Spatiotemporal analysis of vocal fold vibrations between children and adults

Multivariate Analysis of Vocal Fold Vibrations in Normal Speakers Using High-Speed Digital Imaging

INTRODUCTION

Little is known about the normal variations in vocal fold vibrations. We conducted a prospective study on normal subjects using high-speed digital imaging (HSDI) to elucidate key parameters regarding age/gender-related normal variations.

METHODS

Forty-six healthy adult volunteers were divided into young (aged ≤35 years) male, young female, elderly (aged ≥65 years) male, and elderly female subgroups. HSDI data of sustained phonation of /i/ at a comfortable pitch and loudness were obtained, and vibratory parameters were calculated using the visual-perceptual rating, laryngotopography, digital kymography, and glottal area waveform. Multivariate analysis was then performed on these parameters to clarify the subgroup-specific key parameters.

RESULTS

Four key parameters were identified from a total of 83: one from visual perceptual rating and three from laryngotopography. Subgroup analyses showed that posterior-to-anterior longitudinal phase difference (PD) and high fundamental frequency (F0) were specific to young female participants. A low F0 was specific to young male participants. Large anterior-to-posterior longitudinal PD and its left-right difference were specific to elderly male participants. There were no key parameters for elderly female participants.

CONCLUSIONS

Methods that can assess F0 and longitudinal PD, such as visual-perceptual rating and laryngotopography, were effective in the evaluation of normal vocal fold vibrations and their variations.

Influence of Reduced Saliva Production on Phonation in Patients With Ectodermal Dysplasia

OBJECTIVE

Patients with ectodermal dysplasia (ED) suffer from an inherited disorder in the development of the ectodermal structures. Besides the main symptoms, i.e. significantly reduced formation/expression of teeth, hair and sweat glands, a decreased saliva production is objectively accounted. In addition to difficulties with chewing/swallowing, ED patients frequently report on the subjective impression of rough and hoarse voices. A correlation between the reduced production of saliva and an affliction of the voice has not yet been investigated objectively for this rare disease.

METHODS

Following an established measurement protocol, a study has been conducted on 31 patients with ED and 47 controls (no ED, healthy voice). Additionally, the vocal fold oscillations were recorded by high-speed videoendoscopy (HSV@4 kHz). The glottal area waveform was determined by segmentation and objective glottal dynamic parameters were calculated. The generated acoustic signal was evaluated by objective and subjective measures. The individual impairment was documented by a standardized questionnaire (VHI). Additionally, the amount of generated saliva was measured for a defined period of time.

RESULTS

ED patients displayed a significantly reduced saliva production compared to the control group. Furthermore, the auditory-perceptual evaluation yielded significantly higher ratings for breathiness and hoarseness in the voices of male ED patients compared to male controls. The majority of male ED patients (67%) indicated at least minor impairment in the self-evaluation. Objective acoustic measures like Jitter and Shimmer confirmed the decreased acoustic quality in male ED patients, whereas none of the investigated HSV parameters showed significant differences between the test groups. Statistical analysis did not confirm a statistically significant correlation between reduced voice quality and amount of saliva.

CONCLUSIONS

An objective impairment of the acoustic outcome was demonstrated for male ED patients. However, the vocal folds dynamics in HSV recordings seem unaffected.

The Relationships Among Vocal Variability, Vocal-Articulatory Coordination, and Dysphonia in Children

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relationship between vocal variability and variability of vocal-articulatory coordination in children. Furthermore, this study examined if this relationship was impacted by pediatric dysphonia.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of speech samples in the Arizona Child Acoustic Database.

METHODS

Speech samples from children 2-7 years of age were selected for analysis. Vocal variability was defined as the coefficient of variation (CoV) of fundamental frequency, taken from the center of sustained vowels. Variability of vocal-articulatory coordination was defined as the CoV of voice onset time (VOT) of voiceless stop consonants. Both objective and subjective measures of dysphonia were completed for each participant.

RESULTS

Children had a negative correlation between VOT variability and vocal variability. Further analysis indicated that this relationship was present in children with typical developmental levels of dysphonia but absent for children with moderate to severe dysphonia. Increased dysphonia severity was associated with increased vocal variability.

CONCLUSION

Increased VOT variability was associated with decreased vocal variability in children with dysphonia severities consistent with typical vocal development. However, this relationship was not present in children with moderate to severe dysphonia. This study suggests that future work is needed to examine the relationships between the vocal system and vocal-articulatory coordination in children with and without diagnosed voice disorders.

Voice Onset Time in Children With and Without Vocal Fold Nodules

PURPOSE

Voice onset time (VOT) of voiceless consonants provides information on the coordination of the vocal and articulatory systems. This study examined whether vocal-articulatory coordination is affected by the presence of vocal fold nodules (VFNs) in children.

METHOD

The voices of children with VFNs (6-12 years) and age- and gender-matched vocally healthy controls were examined. VOT was calculated as the time between the voiceless stop consonant burst and the vocal onset of the vowel. Measures of the average VOT and VOT variability, defined as the coefficient of variation, were calculated. The acoustic measure of dysphonia, cepstral peak prominence (CPP), was also calculated. CPP provides information about the overall periodicity of the signal, with more dysphonic voices having lower CPP values.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in either average VOT or VOT variability between the VFN and control groups. VOT variability and average VOT were both significantly predicted by the interaction between Group and CPP. There was a significant negative correlation between CPP and VOT variability in the VFN group, but no significant relationship was found in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Unlike previous studies with adults, there were no group differences in average VOT or VOT variability in this study. However, children with VFNs who were more dysphonic had increased VOT variability, suggestive of a relationship between dysphonia severity and control of vocal onset during speech production.

