Physics-based all-atom modeling of RNA energetics and structure

Na+-Mg2+ ion effects on conformation and translocation dynamics of single-stranded RNA: Cooperation and competition

The nanopore-based translocation of a single-stranded RNA (ssRNA) in mixed salt solution has garnered increasing interest for its biological and technological significance. However, it is challenging to comprehensively understand the effects of the mixed ion species on the translocation dynamics due to their cooperation and competition, which can be directly reflected by the ion screening and neutralizing effects, respectively. In this study, Langevin dynamics simulation is employed to investigate the properties of ssRNA conformation and translocation in mixed Na+-Mg2+ ion environments. Simulation results reveal that the ion screening effect dominates the change in the ssRNA conformational size, the ion neutralizing effect controls the capture rate of the ssRNA by the nanopore, and both of them take charge of the different changes in translocation time of the ssRNA under various mixed ion environments. Under high Na+ ion concentration, as Mg2+ concentration increases, the ion neutralizing effect strengthens, weakening the driving force inside the nanopore, leading to longer translocation time. Conversely, at low Na+ concentration, an increase in Mg2+ concentration enhances the ion screening effect, aiding in faster translocation. Furthermore, these simulation results will be explained by quantitative analysis, advancing a deeper understanding of the complicated effects of the mixed Na+-Mg2+ ions.

Simple Adjustment of Intranucleotide Base-Phosphate Interaction in the OL3 AMBER Force Field Improves RNA Simulations

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations represent an established tool to study RNA molecules. The outcome of MD studies depends, however, on the quality of the force field (ff). Here we suggest a correction for the widely used AMBER OL3 ff by adding a simple adjustment of the nonbonded parameters. The reparameterization of the Lennard-Jones potential for the -H8···O5'- and -H6···O5'- atom pairs addresses an intranucleotide steric clash occurring in the type 0 base-phosphate interaction (0BPh). The nonbonded fix (NBfix) modification of 0BPh interactions (NBfix0BPh modification) was tuned via a reweighting approach and subsequently tested using an extensive set of standard and enhanced sampling simulations of both unstructured and folded RNA motifs. The modification corrects minor but visible intranucleotide clash for the anti nucleobase conformation. We observed that structural ensembles of small RNA benchmark motifs simulated with the NBfix0BPh modification provide better agreement with experiments. No side effects of the modification were observed in standard simulations of larger structured RNA motifs. We suggest that the combination of OL3 RNA ff and NBfix0BPh modification is a viable option to improve RNA MD simulations.

Toward Convergence in Folding Simulations of RNA Tetraloops: Comparison of Enhanced Sampling Techniques and Effects of Force Field Modifications

Atomistic molecular dynamics simulations represent an established technique for investigation of RNA structural dynamics. Despite continuous development, contemporary RNA simulations still suffer from suboptimal accuracy of empirical potentials (force fields, ffs) and sampling limitations. Development of efficient enhanced sampling techniques is important for two reasons. First, they allow us to overcome the sampling limitations, and second, they can be used to quantify ff imbalances provided they reach a sufficient convergence. Here, we study two RNA tetraloops (TLs), namely the GAGA and UUCG motifs. We perform extensive folding simulations and calculate folding free energies (ΔG_fold^°) with the aim to compare different enhanced sampling techniques and to test several modifications of the nonbonded terms extending the AMBER OL3 RNA ff. We demonstrate that replica-exchange solute tempering (REST2) simulations with 12-16 replicas do not show any sign of convergence even when extended to a timescale of 120 μs per replica. However, the combination of REST2 with well-tempered metadynamics (ST-MetaD) achieves good convergence on a timescale of 5-10 μs per replica, improving the sampling efficiency by at least 2 orders of magnitude. Effects of ff modifications on ΔG_fold^° energies were initially explored by the reweighting approach and then validated by new simulations. We tested several manually prepared variants of the gHBfix potential which improve stability of the native state of both TLs by ∼2 kcal/mol. This is sufficient to conveniently stabilize the folded GAGA TL while the UUCG TL still remains under-stabilized. Appropriate adjustment of van der Waals parameters for C-H···O5' base-phosphate interaction may further stabilize the native states of both TLs by ∼0.6 kcal/mol.

