Invited review: myoblast transfer: a possible therapy for inherited myopathies?

Stem cell therapy for muscular dystrophies

Muscular dystrophies are a heterogeneous group of genetic diseases, characterized by progressive degeneration of skeletal and cardiac muscle. Despite the intense investigation of different therapeutic options, a definitive treatment has not been developed for this debilitating class of pathologies. Cell-based therapies in muscular dystrophies have been pursued experimentally for the last three decades. Several cell types with different characteristics and tissues of origin, including myogenic stem and progenitor cells, stromal cells, and pluripotent stem cells, have been investigated over the years and have recently entered in the clinical arena with mixed results. In this Review, we do a roundup of the past attempts and describe the updated status of cell-based therapies aimed at counteracting the skeletal and cardiac myopathy present in dystrophic patients. We present current challenges, summarize recent progress, and make recommendations for future research and clinical trials.

The Satellite Cell at 60: The Foundation Years

The resident stem cell for skeletal muscle is the satellite cell. On the 50th anniversary of its discovery in 1961, we described the history of skeletal muscle research and the seminal findings made during the first 20 years in the life of the satellite cell (Scharner and Zammit 2011, doi: 10.1186/2044-5040-1-28). These studies established the satellite cell as the source of myoblasts for growth and regeneration of skeletal muscle. Now on the 60th anniversary, we highlight breakthroughs in the second phase of satellite cell research from 1980 to 2000. These include technical innovations such as isolation of primary satellite cells and viable muscle fibres complete with satellite cells in their niche, together with generation of many useful reagents including genetically modified organisms and antibodies still in use today. New methodologies were combined with description of endogenous satellite cells markers, notably Pax7. Discovery of the muscle regulatory factors Myf5, MyoD, myogenin, and MRF4 in the late 1980s revolutionized understanding of the control of both developmental and regerenative myogenesis. Emergence of genetic lineage markers facilitated identification of satellite cells in situ, and also empowered transplantation studies to examine satellite cell function. Finally, satellite cell heterogeneity and the supportive role of non-satellite cell types in muscle regeneration were described. These major advances in methodology and in understanding satellite cell biology provided further foundations for the dramatic escalation of work on muscle stem cells in the 21st century.

Sarcolemmal Complement Membrane Attack Complex Deposits During Acute Rejection of Myofibers in Nonhuman Primates

We have previously studied in nonhuman primates several aspects of the acute rejection of myofibers, including the histological characteristics, the mechanisms of myofiber elimination by the T cells, and the development of anti-donor antibodies. Here, we report the participation of the complement membrane attack complex (MAC) in this context. We used muscle sections of macaques from experiments of allogeneic muscle precursor cell transplantation with confirmed rejection of the graft-derived myofibers. Sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin, alizarin red and for immunodetection of MAC, CD8, CD4, C3, C4d, and immunoglobulins. The prominent finding was the presence of sarcolemmal MAC (sMAC) deposits in biopsies with ongoing acute rejection or with recent acute rejection. The numbers of sMAC-positive myofibers were variable, being higher when there was an intense lymphocyte infiltration. Few sMAC-positive myofibers were necrotic or had evidence of sarcolemma permeation. The immunodetection of C3, C4d, and immunoglobulins did not provide significant elements. In conclusion, sMAC deposits were related to myofiber rejection. The fact that the vast majority of sMAC-positive myofibers had no signs of necrosis or sarcolemmal permeation suggests that MAC would not be harmful to myofibers by itself.

Changes in Mass and Performance in Rabbit Muscles after Muscle Damage with or without Transplantation of Primary Satellite Cells

Changes in morphology, metabolism, myosin heavy chain gene expression, and functional performances in damaged rabbit muscles with or without transplantation of primary satellite cells were investigated. For this purpose, we damaged bilaterally the fast muscle tibialis anterior (TA) with either 1.5 or 2.6 ml cardiotoxin 10–5 M injections. Primary cultures of satellite cells were autotransplanted unilaterally 5 days after muscle degeneration. Two months postoperation, the masses of damaged TAs, with or without transplantation, were significantly larger than those of the controls. Furthermore, damaged transplanted muscles weighed significantly more than damaged muscles only. The increase in muscle mass was essentially due to increased fiber size. These results were independent of the quantity of cardiotoxin injected into the muscles. Maximal forces were similar in control and 2.6 ml damaged TAs with or without satellite cell transfer. In contrast, 1.5 ml damaged TAs showed a significant decrease in maximal forces that reached the level of controls after transplantation of satellite cells. Fatigue resistance was similar in control and 1.5 ml damaged TAs independently of satellite cell transfer. Fatigue index was significantly higher in 2.6 ml damaged muscles with or without cell transplantation. These changes could be explained in part by muscle metabolism, which shifted towards oxidative activities, and by gene expression of myosin heavy chain isoforms, which presented an increase in type IIa and a decrease in type I and IIb in all damaged muscles with or without cell transfer. Under our experimental conditions, these results show that muscle damage rather than satellite cell transplantation changes muscle metabolism, myosin heavy chain isoform gene expression, and, to a lesser extent, muscle contractile properties. In contrast, muscle weight and fiber size are increased both by muscle damage and by satellite cell transfer.

Cardiomyocyte Transplantation in a Porcine Myocardial Infarction Model

Transplantation of cardiomyocytes into the heart is a potential treatment for replacing damaged cardiac muscle. To investigate the feasibility and efficiency of this technique, either a cardiac-derived cell line (HL-1 cells), or normal fetal or neonatal pig cardiomyocytes were grafted into a porcine model of myocardial infarction. The myocardial infarction was created by the placement of an embolization coil in the distal portion of the left anterior descending artery in Yorkshire pigs (n = 9). Four to 5 wk after creation of an infarct, the three preparations of cardiomyocytes were grafted, at 1 × 106 cells/20 μL into normal and into the middle of the infarcted myocardium. The hearts were harvested and processed for histologic examinations 4 to 5 wk after the cell grafts. Histologic evaluation of the graft sites demonstrated that HL-1 cells and fetal pig cardiomyocytes formed stable grafts within the normal myocardium without any detrimental effect including arrhythmia. In addition, a marked increase in angiogenesis was observed both within the grafts and adjacent host myocardium. Electron microscopy studies demonstrated that fetal pig cardiomyocytes and the host myocardial cells were coupled with adherens-type junctions and gap junctions. Histologic examination of graft sites from infarct tissue failed to show the presence of grafted HL-1 cells, fetal, or neonatal pig cardiomyocytes. Cardiomyocyte transplantation may provide the potential means for cell-mediated gene therapy for introduction of therapeutic molecules into the heart.