Comparative Analysis of Two Methods of Perceptual Voice Assessment

OBJECTIVES

The primary aim was to compare two methods for perceptual evaluation of voice - paired comparison (PC) and visual analog scale (VAS) ratings. Secondary aims were to assess the correspondence between two dimensions of voice- overall severity of voice quality and resonant voice, and to investigate the influence of rater experience on perceptual rating scores and rating confidence scores.

STUDY DESIGN

Experimental design.

METHODS

Voice samples from six children (pre and post therapy) were rated by 15 Speech-Language Pathologists specialized in voice. Raters completed four tasks corresponding to the two rating methods and voice qualities: PC-severity, PC-resonance, VAS-severity, and VAS-resonance. For PC tasks, raters chose the better of two voice samples (better voice quality or better resonance, depending on the task) and indicated the degree of confidence in each choice. Rating and confidence score were combined to produce a number on a 1-10 scale (PC-confidence adjusted). VAS ratings involved rating voices on a scale for degree of severity and resonance, respectively.

RESULTS

PC-confidence adjusted and VAS ratings were moderately correlated for overall severity and also vocal resonance. VAS ratings were normally distributed and had greater rater consistency than PC-confidence adjusted ratings. VAS scores reliably predicted binary PC choices (choice of voice sample only). Overall severity and vocal resonance were weakly correlated and rater experience was not linearly related to rating scores or confidence.

CONCLUSIONS

Results suggest that the VAS rating method holds advantages over PC, including normally distributed ratings, superior consistency of ratings, and the ability to provide more finely grained detail regarding the auditory perception of voice. Overall severity and vocal resonance were not redundant in the current data set, suggesting that resonant voice and overall severity are not isomorphic. Finally, the number of years of clinical experience was not linearly related to perceptual ratings or rating confidence.

Quantitative Analysis of Vocal Fold Vibration using High-Speed Videoendoscopy in Children with and without Bilateral Lesions

OBJECTIVE

To provide data on the measurable vocal fold vibratory differences in children with and without vocal fold lesions using high-speed videoendoscopy.

DESIGN

Prospective study, 24 participants (8 healthy; 16 with lesions) between the ages of 5 and 10.

METHODS

Rigid high-speed videoendoscopy at the rate of 8,000 frames per second was used to examine participants. Four objective vocal fold phase linearity measures were obtained to establish anterior-posterior contact and separation vibratory patterns.

RESULTS

All objective measures showed a difference between nonlesion and bilateral vocal fold lesion groups. Contact-separation patterns in all nonlesion girls and young pre-pubertal boys exhibited an anterior-to-posterior contact and posterior-to-anterior separation; while older boys differed. The objective measures of open quotient, left-right relative phase asymmetry and speed index, showed linear anterior-posterior patterns within the nonlesion group; while the bilateral vocal fold lesion group displayed nonlinear patterns. Patterns in the posterior region of the vocal fold were similar in both groups; while patterns in the anterior region differed.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests lesions have an effect on the anterior aspect of vocal fold vibratory patterns specifically anterior to the lesions. Age-related differences for males are also evidenced, prompting further investigation of laryngeal development in males and females from childhood to adulthood. This study could serve as a basis for the development of objective clinical measurements of vocal fold vibration in presence of lesions. Further findings could help redefine the theoretical framework of pediatric voice.

Quantitative and Qualitative Electroglottographic Wave Shape Differences in Children and Adults Using Voice Map-Based Analysis

Purpose The purpose of this study is to identify the extent to which various measurements of contacting parameters differ between children and adults during habitual range and overlap vocal frequency/intensity, using voice map-based assessment of noninvasive electroglottography (EGG). Method EGG voice maps were analyzed from 26 adults (22-45 years) and 22 children (4-8 years) during connected speech and vowel /a/ over the habitual range and the overlap vocal frequency/intensity from the voice range profile task on the vowel /a/. Mean and standard deviations of contact quotient by integration, normalized contacting speed, quotient of speed by integration, and cycle-rate sample entropy were obtained. Group differences were evaluated using the linear mixed model analysis for the habitual range connected speech and the vowel, whereas analysis of covariance was conducted for the overlap vocal frequency/intensity from the voice range profile task. Presence of a "knee" on the EGG wave shape was determined by visual inspection of the presence of convexity along the decontacting slope of the EGG pulse and the presence of the second derivative zero-crossing. Results The contact quotient by integration, normalized contacting speed, quotient of speed by integration, and cycle-rate sample entropy were significantly different in children compared to (a) adult males for habitual range and (b) adult males and adult females for the overlap vocal frequency/intensity. None of the children had a "knee" on the decontacting slope of the EGG slope. Conclusion EGG parameters of contact quotient by integration, normalized contacting speed, quotient of speed by integration, cycle-rate sample entropy, and absence of a "knee" on the decontacting slope characterize the wave shape differences between children and adults, whereas the normalized contacting speed, quotient of speed by integration, cycle-rate sample entropy, and presence of a "knee" on the downward pulse slope characterize the wave shape differences between adult males and adult females. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.15057345.

