Origin and history of end-to-side neurorrhaphy

Alternative Nerve Coaptations: End-To-Side and Beyond

Modern end-to-side (ETS) nerve transfers have undergone several permutations since the early 1990's. Preclinical data have revealed important mechanisms and patterns of donor axon outgrowth into the recipient nerves and target reinnervation. The versatility of ETS nerve transfers can also potentially address several processes that limit functional recovery after nerve injury by babysitting motor end-plates and/or supporting the regenerative environment within the denervated nerve. Further clinical and basic science work is required to clarify the ideal clinical indications, contraindications, and mechanisms of action for these techniques in order to maximize their potential as reconstructive options.

Round table discussion: the management of idiopathic cubital tunnel syndrome

Idiopathic cubital tunnel syndrome is the second most common neuropathy in the upper limb. Best evidence regarding the surgical management of this condition has evolved from anterior or submuscular transposition as the former reference standard, to in situ simple release. Differences of opinion remain regarding the timing of surgery, type of surgery and adjunctive surgery. Four surgeons with Level 5 expertise were asked to answer specific questions regarding this condition.

End-to-side neurorrhaphy in peripheral nerves: Does it work?

Acute peripheral nerve injuries are common and can cause physical disabilities with sensory and functional sequelae; they therefore require surgery. The aim of this study was to conduct a systematic review to assess the clinical applicability of end-to-side neurorrhaphy in peripheral nerve reconstruction, based on available evidence. We carried out a systematic review of the literature using MEDLINE/PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Scielo and Scopus through March 16, 2021. Most of the selected studies were qualitative and employed nonrandomized groups of patients, without standardized scales for assessing outcomes, which made statistical analysis difficult. Efficacy varied from 24% to 81%. Factors for better outcome included the type of injury, type of injured nerve (sensory, motor or mixed), presence of an epineural window, topography, injury extension <1.3 cm, and intervention within 2 weeks of injury. Clinical studies so far lack scientific evidence on end-to-side neurorrhaphy in peripheral nerve lesions.

Epineurial Window Is More Efficient in Attracting Axons than Simple Coaptation in a Sutureless (Cyanoacrylate-Bound) Model of End-to-Side Nerve Repair in the Rat Upper Limb: Functional and Morphometric Evidences and Review of the Literature

End-to-side nerve coaptation brings regenerating axons from the donor to the recipient nerve. Several techniques have been used to perform coaptation: microsurgical sutures with and without opening a window into the epi(peri)neurial connective tissue; among these, window techniques have been proven more effective in inducing axonal regeneration. The authors developed a sutureless model of end-to-side coaptation in the rat upper limb. In 19 adult Wistar rats, the median and the ulnar nerves of the left arm were approached from the axillary region, the median nerve transected and the proximal stump sutured to the pectoral muscle to prevent regeneration. Animals were then randomly divided in two experimental groups (7 animals each, 5 animals acting as control): Group 1: the distal stump of the transected median nerve was fixed to the ulnar nerve by applying cyanoacrylate solution; Group 2: a small epineurial window was opened into the epineurium of the ulnar nerve, caring to avoid damage to the nerve fibres; the distal stump of the transected median nerve was then fixed to the ulnar nerve by applying cyanoacrylate solution. The grasping test for functional evaluation was repeated every 10-11 weeks starting from week-15, up to the sacrifice (week 36). At week 36, the animals were sacrificed and the regenerated nerves harvested and processed for morphological investigations (high-resolution light microscopy as well as stereological and morphometrical analysis). This study shows that a) cyanoacrylate in end-to-side coaptation produces scarless axon regeneration without toxic effects; b) axonal regeneration and myelination occur even without opening an epineurial window, but c) the window is related to a larger number of regenerating fibres, especially myelinated and mature, and better functional outcomes.

Direct muscle neurotization after end-to end and end-to-side neurorrhaphy: An experimental study in the rat forelimb model

The need for the continuous research of new tools for improving motor function recovery after nerve injury is justified by the still often unsatisfactory clinical outcome in these patients. It has been previously shown that the combined use of two reconstructive techniques, namely end-to-side neurorrhaphy and direct muscle neurotization in the rat hindlimb model, can lead to good results in terms of skeletal muscle reinnervation. Here we show that, in the rat forelimb model, the combined use of direct muscle neurotization with either end-to-end or end-to-side neurorrhaphy to reinnervate the denervated flexor digitorum muscles, leads to muscle atrophy prevention over a long postoperative time lapse (10 months). By contrast, very little motor recovery (in case of end-to-end neurorrhaphy) and almost no motor recovery (in case of end-to-side neurorrhaphy) were observed in the grasping activity controlled by flexor digitorum muscles. It can thus be concluded that, at least in the rat, direct muscle neurotization after both end-to-end and end-to-side neurorrhaphy represents a good strategy for preventing denervation-related muscle atrophy but not for regaining the lost motor function.

