Relationship between nuclear remodeling and subsequent development of mouse embryonic nuclei transferred to enucleated oocytes

Cytoplasmic volume of recipient oocytes affects the nucleus reprogramming and the developmental competence of HMC buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) embryos

The present study was undertaken to examine the effects of cytoplasmic volume on nucleus reprogramming and developmental competence of buffalo handmade cloning (HMC) embryos. We found that both HMC embryos derived from ~150% cytoplasm or ~225% cytoplasm resulted in a higher blastocyst rate and total cell number of blastocyst in comparison with those from ~75% cytoplasm (25.4 ± 2.0, 27.9 ± 1.6% vs. 17.9 ± 3.1%; 150 ± 10, 169 ± 12 vs. 85 ± 6, P<0.05). Meanwhile, the proportions of nuclear envelope breakdown (NEBD) and premature chromosome condensation (PCC) were also increased in the embryos derived from ~150 or ~225% enucleated cytoplasm compared to those from ~75% cytoplasm. Moreover, HMC embryos derived from ~225% cytoplasm showed a decrease of global DNA methylation from the 2-cell to the 4-cell stage in comparison with those of ~75% cytoplasm (P<0.05). Furthermore, the expression of embryonic genome activation (EGA) relative genes (eIF1A and U2AF) in HMC embryos derived from ~225% cytoplasm at the 8-cell stages was also found to be enhanced compared with that of the ~75% cytoplasm. Two of seven recipients were confirmed to be pregnant following transfer of blastocysts derived from ~225% cytoplasm, and one healthy cloned calf was delivered at the end of the gestation period, whereas no recipients were pregnant after the transfer of blastocysts derived from ~75% cytoplasm. These results indicate that the cytoplasmic volume of recipient oocytes affects donor nucleus reprogramming, and then further accounted for the developmental ability of the reconstructed embryos.

Porcine Cloned Embryos Reconstructed with the Cell Nuclei of Tetraploid M-phase Fibroblast Cells Can Restore Normal Diploidy at the Blastocyst Stage

The cell cycle of donor cells as a major factor that affects cloning efficiency remains debatable. G2/M phase cells as a donor can successfully produce cloned animals, but a minimal amount is known regarding nuclear remodeling events. In this study, porcine fetal fibroblasts (PFFs) were carefully synchronized at G1 or M phase as donor cells. Most of the cloned embryos reconstructed from PFFs at G1 (G1-embryos) or M (M-embryos) phase formed a pronucleus-like nucleus (PN) within 6-h post fusion (hpf), but the M-embryos formed PN earlier than the G1-embryos did. Moreover, 77.4% of the M-embryos formed two PNs, whereas the G1-embryos formed a single PN. The rate of extrusion of polar body-like structures by the M-embryos was significantly lower than that extruded by the G1-embryos (26.3% vs. 37.1%, P < 0.05), and DNA synthesis in most embryos in both groups was initiated at 9-12 hpf. Most of the M-embryos were octoploid before the first cleavage. Furthermore, 81.25% of the blastomeres of blastocysts developed from the M-embryos showed abnormal ploidy compared with those developed from the G1-embryos (22.55%). However, some of the blastomeres remained diploid in all the M-embryos tested. A portion of the blastomeres restored normal diploidy in some of the M-embryos at the blastocyst stage. This finding provides an explanation for M-embryos developing to term.

Microtubule distribution in somatic cell nuclear transfer bovine embryos following control of nuclear remodeling type

This study was conducted to evaluate the microtubule distribution following control of nuclear remodeling by treatment of bovine somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) embryos with caffeine or roscovitine. Bovine somatic cells were fused to enucleated oocytes treated with either 5 mM caffeine or 150 µM roscovitine to control the type of nuclear remodeling. The proportion of embryos that underwent premature chromosome condensation (PCC) was increased by caffeine treatment but was reduced by roscovitine treatment (p < 0.05). The microtubule organization was examined by immunostaining β- and γ-tubulins at 15 min, 3 h, and 20 h of fusion using laser scanning confocal microscopy. The γ-tubulin foci inherited from the donor centrosome were observed in most of the SCNT embryos at 15 min of fusion (91.3%) and most of them did not disappear until 3 h after fusion, regardless of treatment (82.9-87.2%). A significantly high proportion of embryos showing an abnormal chromosome or microtubule distribution was observed in the roscovitine-treated group (40.0%, p < 0.05) compared to the caffeine-treated group (22.1%). In conclusion, PCC is a favorable condition for the normal organization of microtubules, and inhibition of PCC can cause abnormal mitotic division of bovine SCNT embryos by causing microtubule dysfunction.

Control of nuclear remodelling and subsequent in vitro development and methylation status of porcine nuclear transfer embryos

We attempted to control the nuclear remodelling of somatic cell nuclear transfer embryos (NTs) and examined their subsequent development and DNA methylation patterns in pigs. Porcine foetal fibroblasts were fused to enucleated oocytes treated with either 5 mM caffeine for 2.5 h or 0.5 mM vanadate for 0.5 h. After activation, NTs were cultured in vitro for 6 days to examine their development. The nuclear remodelling type of the reconstituted embryos was evaluated 1 h after fusion. Methylated DNA of in vitro-fertilised (IVF) embryos and NTs at various developmental stages and of donor cells was detected using a 5-methylcytosine (5-MeC) antibody. Caffeine-treated NTs induced premature chromosome condensation at a high rate (P<0.05), whereas most vanadate-treated NTs formed a pronucleus-like structure. Although cleavage rates to the two-cell stage did not differ among groups, delayed cleavage was observed in the vanadate-treated group. The blastocyst formation rate was significantly reduced by vanadate treatment compared with caffeine-treated and non-treated (control) NT groups (P<0.05). The apoptotic cell index of NT blastocysts was lower in the caffeine-treated group than in other groups (P<0.05). The methylation patterns were similar among NTs, but more hypermethylated DNA was observed at the four-cell stage of control and vanadate-treated NTs when compared with that in IVF embryos (P<0.05). Thus, the nuclear remodelling type controlled by caffeine or vanadate treatment can affect in vitro development and the methylation status of NTs in relation to nuclear reprogramming.

