lung transplant recipients: a nationwide cohort study

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) and invasive aspergillosis (IA) cause morbidity among lung transplant recipients (LTXr). Early diagnosis and treatment could improve outcomes. We examined rates of CMV after IA and vice versa to assess whether screening for one infection is warranted after detecting the other. All Danish LTXr, 2010-2019, were followed for IA and CMV for 2 years after transplantation. IA was defined using ISHLT criteria. Adjusted incidence rate ratios (aIRR) were estimated by Poisson regression adjusted for time after transplantation. We included 295 LTXr, among whom CMV and IA were diagnosed in 128 (43%) and 48 (16%). The risk of CMV was high the first 3 months after IA, IR 98/100 person-years of follow-up (95% CI 47-206). The risk of IA was significantly increased in the first 3 months after CMV, aIRR 2.91 (95% CI 1.32-6.44). Numbers needed to screen to diagnose one case of CMV after IA, and one case of IA after CMV was approximately seven and eight, respectively. Systematic screening for CMV following diagnosis of IA, and vice versa, may improve timeliness of diagnosis and outcomes for LTXr.

Amplicon size and non-encapsidated DNA fragments define plasma cytomegalovirus DNA loads by automated nucleic acid testing platforms: A marker of viral cytopathology?

Management of cytomegalovirus (CMV) in transplant patients relies on measuring plasma CMV-loads using quantitative nucleic acid testing (QNAT). We prospectively compared the automated Roche-cobas®6800-CMV and Roche-CAP/CTM-CMV with laboratory-developed Basel-CMV-UL54-95bp, and Basel-CMV-UL111a-77bp. Roche-cobas®6800-CMV and Roche-CAP/CTM-CMV were qualitatively concordant in 142/150 cases (95%). In-depth comparison revealed higher CMV-loads of the laboratory-developed assay and correlated with smaller amplicon size. After calibration to the 1.WHO-approved CMV international standard, differences were reduced but remained significant. DNase-I pretreatment significantly reduced CMV-loads for both automated Roche-CAP/CTM-CMV and Roche-cobas®6800-CMV assays, whereby 90% and 95% of samples became undetectable. DNase-I pretreatment also reduced CMV-loads quantified by Basel-CMV-UL54-95bp and Basel-CMV-UL111a-77bp, but remaining detectable in 20% and 35%, respectively. Differences were largest for 110 samples with low-level CMV-DNAemia being detectable but not-quantifiable by Roche-cobas®6800-CMV, whereby the smaller amplicon sizes yielded higher viral loads for concordant positives. We conclude that non-encapsidated fragmented CMV-DNA is the major form of plasma CMV-loads also measured by fully-automated platforms. Amplicons of <150 bp and calibrators are needed for reliable and commutable QNAT-results. We hypothesize that non-encapsidated fragmented CMV-DNA results from lysis of CMV-replicating cells and represent a direct marker of viral cell damage, which contribute to delayed viral load responses despite effective antivirals.

Differential Gene Expression of SARS-CoV-2 Positive Bronchoalveolar Lavages: A Case Series

BACKGROUND

Transcriptomic data on bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) from COVID-19 patients are currently scarce.

OBJECTIVES

This case series seeks to characterize the intra-alveolar immunopathology of COVID-19.

METHOD

BALs were performed on 14 patients (5 COVID-19, of which 3 mild and 2 largely asymptomatic, 9 controls). Controls included asthma (n = 1), unremarkable BALs (n = 3), infections with respiratory syncytial virus (n = 1), influenza B (n = 1), and infections with other coronaviruses (n = 3). SARS-CoV-2 RNA load was measured by quantitative nucleic acid testing, while the detection of other pathogens was performed by immunofluorescence or multiplex NAT.

RESULTS

Gene expression profiling showed 71 significantly downregulated and 5 upregulated transcripts in SARS-CoV-2-positive lavages versus controls. Downregulated transcripts included genes involved in macrophage development, polarization, and crosstalk (LGALS3, MARCO, ERG2, BTK, RAC1, CD83), and genes involved in chemokine signaling and immunometabolism (NUPR1, CEBPB, CEBPA, PECAM1, CCL18, PPARG, ALOX5, ALOX5AP). Upregulated transcripts featured genes involved in NK-T cell signaling (GZMA, GZMH, GNLY, PRF1, CD3G). Patients with mild COVID-19 showed a significant upregulation of genes involved in blood mononuclear cell/leukocyte function (G0S2, ANXA6, FCGR2B, ADORA3), coagulation (von Willebrand factor [VWF]), interferon response (IFRD1, IL12RB2), and a zinc metalloprotease elevated in asthma (CPA3) compared to asymptomatic cases. In-silico comparison of the 5 COVID-19 BAL cases to a published cohort of lethal COVID-19 showed a significant upregulation of "antigen processing and presentation" and "lysosome" pathways in lethal cases.

