Genetic analysis of sperm function in fertilization

Spam1-associated transmission ratio distortion in mice: elucidating the mechanism

BACKGROUND

While transmission ratio distortion, TRD, (a deviation from Mendelian ratio) is extensive in humans and well-documented in mice, the underlying mechanisms are unknown. Our earlier studies on carriers of spontaneous mutations of mouse Sperm Adhesion Molecule 1 (Spam1) suggested that TRD results from biochemically different sperm, due to a lack of transcript sharing through the intercellular cytoplasmic bridges of spermatids. These bridges usually allow transcript sharing among genetically different spermatids which develop into biochemically and functionally equivalent sperm.

OBJECTIVES

The goals of the study were to provide support for the lack of sharing (LOS) hypothesis, using transgene and null carriers of Spam1, and to determine the mechanism of Spam1-associated TRD.

METHODS

Carriers of Spam1-Hyal5 BAC transgenes were mated with wild-type female mice and the progeny analyzed for TRD by PCR genotyping. Sperm from transgene and Spam1 null carriers were analyzed using flow cytometry and immunocytochemistry to detect quantities of Spam1 and/or Hyal5. Transgene-bearing sperm with Spam1 overexpression were detected by fluorescence in situ hybridization. In wild-type animals, EM studies of in situ transcript hybridization of testis sections and Northern analysis of biochemically fractionated testicular RNA were performed to localize Spam1 transcript. Finally, AU-rich motifs identified in the 3' UTR of Spam1 RNA were assayed by UV cross-linking to determine their ability to interact with testicular RNA binding proteins.

RESULTS

The Tg8 line of transgene carriers had a significant (P < 0.001) TRD, due to reduced fertilizing ability of transgene-bearing sperm. These sperm retained large cytoplasmic droplets engorged with overexpressed Spam1 or Hyal5 protein. Caudal sperm from transgene carriers and caput sperm of null carriers showed a bimodal distribution of Spam1, indicating that the sperm in a male were biochemically different with respect to Spam1 quantities. Spam1 RNA was absent from the bridges, associated exclusively with the ER, and was shown to be anchored to the cytoskeleton. This compartmentalization of the transcript, mediated by cytoskeletal binding, occurs via protein interactions with 3' UTR AU-rich sequences that are likely involved in its stabilization.

CONCLUSION

We provide strong support for the LOS hypothesis, and have elucidated the mechanism of Spam1-associated TRD.

Lack of Sharing of Spam1 (Ph-20) among Mouse Spermatids and Transmission Ratio Distortion1

Gametic equality is thought to exist, despite haploid gene action in mammalian spermiogenesis, because of product sharing via the intercellular bridges of conjoined spermatids. However, mice carrying different t-alleles have been known to produce functionally different sperm, leading to transmission ratio distortion (TRD), whose mechanism is unknown. The reduced Spam1 mRNA levels, previously shown to be associated with TRD and reduced fertility in mice carrying the Rb(6.16) or the Rb(6.15) Robertsonian translocation, are reflected in the levels of its encoded membrane protein (Spam1) and its accompanying insoluble hyaluronidase activity. Studies of the temporal expression pattern of Spam1 reveal that it is haploid expressed, with both the RNA and protein first appearing on Day 21.5. RNA fluorescence in situ hybridization and immunocytochemistry show both the mRNA and the protein to be compartmentalized. Compartmentalization of the mRNA along with its immediate translation and insertion of the protein in the plasma membrane suggests the nonsharing of Spam1 transcripts among spermatids, resulting in functionally different sperm in males with different Spam1 alleles. Evidence for biochemically different sperm in these heterozygous males was revealed by flow cytometry and confocal microscopy. Our findings support the notion that the Spam1 antigen is not shared, and we may have uncovered a mechanism for TRD.