Expression of enhanced green fluorescent protein in porcine- and bovine-cloned embryos following interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer of fibroblasts transfected by retrovirus vector

Interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer (iSCNT) has emerged as an important tool for studying nucleo-cytoplasmic interactions and cloning of animals whose oocytes are difficult to obtain. This study was designed to explore the feasibility of employing transgenic fibroblasts as donor cells for iSCNT. The study examined the chromatin morphology, in vitro development, and expression of an enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) gene in porcine- and bovine-cloned embryos produced by iSCNT of fetal fibroblast transfected with a pLNbeta-EGFP retroviral vector. Parthenogenetic and transfected or nontransfected intraspecies SCNT embryos were used as controls for comparison. Analysis of data revealed that xenogenic oocyte was able to reprogram somatic cells of different genus and supports their in vitro development to the blastocyst stage. However, the developmental rates of transgenic iSCNT embryos to the blastocyst stage were significantly lower than those of intraspecies SCNT embryos. The reduction in development rates was however, not due to integration of the transgene as the lower (P < 0.05) development rates of the intraspecies SCNT porcine or bovine embryos did not differ between transgenic and nontransgenic groups. Expression of EGFP was observed in 100% of blastocysts and mosaicism was not observed. Furthermore, after iSCNT of porcine or bovine donor nuclei into xenogenic ooplasm, patterns of nuclear remodeling in reconstructed embryos were similar. In conclusion, our data demonstrated the feasibility of producing transgenic iSCNT embryos. To our knowledge, this is the first report of transgenic cloned embryo production by iSCNT approach. In the future, this may provide a powerful research tool for studying developmental events in domestic animals and provide marked cell lines for other genetic manipulations.

The status of human nuclear transfer

Human therapeutic cloning is a recently emerged application of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), which is currently being performed to produce patient-specific stem cell lines for future stem cell therapies. The advantages in producing human nuclear transfer (NT) embryos to derive NT stem cell lines are that these can be tailor-made (i.e., are autologous in nature) for the patient and may overcome the need to administer life-long immunosuppression following stem cell transplantation. Although the rationale for using NT embryos is not for reproductive purposes, human NT remains clouded in ethical, moral, and religious controversies. The recent retraction of high-impact factor publications in the field of human NT from a research group in South Korea has placed stem cell research in a delicate situation. These heavily publicized issues may hinder the progress of this research and may threaten to bring current research to a complete halt. This review outlines the recent status of human NT, its continuing progress and the difficulties the field faces. Of most concern are the ethical issues, which surround obtaining human oocytes for research. Recent evidence suggests that failed-to-fertilize oocytes are poor sources for human SCNT, but obtaining fresh, viable oocytes may be even more problematic. The current status of human SCNT is outlined in this review with particular reference made to, lessons learnt from animal research, the oocyte dilemma and optimization of human NT.

Developmental competence of human in vitro aged oocytes as host cells for nuclear transfer

BACKGROUND

Improving human nuclear transfer (NT) efficiencies is paramount for the development of patient-specific stem cell lines, although the opportunities remain limited owing to difficulties in obtaining fresh mature oocytes.

METHODS

Therefore, the developmental competence of aged, failed-to-fertilize human oocytes as an alternate cytoplasmic source for NT was assessed and compared with use of fresh, ovulation-induced oocytes. To further characterize the developmental potential of aged oocytes, parthenogenetic activation, immunocytochemical analysis of essential microtubule proteins involved in meiotic and mitotic division, and RT-PCR in single oocytes (n = 6) was performed to determine expression of oocyte-specific genes [oocyte-specific histone 1 (H1FOO), growth differentiation factor 9 (GDF9), bone morphogenetic protein 15 (BMP15), zygote arrest 1 (ZAR1)] and microtubule markers [nuclear mitotic arrest (NuMA), minus-end directed motor protein HSET and the microtubule kinesin motor protein EG5].

RESULTS

For NT, enucleation and fusion rates of aged oocytes were significantly lower compared with fresh oocytes (P < 0.05). Cleavage rates and subsequent development were poor. In addition, parthenote cleavage was low. Immunocytochemical analysis revealed that many oocytes displayed aberrant expression of NuMA and EG5, had disrupted meiotic spindles and tetrapolar spindles. One of the six oocytes misexpressed GDF9, BMP15 and ZAR1. Two oocytes expressed EG5 messenger RNA (mRNA), and HSET and NuMA were not detectable. RT-PCR of mRNA for oocyte specific genes and microtubule markers in single aged oocytes.

CONCLUSIONS

Thus, aneuploidy and spindle defects may contribute to poor parthenogenetic development and developmental outcomes following NT.

