Early Ataxia and Subsequent Parkinsonism: PLA2G6 Mutations Cause a Continuum Rather Than Three Discrete Phenotypes

Dystonia and Parkinson's disease: Do they have a shared biology?

Parkinsonism and dystonia co-occur across many movement disorders and are most encountered in the setting of Parkinson's disease. Here we aim to explore the shared neurobiological underpinnings of dystonia and parkinsonism through the clinical lens of the conditions in which these movement disorders can be seen together. Foregrounding the discussion, we briefly review the circuits of the motor system and the neuroanatomical and neurophysiological aspects of motor control and highlight their relevance to the proposed pathophysiology of parkinsonism and dystonia. Insight into shared biology is then sought from dystonia occurring in PD and other forms of parkinsonism including those disorders in which both can be co-expressed simultaneously. We organize these within a biological schema along with important questions to be addressed in this space.

Serum metabolomic characterization of PLA2G6-associated dystonia-parkinsonism: A case-control biomarker study

Introduction

Phospholipase A2 Group VI (PLA2G6), encoding calcium-independent phospholipase A₂, has been isolated as the gene responsible for an autosomal recessive form of early-onset Parkinson's disease (namely, PARK14). Compared to idiopathic Parkinson's disease (iPD), PARK14 has several atypical clinical features. PARK14 has an earlier age at onset and is more likely to develop levodopa-induced dyskinesia. In iPD, serum metabolomics has observed alterations in several metabolic pathways that are related to disease status and clinical manifestations. This study aims to describe the serum metabolomics features of patients with PARK14.

Design

This case-control biomarker study tested nine patients diagnosed with PARK14. Eight age and sex-matched healthy subjects were recruited as controls. To evaluate the influence of single heterozygous mutation, we enrolled eight healthy one-degree family members of patients with PARK14, two patients diagnosed with early-onset Parkinson's disease (EOPD) who had only a single heterozygous PLA2G6 mutation, and one patient with EOPD without any known pathogenic mutation.

Methods

The diagnosis of PARK14 was made according to the diagnostic criteria for Parkinson's disease (PD) and confirmed by genetic testing. To study the serum metabolic features, we analyzed participants' serum using UHPLC-QTOF/MS analysis, a well-established technology.

Results

We quantified 50 compounds of metabolites from the serum of all the study subjects. Metabolites alterations in serum had good predictive accuracy for PARK14 diagnosis (AUC 0.903) and advanced stage in PARK14 (AUC 0.944). Of the 24 metabolites that changed significantly in patients' serum, eight related to lipid metabolism. Oleic acid and xanthine were associated with MMSE scores. Xanthine, L-histidine, and phenol correlated with UPDRS-III scores. Oleic acid and 1-oleoyl-L-alpha-lysophosphatidic acid could also predict the subclass of the more advanced stage in the PLA2G6 Group in ROC models.

Conclusion

The significantly altered metabolites can be used to differentiate PLA2G6 pathogenic mutations and predict disease severity. Patients with PLA2G6 mutations had elevated lipid compounds in C18:1 and C16:0 groups. The alteration of lipid metabolism might be the key intermediate process in PLA2G6-related disease that needs further investigation.

Novel PLA2G6 Pathogenic Variants in Chinese Patients With PLA2G6-Associated Neurodegeneration

Background

PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration (PLAN) is a heterogeneous group of neurodegenerative diseases caused by biallelic PLA2G6 mutations, covering diseases such as infantile neuroaxonal dystrophy (INAD), atypical neuroaxonal dystrophy (ANAD), dystonia parkinsonism (DP), and autosomal recessive early-onset parkinsonism (AREP). The study aims to report the clinical and genetic features of a series of PLAN patients.

Methods

The clinical and radiological findings of five Chinese patients from three families were collected. Whole-exome next generation sequencing (NGS) was applied to identify the genetic causes. Co-segregation analysis of the detected candidate variants were performed in their families. The pathogenicity of identified novel variants was predicted by in silico analysis.

