Molecular mechanisms of microheterogeneity-induced defect formation in ferritin crystallization

Nonclassical mechanisms to irreversibly suppress β-hematin crystal growth

Hematin crystallization is an essential element of heme detoxification of malaria parasites and its inhibition by antimalarial drugs is a common treatment avenue. We demonstrate at biomimetic conditions in vitro irreversible inhibition of hematin crystal growth due to distinct cooperative mechanisms that activate at high crystallization driving forces. The evolution of crystal shape after limited-time exposure to both artemisinin metabolites and quinoline-class antimalarials indicates that crystal growth remains suppressed after the artemisinin metabolites and the drugs are purged from the solution. Treating malaria parasites with the same agents reveals that three- and six-hour inhibitor pulses inhibit parasite growth with efficacy comparable to that of inhibitor exposure during the entire parasite lifetime. Time-resolved in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM), complemented by light scattering, reveals two molecular-level mechanisms of inhibitor action that prevent β-hematin growth recovery. Hematin adducts of artemisinins incite copious nucleation of nonextendable nanocrystals, which incorporate into larger growing crystals, whereas pyronaridine, a quinoline-class drug, promotes step bunches, which evolve to engender abundant dislocations. Both incorporated crystals and dislocations are known to induce lattice strain, which persists and permanently impedes crystal growth. Nucleation, step bunching, and other cooperative behaviors can be amplified or curtailed as means to control crystal sizes, size distributions, aspect ratios, and other properties essential for numerous fields that rely on crystalline materials.

Precrystallization solute assemblies and crystal symmetry

Solution crystallization is a part of the synthesis of materials ranging from geological and biological minerals to pharmaceuticals, fine chemicals, and advanced electronic components. Attempts to predict the structure, growth rates and properties of emerging crystals have been frustrated, in part, by the poor understanding of the correlations between the oligomeric state of the solute, the growth unit, and the crystal symmetry. To explore how a solute monomer or oligomer is selected as the unit that incorporates into kinks and how crystal symmetry impacts this selection, we combine scanning probe microscopy, optical spectroscopy, and all-atom molecular simulations using as examples two organic materials, olanzapine (OZPN) and etioporphyrin I (EtpI). The dominance of dimeric structures in OZPN crystals has spurred speculation that the dimers preform in the solution, where they capture the majority of the solute, and then assemble into crystals. By contrast, EtpI in crystals aligns in parallel stacks of flat EtpI monomers unrelated by point symmetry. Raman and absorption spectroscopies show that solute monomers are the majority solute species in solutions of both compounds. Surprisingly, the kinetics of incorporation of OZPN into kinks is bimolecular, indicating that the growth unit is a solute dimer, a minority solution component. The disconnection between the dominant solute species, the growth unit, and the crystal symmetry is even stronger with EtpI, for which the (010) face grows by incorporating monomers, whereas the growth unit of the (001) face is a dimer. Collectively, the crystallization kinetics results with OZPN and EtpI establish that the structures of the dominant solute species and of the incorporating solute complex do not correlate with the symmetry of the crystal lattice. In a broader context, these findings illuminate the immense complexity of crystallization scenarios that need to be explored on the road to the understanding and control of crystallization.

Core Protein-Directed Antivirals and Importin β Can Synergistically Disrupt HBV Capsids

