The repeatability of tests of eustachian tube function in healthy ears

Eustachian Tube Dysfunction Diagnostic Pathway-What Is the Current State of the Art and How Relevant Is Chronic Nasal Disease?

Background: Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) presents a complex diagnostic challenge in otolaryngology, compounded by its multifaceted nature and overlapping symptoms with chronic nasal disease. This article examines the intricacies of ETD diagnosis, emphasising the necessity for a consensus on diagnostic procedures. Methods: A review of the literature was performed through the OVID research tool in the Pubmed/Medline databases to identify relevant articles that discuss eustachian tube dysfunction diagnostics as well as its correlation with chronic nasal disease. Results: The literature review harvested 201 articles, and only 51 of them were included in the full text review. A consensus statement was identified on eustachian tube dysfunction, function and diagnostics. It appears that there is significant variability in the diagnostic tools used to identify eustachian tube dysfunction. The main diagnostic approaches used are tympanometry, tubomanometry and sonotubometry, combined with the Patient-Reported Outcome Measure ETDQ-7 questionnaire to support the diagnosis of the condition. Nasal pathology is mostly absent from the retrieved studies, while ear pathology is more commonly mentioned in the current literature. Conclusions: There is no gold standard diagnostic tool to determine the presence of eustachian tube dysfunction. Further discussion, large multicentre studies and focused research are required to achieve a consensus on a diagnostic approach. The authors suggest a diagnostic pathway that combines subjective and objective diagnostic tools to determine the presence of eustachian tube dysfunction. This pathway is simple and can be used in district ENT departments, highlighting the nasal pathology relevance to ETD.

Assessment of the Eustachian tube: a review

BACKGROUND

Dysfunction of the Eustachian tube (ET) can lead to negative pressure within the middle ear, which, in turn, causes various pathological changes. Multiple testing methods for ET function have been devised, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Knowing the characteristics of each ET function test and the unique characteristics of ET dysfunction (ETD) in children are prerequisites for choosing the optimal assessment method. For a comprehensive diagnosis, assessment should also include the localisation of any sites of obstruction. This review aims to summarise the methods of evaluating ET function and locating sites of ET lesions.

METHODS

Articles evaluating ET function, localising lesions in the ET, and ETD in children were collected from the PubMed database. We selected only relevant English publications.

RESULTS

ETD in children has different characteristics to those in adults. The appropriate tests for assessing ET function depend on the specific conditions of the individual patient. Valsalva computed tomography can provide information on the soft and bony anatomy of the ET to facilitate identification of lesion sites.

CONCLUSION

An accurate diagnosis should be based on a combined analysis of objective and subjective results, with interpretation made in conjunction with clinical history and physical examination. A comprehensive assessment should include lesion localisation. When assessing ETD in children, it is important to take into account the characteristics of this population.

Place of Tubomanometry in Patulous Eustachian Tube Diagnosis

OBJECTIVE

The aim of our study was to describe the diagnostic performances of tubomanometry (TMM) and to determine tubomanometric parameter thresholds for the diagnosis of patulous eustachian tube (PET).

STUDY DESIGN

We performed a retrospective, monocentric study, including patients treated for PET vs control group.

SETTING

This study was performed at the Otolaryngology Department of a tertiary-care hospital in the south of France.

METHODS

We collected epidemiologic and clinical data, as well as adjusted opening latency index ("R"-index), rhinopharyngeal pressure threshold of tubal opening (Po), and velar contraction index (IVC) on TMM. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were used for determination of R index and Po thresholds.

RESULTS

Twenty-one patients (26 patulous ears) and 14 controls (24 normal ears) were included. The R index values and Po values were significantly lower in the PET group vs controls (0.46 vs 0.80, respectively; P < .05 for R index and 13.89 vs 26.42 mbar, respectively; P < .05 for Po). No significant difference was reported between the 2 groups on IVC measurement (P = .784). After ROC curve analysis, R index was the most discriminating factor to classify PET patients with 89% specificity and 76% sensitivity with a threshold ≤0.6. Po value ≤10 mbar could support this diagnosis with more than 83% specificity.

