Reductant-independent ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by homologous nitrogenase proteins from Azotobacter vinelandii and heterologous crosses with Clostridium pasteuranium

Chimeric Interaction of Nitrogenase-Like Reductases with the MoFe Protein of Nitrogenase

The engineering of transgenic organisms with the ability to fix nitrogen is an attractive possibility. However, oxygen sensitivity of nitrogenase, mainly conferred by the reductase component (NifH)2 , is an imminent problem. Nitrogenase-like enzymes involved in coenzyme F430 and chlorophyll biosynthesis utilize the highly homologous reductases (CfbC)2 and (ChlL)2 , respectively. Chimeric protein-protein interactions of these reductases with the catalytic component of nitrogenase (MoFe protein) did not support nitrogenase activity. Nucleotide-dependent association and dissociation of these complexes was investigated, but (CfbC)2 and wild-type (ChlL)2 showed no modulation of the binding affinity. By contrast, the interaction between the (ChlL)2 mutant Y127S and the MoFe protein was markedly increased in the presence of ATP (or ATP analogues) and reduced in the ADP state. Upon formation of the octameric (ChlL)2 MoFe(ChlL)2 complex, the ATPase activity of this variant is triggered, as seen in the homologous nitrogenase system. Thus, the described reductase(s) might be an attractive tool for further elucidation of the diverse functions of (NifH)2 and the rational design of a more robust reductase.

Mechanism of Mo-dependent nitrogenase

Nitrogenase is the enzyme responsible for biological reduction of dinitrogen (N(2)) to ammonia, a form usable for life. Playing a central role in the global biogeochemical nitrogen cycle, this enzyme has been the focus of intensive research for over 60 years. This chapter provides an overview of the features of nitrogenase as a background to the subsequent chapters of this volume that detail the many methods that have been applied in an attempt to gain a deeper understanding of this complex enzyme.

Evidence for a synergistic salt-protein interaction -- complex patterns of activation vs. inhibition of nitrogenase by salt

The molybdenum nitrogenase enzyme system, comprised of the MoFe protein and the Fe protein, catalyzes the reduction of atmospheric N(2) to NH(3). Interactions between these two proteins and between Fe protein and nucleotides (MgADP and MgATP) are crucial to catalysis. It is well established that salts are inhibitors of nitrogenase catalysis that target these interactions. However, the implications of salt effects are often overlooked. We have reexamined salt effects in light of a comprehensive framework for nitrogenase interactions to offer an in-depth analysis of the sources of salt inhibition and underlying apparent cooperativity. More importantly, we have identified patterns of salt activation of nitrogenase that correspond to at least two mechanisms. One of these mechanisms is that charge screening of MoFe protein-Fe protein interactions in the nitrogenase complex accelerates the rate of nitrogenase complex dissociation, which is the rate-limiting step of catalysis. This kind of salt activation operates under conditions of high catalytic activity and low salt concentrations that may resemble those found in vivo. While simple kinetic arguments are strong evidence for this kind of salt activation, further confirmation was sought by demonstrating that tight complexes that have previously displayed little or no activity due to the inability of Fe protein to dissociate from the complex are activated by the presence of salt. This occurs for the combination Azotobacter vinelandii MoFe protein with: (a) the L127Delta Fe protein; and (b) Clostridium pasteurianum Fe protein. The curvature of activation vs. salt implies a synergistic salt-protein interaction.

Duplication and extension of the Thorneley and Lowe kinetic model for Klebsiella pneumoniae nitrogenase catalysis using a MATHEMATICA software platform

The Thorneley and Lowe kinetic model for nitrogenase catalysis was developed in the early to mid 1980s, and has been of value in accounting for many aspects of nitrogenase catalysis. It has also been of value by providing a model for predicting new catalytic behavior. Since its original publication, new results have been obtained and have been successfully incorporated into the model. However, the computer program used for nitrogenase simulations has not been generally available. Using kinetic schemes and assumptions previously outlined by Thorneley and Lowe, we report attempts to duplicate the original T&L kinetic simulation for Klebsiella pneumoniae nitrogenase catalysis using an updated simulation based on the MATHEMATICA programming format, which makes it more user-friendly and more readily available. Comparisons of our simulations with the original T&L simulations are generally in agreement, but in some cases serious discrepancy is observed. Possible reasons for the differences are discussed. In addition to duplicating the original T&L model, we report effects of updating it by including information that has come to light subsequent to its original publication.

