Prenatal diagnosis for fetuses with isolated and non-isolated congenital heart defects using chromosomal microarray and exome sequencing

Use of Clinically Informed Strategies and Diagnostic Yields of Genetic Testing for Fetal Structural Anomalies Following a Non-Diagnostic Microarray Result: A Population-Based Cohort Study

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the performance of targeted gene sequencing, expanded gene panels, and selected exomes for prenatally identified fetal anomalies, after non-diagnostic microarray results.

METHOD

All fetal samples received for genetic testing for fetal structural anomalies in the Canadian Maritime Provinces (2014-2022) were identified. Utilization and results of NGS sequencing strategies after a non-diagnostic microarray were correlated with ultrasound findings and autopsy results.

RESULTS

Five hundred and ninety-three cases of fetal anomalies with non-diagnostic RAD results were identified, including 319 (54%) with isolated anomalies. Diagnostic yield from the microarray was 7.5%. Sequence-based testing for 131 cases gave an overall diagnostic yield of 38% (8.4% of initial cohort). For isolated anomalies, diagnostic yield was highest in the intracranial, renal, and musculoskeletal systems (44%, 60%, 64% respectively). Appropriate targeted gene sequencing provided a diagnostic yield of 40%. With clinically indicated criteria for exome analysis, diagnostic yields were higher than when clinical information prompted use of a selected gene panel (73% vs. 27%). Expanding to an exome after a non-diagnostic gene panel had an additional diagnostic yield of 13%.

CONCLUSION

Multidisciplinary review and comprehensive clinical information can inform the selection of strategies for expanded genetic testing after non-diagnostic microarray for fetal anomalies within a publicly funded health care system.

Simultaneous CNV-seq and WES: An effective strategy for molecular diagnosis of unexplained fetal structural anomalies

Background

Fetal structural anomalies are detected by ultrasound in approximately 3 % of pregnancies. Numerous genetic diagnostic strategies have been widely applied to identify the genetic causes of prenatal abnormalities. We aimed to assess the value of simultaneous copy number variation sequencing (CNV-seq) and whole exome sequencing (WES) in diagnosing fetuses with structural anomalies.

Methods

Fetuses with structural anomalies detected by ultrasound were included for eligibility. After genetic counseling, WES and CNV-seq were performed on DNA samples of fetuses and their parents. All detected variants were evaluated for pathogenicity according to ACMG criteria, with the final diagnosis was determined based on ultrasound results and relevant family history.

Results

The diagnostic rate of 174 fetuses with prenatal ultrasound abnormalities was 26.44 %, higher than that achieved through either CNV or WES analysis alone. Furthermore, the highest diagnostic rate was observed in fetuses with multiple system anomalies, accounting for 50 % of the total diagnostic yield, followed by skeletal system anomalies at 45.45 %. Three cases with multiple system abnormalities were found to have a dual diagnosis of pathogenic CNVs and SNV variants, representing 1.72 % of the total cohort. 38 pregnant women in their third trimester of pregnancy (27 weeks+) participated in this study, and 23.68 % received a confirmed genetic diagnosis. Finally, 31 women (67.39 %) voluntarily terminated their pregnancy following the testing and extensive genetic counseling.

Conclusions

Our study demonstrated that the simultaneous CNV-seq and WES analyses are beneficial for the molecular diagnosis of underlying unexplained structural anomalies in fetuses. This strategy is more efficient in elucidating prenatal abnormalities with compound problems, such as dual diagnoses. Furthermore, the simultaneous strategy has a shorter turnaround time and is particularly suitable for families with structural anomalies found in the third trimester of pregnancy.