A Deep Learning Enhanced Novel Software Tool for Laryngeal Dynamics Analysis

Purpose High-speed videoendoscopy (HSV) is an emerging, but barely used, endoscopy technique in the clinic to assess and diagnose voice disorders because of the lack of dedicated software to analyze the data. HSV allows to quantify the vocal fold oscillations by segmenting the glottal area. This challenging task has been tackled by various studies; however, the proposed approaches are mostly limited and not suitable for daily clinical routine. Method We developed a user-friendly software in C# that allows the editing, motion correction, segmentation, and quantitative analysis of HSV data. We further provide pretrained deep neural networks for fully automatic glottis segmentation. Results We freely provide our software Glottis Analysis Tools (GAT). Using GAT, we provide a general threshold-based region growing platform that enables the user to analyze data from various sources, such as in vivo recordings, ex vivo recordings, and high-speed footage of artificial vocal folds. Additionally, especially for in vivo recordings, we provide three robust neural networks at various speed and quality settings to allow a fully automatic glottis segmentation needed for application by untrained personnel. GAT further evaluates video and audio data in parallel and is able to extract various features from the video data, among others the glottal area waveform, that is, the changing glottal area over time. In total, GAT provides 79 unique quantitative analysis parameters for video- and audio-based signals. Many of these parameters have already been shown to reflect voice disorders, highlighting the clinical importance and usefulness of the GAT software. Conclusion GAT is a unique tool to process HSV and audio data to determine quantitative, clinically relevant parameters for research, diagnosis, and treatment of laryngeal disorders. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.14575533.

3D-FV-FE Aeroacoustic Larynx Model for Investigation of Functional Based Voice Disorders

For the clinical analysis of underlying mechanisms of voice disorders, we developed a numerical aeroacoustic larynx model, called simVoice, that mimics commonly observed functional laryngeal disorders as glottal insufficiency and vibrational left-right asymmetries. The model is a combination of the Finite Volume (FV) CFD solver Star-CCM+ and the Finite Element (FE) aeroacoustic solver CFS++. simVoice models turbulence using Large Eddy Simulations (LES) and the acoustic wave propagation with the perturbed convective wave equation (PCWE). Its geometry corresponds to a simplified larynx and a vocal tract model representing the vowel /a/. The oscillations of the vocal folds are externally driven. In total, 10 configurations with different degrees of functional-based disorders were simulated and analyzed. The energy transfer between the glottal airflow and the vocal folds decreases with an increasing glottal insufficiency and potentially reflects the higher effort during speech for patients being concerned. This loss of energy transfer may also have an essential influence on the quality of the sound signal as expressed by decreasing sound pressure level (SPL), Cepstral Peak Prominence (CPP), and Vocal Efficiency (VE). Asymmetry in the vocal fold oscillations also reduces the quality of the sound signal. However, simVoice confirmed previous clinical and experimental observations that a high level of glottal insufficiency worsens the acoustic signal quality more than oscillatory left-right asymmetry. Both symptoms in combination will further reduce the quality of the sound signal. In summary, simVoice allows for detailed analysis of the origins of disordered voice production and hence fosters the further understanding of laryngeal physiology, including occurring dependencies. A current walltime of 10 h/cycle is, with a prospective increase in computing power, auspicious for a future clinical use of simVoice.

Fluid-structure-acoustic interactions in an ex vivo porcine phonation model

In the clinic, many diagnostic and therapeutic procedures focus on the oscillation patterns of the vocal folds (VF). Dynamic characteristics of the VFs, such as symmetry, periodicity, and full glottal closure, are considered essential features for healthy phonation. However, the relevance of these individual factors in the complex interaction between the airflow, laryngeal structures, and the resulting acoustics has not yet been quantified. Sustained phonation was induced in nine excised porcine larynges without vocal tract (supraglottal structures had been removed above the ventricular folds). The multimodal setup was designed to simultaneously control and monitor key aspects of phonation in the three essential parts of the larynx. More specifically, measurements will comprise (1) the subglottal pressure signal, (2) high-speed recordings in the glottal plane, and (3) the acoustic signal in the supraglottal region. The automated setup regulates glottal airflow, asymmetric arytenoid adduction, and the pre-phonatory glottal gap. Statistical analysis revealed a beneficial influence of VF periodicity and glottal closure on the signal quality of the subglottal pressure and the supraglottal acoustics, whereas VF symmetry only had a negligible influence. Strong correlations were found between the subglottal and supraglottal signal quality, with significant improvement of the acoustic quality for high levels of periodicity and glottal closure.

