Pelvic exenteration for malignant melanomas of the vagina or urethra with over 3 mm of invasion

Exploring the landscape of urinary tract melanomas: A review for pathologists and clinicians

Melanomas originating within the urinary tract represent a rare and clinically challenging subset of malignancies. Despite extensive research on cutaneous melanomas, urinary tract melanomas remain relatively unexplored, presenting diagnostic dilemmas and limited treatment consensus. In this comprehensive review, we synthesize current knowledge on the epidemiology, risk factors, clinical presentation, histopathological characteristics, and treatment strategies specific to this disease. Enhancing clinical awareness, refining diagnostic approaches, and exploring novel therapeutic interventions hold promise for improving outcomes in this challenging malignancy subset.

Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina: A case report

Malignant primary melanoma of the vagina (PMV) is a rare type of non-cutaneous melanoma often discovered in postmenopausal women. PMV has a very aggressive disease course and a poor prognosis. The best course of treatment is not presently agreed upon. In this report, we describe the case of a 68-year-old woman presenting with a malignant PMV and its subsequent management. The patient presented with right vaginal pain, abnormal vaginal bleeding and a new vaginal mass. A PET scan identified a 28 × 38 mm hypermetabolic vaginal lesion, without nodal involvement or distant metastasis. A posterior exenteration type 2B was performed, including the anal mucosa. Sentinel lymph node dissection, vaginal and rectal resection as well as a terminal colostomy were also carried out. Final staging was FIGO stage III and T4bN1. Four months later, the patient presented with a recurrent vaginal bleed and intra-vaginal induration. Imaging revealed loco-reginal recurrence at the site of the primary malignancy with countless metastases. The patient opted for palliative care given the early disseminated recurrence and her multiple comorbidities. We review the treatment options for PMV, mainly the importance of surgery as the mainstay of treatment as well as the interest of adding checkpoint inhibitor immunotherapy or targeted therapy to the treatment plan. We also summarize the characteristics of PMV and its main prognostic factors.

Case report: a robotic-vaginal approach for total vaginectomy and hysterectomy with pelvic sentinel lymph node dissection in primary vaginal melanoma: a 10-step technique and literature review

Introduction

Primary vaginal melanoma is extremely rare, has a poor prognosis, and occurs mostly in elderly women. The diagnosis is based on histology and immunohistochemistry of a biopsy. Given the rarity of vaginal melanoma, no standardized treatment guidelines are established; however, surgery is the primary treatment modality in the absence of metastatic disease. Most reports in the literature are retrospective single cases, case series, and population-based studies. The open surgical approach is the main modality reported. Here, we report for the first time a 10-step combined robotic-vaginal technique, with en bloc resection of the uterus and total vagina, for treating clinically early-stage primary vaginal melanoma. In addition, the patient in our case underwent a robotic pelvic bilateral sentinel lymph node dissection. The literature on the surgical approach for vaginal melanoma is reviewed.

Case presentation

A 73-year-old woman was referred to our tertiary cancer center and was clinically staged according to the 2009 International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) staging for vaginal cancer as FIGO-stage I (cT1bN0M0) and according to the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) for (cutaneous) Melanoma Staging as clinical stage IB. Preoperative imaging with magnetic resonance imaging, FDG-positron emission tomography-computed tomography, and ultrasound of the groins did not reveal any adenopathy nor metastases. The patient was planned for a combined vaginal and robotic en bloc total vaginectomy and hysterectomy, as well as a pelvic bilateral sentinel lymph node dissection.

Results

The surgical procedure was performed in 10 steps described in this case report. The pathology revealed free surgical margins and negative test results for all sentinel lymph nodes. The postoperative recovery process was uneventful, and the patient was discharged on day 5.

Conclusion

The main surgical approach reported for primary early-stage vaginal melanoma is open surgery. A minimally invasive surgical approach, described here as a combined vaginal-robotic en bloc total vaginectomy and hysterectomy, for the surgical treatment of early-stage vaginal melanoma enables precise dissection, low surgical morbidity, and fast recovery for the patient.

Primary Malignant Melanoma of the Genitourinary System: A Systemic Review and Report of Eight Cases

Malignant melanoma (MM) of mucosal membranes (excluding anus and head-neck) is a rare but aggressive disease with poor outcomes. The knowledge of this tumor's development, etiology, and management is scarce, mainly due to the low case numbers. We presented eight cases and performed a comprehensive literature review on mucosal MM (between 1970 and 2020). We identified 47 manuscripts on 55 patients with primary mucosal MM (limited to urothelium and vagina) and reviewed demographics, tumor specifications (morphology, stage, etc.), management, and survival. We identified 10 manuscripts discussing treatment in 1595 mucosal and non-mucosal MM and extracted the data regarding the non-surgical treatment modalities of mucosal MM patients. In 63 cases, 48 tumors primarily occurred in the urothelium (urethra: 47, bladder: 1) and 15 in the vagina. Molecular studies in a subset of cases revealed alterations in c-KIT, NRAS, BRAF (non-V600E and V600E), TP53, and NF1. Fifty-three patients underwent surgery (with additional chemotherapy, immunotherapy, and radiotherapy in 19, eight, and eight patients, respectively). The outcome was available in 52 cases, showing 21 deaths, 10 without recurrence, two alive with disease, and five lost to follow-up. Shared genetic signatures in mucosal and skin MM suggest a similar development mechanism; however, unlike skin MM, there are less BRAF mutations and more PI3K/AKT/mTOR pathway alterations in mucosal MM. Prolonged chemotherapy (i.e., methotrexate) and immune-modulating agents (i.e., natalizumab) may be risk factors. The stage at diagnosis and proper surgical extirpation are keys to the prognosis and survival of patients.