Viral structural proteins can have multiple activities. Antivirals that target structural proteins have potential to exhibit multiple antiviral mechanisms. Hepatitis B Virus (HBV) core protein (Cp) is involved in most stages of the viral lifecycle: it assembles into capsids, packages viral RNA, is a metabolic compartment for reverse transcription, interacts with nuclear trafficking machinery, and disassembles to release the viral genome into the nucleus. During nuclear localization, HBV capsids bind to host importins (e.g. Impβ) via Cp's C-terminal domain (CTD); the CTD is localized to the interior of the capsid and is transiently exposed on the exterior. We used HAP12 as a representative Cp Allosteric Modulators (CpAMs), a class of antivirals that inappropriately stimulates and misdirects HBV assembly and deforms capsids. CpAM impact on other aspects of the HBV lifecycle is poorly understood. We investigated how HAP12 influenced the interactions between empty or RNA-filled capsids with Impβ and trypsin in vitro. We showed that HAP12 can modulate CTD accessibility and capsid stability, depending on the saturation of HAP12-binding sites. We demonstrated that Impβ synergistically contributes to capsid disruption at high levels of HAP12 saturation, using electron microscopy to visualize disruption and rearrangement of Cp dimers into aberrant complexes. However, RNA-filled capsids resisted the destabilizing effects of HAP12 and Impβ. In summary, we show host protein-induced catalysis of capsid disruption, an unexpected additional mechanism of action for CpAMs. Potentially, untimely capsid disassembly can hamper the HBV lifecycle and also cause the virus to become vulnerable to host innate immune responses. IMPORTANCE The HBV core, an icosahedral complex of 120 copies of the homodimeric core (capsid) protein with or without packaged nucleic acid, is transported to the host nucleus by its interaction with host importin proteins. Importin-core interaction requires the core protein C-terminal domain, which is inside the capsid, to "flip" to the capsid exterior. Core-protein directed drugs that affect capsid assembly and stability have been developed recently. We show that these molecules can, synergistically with importins, disrupt capsids. This mechanism of action, synergism with host protein, has potential to disrupt the virus lifecycle and activate the innate immune system.

High mobility of lattice molecules and defects during the early stage of protein crystallization

Protein crystals are expected to be useful not only for their molecular structure analysis but also as functional materials due to their unique properties. Although the generation and the propagation of defects during crystallization play critical roles in the final properties of protein crystals, the dynamics of these processes are poorly understood. By time-resolved liquid-cell transmission electron microscopy, we observed that nanosized crystal defects are surprisingly mobile during the early stages of the crystallization of a lysozyme as a model protein. This highly dynamic behavior of defects reveals that the lattice molecules are mobile throughout the crystal structure. Moreover, the disappearance of the defects indicated that intermolecular bonds can break and reform rapidly with little energetic cost, as reported in theoretical studies. All these findings are in marked contrast to the generally accepted notion that crystal lattices are rigid with very limited mobility of individual lattice molecules.

Temperature-dependent growth of protein crystals with temperature-independent solubility: case study of apoferritin

Combined diffusion- and interface-controlled crystal growth analysis elucidates the temperature-dependent growth kinetics of protein crystals at a relatively small variation of supersaturation.

Nucleation of Protein Crystals under the Influence of Solution Shear Flow

Several recent theories and simulations have predicted that shear flow could enhance, or, conversely, suppress the nucleation of crystals from solution. Such modulations would offer a pathway for nucleation control and provide a novel explanation for numerous mysteries in nucleation research. For experimental tests of the effects of shear flow on protein crystal nucleation, we found that if a protein solution droplet of approximately 5 microL (2-3 mm diameter at base) is held on a hydrophobic substrate in an enclosed environment and in a quasi-uniform constant electric field of 2 to 6 kV cm(-1), a rotational flow with a maximum rate at the droplet top of approximately 10 microm s(-1) is induced. The shear rate varies from 10(-3) to 10(-1) s(-1). The likely mechanism of the rotational flow involves adsorption of the protein and amphiphylic buffer molecules on the air-water interface and their redistribution in the electric field, leading to nonuniform surface tension of the droplet and surface tension-driven flow. Observations of the number of nucleated crystals in 24- and 72-h experiments with the proteins ferritin, apoferritin, and lysozyme revealed that the crystals are typically nucleated at a certain radius of the droplet, that is, at a preferred shear rate. Variations of the rotational flow velocity resulted in suppression or enhancement of the total number of nucleated crystals of ferritin and apoferritin, while all solution flow rates were found to enhance lysozyme crystal nucleation. These observations show that shear flow may strongly affect nucleation, and that for some systems, an optimal flow velocity, leading to fastest nucleation, exists. Comparison with the predictions of theories and simulations suggest that the formation of ordered nuclei in a "normal" protein solution cannot be affected by such low shear rates. We conclude that the flow acts by helping or suppressing the formation of ordered nuclei within mesoscopic metastable dense liquid clusters. Such clusters were recently shown to exist in protein solutions and to constitute the first step in the nucleation mechanism of many protein and nonproteinsystems.