Use of Repeating Dispensers to Increase the Efficiency of the Intramuscular Myogenic Cell Injection Procedure

Intramuscular myoblast transplantation in humans and nonhuman primates requires precise repetitive cell injections very close to each other. Performed with syringes operated manually throughout large regions, this procedure takes a lot of time, becoming tiring and thus imprecise. We tested two repetitive dispensers with Hamilton syringes as cell injection devices to facilitate this procedure. Monkeys received intramuscular allotransplantations of β-galactosidase-labeled myoblasts, using either a monosyringe or a multisyringe repeating dispenser. The monosyringe repeating dispenser allowed performing cell injections faster and easier than with a manually operated syringe. The multisyringe dispenser accelerated the procedure still more, but it was not ergonomic. Biopsies of the myoblast-injected sites 1 month later showed abundant β-galactosidase-positive myofibers, with the same density and morphological pattern observed following myoblast transplantation with a syringe operated manually. We recommend the monosyringe repeating dispenser for myoblast transplantation in skeletal muscles and maybe in the heart.

Myoblast Transplantation: What's Going on?

Muscle tissue, due to its syncytial cellular structure and specific nerve and vascular requirements, cannot be transplanted as an organ. In an effort to use transplantation to overcome genetically determined biochemical deficiencies in muscle, attention has focused on delivering the developmental precursors of mature muscle fibers, myoblasts, as donor cells for cellular transplantation. Consequent to a brief report showing limited success of the technique in mice in 1988, human trials were summarily designed, funded, and initiated. The human trials have spurred more controversy than concrete data, with more reports appearing in the popular press than in scientific journals. This review summarizes the events leading to the current state of affairs, and underscores the biological hurdles facing myoblast transplantation before it can be considered a therapeutic modality.

A Potential Alternative Strategy for Myoblast Transfer Therapy: The use of Sliced Muscle Grafts

Excellent long-term survival (up to 1 yr) of donor skeletal muscle cells was demonstrated using a mouse Y-chromosome specific probe, following the transplantation of grafts of whole muscles from male “normal” C57B1/10Sn mice into dystrophic muscles of female host mice. After the transplantation of equivalent sliced muscle grafts there was extensive movement of the male donor cells and fusion with host myofibres. This contrasts with the extremely poor survival of isolated myoblasts after injection into the same mouse model for Duchenne muscular dystrophy. The use of sliced muscle grafts may therefore represent a potential alternative approach to myoblast transfer therapy.

Isolation of Type I and Type II Pericytes from Mouse Skeletal Muscles

Pericytes are perivascular multipotent cells that show heterogeneity in different organs or even within the same tissue. In skeletal muscles, there are at least two pericyte subpopulations (called type I and type II), which express different molecular markers and have distinct differentiation capabilities. Using NG2-DsRed and Nestin-GFP double-transgenic mice, type I (NG2-DsRed⁺Nestin-GFP^-) and type II (NG2-DsRed⁺Nestin-GFP⁺) pericytes have been successfully isolated. However, the availability of these double-transgenic mice prevents the widespread use of this purification method. This work describes an alternative protocol that allows for the easy and simultaneous isolation of type I and type II pericytes from skeletal muscles. This protocol utilizes the fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) technique and targets PDGFRβ, rather than NG2, together with the Nestin-GFP signal. Following isolation, type I and type II pericytes show distinct morphologies. In addition, type I and type II pericytes isolated with this new method, like those isolated from the double-transgenic mice, are adipogenic and myogenic, respectively. These results suggest that this protocol can be used to isolate pericyte subpopulations from skeletal muscles and possibly from other tissues.

MMP1 gene expression enhances myoblast migration and engraftment following implanting into mdx/SCID mice

Myoblast transplantation (MT) is a method to introduce healthy genes into abnormal skeletal muscle. It has been considered as a therapeutic modality in the last few decades for diseases such as Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD). However, challenges including cell death and poor graft engraftment have limited its application. The current experiment utilizes MMP1 gene transfer to improve the efficacy of myoblast transplantation into the diseased dystrophic skeletal muscle of mdx mice. Our results indicated that MMP1 expression can promote myogenic differentiation and fusion capacities, increase migration of MMP1 expressing myoblasts in vitro, as well as improve engraftment of dystrophin positive myofibers in vivo. Taken together, our observation suggests that the addition of MMP1 can overcome limitations in MT and improve its clinical efficacy.

Laminin regulates PDGFRβ(+) cell stemness and muscle development

Muscle-resident PDGFRβ⁺ cells, which include pericytes and PW1⁺ interstitial cells (PICs), play a dual role in muscular dystrophy. They can either undergo myogenesis to promote muscle regeneration or differentiate into adipocytes and other cells to compromise regeneration. How the differentiation and fate determination of PDGFRβ⁺ cells are regulated, however, remains unclear. Here, by utilizing a conditional knockout mouse line, we report that PDGFRβ⁺ cell-derived laminin inhibits their proliferation and adipogenesis, but is indispensable for their myogenesis. In addition, we show that laminin alone is able to partially reverse the muscle dystrophic phenotype in these mice at the molecular, structural and functional levels. Further RNAseq analysis reveals that laminin regulates PDGFRβ⁺ cell differentiation/fate determination via gpihbp1. These data support a critical role of laminin in the regulation of PDGFRβ⁺ cell stemness, identify an innovative target for future drug development and may provide an effective treatment for muscular dystrophy.

Muscle PDGFRβ⁺ cells are interstitial stem/progenitor cells with myogenic potential. Here, Yao et al. show that PDGFRβ⁺ cell-derived laminin actively regulates their proliferation, differentiation and fate determination.