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectra and AMBER OL3 and ROC-RNA Simulations of UCUCGU Reveal Force Field Strengths and Weaknesses for Single-Stranded RNA

Single-stranded regions of RNA are important for folding of sequences into 3D structures and for design of therapeutics targeting RNA. Prediction of ensembles of 3D structures for single-stranded regions often involves classical mechanical approximations of interactions defined by quantum mechanical calculations on small model systems. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of short single strands provide tests for how well the approximations model many of the interactions. Here, the NMR spectra for UCUCGU at 2, 15, and 30 °C are compared to simulations with the AMBER force fields, OL3 and ROC-RNA. This is the first such comparison to an oligoribonucleotide containing an internal guanosine nucleotide (G). G is particularly interesting because of its many H-bonding groups, large dipole moment, and proclivity for both syn and anti conformations. Results reveal formation of a G amino to phosphate non-bridging oxygen H-bond. The results also demonstrate dramatic differences in details of the predicted structures. The variations emphasize the dependence of predictions on individual parameters and their balance with the rest of the force field. The NMR data can serve as a benchmark for future force fields.

Supramolecular Cylinders Target Bulge Structures in the 5' UTR of the RNA Genome of SARS-CoV-2 and Inhibit Viral Replication

The untranslated regions (UTRs) of viral genomes contain a variety of conserved yet dynamic structures crucial for viral replication, providing drug targets for the development of broad spectrum anti-virals. We combine in vitro RNA analysis with molecular dynamics simulations to build the first 3D models of the structure and dynamics of key regions of the 5' UTR of the SARS-CoV-2 genome. Furthermore, we determine the binding of metallo-supramolecular helicates (cylinders) to this RNA structure. These nano-size agents are uniquely able to thread through RNA junctions and we identify their binding to a 3-base bulge and the central cross 4-way junction located in stem loop 5. Finally, we show these RNA-binding cylinders suppress SARS-CoV-2 replication, highlighting their potential as novel anti-viral agents.

Supramolecular Cylinders Target Bulge Structures in the 5' UTR of the RNA Genome of SARS-CoV-2 and Inhibit Viral Replication*

The untranslated regions (UTRs) of viral genomes contain a variety of conserved yet dynamic structures crucial for viral replication, providing drug targets for the development of broad spectrum anti-virals. We combine in vitro RNA analysis with molecular dynamics simulations to build the first 3D models of the structure and dynamics of key regions of the 5' UTR of the SARS-CoV-2 genome. Furthermore, we determine the binding of metallo-supramolecular helicates (cylinders) to this RNA structure. These nano-size agents are uniquely able to thread through RNA junctions and we identify their binding to a 3-base bulge and the central cross 4-way junction located in stem loop 5. Finally, we show these RNA-binding cylinders suppress SARS-CoV-2 replication, highlighting their potential as novel anti-viral agents.

Sequence dependent phase separation of protein-polynucleotide mixtures elucidated using molecular simulations

Ribonucleoprotein (RNP) granules are membraneless organelles (MLOs), which majorly consist of RNA and RNA-binding proteins and are formed via liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS). Experimental studies investigating the drivers of LLPS have shown that intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and nucleic acids like RNA and other polynucleotides play a key role in modulating protein phase separation. There is currently a dearth of modelling techniques which allow one to delve deeper into how polynucleotides play the role of a modulator/promoter of LLPS in cells using computational methods. Here, we present a coarse-grained polynucleotide model developed to fill this gap, which together with our recently developed HPS model for protein LLPS, allows us to capture the factors driving protein-polynucleotide phase separation. We explore the capabilities of the modelling framework with the LAF-1 RGG system which has been well studied in experiments and also with the HPS model previously. Further taking advantage of the fact that the HPS model maintains sequence specificity we explore the role of charge patterning on controlling polynucleotide incorporation into condensates. With increased charge patterning we observe formation of structured or patterned condensates which suggests the possible roles of polynucleotides in not only shifting the phase boundaries but also introducing microscopic organization in MLOs.

