Toward whole-cortex enhancement with an ultrahigh dielectric constant helmet at 3T

A review of recent developments and applications of high-permittivity dielectric shimming in magnetic resonance

We present a review outlining the basic mechanism, background, recent technical developments, and clinical applications of aqueous dielectric padding in the field of MRI. Originally meant to be a temporary solution, it has gained traction as an effective method for correcting B1 + inhomogeneities due to the unique properties of the calcium titanate and barium titanate perovskites used. Aqueous dielectric pads have used a variety of high-permittivity materials over the years to improve the quality of MRI acquisitions at 1.5 and 3 T and more recently for 7 T neuroimaging applications. The technical development and assessment of these pads have been advanced by an increased use of mathematical modeling and electromagnetic simulations. These tools have allowed for a more complete understanding of the physical interactions between dielectric pads and the RF coil, making testing and safety assessments more accurate. The ease of use and effectiveness that dielectric pads offer have allowed them to become more commonplace in tackling imaging challenges in more clinically focused environments. More recently, they have seen usage not only in anatomical imaging methods but also in specialized metabolic imaging sequences such as GluCEST and NOEMTR . New colossally high-permittivity materials have been proposed; however, practical utilization has been a continued challenge due to unfavorable frequency dependences as well as safety limitations. A new class of metasurfaces has been under development to address the shortcomings of conventional dielectric padding while also providing increased performance in enhancing MRI images.

B 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ inhomogeneity correction of volumetric brain NOEMTR via high permittivity dielectric padding at 7 T

PURPOSE

Nuclear Overhauser effect magnetization transfer ratio (NOEMTR ) is a technique used to investigate brain lipids and macromolecules in greater detail than other techniques and benefits from increased contrast at 7 T. However, this contrast can become degraded because ofB 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ inhomogeneities present at ultra-high field strengths. High-permittivity dielectric pads (DP) have been used to correct for these inhomogeneities via displacement currents generating secondary magnetic fields. The purpose of this work is to demonstrate that dielectric pads can be used to mitigateB 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ inhomogeneities and improve NOEMTR contrast in the temporal lobes at 7 T.

METHODS

Partial 3D NOEMTR contrast images and whole brainB 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ field maps were acquired on a 7 T MRI across six healthy subjects. Calcium titanate DP, having a relative permittivity of 110, was placed next to the subject's head near the temporal lobes. Pad corrected NOEMTR images had a separate postprocessing linear correction applied.

RESULTS

DP provided supplementalB 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ to the temporal lobes while also reducing theB 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ magnitude across the posterior and superior regions of the brain. This resulted in a statistically significant increase in NOEMTR contrast in substructures of the temporal lobes both with and without linear correction. The padding also produced a convergence in NOEMTR contrast toward approximately equal mean values.

CONCLUSION

NOEMTR images showed significant improvement in temporal lobe contrast when DP were used, which resulted from an increase inB 1 + $$ {\mathrm{B}}_1^{+} $$ homogeneity across the entire brain slab. DP-derived improvements in NOEMTR are expected to increase the robustness of the brain substructural measures both in healthy and pathological conditions.

Radiofrequency safety of high permittivity pads in MRI-Impact of insulation material

PURPOSE

High permittivity dielectric pads are known to be effective for tailoring the RF field and improving image quality in high field MRI. Despite a number of studies reporting benign specific absorption rate (SAR) effects, their "universal" safety remains an open concern. In this work, we evaluate the impact of the insulation material in between the pad and the body, using both RF simulations as well as phantom experiments.

METHODS

A 3T configuration with high permittivity material was simulated and characterized experimentally in terms of B₁ ⁺ fields and RF power absorption, both with and without electrical insulation in between the high permittivity material and the sample. Different insulation conditions were compared, and electromagnetic analyses on the induced current density were performed to elucidate the effect.

RESULTS

Increases in RF heating of up to 49% were observed experimentally in a tissue-mimicking phantom after removing the material insulation. The B₁ ⁺ magnitude and RF transceive phase were not affected. Simulations indicated that an insulation thickness of 0.5-2 mm should be accounted for in numerical models in order to ensure reliable results.

CONCLUSION

A reliable RF safety assessment of high permittivity dielectric pads requires accounting for the insulating properties of the plastic encasing. Ignoring the electrical insulation can lead to erroneous results with substantial increases in local SAR at the interface. Conversely, the material insulation does not need to be modeled to predict the B₁ ⁺ effects during the design of the pad geometry.