Screening for hereditary hemochromatosis: a clinical practice guideline from the American College of Physicians

Hereditary hemochromatosis is a genetic disorder of iron metabolism. Diagnosis of hereditary hemochromatosis is usually based on a combination of various genetic or phenotypic criteria. Decisions regarding screening are difficult because of the variable penetrance of mutations of the HFE gene and the absence of any definitive trials addressing the benefits and risks of therapeutic phlebotomy in asymptomatic patients or those with only laboratory abnormalities. The purpose of this guideline is to increase physician awareness of hereditary hemochromatosis, particularly the variable penetrance of genetic mutations; aid in case finding; and explain the role of genetic testing. This guideline provides recommendations based on a review of evidence in the accompanying background paper by Schmitt and colleagues. The target audience for this guideline is internists and other primary care physicians. The target patient population is all persons who have a probability or susceptibility of developing hereditary hemochromatosis, including the relatives of individuals who already have the disease.

Effect of activation time on the nuclear remodeling and in vitro development of nuclear transfer embryos derived from bovine somatic cells

This study was conducted to investigate the effect of recipient activation time on the chromatin structure and development of bovine nuclear transfer embryos. Serum-starved skin cells were electrofused to enucleated oocytes, activated 1-5 hr after fusion, and cultured in vitro. Some fused eggs were fixed at each time point after fusion without activation, or 3 or 7 hr after activation. Some nocodazole treated zygotes were fixed to analyze their chromosome constitutions. The proportion of eggs with a morphologically normal premature chromosome condensation (PCC) state increased 1-2 hr after fusion. Whereas eggs with elongated chromosome plate increased as activation time was prolonged to 3 hr, and 5 hr after fusion, 58.1% of eggs showed more than two scattered chromosome sets. The proportion of eggs with a single chromatin mass (40.6-56.7%) significantly increased when eggs were activated within 2.5 hr after fusion (P < 0.05). Only 23.3% of reconstituted embryos activated 5 hr after fusion formed one pronucleus-like structure (PN), whereas, 64.5-78.3% of embryos activated 1-2.5 hr after fusion formed one PN. The proportion of embryos with normal chromosome constitutions decreased as activation time was prolonged. Development rates to the blastocyst stage were higher in eggs activated within 2 hr after fusion (17.3-21.7%) compared to those of others (0-8.6%, P < 0.05). The result of the present study suggests that activation time can affect the chromatin structure and in vitro development of bovine nuclear transfer embryos.

Serial pronuclear transfer increases the developmental potential of in vitro-matured oocytes in mouse cloning

In vitro-matured germinal vesicle oocytes are an interesting source of cytoplast recipients in both animal and human nuclear transfer (NT) experiments. We investigated two technical aspects that might improve the developmental potential of nuclear transfer mouse embryos constructed from in vitro-matured germinal vesicle oocytes. In a first step, the effect of two maturation media on the embryonic development of NT embryos originating from in vitro-matured oocytes was compared. Supplementation of the oocyte maturation medium with serum and gonadotrophins improved the developmental rate of NT embryos constructed from in vitro-matured oocytes, but it was still inferior to that obtained with in vivo-matured metaphase II (MII) oocytes. Second, we investigated the effect of serial pronuclear transfer from NT zygotes originating from both in vitro- and in vivo-matured oocytes to in vivo-fertilized zygotic cytoplasts. Blastocyst quality was evaluated by counting nuclei from trophectoderm and inner cell mass cells using a differential staining. Sequential pronuclear transfer significantly improved the blastocyst formation rate of NT embryos originating from in vitro-matured oocytes up to the rate obtained with in vivo-matured MII oocytes. We conclude that the developmental potential of NT embryos constructed from in vitro-matured oocytes can be optimized by serial pronuclear transfer to in vivo-produced zygotic cytoplasts.

Transgenic pig expressing the enhanced green fluorescent protein produced by nuclear transfer using colchicine-treated fibroblasts as donor cells

Fetal-derived fibroblast cells were transduced with replication defective vectors containing the enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP). The transgenic cells were treated with colchicine, which theoretically would synchronize the cells into G2/M stage, and then used as donor nuclei for nuclear transfer. The donor cells were transferred into the perivitalline space of enucleated in vitro matured porcine oocytes, and fused and activated with electrical pulses. A total of 8.3% and 28.6% of reconstructed oocytes showed nuclear envelope breakdown and premature chromosome condensation 0.5 and 2 hr after activation, respectively. Percentage of pronuclear formation was 62.5, 12 hr after activation. Most (91.4%) of the 1-cell embryos with pronuclei did not extrude a polar body. Most (77.2%) embryos on day 5 were diploid. Within 2 hr after fusion, strong fluorescence was detectable in most reconstructed oocytes (92.3%). The fluorescence in all NT embryos became weak 15 hr after fusion and disappeared when culture to 48 hr. But from day 3, cleaved embryos at the 2- to 4-cell stage started to express EGFP again. On day 7, 85.8% of cleaved embryos expressed EGFP. A total of 9.4% of reconstructed embryos developed to blastocyst stage and 71.5% of the blastoctysts expressed EGFP. After 200 reconstructed 1-cell stage embryos were transferred into four surrogate gilts, three recipients were found to be pregnant. One of them maintained to term and delivered a healthy transgenic piglet expressing EGFP. Our data suggest that the combination of transduction of somatic cells by a replication defective vector with the nuclear transfer of colchicine-treated donors is an alternative to produce transgenic pigs. Furthermore, the tissues expressing EGFP from descendents of this pig may be very useful in future studies using pigs that require genetically marked cells.

