Comparison of endoscopic and microscopic stapedotomy in the same patients: a prospective randomized controlled trial

PURPOSE

This study aimed to conduct a comparative analysis of audiological and postoperative clinical outcomes between the endoscopic and microscopic stapedotomy approaches.

METHODS

This study employed a randomized, controlled design. Twenty-seven patients with bilateral otosclerosis underwent stapedotomy in both ears, with randomized allocation of the surgical technique (endoscopic vs. microscopic) for the first operated ear. Air-bone gap (ABG) and ABG gain were measured at least 12 months postoperatively. Postoperative outcomes including pain (Visual Analog Scale-VAS), dizziness, early-term (day 1) and late-term (6 months) dysgeusia were evaluated. The Glasgow Benefit Inventory (GBI) assessed health-related quality of life at one month postoperatively, and operative time was measured.

RESULTS

This study compared endoscopic (n = 27 ears) and microscopic (n = 27 ears) stapedotomy for otosclerosis. Both groups achieved similar hearing improvement with no significant differences in pre-operative and post-operative bone/air conduction thresholds, ABG, and ABG gain (all p > 0.05). The endoscopic stapedotomy group demonstrated reduced postoperative pain (lower VAS scores, p < 0.001), lower early dysgeusia (3.7% vs. 33.3%, p = 0.005), shorter operative time (47.3 vs. 75.4 min, p < 0.001) and improved patient-reported outcomes (higher GBI score, p = 0.014) when compared to microscopic stapedotomy group. No significant differences were observed in postoperative dizziness or late-term dysgeusia between groups.

CONCLUSION

This study found similar hearing improvement with both endoscopic and microscopic stapedotomy for otosclerosis. However, the endoscopic approach showed advantages in reduced postoperative pain, early dysgeusia, and operative time, with improved patient-reported quality of life. These findings suggest endoscopic stapedotomy as a valuable alternative to the conventional microscopic approach.

Local versus general anesthesia for stapes surgery: a prospective study of comfort and results on 100 ears

AIMS

To demonstrate the non-inferiority of perioperative comfort in patients undergoing otosclerosis surgery under local anesthesia versus general anesthesia and to compare audiometric results, quality of life and complications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A prospective non-interventional study was performed. Patients undergoing otosclerosis surgery between January 2019 and March 2021 at the University Hospital of Rennes were included consecutively. Perioperative comfort of LA versus GA (at ward admission, surgery, recovery and 48 h following surgery) was measured on a visual analogue scale at 10 days postoperatively and quality of life by the Glasgow Benefit Inventory at 3 months. Complications and audiometric results were also assessed. To demonstrate the non-inferiority of LA versus GA with a margin of 1.5 points on the comfort VAS, a power of 80% and a first-order risk of 5, 100 patients were included and statistical analyses were performed in accordance with CONSORT2010 statement.

RESULTS

One hundred ears were analyzed, 46% operated under local anesthesia and 54% under general anesthesia. The two groups were similar in terms of demographic and pathological characteristics. Local anesthesia was non-inferior to general anesthesia in terms of comfort with a comfort VAS of 8.74 ± 1.55 and 9.08 ± 0.93 respectively (p < 0.0001). There were no significant differences in rates of complications, audiometric results and quality of life between local and general anesthesia.

CONCLUSION

Local anesthesia is non-inferior to general anesthesia in terms of perioperative patient comfort with similar audiometric results, postoperative quality of life and complication rates.

Audiological outcomes after revision stapes surgeries: a systematic review

PURPOSE

Revision stapes surgery is a challenging procedure performed in relatively small numbers compared to other middle ear procedures. Despite numerous data on hearing results of different middle ear surgeries, the audiological standards for successful outcome of this procedure are still not clarified. On the basis of well-documented data, we wanted to determine what the expected audiological results and complications are after revision stapes surgery in order to set a realistic threshold for surgical success.

METHODS

After the protocol registration in the PROSPERO database, a systematic review was performed in multiple databases (PubMed, Cochrane, Web of Science, Scopus, ScienceOpen, ClinicalTrials.gov, Google Scholar) according to PRISMA guidelines. Twelve articles were reviewed according to the inclusion criteria. A total of 1032 cases were obtained for evaluation. A modified version of Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) was used to assess publication quality.

RESULTS

Average air-bone gap (ABG) gain was 17.3 dB, average air conduction (AC) gain was 17.5 dB. The average postoperative air-bone gap was 11.1 dB. The postoperative ABG distribution was the following 0-10 dB: 53.3%, > 10-20 dB: 28.2%, > 20 dB: 18.5%. SNHL as a surgical complication was described in a total of 17 cases (1.6%), no equilibrium disorder was reported.

CONCLUSION

The pooled data suggest that revision stapes surgery is an effective solution after failure of previous stapes surgery. However, the results are clearly inferior to those of primary stapedotomies. Hence, we need to apply different expectations and use different standards in the indication and evaluation of this type of surgery.

Conventional vs. diode laser stapedotomy: audiological outcomes and clinical safety

PURPOSE

To compare the hearing results and clinical safety of patients undergoing stapes surgery with conventional technique and diode laser.

METHODS

Retrospective observational study, which included patients treated with primary stapes surgery performed between January 2009 and January 2020. Three audiometric measurements (PTA, GAP and SDS) were evaluated as main results, evaluated by analysis of covariance (controlling the preoperative value). Intraoperative and postoperative complications were also analyzed. Outcomes were measured 6 months (± 1 month) after surgery.

RESULTS

153 cases were included, 97 operated with conventional technique and 56 with laser technique. Postoperative GAP ≤ 10 dB was obtained in 85.6% of the total sample, 82.5% in the conventional technique and 91.1% in the laser technique. Analysis of covariance showed no significant differences in the three surgery outcomes between the two groups (PTA, p = 0.277; GAP, p = 0.509 and SDS, p = 0.530). Regarding surgical complications, sensorineural damage was higher in the conventional technique group (p = 0.05). On the other hand, there were four cases of facial paresis, all in the laser group, three of them with the 980 nm laser.

