Inhibition of NAE-dependent protein hyper-NEDDylation in cystic cholangiocytes halts cystogenesis in experimental models of polycystic liver disease

Clinical manifestation, epidemiology, genetic basis, potential molecular targets, and current treatment of polycystic liver disease

Polycystic liver disease (PLD) is a rare condition observed in three genetic diseases, including autosomal dominant polycystic liver disease (ADPLD), autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD), and autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease (ARPKD). PLD usually does not impair liver function, and advanced PLD becomes symptomatic when the enlarged liver compresses adjacent organs or increases intra-abdominal pressure. Currently, the diagnosis of PLD is mainly based on imaging, and genetic testing is not required except for complex cases. Besides, genetic testing may help predict patients' prognosis, classify patients for genetic intervention, and conduct early treatment. Although the underlying genetic causes and mechanisms are not fully understood, previous studies refer to primary ciliopathy or impaired ciliogenesis as the main culprit. Primarily, PLD occurs due to defective ciliogenesis and ineffective endoplasmic reticulum quality control. Specifically, loss of function mutations of genes that are directly involved in ciliogenesis, such as Pkd1, Pkd2, Pkhd1, and Dzip1l, can lead to both hepatic and renal cystogenesis in ADPKD and ARPKD. In addition, loss of function mutations of genes that are involved in endoplasmic reticulum quality control and protein folding, trafficking, and maturation, such as PRKCSH, Sec63, ALG8, ALG9, GANAB, and SEC61B, can impair the production and function of polycystin1 (PC1) and polycystin 2 (PC2) or facilitate their degradation and indirectly promote isolated hepatic cystogenesis or concurrent hepatic and renal cystogenesis. Recently, it was shown that mutations of LRP5, which impairs canonical Wnt signaling, can lead to hepatic cystogenesis. PLD is currently treated by somatostatin analogs, percutaneous intervention, surgical fenestration, resection, and liver transplantation. In addition, based on the underlying molecular mechanisms and signaling pathways, several investigational treatments have been used in preclinical studies, some of which have shown promising results. This review discusses the clinical manifestation, complications, prevalence, genetic basis, and treatment of PLD and explains the investigational methods of treatment and future research direction, which can be beneficial for researchers and clinicians interested in PLD.

Polycystic liver diseases: from molecular basis to development of effective treatments

Polycystic liver diseases (PLDs) comprise a heterogeneous group of congenital genetic disorders that mainly affect bile duct epithelial cells, known as cholangiocytes. Patients with PLD usually present bile duct dilatation and/or progressive develop intrahepatic, fluid-filled biliary cysts (more than 10), which is the main cause of morbidity.

Novel α-1,3-Glucosyltransferase Variants and Their Broad Clinical Polycystic Liver Disease Spectrum

Protein-truncating variants in α-1,3-glucosyltransferase (ALG8) are a risk factor for a mild cystic kidney disease phenotype. The association between these variants and liver cysts is limited. We aim to identify pathogenic ALG8 variants in our cohort of autosomal dominant polycystic liver disease (ADPLD) individuals. In order to fine-map the phenotypical spectrum of pathogenic ALG8 variant carriers, we performed targeted ALG8 screening in 478 ADPLD singletons, and exome sequencing in 48 singletons and 4 patients from two large ADPLD families. Eight novel and one previously reported pathogenic variant in ALG8 were discovered in sixteen patients. The ALG8 clinical phenotype ranges from mild to severe polycystic liver disease, and from innumerable small to multiple large hepatic cysts. The presence of <5 renal cysts that do not affect renal function is common in this population. Three-dimensional homology modeling demonstrated that six variants cause a truncated ALG8 protein with abnormal functioning, and one variant is predicted to destabilize ALG8. For the seventh variant, immunostaining of the liver tissue showed a complete loss of ALG8 in the cystic cells. ALG8-associated ADPLD has a broad clinical spectrum, including the possibility of developing a small number of renal cysts. This broadens the ADPLD genotype-phenotype spectrum and narrows the gap between liver-specific ADPLD and kidney-specific ADPKD.

