Retinoic acid induction of featherlike structures from reticulate scales

Expressed miRNAs target feather related mRNAs involved in cell signaling, cell adhesion and structure during chicken epidermal development

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are small non-coding RNAs that regulate gene expression at the post-transcriptional level. Previous studies have shown that miRNA regulation contributes to a diverse set of processes including cellular differentiation and morphogenesis which leads to the creation of different cell types in multicellular organisms and is thus key to animal development. Feathers are one of the most distinctive features of extant birds and are important for multiple functions including flight, thermal regulation, and sexual selection. However, the role of miRNAs in feather development has been woefully understudied despite the identification of cell signaling pathways, cell adhesion molecules and structural genes involved in feather development. In this study, we performed a microarray experiment comparing the expression of miRNAs and mRNAs among three embryonic stages of development and two tissues (scutate scale and feather) of the chicken. We combined this expression data with miRNA target prediction tools and a curated list of feather related genes to produce a set of 19 miRNA-mRNA duplexes. These targeted mRNAs have been previously identified as important cell signaling and cell adhesion genes as well as structural genes involved in feather and scale morphogenesis. Interestingly, the miRNA target site of the cell signaling pathway gene, Aldehyde Dehydrogenase 1 Family, Member A3 (ALDH1A3), is unique to birds indicating a novel role in Aves. The identified miRNA target site of the cell adhesion gene, Tenascin C (TNC), is only found in specific chicken TNC splice variants that are differentially expressed in developing scutate scale and feather tissue indicating an important role of miRNA regulation in epidermal differentiation. Additionally, we found that β-keratins, a major structural component of avian and reptilian epidermal appendages, are targeted by multiple miRNA genes. In conclusion, our work provides quantitative expression data on miRNAs and mRNAs during feather and scale development and has produced a highly diverse, but manageable list of miRNA-mRNA duplexes for future validation experiments.

Dorsal versus ventral scales and the dorsoventral patterning of chick foot epidermis

The dorsal and ventral scales of the chick foot can be distinguished morphologically and molecularly: the dorsal oblong overlapping scuta expressing both alpha and beta keratins, and the ventral roundish nonprotruding reticula expressing only alpha keratins. The question arises how En-1 and Lmx1, whose role in dorsoventral limb patterning has been well established, can affect skin morphogenesis, which occurs 8 to 12 days later. Forced expression of En-1 or of Lmx1 in the hindlimb have, respectively, as expected, a ventralizing or a dorsalizing effect on skin, leading to the formation of either reticula-type or scuta-type scales on both faces. In both cases, however, the scales are abnormal and even glabrous skin without any scales at all may form. The normal inductive interactions between dermis and epidermis are disturbed after En-1 or Lmx1 misexpression. Effectively, while Lmx1 endows the dermal precursors of the ventral region with scuta inducing ability, En-1 blocks the competence of the dorsal epidermis to build scuta.

Development and evolution of the amniote integument: current landscape and future horizon

This special issue on the development and evolution of the amniote integument begins with a discussion of the adaptations to terrestrial conditions, the acquisition of water-impermeability of the reptilian integument, and the initial formation of filamentous integumentary appendages that prepare the way towards avian flight. Recent feather fossils are reviewed, and a definition of feathers is developed. Hierarchical models are proposed for the formation of complex structures, such as feathers. Molecular signals that alter the phenotype of integumentary appendages at different levels of the hierarchy are presented. Tissue interactions and the roles of keratins in evolution are discussed and linked to their bio-mechanical properties. The role of mechanical forces on patterning is explored. Elaborate extant feather variants are introduced. The regeneration/gene mis-expression protocol for the chicken feather is established as a testable model for the study of biological structures. The adaptations of the mammalian distal limb end organs to terrestrial, arboreal and aquatic conditions are discussed. The development and cycling of hair are reviewed from a molecular perspective. These contributions reveal that the structure and function of diverse integumentary appendages are variations that are superimposed on a common theme, and that their formation is modular, hierarchical and cyclical. They further reveal that these mechanisms can be understood at the molecular level, and that an integrative and organismal approach to studying integumentary appendages is called for. We propose that future research should foster interdisciplinary approaches, pursue understanding at the cellular and molecular level, analyze interactions between the environment and genome, and recognize the contributions of variation in morphogenesis and evolution.

