1H and 15N nuclear magnetic resonance assignment and secondary structure of the cytotoxic ribonuclease alpha-Sarcin

Nanobody-Based EGFR-Targeting Immunotoxins for Colorectal Cancer Treatment

Immunotoxins (ITXs) are chimeric molecules that combine the specificity of a targeting domain, usually derived from an antibody, and the cytotoxic potency of a toxin, leading to the selective death of tumor cells. However, several issues must be addressed and optimized in order to use ITXs as therapeutic tools, such as the selection of a suitable tumor-associated antigen (TAA), high tumor penetration and retention, low kidney elimination, or low immunogenicity of foreign proteins. To this end, we produced and characterized several ITX designs, using a nanobody against EGFR (V_HH 7D12) as the targeting domain. First, we generated a nanoITX, combining V_HH 7D12 and the fungal ribotoxin α-sarcin (αS) as the toxic moiety (V_HHEGFRαS). Then, we incorporated a trimerization domain (TIE^XVIII) into the construct, obtaining a trimeric nanoITX (TriV_HHEGFRαS). Finally, we designed and characterized a bispecific ITX, combining the V_HH 7D12 and the scFv against GPA33 as targeting domains, and a deimmunized (DI) variant of α-sarcin (BsITXαSDI). The results confirm the therapeutic potential of α-sarcin-based nanoITXs. The incorporation of nanobodies as target domains improves their therapeutic use due to their lower molecular size and binding features. The enhanced avidity and toxic load in the trimeric nanoITX and the combination of two different target domains in the bispecific nanoITX allow for increased antitumor effectiveness.

Hirsutellin A: A Paradigmatic Example of the Insecticidal Function of Fungal Ribotoxins

The fungal pathogen Hirsutella thompsonii produces an insecticidal protein named hirsutellin A (HtA), which has been described to be toxic to several species of mites, insect larvae, and cells. On the other hand, on the basis of an extensive biochemical and structural characterization, HtA has been considered to be a member of the ribotoxins family. Ribotoxins are fungal extracellular ribonucleases, which inactivate ribosomes by specifically cleaving a single phosphodiester bond located at the large rRNA. Although ribotoxins were brought to light in the 1960s as antitumor agents, their biological function has remained elusive. Thus, the consideration of hirsutellin A, an insecticidal protein, as a singular ribotoxin recalled the idea of the biological activity of these toxins as insecticidal agents. Further studies have demonstrated that the most representative member of the ribotoxin family, α-sarcin, also shows strong toxic action against insect cells. The determination of high resolution structures, the characterization of a large number of mutants, and the toxicity assays against different cell lines have been the tools used for the study of the mechanism of action of ribotoxins at the molecular level. The aim of this review is to serve as a compilation of the facts that allow identification of HtA as a paradigmatic example of the insecticidal function of fungal ribotoxins.

Fungal ribotoxins: molecular dissection of a family of natural killers

RNase T1 is the best known representative of a large family of ribonucleolytic proteins secreted by fungi, mostly Aspergillus and Penicillium species. Ribotoxins stand out among them by their cytotoxic character. They exert their toxic action by first entering the cells and then cleaving a single phosphodiester bond located within a universally conserved sequence of the large rRNA gene, known as the sarcin-ricin loop. This cleavage leads to inhibition of protein biosynthesis, followed by cellular death by apoptosis. Although no protein receptor has been found for ribotoxins, they preferentially kill cells showing altered membrane permeability, such as those that are infected with virus or transformed. Many steps of the cytotoxic process have been elucidated at the molecular level by means of a variety of methodological approaches and the construction and purification of different mutant versions of these ribotoxins. Ribotoxins have been used for the construction of immunotoxins, because of their cytotoxicity. Besides this activity, Aspf1, a ribotoxin produced by Aspergillus fumigatus, has been shown to be one of the major allergens involved in allergic aspergillosis-related pathologies. Protein engineering and peptide synthesis have been used in order to understand the basis of these pathogenic mechanisms as well as to produce hypoallergenic proteins with potential diagnostic and immunotherapeutic applications.

