Tolerance to the anticonvulsant effects of lamotrigine on amygdala kindled seizures: cross-tolerance to carbamazepine but not valproate or diazepam

Drug-resistant epilepsy: From multiple hypotheses to an integral explanation using preclinical resources

Drug-resistant epilepsy affects approximately one-third of the patients with epilepsy. The pharmacoresistant condition in epilepsy is mainly explained by six hypotheses. In addition, several experimental models have been used to understand the mechanisms involved in pharmacoresistant epilepsy and to identify novel therapies to control this condition. However, the global prevalence of this disease persists without changes. Several factors can explain this situation. First of all, the pharmacoresistant epilepsy is explained by different and independent hypotheses. Each hypothesis indicates specific mechanisms to explain the drug-resistant condition in epilepsy. However, there are different findings suggesting common mechanisms between the different hypotheses. Other important situation is that the experimental models designed for the screening of drugs with potential anticonvulsant effect do not consider factors such as age, gender, type of epilepsy, and comorbid disorders. The present review focuses on indicating the limitations for each hypothesis and the relationships among them. The relevance to consider central and peripheral phenomena associated with the drug-resistant condition in different types of epilepsy is also indicated. The necessity to establish a global hypothesis that integrates all the phenomena associated with the pharmacoresistant epilepsy is proposed. This article is part of the Special Issue "NEWroscience 2018".

Evaluation of antiseizure drug efficacy and tolerability in the rat lamotrigine-resistant amygdala kindling model

OBJECTIVE

The lamotrigine-resistant amygdala kindling model uses repeated administration of a low dose of lamotrigine during the kindling process to produce resistance to lamotrigine, which also extends to some other antiseizure drugs (ASDs). This model of pharmacoresistant epilepsy has been incorporated into the testing scheme utilized by the Epilepsy Therapy Screening Program (ETSP). Although some ASDs have been evaluated in this model, a comprehensive evaluation of ASD prototypes has not been reported.

METHODS

Following depth electrode implantation and recovery, rats were exposed to lamotrigine (5 mg/kg, i.p.) prior to each stimulation during the kindling development process (~3 weeks). A test dose of lamotrigine was used to confirm that fully kindled rats were lamotrigine-resistant. Efficacy (unambiguous protection against electrically elicited convulsive seizures) was defined as a Racine score < 3 in the absence of overt compound-induced side effects. Various ASDs, comprising several mechanistic classes, were administered to fully kindled, lamotrigine-resistant rats. Where possible, multiple doses of each drug were administered in order to obtain median effective dose (ED50) values.

RESULTS

Five sodium channel blockers tested (eslicarbazepine, lacosamide, lamotrigine, phenytoin, and rufinamide) were either not efficacious or effective only at doses that were not well-tolerated in this model. In contrast, compounds targeting either GABA receptors (clobazam, clonazepam, phenobarbital) or GABA-uptake proteins (tiagabine) produced dose-dependent efficacy against convulsive seizures. Compounds acting to modulate Ca2+ channels show differential activity: Ethosuximide was not effective, whereas gabapentin was moderately efficacious. Ezogabine and valproate were also highly effective, whereas topiramate and levetiracetam were not effective at the doses tested.

SIGNIFICANCE

These results strengthen the conclusion that the lamotrigine-resistant amygdala kindling model demonstrates pharmacoresistance to certain ASDs, including, but not limited to, sodium channel blockers, and supports the utility of the model for helping to identify compounds with potential efficacy against pharmacoresistant seizures.

Effect of zonisamide on refractory epilepsy during pregnancy in lamotrigine resistant kindled rats

Drug-resistant epilepsy with uncontrolled severe seizures despite state-of-the-art medical treatment continues to be a major clinical problem. Pregnancy is a state where drug pharmacokinetic changes are more pronounced and more rapid than any other period of life. The current study investigated the effect of zonisamide (ZNS) on refractory epilepsy during pregnancy in lamotrigine-resistant kindled rats. Fifty-six lamotrigine (LTG)-resistant kindled Wistar rats were divided into five experimental (four pregnant and one non-pregnant) and 2 positive controls (pregnant and non-pregnant) groups and eight intact Wistar rats were put in the negative pregnant control group. Experimental groups received daily ZNS 50mg/kg by oral gavage and 30min later, pentylenetetrazol (PTZ) (30mg/kg) was injected intraperitoneal (i.p) on Gestational Days 10-15 (in rats with or without ZNS or methanol and ethyl acetate as a ZNS solvent challenge in days -5 to 0) or Days 15-20 and for six days in the non-pregnant group. The positive control groups received the ZNS solvent for the same number of days, but the negative pregnant control group did not receive any treatment. Epilepsy was significantly controlled by ZNS in the experimental groups compared to the positive control groups. It was concluded that ZNS can control refractory epilepsy during pregnancy and increase pregnancy survival in refractory epileptic rats.