CONCLUSIONS

Stapedotomy offered a high percentage of hearing success in the two groups studied. There were no significant differences in audiometric result, but there was a differential presentation of complications, being more frequent sensorineural hearing loss in the conventional technique group and facial paresis in the laser group.

Primary Stapedectomy: A Retrospective Review of Surgical Results Using a Cold Steel Technique and Pre-Operative CT Correlates

IMPORTANCE

Stapedectomy is an effective treatment option for patients with symptomatic otosclerosis. A common surgical technique today is laser stapedotomy, although the equipment required adds a significant cost to the procedure and may not be available in certain, particularly remote, centers. This study aimed to evaluate cold steel stapedectomy in a modern otology practice as a cost-effective and versatile alternative.

OBJECTIVE

The primary objective was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of cold steel stapedectomy. The secondary objectives included characterizing the prevalence of relevant computed tomography (CT) findings and evaluating other factors such as piston size.

DESIGN

A retrospective case series from April 2006 to November 2021.

SETTING

A single tertiary care hospital in Montreal, QC, Canada.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients with suspected otosclerosis and no prior stapes surgery.

INTERVENTION

Cold steel primary stapedectomy.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

In primary analysis, change in pure tone thresholds, pure tone average (PTA), and complication rates were obtained. Secondary analysis measures included rates of relevant CT findings and change in PTA with piston size.

RESULTS

A total of 302 cases were included in the analysis. The average change in air conduction PTA was a decrease of 27 dB, with 91% (276/302) having over 10 dB of improvement. The air-bone gap was closed to within 10 dB in 82% (248/302) of cases and within 20 dB in 96% (290/302) of cases. Overclosure occurred in 19% of cases, while only 4% resulted in worsened PTA bone conduction thresholds. In secondary analysis, 74% of CT scans demonstrated radiologic otosclerosis. Other findings included suspected superior semicircular canal dehiscence in 1.8%.

CONCLUSION

Cold steel stapedectomy was demonstrated to be a safe and effective technique, with audiometric results comparable to laser and drill studies in recent literature. It should be considered as a cost-effective and global health accessible alternative. Additionally, CT scans can provide valuable information in the pre-operative workup.

Brazilian Society of Otology task force - Otosclerosis: evaluation and treatment

OBJECTIVES

To review and provide evidence-based recommendations for the diagnosis and treatment of otosclerosis.

METHODS

Task force members were educated on knowledge synthesis methods, including electronic database search, review and selection of relevant citations, and critical appraisal of selected studies. Articles written in English or Portuguese on otosclerosis were eligible for inclusion. The American College of Physicians' guideline grading system and the American Thyroid Association's guideline criteria were used for critical appraisal of evidence and recommendations for therapeutic interventions.

RESULTS

The topics were divided into 2 parts: 1) Diagnosis - audiologic and radiologic; 2) Treatment - hearing AIDS, pharmacological therapy, stapes surgery, and implantable devices - bone-anchored devices, active middle ear implants, and Cochlear Implants (CI).

CONCLUSIONS

The pathophysiology of otosclerosis has not yet been fully elucidated, but environmental factors and unidentified genes are likely to play a significant role in it. Women with otosclerosis are not at increased risk of worsening clinical condition due to the use of contraceptives or during pregnancy. Drug treatment has shown little benefit. If the patient does not want to undergo stapedotomy, the use of hearing aids is well indicated. Implantable systems should be indicated only in rare cases, and the CI should be indicated in cases of profound deafness.

Impact of manual crimping on stapedotomy outcomes

BACKGROUND

The impact of tight stapes crimping on hearing is a matter of debate. Several studies postulate that tight crimping is essential for lifelong success, whereas others have debated whether firm attachment leads to incus necrosis. Several types of prostheses with different coupling mechanisms have been developed, and manual crimping remains the most frequently used technique. This study investigates whether tightness really does affect hearing outcome.

METHODS

The hearing results of patients who underwent primary stapedotomies using three different titanium pistons were analysed. The surgeons categorised the firmness of the piston attachment into 'tight' and 'loose' crimping groups. Hearing outcome and reasons for revision surgical procedures were investigated.

RESULTS

The mean post-operative air-bone gap for frequencies of 0.5-4 kHz was 8.80 dB for the tight crimping group (n = 308) and 9.55 dB for the loose crimping group (n = 39). No significant difference was found (p = 0.4650). Findings at revision procedures were comparable (1.6 per cent vs 5 per cent).

CONCLUSION

Although firm crimping is strongly advised, a movable loop upon palpation does not lead to unsatisfactory hearing results, and does not mandate piston replacement or bone cement use.

Vertigo Associated with Otosclerosis and Stapes Surgery-A Narrative Review

Otosclerosis is a pathological condition affecting the temporal bone, and is characterized by remodelling of the labyrinthine bone tissue through a dynamic process of osteolysis and osteogenesis. This condition progressively leads to hearing loss, tinnitus, and vertigo. Stapedotomy, a surgical procedure involving the removal of the stapes superstructure and its replacement with a prosthesis, is the treatment of choice to improve hearing in individuals with otosclerosis. However, vestibular dysfunction is a significant complication associated with this procedure, which can occur intraoperatively or postoperatively, ranging from the immediate postoperative period to weeks, months, or even years after surgery. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive review of the most important causes of vertigo associated with otosclerosis and stapes surgery with the goal of minimizing the incidence of this complication. Understanding the underlying factors contributing to vertigo in this context is crucial for the prevention and effective management of vertigo in patients undergoing stapedotomy.

Predictive factors of revision stapes surgery in otosclerosis

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to investigate predictive factors for revision surgery in otosclerosis.

METHODS

This was a retrospective, multicentre study in four tertiary centres. The primary objective was to investigate factors that were predictive of the need for revision stapes surgery.

RESULTS

The 'revision' group included 145 patients, and the 'control' group included 143 patients. This study identified statistically significant predictive factors for the need for revision surgery: younger age, active smoking status, dyslipidaemia and high blood pressure. There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups in terms of surgical technique or stapedotomy technique.

