Transcriptome sequencing identifies a noncoding, deep intronic variant in CLCN7 causing autosomal recessive osteopetrosis

CLCN7, a gene shared by autosomal recessive and autosomal dominant osteopetrosis

After the discovery of abundant v-ATPase complexes in the osteoclast ruffled membrane it was obvious that in parallel a negative counter-ion needs to be transported across this membrane to allow for efficient transport of protons into the resorption lacuna. While different candidate proteins were discussed the osteopetrosis phenotype of Clcn7 knockout mice suggested that the chloride/proton-exchanger ClC-7 might be responsible for transporting the negative charge. In the following, individuals with autosomal recessive osteopetrosis (ARO) were found to carry biallelic CLCN7 pathogenic variants. Shortly thereafter, heterozygous pathogenic variants were identified as the exclusive cause of autosomal dominant osteopetrosis type 2 (ADO2). Since in most cell types other than osteoclasts ClC-7 resides in late endosomes and lysosomes, it took some time until the electrophysiological properties of ClC-7 were elucidated. Whereas most missense variants lead to reduced chloride currents, several variants with accelerated kinetics have been identified. Evidence for folding problems is also known for several missense variants. Paradoxically, a heterozygous activating variant in ClC-7 was described to cause lysosomal alteration, pigmentation defects, and intellectual disability without osteopetrosis. The counter-intuitive 2 Cl^-/H⁺ exchange function of ClC-7 was shown to be physiologically important for intravesicular ion homeostasis. The lysosomal function of ClC-7 is also the reason why individuals with CLCN7-ARO can develop a storage disorder and neurodegeneration, a feature that is variable and difficult to predict. Furthermore, the low penetrance of heterozygous pathogenic CLCN7 variants and the clinical variability of ADO2 are incompletely understood. We aim to give an overview not only of the current knowledge about ClC-7 and its related pathologies, but also of the scientists and clinicians that paved the way for these discoveries.

Lessons learned: next-generation sequencing applied to undiagnosed genetic diseases

Rare genetic disorders, when considered together, are relatively common. Despite advancements in genetics and genomics technologies as well as increased understanding of genomic function and dysfunction, many genetic diseases continue to be difficult to diagnose. The goal of this Review is to increase the familiarity of genetic testing strategies for non-genetics providers. As genetic testing is increasingly used in primary care, many subspecialty clinics, and various inpatient settings, it is important that non-genetics providers have a fundamental understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of various genetic testing strategies as well as develop an ability to interpret genetic testing results. We provide background on commonly used genetic testing approaches, give examples of phenotypes in which the various genetic testing approaches are used, describe types of genetic and genomic variations, cover challenges in variant identification, provide examples in which next-generation sequencing (NGS) failed to uncover the variant responsible for a disease, and discuss opportunities for continued improvement in the application of NGS clinically. As genetic testing becomes increasingly a part of all areas of medicine, familiarity with genetic testing approaches and result interpretation is vital to decrease the burden of undiagnosed disease.

Differential Diagnosis of the Short IGF-I-Deficient Child with Apparently Normal Growth Hormone Secretion

The current differential diagnosis for a short child with low insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) and a normal growth hormone (GH) peak in a GH stimulation test (GHST), after exclusion of acquired causes, includes the following disorders: (1) a decreased spontaneous GH secretion in contrast to a normal stimulated GH peak ("GH neurosecretory dysfunction," GHND) and (2) genetic conditions with a normal GH sensitivity (e.g., pathogenic variants of GH1 or GHSR) and (3) GH insensitivity (GHI). We present a critical appraisal of the concept of GHND and the role of 12- or 24-h GH profiles in the selection of children for GH treatment. The mean 24-h GH concentration in healthy children overlaps with that in those with GH deficiency, indicating that the previously proposed cutoff limit (3.0-3.2 μg/L) is too high. The main advantage of performing a GH profile is that it prevents about 20% of false-positive test results of the GHST, while it also detects a low spontaneous GH secretion in children who would be considered GH sufficient based on a stimulation test. However, due to a considerable burden for patients and the health budget, GH profiles are only used in few centres. Regarding genetic causes, there is good evidence of the existence of Kowarski syndrome (due to GH1 variants) but less on the role of GHSR variants. Several genetic causes of (partial) GHI are known (GHR, STAT5B, STAT3, IGF1, IGFALS defects, and Noonan and 3M syndromes), some responding positively to GH therapy. In the final section, we speculate on hypothetical causes.

Analysis of Pathogenic Pseudoexons Reveals Novel Mechanisms Driving Cryptic Splicing

