Detection of fetal cells in maternal blood

PCR detectable Y chromosome-specific DNA but no intact Y chromosome-bearing cells in polymyositis biopsies of two women with male offspring

AIMS

Pregnancy-related and idiopathic adult polymyositis are inflammatory myopathies of unknown aetiology in which CD8 positive T cells are found in close association with the up-regulation of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I on affected muscle cells. A similar polymyositis can also occur in patients with chronic graft versus host disease, wherein graft lymphocytes may be involved in the myositis. We investigated whether polymyositis that was temporally related to pregnancy, contained Y chromosome-bearing cells or signals using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in biopsies of lesional muscle from two women who had given birth to sons. Furthermore, if Y chromosome material was present, we investigated whether it was contained in the intact inflammatory cells (CD8 positive lymphocytes for example), fetal macrophages, or differentiated fetal stem cells engrafted in the lesional skeletal muscle, and thus whether fetal cells played a role in the pathogenesis of the myositis.

METHODS

PCR analysis was used for the Y chromosome in lesional tissue and fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) for intact cells carrying the Y chromosome.

RESULTS

Small amounts of Y chromosome material were detected on second round PCR in fresh frozen tissue. No Y chromosome-bearing intact cells of lymphocytic, macrophage or muscle lineage were detected.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that microchimeric fetal cells are not found in the lesional tissue of pregnancy-related polymyositis.

Simultaneous fetal cell identification and diagnosis by epsilon-globin chain immunophenotyping and chromosomal fluorescence in situ hybridization

Isolating fetal erythroblasts from maternal blood offers a promising noninvasive alternative for prenatal diagnosis. The current immunoenzymatic methods of identifying fetal cells from background maternal cells postenrichment by labeling gamma-globin are problematic. They are nonspecific because maternal cells may produce gamma-globin, give poor hybridization efficiencies with chromosomal fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), and do not permit simultaneous visualization of the fetal cell identifier and the FISH signal. We describe a novel technique that allows simultaneous visualization of fetal erythroblast morphology, chromosomal FISH, and epsilon-globin labeled with AMCA (7-amino-4-methylcoumarin-3-acetic acid). AMCA was chosen as the fluorescent label to circumvent the problem of heme autofluorescence because the mean difference in relative fluorescence intensity between fetal erythroblasts stained positive for antiglobin antibody and autofluorescence of unstained cells was greater with AMCA (mean 43.2; 95% confidence interval [CI], 34.6-51.9; SD = 14.0) as the reporting label compared with fluorescein isothiocyanate (mean 24.2; 95% CI, 16.4-31.9; SD = 12.4) or phycoerythrin (mean 9.8; 95% CI, 4.8-14.8; SD = 8.0). Median FISH hybridization efficiency was 97%, comparable to the 98% (n = 5 paired samples) using Carnoy fixative. One epsilon-positive fetal erythroblast was identified among 10(5) maternal nucleated cells in 6 paired mixture experiments of fetal erythroblasts in maternal blood (P <.001). Male epsilon-positive fetal erythroblasts were clearly distinguishable from adult female epsilon-negative erythroblasts, with no false positives (n = 1000). The frequency of fetal erythroblasts expressing epsilon-globin declines linearly from 7 to 14 weeks' gestation (y = -15.8 x + 230.8; R(2) = 0.8; P <.001). We describe a rapid and accurate method to detect simultaneously fetal erythroblast morphology, intracytoplasmic epsilon-globin, and nuclear FISH. (Blood. 2001;98:554-557)

Isolation of fetal cells from the maternal circulation: prospects for the non-invasive prenatal diagnosis