Emerging issues in peripheral nerve repair

It is today widely acknowledged that nerve repair is now more than a matter of perfect microsurgical reconstruction only and that, to further improve clinical outcome, the involvement of different scientific disciplines is required. This evolving reconstructive/regenerative approach is based on the interdisciplinary and integrated pillars of tissue engineering such as reconstructive microsurgery, transplantation and biomaterials. In this paper, some of the most promising innovations for the tissue engineering of nerves, emerging from basic science investigation, are critically overviewed with special focus on those approaches that appear today to be more suitable for clinical translation.

Morphological assessment of early axonal regeneration in end-to-side nerve coaptation models

Histological changes were observed in peripheral nerves following end-to-side nerve coaptation to determine the effects of perineurial opening and deliberate donor nerve injury during surgery. Twenty rats were randomised into four groups as follows: group 1, end-to-side nerve coaptation without perineurial opening; group 2, end-to-side nerve coaptation with simple perineurial opening; group 3, end-to-side nerve coaptation with partial crush injury after perineurial opening; group 4, end-to-side nerve coaptation with partial neurotomy after perineurial opening. Seven days after coaptation of the musculocutaneous (recipient) nerve to the ulnar (donor) nerve, the nerves were immunohistochemically analysed using antibodies against neurofilament-H (RT97) and phosphorylated GAP-43 (p-GAP-43). The former labels all axons, including regenerating axons and degenerated axonal debris, while the latter only labels regenerating axons. Results demonstrated no regenerating nerves in the recipient nerve of group 1. In group 2, because nerve herniation from the perineurial opening partially injured donor nerve fibres, some regenerating axons extended proximally and distally along the partially injured fibres in the donor nerve; some of these regenerating axons also extended into the recipient nerve via the perineurial opening. In groups 3 and 4, thin regenerating axons were more prominent in recipient and donor nerves compared with group 2. Statistical evaluation revealed increased efficacy of perineurial opening and deliberate donor nerve injury in end-to-side nerve coaptation, suggesting that partial nerve fibre herniation with partial axonotmesis or neurotomesis was important for effective axonal regeneration in end-to-side nerve coaptation.

Single versus double end-to-side nerve grafts in rats

PURPOSE

Although the end-to-side nerve repair technique has been used clinically, it has not yet produced consistent motor and sensory recovery in patients. The aim of this study was to investigate whether end-to-side double nerve grafts display more axonal regeneration compared with a single nerve graft in a rat lower limb preparation.

METHODS

The lower limbs of 96 Wister rats were used in experiments comparing single and double end-to-side nerve grafts. Left peroneal nerves were harvested and grafted between the right peroneal and tibial nerves. A single graft was attached end-to-side to the peroneal and tibial nerves through an epineural window (single graft group, n = 24). Two grafts were performed in the same manner in the double graft group (n = 24). The peroneal nerve was exposed in positive controls (n = 24) and no graft was performed in negative controls (n = 24). We recorded action potentials and moist weights of the left tibialis anterior muscle at each time point. Fluoro-Gold-labeled (Fluorochrome, Denver, CO) dorsal root ganglion neurons from L1 to L6 were counted using fluorescence microscopy and compared among the 4 groups.

RESULTS

In both single and double groups, the amplitude and the tibialis anterior muscle weight increased significantly compared with negative controls but remained lower than those measured in positive controls. There was no significant difference between single and double groups. In Fluoro-Gold-labeled neurons, there was also no significant difference between single and double groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The study showed that regeneration of motor and sensory nerve fibers was possible using 2 end-to-side nerve grafts. However, there was no significant difference between single and double grafts. This might suggest a therapeutic limitation of nerve transplants using 2 end-to-side nerve grafts.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Double end-to-side repair attracts both motor and sensory axons, and this results in a medium degree of recovery of function; however, double end-to-side nerve grafting does not appear to offer any advantage over a single end-to-side graft.