A fast response mechanism for insulin storage in crystals may involve kink generation by association of 2D clusters

Crystals that are likely rhombohedral of Zn-insulin hexamers form in the islets of Langerhans in the pancreases of many mammals. The suggested functions of crystal formation is to protect the insulin from proteases and increase the degree of conversion of soluble proinsulin. To accomplish these ends, crystal growth should be fast and adaptable to rate fluctuations in the conversion reaction. Zn-insulin crystals grow layer by layer. Each layer spreads by the attachment of molecules to kinks located at the layers' edges, also called steps. The kinks are thought to be generated either by thermal fluctuations, as postulated by Gibbs, or by 1D nucleation of new crystalline rows. The kink density determines the rate at which steps advance, and these two kink-generation mechanisms lead to weak near-linear responses of the growth rate to concentration variations. We demonstrate for the crystallization of Zn-insulin a mechanism of kink generation whereby 2D clusters of several insulin molecules preformed on the terraces between steps associate to the steps. This mechanism results in several-fold-higher kink density, a faster rate of crystallization, and a high sensitivity of the kinetics to small increases of the solute concentration. If the found mechanism operates during insulin crystallization in vivo, it could be a part of the biological regulation of insulin production and function. For other crystallizing materials in biological and nonbiological systems, this mechanism provides an understanding of the often seen nonlinear acceleration of the kinetics.

A Metastable Prerequisite for the Growth of Lumazine Synthase Crystals

Dense liquid phases, metastable with respect to a solid phase, form in solutions of proteins and small-molecule materials. They have been shown to serve as a prerequisite for the nucleation of crystals and other ordered solid phases. Here, using crystals of the protein lumazine synthase from Bacillus subtilis, which grow by the generation and spreading of layers, we demonstrate that within a range of supersaturations the only mechanism of generation of growth layers involves the association of submicrometer-size droplets of the dense liquid to the crystal surface. The dense liquid is metastable not only with respect to the crystals, but also with respect to the low-concentration solution: dynamic light scattering reveals that the droplets' lifetime is limited to several seconds, after which they decay into the low-concentration solution. The short lifetime does not allow growth to detectable dimensions so that liquid-liquid phase separation is not observed within a range of conditions broader than the one used for crystallization. If during their lifetime the droplets encounter a crystal surface, they lower their free energy not by decay, but by transformation into crystalline matter, ensuring perfect registry with the substrate. These observations illustrate two novel features of phase transformations in solutions: the existence of doubly metastable, short-lifetime dense phases and their crucial role for the growth of an ordered solid phase.

Crystallization of Transmembrane Proteins in cubo: Mechanisms of Crystal Growth and Defect Formation

Crystallization of membrane proteins is a major stumbling block en route to elucidating their structure and understanding their function. The novel concept of membrane protein crystallization from lipidic cubic phases, "in cubo", has yielded well-ordered crystals and high-resolution structures of several membrane proteins, yet progress has been slow due to the lack of understanding of the molecular mechanisms of protein transport, crystal nucleation, growth, and defect formation in cubo. Here, we examine at molecular and mesoscopic resolution with atomic force microscopy the morphology of in cubo grown bacteriorhodopsin crystals in inert buffers and during etching by detergent. The results reveal that crystal nucleation occurs following local rearrangement of the highly curved lipidic cubic phase into a lamellar structure, which is akin to that of the native membrane. Crystals grow within the bulk cubic phase surrounded by such lamellar structures, whereby transport towards a growing crystalline layer is constrained to within an individual lamella. This mechanism leads to lack of dislocations, generation of new crystalline layers at numerous locations, and to voids and block boundaries. The characteristic macroscopic lengthscale of these defects suggests that the crystals grow by attachment of single molecules to the nuclei. These insights into the mechanisms of nucleation, growth and transport in cubo provide guidance en route to a rational design of membrane protein crystallization, and promise to further advance the field.