Multi-feed, loop-dipole combined dielectric resonator antenna arrays for human brain MRI at 7 T

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether a multi-feed, loop-dipole combined approach can be used to improve performance of rectangular dielectric resonator antenna (DRA) arrays human brain for MRI at 7 T.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Electromagnetic field simulations in a spherical phantom and human voxel model "Duke" were conducted for different rectangular DRA geometries and dielectric constants ε_r. Three types of RF feed were investigated: loop-only, dipole-only and loop-dipole. Additionally, multi-channel array configurations up to 24-channels were simulated.

RESULTS

The loop-only coupling scheme provided the highest B₁⁺ and SAR efficiency, while the loop-dipole showed the highest SNR in the center of a spherical phantom for both single- and multi-channel configurations. For Duke, 16-channel arrays outperformed an 8-channel bow-tie array with greater B₁⁺ efficiency (1.48- to 1.54-fold), SAR efficiency (1.03- to 1.23-fold) and SNR (1.63- to 1.78). The multi-feed, loop-dipole combined approach enabled the number of channels increase to 24 with 3 channels per block.

DISCUSSION

This work provides novel insights into the rectangular DRA design for high field MRI and shows that the loop-only feed should be used instead of the dipole-only in transmit mode to achieve the highest B₁⁺ and SAR efficiency, while the loop-dipole should be the best suited in receive mode to obtain the highest SNR in spherical samples of similar size and electrical properties as the human head.

Repeatability of B1 + inhomogeneity correction of volumetric (3D) glutamate CEST via High-permittivity dielectric padding at 7T

PURPOSE

Ultra-high field MR imaging lacks B1 + inhomogeneity due to shorter RF wavelengths used at higher field strengths compared to human anatomy. CEST techniques tend to be highly susceptible to B1 + inhomogeneities due to a high and uniform B1 + field being necessary to create the endogenous contrast. High-permittivity dielectric pads have seen increasing usage in MR imaging due to their ability to tailor the spatial distribution of the B1 + field produced. The purpose of this work is to demonstrate that dielectric materials can be used to improve glutamate weighted CEST (gluCEST) at 7T.

THEORY AND METHODS

GluCEST images were acquired on a 7T system on six healthy volunteers. Aqueous calcium titanate pads, with a permittivity of approximately 110, were placed on either side in the subject's head near the temporal lobes. A post-processing correction algorithm was implemented in combination with dielectric padding to compare contrast improvement. Tissue segmentation was performed to assess the effect of dielectric pads on gray and white matter separately.

RESULTS

GluCEST images demonstrated contrast enhancement in the lateral temporal lobe regions with dielectric pad placement. Tissue segmentation analysis showed an increase in correction effectiveness within the gray matter tissue compared to white matter tissue. Statistical testing suggested a significant difference in gluCEST contrast when pads were used and showed a difference in the gray matter tissue segment.

CONCLUSION

The use of dielectric pads improved the B1 + field homogeneity and enhanced gluCEST contrast for all subjects when compared to data that did not incorporate padding.

Novel materials in magnetic resonance imaging: high permittivity ceramics, metamaterials, metasurfaces and artificial dielectrics

This article reviews recent developments in designing and testing new types of materials which can be: (i) placed around the body for in vivo imaging, (ii) be integrated into a conventional RF coil, or (iii) form the resonator itself. These materials can improve the quality of MRI scans for both in vivo and magnetic resonance microscopy applications. The methodological section covers the basic operation and design of two different types of materials, namely high permittivity materials constructed from ceramics and artificial dielectrics/metasurfaces formed by coupled conductive subunits, either in air or surrounded by dielectric material. Applications of high permittivity materials and metasurfaces placed next to the body to neuroimaging and extremity imaging at 7 T, body and neuroimaging at 3 T, and extremity imaging at 1.5 T are shown. Results using ceramic resonators for both high field in vivo imaging and magnetic resonance microscopy are also shown. The development of new materials to improve MR image quality remains an active area of research, but has not yet found significant use in clinical applications. This is mainly due to practical issues such as specific absorption rate modelling, accurate and reproducible placement, and acceptable size/weight of such materials. The most successful area has been simple “dielectric pads” for neuroimaging at 7 T which were initially developed somewhat as a stop-gap while parallel transmit technology was being developed, but have continued to be used at many sites. Some of these issues can potentially be overcome using much lighter metasurfaces and artificial dielectrics, which are just beginning to be assessed.