Effect of lamotrigine on seizure development in a rat pentylenetetrazole kindling model

INTRODUCTION

Epileptogenesis is a process of seizure development. Lamotrigine is a novel antiepileptic drug which is also used for antiepileptogenic research. Kindling models are recommended as potentially useful tools for antiepileptogenic treatment discovery. However, previous studies demonstrated that the antiepileptogenic effect of lamotrigine is controversial in the electrical kindling model. Chemical kindling such as with pentylenetetrazole is another kindling model. The aims of this study were to examine whether lamotrigine could prevent the development of seizure in pentylenetetrazole kindling rats.

METHODS

Female rats were kindled by subconvulsive doses of pentylenetetrazole (35 mg/kg) once every other day for 15 times. Thereafter, the kindled rats received different doses of lamotrigine (5, 10 and 20 mg/kg) before pentylenetetrazole to observe the anticonvulsant effect. For the antiepileptogenic experiment, rats were kindled as the same way while pretreated (1 h) with different doses of lamotrigine (5, 10 and 20 mg/kg) before each injection of pentylenetetrazole. After a washout period for 1 week, the rats were administrated with pentylenetetrazole again for 3 times. The seizures were recorded each time. Later it was in vivo electrophysiological experiments followed with histologic analysis.

RESULTS

For the anticonvulsant experiment lamotrigine dose-dependently suppressed pentylenetetrazole-induced seizures. Here, 20 mg/kg of lamotrigine pretreatment significantly blocked the seizure development in rats for their seizure stages remained longer in 1-3 during the kindling phase. Mean seizure stages or generalized seizure durations in the 10 and 20 mg/kg lamotrigine pretreated groups were significantly lower or shorter when received 3 times of pentylenetetrazole after the washout period. Electrophysiological study also demonstrated 20 mg/kg of lamotrigine pretreatment obviously eliminated increased population spike amplitude in hippocampus. However, different doses of lamotrigine pretreatment could not alleviate severity of hippocampal neuronal damage.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that adequate doses of lamotrigine can prevent seizure development in the pentylenetetrazole kindling rat model.

Cerebral small vessel disease predisposes to temporal lobe epilepsy in spontaneously hypertensive rats

The link between cerebral small vessel disease (CSVD) and epilepsy has been poorly investigated. Some reports suggest that CSVD may predispose to temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). Aim of this study was to evaluate whether spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHRs), an established model of systemic hypertension and CSVD, have a propensity to develop TLE more than generalized seizures. To this aim, amygdala kindling, as a model of TLE, and pentylenetetrazole (PTZ)-induced kindling, as a model of generalized seizures, have been used to ascertain whether SHRs are more prone to TLE as compared to Wistar Kyoto control rats. While young SHRs (without CSVD) do not differ from their age-matched controls in both models, old SHRs (with CSVD) develop stage 5 seizures in the amygdala kindling model (TLE) faster than age-matched control rats without CSVD. At odds, no differences between old SHRs and age-matched controls was observed in the development of PTZ kindling. Enalapril pre-treatment prevented the development of CSVD and normalized kindling development to control levels in SHRs. No difference was observed in the response to pharmacological treatment with carbamazepine or losartan. Overall, our study suggests that uncontrolled hypertension leading to CSVD might represent a risk factor for TLE. Further experimental studies are needed to unravel other risk factors that, along with CSVD, may predispose to TLE.

Fit for purpose application of currently existing animal models in the discovery of novel epilepsy therapies

Animal seizure and epilepsy models continue to play an important role in the early discovery of new therapies for the symptomatic treatment of epilepsy. Since 1937, with the discovery of phenytoin, almost all anti-seizure drugs (ASDs) have been identified by their effects in animal models, and millions of patients world-wide have benefited from the successful translation of animal data into the clinic. However, several unmet clinical needs remain, including resistance to ASDs in about 30% of patients with epilepsy, adverse effects of ASDs that can reduce quality of life, and the lack of treatments that can prevent development of epilepsy in patients at risk following brain injury. The aim of this review is to critically discuss the translational value of currently used animal models of seizures and epilepsy, particularly what animal models can tell us about epilepsy therapies in patients and which limitations exist. Principles of translational medicine will be used for this discussion. An essential requirement for translational medicine to improve success in drug development is the availability of animal models with high predictive validity for a therapeutic drug response. For this requirement, the model, by definition, does not need to be a perfect replication of the clinical condition, but it is important that the validation provided for a given model is fit for purpose. The present review should guide researchers in both academia and industry what can and cannot be expected from animal models in preclinical development of epilepsy therapies, which models are best suited for which purpose, and for which aspects suitable models are as yet not available. Overall further development is needed to improve and validate animal models for the diverse areas in epilepsy research where suitable fit for purpose models are urgently needed in the search for more effective treatments.