Oct4 distribution and level in mouse clones: consequences for pluripotency

Somatic cell clones often fail at a developmental stage coincident with commencement of differentiation. The transcription factor Oct4 is expressed during cleavage stages and is essential for the differentiation of the blastocyst. Oct4 expression becomes restricted to the inner cell mass and epiblast. After gastrulation Oct4 is active only in germ cells and is silent in somatic cells. Here, Oct4 and an Oct4-GFP transgene were used as markers for which gene reprogramming could be directly related to the developmental potential of somatic cell clones. Cumulus cell clones initiated Oct4 expression at the correct stage but showed an incorrect spatial expression in the majority of blastocysts. The ability of clones to form outgrowths was reduced, and the outgrowths had low or even undetectable levels of Oct4 RNA or GFP. The quality of GFP signals in blastocysts correlated with the ability to generate outgrowths that maintain GFP expression and the frequency of embryonic stem (ES) cell derivation. Abnormal Oct4 expression in clones is either directly or indirectly caused by reprogramming errors and is indicative of a general failure to reset the genetic program. The abnormal Oct4 expression may be associated with aberrant expression of other crucial developmental genes, leading to abnormalities at various embryonic stages. Regardless of other genes, the variations observed in Oct4 levels alone account for the majority of failures currently observed for somatic cell cloning.

Effect of elevated Ca(2+) concentration in fusion/activation medium on the fusion and development of porcine fetal fibroblast nuclear transfer embryos

The present study examined the effect of elevated Ca(2+) concentration in fusion/activation medium on the fusion and development of fetal fibroblast nuclear transfer (NT) porcine embryos. Frozen-thawed and serum starved fetal fibroblasts were transferred into the perivitelline space of enucleated oocytes. Cell fusion and activation were induced simultaneously with electric pulses in 0.3 M mannitol-based medium containing 0.1 or 1.0 mM CaCl(2). Some fused embryos were further activated 1 hr after the fusion treatment by exposure to an electric pulse. The NT embryos were cultured in vitro for 6 days. Fusion and blastocyst formation rates were significantly (P<0.05) increased by increasing the Ca(2+) concentration from 0.1 mM (67.1 and 6.3%) to 1.0 mM (84.7 and 15.8%). However, no difference in the number of cells in blastocysts was observed between the two groups. A higher percentage of blastocyst was also observed when control oocytes were parthenogenetically activated in the presence of elevated Ca(2+) (19.3% vs. 32.4%, P<0.05). When the reconstituted oocytes were fused in the medium containing 1.0 mM CaCl(2), increasing the number of pulses from 2 to 3 or an additional activation treatment did not enhance the blastocyst formation rate or cell number in blastocysts. These results demonstrate that increasing the Ca(2+) concentration in the fusion/activation medium can enhance the fusion and blastocyst formation rates of fetal fibroblast NT porcine embryos without an additional activation treatment.

Feasibility of producing porcine nuclear transfer embryos by using G2/M-stage fetal fibroblasts as donors

The type of donor cell most suitable for producing cloned animals is one of the topics under debate in the field of nuclear transfer. To provide useful information to answer this question, G2/M- and G0/G1-stage fetal fibroblasts were used as donor cells for nuclear transfer. In vitro-matured oocytes derived from abattoir ovaries were used as recipient cytoplasts. In both groups, nuclear envelope breakdown and premature chromosome condensation were completed within 1-2 h after donor cells were injected into the cytoplasm of oocytes. Microtubules were organized around condensed chromosomes and formed a spindle within 1-1.5 h after activation. Decondensation of chromosomes could be seen within 2-4 h after activation. Reformation of the new nuclear envelope occurred 4-6 h after activation and was followed by nuclear swelling and formation of a pronucleus-like structure (PN) 8-12 h after activation. Most (80.6%) of the reconstructed oocytes derived from G2/M cells extruded polar body-like structures (PB). However, a much lower frequency of PB (21.7%) was observed in the reconstructed oocytes derived from G0/G1 donors. A variety of PN and PB combinations were observed in reconstructed oocytes derived from G2/M-stage donors, including 1PN+0PB, 1PN+1PB, 1PN+2PB, 2PN+0PB, 2PN+1PB, 2PN+2PB, and 3PN+1PB. Chromosomes of most embryos (10/13) derived from G2/M stage were diploid. The percentage of cleavage and blastocysts and the average nuclear number of blastocysts in the G2/M and G0/G1 groups were not different. These results demonstrate that the G2/M stage can be morphologically remodeled by cytoplasm of MII oocytes in pigs. To maintain normal ploidy, the extra chromosomes derived from G2/M-stage cells could be expelled by oocytes as a second polar body. G2/M-stage fibroblast nuclei could direct reconstructed embryos to develop to the blastocyst stage.