Interdependencies between acoustic and high-speed videoendoscopy parameters

In voice research, uncovering relations between the oscillating vocal folds, being the sound source of phonation, and the resulting perceived acoustic signal are of great interest. This is especially the case in the context of voice disorders, such as functional dysphonia (FD). We investigated 250 high-speed videoendoscopy (HSV) recordings with simultaneously recorded acoustic signals (124 healthy females, 60 FD females, 44 healthy males, 22 FD males). 35 glottal area waveform (GAW) parameters and 14 acoustic parameters were calculated for each recording. Linear and non-linear relations between GAW and acoustic parameters were investigated using Pearson correlation coefficients (PCC) and distance correlation coefficients (DCC). Further, norm values for parameters obtained from 250 ms long sustained phonation data (vowel /i/) were provided. 26 PCCs in females (5.3%) and 8 in males (1.6%) were found to be statistically significant (|corr.| ≥ 0.3). Only minor differences were found between PCCs and DCCs, indicating presence of weak non-linear dependencies between parameters. Fundamental frequency was involved in the majority of all relevant PCCs between GAW and acoustic parameters (19 in females and 7 in males). The most distinct difference between correlations in females and males was found for the parameter Period Variability Index. The study shows only weak relations between investigated acoustic and GAW-parameters. This indicates that the reduction of the complex 3D glottal dynamics to the 1D-GAW may erase laryngeal dynamic characteristics that are reflected within the acoustic signal. Hence, other GAW parameters, 2D-, 3D-laryngeal dynamics and vocal tract parameters should be further investigated towards potential correlations to the acoustic signal.

Indicators of anterior-posterior phase difference in glottal opening measured from natural production of vowels

Voiced speech is generated by the glottal flow interacting with vocal fold vibrations. However, the details of vibrations in the anterior-posterior direction (the so-called zipper-effect) and their correspondence with speech and other glottal signals are not fully understood due to challenges in direct measurements of vocal fold vibrations. In this proof-of-concept study, the potential of four parameters extracted from high-speed videoendoscopy (HSV), electroglottography, and speech signals to indicate the presence of a zipper-type glottal opening is investigated. Comparison with manual labeling of the HSV videos highlighted the importance of multiple parameter-signal pairs in indicating the presence of a zipper-type glottal opening.

Machine learning based identification of relevant parameters for functional voice disorders derived from endoscopic high-speed recordings

In voice research and clinical assessment, many objective parameters are in use. However, there is no commonly used set of parameters that reflect certain voice disorders, such as functional dysphonia (FD); i.e. disorders with no visible anatomical changes. Hence, 358 high-speed videoendoscopy (HSV) recordings (159 normal females (N_F), 101 FD females (FD_F), 66 normal males (N_M), 32 FD males (FD_M)) were analyzed. We investigated 91 quantitative HSV parameters towards their significance. First, 25 highly correlated parameters were discarded. Second, further 54 parameters were discarded by using a LogitBoost decision stumps approach. This yielded a subset of 12 parameters sufficient to reflect functional dysphonia. These parameters separated groups N_F vs. FD_F and N_M vs. FD_M with fair accuracy of 0.745 or 0.768, respectively. Parameters solely computed from the changing glottal area waveform (1D-function called GAW) between the vocal folds were less important than parameters describing the oscillation characteristics along the vocal folds (2D-function called Phonovibrogram). Regularity of GAW phases and peak shape, harmonic structure and Phonovibrogram-based vocal fold open and closing angles were mainly important. This study showed the high degree of redundancy of HSV-voice-parameters but also affirms the need of multidimensional based assessment of clinical data.

BAGLS, a multihospital Benchmark for Automatic Glottis Segmentation

Laryngeal videoendoscopy is one of the main tools in clinical examinations for voice disorders and voice research. Using high-speed videoendoscopy, it is possible to fully capture the vocal fold oscillations, however, processing the recordings typically involves a time-consuming segmentation of the glottal area by trained experts. Even though automatic methods have been proposed and the task is particularly suited for deep learning methods, there are no public datasets and benchmarks available to compare methods and to allow training of generalizing deep learning models. In an international collaboration of researchers from seven institutions from the EU and USA, we have created BAGLS, a large, multihospital dataset of 59,250 high-speed videoendoscopy frames with individually annotated segmentation masks. The frames are based on 640 recordings of healthy and disordered subjects that were recorded with varying technical equipment by numerous clinicians. The BAGLS dataset will allow an objective comparison of glottis segmentation methods and will enable interested researchers to train their own models and compare their methods.

Relative Fundamental Frequency in Children With and Without Vocal Fold Nodules

Purpose Relative fundamental frequency (RFF) is an acoustic measure that is sensitive to functional voice differences in adults. The aim of the current study was to evaluate RFF in children, as there are known structural and functional differences between the pediatric and adult vocal mechanisms. Method RFF was analyzed in 28 children with vocal fold nodules (CwVN, M = 9.0 years) and 28 children with typical voices (CwTV, M = 8.9 years). RFF is the instantaneous fundamental frequency (f ₀) of the 10 vocalic cycles during devoicing (vocal offset) and 10 vocalic cycles during the revoicing (vocal onset) of the vowels that surround a voiceless consonant. Each cycle's f ₀ was normalized to a steady-state portion of the vowel. RFF values for the cycles closest to the voiceless consonant, that is, Offset Cycle 10 and Onset Cycle 1, were examined. Results Average RFF values for Offset Cycle 10 and Onset Cycle 1 did not differ between CwVN and CwTV; however, within-subject variability of Offset Cycle 10 was decreased in CwVN. Across both groups, male children had lower Offset Cycle 10 RFF values as compared to female children. Additionally, Onset Cycle 1 values were decreased in younger children as compared to those of older children. Conclusions Unlike previous work with adults, CwVN did not have significantly different RFF values than CwTV. Younger children had lower RFF values for Onset Cycle 1 than older children, suggesting that vocal onset f ₀ may provide information on the maturity of the laryngeal motor system.

