A case of tardive tremor successfully treated with clozapine

A systematic review on the use of clozapine in treatment of tardive dyskinesia and tardive dystonia in patients with psychiatric disorders

RATIONALE

Though clozapine is recommended for treatment of tardive dyskinesia (TD) relating to the use of antipsychotic medications, studies comprehensively investigating the treatment effect of clozapine on TD are still limited.

OBJECTIVES

This review examines the effectiveness of clozapine as an intervention for tardive dyskinesia and dystonia in patients with all psychiatric conditions. Effectiveness of clozapine, duration to exert the effect and dosage used were also analysed.

METHODS

A search in the PubMed, PsycINFO and clinicaltrials databases was performed, using the search terms "Clozapine" AND "dyskinesia" OR "dystonia". Full-text articles that reported the use of clozapine to treat abnormal involuntary movements and were written in English were included.

RESULTS

A total of 48 studies were identified, of which 13 were clinical trials and 35 were case reports. Significant improvement was seen in 86.7% of patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders (average dose of clozapine = 355 mg/day) and 93% of patients with other psychiatric disorders (average dose of clozapine = 152.5 mg/day). Patients with other psychiatric diagnoses had faster improvement than the patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders. Variation in improvements and dosage were also seen in the clinical trials.

CONCLUSION

Results suggested an overall effectiveness of clozapine in the treatment of TD for patients with a range of psychiatric conditions. Different response time and clozapine dosage were seen in patients with different psychiatric conditions, suggesting different treatment protocols are required for different conditions. Most of the studies identified are of inadequate qualities, highlighting the need for high quality studies to provide clearer evidence.

Management of tardive syndromes with clozapine: a case series

Tardive syndromes are among the most debilitating side effects associated with use of antipsychotics. In this case series we present 5 cases of drug induced tardive syndromes, who had not responded to many of the other therapeutic measures but responded to clozapine. The response rate with clozapine varied from 50% to 100% and the response was seen by week 3 in most cases. Over the long term follow-up of as long as 6 years the response to clozapine was sustained. In two cases clozapine could be stopped.

Clozapine and tardive movement disorders: a review

BACKGROUND

Tardive syndromes (TS) arise from long term exposure to dopamine receptor blocking agents. Clozapine has been considered to have low risk of causing new onset TS and is considered as a treatment option in patients with TS.

AIM

This review evaluates the usefulness of clozapine in patients with TS and occasional reports of clozapine causing TS.

METHODOLOGY

Electronic searches were carried out using the search engines of PUBMED, Science direct and Google Scholar databases. All reports describing use of clozapine in management of TS, monitoring of TS while on clozapine and onset of TS after initiation of clozapine were identified.

RESULTS

Fifteen trials and 28 case series/case reports describe the use of clozapine in TS. Most of these reports show that clozapine is useful in patients with TS, in the dose range of 200-300 mg/day and the beneficial effect is seen within 4-12 weeks of initiation. One case series and two case reports described clozapine withdrawal emergent dyskinesias suggesting a masking role of clozapine. One trial, three case series and two case reports describe beneficial effects of clozapine on long standing neurological syndromes. There is relatively less literature (2 trials and 15 case series/reports) describing the emergence of TS with clozapine.

CONCLUSION

Evidence of beneficial effects of clozapine in TS is greater than its role in causation/worsening of TS. Hence, clozapine should be considered in symptomatic patients who develop TS while receiving other antipsychotics. Further research on mechanism of TS and clozapine effect on TS is required.

Sensory trick with metoclopramide-associated tardive tremor

Tardive tremor is a 3-5 Hz bilateral resting and action tremor, associated with the use of dopamine receptor blocking drugs, accompanied by other tardive movement disorders and responsive to tetrabenazine or clozapine. We describe a case of a sensory trick associated with tardive tremor which raises important points about semiology and management. First, the presence of a sensory trick with tardive limb tremor suggests that the disorder may be a form of dystonia. Second, further study of osteopathic manipulative therapy for treatment of dystonia or tardive tremor is supported by a symptomatic response observed in our case.

Olanzapine versus propranolol in essential tremor

PURPOSE

In this study, we evaluated the anti-tremor effect of olanzapine in patients with essential tremor (ET).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Thirty-eight patients with ET affecting upper limbs underwent a randomized, crossover study with olanzapine (20 mg/day) and propranolol (120 mg/day). Evaluation (baseline and 1 month after each drug) was done by using the tremor clinical rating scale and a self-reported disability scale.

RESULTS

We did not find statistical difference in all tremor parameters before treatment in two groups. Both drugs improved essential tremor parameters. However, olanzapine significantly improved all tremor parameters except hygiene as compared to propronalol.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that olanzapine might be efficacious for essential tremor. Further clinical trials are indicated to establish the efficacy of olanzapine in patients with ET.

Tardive tremor due to metoclopramide

Tardive tremor is a very uncommon neuroleptic-induced tardive syndrome which was initially described in five patients by Stacy and Jankovic (Stacy and Jankovic, Mov Disord 1992;7:53-57). Since then, there have been only three additional case reports attesting to the apparent rarity of this condition, although it is unknown whether other unreported cases have been observed. We describe a patient with persistent tardive tremor that was associated with tardive dyskinesia, who closely resembles previously reported cases.

Acute and chronic effects of clozapine in essential tremor

Patients with essential tremor (ET) may not respond to commonly used drugs. Clozapine, an atypical neuroleptic drug, has been reported to improve postural Parkinson's disease tremor clinically resembling ET. The effects of a single dose of 12.5 mg clozapine and placebo were evaluated in a randomized, double-blind, crossover study in 15 drug-resistant patients with ET. Patient responders with more than 50% improvement after a single dose of clozapine subsequently received the drug (39+/-9 mg up to 50 mg) unblinded for a period of 15.8+/-7.7 months. Tremor was effectively reduced by a single dose of clozapine in 13 of 15 patients (p <0.01). Sedation was the only side effect reported during the clozapine test; however, the time course of sedation and of the antitremor effect were not coincident. A significant reduction of tremor was reported with chronic clozapine treatment (p <0.01) with no tolerance to drug antitremor effect, whereas sedation markedly decreased after 6-7 weeks of therapy. No clozapine-induced hematologic side effects were observed in our cohort of patients during long-term treatment. Our results suggest that in selected drug-resistant ET cases, clozapine should be considered before resorting to neurosurgical options.