Effects of maturational age of porcine oocytes on the induction of activation and development in vitro following somatic cell nuclear transfer

To determine the effect of maturational age of porcine oocytes on the induction of activation and development following nuclear transfer, we investigated maturation rate and efficacy of oocyte activation treatment with an electrical stimulus (ES) and cycloheximide (CHX) at various timing of maturation culture. Most oocytes developed to the metaphase II (MII) stage after 32 hr of maturation culture. Both in newly matured (32 and 36 hr of age) and MII-arrested (42 and 48 hr of age) oocytes, ES followed by exposure to CHX for 6 hr caused higher rates of pronuclear formation than ES alone. Effect of maturational age of oocytes on the development of parthenotes activated with ES and CHX was then examined. The highest percentage of parthenotes developed to blastocysts was obtained when ES was added at 42 hr of culture. Finally, newly matured (33 hr of age) and MII-arrested oocytes (44 hr of age) were enucleated, fused with serum-starved pig fetal fibroblasts and activated with ES and CHX around suitable timing (39 to 40 hr of age) or later (50 to 51 hr of age), respectively. The frequencies of cleavage (58.8%) and blastocyst formation (13.6%) of newly matured oocytes were significantly (P<0.05) higher than those of MII-arrested oocytes (38.9 and 1.8%, respectively). These results demonstrated that the development of porcine nuclear transfer embryos can be improved by using complete matured oocytes as cytoplasts and activation treatment with ES followed by CHX treatment.

Mammalian cloning: advances and limitations

For many years, researchers cloning mammals experienced little success, but recent advances have led to the successful cloning of several mammalian species. However, cloning by the transfer of nuclei from adult cells is still a hit-and-miss procedure, and it is not clear what technical and biological factors underlie this. Our understanding of the molecular basis of reprogramming remains extremely limited and affects experimental approaches towards increasing the success rate of cloning. Given the future practical benefits that cloning can offer, the time has come to address what should be done to resolve this problem.

in vitro development of porcine enucleated oocytes reconstructed by the transfer of porcine fetal fibroblasts and cumulus cells

In the pig little information is available on cytoplasmic events during the reprogramming of oocytes reconstructed with somatic nuclei. The present study was conducted to determine the developmental potential of porcine cumulus cells (CC) and fetal fibroblasts (FF) after they were transferred into enucleated oocytes. Non-quiescent FF were fused to the enucleated oocytes using electrical pulse, whereas CC were directly injected into the oocytes. Transferred nuclei from both CC and FF underwent premature chromosome condensation (PCC), nuclear swelling and pronucleus formation. The remodeled oocytes developed to the mitotic and 2-cell stage at 18 to 24 h after nuclear transfer. The pattern of nuclear remodeling was similar regardless of the sources of karyoplasts or nuclear transfer methods. However, using FF, 24% of nuclear transferred embryos developed to the morula or blastocyst stage, whereas only 8% of those using CC developed to the morula or blastocyst stage. These results suggest that porcine oocyte cytoplasm can successfully reprogram somatic cell nuclei and support the development of nuclear transferred embryos to the blastocyst stage.

Behavior of M-phase synchronized blastomeres after nuclear transfer in cattle

M-phase synchronized bovine blastomeres were used to study the effect of nuclear-cytoplasmic synchronization on the developmental potential after nuclear transfer (NT). The capacity of nocodazole and benomyl to reversibly synchronize blastomeres from embryos in M-phase was evaluated. Nocodazole reversibly arrested bovine embryos at the studied stages and induced high rates of M-phases in morulae and compact morulae. In contrast, benomyl was less efficient than nocodazole to synchronize in M-phase. After transfer of an M-phase blastomere, premature chromatin condensation was the prevalent finding 1 hr post-fusion (hpf). Condensed chromosomes non-arranged in the equatorial plate (1-3 hpf) that acquired an organized structure over time (3-7 hpf) were subsequently observed. Anaphase-telophase structures were predominantly recorded at 4-9 hpf. About 50% of the embryos activated at both 3-4 and 6-7 hpf extruded a polar body-like structure 5 hr after activation, but this was not observed in embryos activated immediately after fusion. A significantly lower activation rate was observed for oocytes activated 3-4 hpf compared to those activated 6-7 hpf. However, the ability to undergo first cleavage was significantly lower in the latter group. Reconstructed embryos activated immediately after fusion showed no difference in the rate of activation compared to those activated 6-7 hpf, although the cleavage rate was higher. DNA synthesis was observed at a significantly higher rate in embryos activated both immediately and 3-4 hpf that did not extrude a PB-like structure than in those activated 3-4 hpf that extruded a polar body-like structure. Under the conditions tested M-phase donor cells cannot be properly remodeled after NT in cattle to trigger normal embryonic development. Our observations of chromatin structures together with DNA synthesis suggest that the failure in the development may be due to improper chromatin remodeling of mitotic nuclei after NT, which may result in chromosomal abnormalities incompatible with normal embryo development.

A reliable, noninvasive technique for spindle imaging and enucleation of mammalian oocytes

Factors affecting the efficiency of animal cloning remain to be elucidated. Enucleation of recipient oocytes is a critical step in cloning procedures and typically is performed by aspirating a portion of the cytoplasm underlying the first polar body. Enucleation is evaluated using epifluorescence after Hoechst staining for DNA, which may disrupt functions of the cytoplast, especially mitochondria. Mitochondrial DNA in Dolly and other cloned sheep has been shown to derive exclusively from recipient oocytes. Not only might evaluation of the aspirated karyoplast portion inadequately reflect the state of the cytoplast, it is also time consuming. Here we report a reliable, noninvasive technique for spindle imaging and enucleation of oocytes using a new microscope, the Pol-Scope. The efficiency of enucleation was 100%, and only 5.5% of the oocytes' mitochondria entered the karyoplast upon Pol-Scope-directed removal of the spindle. Moreover, Pol-Scope imaging of spindles and micromanipulation did not compromise the developmental competence of reconstituted oocytes and cytoplasts.