Intersegmenter Variability in High-Speed Laryngoscopy-Based Glottal Area Waveform Measures

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

High-speed videoendoscopy (HSV) has potential to objectively quantify vibratory vocal fold characteristics during phonation. Glottal Analysis Tools (GAT) version 2018, developed in Erlangen, Germany, is software for determining various glottal area waveform (GAW) quantities. Before having GAT analyze HSV videos, segmenters have to define glottis manually across videos in a semiautomatic segmentation protocol. Such interventions are hypothesized to induce variability of subsequent GAW measure computation across segmenters and may attenuate GAT measures' reliability to a certain point. This study explored intersegmenter variability in GAT's GAW measures based on semiautomatic image processing.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study of rater reliability.

METHODS

In total, 20 HSV videos from normophonic and dysphonic subjects with various laryngeal disorders were selected for this study and segmented by three trained segmenters. They separately segmented glottis areas in the same frame sets of the videos. Upon analysis of GAW, GAT offers 46 measures related to topologic GAW dynamic characteristics, GAW periodicity and perturbation characteristics, and GAW harmonic components. To address GAT's reliability, intersegmenter-based variability in these measures was examined with intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS

In general, ICC behavior of the 46 GAW measures across three raters was highly acceptable. ICC of one parameter was moderate (0.5 < ICC < 0.75), good for seven parameters (0.75 < ICC < 0.9), and excellent for 38 parameters (0.9 < ICC).

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, high ICC values confirm clinical applicability of GAT for objective and quantitative assessment of HSV. Small intersegmenter differences with actual small parameter differences suggest that manual or semiautomatic segmentation in GAT does not noticeably influence clinical assessment outcome. To guarantee the software's performance, we suggest segmentation training before clinical application.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2b Laryngoscope, 130:E654-E661, 2020.

Adductory Vocal Fold Kinematic Trajectories During Conventional Versus High-Speed Videoendoscopy

Objective Prephonatory vocal fold angle trajectories may supply useful information about the laryngeal system but were examined in previous studies using sigmoidal curves fit to data collected at 30 frames per second (fps). Here, high-speed videoendoscopy (HSV) was used to investigate the impacts of video frame rate and sigmoidal fitting strategy on vocal fold adductory patterns for voicing onsets. Method Twenty-five participants with healthy voices performed /ifi/ sequences under flexible nasendoscopy at 1,000 fps. Glottic angles were extracted during adduction for voicing onset; resulting vocal fold trajectories (i.e., changes in glottic angle over time) were down-sampled to simulate different frame rate conditions (30-1,000 fps). Vocal fold adduction data were fit with asymmetric sigmoids using 5 fitting strategies with varying parameter restrictions. Adduction trajectories and maximum adduction velocities were compared between the fits and the actual HSV data. Adduction trajectory errors between HSV data and fits were evaluated using root-mean-square error and maximum angular velocity error. Results Simulated data were generally well fit by sigmoid models; however, when compared to the actual 1,000-fps data, sigmoid fits were found to overestimate maximum angle velocities. Errors decreased as frame rate increased, reaching a plateau by 120 fps. Conclusion In healthy adults, vocal fold kinematic behavior during adduction is generally sigmoidal, although such fits can produce substantial errors when data are acquired at frame rates lower than 120 fps.

Laryngeal Pressure Estimation With a Recurrent Neural Network

Quantifying the physical parameters of voice production is essential for understanding the process of phonation and can aid in voice research and diagnosis. As an alternative to invasive measurements, they can be estimated by formulating an inverse problem using a numerical forward model. However, high-fidelity numerical models are often computationally too expensive for this. This paper presents a novel approach to train a long short-term memory network to estimate the subglottal pressure in the larynx at massively reduced computational cost using solely synthetic training data. We train the network on synthetic data from a numerical two-mass model and validate it on experimental data from 288 high-speed ex vivo video recordings of porcine vocal folds from a previous study. The training requires significantly fewer model evaluations compared with the previous optimization approach. On the test set, we maintain a comparable performance of 21.2% versus previous 17.7% mean absolute percentage error in estimating the subglottal pressure. The evaluation of one sample requires a vanishingly small amount of computation time. The presented approach is able to maintain estimation accuracy of the subglottal pressure at significantly reduced computational cost. The methodology is likely transferable to estimate other parameters and training with other numerical models. This improvement should allow the adoption of more sophisticated, high-fidelity numerical models of the larynx. The vast speedup is a critical step to enable a future clinical application and knowledge of parameters such as the subglottal pressure will aid in diagnosis and treatment selection.

Comparing the Nonlinear Dynamic Acoustic Parameters of Healthy Adult and Pediatric Voices

Objectives:

The aims of this study were to compare nondysphonic adult and pediatric voices using linear and nonlinear acoustic parameters and to evaluate the ability of adult spectrum convergence ratio (SCR) and rate of divergence (ROD) reference values to correctly identify a pediatric voice type as periodic or aperiodic.

Methods:

Twenty adult and 36 pediatric nondysphonic voice samples were collected and analyzed using linear and nonlinear acoustic parameters. Absence of voice disorder was confirmed using perceptual acoustic and spectral analysis. Mean values for jitter, shimmer, SCR, and ROD were compared between adults and children, across specific age groups, and within genders. Using adult reference values for SCR and ROD, samples were classified as primarily periodic or aperiodic and typed using spectral analysis. Rates of accurate typing were also compared between subject groups.

