Diagnostic accuracy of midtrimester antenatal ultrasound for multicystic dysplastic kidneys

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract: antenatal diagnosis, management and counselling of families

Congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract are collectively one of the most commonly diagnosed antenatal conditions. Clinicians have several tools available to diagnose anomalies, including imaging, biomarkers, family history and genetic studies. In certain cases, antenatal interventions such as vesico-amniotic shunting may be considered to improve postnatal outcomes.Congenital kidney anomalies detected antenatally can vary in clinical significance from almost no impact postnatally to significant morbidity and perinatal mortality. Prognosis broadly depends on kidney size, structure and amount of amniotic fluid, alongside genetics and family history, and progression on subsequent scans. It is important to counsel parents appropriately using a parent-focused and personalised approach. The use of a multidisciplinary team should always be considered.

Multicystic Dysplastic Kidney Disease: An In-Utero Diagnosis

Multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) is a congenital cystic kidney disease that can be incidentally seen during the antenatal ultrasound. The condition is most commonly asymptomatic. The clinical presentation is usually characterized by multiple small cysts or a single dominating cyst in the fetal kidney depending on the type of MCDK. Most cases undergo spontaneous involution, and complications like hypertension, infection, and malignancy are rare. We present the case of a young Primigravida who was diagnosed to have a fetus with unilateral MCDK in the second trimester and further followed up later in pregnancy as well as four months postnatally. The pregnancy was unremarkable, but for the diagnosis of MCDK in the second trimester; the infant was doing well at the four-month follow-up. Pre-natal ultrasound and MRI are able to diagnose MCDK reliably. Conservative management and follow-up is currently the most common protocol used to manage MCDK.

Antenatal imaging: A pictorial review

Today, in parallel with the use of imaging modalities increases in all fields, the use of imaging methods in pregnant women is increasing. Imaging has become an integral component of routine pregnancy follow-up. Imaging provides parents with an early opportunity to learn about the current situation, including prenatal detection of anomalies or diseases, etiology, prognosis, and the availability of prenatal or postnatal treatments. Various imaging modalities, especially ultrasonography, are frequently used for imaging both maternal and fetal imaging. The goal of this review was to address imaging modalities in terms of usefulness and safety, as well as to provide demonstrative examples for disorders. And this review provides current information on selecting a safe imaging modality to evaluate the pregnant and the fetus, the safety of contrast medium use, and summarizes major pathological situations with demonstrative sonographic images to assist radiologists and obstetricians in everyday practice.

Cystic Kidney Diseases That Require a Differential Diagnosis from Autosomal Dominant Polycystic Kidney Disease (ADPKD)

Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) is the most common hereditary cystic kidney disease, with patients often having a positive family history that is characterized by a similar phenotype. However, in atypical cases, particularly those in which family history is unclear, a differential diagnosis between ADPKD and other cystic kidney diseases is important. When diagnosing ADPKD, cystic kidney diseases that can easily be excluded using clinical information include: multiple simple renal cysts, acquired cystic kidney disease (ACKD), multilocular renal cyst/multilocular cystic nephroma/polycystic nephroma, multicystic kidney/multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK), and unilateral renal cystic disease (URCD). However, there are other cystic kidney diseases that usually require genetic testing, or another means of supplementing clinical information to enable a differential diagnosis of ADPKD. These include autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease (ARPKD), autosomal dominant tubulointerstitial kidney disease (ADTKD), nephronophthisis (NPH), oral-facial-digital (OFD) syndrome type 1, and neoplastic cystic kidney disease, such as tuberous sclerosis (TSC) and Von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) syndrome. To help physicians evaluate cystic kidney diseases, this article provides a review of cystic kidney diseases for which a differential diagnosis is required for ADPKD.

Sonographic Detection of Multicystic Dysplastic Kidneys

Multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) is a common nonhereditary cystic dysplasia that can be detected antenatally. This disorder commonly manifests in utero and presents unilaterally; however, this patient’s case demonstrates bilateral MCDKs. The use of sonography is essential in diagnosing this disorder both antenatally and following birth. Bilateral MCDKs present as large anechoic cysts overtaking renal parenchyma and halting all normal renal physiologic functions. This case study demonstrates the importance of early detection, the progression of this disorder, as well as the large part sonographic imaging plays in visualizing the MCDK.

Multicystic Dysplastic Kidney: Prenatal Compensatory Renal Growth Pattern

OBJECTIVES

To assess the prenatal growth pattern of the normal kidney contralateral to a multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK).

METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted in a single referral center over 4 years. Cases diagnosed prenatally as MCDK and confirmed postnatally constituted the study group. For creation of nomograms, only isolated cases of MCDK were included.