Rapid loss of efficacy to the antiseizure drugs lamotrigine and carbamazepine: a novel experimental model of pharmacoresistant epilepsy

PURPOSE

Kindling is a well-established model of secondarily generalized partial seizures that is widely employed in the search for novel antiseizure drugs. During the kindling and postkindling acquisition phase, an active process of neuronal remodeling occurs. We tested the hypothesis that exposure to the voltage-gated sodium channel blockers lamotrigine (LTG) and carbamazepine (CBZ) during the period of active remodeling will lead to a diminished therapeutic effect.

METHODS

Two days after the last kindling stimulation, fully kindled rats were randomized to receive either 0.5% methyl cellulose (MC), LTG (30 mg/kg), or CBZ (40 mg/kg). The effect of LTG and CBZ on behavioral seizure severity and electrographic afterdischarge duration (ADD) was recorded. One week after this treatment, rats in both groups were rechallenged with LTG 30 or CBZ 40 mg/kg and their seizure score and ADD recorded. In vitro efficacy of LTG on neuronal action potentials was also evaluated using whole cell current clamp recording in hippocampal brain slices obtained from kindled control rats, LTG-sensitive kindled rats, and LTG-resistant kindled rats.

KEY FINDINGS

When acutely administered 48 h after the last kindling stimulation, LTG and CBZ blocked the expression of behavioral seizures and reduced the ADD. In contrast, a second challenge dose of LTG or CBZ administered after a 7-day "no drug, no stimulation" period did not result in reduction of either the seizure score or the ADD. Interestingly, the potassium channel opener, ezogabine, also known as retigabine (EZG; 40 mg/kg), blocked the expression of behavioral seizures at both time points evaluated (i.e., 2 days and 9 days after last stimulation). In vivo resistance to LTG was associated with a similar reduction in the ability of LTG to limit action potential firing in CA1 neurons. LTG (50 μm) significantly decreased the number of action potentials generated by a depolarizing current pulse in neurons recorded from slices obtained from kindled control and LTG-sensitive rats, but not in slices obtained from LTG-resistant rats.

SIGNIFICANCE

Collectively, results obtained from both in vivo and in vitro studies demonstrate that even a single exposure to the sodium channel blockers LTG, or CBZ, during the postkindling remodeling phase leads to an altered pharmacologic response to these two ASDs, but not to EZG. The LTG- and CBZ-resistant amygdala kindled rats may serve as a useful model of therapy-resistant epilepsy.

Carbamazepine, but not valproate, displays pharmacoresistance in lamotrigine-resistant amygdala kindled rats

The voltage gated sodium channel (VGSC) blocker lamotrigine (LTG), when administered during kindling acquisition, leads to the development of resistance to LTG. The present study aimed to assess whether LTG-resistant amygdala-kindled rats display subsequent resistance to the VGSC blocker carbamazepine (CBZ) and the broad-spectrum antiepileptic drug (AED) sodium valproate (VPA). Two groups of male Sprague Dawley rats received either 0.5% methylcellulose (MC) or LTG (5mg/kg, i.p.) 1h before each amygdala kindling stimulation. Treatments were stopped once both the groups were fully kindled. Two days later, both groups were challenged with a higher dose of LTG (15mg/kg, i.p.) to verify LTG-resistance in the experimental group (i.e., LTG-pretreated rats). The efficacy of CBZ and VPA was then evaluated in both groups. A higher dose of LTG blocked fully kindled seizures in the vehicle-treated rats but not seizures in the LTG-treated group. The mean seizure score, of the control group (1.2±0.3) was significantly lower (P<.05) than that of the LTG-treated population (3.5±0.7; n=8). A lower percent of the population in the control group was observed to display a generalized stage 4-5 seizure compared to the experimental group (i.e., those that received LTG during kindling acquisition) (28.5% vs. 62%, respectively). Interestingly, CBZ (10, 20, and 40mg/kg) displayed a dose-dependent anticonvulsant effect in the vehicle-kindled group, but was less effective in LTG-treated animals. In contrast, VPA (300mg/kg) effectively blocked the behavioral seizure and decreased the afterdischarge duration (ADD) in both vehicle and LTG groups. These findings suggest that the LTG-resistant, amygdala-kindled rat may represent a novel model of pharmacoresistant epilepsy.