Invited review: Stem cells and muscle diseases: advances in cell therapy strategies

Despite considerable progress to increase our understanding of muscle genetics, pathophysiology, molecular and cellular partners involved in muscular dystrophies and muscle ageing, there is still a crucial need for effective treatments to counteract muscle degeneration and muscle wasting in such conditions. This review focuses on cell-based therapy for muscle diseases. We give an overview of the different parameters that have to be taken into account in such a therapeutic strategy, including the influence of muscle ageing, cell proliferation and migration capacities, as well as the translation of preclinical results in rodent into human clinical approaches. We describe recent advances in different types of human myogenic stem cells, with a particular emphasis on myoblasts but also on other candidate cells described so far [CD133+ cells, aldehyde dehydrogenase-positive cells (ALDH+), muscle-derived stem cells (MuStem), embryonic stem cells (ES) and induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS)]. Finally, we provide an update of ongoing clinical trials using cell therapy strategies.

First study of intra-arterial delivery of myogenic mononuclear cells to skeletal muscles in primates

The main challenge of cell transplantation as a treatment of myopathies is the large amount of tissue to treat. Intravascular delivery of cells may be an ideal route if proven to be effective and safe. Given the importance of nonhuman primates for preclinical research in transplantation, we tested the intra-arterial injection of β-galactosidase (β-Gal)-labeled myoblasts in macaques. Cells were injected into one of the femoral arteries in seven monkeys. Some muscle sites were damaged concomitantly in three monkeys. Various organs and muscles were sampled 1 h, 1 day, 12 days, 3 weeks, and 5 weeks after transplantation. Samples were analyzed by histology. Most β-Gal(+) cells were observed in the capillaries and arterioles of muscles and other tissues of the leg homolateral to the cell injection. Groups of necrotic myofibers in the proximity of an arteriole plugged by a β-Gal(+) embolus were interpreted as microinfarcts. Scarce β-Gal(+) cells were observed in the lungs 1 h and 1 day posttransplantation. No β-Gal(+) cells were observed in other organs or muscles. β-Gal(+) myofibers were observed 12 days, 3 weeks, and 5 weeks after transplantation in muscles of the leg after the cell injection, in sites that were damaged at the time of cell injection. In conclusion, most intra-arterially injected myoblasts were retained in vessels of the leg homolateral to the cell injection site, and they fused with myofibers in regions in which there was a process of myofiber regeneration. This manuscript is published as part of the International Association of Neurorestoratology (IANR) special issue of Cell Transplantation.

BIOLOGICAL INTERVENTION BASED ON CELL AND GENE THERAPY TO IMPROVE MUSCLE HEALING AFTER LACERATION

Muscle laceration is a challenging problem in traumatology and is common in sports injuries, with functional recovery remaining slow and incomplete. Even though muscles retain their ability to regenerate after injury, muscles' healing process after such injuries has been found to be very slow and often leads to incomplete muscle recovery. Growth factors may have a role in enhancing recovery. Our previous study showed that IGF-1, β-FGF and NGF can improve myoblast proliferation and differentiation in vitro. We then investigated whether the delivery of IGF-1 would improve muscle healing after injuries. We observed that muscle regeneration was enhanced in lacerated muscles treated with IGF-1 protein, which consequently led to an improvement in muscle healing. However, the rapid clearance and short biological half-lives of these proteins may have limited the success of this approach. We then investigated the efficiency of gene therapy based on adenovirus to deliver a stable expression of the growth factor IGF-1. Although a slight improvement in the healing process occurred in the muscle injected with adenovirus (AIGF), the combination of myoblast transplantation and gene therapy with the ex vivo approach further improved the healing process. The injection of normal myoblasts into the injured muscle led to the best improvement of muscle healing at two weeks post-injection. Implantation of normal minced muscle into mdx mice was also capable of improving muscle healing at 2–4 weeks post-implantation. These studies will further our understanding of muscle healing post-injury and help in the development of strategies to promote efficient muscle healing and complete functional recovery after common muscle injuries.

An absolute requirement for Pax7-positive satellite cells in acute injury-induced skeletal muscle regeneration

Skeletal muscle tissue provides mechanical force for locomotion of all vertebrate animals. It is prone to damage from acute physical trauma and physiological stress. To cope with this, it possesses a tremendous capacity for rapid and effective repair that is widely held to be accomplished by the satellite cells lying between the muscle fiber plasmalemma and the basement membrane. Cell transplantation and lineage-tracing studies have demonstrated that Pax7-expressing (Pax7(+)) satellite cells can repair damaged muscle tissue repeatedly after several bouts of acute injury. These findings provided evidence that Pax7(+) cells are muscle stem cells. However, stem cells from a variety of other origins are also reported to contribute to myofibers upon engraftment into muscles, questioning whether satellite cells are the only stem cell source for muscle regeneration. Here, we have engineered genetic ablation of Pax7(+) cells to test whether there is any significant contribution to muscle regeneration after acute injury from cells other than this source. We find that such elimination of Pax7(+) cells completely blocks regenerative myogenesis either following injury to the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle or after transplantation of extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscles into nude mice. As Pax7 is specifically expressed in satellite cells, we conclude that they are essential for acute injury-induced muscle regeneration. It remains to be established whether there is any significant role for stem cells of other origins. The implications of our results for muscle stem cell-based therapy are discussed.

Progress in therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is a devastating muscular dystrophy of childhood. Mutations in the dystrophin gene destroy the link between the internal muscle filaments and the extracellular matrix, resulting in severe muscle weakness and progressive muscle wasting. There is currently no cure and, whilst palliative treatment has improved, affected boys are normally confined to a wheelchair by 12 years of age and die from respiratory or cardiac complications in their twenties or thirties. Therapies currently being developed include mutation-specific treatments, DNA- and cell-based therapies, and drugs which aim to modulate cellular pathways or gene expression. This review aims to provide an overview of the different therapeutic approaches aimed at reconstructing the dystrophin-associated protein complex, including restoration of dystrophin expression and upregulation of the functional homologue, utrophin.

Generation of skeletal muscle stem/progenitor cells from murine induced pluripotent stem cells

Induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells, which are a type of pluripotent stem cell generated from reprogrammed somatic cells, are expected to have potential for patient-oriented disease investigation, drug screening, toxicity tests, and transplantation therapies. Here, we demonstrated that murine iPS cells have the potential to develop in vitro into skeletal muscle stem/progenitor cells, which are almost equivalent to murine embryonic stem cells. Cells with strong in vitro myogenic potential effectively were enriched by fluorescence-activated cell sorting using the anti-satellite cell antibody SM/C-2.6. Furthermore, on transplantation into mdx mice, SM/C-2.6(+) cells exerted sustained myogenic lineage differentiation in injured muscles, while providing long-lived muscle stem cell support. Our data suggest that iPS cells have the potential to be used in clinical treatment of muscular dystrophies.