Tyr-48, a conserved residue in ribotoxins, is involved in the RNA-degrading activity of α-sarcin

Residue Tyr-48 in alpha-sarcin is conserved not only within the ribotoxin family, but also within the larger group of extracellular fungal ribonucleases, best represented by RNase T1. A mutant protein in which this Tyr residue was substituted by Phe has been produced and isolated to homogeneity. It was spectroscopically analyzed by means of circular dichroism, fluorescence emission and NMR. Taken together, these results and those from enzyme characterization have revealed the essential role of the -OH group from the Tyr-48 phenolic ring in the cleavage of polymeric RNA substrates, including the ribosome-embedded 28S rRNA, the natural substrate of ribotoxins. Thus, the mutant protein does not degrade its natural ribosomal RNA substrate. However, it has been shown that this Y48F mutant still retains its ability to cleave a phosphodiester bond in a minimal substrate such as the dinucleoside phosphate ApA. The role of different alpha-sarcin residues within the enzyme reaction catalyzed by this protein is discussed.

NMR structure of the noncytotoxic alpha-sarcin mutant Delta(7-22): the importance of the native conformation of peripheral loops for activity

The deletion mutant Delta(7-22) of alpha-sarcin, unlike its wild-type protein counterpart, lacks the specific ability to degrade rRNA in intact ribosomes and exhibits an increased unspecific ribonuclease activity and decreased interaction with lipid vesicles. In trying to shed light on these differences, we report here on the three-dimensional structure of the Delta(7-22) alpha-sarcin mutant using NMR methods. We also evaluated its dynamic properties on the basis of theoretical models and measured its correlation time (6.2 nsec) by time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy. The global fold characteristic of ribotoxins is preserved in the mutant. The most significant differences with respect to the alpha-sarcin structure are concentrated in (1) loop 2, (2) loop 3, which adopts a new orientation, and (3) loop 5, which shows multiple conformations and an altered dynamics. The interactions between loop 5 and the N-terminal hairpin are lost in the mutant, producing increased solvent accessibility of the active-site residues. The degree of solvent exposure of the catalytic His 137 is similar to that shown by His 92 in RNase T1. Additionally, the calculated order parameters of residues belonging to loop 5 in the mutant correspond to an internal dynamic behavior more similar to RNase T1 than alpha-sarcin. On the other hand, changes in the relative orientation of loop 3 move the lysine-rich region 111-114, crucial for substrate recognition, away from the active site. All of the structural and dynamic data presented here reveal that the mutant is a hybrid of ribotoxins and noncytotoxic ribonucleases, consistent with its biological properties.

Tautomeric state of alpha-sarcin histidines. Ndelta tautomers are a common feature in the active site of extracellular microbial ribonucleases

Extracellular fungal RNases, including ribotoxins such as alpha-sarcin, constitute a family of structurally related proteins represented by RNase T1. The tautomeric preferences of the alpha-sarcin imidazole side chains have been determined by nuclear magnetic resonance and electrostatic calculations. Histidine residues at the active site, H50 and H137, adopt the Ndelta tautomer, which is less common in short peptides, as has been found for RNase T1. Comparison with tautomers predicted from crystal structures of other ribonucleases suggests that two active site histidine residues with the Ndelta tautomer are a conserved feature of microbial ribonucleases and that this is related to their ribonucleolytic function.

Leucine 145 of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin plays a key role for determining the specificity of the ribosome-inactivating activity of the protein

Secreted fungal RNases, represented by RNase T1, constitute a family of structurally related proteins that includes ribotoxins such as alpha-sarcin. The active site residues of RNase T1 are conserved in all fungal RNases, except for Phe 100 that is not present in the ribotoxins, in which Leu 145 occupies the equivalent position. The mutant Leu145Phe of alpha-sarcin has been recombinantly produced and characterized by spectroscopic methods (circular dichroism, fluorescence spectroscopy, and NMR). These analyses have revealed that the mutant protein retained the overall conformation of the wild-type alpha-sarcin. According to the analyses performed, Leu 145 was shown to be essential to preserve the electrostatic environment of the active site that is required to maintain the anomalous low pKa value reported for the catalytic His 137 of alpha-sarcin. Enzymatic characterization of the mutant protein has revealed that Leu 145 is crucial for the specific activity of alpha-sarcin on ribosomes.