Tolerance to the beneficial effects of prophylactic migraine drugs: a systematic review of causes and mechanisms

Loss of benefit of a previously effective treatment regimen, also known as tolerance, can be an important barrier to the successful preventive treatment of migraine. We undertook a systematic review of the literature to identify the prevalence and possible mechanisms of drug tolerance in migraine prophylaxis. Results demonstrate that the frequency of tolerance to prophylactic migraine treatment is unknown, but available data support an estimate that it occurs in 1-8% of patients receiving prophylaxis. Four broad types of tolerance were identified that are likely to be relevant to migraine prophylaxis. These are pharmacokinetic, pharmacodynamic, behavioral, and cross tolerance. The mechanisms that underlie these types of tolerance determine whether their effects can be overcome or minimized. For example, certain forms of tolerance may be affected by manipulation of environmental cues associated with drug administration, by the order in which drugs are used, and by the concomitant use of other medications. Many medications used for migraine prophylaxis exert their effects through the endogenous opioid system. The implications of this finding are explored, particularly the parallels between medication overuse headache and tolerance to migraine prophylaxis. Given the many ways in which tolerance to migraine medications may develop, in some ways it is not surprising that migraine-preventive drugs stop working; it is more surprising that in many cases they do not.

Tolerance to the prophylactic effects of carbamazepine and related mood stabilizers in the treatment of bipolar disorders

Tolerance development after successful long‐term treatment of bipolar disorder is under recognized, as are ways to prevent or show its occurrence or reverse it once it has occurred. We review the clinical literature which suggests that tolerance can develop to most treatment approaches in bipolar illness and present an animal model of tolerance development to anticonvulsant effects of carbamazepine or lamotrigine on amgydala‐kindled seizures. In this model tolerance does not have a pharmacokinetic basis, but is contingent upon the drug being present in the brain at the time of amygdala stimulation. The occurrence of seizures in the absence of drug is sufficient to reverse tolerance and re‐establish anticonvulsant efficacy. Based on the model, we hypothesize that some episode‐induced compensatory adaptive changes in gene expression fail to occur in tolerant subjects and that episodes off medication re‐induce these changes and renew drug effectiveness. Approaches that slow or reverse tolerance development in the animal model are reviewed so that they can be tested for their applicability in the clinic. Criteria for assessing tolerance development are offered in the hope that this will facilitate a more systemic literature about its prevalence, prevention, and reversal. Careful longitudinal monitoring of episode occurrence is essential to understanding tolerance development in the affective disorder and its treatment.

ECoG studies of valproate, carbamazepine and halothane in frontal-lobe epilepsy induced by head injury in the rat

The use of electrocorticography (ECoG) with etiologically realistic epilepsy models promises to facilitate the discovery of better anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs). However, this novel approach is labor intensive, and must be optimized. To this end, we employed rostral parasagittal fluid percussion injury (rpFPI) in the adolescent rat, which closely replicates human contusive closed head injury and results in posttraumatic epilepsy (PTE). We systematically examined variables affecting the power to detect anti-epileptic effects by ECoG and used a non-parametric bootstrap strategy to test several different statistics, study designs, statistical tests, and impact of non-responders. We found that logarithmically transformed data acquired in repeated-measures experiments provided the greatest statistical power to detect decreases in seizure frequencies of preclinical interest with just 8 subjects and with up to approximately 40% non-responders. We then used this optimized design to study the anti-epileptic effects of acute exposure to halothane, and chronic (1 week) exposures to carbamazepine (CBZ) and valproate (VPA) 1 month post-injury. While CBZ was ineffective in all animals, VPA induced, during treatment, a progressive decrease in seizure frequency in animals primarily suffering from non-spreading neocortical seizures, but was ineffective in animals with a high frequency of spreading seizures. Halothane powerfully blocked all seizure activity. The data show that rpFPI and chronic ECoG can conveniently be employed for the evaluation of AEDs, suggest that VPA may be more effective than CBZ to treat some forms of PTE, and support the theory that pharmacoresistance may depend on the severity of epilepsy. The data also demonstrate the utility of chronic exposures to experimental drugs in preclinical studies and highlight the need for greater attention to etiology in clinical studies of AEDs.