Matrix metalloproteinase-1 promotes muscle cell migration and differentiation

Injured skeletal muscle has the capacity to regenerate through a highly coordinated sequence of events that involves both myoblast migration and differentiation into myofibers. Fibrosis may impede muscle regeneration by posing as a mechanical barrier to cell migration and fusion, providing inappropriate signals for cell differentiation, and limiting vascular perfusion of the injury site, subsequently leading to incomplete functional recovery. Our previous studies demonstrated that matrix metalloproteinase-1 (MMP-1) is able to digest fibrous scar tissue and improve muscle healing after injury. The goal of this study is to investigate whether MMP-1 could further enhance muscle regeneration by improving myoblast migration and differentiation. In vitro wound healing assays, flow cytometry, reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), and Western blot analyses demonstrated that MMP-1 enhances myoblast migration but is not chemoattractive. We discovered that MMP-1 also enhances myoblast differentiation, which is a critical step in the sequence of muscle regeneration. In addition, RT-PCR and Western blot analyses demonstrated the up-regulation of myogenic factors after MMP-1 treatment. In vivo, we observed that myoblast transplantation was greatly improved after MMP-1 treatment within the dystrophic skeletal muscles of MDX mice. MMP-1 may therefore be able to improve muscle function recovery after injury or disease by increasing both the number of myofibers that are generated by activated myoblasts and the size of myoblast coverage area by promoting migration, thus fostering a greater degree of engraftment.

Heat shock enhances troponin expression and decreases differentiation-associated caspase-3 dependence in myoblasts under hypoxia

BACKGROUND

Myoblast transplantation can functionally restore muscle tissues damaged by ischemic or other insults. Despite promising results in clinical trials, however, myoblast transplantation still presents several challenges, with effective differentiation under harsh conditions of the host tissue being one of the most demanding. In keeping with a straightforward clinical application, heat shock (HS) pretreatment as a nonviral method can be utilized with promising results in cell therapy. The aim of this study was to demonstrate whether HS-pretreated cells would receive a differentiation benefit under hypoxic conditions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We studied HS preconditioning of C2C12 myoblasts in relation to their differentiation- and apoptosis-associated responses under normoxia or 1% hypoxia.

RESULTS

HS induced long-lasting expression of Hsp70/72 and Hsp90. Although myoblast differentiation proceeded in HS-pretreated and control cells under both normoxia and hypoxia, expression of differentiation-associated troponin was enhanced in HS-preconditioned cells under hypoxia. This effect persisted when differentiation was inhibited by Z-DEVD-FMK, a caspase-3 inhibitor.

CONCLUSIONS

HS preconditioning enhances expression of myoblast differentiation-associated troponin and may reduce dependence of differentiation on caspase-3.

Isolation of a slowly adhering cell fraction containing stem cells from murine skeletal muscle by the preplate technique

This protocol details a procedure, known as the modified preplate technique, which is currently used in our laboratory to isolate muscle cells on the basis of selective adhesion to collagen-coated tissue culture plates. By employing this technique to murine skeletal muscle, we have been able to isolate a rapidly adhering cell (RAC) fraction within the earlier stages of the process, whereas a slowly adhering cell (SAC) fraction containing muscle-derived stem cells is obtained from the later stages of the process. This protocol outlines the methods and materials needed to isolate RAC and SAC populations from murine skeletal muscle. The procedure involves mechanical and enzymatic digestion of skeletal muscle tissue with collagenase XI, dispase and trypsin followed by plating the resultant muscle slurry on collagen type I-coated flasks where the cells adhere at different rates. The entire preplate technique requires 5 d to obtain the final preplate SAC population. Two to three additional days are usually required before this population is properly established. We also detail additional methodologies designed to further enrich the resultant cell population by continuing the modified preplating process on the SAC population. This process is known as replating and requires further time.

Enhancement of viability of muscle precursor cells on 3D scaffold in a perfusion bioreactor

The aim of this study was to develop a methodology for the in vitro expansion of skeletal-muscle precursor cells (SMPC) in a three-dimensional (3D) environment in order to fabricate a cellularized artificial graft characterized by high density of viable cells and uniform cell distribution over the entire 3D domain. Cell seeding and culture within 3D porous scaffolds by conventional static techniques can lead to a uniform cell distribution only on the scaffold surface, whereas dynamic culture systems have the potential of allowing a uniform growth of SMPCs within the entire scaffold structure. In this work, we designed and developed a perfusion bioreactor able to ensure long-term culture conditions and uniform flow of medium through 3D collagen sponges. A mathematical model to assist the design of the experimental setup and of the operative conditions was developed. The effects of dynamic vs static culture in terms of cell viability and spatial distribution within 3D collagen scaffolds were evaluated at 1, 4 and 7 days and for different flow rates of 1, 2, 3.5 and 4.5 ml/min using C2C12 muscle cell line and SMPCs derived from satellite cells. C2C12 cells, after 7 days of culture in our bioreactor, perfused applying a 3.5 ml/min flow rate, showed a higher viability resulting in a three-fold increase when compared with the same parameter evaluated for cultures kept under static conditions. In addition, dynamic culture resulted in a more uniform 3D cell distribution. The 3.5 ml/min flow rate in the bioreactor was also applied to satellite cell-derived SMPCs cultured on 3D collagen scaffolds. The dynamic culture conditions improved cell viability leading to higher cell density and uniform distribution throughout the entire 3D collagen sponge for both C2C12 and satellite cells.

Prospective identification of myogenic endothelial cells in human skeletal muscle

We document anatomic, molecular and developmental relationships between endothelial and myogenic cells within human skeletal muscle. Cells coexpressing myogenic and endothelial cell markers (CD56, CD34, CD144) were identified by immunohistochemistry and flow cytometry. These myoendothelial cells regenerate myofibers in the injured skeletal muscle of severe combined immunodeficiency mice more effectively than CD56+ myogenic progenitors. They proliferate long term, retain a normal karyotype, are not tumorigenic and survive better under oxidative stress than CD56+ myogenic cells. Clonally derived myoendothelial cells differentiate into myogenic, osteogenic and chondrogenic cells in culture. Myoendothelial cells are amenable to biotechnological handling, including purification by flow cytometry and long-term expansion in vitro, and may have potential for the treatment of human muscle disease.