Adult cloning in cattle: potential of nuclei from a permanent cell line and from primary cultures

Nuclear transfer was used to evaluate the developmental potential of nuclei from a spontaneously immortalized bovine mammary gland epithelial cell line (MECL) and from primary cultures of mammary gland cells (PMGC) and ear skin fibroblasts (PESF) established from 3-year-old cows. Cell proliferation was investigated by incorporation and detection of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU). The proportion of cells in S-phase was significantly (P < 0.05) higher for MECL cells than for PMGC and PESF, both in the presence of serum (90% vs. 28% and 15%) and following serum starvation (27% vs. 6% and 3%). Nuclei from PESF supported the development of reconstructed embryos to the blastocyst stage significantly better than those of PMGC (60% vs. 26%; P < 0.05). Embryos reconstructed with cells from MECL failed to develop to blastocysts. After transfer of embryos derived from PMGC and PESF, respectively, 2/2 and 5/12 recipients were pregnant on day 42. On day 90, the corresponding pregnancy rates were 2/2 and 3/12. One live calf derived from a PMGC was born at day 287 of gestation. Another live PESF-derived calf was delivered by caesarean section at day 286 of gestation. Our study suggests that nuclei from primary cultures of adult cells can be successfully reprogrammed by nuclear transfer, whereas nuclei from a permanent cell line failed to support the development of nuclear transfer embryos.

Bovine oocyte cytoplasm supports development of embryos produced by nuclear transfer of somatic cell nuclei from various mammalian species

The transfer of nuclei from one cell to another provides a powerful tool for studying the interactions between the cytoplasm of one cell and the nucleus of another. This study was designed to examine the ability of the bovine metaphase oocyte cytoplasm to support mitotic cell cycles under the direction of differentiated somatic cell nuclei of various mammalian species. Skin fibroblast cells from cows, sheep, pigs, monkeys, and rats were used as sources of donor nuclei. Nuclear transfer units produced by fusion of enucleated bovine oocytes and individual fibroblasts from all species examined underwent transition to interphase accompanied by nuclear swelling, further progression through the cell cycle, and completion of the first mitosis. Regardless of the species of donor fibroblasts used, some cleaving units progressed further and developed to advanced stages, as evidenced by continuation of cell proliferation and formation of a blastocoele cavity at the time appropriate for the donor fibroblast species. Although no pregnancies have been carried to term after transfer of embryos into surrogate animals, these observations suggest that mechanisms regulating early embryonic development may be conserved among mammalian species and that bovine oocyte cytoplasm can support the introduced differentiated nucleus regardless of chromosome number, species, or age of the donor fibroblast.

Potential of fetal germ cells for nuclear transfer in cattle

The developmental potential of bovine fetal germ cells was evaluated using nuclear transfer. Male and female germ cells at three stages of fetal development from 50- to 57-, 65- to 76- or 95- to 105-day-old fetuses were fused to enucleated oocytes 2 to 4 hr prior to activation with 7% ethanol (5 min) followed by 5 hr culture in 10 microg/ml cycloheximide and 5 microg/ml cytochalasin B. The in vitro development of nuclear transfer embryos derived from germ cells was compared with those derived from embryonic cells (blastomeres from day 5 or day 6 embryos). Blastocyst rate (38%) obtained with germ cells from 50- to 57-day-old fetuses tended to be higher than when using germ cells from 65- to 76- or 95- to 105-day-old fetuses (23% and 20%, respectively). Within each stage of fetal development, the proportion of blastocysts derived from male germ cells tended to be higher than that obtained with female germ cells, but due to the high variation between individual fetuses this difference was not significant. With the post activation procedure used in this study, germ cells from 50- to 57-day-old fetuses supported the development of nuclear transfer embryos to the blastocyst stage significantly (P<0.05) better than nuclei of embryonic cells (38% vs. 3%). After transfer of blastocysts derived from germ cells of 50-to 57- and 65- to 76-day fetuses, respectively, 45% (5/11) and 50% (3/6) recipients were pregnant on day 30. The corresponding pregnancy rates on day 90 were 36% (4/11) and 17%(1/6). One live male calf was delivered by cesarean section at day 277 of gestation. Our results show that nuclei of bovine fetal germ cells may successfully be reprogrammed to support full-term development of nuclear transfer embryos.

Nuclear transfer in mammals: recent developments and future perspectives

A clone can be defined as a set of genetically identical animals. Small clones of two or occasionally up to four identical animals can be obtained by embryo splitting or blastomere separation. Embryo cloning by nuclear transfer involves the transfer of genetic material from a donor cell (karyoplast) to the cytoplasm of an oocyte or zygote from which the genetic material has been removed (cytoplast). In farm animals, metaphase II oocytes are most widely used as cytoplasts. There are now many factors known to influence the efficiency of embryo cloning by nuclear transfer. These include stage of development and cell cycle of donor cells, the choice of the recipient cell, the methods for activation of oocytes, the cell cycle coordination between donor cell and recipient cytoplast, and the method for fusion between nuclear donor and recipient cytoplast. Recent progress in cloning embryos and animals from cultured cells of embryonic, fetal, or adult origin offers a wide spectrum of potential applications of nuclear transfer, such as the unlimited multiplication of elite embryos or animals from selected matings and the potential for precise genetic modification of farm animals for gene farming or xenotransplantation.