Kindling and sensitization as models for affective episode recurrence, cyclicity, and tolerance phenomena

We use the non-homologous model of sensitization and kindling to help conceptualize processes occurring in the longitudinal course of bipolar disorder. The models help focus on the phenomena of episode recurrence, regression, and cycle acceleration occurring without medication and during treatment, when these progressive processes can re-emerge during tolerance development. The preclinical data suggest that it is the ratio of pathological versus adaptive factors mediated by changes in gene expression that mediate episode recurrence or suppression. During tolerance development, there may be selective loss of some episode-induced adaptive factors that may be re-engendered during a period off that medication. The models reveal long-term molecular changes induced by recurrent stresses, episodes of illness, and substances of abuse that can accumulate and lead to progressive increases in vulnerability to episode recurrence. The clinical and preclinical data converge in emphasizing the importance of prevention and early and sustained prophylaxis. New data also implicate brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) in genetic and environmental illness vulnerability and progression, as well as in the mechanisms of action of the mood stabilizers and antidepressants. Therapeutic agents may thus not only prevent recurrent affective episodes and their adverse consequences on the brain, behavior, and quality of life, but they may also be able to ameliorate the effects of stressors, and reverse or prevent some of the basic pathological brain mechanisms underlying illness progression.

Experimental and clinical evidence for loss of effect (tolerance) during prolonged treatment with antiepileptic drugs

Development of tolerance (i.e., the reduction in response to a drug after repeated administration) is an adaptive response of the body to prolonged exposure to the drug, and tolerance to antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) is no exception. Tolerance develops to some drug effects much more rapidly than to others. The extent of tolerance depends on the drug and individual (genetic?) factors. Tolerance may lead to attenuation of side effects but also to loss of efficacy of AEDs and is reversible after discontinuation of drug treatment. Different experimental approaches are used to study tolerance in laboratory animals. Development of tolerance depends on the experimental model, drug, drug dosage, and duration of treatment, so that a battery of experimental protocols is needed to evaluate fully whether tolerance to effect occurs. Two major types of tolerance are known. Pharmacokinetic (metabolic) tolerance, due to induction of AED-metabolizing enzymes has been shown for most first-generation AEDs, and is easy to overcome by increasing dosage. Pharmacodynamic (functional) tolerance is due to "adaptation" of AED targets (e.g., by loss of receptor sensitivity) and has been shown experimentally for all AEDs that lose activity during prolonged treatment. Functional tolerance may lead to complete loss of AED activity and cross-tolerance to other AEDs. Convincing experimental evidence indicates that almost all first-, second-, and third-generation AEDs lose their antiepileptic activity during prolonged treatment, although to a different extent. Because of diverse confounding factors, detecting tolerance in patients with epilepsy is more difficult but can be done with careful assessment of decline during long-term individual patient response. After excluding confounding factors, tolerance to antiepileptic effect for most modern and old AEDs can be shown in small subgroups of responders by assessing individual or group response. Development of tolerance to the antiepileptic activity of an AED may be an important reason for failure of drug treatment. Knowledge of tolerance to AED effects as a mechanism of drug resistance in previous responders is important for patients, physicians, and scientists.

Effect of lamotrigine treatment on epileptogenesis: an experimental study in rat

Prevention of epileptogenesis in patients with acute brain damaging insults like status epilepticus (SE) is a major challenge. We investigated whether lamotrigine (LTG) treatment started during SE is antiepileptogenic or disease-modifying. To mimic a clinical study design, LTG treatment (20 mg/kg) was started 2 h after the beginning of electrically induced SE in 14 rats and continued for 11 weeks (20 mg/kg per day for 2 weeks followed by 10 mg/kg per day for 9 weeks). One group of rats (n = 14) was treated with vehicle. Nine non-stimulated rats with vehicle treatment served as controls. Outcome measures were occurrence of epilepsy, severity of epilepsy, and histology (neuronal loss, mossy fiber sprouting). Clinical occurrence of seizures was assessed with 1-week continuous video-electroencephalography monitoring during the 11th (i.e. during treatment) and 14th week (i.e. after drug wash-out) after SE. LTG reduced the number of electrographic seizures during SE to 43% of that in the vehicle group (P < 0.05). In the vehicle group, 93% (13/14), and in the LTG group, 100% (14/14) of the animals, developed epilepsy. In both groups, 64% of the rats had severe epilepsy (seizure frequency >1 per day). The mean frequency of spontaneous seizures, seizure duration, or behavioral severity of seizures did not differ between groups. The severity of hippocampal neuronal damage and density of mossy fiber sprouting were similar. In LTG-treated rats with severe epilepsy, however, the duration of seizures was shorter (34 versus 54s, P < 0.05) and the behavioral seizure score was milder (1.4 versus 3.4, P < 0.05) during LTG treatment than after drug wash-out. LTG treatment started during SE and continued for 11 weeks was not antiepileptogenic but did not worsen the outcome. These data, together with earlier studies of other antiepileptic drugs, suggest that strategies other than Na(+)-channel blockade should be explored to modulate the molecular cascades leading to epileptogenesis after SE.

