Ganglioside changes in the regenerating goldfish optic system: comparison with glycoproteins and phospholipids

Concept of Normativity in Multi-Omics Analysis of Axon Regeneration

Transcriptomes and proteomes can be normalized with a handful of RNAs or proteins (or their peptides), such as GAPDH, β-actin, RPBMS, and/or GAP43. Even with hundreds of standards, normalization cannot be achieved across different molecular mass ranges for small molecules, such as lipids and metabolites, due to the non-linearity of mass by charge ratio for even the smallest part of the spectrum. We define the amount (or range of amounts) of metabolites and/or lipids per a defined amount of a protein, consistently identified in all samples of a multiple-model organism comparison, as the normative level of that metabolite or lipid. The defined protein amount (or range) is a normalized value for one cohort of complete samples for which intrasample relative protein quantification is available. For example, the amount of citrate (a metabolite) per µg of aconitate hydratase (normalized protein amount) identified in the proteome is the normative level of citrate with aconitase. We define normativity as the amount of metabolites (or amount range) detected when compared to normalized protein levels. We use axon regeneration as an example to illustrate the need for advanced approaches to the normalization of proteins. Comparison across different pharmacologically induced axon regeneration mouse models entails the comparison of axon regeneration, studied at different time points in several models designed using different agents. For the normalization of the proteins across different pharmacologically induced models, we perform peptide doping (fixed amounts of known peptides) in each sample to normalize the proteome across the samples. We develop Regen V peptides, divided into Regen III (SEB, LLO, CFP) and II (HH4B, A1315), for pre- and post-extraction comparisons, performed with the addition of defined, digested peptides (bovine serum albumin tryptic digest) for protein abundance normalization beyond commercial labeled relative quantification (for example, 18-plex tandem mass tags). We also illustrate the concept of normativity by using this normalization technique on regenerative metabolome/lipidome profiles. As normalized protein amounts are different in different biological states (control versus axon regeneration), normative metabolite or lipid amounts are expected to be different for specific biological states. These concepts and standardization approaches are important for the integration of different datasets across different models of axon regeneration.

Effects of nerve growth factor, brain-derived neurotrophic factor and neurotrophin-3 on the laminar distribution of transganglionically fransported choleragenoid in the spinal cord dorsal horn following transection of the sciatic nerve in the adult rat

Spinal cord projections from transected sciatic nerves treated with different neurotrophins were investigated in the adult rat following injections of choleragenoid into the proximal stump of the injured nerve. Transganglionically transported choleragenoid labelled primary afferent fibres in all spinal cord dorsal horn laminae except the outer part of lamina II (II(o)), which is almost devoid of labelling. Transection of the sciatic nerve, however, resulted in intense transganglionic choleragenoid labelling in lamina II(o) and in lamina I. In this study, the sciatic nerve was transected bilaterally and 4erve growth factor (6 or 24 microg), brain-derived neurotrophic factor (20 microg), neurotrophin-3 (27 microg) or cytochrome C (8 microg; control substance) was applied unilaterally during postoperative survival times of eight, 16 and 32 days. The animals received bilateral injections of choleragenoid into the injured nerve two days before they were killed. The effect of the axotomy and neurotrophin treatment was evaluated by analysing the extent of choleragenoid and substance P immunoreactivity in the somatotopically appropriate spinal cord dorsal horn regions. At eight days' postoperative survival, laminae I and II(o) on the transected, non-treated side showed much more intense choleragenoid-like immunoreactivity compared to the contralateral transected, nerve growth factor-treated (6 and 24 microg) side. A similar situation was also found in cases treated with the higher dose (24 microg) at 16 days but to a lesser degree when the lower (6 microg) dose was used. After 32 days' survival, there was no detectable side difference in the choleragenoid labelling pattern. At 16 days' survival, the mean area of choleragenoid-positive ganglion cell body profiles in the L5 dorsal root ganglion of the transected, non-treated side was significantly smaller than the mean area of the transected, nerve growth factor-treated (24 microg) neurons. An axotomy-induced depletion of substance P-like immunoreactivity was seen from eight days' survival and onwards, whereas on the nerve growth factor-treated side a clearcut substance P depletion was not observed until 32 days. Brain-derived neurotrophic factor, neurotrophin-3 and cytochrome C had no detectable effects on the distribution of choleragenoid labelling or substance P-like immunoreactivity in the dorsal horn following sciatic nerve transection. In conclusion, peripheral nerve injury-induced expansion of primary afferent choleragenoid labelling in the spinal cord dorsal horn is counteracted by treating the axotomized nerve with nerve growth factor.

