Diagnostic accuracy of capnography during high-frequency ventilation in neonatal intensive care units

Accuracy and Interpretation of Transcutaneous Carbon Dioxide Monitoring in Critically Ill Children

OBJECTIVES

Transcutaneous carbon dioxide (Tcco2) monitoring can noninvasively assess ventilation by estimating carbon dioxide (CO2) levels in the blood. We aimed to evaluate the accuracy of Tcco2 monitoring in critically ill children by comparing it to the partial pressure of arterial carbon dioxide (Paco2). In addition, we sought to determine the variation between Tcco2 and Paco2 acceptable to clinicians to modify patient care and to determine which patient-level factors may affect the accuracy of Tcco2 measurements.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational cohort study.

SETTING

Single, quaternary care PICU from July 1, 2012, to August 1, 2020.

PATIENTS

Included participants were admitted to the PICU and received noninvasive ventilation support (i.e., continuous or bilevel positive airway pressure), conventional mechanical ventilation, or high-frequency oscillatory or percussive ventilation with Tcco2 measurements obtained within 15 minutes of Paco2 measurement.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Three thousand four hundred seven paired arterial blood gas and Tcco2 measurements were obtained from 264 patients. Bland-Altman analysis revealed a bias of -4.4 mm Hg (95% CI, -27 to 18.3 mm Hg) for Tcco2 levels against Paco2 levels on the first measurement pair for each patient, which fell within the acceptable range of ±5 mm Hg stated by surveyed clinicians, albeit with wide limits of agreement. The sensitivity and specificity of Tcco2 to diagnose hypercarbia were 93% and 71%, respectively. Vasoactive-Infusion Score (VIS), age, and self-identified Black/African American race confounded the relationship between Tcco2 with Paco2 but percent fluid overload, weight-for-age, probe location, and severity of illness were not significantly associated with Tcco2 accuracy.

CONCLUSIONS

Tcco2 monitoring may be a useful adjunct to monitor ventilation in children with respiratory failure, but providers must be aware of the limitations to its accuracy.

Transcutaneous carbon dioxide monitoring during therapeutic hypothermia for neonatal encephalopathy

BACKGROUND

In neonates with post-asphyxial neonatal encephalopathy, further neuronal damage is prevented with therapeutic hypothermia (TH). In addition, fluctuations in carbon dioxide levels have been associated with poor neurodevelopmental outcome, demanding close monitoring. This study investigated the accuracy and clinical value of transcutaneous carbon dioxide (tcPCO₂) monitoring during TH.

METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study in neonates, agreement between arterial carbon dioxide (PaCO₂) values and tcPCO₂ measurements during TH was determined. TcPCO₂ levels during the first 24 h of hypothermia were tested for an association with ischemic brain injury on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

RESULTS

Thirty-four neonates were included. Agreement (bias (95% limits of agreement)) between tcPCO₂ and PaCO₂ levels was 3.9 (-12.4-20.2) mm Hg. No relation was found between the body temperature and tcPCO₂ levels. TcPCO₂ levels differed significantly between patients with considerable and minimal damage on MRI; after 6 h (P = 0.02) and 9 h (P = 0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

Although tcPCO₂ provided a limited estimation of PaCO₂, it can be used for trend monitoring during TH. TcPCO₂ levels after birth could provide an early indicator of ischemic brain injury. This relation should be investigated in large prospective studies, in which adjustments for confounders can be made.

IMPACT

Transcutaneous carbon dioxide measurements during therapeutic hypothermia in neonates show limited accuracy similar to measurements reported in normothermic neonates and can be used for trend monitoring. Low transcutaneous carbon dioxide levels during the first 24 h were associated with considerable ischemic brain injury on MRI. The value of transcutaneous carbon dioxide measurements during the first 24 h as an indicator of considerable ischemic brain injury on MRI should be investigated in future studies, adjusting for confounders. Transcutaneous oxygen measurements during therapeutic hypothermia showed an inaccuracy that could not be related to a low body temperature.

Capnography and Pulse Oximetry Improve Fast Track Extubation in Patients Undergoing Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery: A Randomized Clinical Trial

Background

Use of capnography as a non-invasive method during the weaning process for fast track extubation (FTE) is controversial. We conducted the present study to determine whether pulse oximetry and capnography could be utilized as alternatives to arterial blood gas (ABG) measurements in patients under mechanical ventilation (MV) following coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery.

Methods

In this randomized clinical trial, 70 patients, who were candidates for CABG surgery, were randomly assigned into two equal groups (n = 35), intervention and control group. In the intervention group, the ventilator management and weaning from MV was done using Etco2 from capnography and SpO2 from pulse oximetry. Meanwhile, in the control group, weaning was done based on ABG analysis. The length of intensive care unit (ICU) stay, time to extubation, number of manual ventilators setting changes, and alarms were compared between the groups.