The research into non-invasive and invasive prenatal diagnostic techniques developed almost in parallel. On the one hand the need was arising to ensure the birth of normal progeny in all cases, while on the other, it was not possible to eliminate the abortion risks connected with the invasiveness of amniocentesis (risk of abortion 1/200), chorion villi sampling, (risk of abortion 2%) and funicolocentesis (risk of abortion 3-4%). One of the first researchers in the non-invasive field was Adinolfi who published the earliest data in 1974 on the possibility of detecting three types of fetal cells in the maternal circulation using flow cytometry. Adinolfi suggested the possibility of using fetal cells present in the maternal circulation for prenatal diagnosis of chromosome or biochemical anomalies. Our review takes into consideration the latest methodological and technical progress in relation to the study of fetal cells in maternal circulation, without considering cells present in the endocervical canal where from the 8th week of pregnancy it is only possible to obtain trophoblast cells. This technique has since been abandoned due to the scarcity of cellular material available, the greater risk of contamination by cells of maternal origin, and also because the recovery of the cells is unpredictable, despite their potential use for the early non-invasive diagnosis of sex. The following issues are addressed in this review: the characterization of the fetal cell types present in the maternal circulation, the methods of their separation and enrichment, and the methods of genetic diagnostics applied.

Fetal cells in maternal blood

Fetal lymphocytes, trophoblasts, and nucleated red blood cells have each been separated from maternal blood by methods such as flow cytometry, magnetic cell sorting, and charge flow separation. The frequency of fetal cells among circulating maternal mononuclear cells remains to be ascertained. Current estimates range from about 10-5 to 10-7, but the numbers may be increased in women carrying aneuploid fetuses. Fetal cells separated from maternal blood have been studied by methods such as polymerase chain reaction and fluorescence in situ hybridization. Among fetal conditions so far identified are sex; human leukocyte antigen and Rh blood types; trisomy 13, 18 and 21; triploidy; and sickle cell anemia and thalassemia. Thus, fetal cell separation might one day be used for screening of the common aneuploidies and, ultimately, for prenatal diagnosis. Individual fetal erythroid precursors have been cultured after separation in some laboratories. Culturing and karyotyping of separated fetal cells might enable diagnosis of a spectrum of chromosomal and genetic disorders. Further development will be required, however, before regular clinical application of these methodologies.

Immunoglobulin-secreting cells of maternal origin can be detected in B cell-deficient mice

It is well known that the transfer of immunoglobulins (Igs) from mother to young via milk contributes to the offspring's immune defense. The present study suggests that not only is IgG transmitted to progeny, but that functional maternal Ig-secreting cells (or B cells) can also be transferred to the neonate. We have used B cell-deficient (micro(-/-)) mice and found that a high proportion of them obtain long-lasting, partial reconstitution of their serum Ig levels if born to micro(+/-) mothers. In some of these serum IgG-positive micro(-/-) mice, Ig-secreting cells were detected in spleen and bone marrow. To ensure that cells of maternal origin were present in the progeny, micro(-/-) offspring born to micro(+/-) dams transgenic for green fluorescent protein (GFP) were used. In spleens and bone marrow from some of these micro(-/-)GFP(-/-) offspring, GFP-positive cells were detected, which demonstrated that cells of maternal origin could infiltrate the progeny. In addition, splenic Ig-secreting cells were detected in micro(-/-) mice that were born to micro(-/-) dams and transferred to a lactating micro(+/+) foster dam at birth. This indicates that maternal Ig-secreting cells can be transferred postnatally via milk.

[Fetal cells in the maternal blood and prenatal diagnosis]

Fetal loss after amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling is a limit to prenatal diagnosis practice and to its generalization. The existence of fetal cells in the blood of pregnant women is now well established. Recognizing these cells with specific antibodies and isolating them with fluorescent or magnetic systems are the subject of numerous studies. However, to date, neither the sensitivity nor the specificity of these methods are sufficient to allow a non invasive prenatal diagnosis.