Results:

Overall, jitter and shimmer were similar among the adult and pediatric age groups. ROD was significantly different among the 3 pediatric and 1 adult group; the pediatric age groups were similar to one another. Adult SCR was also significantly different from all of the pediatric age groups. In adult men, ROD and SCR were significantly different from all of the pediatric age groups; the pediatric age groups were similar to one another. In female subjects, ROD was significantly different among all age groups. The ROD and SCR reference values were significantly better at categorizing adult voice types compared with pediatric voice types.

Conclusions:

In healthy subjects, SCR and ROD have discriminatory power for identifying adult versus pediatric voices, while jitter and shimmer cannot differentiate between the 2 groups. However, age- and gender-specific pediatric reference values must be determined to accurately classify voice types using SCR and ROD.

Biomechanical simulation of vocal fold dynamics in adults based on laryngeal high-speed videoendoscopy

MOTIVATION

Human voice is generated in the larynx by the two oscillating vocal folds. Owing to the limited space and accessibility of the larynx, endoscopic investigation of the actual phonatory process in detail is challenging. Hence the biomechanics of the human phonatory process are still not yet fully understood. Therefore, we adapt a mathematical model of the vocal folds towards vocal fold oscillations to quantify gender and age related differences expressed by computed biomechanical model parameters.

METHODS

The vocal fold dynamics are visualized by laryngeal high-speed videoendoscopy (4000 fps). A total of 33 healthy young subjects (16 females, 17 males) and 11 elderly subjects (5 females, 6 males) were recorded. A numerical two-mass model is adapted to the recorded vocal fold oscillations by varying model masses, stiffness and subglottal pressure. For adapting the model towards the recorded vocal fold dynamics, three different optimization algorithms (Nelder-Mead, Particle Swarm Optimization and Simulated Bee Colony) in combination with three cost functions were considered for applicability. Gender differences and age-related kinematic differences reflected by the model parameters were analyzed.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

The biomechanical model in combination with numerical optimization techniques allowed phonatory behavior to be simulated and laryngeal parameters involved to be quantified. All three optimization algorithms showed promising results. However, only one cost function seems to be suitable for this optimization task. The gained model parameters reflect the phonatory biomechanics for men and women well and show quantitative age- and gender-specific differences. The model parameters for younger females and males showed lower subglottal pressures, lower stiffness and higher masses than the corresponding elderly groups. Females exhibited higher subglottal pressures, smaller oscillation masses and larger stiffness than the corresponding similar aged male groups. Optimizing numerical models towards vocal fold oscillations is useful to identify underlying laryngeal components controlling the phonatory process.

Feasibility of Clinical Endoscopy and Stroboscopy in Children With Bilateral Vocal Fold Lesions

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to examine the utility of flexible and rigid endoscopy and stroboscopy for the identification of anatomical and physiological features in children with bilateral vocal fold lesions. The secondary purpose was to describe the age distribution of patients who could tolerate use of the different types of endoscopes.

METHOD

This cross-sectional clinic-based study included 38 children (ages 5 to 12 years) diagnosed with bilateral vocal fold lesions via videoendoscopy. Vocal fold vibratory characteristics (e.g., mucosal wave) were rated by 4 clinicians by consensus.

RESULTS

Bilateral vocal fold lesions could be well described anatomically after visualization with both flexible and rigid endoscopes and were most commonly described as symmetrical and broad based. However, the clinicians' confidence in the accuracy of stroboscopy for rating vocal fold vibratory characteristics was limited for both flexible and rigid stroboscopes.

CONCLUSIONS

Videoendoscopy was adequate for viewing and characterizing anatomical structures of bilateral vocal fold lesions in pediatric patients; however, vibratory characteristics were often not fully visualized with videostroboscopy. In view of the importance of visualizing vocal fold vibration in the differential diagnosis and treatment of vocal fold lesions, other imaging modalities, such as high-speed videoendoscopy, may provide more accurate descriptions of vocal fold vibratory characteristics in this population.

Vibratory onset and offset times in children: A laryngeal imaging study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the study was to evaluate the differences in vibratory onset and offset times across age (adult males, adult females, and children) and waveform types (total glottal area waveform, left glottal area waveform, and right glottal area waveform) using high-speed videoendoscopy.

METHODS

In this prospective study, vibratory onset and offset times were evaluated in a total of 86 participants. Forty-three children (23 girls, 18 boys) between 5 and 11 years and 43 gender matched vocally normal young adults (23 females and 18 males) in the age range (21-45 years) were recruited. Vibratory onset and offset times were calculated in milliseconds from the total, left, and right Glottal Area Waveform (GAW). A two-factor analysis of variance was used to compare the means among the subject groups (children, adult male, and adult female) and waveform type (total GAW, left GAW, right GAW) for onset and offset variables. Post hoc analyses were performed using the Fishers Least Significant Different test with Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons.

RESULTS

Children exhibited significantly shorter vibratory onset and offset times compared to adult males and females. Differences in vibratory onset and offset times were not statistically significant between adult males and females. Across all waveform types (i.e. total GAW, left GAW, and right GAW), no statistical significance was observed among the subject groups.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study reporting vibratory onset and offset times in the pediatric population. The study findings lay the foundation for the development of a large age- and gender-based database of the pediatric population to aid the study of the effects of maturation of vocal fold vibration in adulthood. The findings from this study may also provide the basis for evaluating the impact of numerous lesions on tissue pliability, and thereby has potential utility for the clinical differentiation of various lesions.