CONCLUSIONS

These data underscore the heterogeneity of immune response in COVID-19. Further studies with a larger dataset are required to gain a better understanding of the hallmarks of SARS-CoV-2 immunological response.

Detection of cytomegalovirus in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid from immunocompromised patients with pneumonitis by viral culture and DNA quantification

PURPOSE

To compare the detection of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid by viral culture and quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR), and to establish a viral load threshold that can identify cases of HCMV replication indicative of pneumonitis. There is currently no universal viral load cut-off to differentiate between patients with and without pneumonitis, and the interpretation of qPCR results is challenging.

METHODS

176 consecutive BAL samples from immunosuppressed hosts with signs and/or symptoms of respiratory infection were prospectively studied by viral culture and qPCR.

RESULTS

Concordant results were obtained in 81.25% of the BAL samples. The rest were discordant, as only 34% of the qPCR-positive BAL samples were positive by culture. The median HCMV load was significantly higher in culture-positive than in culture-negative BAL samples (5,038 vs 178 IU/mL). Using a cut-off value of 1,258 IU/mL of HCMV in BAL, pneumonia was diagnosed with a sensitivity of 76%, a specificity of 100%, a VPP of 100% and VPN of 98%, and HCMV was isolated in 100% of the BAL cultures.

CONCLUSION

We found that a qPCR-negative was a quick and reliable way of ruling out HCMV pneumonitis, but a positive result did not always indicate clinically significant replication in the lung. However, an HCMV load in BAL fluid of ≥1,258 IU/mL was always associated with disease, whereas <200 IU/mL rarely so.

Quantitative PCR for the Diagnosis of HCMV Pneumonia in HSCT Recipients and Other Immunocompromised Hosts

Pneumonia is among the most serious manifestations of HCMV infection, with high morbidity and mortality. Probable pneumonia is defined as the detection of HCMV in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) by viral isolation or DNA quantification (qPCR) combined with symptoms and/or signs of respiratory infection. However, currently, there is no reproducible and well-defined viral load (VL) from BAL that can reliably differentiate patients with pneumonia from the much more common detection of viral DNA in seropositive patients without true HCMV pneumonia. Several studies have been published with the aim of establishing an optimal VL for differentiating pneumonia from viral lung shedding. The aim of this review is to collect and analyze the methodology and the conclusions obtained in studies whose objectives included the correlation between HCMV VL in BAL and/or the plasma and the occurrence of HCMV pneumonia. For this purpose, a total of 14 articles have been included. There are some conclusions on which they all agree. PCR techniques were more sensitive and had a higher NPV than culture techniques but were less specific and had a low PPV. The mean HCMV loads in both BAL and the plasma were significantly higher in patients with pneumonitis than in those without. The HCMV load in patients with pneumonitis was higher in BAL than in the plasma, making qPCR in BAL a better predictor of HCMV pneumonitis than in the plasma. Nevertheless, this review highlights the difficulty of establishing a universal VL value, both in BAL and in the blood, to differentiate patients with HCMV pneumonia from those without. To complete the information available in these studies, prospective multicentre studies would be required. Methodologically, a large number of patients with HCMV pneumonitis would have to be included, and a subclassification of the type of immunosuppression of each patient should be made in order to obtain an optimal VL threshold in different host groups.

Hemophagocytic Lymphohistiocytosis Associated With Cytomegalovirus Infection: 5 Cases and a Systematic Review of the Literature

Hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (HLH) is a rare, life-threatening disorder characterized by an uncontrolled, persistent, hyperimmune response. It can be triggered by an infectious, neoplastic, or autoimmune event. The involvement of cytomegalovirus (CMV) in the onset of HLH is subject to debate, and the epidemiology of CMV-associated HLH (HLH-CMV) remains poorly characterized. We identified 5 cases of HLH-CMV in our hospital, systematically searched the PubMed database for publications on HLH-CMV, and reviewed 57 publications with a total of 67 cases of HLH-CMV. Only 48 patients (71.6%) were immunodeficient, suggesting that HLH-CMV can occur in immunocompetent patients. The major cause of underlying immunodepression (51%) was inflammatory bowel disease (mainly treated with azathioprine). CMV infection was nearly always symptomatic, and lung involvement was frequent (31 cases). Fifty-five patients recovered. Nineteen patients were treated for CMV infection only and had a good outcome, suggesting that antiviral drugs might be the cornerstone of HLH-CMV treatment.