Sertoli cell-specific rescue of fertility, but not testicular pathology, in Dax1 (Ahch)-deficient male mice

DAX1 is an orphan member of the nuclear hormone receptor superfamily of transcription factors. Our recent characterization of Dax1 (Ahch)-deficient male mice revealed a primary testicular defect resulting in hypogonadism and sterility. The progressive degeneration of the germinal epithelium, independent of abnormal gonadotropin and testosterone production, suggested an intrinsic loss of Dax1 function in the Sertoli cells. To test this hypothesis, we assessed the effect of Sertoli cell-specific expression of a human DAX1 (AHC) transgene driven using the promoter of the Müllerian inhibiting substance (MIS) gene. The MIS-DAX1 transgene partially rescued the mutant phenotype of the Dax1-deficient male mice. Although testicular morphology remained abnormal, fertility was restored to levels matching that of wild-type littermates. Examination of several markers of sperm fertilizing capability revealed significant improvements in MIS-DAX1-rescued mice. Epididymal sperm count and sperm motility were greater in 12-week-old rescued mice than in age-matched Dax1-deficient mice. The ability of sperm to undergo an immediate acrosome reaction was impaired in Dax1-deficient animals, and sperm from Dax1-deficient mice fertilized only 8.2 +/- 6.8% of eggs in vitro, significantly less than rescue (67.8 +/- 19.1%) and wild-type (88.9 +/- 3.9%) sperm. These results indicate that Dax1 expression in Sertoli cells is adequate to overcome crucial thresholds related to sperm production and function. However, the failure to completely rescue the testicular pathology of Dax1-deficient mice suggests that Dax1 expression in other somatic cells is essential for normal testicular development.

Failure of founder transgenic male mice to transmit an attenuated HSV thymidine kinase transgene results from mosaicism and sperm competition

Previously we found that male mice carrying either of two attenuated herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase reporter transgenes displayed low level ectopic expression of the reporter gene in the testis and, although fertile, exhibited reduced fecundity. In contrast to males of later generations, many of the founder males failed to transmit the transgene to their progeny. This led to the suggestion that these fertile non-transmitting males are mosaic, with the sperm developing from the non-transgenic lineage outperforming those from the heterozygous transgenic lineage. Here we present the results of artificial insemination (AI) and in vitro fertilization (IVF) experiments designed to test this hypothesis. Albino CF(1) hybrid females were inseminated with mixtures of equal numbers of sperm from heterozygous transgenic (HT) males (equivalent to C57BL/6 x CBAF(2)) and CF(1) males. Similar mixed inseminations were carried out in parallel with sperm from non-transgenic (NT) siblings of the HT mice and 13-day fetuses were scored by eye color to determine their paternity. The pooled data from five experiments gave ratios of CF(1) to HT and CF(1) to NT offspring of 8.13 and 0.22 respectively, implying a calculated HT to NT ratio of 0.027. This indicates that, in competition with each other, the NT sperm would be almost 40 times more successful in fertilization than the HT sperm. Smaller differences were observed between HT and NT when AI was performed with unmixed sperm, consistent with the fertility of HT non-founder males. However, in five IVF experiments carried out with unmixed sperm, 142/212 oocytes exposed to NT sperm were activated and divided, while only 8/226 oocytes treated with HT sperm reached the two-cell stage. This confirms that HT sperm are defective and indicates that the IVF method employed amplified these deficiencies, which may have only a small effect upon natural reproduction when the HT sperm are not in competition with normal sperm.

Wise, winsome, or weird? Mechanisms of sperm storage in female animals

Female sperm storage is an integral part of the reproductive pattern of many species. In the female, sperm become sequestered in specialized storage organs or reservoirs, where they may remain for several days, weeks, months, or years before being used to fertilize eggs. Several different but interrelated mechanisms are used by animals to target the sperm to the portion of the female genital tract adapted for sperm storage. Both males and females influence this process. This review describes themes among the mechanisms and molecules necessary for sperm to become efficiently stored in females and the roles that the female storage organs play in the nourishment, protection, and release of stored sperm.