Extension and Application of High-Speed Digital Imaging Analysis Via Spatiotemporal Correlation and Eigenmode Analysis of Vocal Fold Vibration Before and After Polyp Excision

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To evaluate the spatiotemporal correlation of vocal fold vibration using eigenmode analysis before and after polyp removal and explore the potential clinical relevance of spatiotemporal analysis of correlation length and entropy as quantitative voice parameters. We hypothesized that increased order in the vibrating signal after surgical intervention would decrease the eigenmode-based entropy and increase correlation length.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective case series.

METHODS

Forty subjects (23 males, 17 females) with unilateral (n = 24) or bilateral (n = 16) polyps underwent polyp removal. High-speed videoendoscopy was performed preoperatively and 2 weeks postoperatively. Spatiotemporal analysis was performed to determine entropy, quantification of signal disorder, correlation length, size, and spatially ordered structure of vocal fold vibration in comparison to full spatial consistency. The signal analyzed consists of the vibratory pattern in space and time derived from the high-speed video glottal area contour.

RESULTS

Entropy decreased (Z = -3.871, P < .001) and correlation length increased (t = -8.913, P < .001) following polyp excision. The intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) for correlation length and entropy were 0.84 and 0.93.

CONCLUSION

Correlation length and entropy are sensitive to mass lesions. These parameters could potentially be used to augment subjective visualization after polyp excision when evaluating procedural efficacy.

Effects of Vocal Fold Nodules on Glottal Cycle Measurements Derived from High-Speed Videoendoscopy in Children

The goal of this study is to quantify the effects of vocal fold nodules on vibratory motion in children using high-speed videoendoscopy. Differences in vibratory motion were evaluated in 20 children with vocal fold nodules (5–11 years) and 20 age and gender matched typically developing children (5–11 years) during sustained phonation at typical pitch and loudness. Normalized kinematic features of vocal fold displacements from the mid-membranous vocal fold point were extracted from the steady-state high-speed video. A total of 12 kinematic features representing spatial and temporal characteristics of vibratory motion were calculated. Average values and standard deviations (cycle-to-cycle variability) of the following kinematic features were computed: normalized peak displacement, normalized average opening velocity, normalized average closing velocity, normalized peak closing velocity, speed quotient, and open quotient. Group differences between children with and without vocal fold nodules were statistically investigated. While a moderate effect size was observed for the spatial feature of speed quotient, and the temporal feature of normalized average closing velocity in children with nodules compared to vocally normal children, none of the features were statistically significant between the groups after Bonferroni correction. The kinematic analysis of the mid-membranous vocal fold displacement revealed that children with nodules primarily differ from typically developing children in closing phase kinematics of the glottal cycle, whereas the opening phase kinematics are similar. Higher speed quotients and similar opening phase velocities suggest greater relative forces are acting on vocal fold in the closing phase. These findings suggest that future large-scale studies should focus on spatial and temporal features related to the closing phase of the glottal cycle for differentiating the kinematics of children with and without vocal fold nodules.

A generalized procedure for analyzing sustained and dynamic vocal fold vibrations from laryngeal high-speed videos using phonovibrograms

OBJECTIVE

This work presents a computer-based approach to analyze the two-dimensional vocal fold dynamics of endoscopic high-speed videos, and constitutes an extension and generalization of a previously proposed wavelet-based procedure. While most approaches aim for analyzing sustained phonation conditions, the proposed method allows for a clinically adequate analysis of both dynamic as well as sustained phonation paradigms.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The analysis procedure is based on a spatio-temporal visualization technique, the phonovibrogram, that facilitates the documentation of the visible laryngeal dynamics. From the phonovibrogram, a low-dimensional set of features is computed using a principle component analysis strategy that quantifies the type of vibration patterns, irregularity, lateral symmetry and synchronicity, as a function of time. Two different test bench data sets are used to validate the approach: (I) 150 healthy and pathologic subjects examined during sustained phonation. (II) 20 healthy and pathologic subjects that were examined twice: during sustained phonation and a glissando from a low to a higher fundamental frequency. In order to assess the discriminative power of the extracted features, a Support Vector Machine is trained to distinguish between physiologic and pathologic vibrations. The results for sustained phonation sequences are compared to the previous approach. Finally, the classification performance of the stationary analyzing procedure is compared to the transient analysis of the glissando maneuver.

RESULTS

For the first test bench the proposed procedure outperformed the previous approach (proposed feature set: accuracy: 91.3%, sensitivity: 80%, specificity: 97%, previous approach: accuracy: 89.3%, sensitivity: 76%, specificity: 96%). Comparing the classification performance of the second test bench further corroborates that analyzing transient paradigms provides clear additional diagnostic value (glissando maneuver: accuracy: 90%, sensitivity: 100%, specificity: 80%, sustained phonation: accuracy: 75%, sensitivity: 80%, specificity: 70%).

CONCLUSIONS

The incorporation of parameters describing the temporal evolvement of vocal fold vibration clearly improves the automatic identification of pathologic vibration patterns. Furthermore, incorporating a dynamic phonation paradigm provides additional valuable information about the underlying laryngeal dynamics that cannot be derived from sustained conditions. The proposed generalized approach provides a better overall classification performance than the previous approach, and hence constitutes a new advantageous tool for an improved clinical diagnosis of voice disorders.