Understanding pre-mRNA splicing is crucial to accurately diagnosing and treating genetic diseases. However, mutations that alter splicing can exert highly diverse effects. Of all the known types of splicing mutations, perhaps the rarest and most difficult to predict are those that activate pseudoexons, sometimes also called cryptic exons. Unlike other splicing mutations that either destroy or redirect existing splice events, pseudoexon mutations appear to create entirely new exons within introns. Since exon definition in vertebrates requires coordinated arrangements of numerous RNA motifs, one might expect that pseudoexons would only arise when rearrangements of intronic DNA create novel exons by chance. Surprisingly, although such mutations do occur, a far more common cause of pseudoexons is deep-intronic single nucleotide variants, raising the question of why these latent exon-like tracts near the mutation sites have not already been purged from the genome by the evolutionary advantage of more efficient splicing. Possible answers may lie in deep intronic splicing processes such as recursive splicing or poison exon splicing. Because these processes utilize intronic motifs that benignly engage with the spliceosome, the regions involved may be more susceptible to exonization than other intronic regions would be. We speculated that a comprehensive study of reported pseudoexons might detect alignments with known deep intronic splice sites and could also permit the characterisation of novel pseudoexon categories. In this report, we present and analyse a catalogue of over 400 published pseudoexon splice events. In addition to confirming prior observations of the most common pseudoexon mutation types, the size of this catalogue also enabled us to suggest new categories for some of the rarer types of pseudoexon mutation. By comparing our catalogue against published datasets of non-canonical splice events, we also found that 15.7% of pseudoexons exhibit some splicing activity at one or both of their splice sites in non-mutant cells. Importantly, this included seven examples of experimentally confirmed recursive splice sites, confirming for the first time a long-suspected link between these two splicing phenomena. These findings have the potential to improve the fidelity of genetic diagnostics and reveal new targets for splice-modulating therapies.

Spectrum of splicing variants in disease genes and the ability of RNA analysis to reduce uncertainty in clinical interpretation

The complexities of gene expression pose challenges for the clinical interpretation of splicing variants. To better understand splicing variants and their contribution to hereditary disease, we evaluated their prevalence, clinical classifications, and associations with diseases, inheritance, and functional characteristics in a 689,321-person clinical cohort and two large public datasets. In the clinical cohort, splicing variants represented 13% of all variants classified as pathogenic (P), likely pathogenic (LP), or variants of uncertain significance (VUSs). Most splicing variants were outside essential splice sites and were classified as VUSs. Among all individuals tested, 5.4% had a splicing VUS. If RNA analysis were to contribute supporting evidence to variant interpretation, we estimated that splicing VUSs would be reclassified in 1.7% of individuals in our cohort. This would result in a clinically significant result (i.e., P/LP) in 0.1% of individuals overall because most reclassifications would change VUSs to likely benign. In ClinVar, splicing VUSs were 4.8% of reported variants and could benefit from RNA analysis. In the Genome Aggregation Database (gnomAD), splicing variants comprised 9.4% of variants in protein-coding genes; most were rare, precluding unambiguous classification as benign. Splicing variants were depleted in genes associated with dominant inheritance and haploinsufficiency, although some genes had rare variants at essential splice sites or had common splicing variants that were most likely compatible with normal gene function. Overall, we describe the contribution of splicing variants to hereditary disease, the potential utility of RNA analysis for reclassifying splicing VUSs, and how natural variation may confound clinical interpretation of splicing variants.

Subtrochanteric Femoral Fracture in a Patient with Osteopetrosis: Treated with Internal Fixation and Complicated by Intraoperative Femoral Neck Fracture

Objective

Osteopetrosis (OP) is a rare, heritable skeletal disorder that is caused by osteoclast dysfunction, leading to failure of bone resorption and increased bone density. The fragility of such dense bone may result in an increased incidence of fractures. Furthermore, surgery in patients with OP is associated with increased technical difficulty and a higher risk of complications.

Case Report

We report a case of a 20-year-old woman with autosomal dominant OP who developed a subtrochanteric femoral fracture. The fracture was treated by open reduction and internal fixation using a dynamic hip screw. Although technical difficulties were experienced and an intraoperative femoral neck fracture occurred, the surgical outcome was satisfactory. Union of the fractures was visible on radiographs obtained 12 months postoperatively. At 2 years postoperatively, the patient was completely free of any complications resulting from her injury and treatment.

Conclusion

Open reduction and internal fixation may be an effective option for fractures in patients with OP. Orthopedic surgeons should be aware that the increased density and stiffness of osteopetrotic bone increases the risks of intraoperative technical difficulties, iatrogenic fractures, and postoperative complications.

Transcriptome sequencing identifies a noncoding, deep intronic variant in CLCN7 causing autosomal recessive osteopetrosis

Background

Over half of children with rare genetic diseases remain undiagnosed despite maximal clinical evaluation and DNA‐based genetic testing. As part of an Undiagnosed Diseases Program applying transcriptome (RNA) sequencing to identify the causes of these unsolved cases, we studied a child with severe infantile osteopetrosis leading to cranial nerve palsies, bone deformities, and bone marrow failure, for whom whole‐genome sequencing was nondiagnostic.

Methods

We performed transcriptome (RNA) sequencing of whole blood followed by analysis of aberrant transcript isoforms and osteoclast functional studies.

Results

We identified a pathogenic deep intronic variant in CLCN7 creating an unexpected, frameshifting pseudoexon causing complete loss of function. Functional studies, including osteoclastogenesis and bone resorption assays, confirmed normal osteoclast differentiation but loss of osteoclast function.

Conclusion

This is the first report of a pathogenic deep intronic variant in CLCN7, and our approach provides a model for systematic identification of noncoding variants causing osteopetrosis—a disease for which molecular‐genetic diagnosis can be pivotal for potentially curative hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Our work illustrates that cryptic splice variants may elude DNA‐only sequencing and supports broad first‐line use of transcriptome sequencing for children with undiagnosed diseases.