Neurobiology of Seizures and Behavioral Abnormalities

Seizures are both caused by and induce a complex set of neurobiological alterations and adaptations. The animal model of amygdala kindling provides insight into the spatiotemporal evolution of these changes as a function of seizure development and progression. Intracellular, synaptic, and microstructural changes are revealed as related to both the primary pathophysiology of kindled seizure evolution and compensatory secondary, or endogenous anticonvulsant adaptations. At the level of gene expression, the balance of these pathological and adaptive processes (as augmented by exogenous medications) probably determines whether seizures will be manifest or suppressed and could account for aspects of their intermittency. As anxiety and emotion modulation are subserved by many of the same neuroanatomic substrates involved in the evolution of complex partial seizures, particularly those of the medial temporal lobe, it is readily conceptualized how vulnerability to a range of psychiatric disorders could be related to the primary or secondary neurochemical alterations associated with seizure disorders. The discrete and methodologically controlled elucidation of the cascades and spatiotemporal distributions of neurobiological alterations that accompany seizure evolution in the kindling model may help resolve some of the difficulty and complexity of elucidating these biobehavioral relationships in the clinic.

Antiepileptic drugs in neuroprotection

Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) are designed to prevent and suppress seizure activity. Their effects on calcium influx and molecular cascades contributing to necrotic and apoptotic neuronal death, however, suggests that they have functions other than just suppression of excitability. The neuroprotective effects of 20 AEDs currently in use or being investigated in Phase II - III clinical trials for treatment of epilepsy are reviewed. Data analyses is complicated by several factors. Firstly, the available data on the neuroprotective effects of different AEDs varies largely. Secondly, most of the evidence demonstrating neuroprotective effects comes from stroke models and it is uncertain whether these data can be extrapolated to other conditions, such as status epilepticus (SE) or traumatic brain injury. Thirdly, data obtained in adult animals cannot be extrapolated to young animals without caution. For example, AEDs protecting adult brain from stroke or SE-induced injury can cause apoptosis in immature brain. Finally, data comparison is complicated by the variability in study designs and methodologies between studies. With these caveats in mind, an analysis of the available data suggests that AEDs with different mechanisms of action can have mild-to-moderate neuroprotective effects. It is difficult, however, to associate the neuroprotective effects with a favourable functional outcome. For example, it is difficult to conclude that administration of AEDs during the latency phase would have an effect on the molecular cascades underlying epileptogenesis. The few favourable data demonstrating a decrease in the incidence of epilepsy after SE are probably related to the administration of AEDs during SE, which resulted in modification/alleviation of the insult itself and consequently, reduced its epileptogenecity. These experimental data, however, are clinically important because they show that early intervention of SE has an effect on long-term functional outcome. These observations emphasise the need to use additional outcome measures, such as markers of normal development or cognitive performance, when the benefits of neuroprotection achieved by the use of neuroprotective AEDs are assessed.

Convergences in course of illness and treatments of the epilepsies and recurrent affective disorders

The failure to achieve and maintain remission is a critical problem for a high percentage of patients with epilepsy and the primary affective disorders. Early illness onset and delayed initiation of treatment may contribute to primary treatment resistance or that associated with loss of efficacy (tolerance phenomenon). Neurobiological data and principles drawn from the amygdala kinding model of seizure progression are reviewed for their heuristic value in conceptualizing molecular mechanisms of illness progression and its prevention with pharmacological agents in the epilepsies and, indirectly, the recurrent affective disorders. Caveats in the use of this model and convergences and divergences in its predictive validity for seizures and affective disorders are noted.

Unidirectional Cross-tolerance from Levetiracetam to Carbamazepine in Amygdala-kindled Seizures

PURPOSE

Tolerance is a potential problem in long-term anticonvulsant therapy of epilepsy, bipolar disorder, and neuropathic pain. The present study was designed to determine whether cross-tolerance occurs between levetiracetam (LEV) and carbamazepine (CBZ) in amygdala-kindled rats.