Crystallization mechanisms of hemoglobin C in the R state

Crystallization of the mutated hemoglobin, HbC, which occurs inside red blood cells of patients expressing betaC-globin and exhibiting the homozygous CC and the heterozygous SC (in which two mutant beta-globins, S and C, are expressed) diseases, is a convenient model for processes underlying numerous condensation diseases. As a first step, we investigated the molecular-level mechanisms of crystallization of this protein from high-concentration phosphate buffer in its stable carbomonoxy form using high-resolution atomic force microscopy. We found that in conditions of equilibrium with the solution, the crystals' surface reconstructs into four-molecule-wide strands along the crystallographic a (or b) axis. However, the crystals do not grow by the alignment of such preformed strands. We found that the crystals grow by the attachment of single molecules to suitable sites on the surface. These sites are located along the edges of new layers generated by two-dimensional nucleation or by screw dislocations. During growth, the steps propagate with random velocities, with the mean being an increasing function of the crystallization driving force. These results show that the crystallization mechanisms of HbC are similar to those found for other proteins. Therefore, strategies developed to control protein crystallization in vitro may be applicable to pathology-related crystallization systems.

Protein crystals and their growth

Recent results on the associations between protein molecules in crystal lattices, crystal-solution surface energy, elastic properties, strength, and spontaneous crystal cracking are reviewed and discussed. In addition, some basic approaches to understanding the solubility of proteins are followed by an overview of crystal nucleation and growth. It is argued that variability of mixing in batch crystallization may be a source of the variation in the number of crystals ultimately appearing in the sample. The frequency at which new molecules join a crystal lattice is measured by the kinetic coefficient and is related to the observed crystal growth rate. Numerical criteria used to discriminate diffusion- and kinetic-limited growth are discussed on this basis. Finally, the creation of defects is discussed with an emphasis on the role of impurities and convection on macromolecular crystal perfection.

Repair of impurity-poisoned protein crystal surfaces

The surface morphology of Bence-Jones protein (BJP) crystals was investigated during growth and dissolution by using in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM). It was shown that over a wide supersaturation range, impurities adsorb on the crystalline surface and ultimately form an impurity adsorption layer that prevents further growth of the crystal. At low undersaturations, this impurity adsorption layer prevents dissolution. At greater undersaturation, dissolution takes place around large particles incorporated into the crystal, leading to etch pits with impurity-free bottoms. On restoration of supersaturation conditions, two-dimensional nucleation takes place on the impurity-free bottoms of these etch pits. After new growth layers fill in the etch pits, they cover the impurity-poisoned top layer of the crystal face. This leads to the resumption of its growth. Formation of an impurity-adsorption layer can explain the termination of growth of macromolecular crystals that has been widely noted. Growth-dissolution-growth cycles could be used to produce larger crystals that otherwise would have stopped growing because of impurity poisoning.

Diffusion-limited kinetics of the solution-solid phase transition of molecular substances

For critical tests of whether diffusion-limited kinetics is an option for the solution-solid phase transition of molecular substances or whether they are determined exclusively by a transition state, we performed crystallization experiments with ferritin and apoferritin, a unique pair of proteins with identical shells but different molecular masses. We find that the kinetic coefficient for crystallization is identical (accuracy <or=7%) for the pair, indicating diffusion-limited kinetics of crystallization. Data on the kinetics of this phase transition in systems ranging from small-molecule ionic to protein and viri suggest that the kinetics of solution-phase transitions for broad classes of small-molecule and protein materials are diffusion-limited.

Evidence for the surface-diffusion mechanism of solution crystallization from molecular-level observations with ferritin

We employ atomic force microscopy to monitor in situ, in real time, the molecular processes of crystallization of ferritin, a protein that has an inorganic single-crystalline core that can be varied. We determine the statistics of molecular attachment and detachment at the growth sites and find that the ratio of the fluxes in and out of the kinks is significantly lower than expected, assuming direct incorporation of the molecules from the solution. Determinations of the energy barrier for incorporation yield approximately 30 kJ mol(-1), significantly higher than expected for this mechanism. We conclude that attachment of molecules occurs via the surface adsorption layer. The surface coverage resulting from this mechanism is approximately 0.9, suggesting a growth mode different from the classical surface diffusion mechanism.

Atomic force microscopy of macromolecular interactions

The introduction of functional imaging tools and techniques that operate at molecular-length scales has provided investigators with unique approaches to characterizing biomolecular structure and function relationships. Recent advances in the field of scanning probe techniques and, in particular, atomic force microscopy have yielded tantalizing insights into the dynamics of protein self-assembly and the mechanics of protein unfolding.