CONCLUSION

TMM is a reliable noninvasive method for positive diagnosis of PET. TMM could provide an accurate positive PET diagnosis and an objective evaluation for PET management.

Balloon dilation for persistent unilateral chronic obstructive Eustachian tube dysfunction is effective: a prospective multicentre study

PURPOSE

Balloon dilatation of the Eustachian tube (BDET) is an option for treating chronic obstructive Eustachian tube dysfunction (COETD). In this prospective multicentric study, the main objective was to evaluate the results of BDET in unilateral COETD refractory to medical treatment.

METHODS

Adults with unilateral COETD whose Eustachian Tube Score (ETS) was less than 5 despite medical pressure therapy were included. The primary endpoint was the change in ETS measured at 2, 6, and 12 months after BDET. Secondary objectives were the evolution of clinical symptoms assessed by the Eustachian Tube Questionnaire (ETDQ-7), audiometry, tympanometry, and otoscopy changes after BDET.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight patients were included between May 2014 and December 2017 and were treated with BDET without adverse effects in three different referral centers. Population's median age was 52 (Q25; Q75: 24, 82) years. The median follow-up time was 381 (Q25; Q75: 364; 418) days. The median ETS was 2 (Q25; Q75: 1; 4) before BDET. There was a significant improvement in ETS at 2 and 6 months and 1 year after BDET (score at 1 year: 6 (Q25; Q75: 2; 8) (p < 0.0001)). There was a significant, sustained improvement in the ETDQ-7 with a score of 4.21 (Q25; Q75-3.50; 4.79) before BDET and 3.43 (Q25; Q75-2.43; 4.14) (p = 0.0012) at 1 year. There was a suggestive improvement in tympanometry results at 1 year (p = 0.025).

CONCLUSION

BDET provides an improvement in symptoms and objective measures assessed at 1 year in patients with COETD who have failed medical treatment.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

NCT02123277 (April 25, 2014).

[Hyperbaric oxygen therapy : Selected indications in the discipline of otorhinolaryngology]

Hyperbaric oxygenation (HBO) represents the controlled exposure to positive pressure with simultaneous inhalation of pure oxygen. It is considered to be an effective treatment option for diseases with restricted blood flow as oxygen not only binds chemically to hemoglobin but also physically dissolves in blood plasma. With the help of a hyperbaric chamber the ambient pressure of a patient can be modified and the physiological characteristics in positive pressure can be medically used. The indications relevant to otorhinolaryngology are necrotizing otitis externa and skull base osteomyelitis, other forms of osteomyelitis, gangrene, wound healing disorders and sudden loss of hearing. When choosing a treatment, not only the availability and costs of HBO treatment play a role but also the patient's tolerance of overpressure. The risks of treatment, e.g., due to oxygen toxicity or barotrauma of the middle ear or the paranasal sinuses, must be weighed up against the potential benefits.

A Novel Eustachian Tube Test: Preliminary Research of Sonotubometry With Nasopharynx Under Pressure

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to develop a novel Eustachian tube (ET) test consisting of sonotubometry with nasopharynx under pressure to measure opening of the ET. We assessed the advantages of this novel approach compared with those of sonotubometry only or tubomanometry only and explored the possibility of quantifying ET patency.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a prospective clinical study at a tertiary referral center.

METHODS

Sonotubometry, tubomanometry, and sonotubometry with nasopharynx under pressure were performed on a total of 106 ears. The ET-opening detection rates of the different test methods were compared with McNemar's test or Fisher's exact test. The correlation between the ET-opening latency index (R value) and nasopharyngeal pressure, as well as the correlation between the sound pressure of the external ear canal and the nasopharyngeal pressure, was assessed via Spearman's correlation coefficients.