Satellite cells delivered by micro-patterned scaffolds: a new strategy for cell transplantation in muscle diseases

Myoblast transplantation is a potentially useful therapeutic tool in muscle diseases, but the lack of an efficient delivery system has hampered its application. Here we have combined cell biology and polymer processing to create an appropriate microenvironment for in vivo transplantation of murine satellite cells (mSCs). Cells were prepared from single muscle fibers derived from C57BL/6-Tgn enhanced green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgenic mice. mSCs were expanded and seeded within micro-patterned polyglycolic acid 3-dimensional scaffolds fabricated using soft lithography and thermal membrane lamination. Myogenicity was then evaluated in vitro using immunostaining, flow cytometry, and reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction analyses. Scaffolds containing mSCs were implanted in pre-damaged tibialis anterior muscles of GFP-negative syngenic mice. Cells detached from culture dishes were directly injected into contra-lateral limbs as controls. In both cases, delivered cells participated in muscle regeneration, although scaffold-implanted muscles showed a much higher number of GFP-positive fibers in CD57 mice. These findings suggest that implantation of cellularized scaffolds is better than direct injection for delivering myogenic cells into regenerating skeletal muscle.

Myoblast transplantation for inherited myopathies: a clinical approach

Myoblast transplantation (MT) is an experimental strategy for the potential treatment of myopathies. MT has two properties that make it potentially beneficial: genetic complementation and myogenic potential. Preclinical experiments on monkeys have shown that promising results can be obtained with MT in large muscles of primates depending on two conditions: appropriate immunosuppression and cell delivery by a method of high-density injections. Preclinical work on MT is being, or may be, addressed to: develop efficient methods of donor cell delivery applicable to clinics; control or avoid acute rejection by methods with the fewest secondary effects; understand the factors that condition the early survival of donor cells following transplantation; increase the success of each individual injection; re-engineer a functional structure in muscles that degenerates to fibrosis and fat substitution; and search for precursor cells with potential advantages over myoblasts.

Short- or long-term effects of adult myoblast transfer on properties of reinnervated skeletal muscles

Skeletal muscle demonstrates a force deficit after repair of injured peripheral nerves. Data from the literature indicate that myoblast transfer enhances recovery of muscle function. Thus, we tested the hypothesis that transfer of adult myoblasts improves the properties of reinnervated rabbit tibialis anterior (TA) muscles in both the short term (4 months) and long term (14 months). Two months after transection and immediate suture of the common peroneal nerve, TA muscles were made to degenerate by cardiotoxin injection and then transplanted with adult myoblasts cultured for 13 days. Under these conditions, muscles studied at 4 months were heavier, contained larger fibers, and developed a significantly higher maximal force than muscles that had only been denervated-reinnervated. In the long term, although muscles made to degenerate were heavier and developed a significantly higher maximal force than denervated-reinnervated muscles, myoblast transfer failed to improve these parameters. However, the overall characteristics of long-term operated muscles tended clearly to approach those of the controls. Taken together, these results may have significant implications in certain orthopedic contexts, particularly after immediate or delayed muscle reinnervation.

Circulating myogenic progenitors and muscle repair

The capability of bone marrow derived cells to contribute to numerous peripheral tissues may hold tremendous promise for the field of regenerative medicine. In the context of skeletal muscle disease in particular, the ability of these cells to reach sites of damage through the circulation would overcome some key limitations of current cell therapy approaches. In muscle however, this non-classical repair process takes place at an exceedingly low frequency and fails to yield any measurable functional improvement. Recent advances regarding the cell types or mechanisms involved in this phenomenon may now provide direction for strategies aimed at increasing its efficiency to therapeutic levels.

Craniofacial muscle engineering using a 3-dimensional phosphate glass fibre construct

The current technique to replace missing craniofacial skeletal muscle is the surgical transfer of local or free flaps. This is associated with donor site morbidity, possible tissue rejection and limited supply. The alternative is to engineer autologous skeletal muscle in vitro, which can then be re-implanted into the patient. A variety of biomaterials have been used to engineer skeletal muscle with limited success. This study investigated the use of phosphate-based glass fibres as a potential scaffold material for the in vitro engineering of craniofacial skeletal muscle. Human masseter (one of the muscles of mastication)--derived cell cultures were used to seed the glass fibres, which were arranged into various configurations. Growth factors and matrix components were to used to manipulate the in vitro environment. Outcome was determined with the aid of microscopy, time-lapse footage, immunofluorescence imaging and CyQUANT proliferation, creatine kinase and protein assays. A 3-dimensional mesh arrangement of the glass fibres was the best at encouraging cell attachment and proliferation. In addition, increasing the density of the seeded cells and using Matrigel and insulin-like growth factor I enhanced the formation of prototypic muscle fibres. In conclusion, phosphate-based glass fibres can support the in vitro engineering of human craniofacial muscle.

Function induced modifications of gene expression: an alternative approach to gene therapy of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

In Duchenne muscular dystrophy a large gene that codes for dystrophin is altered. The possibility that the defective gene/protein could be at least in part substituted by other molecules that the diseased muscle is able to produce and that have a function similar to that of dystrophin is being discussed. Muscle fibres have a tremendous adaptive potential, and the expression of several protein isoforms can be induced by either stretch or long-term change of activity. The exploitation of this ability of muscle cells to express new genes, which would code for proteins that will not be alien to the individual, for treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy is being considered. The argument for this approach is strengthened by results that in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy the progress of the disease can be slowed with changes of muscle activity.