The murine Spam1 gene: RNA expression pattern and lower steady-state levels associated with the Rb(6.16) translocation

Recently we mapped the murine Spam1 gene to the proximal region of chromosome 6 (MMU 6). Based on the map location and physiological characteristics of its encoded sperm antigen, the gene is an attractive candidate for the sperm dysfunction seen in Rb(6.16) translocation heterozygotes and the reduced fertility of homozygotes. We have analyzed the expression of Spam1 mRNA in normal and Rb(6.16) mice. The expression of Spam1 mRNA was found to be: 1) tissue specific; it is expressed exclusively in testis; and 2) developmentally regulated, with a haploid expression. Notably, the steady-state mRNA level of Spam1 in Rb(6.16) homozygotes was 25-30% of that in chromosomally normal consomic mice and those homozygous for Rb(2.8) (7.18). In Rb(6.16) and Rb(6.15) heterozygotes the levels were 61% and 66% of the normal. Studies are currently under way to determine the protein levels and gene structure of Spam1, to detect the underlying cause of the mRNA reduction associated with these translocations.

Comparison of detergent-solubilized membrane and soluble proteins from flow cytometrically sorted X- and Y-chromosome bearing porcine spermatozoa by high resolution 2-D electrophoresis

The only known and measurable difference between X- and Y-chromosome bearing spermatozoa is the small difference in their DNA content. The X sperm in the human carry 2.8% more DNA than the Y sperm, while in domestic livestock this difference ranges from 3.0 to 4.2%. The only successful sperm separation method, flow cytometric sorting, is based on this difference in DNA content. Using this technique, X and Y sperm populations with purities greater than 90% can be obtained. The number of spermatozoa that can be sorted in a given time period, however, is too low for application of this technique in routine artificial insemination. Therefore, the search for a marker other than DNA to differentiate between X and Y sperm remains of interest in order to develop a method for large scale X and Y sperm separation. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether porcine X and Y sperm contain some difference in their plasma membrane proteins. The flow cytometric sorting of sperm enabled a direct comparison of the proteins of the X and Y sperm populations. High resolution two-dimensional (2-D) electrophoresis was used; however, adaptations were needed to enable its use for analysis of proteins of flow cytometrically sorted sperm, both in the sorting procedure, membrane protein solubilization, and in the 2-D electrophoresis. Up to 1000 protein spots per gel could be detected and quantified. Comparison of the 2-D protein patterns revealed differences in protein spots between sperm of two individual boars. However, no differences in protein spots between the X and Y sperm fractions were found. These results provide additional support for the view that X- and Y-chromosome bearing spermatozoa are phenotypically identical, and cast doubt on the likelihood that a surface marker can provide a base for X and Y sperm separation.

Mutation of a putative sperm membrane protein in Caenorhabditis elegans prevents sperm differentiation but not its associated meiotic divisions

Spermatogenesis in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans uses unusual organelles, called the fibrous body-membranous organelle (FB-MO) complexes, to prepackage and deliver macromolecules to spermatids during cytokinesis that accompanies the second meiotic division. Mutations in the spe-4 (spermatogenesis-defective) gene disrupt these organelles and prevent cytokinesis during spermatogenesis, but do not prevent completion of the meiotic nuclear divisions that normally accompany spermatid formation. We report an ultrastructural analysis of spe-4 mutant sperm where the normally close association of the FB's with the MO's and the double layered membrane surrounding the FB's are both defective. The internal membrane structure of the MO's is also disrupted in spe-4 mutant sperm. Although sperm morphogenesis in spe-4 mutants arrests prior to the formation of spermatids, meiosis can apparently be completed so that haploid nuclei reside in an arrested spermatocyte. We have cloned the spe-4 gene in order to understand its role during spermatogenesis and the molecular basis of how mutation of this gene disrupts this process. The spe-4 gene encodes an approximately 1.5-kb mRNA that is expressed during spermatogenesis, and the sequence of this gene suggests that it encodes an integral membrane protein. These data suggest that mutation of an integral membrane protein within FB-MO complexes disrupts morphogenesis and prevents formation of spermatids but does not affect completion of the meiotic nuclear divisions in C. elegans sperm.