Feto-placental and coronary endothelial genes implicated in miscarriage, congenital heart disease and stillbirth, a systematic review and meta-analysis

The first trimester placenta is very rarely investigated for placental vascular formation in developmental or diseased contexts. Defects in placental formation can cause heart defects in the fetus, and vice versa. Determining the causality is therefore difficult as both organs develop concurrently and express many of the same genes. Here, we performed a systematic review to determine feto-placental and coronary endothelial genes implicated in miscarriages, stillbirth and congenital heart defects (CHD) from human genome wide screening studies. 4 single cell RNAseq datasets from human first/early second trimester cardiac and placental samples were queried to generate a list of 1187 endothelial genes. This broad list was cross-referenced with genes implicated in the pregnancy disorders above. 39 papers reported feto-placental and cardiac coronary endothelial genes, totalling 612 variants. Vascular gene variants were attributed to the incidence of miscarriage (8 %), CHD (4 %) and stillbirth (3 %). The most common genes for CHD (NOTCH, DST, FBN1, JAG1, CHD4), miscarriage (COL1A1, HERC1), and stillbirth (AKAP9, MYLK), were involved in blood vessel and cardiac valve formation, with roles in endothelial differentiation, angiogenesis, extracellular matrix signaling, growth factor binding and cell adhesion. NOTCH1, AKAP12, CHD4, LAMC1 and SOS1 showed greater relative risk ratios with CHD. Many of the vascular genes identified were expressed highly in both placental and heart EC populations. Both feto-placental and cardiac vascular genes are likely to result in poor endothelial cell development and function during human pregnancy that leads to higher risk of miscarriage, congenital heart disease and stillbirth.

Genomic insights into prenatal diagnosis of congenital heart defects: value of CNV-seq and WES in clinical practice

This study aimed to assess the efficiency of CNV-seq and WES in detecting genetic cause of congenital heart disease (CHDs) in prenatal diagnoses and to compare CNV detection rate between isolated and non-isolated CHD cases. We conducted a retrospective study of 118 Chinese fetuses diagnosed with CHD by prenatal ultrasound. Participants underwent CNV-seq and, if necessary, WES to detect chromosomal and single nucleotide variations. The overall detection rate for pathogenic or likely pathogenic chromosomal abnormalities was 16.9%, including 7.6% aneuploidies and 9.3% pathogenic/likely pathogenic copy number variations (CNVs), predominantly 22q11.2 deletion syndrome (54.4%). The sensitivity and specificity of CNV-Seq for detecting P/Lp CNVs were 95% and 100%, respectively. CNV-Seq offered a 6.7% improvement in detecting chromosomal abnormalities over karyotyping. WES further identified significant single nucleotide and small indel variations contributing to CHD in genes such as TMEM67, PLD1, ANKRD11, and PNKP, enhancing diagnostic yield by 14.8% in cases negative for CNVs. Non-isolated CHD cases exhibited higher rates of detectable chromosomal abnormalities compared to isolated cases (32.4% vs. 9.9%, p = 0.005), underlining the genetic complexity of these conditions. The combined use of CNV-seq and WES provides a comprehensive approach to prenatal genetic testing for CHDs, unveiling significant genetic cause that could impact clinical management and parental decision-making. This study supports the integration of these advanced genomic technologies in routine prenatal diagnostics to increase detection diagnostic yields of causal genetic variants associated with CHDs.

The incremental yield of prenatal exome sequencing over chromosome microarray for congenital heart abnormalities: A systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To determine the incremental yield of prenatal exome sequencing (PES) over standard testing in fetuses with an isolated congenital heart abnormality (CHA), CHA associated with extra-cardiac malformations (ECMs) and CHA dependent upon anatomical subclassification.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was performed using MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science and grey literature January 2010-February 2023. Studies were selected if they included greater than 20 cases of prenatally diagnosed CHA when standard testing (QF-PCR/chromosome microarray/karyotype) was negative. Pooled incremental yield was determined. PROSPERO CRD 42022364747.

RESULTS

Overall, 21 studies, incorporating 1957 cases were included. The incremental yield of PES (causative pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants) over standard testing was 17.4% (95% CI, 13.5%-21.6%), 9.3% (95% CI, 6.6%-12.3%) and 35.9% (95% CI, 21.0%-52.3%) for all CHAs, isolated CHAs and CHAs associated with ECMs. The subgroup with the greatest yield was complex lesions/heterotaxy; 35.2% (95% CI 9.7%-65.3%). The most common syndrome was Kabuki syndrome (31/256, 12.1%) and most pathogenic variants occurred de novo and in autosomal dominant (monoallelic) disease causing genes (114/224, 50.9%).

CONCLUSION

The likelihood of a monogenic aetiology in fetuses with multi-system CHAs is high. Clinicians must consider the clinical utility of offering PES in selected isolated cardiac lesions.