Application of capillary nongel sieving electrophoresis for gene analysis

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) has proved to be a strong tool for DNA analysis and has found abundant applications in the fields of restriction fragment sizing, mutation screening, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) product characterizing and forensic identifying. CE may be the main alternative to slab gel electrophoresis. Capillary nongel electrophoresis is the most favorable mode when aiming for this purpose because of its advantages of long lifetime, easy operation, good reproducibility, and low expense. In this paper, a new kind of sieving matrix, with mannitol as the additive for capillary electrophoresis, as well as related methods and their application for gene analysis were reported. Nine DNA fragments amplified by multiplex PCR from a normal dystrophin gene were well separated by this system. Three different deletions were found in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patients. Three to four copies of the sex-determination region of the Y chromosome (SRY) gene, as well as the phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) gene, could be detected in mixed samples. The frequencies of short tandem repeats (STR) in PAH genes was analyzed in 61 normal Chinese individuals and 6 phenylketonuria families. One case of prenatal gene diagnosis was performed. By using this matrix, CE coupled with reverse transcription PCR (RT-PCR), the analysis of the alternative splicing expression pattern of the fragile X mental retardation 1 (FMR1) gene in adult lung tissue was achieved.

The application of individualised fetal growth curves

Individually adjusted or 'customised' growth charts aim to optimise the assessment of fetal growth by taking individual variation into account, and by projecting an optimal curve which delineates the potential weight gain in each pregnancy. This results in an increased detection rate of true growth restriction and a reduction in false positive diagnoses for IUGR. An adjustable standard can apply across geographical boundaries, as individual variation exceeds that between different maternity populations.

Prenatal diagnosis by analysis of fetal cells in maternal blood

The data accumulated thus far indicate that fetal NRBCs are the target cell type of choice in maternal blood for most investigators, although some groups continue to work with the trophoblast. Reports of persistent circulation of hematopoietic stem cells, lymphoid/myeloid progenitors, and lymphocytes mandate that removal of these cell types must occur before clinical diagnosis of the current pregnancy can be made. In selected cases, accurate detection of fetal aneuploidy has been made from fetal cells in maternal blood; the clinical evaluation sponsored by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development will determine the sensitivity and specificity of cytogenetic diagnosis in a larger group of pregnant women, but this information will not be available for several years. At present, detection of uniquely fetal, paternally inherited gene polymorphisms or mutations such as the Rh(D) antigen is possible only because the mother lacks these genes; hence, maternal cell contamination does not hinder diagnosis. Currently the presence of large numbers of maternal cells in enriched samples precludes single-gene diagnosis for conditions in which the mother carries a mutant gene, because her cells are preferentially amplified and difficult to distinguish from those of the fetus. It is likely, however, that as techniques of individual fetal cell isolation are perfected, maternal cell contamination will no longer be an issue, and the entire fetal genome will become available for diagnosis and therapy. Pediatricians need to be aware of the progress of research in this field, because fetal cell isolation from maternal blood not only could change prenatal diagnosis but would change the amount of genetic information that arrives with a newborn infant at birth. The ultimate goal of this work is to diagnose noninvasively, in the first trimester, the common fetal aneuploidies and single-gene disorders, to permit in utero treatment, or to allow low-risk pregnant women carrying an abnormal fetus an opportunity for reproductive choice.

Detection of fetal HLA-DQa sequences in maternal blood: a gender-independent technique of fetal cell identification

The objective of this study was to detect fetal HLA-DQa gene sequences in maternal blood. HLA-DQa genotypes of 70 pregnant women and their partners were determined for type A1. We specifically sought couples where the father, but not the mother, had genotype A1. In 12 women, maternal blood samples were flow-sorted. Candidate fetal cells were isolated and amplified by using PCR primers specific for a paternal HLA-DQa A1 allele. Fetal HLA-DQa A1 genotype was predicted from sorted cells; amniocytes or cheek swabs were used for confirmation. Six of twelve sorted samples had amplification products indicating the presence of the HLA-DQa A1 allele; 6/12 did not. Prediction of the fetal genotype was 100 per cent correct, as determined by subsequent amplification of amniocytes or cheek swabs. We conclude that paternally inherited uniquely fetal HLA-DQa gene sequences can be identified in maternal blood. This system permits the identification of fetal cells independent of fetal gender, and has the potential for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of paternally inherited conditions.