Kinematic measurements of the vocal-fold displacement waveform in typical children and adult populations: quantification of high-speed endoscopic videos

PURPOSE

This article presents a quantitative method for assessing instantaneous and average lateral vocal-fold motion from high-speed digital imaging, with a focus on developmental changes in vocal-fold kinematics during childhood.

METHOD

Vocal-fold vibrations were analyzed for 28 children (aged 5-11 years) and 28 adults (aged 21-45 years) without voice disorders. The following kinematic features were analyzed from the vocal-fold displacement waveforms: relative velocity-based features (normalized average and peak opening and closing velocities), relative acceleration-based features (normalized peak opening and closing accelerations), speed quotient, and normalized peak displacement.

RESULTS

Children exhibited significantly larger normalized peak displacements, normalized average and peak opening velocities, normalized average and peak closing velocities, peak opening and closing accelerations, and speed quotient compared to adult women. Values of normalized average closing velocity and speed quotient were higher in children compared to adult men.

CONCLUSIONS

When compared to adult men, developing children typically have higher estimates of kinematic features related to normalized displacement and its derivatives. In most cases, the kinematic features of children are closer to those of adult men than adult women. Even though boys experience greater changes in glottal length and pitch as they mature, results indicate that girls experience greater changes in kinematic features compared to boys.

Spatiotemporal analysis of high-speed videolaryngoscopic imaging of organic pathologies in males

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to identify parameters that would differentiate healthy from pathological organic-based vocal fold vibrations to emphasize clinical usefulness of high-speed imaging.

METHOD

Fifty-five men (M age = 36 years, SD = 20 years) were examined and separated into 4 groups: 1 healthy (26 individuals) and 3 pathological (10 individuals with contact granuloma, 12 with polyps, and 7 with cysts). Vocal fold vibrations were recorded using a high-speed camera during sustained phonation. Twenty objective glottal area waveform and 24 phonovibrogram parameters representing spatiotemporal characteristics were analyzed. Statistical group comparisons were performed to document spatiotemporal changes for organic lesions that cannot be determined visually. To look for specific pattern profiles within organic lesions, the authors performed linear discriminant analysis.

RESULTS

Thirteen parameters showed significant differences between the healthy group and at least 1 pathological group. The differences occurred more in temporal than in spatial parameters. Contact granuloma showed the fewest statistical differences (3 parameters), followed by cysts (9 parameters), and polyps (10 parameters). Linear discriminant analysis achieved accuracy performance of 76% (all groups separated) and 82% (healthy vs. pathological).

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that for males, the differences between healthy voices and organic voice disorders may be more pronounced within temporal characteristics that cannot be visually detected without high-speed imaging.

Characterizing vibratory kinematics in children and adults with high-speed digital imaging

PURPOSE The aim of this study is to quantify and identify characteristic vibratory motion in typically developing prepubertal children and young adults using high-speed digital imaging. METHOD The vibrations of the vocal folds were recorded from 27 children (ages 5-9 years) and 35 adults (ages 21-45 years), with high speed at 4,000 frames per second for sustained phonation. Kinematic features of amplitude periodicity, time periodicity, phase asymmetry, spatial symmetry, and glottal gap index were analyzed from the glottal area waveform across mean and standard deviation (i.e., intercycle variability) for each measure. RESULTS Children exhibited lower mean amplitude periodicity compared to men and women and lower time periodicity compared to men. Children and women exhibited greater variability in amplitude periodicity, time periodicity, phase asymmetry, and glottal gap index compared to men. Women had lower mean values of amplitude periodicity and time periodicity compared to men. CONCLUSION Children differed both spatially but more temporally in vocal fold motion, suggesting the need for the development of children-specific kinematic norms. Results suggest more uncontrolled vibratory motion in children, reflecting changes in the vocal fold layered structure and aero-acoustic source mechanisms.

Measurement of glottal cycle characteristics between children and adults: physiological variations

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to quantify phases of the vibratory cycle using measurements of glottal cycle quotients and glottal cycle derivatives, in typically developing prepubertal children and young adults with the use of high-speed digital imaging (HSDI).

METHODS

Vocal fold vibrations were recorded from 27 children (age range 5-9 years) and 35 adults (age range 21-45 years), with HSDI at 4000 frames per second for sustained phonation. Glottal area waveform measures of Open Quotient, Closing Quotient, Speed Index (SI), Rate Quotient, and Asymmetry Quotient (AsyQ) were computed. Glottal cycle derivatives of Amplitude Quotient (AQ) and Maximum Area Declination Rate (MADR) were also computed. Group differences (adult females, adult males, and children) were statistically investigated for mean and standard deviation values of the glottal cycle quotients and glottal cycle derivatives.

RESULTS

Children exhibited higher values of SI and AsyQ and lower values of MADR compared with adult males. Children exhibited the highest mean value and lowest variability in AQ compared with adult males and females. Adult males showed lower values of SI, AsyQ, AQ, and higher values of MADR compared with adult females.

CONCLUSIONS

Glottal cycle vibratory motion in children is functionally different compared with adult males and females, suggesting the need for development of children specific norms for both normal and disordered voice qualities.