Inactivation of a sperm motility gene by insertion of an epidermal growth factor receptor transgene whose product is overexpressed and compartmentalized during spermatogenesis

Transgenic mice were generated with a human epidermal growth factor (EGF) receptor cDNA driven by the chicken beta-actin gene promoter. One line (AE24) that exhibited a unique expression pattern in which dramatically elevated levels of EGF receptor RNA were found only in the testis was established, suggesting that the beta-actin promoter was being influenced by an adjacent testis-specific enhancer. EGF receptor RNA was detected in primary spermatocytes, whereas the synthesis of receptor protein was restricted to elongate spermatids, indicating that transgene expression was under translational control. At spermiation, the EGF receptor was sequestered in residual bodies and excluded from mature sperm by a compartmentalization mechanism. About half of AE24 homozygous males were sterile because of sperm paralysis, whereas heterozygous males and females of either genotype were completely fertile. Electron microscopic analysis of sperm flagella from sterile AE24 homozygotes revealed an aberrant axonemal structure in which outer doublet microtubules were missing from the middle piece, resembling changes observed in the sperm of some infertile humans. Flagellar axonemal disassembly was observed in the vas deferens and epididymis but not in the testis, suggesting that outer doublets were assembled in a grossly normal manner but possessed a latent instability. These results demonstrate that in the AE24 mouse line the EGF receptor transgene was integrated into and inactivated an endogenous autosomal gene, causing sperm flagellar axonemal disruption and male sterility.

Protamine transcript sharing among postmeiotic spermatids

Sharing of cytoplasmic constituents through intercellular bridges connecting postmeiotic spermatids can allow for functional equivalence of genetically nonequivalent spermatids. The technique of in situ hybridization was used to study postmeiotic distribution of transcripts from the mouse protamine 1 (Prm-1) gene among spermatids of mice with chromosomally unbalanced gametes. The Prm-1 gene is located on chromosome 16 and is expressed exclusively in haploid spermatids. Mice doubly heterozygous for two Robertsonian translocations involving chromosome 16 were used for the study of postmeiotic accumulation of transcripts of the Prm-1 gene in spermatogenic cells. The meiotic segregation pattern of chromosomal homologues in these mice produces some spermatids that are chromosomally unbalanced; some spermatids lack chromosome 16 while others have two. In situ hybridization with a cDNA probe for the Prm-1 gene transcript performed on both whole testis sections and spermatogenic cell suspensions showed that there was no statistical difference in distribution of grains over step-5 to step-10 spermatids from Robertsonian-translocation heterozygous mice and from control mice of normal karyotype. These results are consistent with sharing of transcripts of the Prm-1 gene among spermatids within a syncytium.

Evidence for an increased sensitivity to Ca2+ in the flagella of sperm from tw32/+mice

The majority of sperm from mice carrying the tw32 haplotype undergo hyperactivation sooner than sperm from +/+ mice of the same strains (Olds-Clarke, Dev Biol 131:475-482, 1989). To investigate the mechanism underlying this abnormal motility, the Ca2+ sensitivity of their flagellar apparatus was compared to that of age- and strain-matched controls using Triton X-100-extracted sperm. Under these conditions, the curvature of the sperm flagellum is controlled by the free calcium concentration. Sperm from mice carrying the tw32 haplotype consistently exhibited a change in flagellar curvature at lower free calcium concentrations than controls. In addition, intact sperm from tw32/+ mice were much more likely than congenic control sperm to have a hook-like bend in the midpiece, which persisted throughout most of the beat cycle. Sperm exhibiting the hooked middle piece could be converted to a more normal appearance by 2 mM procaine, which immobilizes cytoplasmic calcium. Thus an increased sensitivity of the sperm motor apparatus to calcium could be the cause of the precocious hyperactivation of sperm from mice carrying the tw32 haplotype.