Cell transplantation for treatment of acute myocardial infarction: unique capacity for repair by skeletal muscle satellite cells

An adult heart injured by an ischemic episode has a limited capacity to regenerate. We administered three types of adult guinea pig cells [cardiomyocytes (CMs), cardiac fibroblasts (CFs), and skeletal myoblasts (Mbs)] to compare their suitability for repair of acute myocardial infarction. We used confocal fluorescent microscopy and a variety of specific immunomarkers and echocardiography to provide anatomic evidence for the viability of such cells and their possible functional beneficial effects. All cells were transfected with adenovirus-containing beta-galactosidase gene so that migration from the injection sites could be traced. Both freshly isolated CMs as well as CFs were found concentrated in the infarcted zone; these cells survived for at least 2 wk posttransplantation. Transplanted CMs were regularly striated and grew long projections that could form gap junctions with native CMs, which was evidenced by connexin43 labeling. In addition, CM transplantation resulted in increased angiogenesis in the infarcted areas. In contrast, transplanted CFs did not appear to make any gap junctional contacts with native CMs nor did they enhance local angiogenesis. Mbs cultured for 7 days and transfected Mbs were identified 7 days posttransplantation in the infarcted area. During that time and thereafter, Mbs proliferated and differentiated into myotubes that formed new, regularly striated myofibers that occupied most (50-70%) of the infarcted area by 2-3 wk. These newly formed myofibers maintained their Mb skeletal muscle origin as evidenced by their capacity to express myogenin and fast skeletal myosin. This skeletal phenotype appeared to downregulate with time, and Mbs partially transdifferentiated into a cardiac phenotype as indicated by labeling for cardiac-specific troponin T and cardiac myosin heavy chain. By the third week posttransplantation, new myofibers formed apparent contacts with the native CMs via putative gap junctions that expressed connexin43. Myocardial performance of animals that were successfully transplanted with Mbs was improved.

Muscle-derived stem cells: potential for muscle regeneration

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a devastating X-linked muscle disease characterized by progressive muscle weakness caused by the lack of dystrophin expression at the sarcolemma of muscle fibers. Although various approaches to delivering dystrophin in dystrophic muscle have been investigated extensively (e.g., cell and gene therapy), there is still no treatment that alleviates the muscle weakness in this common inherited muscle disease. The transplantation of myoblasts can enable transient delivery of dystrophin and improve the strength of injected dystrophic muscle, but this approach has various limitations, including immune rejection, poor cellular survival rates, and the limited spread of the injected cells. The isolation of muscle cells that can overcome these limitations would enhance the success of myoblast transplantation significantly. The efficiency of cell transplantation might be improved through the use of stem cells, which display unique features, including (1) self-renewal with production of progeny, (2) appearance early in development and persistence throughout life, and (3) long-term proliferation and multipotency. For these reasons, the development of muscle stem cells for use in transplantation or gene transfer (ex vivo approach) as treatment for patients with muscle disorders has become more attractive in the past few years. In this paper, we review the current knowledge regarding the isolation and characterization of stem cells isolated from skeletal muscle by highlighting their biological features and their relationship to satellite cells as well as other populations of stem cells derived from other tissues. We also describe the remarkable ability of stem cells to regenerate skeletal muscle and their potential use to alleviate the muscle weakness associated with DMD.

Muscle-derived stem cells for musculoskeletal tissue regeneration and repair

Muscle recently has been identified as a good source of adult stem cells that can differentiate into cells of different lineages. The most well-known muscle progenitor cells are satellite cells, which not only contribute to the replenishment of the myogenic cell pool but also can become osteoblasts, adipocytes and chondrocytes. Other populations of stem cells that appear to be distinct from satellite cells also have been discovered recently. Muscle-derived stem cells (MDSCs) can be divided into two major categories based on these cells' varied abilities to differentiate into myogenic lineages. Interestingly, MDSCs that can differentiate readily into myogenic cells are usually CD45-. In contrast, MDSCs with less myogenic potential are CD45+. Various lines of evidence suggest that different populations of MDSCs are closely related. Furthermore, MDSCs appear to be closely related to endothelial cells or pericytes of the capillaries surrounding myofibers. When used in tissue engineering applications, MDSCs--particularly those genetically engineered to express growth factors--have been demonstrated to possess great potential for the regeneration and repair of muscle, bone and cartilage. Further research is necessary to delineate the relationship between different populations of MDSCs and between MDSCs and other adult stem cells, to investigate their developmental origin, and to determine the regulatory pathways and factors that control stem cell self-renewal, proliferation and differentiation. This knowledge could greatly enhance the usefulness of muscle-derived stem cells, as well as other adult stem cells, for tissue repair and regeneration applications.

Transplantation of primary satellite cells improves properties of reinnervated skeletal muscles

Skeletal muscle demonstrates a force deficit after repair of injured peripheral nerves. We tested the hypothesis that transplantation of satellite cells into reinnervated rabbit tibialis anterior (TA) muscles improves their properties. Adult rabbits underwent transection and immediate suture of the common peroneal nerve. In order to provide an environment favorable for cell transplantation, TA were then made to degenerate by cardiotoxin injection, either immediately or after a 2-month delay, which is sufficient for muscle reinnervation. In both cases, the injured TA were transplanted with cultured satellite cells 5 days after induction of muscle degeneration. When cells were transferred immediately after nerve repair, drastic morphological and functional muscle alterations were observed. However, when the muscles were allowed to become reinnervated before cell transplantation, muscles were heavier and developed a significantly higher maximal force compared to denervated-reinnervated muscles. Thus, application of the cell therapy protocol improved properties of denervated muscles only when they were allowed to become innervated. These results, which represent the application of cell therapy to improve force recovery of reinnervated muscles, will be of significant interest in certain clinical contexts, particularly after immediate or delayed muscle reinnervation.

Cell therapies for inherited myopathies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Cell therapies for inherited myopathies are based on the implantation of normal or genetically corrected myogenic cells into the body. This review summarizes the recent progress in this field, systematized according to the factors important for success.

RECENT FINDINGS

In the choice of donor cells, myoblasts derived from satellite cells remain the best choice. Some studies on the population of muscle-derived stem cells in mice suggested that these cells may have some advantages over myoblasts; however, no results supporting this advantage have been presented in a primate model. Recent studies on bone marrow transplantation as a systemic source of myogenic precursors for the treatment of myopathies were disappointing. Concerning donor cell delivery, intramuscular myoblast injection remains the only way that can significantly introduce exogenous myogenic cells into the muscles. A recent study in primates showed some parameters of myoblast injection that could be useful in the human. Progress was made in mice to understand the factors that could favor the migration of the donor myoblasts in the host muscles. Concerning donor cell survival, analysis of immune cell infiltration dynamics allowed a better understanding of the factors implicated in early donor cell death. Progress was made on the control of acute rejection for myoblast transplantation in primates. So far, few mouse experiments have advanced the field of tolerance induction toward myogenic cells.