Cloning: new breakthroughs leading to commercial opportunities

Research on cloning animals, again, came to the forefront of public attention in 1997. Most scientists involved in biomedical and agricultural research have emphasized the benefits, of which there are many, of cloning to the public. Basic studies on nuclear transfer have and will continue to contribute to our understanding of how genomic activation and cell cycle synchrony affect nuclear reprogramming and cloning efficiencies, specifically. Also, more basic information on actual mechanisms and specific factors in the oocyte causing nuclear reprogramming is forthcoming. As new molecular approaches in functional genomics are combined with nuclear transfer experiments, new genes involved in nuclear reprogramming will be found. The commercial potentials of products stemming from discoveries in cloning are vast. Cloning will be a more efficient, faster and more useful way of making transgenic fetuses for cell therapies, adult animals for protein production and organs for xenotransplantation. Clearly there are new opportunities in animal cloning technology that will produce many benefits to society.

The behaviour of mitotic nuclei after transplantation to early meiotic ooplasts or mitotic cytoplasts

This study evaluates the ability of the cytoplasm to determine the nature of the division cycle (meiotic or mitotic) in nuclei obtained from mitotically dividing cells. Using mouse oocytes in different stages of development two types of cytoplasm were prepared: firstly, early meiotic ooplasts were obtained by enucleation of non-matured, prophase-stage oocytes; secondly, mitotic cytoplasts were prepared by enucleation and activation of metaphase II (MII)-stage oocytes. These two types of cytoplasts were then used in fusion experiments, in which mouse primitive type A spermatogonia (prospermatogonia) or mouse fibroblasts were used as a source of donor nuclei. While the fusion of prospermatogonia with mitotic cytoplasts resulted, as expected, in normal premature chromosome condensation (PCC) and subsequent pronuclear formation (58.1%), the majority of hybrids obtained by fusion of prospermatogonia with early meiotic ooplasts (40.3%) displayed unique morphology consisting of two sets of chromosomes organised in two spindle centres connected by microtubules. Each set of chromosomes contained the haploid (1n) number of chromosomes as revealed by chromosome analyses. The same morphology was observed also in 44.2% of hybrids in which the differentiated nuclei of fibroblasts were used as a source of donor mitotic nuclei. In both cases the hybrids were blocked at this stage with high activity of maturation promoting factor (MPF), resistant to any kind of activation and not able to undergo further development. These results suggest that the early meiotic ooplasm was able to induce the initiation of a meiosis-like reducing division in mitotic nuclei originating both from the germline cells and from more differentiated somatic cells.

Nuclear transfer in sheep embryos: the effect of cell-cycle coordination between nucleus and cytoplasm and the use of in vitro matured oocytes

The developmental ability of nuclear transplant sheep embryos derived from in vitro matured oocytes was studied by controlling cell-cycle coordination of donor embryonic nuclei and recipient cytoplasts. Oocytes were recovered from nonatretic antral follicles of adult sheep ovaries and cocultured with follicle shells in M199-based medium supplemented with gonadotrophins in a nonstatic system. Effective activation if IVM oocytes was obtained by applying two pulses of 1.0 kv/cm 22 min apart in inositol-based electroporation medium to oocytes matured in vitro for 27 hr. Synthesis of DNA (S-phase) was assessed by BrdU incorporation and was found to initiate around 5 hpa (hours postactivation) and to persist until 18 hpa. Mitotic blastomeres were induced by treating embryos with 6.6 microM nocodazole for 14-17 hr. Three types of transfers were compared directly: "S-->S," early embryonic nuclei (mostly in S-phase) were transferred to presumptive S-phase cytoplasts; "M-->MII," nocodazole-treated embryonic nuclei (most in M-phase) were transferred to MII-phase cytoplasts; and control (S-->MII), conventional nuclear transfer of fusion and activation simultaneously. The results showed that fusion and recovery rates did not differ among the three groups. However, after 6 days of in vivo culture, the morula and blastocyst formation rate was significantly higher for the M-->MII combination than for the control (28.3% vs. 8.1%, P < 0.05), while no significant differences in developmental rate were observed between S-->S and M-->MII, and between S-->S and control, though developmental rate was also increased for S-->S compared to control (20.9% vs. 8.1%, P > 0.05). Transfer of blastocysts derived from M-->MII or S-->S nuclear cytoplasmic reconstitution to synchronized recipient ewes resulted in the birth of lambs. These data suggest that in vitro matured oocytes can support full-term development of nuclear transplant sheep embryos when the cell cycle of nucleus and cytoplasm is coordinated, and that M-->MII nuclear transfer might be an efficient and simple way to improve the developmental competence of the reconstituted embryos.

In vivo aging of oocytes influences the behavior of nuclei transferred to enucleated rabbit oocytes

The present study examined nuclear remodeling in rabbit nuclear transfer (NT) embryos formed from metaphase II (MII) oocytes aged in vivo until 19 hr postcoitum (hpc), enucleated, and fused at 22-26 hpc with 32-cell morula blastomeres by means of electric fields, which also induced recipient oocyte activation. Post-activation events observed during the first hour following the fusion/activation pulse were studied in terms of chromatin, lamins, and microtubules, and revealed that transferred nuclei underwent premature chromosomes condensation (PCC) in only one-third of NT embryos and remained in interphase in others. Recipient oocytes were mostly not activated by manipulations performed before the fusion/activation pulse. The persistence of transferred nuclei in interphase resulted from the rapid progression of recipient oocytes to interphase after activation, suggesting that the cytoplasmic state of MII oocytes aged in vivo was poised for the approach to interphase. Studying microtubular organization in MII oocytes before nuclear transfer manipulations, we found that 19 hpc MII oocytes aged in vivo differed from 14 hpc MII oocytes (freshly ovulated) and from 19-hpc MII oocytes aged in vitro (collected at 14 hpc and cultured for 5 hr), notably by the presence of microtubule asters and tubulin foci or only tubulin foci dispersed throughout the cytoplasm. When PCC was avoided, remodeling of the transferred nucleus was well advanced 1 hr after nuclear transfer, and NT embryos developed better to the blastocyst stage.