Fine-Tuning of the AMBER RNA Force Field with a New Term Adjusting Interactions of Terminal Nucleotides

Determination of RNA structural-dynamic properties is challenging for experimental methods. Thus, atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations represent a helpful technique complementary to experiments. However, contemporary MD methods still suffer from limitations of force fields (ffs), including imbalances in the nonbonded ff terms. We have recently demonstrated that some improvement of state-of-the-art AMBER RNA ff can be achieved by adding a new term for H-bonding called gHBfix, which increases tuning flexibility and reduces risk of side-effects. Still, the first gHBfix version did not fully correct simulations of short RNA tetranucleotides (TNs). TNs are key benchmark systems due to availability of unique NMR data, although giving too much weight on improving TN simulations can easily lead to overfitting to A-form RNA. Here we combine the gHBfix version with another term called tHBfix, which separately treats H-bond interactions formed by terminal nucleotides. This allows to refine simulations of RNA TNs without affecting simulations of other RNAs. The approach is in line with adopted strategy of current RNA ffs, where the terminal nucleotides possess different parameters for terminal atoms than the internal nucleotides. Combination of gHBfix with tHBfix significantly improves the behavior of RNA TNs during well-converged enhanced-sampling simulations using replica exchange with solute tempering. TNs mostly populate canonical A-form like states while spurious intercalated structures are largely suppressed. Still, simulations of r(AAAA) and r(UUUU) TNs show some residual discrepancies with primary NMR data which suggests that future tuning of some other ff terms might be useful. Nevertheless, the tHBfix has a clear potential to improve modeling of key biochemical processes, where interactions of RNA single stranded ends are involved.

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance of Single-Stranded RNAs and DNAs of CAAU and UCAAUC as Benchmarks for Molecular Dynamics Simulations

RNA and DNA are rapidly emerging as targets for therapeutics and as potential frameworks for nanotechnology. Accurate methods for predicting and designing structures and dynamics of nucleic acids would accelerate progress in these and other applications. Suitable approximations for modeling nucleic acids are being developed but require validation against disparate experimental observations. Here, nuclear magnetic resonance spectra for RNA and DNA single strands, CAAU and UCAAUC, are used as benchmarks to test molecular dynamics simulations with AMBER force fields OL3 and ROC-RNA for RNA and BSC1 for DNA. A detailed scheme for making comparisons is also presented. The results reflect recent progress in approximations and reveal remaining challenges.

In silico survey of the central conserved regions in viroids of the Pospiviroidae family for conserved asymmetric loop structures

Viroids are the smallest replicative pathogens, consisting of RNA circles (∼300 nucleotides) that require host machinery to replicate. Structural RNA elements recruit these host factors. Currently, many of these structural elements and the nature of their interactions are unknown. All Pospiviroidae have homology in the central conserved region (CCR). The CCR of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) contains a sarcin/ricin domain (SRD), the only viroid structural element with an unequivocal replication role. We assumed that every member of this family uses this region to recruit host factors, and that each CCR has an SRD-like asymmetric loop within it. Potential SRD or SRD-like motifs were sought in the CCR of each Pospiviroidae member as follows. Motif location in each CCR was predicted with MUSCLE alignment and Vienna RNAfold. Viroid-specific models of SRD-like motifs were built by superimposing noncanonical base pairs and nucleotides on a model of an SRD. The RNA geometry search engine FR3D was then used to find nucleotide groups close to the geometry suggested by this superimposition. Atomic resolution structures were assembled using the molecular visualization program Chimera, and the stability of each motif was assessed with molecular dynamics (MD). Some models required a protonated cytosine. To be stable within a cell, the pK_a of that cytosine must be shifted up. Constant pH-replica exchange MD analysis showed such a shift in the proposed structures. These data show that every Pospiviroidae member could form a motif that resembles an SRD in its CCR, and imply there could be undiscovered mimics of other RNA domains.