Results

NGS revealed compound heterozygous variants of PLA2G6 gene in all five patients. There were six PLA2G6 variants identified, including two known variants (c.116G>A, c.238G>A) and four novel variants (c.2120dupA, c.2071C>G, c.967G>A, c1534T>A). ACMG predicts c.2120dupA to be pathogenic, c.2071C>G and c.1534T>A to be likely pathogenic, and c1534T>A to be of uncertain significance. Clinically, four patients fell into the diagnosis of ANAD, and 1 into the diagnosis of AREP. Brain imaging revealed cerebellar atrophy, iron deposition in bilateral globus pallidus, and substantia nigra in three cases.

Conclusions

Four novel pathogenic variants were discovered and the pathogenic variant spectrum of the PLA2G6 gene was expanded.

Dissecting the Phenotype and Genotype of PLA2G6-Related Parkinsonism

BACKGROUND

Complex parkinsonism is the commonest phenotype in late-onset PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to deeply characterize phenogenotypically PLA2G6-related parkinsonism in the largest cohort ever reported.

METHODS

We report 14 new cases of PLA2G6-related parkinsonism and perform a systematic literature review.

RESULTS

PLA2G6-related parkinsonism shows a fairly distinct phenotype based on 86 cases from 68 pedigrees. Young onset (median age, 23.0 years) with parkinsonism/dystonia, gait/balance, and/or psychiatric/cognitive symptoms were common presenting features. Dystonia occurred in 69.4%, pyramidal signs in 77.2%, myoclonus in 65.2%, and cerebellar signs in 44.6% of cases. Early bladder overactivity was present in 71.9% of cases. Cognitive impairment affected 76.1% of cases and psychiatric features 87.1%, the latter being an isolated presenting feature in 20.1%. Parkinsonism was levodopa responsive but complicated by early, often severe dyskinesias. Five patients benefited from deep brain stimulation. Brain magnetic resonance imaging findings included cerebral (49.3%) and/or cerebellar (43.2%) atrophy, but mineralization was evident in only 28.1%. Presynaptic dopaminergic terminal imaging was abnormal in all where performed. Fifty-four PLA2G6 mutations have hitherto been associated with parkinsonism, including four new variants reported in this article. These are mainly nontruncating, which may explain the phenotypic heterogeneity of childhood- and late-onset PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration. In five deceased patients, median disease duration was 13.0 years. Brain pathology in three cases showed mixed Lewy and tau pathology.

CONCLUSIONS

Biallelic PLA2G6 mutations cause early-onset parkinsonism associated with dystonia, pyramidal and cerebellar signs, myoclonus, and cognitive impairment. Early psychiatric manifestations and bladder overactivity are common. Cerebro/cerebellar atrophy are frequent magnetic resonance imaging features, whereas brain iron deposition is not. Early, severe dyskinesias are a tell-tale sign. © 2021 The Authors. Movement Disorders published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Parkinsonism and ataxia

Ataxia is not a common feature in Parkinson's disease. Nevertheless, some rare forms of parkinsonism have ataxia as one of the main features in their clinical picture, especially those with juvenile or early-onset. On the other side, in cerebellar degenerative diseases, parkinsonism might accompany the typical symptoms and even become predominant in some cases. Many disorders involving different neurological systems present with a movement phenomenology reflecting the underlying pattern of pathological involvement, such as neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation, neurodegeneration associated with calcium deposition, and metabolic and mitochondrial disorders. The prototype of sporadic disorders that present with a constellation of symptoms due to the involvement of multiple Central Nervous System regions is multiple system atrophy, whose motor symptoms at onset can be cerebellar ataxia or parkinsonism. Clinical syndromes encompassing both parkinsonian and cerebellar features might represent a diagnostic challenge for neurologists. Recognizing acquired and potentially treatable causes responsible for complex movement disorders is of paramount importance, since an early diagnosis is essential to prevent permanent consequences. The present review aims to provide a pragmatic overview of the most common diseases characterized by the coexistence of cerebellar and parkinsonism features and suggests a possible diagnostic approach for both inherited and sporadic disorders. This article is part of the Special Issue "Parkinsonism across the spectrum of movement disorders and beyond" edited by Joseph Jankovic, Daniel D. Truong and Matteo Bologna.