SUMMARY

Myoblast transplantation (intramuscular injection of satellite cell-derived myoblasts) currently remains the only cell-based therapy that has produced promising results in the context of a preclinical model such as the nonhuman primate.

Stem cell route to neuromuscular therapies

As applied to skeletal muscle, stem cell therapy is a reincarnation of myoblast transfer therapy that has resulted from recent advances in the cell biology of skeletal muscle. Both strategies envisage the reconstruction of damaged muscle from its precursors, but stem cell therapy employs precursors that are earlier in the developmental hierarchy. It is founded on demonstrations of apparently multipotential cells in a wide variety of tissues that can assume, among others, a myogenic phenotype. The main demonstrated advantage of such cells is that they are capable of colonizing many tissues, including skeletal and cardiac muscle via the blood vascular system, thereby providing the potential for a body-wide distribution of myogenic progenitors. From a practical viewpoint, the chief disadvantage is that such colonization has been many orders of magnitude too inefficient to be useful. Proposals for overcoming this drawback are the subject of much speculation but, so far, relatively little experimentation. This review attempts to give some perspective to the status of the stem cell as a therapeutic instrument for neuromuscular disease and to identify issues that need to be addressed for application of this technology.

Non-viral gene delivery in skeletal muscle: a protein factory

Ever since the publication of the first reports in 1990 using skeletal muscle as a direct target for expressing foreign transgenes, an avalanche of papers has identified a variety of proteins that can be synthesized and correctly processed by skeletal muscle. The impetus to the development of such applications is not only amelioration of muscle diseases, but also a range of therapeutic applications, from immunization to delivery of therapeutic proteins, such as clotting factors and hormones. Although the most efficient way of introducing transgenes into muscle fibres has been by a variety of recombinant viral vectors, there are potential benefits in the use of non-viral vectors. In this review we assess the recent advances in construction and delivery of naked plasmid DNA to skeletal muscle and highlight the options available for further improvements to raise efficiency to therapeutic levels.

Long-term persistence of donor nuclei in a Duchenne muscular dystrophy patient receiving bone marrow transplantation

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe progressive muscle-wasting disorder caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene. Studies have shown that bone marrow cells transplanted into lethally irradiated mdx mice, the mouse model of DMD, can become part of skeletal muscle myofibers. Whether human marrow cells also have this ability is unknown. Here we report the analysis of muscle biopsies from a DMD patient (DMD-BMT1) who received bone marrow transplantation at age 1 year for X-linked severe combined immune deficiency and who was diagnosed with DMD at age 12 years. Analysis of muscle biopsies from DMD-BMT1 revealed the presence of donor nuclei within a small number of muscle myofibers (0.5-0.9%). The majority of the myofibers produce a truncated, in-frame isoform of dystrophin lacking exons 44 and 45 (not wild-type). The presence of bone marrow-derived donor nuclei in the muscle of this patient documents the ability of exogenous human bone marrow cells to fuse into skeletal muscle and persist up to 13 years after transplantation.

Properties of primary mouse myoblasts expanded in culture

Implantation of myoblasts is a strategy used to enhance the regeneration of skeletal muscle tissue in vivo. In mouse models, myogenic cell lines and primary cells have been employed with different yields of adult muscle tissue formed. The present work is a study of some developmental features of expanded primary mouse myoblasts (i28), which have been shown to form muscle tissue. i28 myoblasts were differentiated in vitro and the expression of acetylcholine receptor channels and maturation of the excitation-contraction coupling mechanism were investigated using patch clamp and videoimaging techniques. In all the developing cells the embryonic isoform of the acetylcholine receptors was present. Skeletal muscle-type excitation-contraction coupling (i.e., a mechanical link between voltage-dependent calcium channels and ryanodine receptor channels) was detected in about 75% of differentiating i28 myotubes. Only these cells showed spontaneous changes in cytosolic free calcium concentration associated with twitches. Our findings are the first description of the physiological properties of expanded primary myoblasts which are used for implantation and confirm that they are a heterogeneous cell population. In comparison to permanent cell lines, the Ca(2+) signaling is more similar to that described in mature nonexpanded muscle fibers. This suggests that cultured primary cells are, so far, the most suitable cell type for muscle regeneration.

Muscle stem cells

Since its discovery four decades ago, the satellite cell of skeletal muscle has been implicated as the major source of myogenic cells involved in growth and repair of muscle fibres. This review not only looks at the role of the satellite cell in these processes but discusses how cells derived from other sources and tissues have recently been implicated in muscle formation and regeneration. Muscle itself also yields cells that contribute to other cell lineages although it is currently debated as to whether these cells originate within muscle or have migrated there from other tissues. The reality of using cells from muscle or other tissues to repair diseased muscle fibres is also addressed.

A subpopulation of murine bone marrow cells fully differentiates along the myogenic pathway and participates in muscle repair in the mdx dystrophic mouse

Bone marrow (BM) transplantation in mice suggests the existence of pluripotent cells able to differentiate into skeletal muscle tissue, although sustained myofiber reconstitution has not yet been achieved. We investigated the myogenic potential of mouse BM cells and evaluated whether a BM fraction enriched for cells expressing skeletal muscle markers would ameliorate muscle repair, when compared to whole BM, into the dystrophic mdx mouse. We demonstrate that cells expressing striated-muscle-specific proteins are already present in the BM independently from experimentally forced myogenic conversion. We observed the presence of both markers of early myogenic program such as Pax3, Myf5, MyoD, desmin, and late myogenesis such as myosin heavy chain and alpha-sarcomeric actin. These myogenic cells are more represented in the early nonadherent BM fraction, which generates clones able to fully differentiate into myotubes. Transplantation in mdx mice by intravenous injection of whole BM and a tenfold BM myogenic enriched fraction resulted in BM reconstitution and limited dystrophin restoration. Taken together, these data show that a fraction of BM cells have a definite potential for differentiation along the skeletal muscle pathway and can be recruited by muscle repair mechanisms. They also indicate that factors limiting the degree of muscle recruitment and the host stem cell competition should be assessed in order to evaluate the usefulness of BM-derived myogenic cells into the context of cell-mediated gene therapy of inherited muscle diseases.