Experimental and clinical employment of end-to-side coaptation: our experience

The last 15 years have seen a growing interest regarding a technique for nerve repair named end-to-side coaptation. Since 2000, we have carried out experimental studies on end-to-side nerve repair as well as employed this technique to a series of selected clinical cases. Here we report on the results of this experience.For experimental studies, we have used the model represented by median nerve repair by end-to-side coaptation either on the ulnar (agonistic) or the radial (antagonistic) nerve. For time course assessment of median nerve functional recovery we used the grasping test, a test which permits to assess voluntary control of muscle function. Repaired nerves were processed for resin embedding to allow nerve fibre stereology and electron microscopy. Results showed that, in either experimental group, end-to-side-repaired median nerves were repopulated by axons regenerating from ulnar and radial donor nerves, respectively. Moreover, contrary to previously published data, our results showed that voluntary motor control of the muscles innervated by the median nerve was progressively recovered also when the antagonistic radial nerve was the donor nerve.As regards our clinical experience, results were not so positive. We have treated by end-to-side coaptation patients with both sensory (n = 7, collateral digital nerves) and mixed (n = 8, plexus level) nerve lesions. Results were good, as in other series, in sensory nerves whilst they were very difficult to investigate in mixed nerves at the plexus level.Take together, these results suggest that clinical employment of end-to-side coaptation should still be considered at the moment as the ultima ratio in cases in which no other repair technique can be attempted. Yet, it is clear that more basic research is needed to explain the reasons for the different results between laboratory animal and humans and, especially, to find out how to ameliorate the outcome of end-to-side nerve repair by adequate treatment and rehabilitation.

Functional recovery following an end to side neurorrhaphy of the accessory nerve to the suprascapular nerve: case report

The use of end-to-side neurrorhaphy remains a controversial topic in peripheral nerve surgery. The authors report the long-term functional outcome following a modified end-to-side motor reinnervation using the spinal accessory to innervate the suprascapular nerve following a C5 to C6 avulsion injury. Additionally, functional outcomes of an end-to-end neurotization of the triceps branch to the axillary nerve and double fascicular transfer of the ulnar and medial nerve to the biceps and brachialis are presented. Excellent functional recoveries are found in respect to shoulder abduction and flexion and elbow flexion.

ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL

The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s11552-009-9242-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Termino-lateral nerve suture in lesions of the digital nerves: clinical experience and literature review

Documented experience of treatment of digital nerve lesions with the termino-lateral (end-to-side) nerve suture is limited. Our clinical experience of this technique is detailed here alongside a systematic review of the previous literature. We performed, from 2002 to 2008, seven termino-lateral sutures with epineural window opening for digital nerve lesions. Functional outcome was analysed using the two-point discrimination test and the Semmes-Weinstein monofilament test. The results showed a sensory recovery of S3+ in six cases and S3 in one case. The mean distance found in the two-point discrimination test was 12.7 mm (range 8-18 mm). After a review of the literature, we were able to obtain homogeneous data from 17 additional patients operated by termino-lateral coaptation. The overall number of cases included in our review was 24. A sensory recovery was observed in 23 out of 24 patients. The functional results were S0 in one case, S3 in one case, S3+ in twenty cases and S4 in two cases. Excluding the one unfavourable case, the mean distance in the two-point discrimination test was 9.7 mm (range 3-18 mm). It can thus be concluded that the treatment of digital nerve lesions with termino-lateral suture showed encouraging results. Based on the results obtained in this current study we believe that in case of loss of substance, end-to-side nerve coaptation may be an alternative to biological and synthetic tubulisation when a digital nerve reconstruction by means of nerve autograft is declined by the patient.

End-to-side nerve suture in traumatic injuries of brachial plexus: review of the literature and personal case series

We used end-to-side nerve coaptation combined with standard end-to-end neurotisations to treat 11 patients who presented with complete (six cases) or incomplete (five cases) traumatic brachial plexus injuries. All patients were available for functional evaluation at a minimum of 2 years postoperatively. In three patients with shoulder abduction recovery, electromyographical studies (EMG) showed a contribution from the end-to-side neurotisation. In the remaining cases end-to-side neurotisations were unsuccessful. Our study did not demonstrate a reliable role for end-to-side nerve suture in brachial plexus surgery. We believe that at present end-to-side suture must not be a substitute for standard reconstructive techniques in brachial plexus surgery. Occasionally termino-lateral nerve sutures may represent a support to standard reconstructive procedures especially in case of severe injuries when few undamaged donor nerves are available.