Gangliosides and regeneration of the goldfish optic nerve in vivo and in vitro

One to forty days after optic nerve transection, goldfish received an i.p. injection of [3H]proline (proteins), 3HNAcGluc (gangliosides) or [3H]thymidine (DNA). After 1 or 2 days of incorporation, both optic systems were analyzed by biochemical and autoradiographical procedures. In the regenerating retina an enhanced retinal mitotic activity, protein synthesis (up to 2-fold) and ganglioside synthesis (up to 1.5-fold) was found. Simultaneously, a transiently enhanced accumulation (up to 4.5-fold) of axonally transported protein- and ganglioside-bound radioactivity in the regenerating optic nerve stump occurred. These regeneration-related proliferative and metabolic changes were found to be maximal at 6-8 days post lesion, but still measurable after 40 days. Concerning the endogenous ganglioside metabolism, in the regenerating retina no obvious change in ganglioside synthesis and composition could be observed, while in the regenerating optic nerve there was an enhanced accumulation of the ganglioside GP1c. Daily i.p. application of a ganglioside mixture from bovine brain (GMix) or of the monosialoganglioside GM1, did not alter significantly the degree and time course of the above regeneration induced metabolic changes or the regain of visual acuity. Sprouting activity of goldfish retinal explants was found to strongly depend upon a conditioning lesion of the optic nerve, reaching a maximum 8 days after nerve transection. This result strictly coincided with the profile of metabolic changes observed in vivo. Again, daily i.p. or i.o. injection of exogenous gangliosides did not influence the lesion induced increase of retinal sprouting activity. However, in normal, not regenerating animals, a local i.o. injection of GMix or GM1 led to a significant enhancement of the "basal" sprouting activity, normally occurring after lesion of the retina after injection of 0.9% NaCl. This ganglioside related stimulation was maximal at low concentrations (3 micrograms/eye) and did not occur at high concentrations (> 30 micrograms/eye). Injection of the phospholipid phosphatidylcholine or phosphatidylserine had no or a slightly inhibitory effect, when compared to NaCl controls. These data suggest an involvement of gangliosides in the complex process of induction of axonal sprouting.

Neurite outgrowth in dorsal root neuronal hybrid clones modulated by ganglioside GM1 and disintegrins

Subclones of F11 neuronal hybrid cells (neuroblastoma x dorsal root ganglion neurons) have segregated differing and/or overlapping neuritogenic mechanisms on three substrata--plasma fibronectin (pFN) with its multiple receptor activities, cholera toxin B subunit (CTB) for binding to ganglioside GM1, and platelet factor-4 (PF4) for binding to heparan sulfate proteoglycans. In this study, specific cell surface receptor activities for the three substrata were tested for their modulation during neuritogenesis by several experimental paradigms, using F11 subclones representative of three differentiation classes (neuritogenic on pFN only, on CTB only, or on all three substrata). When cycloheximide was included in the medium to inhibit protein synthesis during the active period, neurite formation increased significantly for all subclones on all three substrata, virtually eliminating substratum selectivity for differentiation mediated by cell surface integrin, ganglioside GM1, or heparan sulfate proteoglycans. Therefore, one or more labile proteins (referred to as disintegrins) must modulate functions of matrix receptors (e.g., integrins) mediating neurite formation. To verify whether cycloheximide-induced neuritogenesis was also regulated by integrin interaction with cell surface GM1, two approaches were used. When (Arg-Gly-Asp-Ser)-containing peptide A was added to the medium, it completely inhibited cycloheximide-induced neuritogenesis on all three substrata of all subclones, indicating stringent requirement for cell surface integrin function in these mechanisms. In contrast, when CTB or a monoclonal anti-GM1 antibody was also added to the medium, cycloheximide-induced neuritogenesis was amplified further on pFN and sensitivity to peptide A inhibition was abolished. Therefore, in some contexts ganglioside GM1 must complex with integrin receptors at the cell surface to modulate their function. These results also indicate that (a) cycloheximide treatment leads to loss of substratum selectivity in neuritogenesis, (b) this negative regulation of neurite outgrowth is affected by integrin receptor association with labile regulatory proteins (disintegrins) as well as with GM1, and (c) complexing of GM1 by multivalent GM1-binding proteins shifts neuritogenesis from an RGDS-dependent integrin mechanism to an RGDS-independent receptor mechanism.