CONCLUSION

This study showed that patients who are candidates for primary stapes surgery with younger age, active smoking status, dyslipidaemia and high blood pressure are at higher risk of needing revision surgery. A holistic approach prior to stapes surgery with multidisciplinary assessment is recommended. These results are important for better patient counselling on expected outcomes and risks.

The utility and safety of diode laser in endoscopic stapes surgery

Objective

The advantages of laser stapedotomy are less trauma and more precise and minimally invasive techniques; however, the potential risk of overheating from the laser combined with the endoscope tip must be considered. This study aimed to assess the efficacy and safety of diode lasers for endoscopic stapes surgery.

Methods

A retrospective review of 56 patients with otosclerosis who underwent primary endoscopic stapedotomy with a diode laser from 2017 to 2020 was conducted. Demographic data, intraoperative findings, preoperative and postoperative audiological assessments, and postoperative complications were analyzed.

Results

There was no statistically significant difference between the preoperative and postoperative bone conduction thresholds. The mean postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) improved significantly compared to the preoperative ABG (4.07 vs. 35.43 dB, p < .001). The postoperative ABG closure within 10 dB at 6 and 12 months was achieved in 87.50% and 91.07% of patients, respectively. The postoperative pain scores at 4 and 24 h were 2.55 and 0.39, respectively. Immediate postoperative vertigo was reported in 12.50% of patients, with 100% complete recovery 2 months after surgery. The chorda tympani nerve was preserved in all the cases. Postoperative taste disturbances at 2 and 12 months were observed in 17.86% and 1.79% of patients, respectively.

Conclusion

The diode laser in endoscopic stapedotomy is a safe and effective technique that provides satisfactory hearing outcomes. Temporary taste disturbances during the early postoperative period are a concern. The handheld diode laser delivery system is suitable for an endoscopic approach and is an alternative armamentarium for the treatment of otosclerosis. Level of evidence: IV.

Otosclerosis: audiometric results and quality of life after stapedectomy with interposition or CO2 laser-calibrated stapedotomy without interposition

BACKGROUND

The surgical treatment of otosclerosis consists of the replacement of the stapes using a piston.

AIMS/OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study is to assess the audiometric results and quality of life (QOL) of patients who underwent surgery for otosclerosis by stapedectomy with fascia interposition (STIP) or by stapedotomy using CO₂ laser (SLaser) without fascia interposition.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Ninety-one patients operated on for otosclerosis by STIP (40 patients) and by SLaser (51 patients) were included. Audiometric results were graphically displayed using the Amsterdam Hearing Evaluation Plot and were compared to the Common Otology Database (COD) comprising 660 patients. The patients' QOL was assessed with an otological validated survey. The significance level was p < .05.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference in hearing improvement between SLaser and STIP-operated patients. There was no significant difference between our results and that of COD. QOL was significantly improved (+3.5/10) postoperatively for both STIP and SLaser in both social and professional fields.

CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE

By comparing QOL and hearing gain of STIP and SLaser, our results suggest that both surgical techniques are a safe and successful treatment for otosclerotic stapes fixation. Further studies aiming at comparing larger series may confirm and refine these results.

Effects of Varying Laser Parameters During Laser Stapedotomy on Intracochlear Pressures

OBJECTIVE

Sensorineural hearing loss is a known complication of stapes surgery. We previously showed that laser stapedotomy can result in intracochlear pressures that are comparable to high sound pressure levels. Optimizing laser settings to those that correspond with the lowest pressure changes may mitigate risk for postoperative hearing loss. Here we quantify the effects of various laser parameters on intracochlear pressures and test the hypothesis that intracochlear pressure changes are proportional to the laser energy delivered.

STUDY DESIGN

Basic and translational science.

SETTING

Cadaveric dissection and basic science laboratory.

METHODS

Cadaveric human heads underwent mastoidectomies. Intracochlear pressures were measured via fiber-optic pressure probes placed in scala vestibuli and tympani. Pulses of varied stimulus power and duration from a 980-nm diode laser were applied to the stapes footplate.

RESULTS

Sustained high-intensity pressures were observed in the cochlea during all laser applications. Observed pressure magnitudes increased monotonically with laser energy and rose linearly for lower stimulus durations and powers, but there was increased variability for laser applications of longer duration (200-300 ms) and/or higher power (8 W).

CONCLUSIONS

Results confirm that significant pressure changes occur during laser stapedotomy, which we hypothesize may cause injury. Overall energy delivered depends predictably on duration and power, but surgeons should use caution at the highest stimulus levels and longest pulse durations due to the increasing variability in intracochlear pressure under these stimulus conditions. While the risk to hearing from increased intracochlear pressures from laser stapedotomy remains unclear, these results affirm the need to optimize laser settings to avoid unintended injury.

Rates of Sensorineural Hearing Loss and Revision Surgery After Stapedotomy: A Single-institution Experience Using the Nitinol Prosthesis

Background

Historically, stapedectomy complication rates are quoted as 1% profound postoperative sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL), 5%-10% nonprofound SNHL, and 5%-10% revision surgery.

Objective

We sought to reassess rates of post-stapedotomy complications based on our experience using contemporary surgical technique.

Methods

A retrospective case series was carried out at an academic tertiary referral center. Adult patients undergoing stapedotomy from 2013 to 2020 were included. Primary outcomes were rates of hearing loss and revision surgery. Rates of dizziness, tinnitus, dysgeusia, and proportions of patients who achieved air-bone gap (ABG) closure at 8-12 weeks postoperatively were also assessed.

Results

Four hundred sixty-eight stapedotomies in 399 patients with a median follow-up duration of 99 days (range, 11-5134) were reviewed. One patient (0.21%) suffered profound SHNL and 15 (3.20%) patients suffered nonprofound SNHL. The revision rate for stapedotomies from our institution was 4.49% (21 total revision surgeries). In 277 operations (59.19%), the patient had closure of the ABG within 10 dB. A further 132 (28.21%) had closure of the ABG between 10 and 20 dB. Air pure-tone audiometry scores improved by an average of 25.03 dB. Eighty-three (17.74%) patients complained of postoperative dizziness, which resolved by the time of the first follow-up appointment in all but 26 (5.56%). Seventeen patients (3.63%) complained of tinnitus, and 22 (4.70%) complained of dysgeusia.

