Quantitative structure-hydrophobicity and structure-activity relationships of antibacterial gramicidin S analogs

Development of Tyrocidine A analogues with improved antibacterial activity

The development of new antibacterial therapeutic agents capable of halting microbial resistance is a chief pursuit in clinical medicine. Classes of antibiotics that target and destroy bacterial membranes are attractive due to the decreased likelihood that bacteria will be able to generate resistance to this mechanism. The amphipathic cyclic decapeptide, Tyrocidine A, is a model for this class of antibiotics. Tyrocidine A is composed of a hydrophobic and a hydrophilic face, allowing for insertion into bacterial membranes, creating porous channels and destroying membrane integrity. We have used a combination of molecular modeling and solid phase synthesis to prepare Tyrocidine A and analogues 1-8. The minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of these compounds were determined for a host of gram positive species and E. coli as a representative gram negative bacterium. Analogues 2 and 5 demonstrated moderate 2- to 8-fold increases in antibacterial activity over the parent Tyrocidine A for a variety of pathogenic microbes (best MICs for E. coli 32 microg/mL and 2 microg/mL for most gram positives). Examination of the structure- activity relationship between the analogues demonstrated a preference for increased amphipathicity but did not show a clear preference for increasing hydrophilicity versus hydrophobicity in improving antibacterial activity. Of note, movement of positively charged lysine residues or neutral pentafluorophenyl residues to different positions within the cyclopeptide ring system demonstrated improvements in antibacterial activity.

Dissociation of antimicrobial and hemolytic activities in cyclic peptide diastereomers by systematic alterations in amphipathicity

We have investigated the role of amphipathicity in a homologous series of head-to-tail cyclic antimicrobial peptides in efforts to delineate features resulting in high antimicrobial activity coupled with low hemolytic activity (i.e. a high therapeutic index). The peptide GS14, cyclo(VKLKVd-YPLKVKLd-YP), designed on the basis of gramicidin S (GS), exists in a preformed highly amphipathic beta-sheet conformation and was used as the base compound for this study. Fourteen diastereomers of GS14 were synthesized; each contained a different single enantiomeric substitution within the framework of GS14. The beta-sheet structure of all GS14 diastereomers was disrupted as determined by CD and NMR spectroscopy under aqueous conditions; however, all diastereomers exhibited differential structure inducibility in hydrophobic environments. Because the diastereomers all have the same composition, sequence, and intrinsic hydrophobicity, the amphipathicity of the diastereomers could be ranked based upon retention time from reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography. There was a clear correlation showing that high amphipathicity resulted in high hemolytic activity and low antimicrobial activity in the diastereomers. The latter may be the result of increased affinity of highly amphipathic peptides to outer membrane components of Gram-negative microorganisms. The diastereomers possessing the most favorable therapeutic indices possessed some of the lowest amphipathicities, although there was a threshold value below which antimicrobial activity decreased. The best diastereomer exhibited 130-fold less hemolytic activity compared with GS14, as well as greatly increased antimicrobial activities, resulting in improvement in therapeutic indices of between 1,000- and 10,000-fold for a number of microorganisms. The therapeutic indices of this peptide were between 16- and 32-fold greater than GS for Gram-negative microorganisms and represents a significant improvement in specificity over GS. Our findings show that a highly amphipathic nature is not desirable in the design of constrained cyclic antimicrobial peptides and that an optimum amphipathicity can be defined by systematic enantiomeric substitutions.

Differential scanning calorimetric study of the effect of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S on the thermotropic phase behavior of phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylglycerol lipid bilayer membranes