Transition state complexes of the Klebsiella pneumoniae nitrogenase proteins. Spectroscopic properties of aluminium fluoride-stabilized and beryllium fluoride-stabilized MgADP complexes reveal conformational differences of the Fe protein

Stable inactive 2 : 1 complexes of the Klebsiella pneumoniae nitrogenase components (Kp2/Kp1) were prepared with ADP or the fluorescent ADP analogue, 2'(3')-O-[N-methylanthraniloyl] ADP and AlF(4)(-) or BeF(3)(-) ions. By analogy with published crystallographic data [Schindelin et al. (1997) Nature 387, 370-376)], we suggest that the metal fluoride ions replaced phosphate at the two ATP-binding sites of the iron protein, Kp2. The beryllium (BeF(x)) and aluminium (AlF(4)(-)) containing complexes are proposed to correspond to the ATP-bound state and the hydrolytic transition states, respectively, by analogy with the equivalent complexes of myosin [Fisher et al. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 8960-8972]. (31)P NMR spectroscopy showed that during the initial stages of complex formation, MgADP bound to the complexed Kp2 in a manner similar to that reported for isolated Kp2. This process was followed by a second step that caused broadening of the (31)P NMR signals and, in the case of the AlF4- complex, slow hydrolysis of some of the excess ADP to AMP and inorganic phosphate. The purified BeFx complex contained 3.8 +/- 0.1 MgADP per mol Kp1. With the AlF(4)(-) complex, MgAMP and adenosine (from MgAMP hydrolysis) replaced part of the bound MgADP although four AlF(4)(-) ions were retained, demonstrating that full occupancy by MgADP is not required for the stability of the complex. The fluorescence emission maximum of 2'(3')-O-[N-methylanthraniloyl] ADP was blue-shifted by 6-8 nm in both metal fluoride complexes and polarization was 6-9 times that of the free analogue. The fluorescence yield of bound 2'(3')-O-[N-methylanthraniloyl] ADP was enhanced by 40% in the AlF(4)(-) complex relative to the solvent but no increase in fluorescence was observed in the BeFx complex. Resonance energy transfer from conserved tyrosine residues located in proximity to the Kp2 nucleotide-binding pocket was marked in the AlF(4)(-) complex but minimal in the BeFx fluoride complex, illustrating a clear conformational difference in the Fe protein of the two complexes. Our data indicate that complex formation during the nitrogenase catalytic cycle is a multistep process involving at least four conformational states of Kp2: similar to the free Fe protein; as initially complexed with detectable (31)P NMR; as detected in mature complexes with no detectable (31)P NMR; in the AlF(4)(-) complex in which an altered tyrosine interaction permits resonance energy transfer with 2'(3')-O-[N-methylanthraniloyl] ADP.

Hydrolysis of nucleoside triphosphates other than ATP by nitrogenase

The hydrolysis of ATP to ADP and P(i) is an integral part of all substrate reduction reactions catalyzed by nitrogenase. In this work, evidence is presented that nitrogenases isolated from Azotobacter vinelandii and Clostridium pasteurianum can hydrolyze MgGTP, MgITP, and MgUTP to their respective nucleoside diphosphates at rates comparable to those measured for MgATP hydrolysis. The reactions were dependent on the presence of both the iron (Fe) protein and the molybdenum-iron (MoFe) protein. The oxidation state of nitrogenase was found to greatly influence the nucleotide hydrolysis rates. MgATP hydrolysis rates were 20 times higher under dithionite reducing conditions (approximately 4,000 nmol of MgADP formed per min/mg of Fe protein) as compared with indigo disulfonate oxidizing conditions (200 nmol of MgADP formed per min/mg of Fe protein). In contrast, MgGTP, MgITP, and MgUTP hydrolysis rates were significantly higher under oxidizing conditions (1,400-2,000 nmol of MgNDP formed per min/mg of Fe protein) as compared with reducing conditions (80-230 nmol of MgNDP formed per min/mg of Fe protein). The K(m) values for MgATP, MgGTP, MgUTP, and MgITP hydrolysis were found to be similar (330-540 microM) for both the reduced and oxidized states of nitrogenase. Incubation of Fe and MoFe proteins with each of the MgNTP molecules and AlF(4)(-) resulted in the formation of non-dissociating protein-protein complexes, presumably with trapped AlF(4)(-) x MgNDP. The implications of these results in understanding how nucleotide hydrolysis is coupled to substrate reduction in nitrogenase are discussed.