Isolating fetal cells in maternal circulation for prenatal diagnosis

Fetal cells unequivocally exist in and can be isolated from maternal blood. Erythroblasts, trophoblasts, granulocytes and lymphocytes have all been isolated by various density gradient and flow sorting techniques. Chromosomal abnormalities detected on isolated fetal cells include trisomy 21, trisomy 18, Klinefelter syndrome (47,XXY) and 47,XYY. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technology has enabled the detection of fetal sex, Mendelian disorders (e.g. beta-globin mutations), HLA polymorphisms, and fetal Rhesus (D) blood type. The fetal cell type that has generated the most success is the nucleated erythrocyte; however, trophoblasts, lymphocytes and granulocytes are also considered to be present in maternal blood. Fetal cells circulate in maternal blood during the first and second trimesters, and their detection is probably not affected by Rh or ABO maternal-fetal incompatibilities. Emphasis is now directed toward determining the most practical and efficacious manner for this technique to be applied to prenatal genetic diagnosis. Only upon completion of clinical evaluations could it be considered appropriate to offer this technology as an alternative to conventional invasive and non-invasive methods of prenatal cytogenetic diagnosis.

Fetal cells in maternal blood: determination of purity and yield by quantitative polymerase chain reaction

OBJECTIVE

The detection of fetal aneuploidy and gene mutations by analysis of fetal cells in maternal blood has demonstrated the feasibility of noninvasive prenatal diagnosis. Fetal cells are rare in the maternal circulation; all current methods used for their isolation also yield maternal cells. We developed a method that permits a quantitative assessment of the relative numbers of fetal and maternal cells.

STUDY DESIGN

Samples from 40 pregnant women were flow sorted with different monoclonal antibodies. Deoxyribonucleic acid was subsequently purified from candidate fetal cells; polymerase chain reaction was performed with synthetic primers specific for sequences on chromosomes Y and 7.

RESULTS

The maximum number of fetal cells detected was 52 in 1080 maternal cells. Fetal cell purity ranged from 0.001% to 4.8%. Fetal cells were detected with antibodies to CD71, CD36, and glycophorin A.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative polymerase chain reaction enables the determination of the purity and yield of fetal cells remaining after isolation from maternal blood, facilitating rapid comparisons between different cell separation techniques.

Simultaneous immunophenotyping and FISH on fetal cells from maternal blood

Current methods for the prenatal diagnosis of genetic disorders from fetal cells in the maternal circulation are restricted by maternal cell contamination and therefore must rely on the presence of features (such as Y-specific DNA sequences) absent from maternal cells. We have used density gradient centrifugation and magnetic-activated cell sorting to enrich maternal blood samples for fetal nucleated red cells. Mouse monoclonal antibodies for CD45 and CD32 were used to reduce the proportion of leukocytes. Unequivocal identification of fetal cells was achieved using an immunophenotypic test for fetal hemoglobin that allowed the simultaneous application of a diagnostic FISH analysis with chromosome-specific DNA probes. A positive diagnosis of female fetal sex (among other diagnoses) is thus possible even in the presence of an excess of maternal cells. The method, which appears to represent an advance over previous techniques, has considerable application in the development of noninvasive prenatal diagnosis from maternal blood.

Erythroid-specific antibodies enhance detection of fetal nucleated erythrocytes in maternal blood

Fetal nucleated erythrocytes (NRBC) in maternal blood are a non-invasive source of fetal DNA for prenatal genetic screening. We compared the effectiveness of three monoclonal antibodies for the separation of fetal cells from maternal blood by flow sorting. Mononuclear blood cells from 49 healthy pregnant women were incubated with antibody to CD 71, CD 36, and/or glycophorin A (GPA), employed singly or in combination with each other. These monoclonal antibodies recognize surface antigens on haematopoietic precursor cells. Successful isolation of fetal cells was defined as detection of Y chromosomal sequences in maternal blood from women carrying male fetuses, with absence of Y sequences when female fetuses were carried. Thus, gender prediction accuracy was used as a measure of fetal cell separation. Using anti-CD 71 to isolate fetal cells, gender prediction was 57 per cent correct; with anti-CD 36, it was 88 per cent correct. Anti-GPA, an erythrocyte-specific antigen, used alone or in combination with anti-CD 71 or 36, improved gender prediction to 100 per cent. We conclude that antibody to GPA improves the retrieval of fetal NRBC from maternal blood, permitting genetic analysis by the polymerase chain reaction.