Novel deep intronic mutation in PLA2G6 causing early-onset Parkinson's disease with brain iron accumulation through pseudo-exon activation

PLA2G6 is the causative gene for a group of autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorders known as PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration (PLAN). We present a case with early-onset parkinsonism, ataxia, cognitive decline, cerebellar atrophy, and brain iron accumulation. Sequencing of PLA2G6 coding regions identified only a heterozygous nonsense variant, but mRNA analysis revealed the presence of an aberrant transcript isoform due to a novel deep intronic variant (c.2035-274G > A) leading to activation of an intronic pseudo-exon. These results expand the genotypic spectrum of PLAN, showing the paramount importance of detecting possible pathogenic variants in deep intronic regions in undiagnosed patients.

PLA2G6 variants associated with the number of affected alleles in Parkinson's disease in Japan

This study aimed to evaluate genotype-phenotype correlations of Parkinson's disease (PD) patients with phospholipase A2 group V (PLA2G6) variants. We analyzed the DNA of 798 patients with PD, including 78 PD patients reported previously, and 336 in-house controls. We screened the exons and exon-intron boundaries of PLA2G6 using the Ion Torrent system and Sanger method. We identified 21 patients with 18 rare variants, such that 1, 9, and 11 patients were homozygous, heterozygous, and compound heterozygous, respectively, with respect to PLA2G6 variants. The allele frequency was approximately equal between patients with familial PD and those with sporadic PD. The PLA2G6 variants detected frequently were identified in the early-onset sporadic PD group. Patients who were homozygous for a variant showed more severe symptoms than those who were heterozygous for the variant. The most common variant was p.R635Q in our cohort, which was considered a risk variant for PD. Thus, the variants of PLA2G6 may play a role in familial PD and early-onset sporadic PD.

Genotype-phenotype correlations of adult-onset PLA2G6-associated Neurodegeneration: case series and literature review

Background

Phospholipase A2 group VI (PLA2G6) mutations associated with neurodegeneration (PLAN) manifest as heterogeneous neurodegenerative disorders with variable ages of onset. The genotype-phenotype correlation is not well-established. We aim to describe three adult patients with PLAN and combined these data with results from previous studies to elucidate adult-onset PLA2G6 phenotype-genotype correlations.

Case presentations

The first index patient presented with dystonia-parkinsonism starting at age 31 years, accompanied by major depression and cognitive decline. Genetic analysis using targeted next generation sequencing (NGS) panel, Sanger sequencing, and segregation analyses revealed a compound heterozygous mutation, c.991G > T (p.D331Y)/c.1077G > A (M358IfsX), in PLA2G6. The other two patients had levodopa-responsive, early-onset parkinsonism, starting in their late twenties. Both patients had homozygous c.991G > T (p.D331Y) mutations in PLA2G6. Patient characteristics of our reported 3 cases were compared to those of 32 previously described (2008 to 2019) patients with adult-onset PLAN. Among the combined cohort of 35 patients with adult-onset PLAN, 14 had dystonia-parkinsonism, 17 had early-onset Parkinson’s disease, 3 had hereditary spastic paraparesis, and one had ataxia. The c.991G > T (p. D331Y) mutation was almost exclusively found in Chinese patients, suggesting a common founder effect. All patients with homozygous p.D331Y mutations had levodopa-responsive, early-onset PD (100%); while other mutations mostly led to dystonia-parkinsonism, ataxia, spasticity, and combine psychiatric comorbidities.

Conclusions

We showed that adult-onset PLAN could present as purely parkinsonism features, without brain iron accumulation, particularly patients with homozygous p.D331Y mutations. Compound heterozygous mutations, including heterozygous p.D331Y, produced heterogeneous phenotypes, without obvious levodopa responsiveness.