Retinoid receptors and keratinocytes

In 1987, a tremendous boost in our understanding of the action of dietary vitamin A occurred with the discovery and characterization of nuclear receptors for retinoic acid, the active form of the vitamin, in the laboratories of P. Chambon and R. Evans. They have shown that the nuclear receptors are ligand-activated transcription factors capable of specific gene regulation. Since that discovery, it has been determined that there are at least six retinoic acid receptors belonging to two families, RARs and RXRs, that they are differentially expressed in various mammalian tissues, and that they act as homo- and heterodimers interacting with other ligand-activated nuclear receptors. The domain structure of the receptors has been described, and their DNA-binding, ligand-binding, dimerization, and transcriptional activation regions characterized. Among the most important retinoid-regulated genes are the homeobox proteins, regulatory transcription factors which are responsible for body axis formation, patterning, limb formation, and other crucial processes during development. Retinoic acid and its receptors also regulate many differentiation markers which are particularly important in stratified epithelia, such as skin and oral epithelia. Our increased understanding led to improved therapy of a large number of skin disorders, ranging from acne to wrinkles and including epidermal and oral carcinomas.

The making of a feather: homeoproteins, retinoids and adhesion molecules

We have been using feather development as a model for understanding the molecular basis of pattern formation and to explore the roles of homeoproteins, retinoids and adhesion molecules in this process. Two kinds of homeobox (Hox) protein gradients in the skin have been identified: a 'microgradient' within a single feather bud and a 'macrogradient' across the feather tract. The asynchronous alignment of different Hox macrogradients establishes a unique repertoire of Hox expression patterns in skin appendages within the integument, designated here as the 'Hox codes of skin appendages'. It is hypothesized that these Hox codes contribute to the phenotypic determination of skin appendages. High doses of retinoic acid cause a morphological transformation between feather and scale, while low doses of retinoic acid cause an alteration of the axial orientation of skin appendages. We have tested the ability of molecules directly involved in the feather formation process to mediate the action of the Hox codes, and surmise that adhesion molecules are potential candidates. Using specific Fabs to suppress the activity of adhesion molecules, we have found that L-CAM is involved in the formation of the hexagonal pattern, N-CAM is involved in mediating dermal condensations, tenascin is involved in feather bud growth and elongation, and integrin beta-1 is essential for epithelial-mesenchymal interactions. More work is in progress to fully understand the molecular pathways regulating the feather formation process.

Adhesion molecules and homeoproteins in the phenotypic determination of skin appendages

We examined the roles of adhesion molecules and homeoproteins in the morphogenesis of skin appendages using feather as a model. The expression pattern of these molecules in different stages of feather development were very dynamic. For example, neural cell adhesion molecules are present first in the dermal condensations, then in distal bud epithelium, then in the dermal papilla, and finally in the marginal and axial plates. Tenascin is present first in the placode, then in the anterior bud epithelium and mesoderm, and then in the dermal papilla. The expression patterns suggest that the adhesion molecules are involved in forming the boundary of cell groups that interact to form skin appendages. Antibody perturbation of embryonic skin-explant cultures showed that liver cell adhesion molecules are involved in establishing the hexagonal pattern, neural cell adhesion molecules are involved in the formation of dermal condensations, tenascin appears to be involved in the growth of feather buds, and integrin is essential for epithelial-mesenchymal interactions. Using antibodies to XlHbox 1 (similar to Hox 3.3 or C6) and Hox 4.2 (or D4), we showed that there is a homeoprotein gradient within the feather buds, and that the expression pattern is position-specific. It is hypothesized that Hox codes, derived from the combined expression pattern of homeoproteins, determine the phenotypes and orientation of skin appendages. Experiments using retinoids in the media or retinoid-soaked beads to create a local retinoid gradient are consistent with this hypothesis. As demonstrated here, feather development provides an excellent opportunity to analyze the molecular cascade of skin-appendage morphogenesis.

Mechanism of skin morphogenesis. II. Retinoic acid modulates axis orientation and phenotypes of skin appendages

The factors that determine the axial orientation and phenotypes of skin appendages were analyzed by studying the effect of retinoic acid (RA) on embryonic chicken skin explant cultures. With RA uniformly distributed in the culture media, the feather buds became smaller, were disoriented or were transformed into scale-like structures in a concentration-dependent manner (from 0.05-2.5 microM). With RA distributed as a gradient created by a RA-soaked anion exchange bead, a radial zone of inhibition with a rim of disoriented buds was observed. The new axis of the disoriented buds appeared to be determined by a combination of the original feather axis determining force and a new axial force pointing centrifugally away from the RA source. This observed result can be simulated with a computer model using a vectorial sum of different feather axial determination forces. The size of the inhibited zone is linearly correlated to the RA concentration and may be used to quantify the morphogenetic activity of retinoids. These effects are specific to developmental stages (Hamburg and Hamilton stage 31–34). Both all-trans and 13-cis RA have morphogenetic activity. Retinol has no effect and retinal has a small inhibitory effect but neither phenotypic transformation nor axial disorientation were observed. The antero-posterior gradient of homeoprotein XlHbox 1 in feather buds became diffusive after RA treatment. RA dissolves dermal condensations and the distribution of N-CAM is altered from an anterior localized pattern to a diffusive presence in the bud cores. Endogenous retinoids in developing skins show developmental stage-dependent changes both quantitatively and qualitatively. The results suggest that RA either is or can modulate the endogenous morphogen(s) that determine the orientation and phenotype of skin appendages, and that this morphogenetic pathway involves Hox genes and adhesion molecules.