Improving the Performance of the Amber RNA Force Field by Tuning the Hydrogen-Bonding Interactions

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations became a leading tool for investigation of structural dynamics of nucleic acids. Despite recent efforts to improve the empirical potentials (force fields, ffs), RNA ffs have persisting deficiencies, which hamper their utilization in quantitatively accurate simulations. Previous studies have shown that at least two salient problems contribute to difficulties in the description of free-energy landscapes of small RNA motifs: (i) excessive stabilization of the unfolded single-stranded RNA ensemble by intramolecular base-phosphate and sugar-phosphate interactions and (ii) destabilization of the native folded state by underestimation of stability of base pairing. Here, we introduce a general ff term (gHBfix) that can selectively fine-tune nonbonding interaction terms in RNA ffs, in particular, the H bonds. The gHBfix potential affects the pairwise interactions between all possible pairs of the specific atom types, while all other interactions remain intact; i.e., it is not a structure-based model. In order to probe the ability of the gHBfix potential to refine the ff nonbonded terms, we performed an extensive set of folding simulations of RNA tetranucleotides and tetraloops. On the basis of these data, we propose particular gHBfix parameters to modify the AMBER RNA ff. The suggested parametrization significantly improves the agreement between experimental data and the simulation conformational ensembles, although our current ff version still remains far from being flawless. While attempts to tune the RNA ffs by conventional reparametrizations of dihedral potentials or nonbonded terms can lead to major undesired side effects, as we demonstrate for some recently published ffs, gHBfix has a clear promising potential to improve the ff performance while avoiding introduction of major new imbalances.

A two-dimensional replica-exchange molecular dynamics method for simulating RNA folding using sparse experimental restraints

We present a 2D replica exchange protocol incorporating secondary structure information to dramatically improve 3D RNA folding using molecular dynamics simulations. We show that incorporating base-pairing restraints into all-atom, explicit solvent simulations enables the accurate recapitulation of the global tertiary fold for 4 representative RNAs ranging in length from 24 to 68 nt. This method can potentially utilize base-pairing information from a wide variety of experimental inputs to predict complex RNA tertiary folds including pseudoknots, multi-loop junctions, and non-canonical interactions.

Accurate geometrical restraints for Watson-Crick base pairs

Geometrical restraints provide key structural information for the determination of biomolecular structures at lower resolution by experimental methods such as crystallography or cryo-electron microscopy. In this work, restraint targets for nucleic acids bases are derived from three different sources and compared: small-molecule crystal structures in the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD), ultrahigh-resolution structures in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) and quantum-mechanical (QM) calculations. The best parameters are those based on CSD structures. After over two decades, the standard library of Parkinson et al. [(1996), Acta Cryst. D52, 57-64] is still valid, but improvements are possible with the use of the current CSD database. The CSD-derived geometry is fully compatible with Watson-Crick base pairs, as comparisons with QM results for isolated and paired bases clearly show that the CSD targets closely correspond to proper base pairing. While the QM results are capable of distinguishing between single and paired bases, their level of accuracy is, on average, nearly two times lower than for the CSD-derived targets when gauged by root-mean-square deviations from ultrahigh-resolution structures in the PDB. Nevertheless, the accuracy of QM results appears sufficient to provide stereochemical targets for synthetic base pairs where no reliable experimental structural information is available. To enable future tests for this approach, QM calculations are provided for isocytosine, isoguanine and the iCiG base pair.

Computational modeling of RNA 3D structure based on experimental data

RNA molecules are master regulators of cells. They are involved in a variety of molecular processes: they transmit genetic information, sense cellular signals and communicate responses, and even catalyze chemical reactions. As in the case of proteins, RNA function is dictated by its structure and by its ability to adopt different conformations, which in turn is encoded in the sequence. Experimental determination of high-resolution RNA structures is both laborious and difficult, and therefore the majority of known RNAs remain structurally uncharacterized. To address this problem, predictive computational methods were developed based on the accumulated knowledge of RNA structures determined so far, the physical basis of the RNA folding, and taking into account evolutionary considerations, such as conservation of functionally important motifs. However, all theoretical methods suffer from various limitations, and they are generally unable to accurately predict structures for RNA sequences longer than 100-nt residues unless aided by additional experimental data. In this article, we review experimental methods that can generate data usable by computational methods, as well as computational approaches for RNA structure prediction that can utilize data from experimental analyses. We outline methods and data types that can be potentially useful for RNA 3D structure modeling but are not commonly used by the existing software, suggesting directions for future development.