RESULTS

ET openings were detected most frequently during sonotubometry with nasopharynx under pressure, with opening rates of 93.40, 98.10, and 98.10% at 30, 40, and 50 mbar, respectively, which were significantly higher than those of sonotubometry (80.20%) and tubomanometry (74.50, 86.80, and 90.60% at 30, 40, and 50 mbar, respectively). Both R values and sound pressures were significantly different at pressures of 30, 40, and 50 mbar; the R value decreased with the increase of nasopharyngeal pressure (r = -0.298, p  = 0.000), while the sound pressure increased with nasopharyngeal pressure (r = 0.251, p  = 0.000).

CONCLUSIONS

Sonotubometry with nasopharynx under pressure represents a novel hybrid ET test that our findings suggest is superior to sonotubometry only and tubomanometry only in detecting ET openings in healthy ears. Sound pressure resulting from sonotubometry with nasopharynx under pressure may be useful for quantifying the degree of openness of the ET. However, further validation in both healthy subjects and patients with ET dysfunction is required before this novel ET test may be recommended for clinical use.

Tubomanometry correlations with patient characteristics and other diagnostic tests of Eustachian tube dysfunction: a cohort study of 432 ears

Objectives

Currently, there is no consensus regarding the best protocol for diagnosing Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD). We aimed to evaluate how patient characteristics affect tubomanometry (TMM) results. If an association between patient characteristics and TMM results exists, this should be considered in TMM interpretation. We also wanted to study if TMM correlates with other diagnostic tools of ETD.

Methods

A retrospective chart review was conducted on all patients with TMM results available from November 2011 to October 2020 at a tertiary referral center, including 432 ears from 219 patients. An association between diagnostic tests and patient characteristics was assessed using regression models. Spearman’s rank correlation was used to analyze correlations between diagnostic tests.

Results

None of the studied patient characteristics (age, gender, body mass index, smoking, sinonasal disease) was associated with TMM results except for pollen allergy (OR 1.74, 95% CI 1.15–2.63, P = 0.009). TMM results correlated with Valsalva maneuver performance (P < 0.001, ρ = 0.31) and otomicroscopic signs of inadequate middle ear ventilation (P < 0.001, ρ = 0.28). The Eustachian tube dysfunction questionnaire-7 (ETDQ-7) score did not correlate with any diagnostic method.

Conclusions

TMM results are unaffected by patient characteristics other than pollen allergy. Thus, TMM may be used in ETD diagnostics in a wide variety of patients with straightforward interpretation. TMM correlates with other diagnostic tests studied but not with ETDQ-7. ETDQ-7 does not seem to correlate with other diagnostic tests and appears nonspecific in ETD diagnostics.

Tubomanometry Measurement Success Rate in Clinical Practice

OBJECTIVES

Tubomanometry (TMM) is an objective method for investigating Eustachian tube (ET) function, but difficulties in technique and interpretation may reduce its usability. The objective of our study was to investigate common difficulties with TMM in different ET dysfunction (ETD) patient groups and at different pressures (30, 40, and 50 mbars) when first introducing TMM to otologic practice. Furthermore, we wanted to investigate whether it would be possible to perform TMM at only one pressure and obtain a representative result.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review of a 2-year cohort of 114 patients with a history of ETD treated at a tertiary referral center. Primary outcome was the success rate of TMM, secondary the reasons for unsuccessful measurements. Tertiary outcome was the correlation of TMM results at adjacent pressures.

RESULTS

TMM success rate was 91%, varying 81 to 94% in different ETD patient groups and 87 to 94% at different pressures. Unsuccessful measurements resulted from air-leaks from the external ear canal, abnormal ear canal pressure curves (R < 0) and at 50 mbar, difficulties in reaching sufficient nasopharyngeal pressure. TMM results were similar in 88% of cases at 30 and 40 mbars and in 86% of cases at 40 and 50 mbars.