RESULTS

Sixty-one fetuses had a diagnosis of an MCDK during the study period. After exclusion of cases with associated malformations, 47 fetuses remained, providing 94 measurements for creation of nomograms. The growth pattern of the normal kidney contralateral to an MCDK was linear throughout gestation (percentile = 20.01 + 1.5 gestational age; linear R²  = 0.753; r = 0.868) and was significantly higher during the third trimester (29-38 weeks' gestation) compared to the second trimester (22-28 weeks' gestation; P < .001). A comparison of the growth pattern of the normal kidney contralateral to the MCDK to the growth pattern of a solitary kidney revealed a significant higher compensatory trend during the third trimester (P < .0001). The mean kidney lengths at 22 and 38 weeks' gestation correlated with the 52nd and 88th and with the 84th and 90th percentiles for the normal kidney contralateral to the MCDK and a solitary kidney, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

According to our study, the normal kidney contralateral to an MCDK has a unique growth pattern during intrauterine life, with dominant growth during the third trimester. The exact mechanism for this pattern, in comparison to early renal hypertrophy shown in solitary kidneys, is currently not clear. These data provide relevant information for the multidisciplinary prenatal counseling of future parents regarding the future renal outcome.

Postnatal outcome of prenatally-detected "simple" renal cysts: Are they really simple?

BACKGROUND

The majority of simple renal cysts diagnosed postnatally are asymptomatic and rarely require treatment unless they become symptomatic or complex. We hypothesised that prenatally-detected simple renal cysts would have a similar harmless outcome.

AIMS

To establish the natural history and postnatal outcome of prenatally-diagnosed simple renal cysts.

STUDY DESIGN

Single-centre retrospective case-series review (12-year period).

SUBJECTS

All patients with prenatally-diagnosed simple renal cysts (defined as a solitary, non-septated, non-communicating cyst in an otherwise normal kidney).

OUTCOME MEASURES

Prenatal and postnatal changes to cyst size, persistence, resolution or modification of diagnosis. Data is presented as the proportion of patients or median (range).

RESULTS

30 cysts were detected (2 bilateral, 26 unilateral) in 28 fetuses (median gestational age of 23 [20-36] weeks). Median maximum diameter was 15 (4-35) mm at initial diagnosis and 17.5 (4-100) mm across all prenatal scans. On follow-up scans diagnosis was modified in 16 (53%) to: multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK), dilated duplex kidney, hydronephrosis, urinoma, renal agenesis and adrenal mass. 12 (40%) cysts resolved. 2 (7%) asymptomatic cysts persisted at one year postnatally. Cyst maximum diameter in the modified diagnosis group (21.5 [10-100] mm) was significantly larger than the simple cyst group (12 [4-20] mm) (P = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Our study revealed the challenges of prenatal ultrasound imaging, with modified diagnoses in over half the cases. Kidneys with solitary cysts could evolve into multicystic kidneys or involute completely, which suggests a true alteration in morphology rather than sonographic error. Persistent simple cysts in an otherwise normal kidney, however, resolved spontaneously or remained asymptomatic. Prenatally-detected simple cysts should be monitored with serial imaging.

Prenatal diagnosis and outcome of unilateral multicystic kidney

We reviewed the records of 144 patients. The mean gestational age at first US diagnosis was 27.5 ± 4.3 weeks. An anomaly of the contralateral kidney was detected in 25% of cases. An extrarenal anomaly was detected in 13.8%. Karyotype analysis was performed in 16.6% of cases and revealed trisomy 18 in 2 cases with extrarenal defects. Karyotype analysis was normal in all the patients who had isolated multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK). The diagnostic accuracy of prenatal ultrasound was 92.2%. Contralateral kidney anomaly was detected 33.9% of patients, and half of these were vesicoureteral reflux. Antihypertensive therapy was required in 2.6% of cases. Nephrectomy was performed in 8%, and partial or total involution of MCDK was achieved in 33.9% of patients. MCDK can be accurately diagnosed by prenatal sonography, and prognosis depends on extrarenal and contralateral renal abnormalities. In isolated cases, require of surgery is rare, and serial follow-up is suggested to determine involution.Impact statementWhat is already known on this subject? Multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) is one of the most renal anomalies and is associated with numerous renal and extrarenal abnormalities. It can lead to severe consequences in the neonatal period.What do the results of this study add? The accuracy of prenatal ultrasonography is excellent for detecting MCDK. In isolated unilateral cases, chromosomal aberrations are low, and the majority of them involute spontaneously. A periodic follow-up of the contralateral kidney is mandatory due to an increased risk of an anomaly. Genital anomaly risk is increased in males.What are the implications of these findings for clinical practice and/or further research? Detailed evaluation and follow-up of the contralateral kidney are crucial for counselling in isolated cases. Karyotype analysis in isolated unilateral MCDK is debateable. Postnatal prognosis is encountering, and the majority of patients have no requirement of surgery.