Results

The end-tidal carbon dioxide (ETCO2) levels in the intervention group were completely similar to the partial pressure of carbon dioxide (PaCo2) in the control group (39.5 ± 3.1 vs. 39.4 ± 4.32, p > 0.05). The mean extubation times were significantly shorter in the intervention group compared to those in the control patients (212.2 ± 80.6 vs. 342.7 ± 110.7, p < 0.001). Moreover, the number of changes in the manual ventilator setting and the number of alarms were significantly lower in the intervention group. However, the differences in the length of stay in ICU between the two groups were not significant (p = 0.219).

Conclusion

Our results suggests that capnography can be used as an alternative to ABG. Furthermore, it is a safe and valuable monitor that could be a good alternative for ABG in this population. Further studies with larger sample sizes and on different disease states and populations are required to assess the accuracy of our findings.

Clinical Trial Registration

Current Controlled Trials, IRCT, IRCT201701016778N6, Registered 3 March 2017, https://www.irct.ir/trial/7192.

Monitoring of carbon dioxide in ventilated neonates: a prospective observational study

OBJECTIVE

To assess the reliability, accuracy and precision of distal end-tidal capnography (detCO₂) in neonates compared with transcutaneous (tcCO₂) carbon dioxide measurements.

DESIGN

Observational, prospective clinical study.

SETTING

Neonatal intensive care unit at Medical University of Vienna.

PARTICIPANTS

Conventionally ventilated neonates with a body weight between 1000 g and 3000 g.

INTERVENTION

End-tidal partial pressure of CO₂ was measured in distal position using the separate lumen of a double-lumen endotracheal tube connected to an external side-stream capnometer. Three consecutive detCO₂ and tcCO₂ values were recorded simultaneously and compared with simultaneous arterialised partial pressure of CO₂ (paCO₂) measurements in each patient.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Reliability, accuracy and precision of detCO₂ and tcCO₂ measurements compared with paCO₂ in neonates.

RESULTS

Twenty-five neonates were included with a median (range) weight at enrolment of 1410 (1010-2980) g, from which 81 simultaneous measurements of detCO₂, tcCO₂ and paCO₂ were obtained. The mean (SD) of paCO₂, detCO₂ and tcCO₂ was 45.0 (8.6) mmHg, 42.4 (8.4) mmHg and 50.4 (20.4) mmHg, respectively. The intraclass correlation between paCO₂ and detCO₂ and between paCO₂ and tcCO₂ reached 0.80 (95% CI 0.71 to 0.87, p<0.001) and 0.59 (95% CI 0.43 to 0.72, p<0.001), respectively. In the Bland-Altman analysis, bias and precision of detCO₂ with respect to paCO₂ amounted to -2.68 mmHg and 10.62 mmHg (95% CI 8.49 to 14.51), respectively. Bias and precision of tcCO₂ with respect to paCO₂ amounted to 5.39 mmHg and 17.22 mmHg (95% CI 13.21 to 23.34), respectively.

CONCLUSION

DetCO₂ had better reliability, accuracy and precision with paCO₂ than tcCO₂ in ventilated neonates without severe lung diseas.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT03758313.

Correlation of End-Tidal Carbon Dioxide with Arterial Carbon Dioxide in Mechanically Ventilated Neonates: A Scoping Review

Monitoring CO2 levels in intubated neonates is highly relevant in the face of complications associated with altered CO2 levels. Thus, this review aims to present the scientific evidence in the literature regarding the correlation between arterial carbon dioxide measured by non-invasive methods in newborns submitted to invasive mechanical ventilation. The search was carried out from January 2020 to January 2021, in the Scopus, Medline, The Cochrane Library, Web of Science, CINAHL and Embase databases. Also, a manual search of the references of included studies was performed. The main descriptors used were: "capnography," "premature infant," "blood gas analysis," and "mechanical ventilation." As a result, 221 articles were identified, and 18 were included in this review. A total of 789 newborns were evaluated, with gestational age between 22.8 and 42.2 weeks and birth weight between 332 and 4790 g. Capnometry was the most widely used non-invasive method. In general, the correlation and agreement between the methods evaluated in the studies were strong/high. The birth weight did not influence the results. The gestational age of fewer than 37 weeks implied, in its majority, a moderate correlation and agreement. Therefore, we can conclude that there was a predominance of a strong correlation between arterial blood gases and non-invasive methods, although there are variations found in the literature. Even so, the results were promising and may provide valuable data for future studies, which are necessary to consolidate non-invasive methods as a reliable and viable alternative to arterial blood gasometry.