Treatment of Polycystic Liver Disease: Impact on Patient-reported Symptom Severity and Health-related Quality of Life

Polycystic liver disease (PLD) is a genetic disorder in which patients suffer from progressive development of multiple (>10) hepatic cysts. Most patients remain asymptomatic during the course of their disease. However, a minority of PLD patients suffer from symptoms caused by hepatomegaly leading to serious limitations in daily life. Untreated symptomatic PLD patients score significantly worse on health-related quality of life (HRQoL) compared to age and gender-matched populations. Currently, liver transplantation is the only curative treatment for PLD. The main goal of other available therapies is to strive for symptomatic relief and improvement of HRQoL by suppressing disease progression. In this review, we summarize the effect of PLD treatment on patient-reported outcome measures with a distinction between HRQoL and symptom severity. At present there is heterogeneity in application of questionnaires and no questionnaire is available that measures both HRQoL and PLD symptom severity. Therefore, we recommend the combination of a validated PLD-specific symptom severity questionnaire and a general HRQoL questionnaire to evaluate treatment success as a minimal core set. However, the specific choice of questionnaires depends on treatment choice and/or research question. These questionnaires may serve as a biomarker of treatment response, failure, and adverse events.

Genetics, pathobiology and therapeutic opportunities of polycystic liver disease

Polycystic liver diseases (PLDs) are inherited genetic disorders characterized by progressive development of intrahepatic, fluid-filled biliary cysts (more than ten), which constitute the main cause of morbidity and markedly affect the quality of life. Liver cysts arise in patients with autosomal dominant PLD (ADPLD) or in co-occurrence with renal cysts in patients with autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD and ARPKD, respectively). Hepatic cystogenesis is a heterogeneous process, with several risk factors increasing the odds of developing larger cysts. Depending on the causative gene, PLDs can arise exclusively in the liver or in parallel with renal cysts. Current therapeutic strategies, mainly based on surgical procedures and/or chronic administration of somatostatin analogues, show modest benefits, with liver transplantation as the only potentially curative option. Increasing research has shed light on the genetic landscape of PLDs and consequent cholangiocyte abnormalities, which can pave the way for discovering new targets for therapy and the design of novel potential treatments for patients. Herein, we provide a critical and comprehensive overview of the latest advances in the field of PLDs, mainly focusing on genetics, pathobiology, risk factors and next-generation therapeutic strategies, highlighting future directions in basic, translational and clinical research.

Targeting NAE1-mediated protein hyper-NEDDylation halts cholangiocarcinogenesis and impacts on tumor-stroma crosstalk in experimental models

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Cholangiocarcinoma (CCA) comprises a heterogeneous group of malignant tumors associated with dismal prognosis. Alterations in post-translational modifications (PTMs), including NEDDylation, result in abnormal protein dynamics, cell disturbances and disease. Herein, we investigate the role of NEDDylation in CCA development and progression.

METHODS

Levels and functions of NEDDylation, together with response to pevonedistat (NEDDylation inhibitor) or CRISPR/Cas9 against NAE1 were evaluated in vitro, in vivo and/or in patients with CCA. The development of preneoplastic lesions in Nae1^+/- mice was investigated using an oncogene-driven CCA model. The impact of NEDDylation in CCA cells on tumor-stroma crosstalk was assessed using CCA-derived cancer-associated fibroblasts (CAFs). Proteomic analyses were carried out by mass-spectrometry.

RESULTS

The NEDDylation machinery was found overexpressed and overactivated in human CCA cells and tumors. Most NEDDylated proteins found upregulated in CCA cells, after NEDD8-immunoprecipitation and further proteomics, participate in the cell cycle, proliferation or survival. Genetic (CRISPR/Cas9-NAE1) and pharmacological (pevonedistat) inhibition of NEDDylation reduced CCA cell proliferation and impeded colony formation in vitro. NEDDylation depletion (pevonedistat or Nae1^+/- mice) halted tumorigenesis in subcutaneous, orthotopic, and oncogene-driven models of CCA in vivo. Moreover, pevonedistat potentiated chemotherapy-induced cell death in CCA cells in vitro. Mechanistically, impaired NEDDylation triggered the accumulation of both cullin RING ligase and NEDD8 substrates, inducing DNA damage and cell cycle arrest. Furthermore, impaired NEDDylation in CCA cells reduced the secretion of proteins involved in fibroblast activation, angiogenesis, and oncogenic pathways, ultimately hampering CAF proliferation and migration.

CONCLUSION

Aberrant protein NEDDylation contributes to cholangiocarcinogenesis by promoting cell survival and proliferation. Moreover, NEDDylation impacts the CCA-stroma crosstalk. Inhibition of NEDDylation with pevonedistat may represent a potential therapeutic strategy for patients with CCA.

LAY SUMMARY

Little is known about the role of post-translational modifications of proteins in cholangiocarcinoma development and progression. Herein, we show that protein NEDDylation is upregulated and hyperactivated in cholangiocarcinoma, promoting tumor growth. Pharmacological inhibition of NEDDylation halts cholangiocarcinogenesis and could be an effective therapeutic strategy to tackle these tumors.