METHODS

Male Sprague-Dawley rats were implanted with an electrode into the left amygdala. While kindling stimulation was started, animals received repeated treatment (i.p.) with saline (n = 7) or LEV (150 mg/kg, n = 8). Saline-injected rats were subsequently challenged with a single dose of 150 mg/kg LEV when full kindling developed (stage > or =4). Both groups of rats were then administered long-term CBZ (5 mg/kg) until rats developed complete tolerance. All CBZ-tolerant rats were subsequently re-exposed to LEV (150 mg/kg) for an additional 10 consecutive days.

RESULTS

Repeated LEV treatment significantly suppressed the increase in seizure stage, seizure duration, and afterdischarge duration induced by amygdala stimulation, markedly increasing the number of stimulations to achieve a kindling major motor seizure. The LEV challenge produced a more robust suppression of seizure stage in saline-injected rats compared with LEV-treated animals. CBZ treatment markedly suppressed fully kindled seizures in rats initially injected with saline, and then anticonvulsant tolerance rapidly developed after 3-4 days of repeated treatment. In contrast, rats that had initially received repeated LEV treatment did not show a response to treatment with CBZ (5 mg/kg). When CBZ-tolerant rats were subsequently exposed to LEV (150 mg/kg), noticeable anticonvulsant effects were observed; but these were gradually lost with increasing numbers of LEV exposures.

CONCLUSIONS

Whereas LEV shows potent antiepileptogenic and anticonvulsant effects in amygdala-kindled rats, its repeated treatment induces anticonvulsant tolerance and unidirectional cross-tolerance to CBZ. In contrast, anticonvulsant tolerance to CBZ does not transfer to LEV. The mechanistic implications of the present results for clinical therapeutics remain to be evaluated.

Potential mechanisms of action of lamotrigine in the treatment of bipolar disorders

Based on the mood-stabilizing properties of carbamazepine and valproate, new anticonvulsants have been explored for use in bipolar disorders. One such agent, lamotrigine, has a novel clinical profile in that it may "stabilize mood from below," as it appears to maximally impact depressive symptoms in bipolar disorders. In this paper, we review the mechanisms of action of lamotrigine in an effort to understand the basis of its distinctive clinical use in the management of bipolar disorders as well as its diverse antiseizure effects. We consider lamotrigine mechanisms, emphasizing commonalities and dissociations among actions of lamotrigine, older mood stabilizers, and other anticonvulsants. Although ion channel effects, especially sodium channel blockade, may importantly contribute to antiseizure effects, such actions may be less central to lamotrigine thymoleptic effects. Antiglutamatergic and neuroprotective actions are important candidate mechanisms for lamotrigine psychotropic effects. Lamotrigine has a variable profile in kindling and contingent tolerance experiments and does not appear to have robust gamma-aminobutyric acid or monoaminergic actions. Lamotrigine intracellular signaling effects warrant investigation. Although lamotrigine mechanisms overlap those of other mood-stabilizing anticonvulsants, important dissociations suggest candidate mechanisms, which could contribute to lamotrigine's distinctive psychotropic profile.

Coadministration of gabapentin or MK-801 with lamotrigine slows tolerance to its anticonvulsant effects on kindled seizures

The development of tolerance to therapeutic effects of antiepileptic drugs can be a problem in the treatment of epilepsy, bipolar disorder, and pain syndromes. In the present study, acute treatment with the new antiepileptic drug lamotrigine (LTG, 15 mg/kg) markedly suppressed seizure stage and seizure duration in amygdala-kindled rats; but this antiseizure effect was rapidly lost following 4-8 days of repeated treatment. When gabapentin (GBP, 20 mg/kg) was coadministered with LTG, the ability of LTG to suppress seizure stage, seizure duration, and after-discharge (AD) duration was markedly extended. In addition, GBP coadministration with LTG decreased the number of animals that developed LTG-related running fits (Stage 6 seizures) and lengthened the number of days required to develop running fits or complete tolerance. Neither acute nor repeated treatment with MK-801 (0.3 mg/kg), a noncompetitive N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist, had effects on kindled seizures. However, cotreatment with MK-801 markedly extended the anticonvulsant effects of LTG on the three seizure indices and reduced running fits. These data indicate that cotreatment with either GBP or MK-801 slows tolerance development to the anticonvulsant effects of LTG on kindled seizures. Therapeutic implications of the present study remain to be explored.