Non-invasive carbon dioxide monitoring in neonates: methods, benefits, and pitfalls

Wide fluctuations in partial pressure of carbon dioxide (PaCO₂) can potentially be associated with neurological and lung injury in neonates. Blood gas measurement is the gold standard for assessing gas exchange but is intermittent, invasive, and contributes to iatrogenic blood loss. Non-invasive carbon dioxide (CO₂) monitoring has become ubiquitous in anesthesia and critical care and is being increasingly used in neonates. Two common methods of non-invasive CO₂ monitoring are end-tidal and transcutaneous. A colorimetric CO₂ detector (a modified end-tidal CO₂ detector) is recommended by the International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) and the American Academy of Pediatrics to confirm endotracheal tube placement. Continuous CO₂ monitoring is helpful in trending PaCO₂ in critically ill neonates on respiratory support and can potentially lead to early detection and minimization of fluctuations in PaCO₂. This review includes a description of the various types of CO₂ monitoring and their applications, benefits, and limitations in neonates.

Comparison of mainstream (Capnostat 5) and two low-flow sidestream capnometers (VM-2500-S and Capnostream) in spontaneously breathing rabbits anesthetized with a Bain coaxial breathing system

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate agreement with PaCO₂ of two low sampling rate sidestream capnometers and a mainstream capnometer in rabbits and the effect of using high fresh gas flow from a Bain coaxial breathing system.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective, crossover study.

ANIMALS

A total of 10 New Zealand White rabbits weighing 3.4 ± 0.3 kg [mean ± standard deviation (SD)].

METHODS

Two sidestream analyzers (Viamed VM-2500-S and Capnostream 35) with a sampling rate of 50 mL minute^-1 and a mainstream capnometer (Capnostat 5) were tested. All capnometers used infrared spectroscopy and advanced microprocessor technology. Rabbits were anesthetized and intubated with noncuffed endotracheal tubes of 3 mm internal diameter and adequate seal. A sidestream sampling adapter or the mainstream capnometer was attached to the endotracheal tube and connected to a Bain coaxial breathing system. Oxygen (1.5 L minute^-1) delivered sevoflurane to maintain anesthesia. An auricular artery catheter allowed blood sampling for PaCO₂ analysis corrected to rectal temperature. Inspired and end-tidal carbon dioxide (Pe'CO₂) measurements were recorded during blood sample withdrawal. From each rabbit, 10 paired PaCO₂/Pe'CO₂ measurements were obtained. Each rabbit was recovered from anesthesia and was anesthetized again with an alternate capnometer after 1 week. Data were analyzed using Bland-Altman and two-way anova for repeated measures.

RESULTS

Analysis included 100 paired samples. Negative bias reflects underestimation of PaCO₂. Bland-Altman mean (±1.95 SD) was -16.7 (-35.2 to 1.8) mmHg for Capnostat 5, -27.9 (-48.6 to -7.2) mmHg for Viamed, and -18.1 (-34.3 to -1.9) mmHg for Capnostream. Viamed PaCO₂-Pe'CO₂ gradient was greater than other two capnometers.

CONCLUSIONS

All three capnometers underestimated PaCO₂. Capnostat 5 and Capnostream performed similarly.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

These capnometers underestimated PaCO₂ in spontaneously breathing rabbits anesthetized using a Bain coaxial breathing system with high fresh gas flows.

Continuous Noninvasive Carbon Dioxide Monitoring in Neonates: From Theory to Standard of Care

Ventilatory support may affect the short- and long-term neurologic and respiratory morbidities of preterm infants. Ongoing monitoring of oxygenation and ventilation and control of adequate levels of oxygen, pressures, and volumes can decrease the incidence of such adverse outcomes. Use of pulse oximetry became a standard of care for titrating oxygen delivery, but continuous noninvasive monitoring of carbon dioxide (CO₂) is not routinely used in NICUs. Continuous monitoring of CO₂ level may be crucial because hypocarbia and hypercarbia in extremely preterm infants are associated with lung and brain morbidities, specifically bronchopulmonary dysplasia, intraventricular hemorrhage, and cystic periventricular leukomalacia. It is shown that continuous monitoring of CO₂ levels helps in maintaining stable CO₂ values within an accepted target range. Continuous monitoring of CO₂ levels can be used in the delivery room, during transport, and in infants receiving invasive or noninvasive respiratory support in the NICU. It is logical to hypothesize that this will result in better outcome for extremely preterm infants. In this article, we review the different noninvasive CO₂ monitoring alternatives and devices, their advantages and disadvantages, and the available clinical data supporting or negating their use as a standard of care in NICUs.

Pediatric pulmonology year in review 2016: Part 2

Pediatric Pulmonology continues to publish research and clinical topics related to the entire range of children's respiratory disorders. As we have done annually in recent years, we here summarize some of the past year's publications in our major topic areas, as well as selected literature in these areas from other core journals relevant to our discipline. This review (Part 2) covers selected articles on neonatology, asthma, physiology and lung function testing, and infectious diseases.