CONCLUSIONS

TMM success rate seems sufficiently high for clinical diagnostics, and most difficulties may be overcome with proper interpretation during the TMM measurement session, and thus repeating the measurements when necessary. Considering the diagnostic information that would be lost if using only a single, predefined pressure, we suggest using all three pressures.

Investigations on the potential of optical coherence tomography as an imaging tool for eustachian tube

The purpose of this study was to explore the feasibility of eustachian tube optical coherence tomography (ET-OCT) for imaging the pharyngeal region of the eustachian tube (ET). Ten subjects with ear complaints underwent ET-OCT guided by nasal endoscopy, and ET-OCT examination was performed on both sides of each subject's ETs. The process and resulting images were analysed. Ten subjects ranging from 21 to 73 years old (45 ± 14.77) were enrolled in this study. Eighteen ET-OCT imaging examinations were completed. The mean duration of each examination was 2.80 ± 1.62 min (ranging from 2 to 7 min). There were no adverse events or complications. In some subjects, the ET-OCT images clearly presented the microstructures of the ET wall, including the lumen, mucosa, submucosa, cartilage and plica. However, in some subjects, it showed different characteristics, such as an unclear hierarchy and secretions in the lumen. ET-OCT may help to distinguish the structural composition of the ET and elucidate related pathophysiological mechanisms. It is a valuable imaging tool suited for the ET, with potential diagnostic value in determining the morphology of the lumen, intraluminal mucosa and submucosal tissue in the pharyngeal region of the ET.

The usefulness of Valsalva computed tomography as an assessment tool for the Eustachian tube

PURPOSE

To determine the usefulness of 'computed tomography (CT) with Valsalva maneuver (VM)' (Valsalva CT) for localizing lesions of the eustachian tube (ET) and identifying characteristics of ET dysfunction (ETD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this case-control study, 12, 17, and 25 patients with obstructive ETD (OETD), patulous eustachian tube (PET), and conductive hearing loss (control), respectively, underwent Valsalva CT in the supine position. The visualized length to total length ratio of the cartilaginous ET (VTRET) with and without VM were compared in the three groups. In the OETD group, obstructed areas of the ET were identified on multiplanar reconstructed images.

RESULTS

VTRET without VM in the PET group was significantly higher than that in the control and OETD groups (p-values, 0.003 and 0.007, respectively). However, there was no significant difference between the control and OETD groups (p = 0.053). VTRET with VM in the PET group was significantly higher than that in the other two groups (p < 0.001), whereas that in the control group was significantly higher than that in the OETD group (p < 0.001). In the OETD group, the obstructed area was clearly identified, and there were one, one, six, and eight patients in the isthmus; bony portion and isthmus; bony portion, isthmus, and cartilaginous portion; and isthmus and cartilaginous portion subgroups, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Valsalva CT is particularly valuable as a visualization assessment tool for identifying obstructed areas in the OETD. It may help future research of disease-specific mechanical characteristics of the ET on controlling pressure variables.

Eustachian Tube Function in Patients with Symptoms on Baro-Challenge

OBJECTIVES

To explore the relationship between aural symptoms during baro-challenge and the underlying measured Eustachian tube (ET) function. Two key questions were addressed. (1) In patients who have features of obstructive ET dysfunction, is there a measurable underlying difference in ET function between those who experience severe symptoms on baro-challenge and those that do not? (2) What is the diagnostic value of ET function tests in the identification of patients with severe symptoms on baro-challenge?

METHODS

Patients with symptoms of obstructive ET dysfunction were recruited, with the presence of aural symptoms on baro-challenge established via the clinical history and analysis of the Cambridge ET Dysfunction Assessment, a patient-reported outcome measure (PROM). ET function tests were assessed in each patient: 9 objective and semi-objective measures of ET opening, and 2 symptom-based PROMs. The tests' results were grouped by type of ET opening assessed, generating passive and active dysfunction scores. Individual test results were assessed for diagnostic accuracy in reference to features in the history or PROM-based evidence of symptoms on baro-challenge.