Characterization and regional distribution of individual gangliosides in goldfish central nervous system

Gangliosides were partially purified from goldfish brain and fractionated by DEAE Fractogel column chromatography. Each fraction was then analyzed by HPTLC and also by HPLC after conversion of the gangliosides to 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazides. The tetrasialoganglioside GQ1c was found to constitute more than 50% of the total gangliosides. Gangliosides in smaller quantities were also tentatively identified. These included GT1b, GT1c, GT2, GT3, GD1a, and several others. By using this information, the amounts of individual gangliosides in various regions of goldfish central nervous system were compared. Although all areas of brain examined contained similar concentrations of gangliosides, with GQ1c as the predominant component, retina and optic nerve contained significantly lower concentrations of GQ1c, and GM3 was the major component.

Ability of adult rat ganglion cells to regrow axons in vitro can be influenced by fibroblast growth factor and gangliosides

The ability of lesioned adult retina ganglion cells (RGC) to survive and regrow axons in vitro was investigated in retina organ cultures under chemically defined conditions. Factors which are known to either affect the RGC survival like the basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF) or influence neurite outgrowth like gangliosides were assayed by recording the course of prelabeled RGC degeneration in vitro and the number and length of regrowing RGC axons from explanted retinal pieces. Administration of basic FGF significantly slowed down the decrease in the number of RITC-prelabeled RGC in the cultured retinae. In addition, in the presence of gangliosides (GM1, GD1a, GD1b GT1b), the numbers of regrown RGC axons (Thy 1-immunostained) increased dramatically as compared to controls. The data indicate that adult neurons with an intrinsic ability to regenerate axons can respond to substances with neurotrophic or neurite-promoting activities in tissue cultures.

Immunocytochemical evaluation of a cholinergic-specific ganglioside antigen (Chol-1) in the central nervous system of the rat

Previous work from this laboratory has identified gangliosidic surface markers specific for cholinergic neurons. Antibodies to these markers, collectively designated Chol-1, induce complement-mediated lysis of the cholinergic subpopulation of synaptosomes and provide the basis for a new immunocytochemical method for staining cholinergic neurons in rat, guinea pig and human material. The specification and localization of immunocytochemical staining for Chol-1 was investigated in selected areas of the rat central nervous system. The antigen was typically expressed on all neurons previously identified as being cholinergic using monoclonal antibodies to choline acetyltransferase. At spinal levels Chol-1 was present on large and smaller cell bodies in the ventral horn motoneuron area. The preganglionic sympathetic neurons in the thoracic intermediolateral nucleus were also Chol-1-positive. Nerve terminal-like staining was observed in association with stained large Chol-1 positive and smaller unstained Chol-1 negative neurons, and in lamina I and III of the dorsal horn. In the mesencephalon, motoneurons of the oculomotor and trochlear nucleus, as well as neurons within the pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus and the red nucleus were Chol-1-positive. In addition visceromotoneurons of the Edinger-Westphal nucleus were stained with anti-Chol-1 antibodies. In the basal forebrain the antibodies gave a positive reaction on well known cholinergic neurons in the vertical and horizontal limbs of the diagonal bands of Broca and the medial forebrain bundle. In agreement with studies using antibodies to choline acetyltransferase, a small subpopulation of neostriatal neurons (1-2%) was Chol-1-positive. In the rat retina, both anti-Chol-1 and anti-choline acetyltransferase antibodies gave rise to a nerve terminal-like staining in the same bands within the inner plexiform layer. The anti-Chol-1 antibodies also stain normal and pathological human material and could have a useful application in human neuropathology.