Comparison of regeneration results of prefabricated nerve graft, autogenous nerve graft, and vein graft in repair of nerve defects

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectivity of prefabricated nerve grafts in the repairing nerve defect and to compare them with the autogenous nerve graft and vein graft. Four groups were created, each containing 10 rats. First, nerve prefabrication was carried out in groups I and II during 8 weeks. For this purpose, jugular vein graft was sutured to the epineural windows on the peroneal and tibial nerve at the right side in an end-to-side fashion. To create neurotrophic stimulus, partial incision was performed on the nerves in group I, and gene therapy was performed by plasmid injecting to the adjacent muscles in group II. At the end of the eighth week, prefabricated nerve grafts, jugular vein, and the axons passing through it were taken. Then, gap was created on the left peroneal nerve in all groups. Defect on the peroneal nerve was repaired by using the prefabricated nerve grafts in groups I and II, the autogenous nerve graft in group III, and the vein in group IV. Assessment of nerve regeneration was performed by using electromyography. Morphological assessment was performed after follow-up period. According to electrophysiological and morphological results, the results of first three groups were similar. There was no statistically significant difference between three groups. Prefabricated nerve graft is as effective as autogenous nerve graft, and it can be used in the repair of nerve defects as autogenous nerve graft as an alternative.

Chapter 1: Peripheral nerve repair and regeneration research: a historical note

Although the most significant advances in nerve repair and regeneration have been acquired over the last few decades, the study of nerve repair and regeneration potential dates back to ancient times namely to Galen in the second century A.D. This brief historical note outlines the milestones which have guided us to our present knowledge. In particular, we focus on the nineteenth century and the first decades of the twentieth century, an age in which the fathers of neurosurgery and neurobiology established the basis for most of the nerve repair and regeneration concepts used today. Finally, we shine a light on the most current history to show how recent pressure to use modern interdisciplinary and translational approach represents a sort of rediscovery of the scientific habits of the fathers of modern biomedicine, who used to carry out research from an integrated and broad point of view rather than from a super-specialized and specific one as it is often used today.

End-to-side neurorrhaphy for median nerve repair after elbow tumor resection: case report

We report a case of a median to ulnar end-to-side neurorrhaphy with epineurectomy but without fascicular donor nerve section. Surgery was performed for the curative treatment of an elbow synovial sarcoma at the level of the elbow that necessitated resection of 10 cm of the median nerve. The patient was followed up for 24 months. After 4 months, a recovery of protective sensation in the territory of the median nerve was noticed and had stabilized by 1 year.

Evaluation and management of peripheral nerve injury

Common etiologies of acute traumatic peripheral nerve injury (TPNI) include penetrating injury, crush, stretch, and ischemia. Management of TPNI requires familiarity with the relevant anatomy, pathology, pathophysiology, and the surgical principles, approaches and concerns. Surgical repair of TPNI is done at varying time intervals after the injury, and there are a number of considerations in deciding whether and when to operate. In neurapraxia, the compound muscle and nerve action potentials on stimulating distal to the lesion are maintained indefinitely; stimulation above the lesion reveals partial or complete conduction block. The picture in axonotmesis and neurotmesis depends on the time since injury. The optimal timing for an electrodiagnostic study depends upon the clinical question being asked. Although conventional teaching usually holds that an electrodiagnostic study should not be done until about 3 weeks after the injury, in fact a great deal of important information can be obtained by studies done in the first week. Proximal nerve injuries are problematic because the long distance makes it difficult to reinnervate distal muscles before irreversible changes occur. Decision making regarding exploration must occur more quickly, and exploration using intraoperative nerve action potential recording to guide the choice of surgical procedure is often useful.

Sex-related differences in recovery of cutaneous nociception after end-to-side nerve repair in the rat

Sex-related differences in the recovery of cutaneous nociception after end-to-side nerve repair were examined in rats. Recovery of nociception in the dorsal foot was determined by skin pinch test 19 weeks after the proximal end of the distal stump of the transected peroneal nerve was sutured to the side of the adjacent intact sural nerve (end-to-side nerve coaptation). Axon sprouts in the recipient peroneal nerve were counted by light and electron microscopy. Recovery of nociception due to axon sprouting through the end-to-side coaptation was found in 87% of females and in 60% of males. The area of nociception was not significantly different (P=0.59) between females and males (13+/-8% and 11+/-9%, respectively). The number of myelinated axons in the recipient peroneal nerve (but not of unmyelinated axons) was significantly larger (P=0.028) in females (median=512, 25th and 75th percentiles: 467 and 594) than in males (median=322, 25th and 75th percentiles: 239 and 468). The majority of these axons in females and males were thin fibres, and recipient nerves in both groups were responsive to nerve pinch test. In conclusion, collateral sprouting of thin myelinated nociceptive axons into the end-to-side coapted nerve is more abundant in female than in male rats. However, recovery of cutaneous mechano-nociception due to sprouting of these axons was not different between the two sexes. Possible reasons are discussed.