Localisation of cis regulatory elements at the beta-globin locus: analysis of hybrid haplotype chromosomes

Genetic Variation and Sickle Cell Disease Severity: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Importance

Sickle cell disease (SCD) is a monogenic disorder, yet clinical outcomes are influenced by additional genetic factors. Despite decades of research, the genetics of SCD remain poorly understood.

Objective

To assess all reported genetic modifiers of SCD, evaluate the design of associated studies, and provide guidelines for future analyses according to modern genetic study recommendations.

Data Sources

PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus were searched through May 16, 2023, identifying 5290 publications.

Study Selection

At least 2 reviewers identified 571 original, peer-reviewed English-language publications reporting genetic modifiers of human SCD phenotypes, wherein the outcome was not treatment response, and the comparison was not between SCD subtypes or including healthy controls.

Data Extraction and Synthesis

Data relevant to all genetic modifiers of SCD were extracted, evaluated, and presented following STREGA and PRISMA guidelines. Weighted z score meta-analyses and pathway analyses were conducted.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Outcomes were aggregated into 25 categories, grouped as acute complications, chronic conditions, hematologic parameters or biomarkers, and general or mixed measures of SCD severity.

Results

The 571 included studies reported on 29 670 unique individuals (50% ≤ 18 years of age) from 43 countries. Of the 17 757 extracted results (4890 significant) in 1552 genes, 3675 results met the study criteria for meta-analysis: reported phenotype and genotype, association size and direction, variability measure, sample size, and statistical test. Only 173 results for 62 associations could be cross-study combined. The remaining associations could not be aggregated because they were only reported once or methods (eg, study design, reporting practice) and genotype or phenotype definitions were insufficiently harmonized. Gene variants regulating fetal hemoglobin and α-thalassemia (important markers for SCD severity) were frequently identified: 19 single-nucleotide variants in BCL11A, HBS1L-MYB, and HBG2 were significantly associated with fetal hemoglobin (absolute value of Z = 4.00 to 20.66; P = 8.63 × 10-95 to 6.19 × 10-5), and α-thalassemia deletions were significantly associated with increased hemoglobin level and reduced risk of albuminuria, abnormal transcranial Doppler velocity, and stroke (absolute value of Z = 3.43 to 5.16; P = 2.42 × 10-7 to 6.00 × 10-4). However, other associations remain unconfirmed. Pathway analyses of significant genes highlighted the importance of cellular adhesion, inflammation, oxidative and toxic stress, and blood vessel regulation in SCD (23 of the top 25 Gene Ontology pathways involve these processes) and suggested future research areas.

Conclusions and Relevance

The findings of this comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis of all published genetic modifiers of SCD indicated that implementation of standardized phenotypes, statistical methods, and reporting practices should accelerate discovery and validation of genetic modifiers and development of clinically actionable genetic profiles.

Effect of a group of genetic markers around the 5' regulatory regions of the β globin gene cluster linked to high HbF on the clinical severity of β thalassemia

The clinical and hematological course of β thalassemia intermedia is influenced by a number of genetic factors which play a role in increasing fetal haemoglobin levels. Several polymorphisms located in the promoters of β and γ globin gene are involved in influencing the disease severity. Our objective was to study the effect of cis-DNA haplotypes, motifs, or polymorphisms (Pre G γ globin gene haplotypes, Aγ-δ intergenic region haplotypes XmnI and (AT)(x)(T)(y) polymorphisms, β-LCR HS2 and HS3 site motifs) that may contribute to higher HbF levels and a milder clinical course. We found that a combination of T haplotype of the Aγ-δ intergenic region, TAG Pre-Gγ haplotype, presence of the XmnI polymorphism along with the (AT)(9)(T)(5) motif constitutes a topography that co-relates with raised HbF levels which may contribute in ameliorating the disease severity.

Molecular analysis of β-thalassemia patients: first identification of mutations HBB:c.93-2A>G and HBB:c.114G>A in Brazil

The various clinical phenotypes in β-thalassemias have stimulated the study of genetic factors that could modify the manifestations of these diseases. We examined 21 patients with β-thalassemia (β-thal) in order to identify some genetic modifying factors: β-thalassemia mutations, HBG2:g.-158C>T polymorphism, α-globin gene deletions and (AT)xNz(AT)y motif within the hypersensitive site 2-locus control region (HS2-LCR). In the 42 alleles analyzed, the most frequent mutations observed were HBB:c.92+6T>C (30.9%), HBB:c.118C>T (16.7%), HBB:c.93-21G>A (11.9%) and HBB:c.92+1G>A (4.8%); this finding is in accordance with previous data of the Brazilian population. The other genetic factors analyzed showed no relation with the severity of the disease. For the first time in Brazil, we report HBB:c.93-2A>G and HBB:c.114G>A mutations on the β-globin gene, both in a heterozygous state. This is also the first study to analyze the HS2-LCR in β-thalassemic individuals in the Brazilian population.