Recommendations of Choice of Head Coil and Prescan Normalize Filter Depend on Region of Interest and Task

The performance of MRI head coils together with the influence of the prescan normalize filter in different brain regions was evaluated. Functional and structural data were recorded from 26 participants performing motor, auditory, and visual tasks in different conditions: with the 20- and 64-channel Siemens head/neck coil and the prescan normalize filter turned ON or OFF. Data were analyzed with the MRIQC tool to evaluate data quality differences. The functional data were statistically evaluated by comparison of the β estimates and the time-course signal-to-noise ratio (tSNR) in four regions of interest, i.e., the auditory, visual, and motor cortices and the thalamus. The MRIQC tool indicated a better data quality for both functional and structural data with the prescan normalize filter, with an advantage for the 20-channel head coil in functional data and an advantage for the 64-channel head coil in structural measurements. Nevertheless, recommendations for the functional data regarding choice of head coils and prescan normalize filter depend on the brain regions of interest. Higher β estimates and tSNR values occurred in the auditory cortex and thalamus with the prescan normalize filter, whereas the contrary was true for the visual and motor cortices. Due to higher β estimates in the visual cortex in the 64-channel head coil, this head coil is recommended for studies investigating the visual cortex. For most of the research questions, the 20-channel head coil is better suited for functional experiments, with the prescan normalize filter, especially when investigating deep brain areas. For anatomical studies, the 64-channel head coil seemed to be the better choice.

Displacement current distribution on a high dielectric constant helmet and its effect on RF field at 10.5 T (447 MHz)

PURPOSE

Investigating the designs and effects of high dielectric constant (HDC) materials in the shape of a conformal helmet on the enhancement of RF field and reduction of specific absorption rate at 10.5 T for human brain studies.

METHODS

A continuous and a segmented four-piece HDC helmet fit to a human head inside an eight-channel fractionated-dipole array were constructed and studied with a phantom and a human head model using computer electromagnetic simulations. The simulated transmit efficiency and receive sensitivity were experimentally validated using a phantom with identical electric properties and helmet-coil configurations of the computer model. The temporal and spatial distributions of displacement currents on the HDC helmets were analyzed.

RESULTS

Using the continuous HDC helmet, simulation results in the human head model demonstrated an average transmit efficiency enhancement of 66%. A propagating displacement current was induced on the continuous helmet, leading to an inhomogeneous RF field enhancement in the brain. Using the segmented four-piece helmet design to reduce this effect, an average 55% and 57% enhancement in the transmit efficiency and SNR was achieved in human head, respectively, along with 8% and 28% reductions in average and maximum local specific absorption rate.

CONCLUSION

The HDC helmets enhanced the transmit efficiency and SNR of the dipole array coil in the human head at 10.5 T. The segmentation of the helmet to disrupt the continuity of circumscribing displacement currents in the helmet produced a more uniform distribution of the transmit field and lower specific absorption rate in the human head compared with the continuous helmet design.

Improved whole-brain SNR with an integrated high-permittivity material in a head array at 7T

PURPOSE

To demonstrate that strategic use of materials with high electric permittivity along with integrated head-sized coil arrays can improve SNR in the entire brain.

METHODS

Numerical simulations were used to design a high-permittivity material (HPM) helmet for enhancing SNR throughout the brain in receive arrays of 8 and 28 channels. Then, two 30-channel head coils of identical geometry were constructed: one fitted with a prototype helmet-shaped ceramic HPM helmet, and the second with a helmet-shaped low-permittivity shell, each 8-mm thick. An eight-channel dipole array was used for excitation. In vivo maps of excitation flip angle and SNR were acquired.

RESULTS

Simulation results showed improvement in transmit efficiency by up to 65% and in receive-side SNR by up to 47% on average through the head with use of an HPM helmet. Experimental results showed that experimental transmit efficiency was improved by approximately 56% at the center of brain, and experimental receive-side SNR (SNR normalized to flip angle) was improved by approximately 21% on average through orthogonal planes through the cerebrum, including at the center of the brain, with the HPM.

CONCLUSION

Although HPM is used increasingly to improve transmit efficiency locally in situations in which the transmit coil and imaging volume are much larger than the HPM, here we demonstrate that HPM can also be used to improve transmit efficiency and receive-side SNR throughout the brain by improving performance of a head-sized receive array. This includes the center of the brain, where it is difficult to improve SNR by other means.