Nuclear transplantation in mammals: remodelling of transplanted nuclei under the influence of maturation promoting factor

Whilst the role of Maturation or M-phase Promoting Factor (MPF) as a universal M-phase regulator is well documented, much less attention has been paid to its role in nuclear transplantation experiments and especially to its influence upon remodelling of transplanted nuclei. There is currently wide acceptance that successful nuclear transplantation using differentiated nuclei is possible only in a cytoplasmic environment that is capable of inducing rapid nuclear de-differentiation to a pronuclear-like form. In this review our purpose is firstly, to outline the conditions under which such remodelling can be induced, and secondly, to extend the debate to include a consideration of whether complete nuclear remodelling is an absolute necessity for clonal development.

Quantitative control of gene expression by nucleocytoplasmic interactions in early mouse embryos: consequence for reprogrammation by nuclear transfer

HSP 70.1 is one of the first genes to be expressed in the mouse embryo at the time of zygotic genome activation. We studied the regulation of this gene, using a transgene associating HSP 70.1 promoter and the firefly luciferase reporter gene, which allows the precise quantification of HSP 70.1 level of expression on individual embryos. In the present work, we show first that the level of HSP 70.1 expression at the two-cell stage is significantly higher (around two-fold) in embryos whose maternal cytoplasm is from C3H strain than with BALB/c strain. We verified that this difference is not an artefact of the use of transgenic embryos, of the time of first cleavage, or of in vitro culture. This regulation of HSP 70.1 level of expression is controlled by strain-specific maternal modifiers and is independent of replication, syngamy, and mitosis. Following nuclear transfer, reactivation of HSP 70.1 is also subjected to the same epigenetic influence. Only the strain-of-origin of the recipient cytoplast modulates the level of HSP 70.1 reprogrammation; the origin of donor nucleus is not significant, demonstrating the reversibility of this strain effect. These results point out the importance of the quality of recipient cytoplast in the intensity of gene reprogrammation, which may be of importance for nuclear transfer efficiency.

Nuclear transplantation of ectodermal cells in pig oocytes: ultrastructure and radiography

This study investigated the changes in nucleolar fine structure and the synthesis of both heterogeneous nuclear RNA (hnRNA) and ribosomal RNA (rRNA) in pig reconstructed embryos obtained by electrofusion of a single pig ectodermal cell to an enucleated metaphase-II oocyte. The nucleolar morphological changes and the pattern of transcription were examined in the ectodermal cells before fusion and in the nuclear transfer reconstructed embryos 16-18 hr after fusion. Before fusion the ectodermal cells exhibited a reticulated nucleolus with active RNA synthesis. In the reconstructed embryos, modifications of the nucleolar structure were observed, as assessed by the presence of either round-shaped, compact, dense nucleolar precursor bodies, or reticulated nucleoli. However, in both cases there was no RNA synthesis. Blebbing activity of the nuclear envelope was not observed. These results indicate that the nucleus of pig ectodermal cells exhibited either a complete or an incomplete remodelling when transferred to an enucleated metaphase-II oocyte, with no detectable RNA synthesis. Cell-cycle synchronization of ectodermal cell donor nuclei may play an important role in nuclear reprogramming after fusion.

Transcriptional activity and nucleolar ultrastructure of embryonic rabbit nuclei after transplantation to enucleated oocytes

Changes in the level of transcriptional activity in 32-cell stage morula nuclei were studied after blastomere electrofusion to enucleated oocytes. Nuclear transplant recipients were pulse labelled with 3H-uridine during cultivation in vitro, embryos were then fixed and processed for autoradiography and electron microscopy. Transcriptional activity substantially decreased after 4.5 hr and was completely inhibited at last 15 hr after fusion. Transcription resumed thereafter in two-cell stage embryos and could be detected in both nuclei from 70% of the embryos analyzed. Transcription activity rapidly increased at the eight 16-cell stages, reaching the level typical for 32-cell stage nuclei used for the transfer. Changes in nucleolar ultrastructure after the nuclear transfer reflected the inhibition and subsequent reactivation of rRNA transcription. Nucleoli of 32-cell embryos had a typical structure of active nucleoli; many fibrillar centers surrounded and interconnected by threads of the dense fibrillar component and embedded in the granular component. Six hours following nuclear transplantation, these nucleoli underwent drastic changes including loss of granular material, collapse of nucleolar structure, and segregation of nucleolar components. Following the first cleavage, segregated fibrillar components of nucleoli manifested a complete inhibition of nucleolar transcription. Ribosomal RNA transcription was restored at the eight-cell stage and the sequence of ultrastructural changes was similar to that of the normal development. However, at the 32-cell stage, excessive extrusion of pre-ribosomal particles in the cytoplasm occurred, suggesting a possible alteration in regulating mechanisms of ribosome delivery. These results show that after fusion with enucleated metaphase II cytoplasm and subsequent activation, transcription is inhibited in donor embryonic nuclei and progressively increases again during cleavage; almost as in normal embryos. Migration of ribosomes into cytoplasm appears more intense in 32-cell stage reconstituted embryos but this does not seem to inhibit blastocyst building.