High-density SNP genotyping to define beta-globin locus haplotypes

Five major beta-globin locus haplotypes have been established in individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD) from the Benin, Bantu, Senegal, Cameroon, and Arab-Indian populations. Historically, beta-haplotypes were established using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis across the beta-locus, which consists of five functional beta-like globin genes located on chromosome 11. Previous attempts to correlate these haplotypes as robust predictors of clinical phenotypes observed in SCD have not been successful. We speculate that the coverage and distribution of the RFLP sites located proximal to or within the globin genes are not sufficiently dense to accurately reflect the complexity of this region. To test our hypothesis, we performed RFLP analysis and high-density single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping across the beta-locus using DNA samples from healthy African Americans with either normal hemoglobin A (HbAA) or individuals with homozygous SS (HbSS) disease. Using the genotyping data from 88 SNPs and Haploview analysis, we generated a greater number of haplotypes than that observed with RFLP analysis alone. Furthermore, a unique pattern of long-range linkage disequilibrium between the locus control region and the beta-like globin genes was observed in the HbSS group. Interestingly, we observed multiple SNPs within the HindIII restriction site located in the Ggamma-globin intervening sequence II which produced the same RFLP pattern. These findings illustrated the inability of RFLP analysis to decipher the complexity of sequence variations that impacts genomic structure in this region. Our data suggest that high-density SNP mapping may be required to accurately define beta-haplotypes that correlate with the different clinical phenotypes observed in SCD.

Genotypic heterogeneity and correlation to intergenic haplotype within high HbF beta-thalassemia intermedia

OBJECTIVES

A molecular study was carried out of beta-thalassemia intermedia patients, compound heterozygotes for mutations usually found in beta-thalassemia major, with high levels of HbF in the absence of hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin (HPFH) syndrome. Our objective was to locate cis-DNA structures, DNA haplotypes, motifs, or polymorphisms that may correlate with the presence of high HbF.

METHODS

Allele-specific oligonucleotide (ASO) hybridization was used for the detection of mutations and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis and automated sequencing for motifs, haplotypes, and polymorphisms. Southern blot was used for investigating alpha-thalassemia and/or alpha- or gamma-globin genes triplications. RNA extracted from burst forming unit-erythroid (BFU-e) colonies of peripheral blood mononuclear cell cultures was used in reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) to investigate intergenic transcription.

RESULTS

We established that (i) the combination: T haplotype of the Agamma-delta-globin intergenic region, the motif (TA)9N10(TA)10 in the HS2 site of locus control region (LCR), and TAG pre-Ggamma haplotype is sufficient but not necessary for high HbF, (ii) the genetic determinant(s) for high HbF involves an element associated with this combination and must be present in the specific R haplotype occurring in beta-thalassemia intermedia and (iii) the genetic determinant(s) for high HbF does not involve the abolition of intergenic transcription in the Agamma-delta-globin intergenic region.

CONCLUSIONS

The genetic determinant(s) of high HbF in the absence of HPFH is linked to intergenic haplotype T and does not disrupt intergenic transcription.

Predicting clinical severity in sickle cell anaemia

The ability to predict the phenotype of an individual with sickle cell anaemia would allow a reliable prognosis and could guide therapeutic decision making. Some risk factors for individual disease complications are known but are insufficiently precise to use for prognostic purposes; predicting the global disease severity is not yet possible. Genetic association studies, which attempt to link gene polymorphisms with selected disease subphenotypes, may eventually provide useful methods of foretelling the likelihood of certain complications and allow better individualized treatment.

β -thalassaemia-87 C→G: relationship of the Hb F modulation and polymorphisms in compound heterozygous patients

A clinical, haematological, biochemical and molecular study was carried out in 17 patients affected with thalassaemia intermedia, who were compound heterozygotes for the beta-thalassaemia mutation beta-87 C-->G to determine the genetic basis of their clinical heterogeneity. The beta-87 was found associated with haplotype VIII (beta-87/VIII) or V (beta-87/V). The 10 patients with the beta-87/VIII showed milder clinical conditions, with significantly higher levels of haemoglobin (Hb) (9.8 +/- 1.1 g/dl vs. 8.5 +/- 1.3 g/dl) and fetal haemoglobin (Hb F) (6.2 +/- 1.5 g/dl vs. 2.6 +/- 1.5 g/dl; P = 0.0034) and higher synthesis of (G)gamma ((G)gamma/(Total)gamma 69.4 +/- 2.6% vs. 42.8 +/- 16.2%; P = 0.0042) than the seven patients with the beta-87/V. The beta-87/VIII showed a configuration of rare polymorphisms in the 5' sub-haplotype, which have been reported to exert an increasing effect on Hb F. They were "T"-158 (G)gamma-globin gene, T-A-G in pre-(G)gamma framework, (TG)(11)(CG)(3) in the (G)gamma-IVS2, (AT)(9)N(12)(AT)(10) in LCR-HS2; in contrast, the haplotype V had, respectively, "C", T-G-A (TG)(19)(CG)(2)CACG in the (G)gamma-IVS2, and (AT)(10)N(12)(AT)(11). In all patients the beta-87 was associated with the (AT)(9)T(5) motif 5' beta-globin gene with increased affinity for the BP-1 protein, and with the (TG)(13) in the (A)gamma-IVS2. The high increase of the Hb F, mostly of the (G)gamma-type, strongly suggests the hypothesis that the 'T'-158 (G)gamma plays a principal role and that the other polymorphisms could exert a cooperative role in the modulation of Hb F in patients with erythropoietic stress.