Conclusions

SNHL, complications, and revision rates for stapedotomy in the modern era may be substantially lower than those currently presented to patients based on classic techniques and historical data.

Thulium laser in stapedotomy surgery

BACKGROUND

Thulium laser use in stapedotomy surgery is usually associated with many doubts regarding the thermal effect on the vestibular area and the production of acoustic shock waves, which may result in permanent complications.

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of the Thulium laser use in stapedotomy and its long-term effects on the clinical and audiological results.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

It was a retrospective randomized case-series study. We included 148 otosclerosis patients. They were divided randomly into two groups; group A (multiple shots) included 62 patients and group B (one shot with a manual perforator) included 86 patients.

RESULTS

There was a statistically significant improvement of the ABG in both groups. ABG closure (<10 dB) occurred in 87.1% of patients in group A, and 89.5% of patients in group B. Intraoperative complications were more in group B (p-value = 0.038). The postoperative complications were more in group A (p-value = .017).

CONCLUSIONS

According to our experience on a relatively large number of cases, the Thulium laser is a safe tool to be used in stapedotomy either in multiple shots or one shot with a manual perforator. It improved functional hearing efficiently without showing signs of inner ear impairment.

Audiologic Outcomes of Footplate Drillout for Obliterative Otosclerosis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the audiologic outcomes of microdrill fenestration for obliterative otosclerosis compared to traditional stapedotomy technique.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

Adult patients undergoing stapedotomy for otosclerosis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Patients were separated into groups that underwent either microdrill or laser fenestration based on intraoperative severity of disease. Audiologic outcomes and complications were compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

There were 588 ears in 519 patients that were evaluated. There was a significant postoperative improvement in pure tone average, air-bone gap, and mean bone conduction thresholds for both the obliterative and nonobliterative group (p < 0.001). There was no significant difference in the pre- or postoperative hearing status between the two groups. There was no significant difference in complications between the two groups, including no cases of postoperative profound hearing loss in the drill fenestration group.

CONCLUSIONS

Audiologic outcomes are similar between microdrill fenestration and laser fenestration for otosclerosis. Pure tone average, air-bone gap, and mean bone conduction thresholds all improved postoperatively and were similar between groups.

Taste impairment after endoscopic stapes surgery: Do anatomic variability of chorda tympani and surgical technique matter? : Post-operative dysgeusia after EStS

PURPOSE

To investigate how the anatomical configuration of the oval window region (OWR) influences the management of the chorda tympani (ChT) and the curetting of adjacent bony structures, in a setting of patients undergoing endoscopic stapes surgery (EStS); to assess the incidence of early and late post-operative dysgeusia and to identify anatomical and surgical factors influencing taste function after EStS.

METHODS

Surgical video recordings of 48 patients undergoing EStS for otosclerosis between January 2019 and July 2020 were retrospectively revised, to classify the anatomical variability of selected middle ear structures and the management strategies for the ChT. Clinical records of included patients were reviewed for subjective early and late post-operative taste impairment using a 5-point Likert-scale.

RESULTS

The most common configuration of the OWR was type III. The extension of the bony curettage resulted inversely proportional to the exposure of the OWR. The long-term rate of preserved post-operative taste function was 85%. Displacement of the ChT was necessary in 43/48 cases (90%), mostly medially (36/48, 75%).

CONCLUSION

Bone curetting during EStS does not correlate with post-operative taste impairment. Despite 100% ChT preservation rate, dysgeusia may occur in a minority of patients, with no apparent relationship to anatomical variability or intraoperative management of the ChT. The use of CO₂ laser could have a role in increasing the risk of post-operative dysgeusia after EStS.

Evaluation of Audiological Results and Cochleo-Vestibular Subclinical Injury After CO2 Laser Stapedotomy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Evaluation of the effectiveness and safety of CO₂ laser stapedotomy, focusing on the audiological results, and on the surgical cochleo-vestibular trauma.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective clinical trial on 38 patients with the diagnosis of otosclerosis, who underwent CO₂ laser stapedotomy between January 2015 and October 2019. Postoperative air-bone gap (ABG), mean air conduction gain, and postoperative changes of high frequency threshold were evaluated 1, 3, 6, and 12 months after surgery. Videoculography (VOG) was performed to assess the vestibular impairment preoperatively and 1 day, 1 week, and 1 month after surgery.

RESULTS

Postoperative ABG closure within 10 dB was obtained in 35 cases (92.1%), with a mean postoperative ABG of 4.4 dB and a mean air conduction improvement of 32.3 dB. No significant worsening of high frequency threshold was observed. Spontaneous nystagmus was found preoperatively in 5/38 patients (13.2%), 1 day after surgery in 13/38 patients (34.2%), 1 week after surgery in 12/38 patients (31.6%), and 1 month after surgery in 4/38 patients (10.5%). Positional nystagmus was found preoperatively in 12/38 patients (31.6%), 1 day after surgery in 25/38 patients (65.8%), 1 week after surgery in 22/38 patients (57.9%), and 1 month after surgery in 10/38 patients (26.3%). The occurrence of nystagmus did not always correlate with vestibular symptoms: after surgery, 10 patients (26.3%) experienced vertigo associated with dizziness, 8 patients (21.1%) suffered from dizziness without vertigo, and 14 patients (36.8%) showed nystagmus without any symptomatology. At 1 month after surgery none of the patients complained about vestibular symptoms.

CONCLUSION

CO₂ laser stapedotomy is a safe and effective technique, which allows to obtain good functional results with minimal perioperative cochleo-vestibular trauma.© 2021 Wiley Periodicals LLC.

Lasers in endoscopic middle ear surgery: where do we stand today?