Evidence that MgATP accelerates primary electron transfer in a Clostridium pasteurianum Fe protein-Azotobacter vinelandii MoFe protein nitrogenase tight complex

The nitrogenase catalytic cycle involves binding of the iron (Fe) protein to the molybdenum-iron (MoFe) protein, transfer of a single electron from the Fe protein to the MoFe protein concomitant with the hydrolysis of at least two MgATP molecules, followed by dissociation of the two proteins. Earlier studies found that combining the Fe protein isolated from the bacterium Clostridium pasteurianum with the MoFe protein isolated from the bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii resulted in an inactive, nondissociating Fe protein-MoFe protein complex. In the present work, it is demonstrated that primary electron transfer occurs within this nitrogenase tight complex in the absence of MgATP (apparent first-order rate constant k = 0.007 s-1) and that MgATP accelerates this electron transfer reaction by more than 10,000-fold to rates comparable to those observed within homologous nitrogenase complexes (k = 100 s-1). Electron transfer reactions were confirmed by EPR spectroscopy. Finally, the midpoint potentials (Em) for the Fe protein [4Fe-4S]2+/+ cluster and the MoFe protein P2+/N cluster were determined for both the uncomplexed and complexed proteins and with or without MgADP. Calculations from electron transfer theory indicate that the measured changes in Em are not likely to be sufficient to account for the observed nucleotide-dependent rate accelerations for electron transfer.

Nucleotide binding by the nitrogenase Fe protein: a 31P NMR study of ADP and ATP interactions with the Fe protein of Klebsiella pneumoniae

Investigation of the interaction of MgADP- and MgATP2- with the Fe protein of Klebsiella pneumoniae nitrogenase by 31P NMR showed that the adenine nucleotides are reversibly bound in slow exchange with free nucleotides. Dissociation of the MgADP--Fe protein complex was slow enough to enable its isolation by gel filtration, thus permitting the assignment of resonances to bound nucleotides. Spectra of ADP bound to Kp2 were similar to spectra of ADP bound to the myosin motor domain. Oxidative inactivation of a Kp2-MgADP- complex with excess ferricyanide ion eliminated exchange between bound and free ADP, indicating that the intact iron sulphur cluster, located 20 A from the binding sites, is required for the reversible binding of MgADP-. A change in conformation on controlled oxidation of Kp2 with indigocarmine increased the chemical shift of the beta phosphate resonance of bound MgADP-. Both oxidized and reduced conformers were observed transiently in the absence of dithionite. The 31P resonances of both the beta and gamma phosphates of bound MgATP2- indicated major changes in environment and labilization of both groups on binding to the Fe protein. Highly purified Kp2 slowly hydrolysed ATP, resulting in mixtures of bound nucleotides. Partial occupation of Kp2 MgATP2--binding sites (N=1.9+/-0.2, Kd=145 microM) in concentrated protein solutions was demonstrated by flow dialysis. Scatchard plots of data for bound and free ligand obtained after equilibration with Kp2 were linear and no co-operative interactions were detected. We conclude that MgADP- stabilizes the oxidized Fe protein conformer and this conformation in turn triggers the dissociation of the Fe protein from the MoFe protein in the rate-limiting step of the overall process of dinitrogen reduction.

Covalent modification of nitrogenase MoFe protein by ADP

MgADP- reacted with the nitrogenase molybdenum-iron (MoFe) protein of Klebsiella pneumoniae (Kp1) over a period of 2 h to yield a stable, catalytically active conjugate. The isolated protein exhibited a new, broad 31P NMR resonance at -1 p.p.m. lacking phosphorus J coupling. The adenine ring of [8-14C]ADP remained associated with the conjugate. A covalently bound nucleotide was identified as AMP by NMR and TLC. Extended dialysis of Kp1 against MgADP- resulted in further AMP binding at the protein surface. ADP was initially bound tightly to Kp1 at a site distinct from the AMP sites. ATP did not replace ADP. The time course of the formation of the Kp1-AMP was altered by the nitrogenase iron protein (Kp2) and was dependent on redox potential. Kp1-AMP was stable to concentration and oxidation with ferricyanide ion at -350 mV. Slow hydrolysis of Kp1-AMP over a period of 6 h yielded AMP and unaltered Kp1. The adenine ring of ADP exchanged with adenine of MgATP2- during reductant-limited turnover of nitrogenase under N2, indicating reversibility of ATP hydrolysis at 15 degrees C. [32P]Pi exchanged with the terminal phosphate group of both ADP and ATP on incubation with Kp1. 32P exchange and the catalytic activity of Kp1 were inhibited by a 20-fold molar excess of the lysine-modifying reagent, o-phthalaldehyde (OPT). Preincubation with MgADP- protected against OPT inactivation. Two potentially reactive lysine residues on the alpha chain of the MoFe protein near a putative hydrophobic docking site for the nitrogenase Fe protein are proposed as sites of OPT and nucleotide binding. Azotobacter vinelandii MoFe protein (Av1) also formed an AMP adduct but Kp2 did not. Catalase did not interact with ADP. The reactions of the nitrogenase MoFe protein with adenine nucleotides have no counterpart in known protein-nucleotide interactions.