Deletion of the NH2-terminal beta-hairpin of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin produces a nontoxic but active ribonuclease

Ribotoxins are a family of highly specific fungal ribonucleases that inactivate the ribosomes by hydrolysis of a single phosphodiester bond of the 28 S rRNA. alpha-Sarcin, the best characterized member of this family, is a potent cytotoxin that promotes apoptosis of human tumor cells after internalization via endocytosis. This latter ability is related to its interaction with phospholipid bilayers. These proteins share a common structural core with nontoxic ribonucleases of the RNase T1 family. However, significant structural differences between these two groups of proteins are related to the presence of a long amino-terminal beta-hairpin in ribotoxins and to the different length of their unstructured loops. The amino-terminal deletion mutant Delta(7-22) of alpha-sarcin has been produced in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. It retains the same conformation as the wild-type protein as ascertained by complete spectroscopic characterization based on circular dichroism, fluorescence, and NMR techniques. This mutant exhibits ribonuclease activity against naked rRNA and synthetic substrates but lacks the specific ability of the wild-type protein to degrade rRNA in intact ribosomes. The results indicate that alpha-sarcin interacts with the ribosome at two regions, i.e. the well known sarcin-ricin loop of the rRNA and a different region recognized by the beta-hairpin of the protein. In addition, this latter protein portion is involved in interaction with cell membranes. The mutant displays decreased interaction with lipid vesicles and shows behavior compatible with the absence of one vesicle-interacting region. In agreement with this conclusion, the deletion mutant exhibits a very low cytotoxicity on human rhabdomyosarcoma cells.

Solution structure and dynamics of ribonuclease Sa

We have used NMR methods to characterize the structure and dynamics of ribonuclease Sa in solution. The solution structure of RNase Sa was obtained using the distance constraints provided by 2,276 NOEs and the C6-C96 disulfide bond. The 40 resulting structures are well determined; their mean pairwise RMSD is 0.76 A (backbone) and 1.26 A (heavy atoms). The solution structures are similar to previously determined crystal structures, especially in the secondary structure, but exhibit new features: the loop composed of Pro 45 to Ser 48 adopts distinct conformations and the rings of tyrosines 51, 52, and 55 have reduced flipping rates. Amide protons with greatly reduced exchange rates are found predominantly in interior beta-strands and the alpha-helix, but also in the external 3/10 helix and edge beta-strand linked by the disulfide bond. Analysis of (15)N relaxation experiments (R1, R2, and NOE) at 600 MHz revealed five segments, consisting of residues 1-5, 28-31, 46-50, 60-65, 74-77, retaining flexibility in solution. The change in conformation entropy for RNase SA folding is smaller than previously believed, since the native protein is more flexible in solution than in a crystal.

Assignment of the contribution of the tryptophan residues to the spectroscopic and functional properties of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin

alpha-Sarcin, a potent cytotoxic protein from Aspergillus giganteus, contains two tryptophan residues at positions 4 and 51. Two single, W4F and W51F, and the double mutant, W4/51F, have been produced and purified to homogeneity. These two residues are neither required for the highly specific ribonucleolytic activity of the protein on the ribosomes (production of the so called alpha-fragment) nor for its interaction with lipid membranes (aggregation and fusion of vesicles), although the mutant forms involving Trp-51 show a decreased ribonuclease activity. Proton NMR data reveal that no significant changes in the global structure of the enzyme occur upon replacement of Trp-51 by Phe. Substitution of each Trp residue results in a 4 degrees C drop in the thermal denaturation midpoint, and the double mutant's midpoint is 9 degrees C lower. Trp-51 is responsible for most of the near-UV circular dichroism of the protein and also contributes to the overall ellipticity of the protein in the peptide bond region. Trp-51 does not show fluorescence emission. The membrane-bound proteins undergo a thermal denaturation at a lower temperature than the corresponding free forms. The interaction of the protein with phospholipid bilayers promotes a large increase of the quantum yield of Trp-51 and its fluorescence emission is quenched by anthracene incorporated into the hydrophobic region of such bilayers. This indicates that the region around this residue is located in the hydrophobic core of the bilayer following protein-vesicle interaction.