OBJECTIVE

To provide an overview of the current status regarding the parallel use of the endoscope and the laser in middle ear surgery.

METHODS

Comprehensive Pubmed search from 1975 to 2020 including clinical articles, of any type, reporting the combined use of a laser and an endoscope. Purely experimental and non-human studies were excluded.

RESULTS

Reports on the application of the laser in pediatric and adult endoscopic middle ear surgery (EES) are increasing since 2013. Laser-assisted EES is performed for cholesteatoma, non-squamous chronic otitis media, ossicular fixation, otosclerosis and tympanic paraganglioma. The improved haemostasis and the non-contact ablation of tissue around the ossicles and inaccessible areas, represent unique advantages. In stapes surgery, the resection of stapes superstructure with minimal force and the non-contact footplate fenestration are potential advantages. Proper use of the laser, i.e. direction away from the facial nerve and the open labyrinth and safe energy settings have resulted in minimal complications.

CONCLUSION

Based on the increasing number of publications, endoscopic ear surgeons show an interest in using a laser for specific operative tasks. The configuration of a hand-held laser probe does not differ significantly from other otological instruments and therefore is easy to use alongside the endoscope, even in children. The 'handicap' of single-handed surgery can be partially offset by the bloodless and non-contact laser ablation of tissue.

Conventional Microscopic Stapedotomy: An Obsolete Technique or Still the Gold Standard for the Management of Otosclerosis?

Background and objectives Clinical otosclerosis is a relatively common entity, accounting for 0.5%-2% of the general population. Otosclerosis is characterized by an abnormal bone formation in the temporal bone that eventually causes conductive hearing loss. Bilateral involvement is fairly common. Treatment can be either conservative with medications and a hearing aid, or surgical. Stapedotomy is considered, nowadays, the most effective surgical technique for the management of otosclerosis. The purpose of the present study is to present our long-term results with stapedectomy, the audiological outcome, as well as the complications encountered. Subjects and methods This is a retrospective single-centre study. All patients diagnosed with otosclerosis and treated operatively with a stapedotomy from January 2010 to December 2019 were included in the study. Demographic data, air and bone conduction thresholds, complications and length of the prosthesis were recorded.  Results The study included a total of 72 patients. The audiological results showed a statistically significant improvement in the air conduction thresholds in all the affected frequencies (p<0.001). Post-operative complications included deterioration or severe hearing loss up to 100 dB (n=1, 1.39%), loss or distortion of taste (n=4, 5.6%) and tinnitus (n=2, 2.8%). Conclusions Our results demonstrate that stapedotomy is an effective technique for the management of otosclerosis. Stapedotomy, when performed by an experienced surgeon, provides excellent outcomes, with limited complications.

Prognostic factors for duration of vertigo after stapes surgery via a time-to-event analysis

BACKGROUND

Vertigo or dizziness after stapes surgery occurs sometimes, and it is generally temporary. However, while rare, it can be prolonged.

AIMS/OBJECTIVES

To investigate the prognostic factors for duration of vertigo following stapedotomy using a time-to-event analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The present study included a total of 35 primary ears (26 with otosclerosis and nine with congenital stapes fixation) from 31 patients. We assessed residual rates of nystagmus and complaints of subjective vestibular symptoms using Kaplan-Meier time-to-event methods.

RESULTS

Postoperative spontaneous nystagmus was observed in 23 (65.7%) ears, and postoperative subjective vestibular symptoms were confirmed in 27 (77.1%) ears. The total mean duration of postoperative spontaneous nystagmus and subjective vestibular symptoms was 9.8 (range: 0-158) and 33.9 days (0-732), respectively. A history of stapes surgery in the opposite ear was a significant predictive factor for prolonged nystagmus and subjective vestibular symptoms (p = .0059 and p = .0146).

CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE

For individuals with a history of stapes surgery in the opposite ear, spontaneous nystagmus and vertigo/dizziness sensations following stapedotomy may persist for a longer duration than in those without a history of stapes surgery in the opposite ear.

Microdrill stapedotomy for otosclerosis with small and large preoperative air-bone gap: a retrospective comparison of results

Background: In otosclerosis mixed hearing loss is the most frequent symptom and arises when the focus involves the stapes footplate. Surgeons usually prefer to wait a minimum air-bone gap of 25 - 35 dB before surgery.Objectives: To evaluate the outcome of microdrill stapedotomy for otosclerosis in patients with a preoperative air-bone gap (ABG) <25 dB versus patients with a preoperative gap ≥ 25 dB.Material and methods: For this retrospective study, the outcomes and complications after microdrill stapedotomy were compared between adult patients with a preoperative small ABG (n = 127, ABG <25 dB) and those with a large ABG (n = 254, ABG ≥25 dB).Results: The postoperative ABG was significantly smaller than the preoperative ABG (p < .05) in both groups; there were no differences in complications rates (severe sensorineural hearing loss, footplate fracture or early postoperative vertigo) between the two groups.Conclusions: Our findings show that microdrill stapedotomy is safe and can be performed even in patients with a preoperative small ABG without increasing the risk of sensorineural hearing loss due to inner ear damage.

The Use of Lasers in Stapes Surgery

OBJECTIVES

Otosclerosis is a disease process that usually starts around the oval window, causing fixation of the stapes, resulting in conductive hearing loss. Treatment of the conductive hearing loss caused by otosclerosis consists of either rehabilitation with hearing aids or performing surgery. Given the risks of hearing impairment and vertigo associated with the surgery, there has been a desire to advance the practice to minimize the complications. The so-called "non-contact" or "no touch" techniques with the use of various lasers are in current practice. This review article will cover the surgical aspects, the theory behind laser and the various types used in stapes surgery. It will also review the evidence of laser versus conventional stapes surgery and the comparison of different laser types.

METHODS

A literature search up to December 2019 was performed using Pubmed and a nonsystematic review of appropriate articles was undertaken. Keywords used were stapes, surgery, laser, stapedectomy, and stapedotomy.