Evidence for electron transfer-dependent formation of a nitrogenase iron protein-molybdenum-iron protein tight complex. The role of aspartate 39

Nitrogenase-catalyzed substrate reduction reactions require the association of the iron (Fe) protein and the molybdenum-iron (MoFe) protein, electron transfer from the Fe protein to the MoFe protein coupled to the hydrolysis of MgATP, followed by protein-protein complex dissociation. This work examines the role of MgATP hydrolysis and electron transfer in the dissociation of the Fe protein-MoFe protein complex. Alteration of aspartate 39 to asparagine (D39N) in the nucleotide binding site of Azotobacter vinelandii Fe protein by site-directed mutagenesis resulted in an Fe protein-MoFe protein complex that did not dissociate after electron transfer. While the D39N Fe protein-MoFe protein complex was inactive in all substrate reduction reactions, the complex catalyzed both reductant-dependent and reductant-independent MgATP hydrolysis. Once docked to the MoFe protein, the D39N Fe protein was found to transfer one electron to the MoFe protein requiring MgATP hydrolysis, with an apparent first order rate constant of 0.02 s-1 compared with 140 s-1 for the wild-type Fe protein. Only following electron transfer to the MoFe protein did the D39N Fe protein form a tight complex with the MoFe protein, with no detectable dissociation rate. This was in contrast with the dissociation rate constant of the wild-type Fe protein from the MoFe protein following electron transfer of 5 s-1. Chemically oxidized D39N Fe protein with MgADP-bound did not form a tight complex with the MoFe protein, showing a dissociation rate similar to chemically oxidized wild-type Fe protein (3 s-1 for D39N Fe protein and 6 s-1 for wild-type Fe protein). These results suggest that electron transfer from the Fe protein to the MoFe protein within the protein-protein complex normally induces conformational changes which increase the affinity of the Fe protein for the MoFe protein. A model is presented in which Asp-39 participates in a nucleotide signal transduction pathway involved in component protein-protein dissociation.

Steady-state kinetic studies of dithionite utilization, component protein interaction, and the formation of an oxidized iron protein intermediate during Azotobacter vinelandii nitrogenase catalysis

Steady-state kinetic analysis of the two-component protein system of Azotobacter vinelandii (Av) nitrogenase is reported. A precisely obeyed half-order reaction in dithionite was observed at concentrations up to 21 mM with no indication of saturation by this substrate. This behavior was monitored by optical, amperometric, and manometric kinetic techniques, and the results were mathematically fit to establish the half-order reaction in dithionite. Under conditions where the MgATP and dithionite concentrations remain unchanged, Av2 (the Fe protein component) interacts with Av1 (the MoFe protein component according to the rate law, suggesting a rapid 1:1 Av2-Av1 interaction: [formula: see text]. with [Av2] the free Fe protein concentration, K = 5.9 microM, and Vmax = 2314 nmol of H2 min-1 (mg of Av1)-1. Under dithionite-depleted conditions, Av2 undergoes an Av1-mediated, one-electron oxidation, consistent with its proposed role as a specific, single-electron reductant for Av1. During steady-state turnover as a function of Av2/Av1 ratio, optical spectroscopy demonstrated the presence of 25-30% oxidized Av2 as an enzyme intermediate. Computer-averaged EPR spectra showed that Av1 was > 95% EPR-silent and Av2 was up to 30% oxidized (Av2ox), consistent with the optical measurements. These optical and EPR results show that up to six Av2ox per Av1 can accumulate in the presence of dithionite during catalysis, suggesting that the conversion of Av2ox back into Av2red is a relatively slow process.