Polarizable force field for RNA based on the classical drude oscillator

RNA molecules are highly dynamic and capable of adopting a wide range of complex, folded structures. The factors driving the folding and dynamics of these structures are dependent on a balance of base pairing, hydration, base stacking, ion interactions, and the conformational sampling of the 2'-hydroxyl group in the ribose sugar. The representation of these features is a challenge for empirical force fields used in molecular dynamics simulations. Toward meeting this challenge, the inclusion of explicit electronic polarization is important in accurately modeling RNA structure. In this work, we present a polarizable force field for RNA based on the classical Drude oscillator model, which represents electronic degrees of freedom via negatively charged particles attached to their parent atoms by harmonic springs. Beginning with parametrization against quantum mechanical base stacking interaction energy and conformational energy data, we have extended the Drude-2017 nucleic acid force field to include RNA. The conformational sampling of a range of RNA sequences were used to validate the force field, including canonical A-form RNA duplexes, stem-loops, and complex tertiary folds that bind multiple Mg2+ ions. Overall, the Drude-2017 RNA force field reproduces important properties of these structures, including the conformational sampling of the 2'-hydroxyl and key interactions with Mg2+ ions. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Chemically Accurate Relative Folding Stability of RNA Hairpins from Molecular Simulations

To benchmark RNA force fields, we compared the folding stabilities of three 12-nucleotide hairpin stem loops estimated by simulation to stabilities determined by experiment. We used umbrella sampling and a reaction coordinate of end-to-end (5' to 3' hydroxyl oxygen) distance to estimate the free energy change of the transition from the native conformation to a fully extended conformation with no hydrogen bonds between non-neighboring bases. Each simulation was performed four times using the AMBER FF99+bsc0+χ_OL3 force field, and each window, spaced at 1 Å intervals, was sampled for 1 μs, for a total of 552 μs of simulation. We compared differences in the simulated free energy changes to analogous differences in free energies from optical melting experiments using thermodynamic cycles where the free energy change between stretched and random coil sequences is assumed to be sequence-independent. The differences between experimental and simulated ΔΔ G° are, on average, 0.98 ± 0.66 kcal/mol, which is chemically accurate and suggests that analogous simulations could be used predictively. We also report a novel method to identify where replica free energies diverge along a reaction coordinate, thus indicating where additional sampling would most improve convergence. We conclude by discussing methods to more economically perform these simulations.

RNA modifications in structure prediction - Status quo and future challenges

Chemical modifications of RNA nucleotides change their identity and characteristics and thus alter genetic and structural information encoded in the genomic DNA. tRNA and rRNA are probably the most heavily modified genes, and often depend on derivatization or isomerization of their nucleobases in order to correctly fold into their functional structures. Recent RNomics studies, however, report transcriptome wide RNA modification and suggest a more general regulation of structuredness of RNAs by this so called epitranscriptome. Modification seems to require specific substrate structures, which in turn are stabilized or destabilized and thus promote or inhibit refolding events of regulatory RNA structures. In this review, we revisit RNA modifications and the related structures from a computational point of view. We discuss known substrate structures, their properties such as sub-motifs as well as consequences of modifications on base pairing patterns and possible refolding events. Given that efficient RNA structure prediction methods for canonical base pairs have been established several decades ago, we review to what extend these methods allow the inclusion of modified nucleotides to model and study epitranscriptomic effects on RNA structures.

Molecular dynamics correctly models the unusual major conformation of the GAGU RNA internal loop and with NMR reveals an unusual minor conformation

The RNA "GAGU" duplex, (5'GACGAGUGUCA)2, contains the internal loop (5'-GAGU-3')2 , which has two conformations in solution as determined by NMR spectroscopy. The major conformation has a loop structure consisting of trans-Watson-Crick/Hoogsteen GG pairs, A residues stacked on each other, U residues bulged outside the helix, and all sugars with a C2'-endo conformation. This differs markedly from the internal loops, (5'-GAGC-3')2, (5'-AAGU-3')2, and (5'-UAGG-3')2, which all have cis-Watson-Crick/Watson-Crick AG "imino" pairs flanked by cis-Watson-Crick/Watson-Crick canonical pairs resulting in maximal hydrogen bonding. Here, molecular dynamics was used to test whether the Amber force field (ff99 + bsc0 + OL3) approximates molecular interactions well enough to keep stable the unexpected conformation of the GAGU major duplex structure and the NMR structures of the duplexes containing (5'-GAGC-3')2, (5'-AAGU-3')2, and (5'-UAGG-3')2 internal loops. One-microsecond simulations were repeated four times for each of the duplexes starting in their NMR conformations. With the exception of (5'-UAGG-3')2, equivalent simulations were also run starting with alternative conformations. Results indicate that the Amber force field keeps the NMR conformations of the duplexes stable for at least 1 µsec. They also demonstrate an unexpected minor conformation for the (5'-GAGU-3')2 loop that is consistent with newly measured NMR spectra of duplexes with natural and modified nucleotides. Thus, unrestrained simulations led to the determination of the previously unknown minor conformation. The stability of the native (5'-GAGU-3')2 internal loop as compared to other loops can be explained by changes in hydrogen bonding and stacking as the flanking bases are changed.