Concordant fetal hemoglobin response to hydroxyurea in siblings with sickle cell disease

Fetal hemoglobin (HbF) level and the HbF responses to hydroxyurea (HU) vary among patients with sickle cell disease and are, at least in part, genetically regulated. We hypothesized that siblings with sickle cell disease are likely to share the same parental beta-like globin gene clusters with their cis-acting regulatory sequences and therefore, if regulation of this response is linked to the beta-globin gene cluster, might have concordant HbF responses to HU. Accordingly, we studied 26 families (30 sib pairings), 20 with sickle cell anemia (three families had three siblings) and 6 families with HbS-beta-thalassemia (one family had three siblings, and one family consisted of monozygotic twins), to see if siblings with sickle cell disease had discordant or concordant changes in HbF during HU treatment. Intraclass correlation coefficients (r) showed a high, positive correlation between sibs for HbF levels before and during HU treatment and a concordant change in HbF response from baseline to treatment-associated levels. Changes in mean corpuscular volume (MCV) paralleled HbF levels, while the expected correlations between treatment-associated fall in leukocyte count and increase in MCV were also present. Our results provide additional evidence that some elements that regulate HbF expression are linked to the beta-globin gene cluster.

Non-anemic homozygous beta(o) thalassemia in an African-American family: association of high fetal hemoglobin levels with beta thalassemia alleles

We have studied a four-generation (23 subjects) African-American family with beta(o) thalassemia and high fetal hemoglobin (HbF) levels. The beta(o) thalassemia in this family is due to the splicing site mutation, beta IVS2+1G-->A, that leads to aberrant mRNA processing and the absence of beta globin. Two members of this family are homozygous for beta(o) thalassemia and are non-anemic. All family members who are heterozygous for the beta IVS2+1G-->A mutation have elevated HbF, with the exception of two individuals who also have severe alpha-globin chain deficiency. We excluded linkage with the hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin loci on chromosomes 6 and X. We also excluded the presence of all previously described determinants in the beta globin gene cluster associated with elevated HbF production. One thalassemia allele is in the Cameroon-like (HS2)/Benin-like beta globin gene cluster haplotype, and the other is in the Senegal-like (HS2)/Benin-like beta globin gene cluster haplotype. We speculate that in the homozygotes, those erythroid cells that express low to absent levels of gamma globin are selectively destroyed. In contrast, in the heterozygotes, the presence of the normal beta globin allele would ameliorate the globin chain imbalance and thus allow survival of erythroid cells that express the abnormal transcript, leading to a typical beta(o) thalassemia phenotype. Thus, the heterocellular gamma globin expression together with in vivo preferential survival of HbF-containing erythroid cells ameliorates Cooley's anemia in the beta(o) thalassemia homozygotes. It remains to be determined what sequences linked to each thalassemia allele and what trans-acting factors contribute to high HbF levels.

Nucleotide variation regulates the level of enhancement by hypersensitive site 2 of the beta-globin locus control region

The beta-globin locus control region hypersensitive site 2 (HS2) enhancer possesses a unique property for stimulating high-level globin gene expression. Although the deletion of cis-acting motifs influences the level of enhancement conferred by HS2, there is controversy on whether polymorphism of the same elements contributes to variation of the fetal hemoglobin (HbF) level among patients with sickle cell anemia. We analyzed reporter gene activity of constructs containing variant HS2 enhancers derived from beta(S) chromosomes to directly test the effect of polymorphism on enhancer activity. Constructs containing four enhancer variants linked to an identical gamma-globin promoter showed markedly different levels of reporter gene activity. Juxtaposition of HS2 derived from the Asian and Senegal chromosomes, which are associated with similarly high levels of HbF, to cognate sequence extending to -1500 of the (G)gamma globin gene showed significantly different levels of reporter gene activity. Our findings indicate that nucleotide variation regulates the level of enhancement conferred by HS2; however, the reporter activities showed no correlation with the level of Hb F associated with the common beta(S) chromosomes.

Sickle cell disease: no longer a single gene disorder

Patients who are homozygous for the sickle hemoglobin mutation can present with remarkably different clinical courses, varying from death in childhood, to recurrent painful vasoocclusive crises and multiple organ damage in adults, to being relatively well even until old age. Increasing numbers of genetic loci have now been identified that can modulate sickle cell disease phenotype, from nucleotide motifs within the beta-globin gene cluster, to genes located on different chromosomes. With recent success of the human genome project, it is anticipated that many more genetic modifiers of sickle cell disease will be discovered that can lead to the development of more effective therapeutic approaches. The multigenic origin of the variable phenotype in sickle cell disease will serve as a paradigm for the study of variation in phenotypes of all single gene disorders in man.