Contribution of genetic variants to congenital heart defects in both singleton and twin fetuses: a Chinese cohort study

BACKGROUND

The contribution of genetic variants to congenital heart defects (CHDs) has been investigated in many postnatal cohorts but described in few prenatal fetus cohorts. Overall, specific genetic variants especially copy number variants (CNVs) leading to CHDs are somewhat diverse among different prenatal cohort studies. In this study, a total of 1118 fetuses with confirmed CHDs were recruited from three units over a 5-year period, composing 961 of singleton pregnancies and 157 of twin pregnancies. We performed chromosomal microarray analysis on all cases to detect numerical chromosomal abnormalities (NCAs) and pathogenic/likely pathogenic CNVs (P/LP CNVs) and employed whole-exome sequencing for some cases without NCAs and P/LP CNVs to detect P/LP sequence variants (P/LP SVs).

RESULTS

Overall, NCAs and P/LP CNVs were identified in 17.6% (197/1118) of cases, with NCA accounting for 9.1% (102/1118) and P/LP CNV for 8.5% (95/1118). Nonisolated CHDs showed a significantly higher frequency of NCA than isolated CHD (27.3% vs. 4.4%, p < 0.001), but there was no significant difference in the frequency of P/LP CNVs between isolated and nonisolated CHD (11.7% vs. 7.7%). A total of 109 P/LP CNVs were identified in 95 fetuses, consisting of 97 (89.0%) de novo, 6 (5.5%) parental inherited and 6 (5.5%) with unavailable parental information. The 16p11.2 proximal BP4-BP5 deletion was detected in 0.9% (10/1118) of all cases, second only to the most common 22q11.21 proximal A-D deletion (2.1%, 23/1118). Most of the 16p11.2 deletions (8/10) detected were de novo, and were enriched in CHD cases compared with a control cohort from a previous study. Additionally, SV was identified in 12.9% (8/62) of cases without NCA and P/LP CNV, most of which were de novo with autosomal dominant inheritance.

CONCLUSIONS

Our cohort study provides a deep profile of the contribution of genetic variants to CHDs in both singleton and twin fetuses; NCA and P/LP CNV contribute to 9.1% and 8.5% of CHD in fetuses, respectively. We confirmed the 16p11.2 deletion as a CHD-associated hotspot CNV, second only to the 22q11.21 deletion in frequency. Most 16p11.2 deletions detected were de novo. Additionally, P/LP SV was identified in 12.9% (8/62) of fetuses without NCA or P/LP CNV.

Analysis of genetic testing in fetuses with congenital heart disease of single atria and/or single ventricle in a Chinese prenatal cohort

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to investigate the genetic etiologies of fetuses with single atria and/or ventricle (SA or/and SV) using different genetic detection methods in a Chinese prenatal cohort.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, the various genetic results of 44 fetuses with SA and/or SV were analyzed. All 44 cases were tested by chromosomal microarray analysis (CMA) and karyotyping simultaneously, and 8 underwent whole exome sequencing (WES). Data on the pregnancy outcomes and neonatal prognoses were collected from medical records and postnatal follow-up.

RESULTS

The whole cohort of 44 fetuses included 14 SA cases (31.8%), 12 SV cases (27.3%), and 18 SA and SV cases (40.9%). A total of 9 pathogenic genetic results were detected by conventional karyotyping, CMA and trio-WES, indicating an overall detection rate of 20.5% (9/44). Six pathogenic chromosomal abnormalities were identified by CMA among the 44 cases, showing a detection rate of 13.6% (6/44). Two microdeletions being missed by karyotyping were diagnosed by CMA, showing an additional diagnostic yield of 4.5% for CMA in present cohort(2/44). Three pathogenic variants in two fetuses were identified by WES, indicating an incremental diagnostic yield of 4.5%(2/44) for WES in fetuses with SA or/and SV.

CONCLUSION

In this study, WES achieved an additional diagnostic yield of 4.5% in fetuses with SA or/and SV. WES is valuable for fetal prognosis assessment and could add diagnostic value for fetuses with SA and/or SV when CMA is negative. It would be a valuable technique for the identification of underlying pathogenic variants in prenatal cohorts.