RESULTS

Both passive and active opening of the ET was significantly reduced in ears with a history of pain on baro-challenge. Some patients had apparent severe obstructive ET dysfunction without symptoms on baro-challenge, whilst others had symptoms but normal test results. No individual test of ET opening was of diagnostic value in predicting those ears likely to experience pain or exacerbated symptoms on baro-challenge.

CONCLUSION

The relationship between aural pain during baro-challenge and ET function appears more complex than had been assumed, with pain possibly related to factors other than just ET function.

Comparison of sonotubometry, impedance, tubo-tympano-aerography, and tubomanometry to test eustachian tube function

PURPOSE

There is currently no gold standard for the diagnosis of eustachian tube (ET) dysfunction. To provide an objective basis for the clinical diagnosis of ET dysfunction, we explored the characteristics of sonotubometry, impedance, tubo-tympano-aerography (TTAG), and tubomanometry (TMM) in volunteers with healthy ETs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sonotubometry, impedance, TTAG, and TMM tests were performed in 110 healthy ears of 55 volunteers, and the characteristics of each ET test were compared and discussed.

RESULTS

The ET opening rate was compared between sonotubometry with dry swallowing, impedance with the Valsalva maneuver, TTAG with the Valsalva maneuver, and TMM with a nasopharyngeal pressure of 50 mbar in 100 (90.9%), 102 (92.7%), 99 (90.0%), and 104 (94.5%) ears, respectively; there was no significant difference among the four methods (P = 0.575). In sonotubometry, both dry swallowing and the Valsalva maneuver were superior to wet swallowing in terms of detecting ET opening (P = 0.000). In TMM, both the opening rate and the external auditory canal pressure were positively correlated with the nasopharyngeal pressure. Specifically, the opening rate and external auditory canal pressure increased with an increase in the nasopharyngeal pressure (r = 0.271, P = 0.000; r = 0.315, P = 0.000, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Sonotubometry, impedance, TTAG, and TMM have their own advantages and disadvantages. In clinical practice, the appropriate ET function test should be chosen on the basis of the patient's specific condition.

The effect of topical xylometazoline on Eustachian tube function

BACKGROUND

Topical nasal decongestants are frequently used as part of the medical management of symptoms related to Eustachian tube dysfunction.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to assess the effect of topical xylometazoline hydrochloride sprayed in the anterior part of the nose on Eustachian tube active and passive opening in healthy ears.

METHODS

Active and passive Eustachian tube function was assessed in healthy subjects before and after intranasal administration of xylometazoline spray, using tympanometry, video otoscopy, sonotubometry, tubo-tympano-aerodynamic-graphy and tubomanometry.

RESULTS

Resting middle-ear pressures were not significantly different following decongestant application. Eustachian tube opening rate was not significantly different following the intervention, as measured by all function tests used. Sonotubometry data showed a significant increase in the duration of Eustachian tube opening following decongestant application.

CONCLUSION

There remains little or no evidence that topical nasal decongestants improve Eustachian tube function. Sonotubometry findings do suggest that further investigation with an obstructive Eustachian tube dysfunction patient cohort is warranted.

Balloon Eustachian Tuboplasty: Systematic Review of Long-term Outcomes and Proposed Indications

Balloon Eustachian tuboplasty (BET) aims to improve the function of the Eustachian tube (ET). The objective of this study was to review the long-term outcome of BET and present the process and results of outlining indications for BET by the Finnish Otosurgical Society. The literature review is based on a database search performed in May 2017. The search resulted in 100 individual articles, which were screened for relevance. Five articles fulfilled the inclusion criteria (follow-up ≥12 months). Five additional articles (follow-up, 6-11 months) were analyzed to obtain supportive information. The proposed BET indications were constituted in the 2016 annual meeting of the Finnish Otosurgical Society. The workshop included a review of the Eustachian tube physiology, middle ear aeration mechanisms, and BET outcome studies. Thereafter, the members of the Society first voted and then discussed 14 cases in order to conclude whether BET was indicated in each case, and subsequently, a consensus statement on the indications for BET was outlined. The long-term follow-up studies were heterogeneous regarding the Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) definition, patient selection, follow-up duration, additional treatments, and outcome measures. The current, but limited, evidence suggests that BET is effective in the long-term. However, more long-term studies with uniform criteria and outcome measures as well as placebo-controlled studies are needed. The proposed indications for BET by the Finnish Otosurgical Society include chronic bothersome symptoms referring to ETD, ETD-related symptoms when pressure changes rapidly, or recurring serous otitis media. With the current evidence, we suggest treating only adults with BET.