Cross-fertilization between Syrian and Chinese hamsters

The role of the zona pellucida in the specificity of fertilization was studied by cross-inseminations between Syrian (Golden) and Chinese hamster gametes. Cumulus-enclosed eggs from both Syrian and Chinese hamsters were placed together in one dish and inseminated with spermatozoa from either one or the other species. Fertilization always took place between gametes of homologous species. Chinese hamster spermatozoa failed to bind to the zona pellucida of Syrian hamster eggs; hence, fertilization was never observed. However, Chinese hamster spermatozoa could fertilize zona-free Syrian hamster eggs. In the reciprocal cross, a large number of Syrian hamster spermatozoa could bind to and penetrate the zonae of Chinese hamster eggs. However, fusion of Syrian hamster spermatozoa with the vitellus of zona-intact Chinese hamster eggs was never observed. After removal of the zona pellucida, only a small percentage (31%) of Syrian hamster spermatozoa could fuse with Chinese hamster vitelli. Thus, in these species, the mechanisms of interspecific gamete recognition and the prevention of interspecies fertilization seem to differ according to the direction of the cross. In Syrian hamster eggs, the block to interspecies fertilization seems to exist at the level of the zona pellucida, while in Chinese hamster eggs the block is at the level of the egg plasma membrane. The implications of these results in analyses of the genetics of spermatozoa, the molecular basis of sperm-egg recognition, and mechanisms of reproductive isolation leading to speciation, are discussed.

Failure of spermatozoa from T/t mice to fertilize in vitro is overcome by zona drilling

Failure of epididymal spermatozoa from T/t mutant mice, but not from t/t individuals, to fertilize oocytes in vitro was partially overcome by opening a small aperture in the zona pellucida with acidified Tyrode's solution to permit direct access of the spermatozoon to the vitellus. This study provides a model system to evaluate requirements for successful zona drilling in the treatment of human infertility and further insights into the effects of the t complex on sperm fertility.

Sperm from tw32/+ mice: capacitation is normal, but hyperactivation is premature and nonhyperactivated sperm are slow

The t complex in the mouse is a large group of linked genes that affect sperm function in fertilization. In t/+ males, sperm carrying the t complex (t sperm) have normal fertilizing ability, while sperm carrying the normal homolog (+t sperm) are dysfunctional (P. Olds-Clarke and B. Peitz, 1985, Genet. Res. 47, 49). The specific step in fertilization which is dysfunctional, however, is not known. Two characteristics of fertilizing sperm, capacitation (the process by which sperm become capable of undergoing the acrosome reaction) and hyperactivation (the change in swimming behavior concomitant with capacitation), were assayed by objective methods in epididymal sperm from tw32/+ males of two strains, and compared to sperm from +/+ males of the same strains. Capacitated and acrosome-reacted sperm were identified by a chlortetracycline assay (C.R. Ward and B.T. Storey, 1984, Dev. Biol. 104, 287). Hyperactivated sperm were identified by their path shape and swimming speed, using a computer-assisted motion-analysis system (J.M. Neill and P. Olds-Clarke, 1987, Gamete Res. 18, 121). Hyperactivation occurred significantly sooner among sperm from tw32/+ mice than among sperm from +/+ mice of the same strain, while the rates and maximal levels of capacitation and spontaneous acrosome reactions were normal. Of the nonhyperactivated motile sperm from tw32/+ mice, almost all were slower than sperm from +/+ mice of the same strain. While the effect of premature hyperactivation on fertilization is not clear, slow movements are likely to impair fertilizing ability. These results raise the possibility that the slow sperm are the dysfunctional +t sperm.

Genetically haploid spermatids are phenotypically diploid

Because chromosomal homologues segregate from one another during meiosis, spermatids are genetically different. Post-meiotic gene expression could lead to gametic differences, some of which might lead to preferential transmission of certain alleles over others. In both insects and mammals, however, all the cells derived from a single spermatogonial cell develop within a common syncytium formed as a result of incomplete cytokinesis at each of the mitotic and meiotic cell divisions. It has been proposed that the intercellular bridges connecting the cells, which are about 1 micron in diameter, permit the sharing of cytoplasmic constituents, thus ensuring the synchronous development of a clone of cells and gametic equivalence between haploid spermatids. By analysing the product of a transgene which is expressed exclusively in post-meiotic germ cells in hemizygous transgenic mice, we have shown that genetically distinct spermatids share the product of the transgene and hence can be phenotypically equivalent.