RESULTS

Overall, there is no evidence to say laser fenestration is better than conventional fenestration techniques; however, with the micro drill, there is an increased risk of footplate fracture and sensorineural hearing loss. There is an increased risk of tinnitus with the laser compared to conventional techniques. Studies have favored the CO₂ laser over potassium titanyl phosphate (KTP) and erbium-doped yttrium aluminium garnet (Erbium-YAG) lasers for postoperative closure of the air-bone gap; and KTP laser has less thermal, mechanical, and sound effects compared with the thulium and carbon dioxide (CO₂) lasers. There is an increased risk if inner ear complications with the thulium laser.

CONCLUSIONS

It can be deduced that theoretically and practically, the thulium laser is less safe compared to the KTP and CO₂ lasers. The choice of laser used depends on the surgeon's preference, as well as availability, cost, side effects profile, as well as ease of use.

Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses Published in High-Impact Otolaryngology Journals

OBJECTIVE

To assess the methodological quality of intervention-focused systematic reviews (SRs) and meta-analyses (MAs) published in high-impact otolaryngology journals.

DATA SOURCES

Ovid Medline, Embase, and Cochrane Library.

REVIEW METHODS

A comprehensive search was performed for SR and MA citations from 2012 to 2017 in the 10 highest impact factor otolaryngology journals. Abstracts were screened to identify published manuscripts in which the authors indicated clearly that they were performing an SR or MA. Applying a modified typology of reviews, 4 reviewers characterized the review type as SR, MA, or another review type. A simplified version of the AMSTAR 2 (A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews 2) tool was used to assess the reporting and methodological quality of the SRs and MAs that were focused on interventions.

RESULTS

Search and abstract screening generated 499 manuscripts that identified themselves as performing an SR or MA. A substantial number (85/499, 17%) were review types other than SRs or MAs, including 34 (7%) that were literature reviews. In total, 236 SRs and MAs focused on interventions. Over 50% of these SRs and MAs had weaknesses in at least 3 of the 16 items in the AMSTAR 2, and over 40% had weaknesses in at least 2 of the 7 critical domains. Ninety-nine percent of SRs and MAs provided critically low confidence in the results of the reviews.

CONCLUSION

Intervention-focused SRs and MAs published in high-impact otolaryngology journals have important methodological limitations that diminish confidence in the results of these reviews.

Robot-based assistance in middle ear surgery and cochlear implantation: first clinical report

PURPOSE

Middle ear surgery may benefit from robot-based assistance to hold micro-instruments or an endoscope. However, the surgical gesture performed by one hand may perturb surgeons accustomed to two-handed surgery. A robot-based holder may combine the benefits from endoscopic exposure and a two-handed technique. Furthermore, tremor suppression and accurate tool control might help the surgeon during critical surgical steps. The goal of this work was to study the safety of an otological robot-based assistant under clinical conditions in a limited series of patients.

METHODS

The RobOtol system has been used as an endoscope or a micro instrument holder for this series. Eleven cases were operated on with the robot as an endoscope holder for chronic otitis. Twenty-one cases were operated on with the robot as a micro-instrument holder for otosclerosis (9 cases), transtympanic tube placement (2 cases), or cochlear implantation (10 cases).

RESULTS

No complications related to the robot manipulation occurred during surgery nor in postoperative. In the chronic otitis group, all perforations were sealed and 3-month postoperative pure-tone average air-bone gap (PTA ABG) was 15 ± 2.6 dB. In the otosclerosis group, 1-month post-op PTA ABG was 10 ± 1 dB. For cochlear implantation cases, a scala tympani insertion, a vestibular scala translocation occurred and a full scala vestibuli insertion was observed in 7, 2 and 1 case, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The RobOtol system has reached the clinical stage. It could be used safely and with accurate control as an endoscope holder or a micro instrument holder in 32 cases.

Risks of Intracochlear Pressures From Laser Stapedotomy

HYPOTHESIS

Surgical manipulations during laser stapedotomy can produce intracochlear pressure changes comparable to pressures created by high-intensity acoustic stimuli.

BACKGROUND

New-onset sensorineural hearing loss is a known risk of stapes surgery and may result from pressure changes from laser use or other surgical manipulations. Here, we test the hypothesis that high sound pressure levels are generated in the cochlea during laser stapedotomy.

METHODS

Human cadaveric heads underwent mastoidectomy. Fiber-optic sensors were placed in scala tympani and vestibuli to measure intracochlear pressures during key steps in stapedotomy surgery, including cutting stapedius tendon, lasering of stapedial crurae, crural downfracture, and lasering of the footplate.

RESULTS

Key steps in laser stapedotomy produced high-intensity pressures in the cochlea. Pressure transients were comparable to intracochlear pressures measured in response to high intensity impulsive acoustic stimuli.

CONCLUSION

Our results demonstrate that surgical manipulations during laser stapedotomy can create significant pressure changes within the cochlea, suggesting laser application should be minimized and alternatives to mechanical downfracture should be investigated. Results from this investigation suggest that intracochlear pressure transients from stapedotomy may be of sufficient magnitude to cause damage to the sensory epithelium and affirm the importance of limiting surgical traumatic exposures.

The impact of intra-operative factors in otosclerosis outcomes: retrospective study in a tertiary centre

The aim of the study was to assess results from a large cohort of patients undergoing otosclerosis surgery with respect to the impact of intra-operative variables on post-operative hearing function and complications. We enrolled 384 patients affected by otosclerosis who were subjected to stapes surgery between 2004 and 2013 at a single institution. Surgery was performed in all cases under local anaesthesia, using a manual perforator and/or microdrill. Teflon-piston prosthesis was used in all patients. Audiological data obtained preoperatively and at last follow-up examination (minimum 12 months) were compared. Statistical analysis was performed using the multiple regression model. Peripheral rim otosclerosis and diffuse otosclerosis were associated with better functional results compared to the obliterative pattern (p < 0.05). Mean post-operative Air-Bone Gap was significantly higher in the 0.4 mm, compared to 0.6 mm piston group at 0.5 kHz (p < 0.001) and 1 kHz (p < 0.02); in the stapedotomy group a statistically significant difference was found between 0.4 and 0.6 mm piston groups, in favour of the latter (p < 0.05). No differences were encountered in terms of average hearing threshold and complications. Intra-operative variables cannot be fully predictable and our data could help in stratification of the results and as a landmark for the surgeon’s decisions.