Outcome Measures for Baro-Challenge-Induced Eustachian Tube Dysfunction: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVES

Baro-challenge-induced Eustachian tube dysfunction (baro-induced ETD) is characterized by failure of the Eustachian tube (ET) to open adequately to permit middle-ear pressure regulation during ambient pressure changes. There are no well-characterized tests for identifying the condition, which makes both patient diagnosis and research into treatment efficacy challenging. This systematic review evaluates ET function tests as potential outcome measures for baro-induced ETD.

DATA SOURCES

MEDLINE and CENTRAL were searched (database inception to March 2017) and reference lists reviewed for all relevant English Language articles.

STUDY SELECTION

Tests in included studies were required to measure ET function in patients reporting baro-induced ear symptoms or barotrauma.

DATA EXTRACTION

Data were extracted in a standardized manner, and studies assessed according to Standards for Reporting of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (STARD) criteria. The primary outcome of interest was the accuracy of ET function tests.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Heterogeneity of subject demographics, ET function test methodology, and reference standards only permitted narrative systematic review.

CONCLUSION

Sixteen studies involving seven different types of ET function tests were identified. The nine-step test was the most commonly used outcome measure, with overall test sensitivity and specificity ranges of 37 to 100% and 57 to 100%, respectively. Tympanometry test sensitivity was consistently poor (0-50%) while specificity was higher (52-97%). Published accuracy data for other ET function tests and test combinations were limited. Currently, no single test can be recommended for use in clinical practice. A combination of the nine-step test with other objective tests or patient-reported measures appears most promising as a core set of outcome measures for baro-induced ETD.

Eustachian tube dysfunction: A diagnostic accuracy study and proposed diagnostic pathway

Background and aims

Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) is a commonly diagnosed disorder of Eustachian tube opening and closure, which may be associated with severe symptoms and middle ear disease. Currently the diagnosis of obstructive and patulous forms of ETD is primarily based on non-specific symptoms or examination findings, rather than measurement of the underlying function of the Eustachian tube. This has proved problematic when selecting patients for treatment, and when designing trial inclusion criteria and outcomes. This study aims to determine the correlation and diagnostic value of various tests of ET opening and patient reported outcome measures (PROMs), in order to generate a recommended diagnostic pathway for ETD.

Methods

Index tests included two PROMs and 14 tests of ET opening (nine for obstructive, five for patulous ETD). In the absence of an accepted reference standard two methods were adopted to establish index test accuracy: expert panel diagnosis and latent class analysis. Index test results were assessed with Pearson correlation and principle component analysis, and test accuracy was determined. Logistic regression models assessed the predictive value of grouped test results.

Results

The expert panel diagnosis and PROMs results correlated with each other, but not with ET function measured by tests of ET opening. All index tests were found to be feasible in clinic, and acceptable to patients. PROMs had very poor specificity, and no diagnostic value. Combining the results of tests of ET function appeared beneficial. The latent class model suggested tympanometry, sonotubometry and tubomanometry have the best diagnostic performance for obstructive ETD, and these are included in a proposed diagnostic pathway.

Conclusions

ETD should be diagnosed on the basis of clinical assessment and tests of ET opening, as PROMs have no diagnostic value. Currently diagnostic uncertainty exists for some patients who appear to have intermittent ETD clinically, but have negative index test results.