Effect of injecting primary myoblasts versus putative muscle-derived stem cells on mass and force generation in mdx mice

It is well established that the injection of normal myoblasts or of muscle-derived stem cells (MDSCs) into the muscle of dystrophin-deficient mdx mice results in the incorporation of a number of donor myoblasts into the host muscle. However, the effect of the injected exogenous cells on mdx muscle mass and functional capacity has not been evaluated. This study evaluates the mass and functional capacity of the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscles of adult, male mdx mice that received intramuscular injections of primary myoblasts or of MDSCs (isolated by a preplating technique; Qu, Z., Balkir, L., van Deutekom, J.C., Robbins, P.D., Pruchnic, R., and Huard, J., J. Cell Biol. 1998;142:1257-1267) derived from normal mice. Evaluations were made 9 weeks after cell transplantation. Uninjected mdx EDL muscles have a mass 50% greater than that of age-matched C57BL/10J (normal) EDL muscles. Injections of either primary myoblasts or MDSCs have no effect on the mass of mdx EDL muscles. EDL muscles of mdx mice generate 43% more absolute twitch tension and 43% less specific tetanic tension then do EDL muscles of C57BL/10J mice. However, the absolute tetanic and specific twitch tension of mdx and C57BL/10J EDL muscles are similar. Injection of either primary myoblasts or MDSCs has no effect on the absolute or specific twitch and tetanic tensions of mdx muscle. Approximately 25% of the myofibers in mdx EDL muscles that received primary myoblasts react positively with antibody to dystrophin. There is no significant difference in the number of dystrophin-positive myofibers when MDSCs are injected. Regardless of the source of donor cells, dystrophin is limited to short distances (60-900 microm) along the length of the myofibers. This may, in part, explain the failure of cellular therapy to alter the contractile properties of murine dystrophic muscle.

Identification of a novel population of muscle stem cells in mice: potential for muscle regeneration

Three populations of myogenic cells were isolated from normal mouse skeletal muscle based on their adhesion characteristics and proliferation behaviors. Although two of these populations displayed satellite cell characteristics, a third population of long-time proliferating cells expressing hematopoietic stem cell markers was also identified. This third population comprises cells that retain their phenotype for more than 30 passages with normal karyotype and can differentiate into muscle, neural, and endothelial lineages both in vitro and in vivo. In contrast to the other two populations of myogenic cells, the transplantation of the long-time proliferating cells improved the efficiency of muscle regeneration and dystrophin delivery to dystrophic muscle. The long-time proliferating cells' ability to proliferate in vivo for an extended period of time, combined with their strong capacity for self-renewal, their multipotent differentiation, and their immune-privileged behavior, reveals, at least in part, the basis for the improvement of cell transplantation. Our results suggest that this novel population of muscle-derived stem cells will significantly improve muscle cell-mediated therapies.

The role of stem cells in skeletal and cardiac muscle repair

In postnatal muscle, skeletal muscle precursors (myoblasts) can be derived from satellite cells (reserve cells located on the surface of mature myofibers) or from cells lying beyond the myofiber, e.g., interstitial connective tissue or bone marrow. Both of these classes of cells may have stem cell properties. In addition, the heretical idea that post-mitotic myonuclei lying within mature myofibers might be able to re-form myoblasts or stem cells is examined and related to recent observations for similar post-mitotic cardiomyocytes. In adult hearts (which previously were not considered capable of repair), the role of replicating endogenous cardiomyocytes and the recruitment of other (stem) cells into cardiomyocytes for new cardiac muscle formation has recently attracted much attention. The relative contribution of these various sources of precursor cells in postnatal muscles and the factors that may enhance stem cell participation in the formation of new skeletal and cardiac muscle in vivo are the focus of this review. We concluded that, although many endogenous cell types can be converted to skeletal muscle, the contribution of non-myogenic cells to the formation of new postnatal skeletal muscle in vivo appears to be negligible. Whether the recruitment of such cells to the myogenic lineage can be significantly enhanced by specific inducers and the appropriate microenvironment is a current topic of intense interest. However, dermal fibroblasts appear promising as a realistic alternative source of exogenous myoblasts for transplantation purposes. For heart muscle, experiments showing the participation of bone marrow-derived stem cells and endothelial cells in the repair of damaged cardiac muscle are encouraging.

Efficacy of myoblast transplantation in nonhuman primates following simple intramuscular cell injections: toward defining strategies applicable to humans

Nonhuman primates were used to define myoblast transplantation strategies applicable to humans. Nevertheless, previous experiments were based on the use of myotoxins concomitant with the myoblast injections. Since myotoxins must be avoided for clinical applications, we analyzed the efficacy of simple myoblast injections (i.e., myoblasts resuspended only in saline) into monkey muscles. We also evaluated different FK506 dosages (in combination or not with mycophenolate mofetil) for immunosuppression. Allogeneic myoblasts transduced with the beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) gene were implanted in the muscles of 19 monkeys by injections placed 1 to 2 mm from each other. A biopsy was performed at the implanted sites 1 month later, and histologically studied for demonstration of beta-Gal+ myofibers, lymphocyte infiltration, and CD8+ cells. The presence of antibodies against the donor myoblasts and the blood levels of FK506 were analyzed. Our results show that: (1) If myoblast injections are sufficiently close to each other, high percentages of hybrid myofibers can be obtained following myoblast transplantation in primates (25 to 67% with an interinjection distance of 1 mm). (2) Efficient immunosuppression can be reached by increasing FK506 dosages, but also by combining this drug with mycophenolate mofetil, a combination that reduces toxic effects. The present results represent a step towards a better designing of myoblast transplantation strategies in humans.

The muscle-specific marker desmin is expressed in a proportion of human dermal fibroblasts after their exposure to galectin-1

We have previously shown that galectin-1 is a factor capable of converting mouse dermal fibroblasts to the myogenic lineage [Cell Transplant 2000;9:519]. Here, we report that human dermal fibroblasts are also capable of expressing the myogenic marker, desmin, when grown in muscle-cell-conditioned media. Furthermore, the human foetal skin cells also express this marker when grown in the presence of galectin-1. These results highlight the importance of galectin-1 in the conversion of both human and murine skin cells to a myogenic lineage. Thus galectin-1 could be an important tool for use in autologous cell therapies for the treatment of human muscular dystrophies.