The action mode of the ribosome-inactivating protein alpha-sarcin

Based on the tertiary structure of the ribosome-inactivating protein alpha-sarcin, domains that are responsible for hydrolyzing ribosomes and naked RNA have been dissected. In this study, we found that the head-to-tail interaction between the first amino beta-strand and the last carboxyl beta-strand is not involved in catalyzing the hydrolysis of ribosomes or ribonucleic acids. Instead, a four-strand pleated beta-sheet is indispensable for catalyzing both substrates, suggesting that alpha-sarcin and ribonuclease T1 (RNase T1) share a similar catalytic center. The integrity of an amino beta-hairpin and that of the loop L3 in alpha-sarcin are crucial for recognizing and hydrolyzing ribosomes in vitro and in vivo. However, a mutant protein without the beta-hairpin structure, or with a disrupted loop L3, is still capable of digesting ribonucleic acids. The functional involvement of the beta-hairpin and the loop L3 in the sarcin stem/loop RNA of ribosomes is demonstrated by a docking model, suggesting that the two structures are in essence naturally designed to distinguish ribosome-inactivating proteins from RNase T1 to inactivate ribosomes.

The highly refined solution structure of the cytotoxic ribonuclease alpha-sarcin reveals the structural requirements for substrate recognition and ribonucleolytic activity

alpha-Sarcin selectively cleaves a single phosphodiester bond in a universally conserved sequence of the major rRNA, that inactivates the ribosome. The elucidation of the three-dimensional solution structure of this 150 residue enzyme is a crucial step towards understanding alpha-sarcin's conformational stability, ribonucleolytic activity, and its exceptionally high level of specificity. Here, the solution structure has been determined on the basis of 2658 conformationally relevant distances restraints (including stereoespecific assignments) and 119 torsional angular restraints, by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy methods. A total of 60 converged structures have been computed using the program DYANA. The 47 best DYANA structures, following restrained energy minimization by GROMOS, represent the solution structure of alpha-sarcin. The resulting average pairwise root-mean-square-deviation is 0.86 A for backbone atoms and 1.47 A for all heavy atoms. When the more variable regions are excluded from the analysis, the pairwise root-mean-square deviation drops to 0.50 A and 1.00 A, for backbone and heavy atoms, respectively. The alpha-sarcin structure is similar to that reported for restrictocin, although some differences are clearly evident, especially in the loop regions. The average rmsd between the structurally aligned backbones of the 47 final alpha-sarcin structures and the crystal structure of restrictocin is 1.46 A. On the basis of a docking model constructed with alpha-sarcin solution structure and the crystal structure of a 29-nt RNA containing the sarcin/ricin domain, the regions in the protein that could interact specifically with the substrate have been identified. The structural elements that account for the specificity of RNA recognition are located in two separate regions of the protein. One is composed by residues 51 to 55 and loop 5, and the other region, located more than 11 A away in the structure, is the positively charged segment formed by residues 110 to 114.

The solubility of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin, produced as a recombinant protein in Escherichia coli, is increased in the presence of thioredoxin

The yield of purified recombinant alpha-sarcin increases approximately three- to fourfold when this toxin is co-expressed in Escherichia coli with thioredoxin. This increased production is attributed to the existence, in the presence of thioredoxin, of a reducing environment which allows rearrangement of incorrect disulphide bonds to produce the soluble native conformation. The protein thus produced retains the structural, spectroscopic and enzymatic features of the natural fungal alpha-sarcin.

Role of histidine-50, glutamic acid-96, and histidine-137 in the ribonucleolytic mechanism of the ribotoxin alpha-sarcin

alpha-Sarcin is a ribotoxin secreted by the mold Aspergillus giganteus that degrades the ribosomal RNA by acting as a cyclizing ribonuclease. Three residues potentially involved in the mechanism of catalysis--histidine-50, glutamic acid-96, and histidine-137--were changed to glutamine. Three different single mutation variants (H50Q, E96Q, H137Q) as well as a double variant (H50/137Q) and a triple variant (H50/137Q/E96Q) were prepared and isolated to homogeneity. These variants were spectroscopically (circular dichroism, fluorescence emission, and proton nuclear magnetic resonance) characterized. According to these results, the three-dimensional structure of these variants of alpha-sarcin was preserved; only very minor local changes were detected. All the variants were inactive when assayed against either intact ribosomes or poly(A). The effect of pH on the ribonucleolytic activity of alpha-sarcin was evaluated against the ApA dinucleotide. This assay revealed that only the H50Q variant still retained its ability to cleave a phosphodiester bond, but it did so to a lesser extent than did wild-type alpha-sarcin. The results obtained are interpreted in terms of His137 and Glu96 as essential residues for the catalytic activity of alpha-sarcin (His137 as the general acid and Glu96 as the general base) and His50 stabilizing the transition state of the reaction catalyzed by alpha-sarcin.