We have studied the effects of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S (GS) on the thermotropic phase behavior of large multilamellar vesicles of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC), dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DMPE) and dimyristoyl phosphatidylglycerol (DMPG) by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. We find that the effect of GS on the lamellar gel to liquid-crystalline phase transition of these phospholipids varies markedly with the structure and charge of their polar headgroups. Specifically, the presence of even large quantities of GS has essentially no effect on the main phase transition of zwitterionic DMPE vesicles, even after repeating cycling through the phase transition, unless these vesicles are exposed to high temperatures, after which a small reduction in the temperature, enthalpy and cooperativity of the gel to liquid-crystalline phase transitions is observed. Similarly, even large amounts of GS produce similar modest decreases in the temperature, enthalpy and cooperativity of the main phase transition of DMPC vesicles, although the pretransition is abolished at low peptide concentrations. However, exposure to high temperatures is not required for these effects of GS on DMPC bilayers to be manifested. In contrast, GS has a much greater effect on the thermotropic phase behavior of anionic DMPG vesicles, substantially reducing the temperature, enthalpy and cooperativity of the main phase transition at higher peptide concentrations, and abolishing the pretransition at lower peptide concentrations as compared to DMPC. Moreover, the relatively larger effects of GS on the thermotropic phase behavior of DMPG vesicles are also manifest without cycling through the phase transition or exposure to high temperatures. Furthermore, the addition of GS to DMPG vesicles protects the phospholipid molecules from the chemical hydrolysis induced by their repeated exposure to high temperatures. These results indicate that GS interacts more strongly with anionic than with zwitterionic phospholipid bilayers, probably because of the more favorable net attractive electrostatic interactions between the positively charged peptide and the negatively charged polar headgroup in such systems. Moreover, at comparable reduced temperatures, GS appears to interact more strongly with zwitterionic DMPC than with zwitterionic DMPE bilayers, probably because of the more fluid character of the former system. In addition, the general effects of GS on the thermotropic phase behavior of zwitterionic and anionic phospholipids suggest that it is located at the polar/apolar interface of liquid-crystalline bilayers, where it interacts primarily with the polar headgroup and glycerol-backbone regions of the phospholipid molecules and only secondarily with the lipid hydrocarbon chains. Finally, the considerable lipid specificity of GS interactions with phospholipid bilayers may prove useful in the design of peptide analogs with stronger interactions with microbial as opposed to eucaryotic membrane lipids.

Octanol-water partition of nonzwitterionic peptides: predictive power of a molecular size-based model

A remarkably simple, molecular size-based model developed to predict octanol-water partition coefficients for organic compounds is tested on a set of 188 neutral peptides with available experimental partition data. Despite using only two parameters, it gives a promising correlation (r2 = 0.914; sigma = 0.455, F = 1978.0), and predictions are in a realistic range even for larger peptides (cyclosporin, melanotan, sandostatin) where common, overparametrized fragment methods become quite unreliable. Ion-pair partitioning and the extraction constant formalism is briefly reviewed to describe the sigmoidal lipophilicity profile of ionizable, nonzwitterionic peptides. It seems possible to extend the present model to estimate apparent partition coefficients measured around neutral pH and physiological conditions for monoionic peptides; however, as no standard conditions are yet defined and only relatively small number of experimental data are available, the situation here is more complex.

Nonlamellar phases induced by the interaction of gramicidin S with lipid bilayers. A possible relationship to membrane-disrupting activity

The interactions of the cyclic peptide gramicidin S (GS) with a variety of single-component lipid bilayers, and with membrane polar lipid extracts of Acholeplasma laidlawii B and Escherichia coli, were examined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), 31P-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and X-ray diffraction. The DSC data indicate that the effects of GS on the thermotropic phase behavior of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine dispersions are compatible with those expected of peptides interacting primarily with the polar headgroup and/or the polar/apolar interfaces of lipid bilayers. These DSC studies also suggest that GS exhibits stronger interactions with the more fluid bilayers. For mixtures of GS with lipids such as phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, cardiolipin, and sphingomyelin, axially symmetric 31P-NMR powder patterns are observed throughout the entire temperature range examined (0-90 degrees C), and there is little evidence for significant destabilization of the lipid bilayer with respect to nonlamellar phases. With mixtures of GS with either phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylglycerol, or a nonlamellar phase-forming phosphatidylcholine, axially symmetric 31P-NMR powder patterns are also observed at low temperatures. However, at high temperatures, an isotropic component is observed in their 31P-NMR spectra, and the relative intensity of this component increases significantly with temperature and with GS concentration. Once formed at high temperatures, this isotropic component exhibits a marked cooling hysteresis and in most cases disappears only when the sample is recooled to temperatures well below the lipid hydrocarbon chain-melting phase transition temperature. We also show that GS induces the formation of isotropic components in the 31P-NMR spectra of heterogeneous lipid mixtures such as occur in A. laidlawii B and E. coli membranes. These observations suggest that GS induces the formation of cubic or other three dimensionally ordered inverted nonlamellar phases when it interacts with some types of lipid bilayers, a suggestion strongly supported by our X-ray diffraction studies. Our results also suggest that the capacity of GS to induce the formation of such phases increases with the intrinsic nonlamellar phase-preferring tendencies of the lipids with which it interacts probably by producing localized increases in membrane monolayer curvature stress. The latter effect could be part of the mechanism through which this peptide exhibits its antimicrobial and hemolytic activities.