RNA Structural Dynamics As Captured by Molecular Simulations: A Comprehensive Overview

With both catalytic and genetic functions, ribonucleic acid (RNA) is perhaps the most pluripotent chemical species in molecular biology, and its functions are intimately linked to its structure and dynamics. Computer simulations, and in particular atomistic molecular dynamics (MD), allow structural dynamics of biomolecular systems to be investigated with unprecedented temporal and spatial resolution. We here provide a comprehensive overview of the fast-developing field of MD simulations of RNA molecules. We begin with an in-depth, evaluatory coverage of the most fundamental methodological challenges that set the basis for the future development of the field, in particular, the current developments and inherent physical limitations of the atomistic force fields and the recent advances in a broad spectrum of enhanced sampling methods. We also survey the closely related field of coarse-grained modeling of RNA systems. After dealing with the methodological aspects, we provide an exhaustive overview of the available RNA simulation literature, ranging from studies of the smallest RNA oligonucleotides to investigations of the entire ribosome. Our review encompasses tetranucleotides, tetraloops, a number of small RNA motifs, A-helix RNA, kissing-loop complexes, the TAR RNA element, the decoding center and other important regions of the ribosome, as well as assorted others systems. Extended sections are devoted to RNA-ion interactions, ribozymes, riboswitches, and protein/RNA complexes. Our overview is written for as broad of an audience as possible, aiming to provide a much-needed interdisciplinary bridge between computation and experiment, together with a perspective on the future of the field.

Surprising Sequence Effects on GU Closure of Symmetric 2 × 2 Nucleotide RNA Internal Loops

GU base pairs are important RNA structural motifs and often close loops. Accurate prediction of RNA structures relies upon understanding the interactions determining structure. The thermodynamics of some 2 × 2 nucleotide internal loops closed by GU pairs are not well understood. Here, several self-complementary oligonucleotide sequences expected to form duplexes with 2 × 2 nucleotide internal loops closed by GU pairs were investigated. Surprisingly, nuclear magnetic resonance revealed that many of the sequences exist in equilibrium between hairpin and duplex conformations. This equilibrium is not observed with loops closed by Watson-Crick pairs. To measure the thermodynamics of some 2 × 2 nucleotide internal loops closed by GU pairs, non-self-complementary sequences that preclude formation of hairpins were designed. The measured thermodynamics indicate that some internal loops closed by GU pairs are unusually unstable. This instability accounts for the observed equilibria between duplex and hairpin conformations. Moreover, it suggests that future three-dimensional structures of loops closed by GU pairs may reveal interactions that unexpectedly destabilize folding.

Exploring RNA structure and dynamics through enhanced sampling simulations

RNA function is intimately related to its structural dynamics. Molecular dynamics simulations are useful for exploring biomolecular flexibility but are severely limited by the accessible timescale. Enhanced sampling methods allow this timescale to be effectively extended in order to probe biologically relevant conformational changes and chemical reactions. Here, we review the role of enhanced sampling techniques in the study of RNA systems. We discuss the challenges and promises associated with the application of these methods to force-field validation, exploration of conformational landscapes and ion/ligand-RNA interactions, as well as catalytic pathways. Important technical aspects of these methods, such as the choice of the biased collective variables and the analysis of multi-replica simulations, are examined in detail. Finally, a perspective on the role of these methods in the characterization of RNA dynamics is provided.