Parkinsonism in diseases predominantly presenting with dystonia

If the presence of dystonia is a well-recognized phenomenon in disorders predominantly presenting with parkinsonism, including sporadic Parkinson Disease, the term dystonia-parkinsonism usually refers to rare conditions, often genetic, in which the severity of dystonia usually equates that of parkinsonism. At variance with parkinsonian syndromes with additional dystonia, the conditions reviewed in this chapter have usually their onset in childhood and their diagnostic work-up is different. In fact, the phenotype is not usually specific of the underlying defect and additional investigations are therefore required. Here, we review the diseases predominantly presenting with dystonia where parkinsonism can develop, according to their main pathophysiological mechanism including disorders of dopamine biosynthesis, neurotransmitter transporter disorders, disorder of metal metabolism (i.e., iron, copper and manganese) and other inherited dystonia-parkinsonism conditions.

Early-Onset Parkinson's Disease Caused by PLA2G6 Compound Heterozygous Mutation, a Case Report and Literature Review

PLA2G6 has been certified as a causative gene in patients with autosomal recessive early-onset Parkinson's disease (EOPD). We reported an EOPD case caused by PLA2G6 gene mutation, and performed neurological examination, genetic analysis, and multimodal neuroimaging to describe this phenotype. A compound heterozygous mutation c.991G>T/c.1472+1G>A was detected in this patient. Heterozygous for the c.991G>T and c.1472+1G>A were separately detected in his parents. Pathogenicity of these two mutations were predicted according to the American college of medical genetics and genomics (ACMG) guideline. MRI assessment showed absence of bilateral “swallow tail sign” and cerebellar atrophy in this patient, while no obvious difference in brain iron accumulation between PLA2G6 mutant PD patient and healthy controls. Cerebellar abnormalities may be a marker for diagnosis and evaluation of PLA2G6 mutation Parkinsonism. However, the iron accumulation in PD may not be the result of PLA2G6 mutation.

Neurodegeneration with Brain Iron Accumulation

The term NBIA encompasses a heterogeneous group of inherited disorders characterized clinically by progressive extra pyramidal syndrome and pathologically by excessive iron deposition in brain, primarily affecting the basal ganglia (globus pallidus mainly). The hallmark of this syndrome is the age specific phenotypic presentation and intraphenotypic heterogeneity. NBIAs at present include ten subtypes with genes identified in nine subtypes. They form an important differential diagnosis for the phenotype of global developmental delay in infancy/childhood to dystonia-parkinsonism or isolated parkinsonism at all ages and also for the isolated craniocervical dystonia of adult onset. There needs to be a high index of clinical suspicion for this syndrome and the evaluation includes MRI brain T2* weighted imaging which reveal symmetrical iron deposition in bilateral globus pallidi and other basal ganglia. The T2 * imaging pattern of iron deposition varies amongst the different subtypes and the combination of clinical phenotype and MRI signature makes it easier to confidently make a diagnosis of NBIA and to recommend genetic testing. The treatment to date is mostly symptomatic with targeted therapies on the horizon.

Genetic Dystonia-ataxia Syndromes: Clinical Spectrum, Diagnostic Approach, and Treatment Options

BACKGROUND

Dystonia and ataxia are manifestations of numerous disorders, and indeed, an ever-expanding spectrum of genes causing diseases that encompass dystonia and ataxia are discovered with the advances of genetic techniques. In recent years, a pathophysiological link between both clinical features and the role of the cerebellum in the genesis of dystonia, in some cases, has been proposed. In clinical practice, the genetic diagnosis of dystonia-ataxia syndromes is a major issue for genetic counseling, prognosis and, occasionally, specific treatment.

METHODS

For this pragmatic and educational review, we conducted a comprehensive and structured literature search in Pubmed, OMIM, and GeneReviews using the key words "dystonia" and "ataxia" to identify those genetic diseases that may combine dystonia with ataxia.

RESULTS

There are a plethora of genetic diseases causing dystonia and ataxia. We propose a series of clinico-radiological algorithms to guide their differential diagnosis depending on the age of onset, additional neurological or systemic features, and imaging findings. We suggest a sequential diagnostic approach to dystonia-ataxia syndromes. We briefly highlight the pathophysiological links between dystonia and ataxia and conclude with a review of specific treatment implications.

CONCLUSIONS

The clinical approach presented in this review is intended to improve the diagnostic success of clinicians when faced with patients with dystonia-ataxia syndromes.