Multicystic dysplastic kidney - treat each case on its merits

OBJECTIVES

To assess outcomes of unilateral multicystic dysplastic kidney (MCDK) managed at an Australasian centre over a 15 year period. To assess if MCDK involution could be predicted based on change noted between first two postnatal ultrasound scans 6 months apart.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

A retrospective study was performed.

RESULTS

One-hundred-and-six cases of unilateral MCDK were studied. Eighty-four of these presented antenatally. Twenty-two MCDK cases presented postnatally. Urological anomalies associated with MCDK included vesicoureteric reflux (VUR), ureterocele and contralateral pelviureteric junction obstruction (PUJO). Children undergoing surgical intervention for these anomalies were offered concurrent MCDK nephrectomy. Morbidity associated with MCDK under surveillance included febrile culture-positive urinary tract infection in 20 cases (20.7%), hypertension in four (3.7%) and Wilms' tumor in one (0.9%). Thirty-six cases (34%) underwent complete involution, 32 (30.2%) were in the process of involuting and 38 cases (35.8%) underwent nephrectomy because of failure of involution or associated morbidity. If the MCDK reduced in cranio-caudal interpolar length by 20% or more between the first postnatal USS and the next one 6 months later, then it was very likely to involute spontaneously. If the MCDK did not reduce in cranio-caudal interpolar length by 20% between the first postnatal scan and the next one 6 months later, then it was highly likely to fail to involute, and in our study, correlated with the outcome of nephrectomy.

CONCLUSION

Although MCDK is a benign condition, it should be carefully investigated and followed-up, as involution may not occur in over a third. In some cases, morbidity may occur. Each case of MCDK should be managed on its own merits.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II - Prognosis study, Retrospective.

[Kidney Cysts and Cystic Nephropathies in Children - A Consensus Guideline by 10 German Medical Societies]

This consensus-based guideline was developed by all relevant German pediatric medical societies. Ultrasound is the standard imaging modality for pre- and postnatal kidney cysts and should also exclude extrarenal manifestations in the abdomen and internal genital organs. MRI has selected indications. Suspicion of a cystic kidney disease should prompt consultation of a pediatric nephrologist. Prenatal management must be tailored to very different degrees of disease severity. After renal oligohydramnios, we recommend delivery in a perinatal center. Neonates should not be denied renal replacement therapy solely because of their age. Children with unilateral multicystic dysplastic kidney do not require routine further imaging or nephrectomy, but long-term nephrology follow-up (as do children with uni- or bilateral kidney hypo-/dysplasia with cysts). ARPKD (autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease), nephronophthisis, Bardet-Biedl syndrome and HNF1B mutations cause relevant extrarenal disease and genetic testing is advisable. Children with tuberous sclerosis complex, tumor predisposition (e. g. von Hippel Lindau syndrome) or high risk of acquired kidney cysts should have regular ultrasounds. Even asymptomatic children of parents with ADPKD (autosomal dominant PKD) should be monitored for hypertension and proteinuria. Presymptomatic diagnostic ultrasound or genetic examination for ADPKD in minors should only be done after thorough counselling. Simple cysts are very rare in children and ADPKD in a parent should be excluded. Complex renal cysts require further investigation.

Is an analysis of copy number variants necessary for various types of kidney ultrasound anomalies in fetuses?

Background

This study aimed to estimate the associations of copy number variants (CNVs) with fetal kidney ultrasound anomalies. A total of 331 fetuses with kidney ultrasound anomalies who underwent prenatal chromosomal microarray analyses were enrolled. The fetuses were classified into groups with isolated and nonisolated anomalies or according to the types of kidney anomalies.

Results

Clinically significant CNVs were identified in 3.4% or 7.3% of fetuses with isolated or nonisolated kidney anomalies, respectively. CNVs were more frequently identified in fetuses with abnormal embryonic migration of the kidneys (6.6%) than in fetuses with malformations of the renal parenchyma (4.7%) or anomalies of the urinary collecting system (3.4%). In particular, CNVs were most frequently detected in fetuses with ectopic kidneys (9.5%) but not in fetuses with horseshoe kidneys or isolated duplex kidneys. Among these CNVs, the most common were del(17)(q12q12) (1.2%) and del(22)(q11q11) (0.6%). The dup(17)(p12p12) and del(15)(q11.2q11.2) CNVs were identified in this study but not in previous studies. The del(X)(p11.4p11.4) and del(16)(p13.3p13.3) CNVs were further implicated as associated with kidney anomalies.

Conclusions

Fetuses with abnormal embryonic migration of the kidneys (particularly ectopic kidneys) showed a higher frequency of clinically significant CNVs, whereas fetuses with horseshoe kidneys or duplex kidneys were less frequently associated with these CNVs.