Avian scale development

Germinative cells of the scutate scale epidermis from 15-day embryos are committed to appendage-specific, beta stratum formation in association with a foreign dermis. Commitment precedes the time (17 days of development) at which beta strata are actually present in their site-specific locations along the outer surface of each scutate scale. This observation suggested the possibility that commitment to beta stratum formation might be occurring as the outer epidermal surface of each scutate scale first becomes established between 12 and 13 days of development. It is at this time that the scale epidermis loses its ability to participate in feather morphogenesis and cell proliferation becomes restricted to a true stratum basale. To examined the ability of the presumptive scutate scale epidermis to generate beta strata in the absence of the inductive scutate scale dermis, scutate scale epidermis from 11-, 12-, and 13-day embryos was recombined with 15-day reticulate scale dermis and grown for 7 or 9 days. The dermis of reticulate scales does not induce beta stratum formation, but it does support differentiation of a beta stratum by the determined 15-day scutate scale epidermis. Using immunohistological and biochemical analyses of beta-keratins, we find that each of these presumptive scutate scale epidermises is competent to generate appendage-specific beta strata in the absence of the scutate scale dermis. This determination is occurring prior to scale ridge morphogenesis and differentiation of the epidermis into the distinct outer and inner epidermal surfaces of the scale ridge. The restricted distribution of beta strata to the apical domes of individual reticulate-like scales demonstrates that the germinative cells of the committed epidermises are responding to patterned cues. This study also suggests that all basal cells of the presumptive scutate scale epidermis are initially endowed with the ability to generate cells that form a beta stratum.

Biochemical identification and immunological localization of two non-keratin polypeptides associated with the terminal differentiation of avian scale epidermis

The expression of two previously uncharacterized polypeptides produced in epidermal cells of chick reticulate and scutate scales during late embryonic scale histogenesis and in hatchling birds has been studied biochemically and immunologically. These polypeptides have been identified by two-dimensional pH gradient gel electrophoresis as basic in charge, with apparent molecular weights of 20 and 23 kD, and they have been characterized immunologically and by amino acid analysis as non-keratin in nature. Monoclonal antibodies which react with both polypeptides have been used for immunohistochemical and immunogold electron-microscopic localization. Immunoreactivity was observed in suprabasal cells of reticulate scale epidermis, where it codistributed with bundles of alpha-type cytokeratins in the alpha-keratin-rich layers of epidermis known as the alpha stratum and in suprabasal cells of the outer epidermal surface of scutate scales, where it codistributed with alpha- and beta-type keratin filament bundles in the beta-keratin-rich layers of epidermis known as the beta stratum.

Avian scale development. XIII. Epidermal germinative cells are committed to appendage-specific differentiation and respond to patterned cues in the dermis

The ability of the germinative cell population of scutate scale epidermis to continue to generate cells that undergo their appendage-specific differentiation (beta stratum formation), when associated with foreign dermis, was examined. Tissue recombination experiments were carried out which placed anterior metatarsal epidermis (scutate scale forming region) from normal 15-day chick embryos with either the anterior metatarsal dermis from 15-day scaleless (sc/sc) embryos or the dermis from the metatarsal footpad (reticulate scale forming region) of 15-day normal embryos. Neither of these dermal tissues are able to induce beta stratum formation in the simple ectodermal epithelium of the chorion, however, the footpad dermis develops an appendage-specific pattern during morphogenesis of the reticulate scales, while the sc/sc dermis does not. Morphological and immunohistological criteria were used to assess appendage-specific epidermal differentiation in these recombinants. The results show that the germinative cell population of the 15-day scutate scale epidermis is committed to generating suprabasal cells that follow their appendage-specific pathways of histogenesis and terminal differentiation. Of significance is the observation that the expression of this determined state occurred only when the epidermis differentiated in association with the footpad dermis, not when it was associated with the sc/sc dermis. The consistent positioning of the newly generated beta strata to the apical regions of individual reticulate-like appendages demonstrates that the dermal cues necessary for terminal epidermal differentiation are present in a reticulate scale pattern. The observation that beta stratum formation is completely missing in the determined scutate scale epidermis when associated with the sc/sc dermis adds to our understanding of the sc/sc defect. The present data support the conclusion of earlier studies that the anterior metatarsal dermis from 15-day sc/sc embryos lacks the ability to induce beta stratum formation in a foreign epithelium. In addition, these observations evoke the hypothesis that the sc/sc dermis either lacks the cues (generated during scutate and reticulate scale morphogenesis) necessary for terminal differentiation of the determined scutate scale epidermis or inhibits the generation of a beta stratum.