One-step enrichment of nucleated red blood cells. A potential application in perinatal diagnosis

We describe a discontinuous triple density gradient to obtain a 25-fold enrichment of nucleated red blood cells from mononuclear cells, granulocytes, and mature red blood cells in a single centrifugation step.

Fetal granulocytes in maternal venous blood detected by in situ hybridization

Fetal male cells from maternal venous blood were detected by a non-radioactive in situ hybridization method using the biotinylated Y-specific DNA probe pY431. The hybridizations were performed on Ficoll-Paque-isolated nucleated blood cells obtained from 11 pregnant women in the seventh to 31st week of gestation. A Y-specific signal was detected in both granulocytes and lymphocyte-like cells in seven of the 11 women studied. These women gave birth to boys. In one of the four remaining cases, a Y-specific signal was detected in the lymphocyte-like cells but not in the granulocytes. This woman gave birth to a girl. The other three women had no cells with a Y-specific signal and all three gave birth to girls. Altogether, 83,500 nucleated cells were analysed. One hundred and three cells showed a Y-specific signal. Of these Y-specific cells, 62 per cent were granulocytes and 38 per cent lymphocyte-like cells. Our results suggest that fetomaternal transfer of granulocytes is common and that it occurs as early as in the seventh week of gestation. None of the ten non-pregnant female control samples showed positive cells with the Y-chromosome-specific probe; approximately 97 per cent of the cells from the five adult male controls showed a Y-specific signal. Our results indicate that in situ hybridization using a Y-specific DNA probe performed on granulocytes in maternal blood can be used for fetal male sex determination.

Extravillus dividing fetal cells at CVS: evidence of their erythroblastic origin

Cytological and cytogenetic studies were performed on nucleated fetal cells present in chorionic villus transport medium. The erythroblastic origin of these cells was shown. Fetal erythroblasts in spontaneous mitosis were frequently observed; chromosome counts were obtained from them but poor quality often prevented banded analysis. Cytogenetic study of erythroblast metaphases can be useful as an additional diagnostic aid in cases of mosaicism with aneuploid cell lines.

Prenatal diagnosis with fetal cells isolated from maternal blood by multiparameter flow cytometry

A long-sought goal of medical genetics has been development of prenatal diagnostic procedures that do not endanger the conceptus. Reliable and universal screening for cytogenetic disorders would require analysis of fetal cells isolated from the maternal circulation. This would be applicable to all pregnant women, irrespective of their ages or histories. In the current study fetal nucleated erythrocytes were flow sorted on the basis of four parameters: cell size, cell granularity, transferrin receptor, and glycophorin-A cell surface molecule. By polymerase chain reaction with oligonucleotide primers flanking single-copy Y-specific deoxyribonucleic acid sequences, male fetuses were correctly identified among flow-sorted samples in 12 of 12 (100%) pregnancies; female fetuses were correctly identified in 5 of 6 (83%) pregnancies. We also achieved the prenatal diagnosis of fetal aneuploidies by use of flow-sorted nucleated fetal erythrocytes and in situ hybridization with chromosome-specific deoxyribonucleic acid probes: one case of trisomy 21 that was detected in maternal blood taken 1 week after chorionic villus sampling and one case of trisomy 18 that was detected in maternal blood taken immediately before chorionic villus sampling. Although our results are promising, additional data on the background sensitivity and specificity of in situ hybridization in flow-sorted fetal cells will be necessary to minimize subjective interpretation and permit clinical application.