Efficacy of current antiepileptics to prevent neurodegeneration in epilepsy models

Results of experiments performed in animal epilepsy models and human epilepsy during the past decade indicate that the epileptic brain is not a stable neuronal network, but undergoes modifications caused by the underlying etiology and/or recurrent seizures. In many forms of epilepsy, such as temporal lobe epilepsy, the underlying etiologic factor triggers a cascade of events (epileptogenesis) leading to spontaneous seizures and cognitive decline. In some patients, the condition progresses, due in part to recurrent seizures. The current treatment of epilepsy focuses exclusively on preventing or suppressing seizures, which are symptoms of the underlying disease. Now, however, we are beginning to understand the underlying neurobiology of the epileptic process, as well as factors that might predict the risk of progression in individual patients. Thus, there are new opportunities to develop neuroprotective and antiepileptogenic treatments for patients who, if untreated, would develop drug-refractory epilepsy associated with cognitive decline. These treatments might improve the long-term outcome and quality-of-life of patients with epilepsy. Here we review the available data regarding the neuroprotective effects of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) at different phases of the epileptic process. Analysis of published data suggests that initial-insult modification and prevention of the progression of seizure-induced damage are candidate indications for treatment with AEDs. An understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying the progression of epileptic process will eventually show what role AEDs have in the neuroprotective and antiepileptogenic treatment regimen.

Do the epilepsies, pain syndromes, and affective disorders share common kindling-like mechanisms?

Kindling, in the classical sense, involves progressively increasing responsivity to the intermittent repetition of the same 1-s subthreshold electrical stimulation over time, with the amygdala being the area most frequently studied. Such repeated subthreshold stimulation is associated with: lowering of the after-discharge (AD) threshold; lengthening and spread of the AD; marked seizure stage progression culminating in full-blown tonic-clonic forelimb convulsions with rearing and falling; and evolution from triggered to spontaneous seizures. This evolving process concomitantly involves changes in the spatio-temporal expression of immediate early genes (IEGs), neurotrophic factors, and late effector genes (LEGs), and an associated changing pattern of effectiveness of different pharmacological interventions. Since seizures are the paradigmatic behavioral manifestation of kindling, some types of pharmacological seizures, such as those induced by the local anesthetics cocaine and lidocaine, and some epileptic syndromes, are most likely homologously modeled by kindling. However, since non-epileptiform syndromes, such as recurrent episodes of affective illness and some pain syndromes possess non-homogenous elements of kindling-like evolution, some of the principles involved in kindling progression may, nonetheless, be pertinent to the understanding and treatment of these syndromes. For example, one could attempt to distinguish between the genes involved in the primary pathological processes of syndrome evolution versus those that are secondary and adaptive; such a differentiation could have important implications for the development of therapeutic approaches targeted to suppressing or enhancing these alterations, respectively. In these instances, inferences drawn from the kindling model are necessarily indirect and circumscribed because different neuroanatomical and biochemical processes are likely involved in the evolution of each neuropsychiatric syndrome. Given these recognized limitations of non-homologous models, kindling may still provide insights into the longitudinal course, progression, and treatment of some neuropsychiatric syndromes that can then be directly tested in the clinic.

Clinical predictors of response to lamotrigine and gabapentin monotherapy in refractory affective disorders

BACKGROUND

The objective of the current study was to examine possible clinical predictors of positive response to lamotrigine or gabapentin monotherapy in treatment-refractory affectively ill patients.

METHODS

Forty-five patients with treatment refractory bipolar (n = 35) or unipolar (n = 10) affective disorder participated in a clinical study evaluating six weeks of treatment with lamotrigine, gabapentin, or placebo monotherapy given in a double-blind, randomized fashion with two subsequent cross-overs to the other agents. Patients received daily mood ratings and weekly cross-sectional scales. Much or very much improved on the Clinical Global Impression scale modified for bipolar illness was considered a positive response. Degree of response was correlated with a number of baseline demographic and course of illness variables in a univariate analysis and then by linear regression.

RESULTS

Response rates to lamotrigine (51%) exceeded those to gabapentin (28%) and placebo (21%). A positive response to lamotrigine monotherapy was associated with a bipolar diagnosis; fewer hospitalizations; fewer prior medication trials; and male gender (of which the latter two variables survived logistic regression). For gabapentin, degree of response correlated with shorter duration of illness; younger age; and lower baseline weight (with the latter two surviving linear regression).

CONCLUSIONS

In this highly treatment-refractory population, lamotrigine appeared most effective for male patients with fewer prior medication trials. Gabapentin monotherapy, although not better than placebo, appeared most effective in those with younger age and lower baseline weight. These preliminary data in a treatment refractory subgroup may help in the further definition of the range of clinical utility of these widely used anticonvulsants.