Modulation of structure and antibacterial and hemolytic activity by ring size in cyclic gramicidin S analogs

We have evaluated the effect of ring size of gramicidin S analogs on secondary structure, lipid binding, lipid disruption, antibacterial and hemolytic activity. Cyclic analogs with ring sizes ranging from 4 to 14 residues were designed to maintain the amphipathic character as found in gramicidin S and synthesized by solid phase peptide synthesis. The secondary structure of these peptides showed a definite periodicity in beta-sheet content, with rings containing 6, 10, and 14 residues exhibiting beta-sheet structure, and rings containing 8 or 12 residues being largely disordered. Peptides containing 4 or 6 residues did not bind lipopolysaccharide, whereas longer peptides showed a trend of increasing binding affinity for lipopolysaccharide with increasing length. Destabilization of Escherichia coli outer membranes was only observed in peptides containing 10 or more residues. Peptides containing fewer than 10 residues were completely inactive and exhibited no hemolytic activity. The 10-residue peptide showed an activity profile similar to that of gramicidin S itself, with activity against Gram-positive and Gram-negative microorganisms as well as yeast, but also showed high hemolytic activity. Differential activities were obtained by increasing the size of the ring to either 12 or 14 residues. The 14-residue peptide showed no antibiotic activity but exhibited increased hemolytic activity. The 12-residue peptide lost activity against Gram-positive bacteria, retained activity against Gram-negative microorganisms and yeast, but displayed decreased hemolytic activity. Biological activities in the 12-residue peptide were optimized by a series of substitutions in residues comprising both hydrophobic and basic sites resulting in a peptide that exhibited activities comparable with gramicidin S against Gram-negative microorganisms and yeast but with substantially lower hemolytic activity. Compared with gramicidin S, the best analog showed a 10-fold improvement in antibiotic specificity for Gram-negative microorganisms and a 7-fold improvement in specificity for yeast over human erythrocytes as determined by a therapeutic index. These results indicate that it is possible to modulate structure and activities of cyclic gramicidin S analogs by varying ring sizes and further show the potential for developing clinically useful antibiotics based on gramicidin S.

Gramicidin S is active against both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria

Four linear and four cyclic analogs of gramicidin S (GS) in which D-Phe was replaced with either D-His, D-Ser, D-Tyr or D-Asn have been prepared by solid-phase peptide synthesis and characterized with respect to antibacterial, antifungal and hemolytic activity. Unlike previous reports, GS and a number of cyclic analogs were found to be active against gram-positive as well as gram-negative bacteria. GS showed MICs ranging from 3 to 12.5 micrograms/mL for gram-negative bacteria, compared to MICs of 3 micrograms/mL for gram-positive bacteria. Furthermore, these analogs were also found to exhibit antifungal activity. Unlike the cyclic analogs, all linear analogs were found to be inactive against a wide range of microorganisms tested, and showed low levels of hemolytic activity. The antibacterial activity was found to be highly dependent on the type of assay used, with solution-based assays showing greater activity against gram-negative bacteria than agar-based assays. The GS cyclic analogs were all less toxic than GS itself, with the analog containing the D-Phe to D-Tyr substitution showing the greatest activity of the synthetic analogs. Hemolytic activity in solution against human and sheep red blood cells paralleled antibiotic activity, with those peptides exhibiting greater antibiotic activity generally showing greater hemolytic activity. Membrane destabilization as monitored using the hydrophobic probe N-phenyl-1-naphthylamine was also found to parallel antibacterial and hemolytic activity of cyclic and linear analogs. These results indicate that GS and certain related analogs may have applications as broad-spectrum antibiotics and should be reevaluated for such purposes.