Variations in Stapes Surgery Cost within a Multihospital Network

Objective

To identify costs and operative times for stapedotomy and evaluate factors influencing cost variation.

Study Design

Case series with cost analysis.

Setting

Multihospital network.

Subjects and Methods

A multihospital network’s standardized activity-based accounting system was used to determine costs and operative times of all patients undergoing stapedotomy from 2013 to 2017. Subjects with additional procedures were excluded. Correlations between variable factors and cost were calculated by Spearman correlation coefficients. Audiometric and cost data were compared with a Mann-Whitney U test.

Results

The study cohort included 176 stapedotomies performed by 23 surgeons at 10 hospitals. Mean ± SD patient age was 44.3 ± 17.4 years. Mean cut-to-close time was 61.1 ± 23.55 minutes. Mean total encounter cost was $3542.14 ± $1258.78 (US dollars). Significant factors correlating with increased total encounter cost were surgical supply cost ( r = 0.74, P < .0001) and cut-to-close time ( r = 0.66, P < .0001). Laser utilization ($563.37 ± $407.41) was the highest-cost surgical supply, with the carbon dioxide laser being significantly more costly than the potassium titanyl phosphate (KTP; $852.60 vs $230.55, P < .001). Additionally, the carbon dioxide laser was associated with a significantly higher mean total encounter cost than the KTP laser ($4645.43 vs $2903.00, P < .001) and cases where no laser was used ($4645.43 vs $2932.47, P < .001). There was no difference in mean total encounter cost between the KTP laser and cases of no laser use ($2903.00 vs $2932.47, P = .75).

Conclusions

Significant cost variation exists in stapes surgery. Surgical supply cost, specifically laser use, may be associated with significantly increased costs. Reducing variation in costs while maintaining outcomes may improve health care value.

Stapes surgery in patients with a small air-bone gap

The objective of this study was to determine hearing outcomes in patients undergoing stapes surgery with a preoperative air-bone gap (ABG) <21.25 dB. Patients with a unilateral or bilateral preoperative ABG <21.25 dB undergoing primary stapes surgery were identified from a database of all stapes surgeries performed in a tertiary center over 15 years. A total of 254 ears met the inclusion criteria. The primary outcome measure was the degree of closure of the preoperative ABG. A secondary outcome measure was improvement in bone-conduction thresholds at 4 kHz. All patients underwent stapes surgery under local anesthesia. Ossicular reconstruction was achieved using a SMart 360 nitinol fluoroplastic piston (Gyrus ACMI, Inc.; Southborough, Mass.), and complete posterior crurotomy was performed with a KTP laser. Hearing was assessed with clinical voice testing immediately postoperatively and with pure-tone audiometry at 6 weeks postoperatively. A total of 248 ears (97.6%) demonstrated ABG closure to <10 dB. Bone-conduction thresholds showed an increase in 114 (44.9%), no change 74 (29.1%), and a decrease in 66 (26.0%). There is a slight increase in the risk of stapes mobilization in ears with a small ABG when compared to those with larger ABGs; however, this can be overcome by using a laser-assisted technique in combination with good surgical experience. The benefit in terms of hearing aid avoidance and the restoration of symmetrical hearing is both achievable and significant for the patient.

Fully endoscopic laser stapedotomy: is it comparable with microscopic surgery?

BACKGROUND

Microscopic stapedotomy is very successful and has long history, but it still has some constraints. Thus, otoendoscopy is increasingly popular nowadays.

AIMS/OBJECTIVES

The retrospective review study was to investigate the role of endoscopic laser stapedotomy in treating patients with otosclerosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventeen patients who received endoscopic laser stapedotomy from April 2014 to July 2017 were enrolled and compared to 13 patients who had microscopic stapedotomy from February 2009 to March 2012. The anatomical structures, operative time, and postoperative hearing outcomes were assessed in two groups. Relation between external acoustic canal and operative time was also analyzed.

RESULTS

Using an endoscope, the operative field was clear, with easily identified anatomy, without need to sacrifice bony structures. The operative time was significantly longer in the endoscopic group in 2014 and decreased in the following years. There was no significant difference of hearing improvements between the two groups. There was a weak correlation between the width of the external auditory canal and the operative time.

CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE

Fully endoscopic stapes surgery is a feasible and safe surgical technique and results in satisfactory hearing outcomes. However, surgeons take longer to master the technique and to achieve shorter endoscopic operative times.

Long-Term Hearing Outcomes following Stapedotomy in Patients with Otosclerosis and Preoperative Small Air-Bone Gap

Objectives: To assess the long-term effectiveness of stapedotomies performed on patients with otosclerosis and preoperative small air-bone gaps (ABGs). Methods: Retrospective study comparing the 10-year postoperative hearing outcomes after primary stapedotomies in patients with small (≤20 dB) and large ABGs (> 20 dB). Ninety out of 175 stapedotomies (22 and 68 in the small and large ABG groups, respectively) were monitored with long-term follow-ups. Results: Ten years after the operation, hearing measurements were similar for both groups, although a significant decline of bone conduction thresholds was evident (p = 0.007 and p < 0.001, respectively). An improvement of ≥10 dB in the postoperative ABG (clinical improvement) was achieved only in the large ABG group. Conclusions: Even though long-term hearing levels will evolve similarly in patients with ≤20 and > 20 dB preoperative ABGs, the lack of clinical improvement found in the small ABG group is not in favor of an early surgery.