Ribotoxins are a more widespread group of proteins within the filamentous fungi than previously believed

Alpha-sarcin, restrictocin and mitogillin are the best known members of the family of fungal ribotoxins. In recent years, new members of this family have been discovered and characterised. In this work, we study the occurrence of ribotoxins among different species of fungi. The presence of ribotoxins has been identified in some new species by means of genetic studies, as well as expression and activity assays. The ribotoxin genes have been partially sequenced, and demonstrate a high degree of similarity. These studies demonstrate that these toxins are more widespread than previously considered. This is surprising, considering the ribotoxins are such specific and potent toxins, of unknown biological function. These studies confirm the hypothesis that these proteins are naturally engineered toxins derived from ribonucleases of broad substrate specificity.

Oligomerization of the cytotoxin alpha-sarcin associated with phospholipid membranes

alpha-Sarcin is a cytotoxic protein that specifically inactivates ribosomes. The protein translocates across phospholipid membranes. Oligomerization of the protein occurs upon interaction with membranes. Chemically cross-linked protein oligomers have been obtained by treatment of protein-vesicle complexes with the membrane impermeant reagent bis-(sulfosuccinimidyl) suberate. These structures are only obtained in the presence of acidic lipid vesicles composed of either natural or synthetic phospholipids. Such oligomers are not produced in concentrated protein solutions in the absence of vesicles. The formation of the chemically stabilized oligomers is saturated at the same lipid to protein molar ratio as all the perturbations caused by alpha-sarcin on lipid vesicles. Results are discussed in terms of the involvement of oligomer formation on protein translocation across membranes.

A peptide of nine amino acid residues from alpha-sarcin cytotoxin is a membrane-perturbing structure

A water-soluble synthetic peptide with only nine amino acid residues, comprising the 131-139 sequence region of the cytotoxic protein alpha-sarcin (secreted by the mold Aspergillus giganteus), interacts with large unilamellar vesicles composed of acid phospholipids. It promotes lipid mixing between bilayers and leakage of vesicle aqueous contents, and it also abolishes the phospholipid phase transition. Other larger peptides containing such an amino acid sequence also produce these effects. These peptides acquire alpha-helical conformation in the presence of trifluoroethanol, but display beta-strand conformation in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. The interaction of these peptides with the lipid vesicles also results in beta-structure. The obtained data are discussed in terms of the involvement of the 131-139 stretch of alpha-sarcin in its interaction with lipid membranes.

Sequence determination and molecular characterization of gigantin, a cytotoxic protein produced by the mould Aspergillus giganteus IFO 5818

Gigantin is a 17-kDa ribonuclease secreted by Aspergillus giganteus IFO 5818. The sequence of the genomic DNA coding for this protein is reported. The deduced amino acid sequence reveals nine amino acid variations with respect to alpha-sarcin, a well-characterized ribosome-inactivating protein from A. giganteus MDH 18894. The peptides obtained after tryptic digestion of reduced and carboxyamidomethylated gigantin have been chromatographically separated. The analysis of these peptides in comparison to those originating from alpha-sarcin corroborates the above sequence differences. These do not sensibly modify the conformation of the protein, based on the coincidence of the circular dichroism and fluorescence emission spectra of the two proteins. The obtained results are discussed in terms of the involvement of the distinctive residues in the immunological and catalytic properties that distinguish gigantin from alpha-sarcin.

Structural basis for the catalytic mechanism and substrate specificity of the ribonuclease alpha-sarcin

alpha-Sarcin is a ribosome-inactivating protein which selectively cleaves a single phosphodiester bond in a universally conserved sequence of the major rRNA. The solution structure of a-sarcin has been determined on the basis of 1898 distance and angular experimental constraints from NMR spectroscopy. It reveals a catalytic mechanism analogous to that of the T1 family of ribonucleases while its exquisite specificity resides in the contacts provided by its distinctive loops.