Effect of crush lesion on radiolabelling of ganglioside in rat peripheral nerve

Left sciatic nerves of adult male Sprague-Dawley rats were crushed and allowed to recover for 0, 1, 2, 4, 7, or 14 days. At each of these times both L-5 dorsal root ganglia were injected with 100 microCi of [3H]glucosamine. Two days later, dorsal root ganglia, lumbosacral trunks, and sciatic nerves were removed bilaterally. The amounts of radiolabelled ganglioside in crushed lumbosacral trunks were consistently higher than in the controls, with the largest difference occurring within 2 days from simultaneous crush and injection to killing (specimens labelled day 0). The largest difference in the amount of radiolabelled ganglioside between crushed and control sciatic nerve (4-9 days from crush to killing) occurred later than that of lumbosacral trunk, but no significant difference occurred within the first 3 days following crush. There was only a slightly higher radioactivity in gangliosides totalled from all three anatomical specimens of crushed than in control nerves. The neutral nonganglioside lipid and acid-precipitable fraction followed patterns of synthesis and accumulation similar to those of the gangliosides. These findings indicate that after nerve crush gangliosides, glucosamine-labelled neutral nonganglioside lipids, and glycoproteins accumulate close to the proximal end of the regenerating axon. This accumulation could serve as a reservoir to increase the ganglioside concentration in the growth cone membrane.

Molecular and cellular aspects of nerve regeneration

Injury of an axon leads to at least four independent events, summarized in Figure 1: first, deprivation of the nerve cell body from target-derived or mediated substances, which leads to a derepressed or a permissive state; second, disruption of anterograde transport, with a resultant accumulation of anterogradely transported molecules; third, environmental response with possible consequent changes in constituents of the extracellular matrix and substances secreted from the surrounding cells; and fourth, appearance of growth inhibitors and modified protease activity. It seems that the first three of these events are obligatory, but not sufficient, i.e., they lead to a growth state only if the cell body is able to respond to the injury-induced signals from the environment (a and b). The regenerative state is characterized by alterations in protein synthesis and axonal transport and by sprouting activity. The subsequent elongation of the growing fibers depends on a continuous supply of appropriate growth factors. These factors are presumably anchored to the appropriate extracellular matrix that serves as a substratum for elongating fibers. It should be mentioned that the proliferating nonneuronal cells have a conducive effect on regeneration by forming a scaffold for the growing fibers. Accordingly, the lack of regeneration may stem from a deficiency in the ability of glial cells to provide the appropriate soluble components or from insufficient formation of extracellular matrix. In this respect, one may consider regeneration of an injured axon as a process which involves regeneration of both the nonneuronal cells and the supported axons. The regeneration of glial cells may fulfill the rules which are applied to regeneration of any other proliferating tissue. Furthermore, the processes of regeneration in the axon and the glial cells are mutually dependent. Perhaps the triggering factors provided by the nonneuronal cells affect the nonneuronal cells themselves by modulating their postlesion gliosis and thereby inducing their appropriate activation. In such a case, regeneration of nonneuronal cells may resemble an autocrine type of regulation that exists also during ontogeny. The growth regulation is shifted back to the paracrine type upon neuronal maturation or cessation of axonal growth. When the elongating fibers reach the vicinity of the target organ, they are under the influence of the target-derived factors, which guide the fibers and eventually cease their elongation.

Gangliosides in the nervous system during development and regeneration

Gangliosides are present in nervous tissues of echinoderms and chordates, but the amounts and patterns differ widely. There are changes in the ganglioside contents of nervous tissues during development in most animals studied. To a large extent, regional differences and changes with development and degeneration in ganglioside composition reflect changing and different proportions of cellular types and subcellular organelles within the tissue. GM1 and GM4 are enriched in myelin; GD1a may be a marker for dendritic arborization. During regeneration of fish optic nerve and rat sciatic nerve there is an increased amount of ganglioside proximal to the regenerating axon tips, which may largely be a result of accumulation. This could provide a relatively large reservoir of ganglioside to become incorporated into the sprouting axolemma. Gangliosides added exogenously to growth medium can induce neuritogenesis of several types of neurons. The mechanisms of this action are unknown but may be related to nerve growth factor, microskeletal organization, membrane fluidity, and other factors. Gangliosides injected into young animals affect brain development, but further studies are required to determine these effects more specifically. Ganglioside administration increases the number of sprouts in regenerating peripheral nerves, but does not seem to accelerate axonal elongation. Parenterally administered gangliosides alter the recovery of brain tissue from a variety of types of lesions, and clinical trials are in progress to determine if they are of benefit in human neurological disorders. The biochemical mechanisms of these in vivo ganglioside effects are poorly understood, but may involve modulation of several enzyme systems as well as other properties of neural membranes, such as fluidity. It is possible that gangliosides may play similar roles and operate through some of the same mechanisms in developing and regenerating nervous tissues.