Short-Term Audiological Results of Diode Laser in Comparison with Manual Perforation in Stapes Surgery

Introduction  Diode laser is a new alternative in stapes surgery for otosclerosis. The present study is the first to compare the short-term results of the surgery performed using diode laser to those obtained through the conventional fenestration technique. Objective  To use audiometry to establish a comparative analysis between the functional results obtained through surgery for otosclerosis using diode laser and the conventional technique. Method  Audiometric evaluation of 12 patients submitted to stapes surgery for otosclerosis, using diode laser or conventional fenestration by needle and drills, between 2014 and 2015. Each group was composed of 6 patients. Pre and post-operative measures were compared for three months in both groups. The speech recognition threshold, the air and bone conduction threshold, as well as the gap between them at 500 Hz, 1 KHz, 2 KHz and 4 KHz were measured. Results  Significant difference in bone conduction and SRT was observed when compared post- and preoperative results in the diode group. However diode and conventional technique groups presented significant differences in air conduction and air-bone gap, suggesting that both can provide functional improvement. Conclusion  Laser stapedotomy is a safe technique with good results. Both laser surgery and the conventional technique have improved the hearing of patients with a discreet advantage for the diode laser. Further prospective and randomized clinical trials are required to disclose all possible benefits of the stapes surgery using diode laser.

Post Stapedotomy Vestibular Deficit: Is CO2 Laser Better than Conventional Technique? A Non-randomized Controlled Trial

The current standard of care for surgical management of Otosclerosis is small fenestra stapedotomy, which can be done by CO₂ Laser assisted as well as conventional techniques. Vertigo is the commonest complication after stapes surgery. The use of CO₂ Laser has been rising recently owing to its no touch principle, high precision and possibly lower risk of vertigo post operatively. To compare the post-operative vestibular deficit in patients of Otosclerosis having undergone small fenestra stapedotomy by conventional versus CO₂ Laser assisted technique. 80 clinically diagnosed Otosclerosis patients fulfilling the inclusion criteria were enrolled. They underwent small fenestra stapedotomy by either conventional or CO₂ Laser assisted technique. Vestibular function was assessed objectively by measuring sway velocity using modified clinical test of sensory interaction on balance by static posturography. Subjective measurement of balance was done using Vestibular balance subscore of Vertigo Symptom Score (VSS-sf-V). The outcome measures were compared pre-operatively and at first and fourth week post-operatively. All patients had vestibular deficit 1 week post-operatively in the form of increased sway velocity and symptom scores, which reduced by 4 weeks after Stapedotomy. The vestibular deficit in the two groups was similar at 1 week after surgery. 4 weeks after surgery, the sway velocity in conventional group was significantly greater than Laser group though there was no significant difference in the symptom scores. The use of CO₂ Laser for Stapedotomy results in lesser post-operative vestibular deficit as compared to conventional method.

Evaluation of Functional Outcomes after Stapes Surgery in Patients with Clinical Otosclerosis in a Teaching Institution

Introduction Otosclerosis is a primary disease of the temporal bone that leads to stapes ankylosis. Hearing loss is the main symptom. Treatment includes surgery, medical treatment, and sound amplification therapy alone or in combination.

Objective To evaluate the functional outcomes of patients with clinical diagnosis of otosclerosis undergoing primary stapes surgery in a teaching institution.

Method Retrospective descriptive study.

Results A total of 210 ears of 163 patients underwent stapes surgery. Of the 163 patients, 116 (71.2%) underwent unilateral surgery and 47 (28.8%) underwent bilateral surgery. Six of the 210 operated ears had obliterative otosclerosis. The average preoperative and postoperative air–bone gap was 32.06 and 4.39 dB, respectively. The mean preoperative and postoperative bone conduction threshold was 23.17 and 19.82 dB, respectively. A total of 184 (87.6%) ears had a residual air–bone gap <10 dB, and 196 (93.3%) had a residual air–bone gap ≤15 dB. Two patients (0.95%) had severe sensorineural hearing loss.

Conclusion Stapes surgery showed excellent functional hearing outcomes in this study. This surgery may be performed in educational institutions with the supervision of experienced surgeons.

The "One Shot" Diode Laser Stapedotomy

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness and the safety of diode laser stapedotomy, through the functional results analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 179 primary cases of otosclerosis that had been operated on with a diode laser technique from 2004 to 2012 were retrospectively reviewed. Preoperative, 1 month postoperative, and late annual follow-up audiograms (up to 8 years) were obtained in all the cases. Mean preoperative and 1 month postoperative pure-tone average (500-1000-2000-4000 Hz) bone conduction thresholds (PTA-BCs), air conduction (AC) hearing outcomes for 8 kHz and mean postoperative air-bone gap (PTA-ABG) closure were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean preoperative (pre) PTA-BC was 24.22 dB (±8.7 SD) whereas the mean postoperative (post) PTA-BC was 21.11 dB (±9.1 SD). The mean preoperative 8 kHz AC was 56.41 dB (±22.86 SD) and the postoperative 8 kHz AC was 52.56 dB (±24.35 SD). A statistically significant improvement of the PTA-BC post and of the postoperative 8 kHz AC was observed. The 1 month ABG closure within 10 dB in 89.02% of the patients and within 20 dB in 97.69% of the patients was obtained with statistically significant stability over long-term follow-up. No major complications occurred in the series.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of diode laser with high power and short time exposure as setup can be considered a safe, precise, and useful tool in stapes surgery.

Audiometric Results after Stapedotomy Operations in Patients with Otosclerosis and Preoperative Small Air-Bone Gaps

Objectives: The efficacy of stapedotomies performed on patients with small air-bone gaps (<25 dB) was compared with the efficacy of the operation in patients who had otosclerosis with high air-bone gaps (≥25 dB). Methods: This retrospective study evaluates the short-term postoperative air and bone conduction thresholds and air-bone gaps after 182 CO2 laser stapedotomies. Results: A significantly smaller air-bone gap and lower air conduction thresholds after surgery were observed in the group of patients who underwent surgery with preoperative air-bone gaps of less than 25 dB. Bone conduction thresholds improve in the group with small air-bone gaps after surgery. Conclusions: The results after stapedotomies are good even if the preoperative air-bone gap is small and the overall risk of hearing deterioration due to stapes surgery remains low.