Innovations in the Management of Vaginal Cancer

Primary vaginal cancer is a rare gynecologic malignancy. Given the rarity of the disease, standardized approaches to management are limited, and a great variety of therapeutic conditions are endorsed. This paper reviews advances in surgical approaches, radiation, chemoradiation, and immunotherapy. Advances in surgical management including the increasing use of laparoscopic and endoscopic approaches, as well as the novel techniques in vaginal reconstruction, are reviewed. Concurrent chemoradiation remains a mainstay of treatment for vaginal cancer and has improved local control of disease and overall survival. Additionally, with metastatic disease or situations where toxicity from CCRT is unacceptable, systemic therapies including immunotherapy approaches are reviewed.

Melanoma of the lower genital tract: Prognostic factors and treatment modalities

Primary melanomas originating from the gynecological tract are rare and aggressive cancers. The vulva is the most frequent site (70%), followed by vagina and more rarely by cervix. The clinical outcome of patients with female genital tract melanoma is very poor, with a 5-year overall survival (OS) of 37-50% for vulvar, 13-32% for vaginal, and approximately 10% for cervical melanoma. In this systematic review, we analyzed the pathogenesis and the different factors influencing the prognosis of melanomas of the lower genital tract, with particular emphasis on biologic variables that may influence new therapeutic approaches. We evaluated the different treatment modalities described in the literature, in order to offer a possible algorithm that may help the clinicians in diagnosing and treating patients with these uncommon malignancies.

Clinical and Imaging Features of Noncutaneous Melanoma

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this article is to summarize the epidemiologic characteristics, clinical aspects, and radiologic appearance of as well as the management considerations and differential diagnoses for noncutaneous primary melanomas occurring at specific anatomic sites. Primary ocular, sinonasal, meningeal, biliary, adrenal, alimentary tract, and genitourinary melanomas are highlighted.

CONCLUSION

Noncutaneous primary melanomas are a complex group of malignancies with biologic findings that are unique when compared with findings for cutaneous melanomas. Each noncutaneous primary melanoma has its own specific diagnostic and management challenges, depending on the anatomic location where they arise.

Radicality of initial surgery for primary malignant melanoma of the vagina

Radical surgery is considered not to improve the prognosis of primary malignant melanoma of the vagina (PMMV). This study was carried out to review the general consensus. A systematic review was performed on the basis of data from 10 patients in our cohort and 147 patients in the previous literature. The radicality of the initial surgery (RAINS) score was defined as the total number of points in terms of the resected organs. The target organs were the vagina, vulva, urethra, bladder, uterus, anus, rectum, pelvic lymph nodes, and inguinal lymph nodes. Overall survival (OS) according to the RAINS score was analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier method. Information on tumor stage, size, and depth of invasion was not obtained in 15, 47, and 43% of patients, respectively. The median follow-up period was 18 months. OS with a RAINS score of at least 7 was significantly longer than that with a RAINS score of up to 6 (median survival time, 41 vs. 19 months; log-rank test, P=0.037), despite the fact that the former group included significantly more patients with advanced-stage disease. A significant difference in OS was not found between patients with a RAINS score of at least 6 and up to 5. The therapeutic significance of radical surgery for PMMV has not been assessed appropriately in previous studies because of the lack of comparability among groups and differences in the definitions of surgical radicality. Patients with PMMV might benefit from initial surgery with appropriate surgical radicality, despite incomplete validation of the RAINS score.

Malignant melanoma of the vagina: A case report and review of the literature

Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina is an extremely rare variant of melanoma that accounts for <3% of all vaginal malignancies. Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina has a worse prognosis as compared with non-genital melanomas or other vaginal malignant neoplasms. A-35-year-old female had a diagnosis of primary malignant melanoma of the vagina. A local excision of the tumor was first performed, followed by a radical excision as a further therapeutic measure. The patient returned after three weeks, presenting with a vesico-vaginal fistula. A conservative operation was subsequently performed in order to improve the quality of life of the patient. Pelvic metastases were identified 6 months after the completion of the last surgical therapy and subsequent follow-up examinations were performed in another hospital. The present case study describes the clinical features and surgical procedures of this patient with primary malignant melanoma of the vagina. In conclusion, melanoma of the vagina is an extremely aggressive cancer and the overall prognosis is poor despite the various treatment options.

A large retrospective multicenter study of vaginal melanomas: implications for new management

The outcome of patients presenting with vaginal melanoma has been assessed in a large multicentric retrospective study. The databases of 12 French institutions were searched for primary vaginal melanomas managed between 1990 and 2007. Among the 54 patients recorded, 46 were managed with a curative intent and included in the study. The clinical characteristics, treatments, and detection of c-KIT protein expression have been studied. The median age of the patients was 63.5 years (42-88). Twenty-eight patients were classified as International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) stage I, five as stage II, six as stage III, and one as stage IVA. c-KIT protein was overexpressed in 80% of the patients. Forty-two patients underwent surgical resection of the tumor, nine patients received local adjuvant treatment, and 10 received systemic adjuvant therapy. The median relapse-free survival was 10.9 months. c-KIT-negative status (P=0.01) and stage I (P=0.02) were associated with locoregional recurrence. The rate of metastasis was increased for advanced FIGO stages (P<0.01). The median overall survival (OS) was 28.4 months. The finding of lymph node metastasis adversely affected OS (P<0.01). Conservative surgery and radiotherapy were associated with a decrease in metastasis-free and OS (P<0.01) compared with surgery alone, this group of patients presenting with advanced FIGO stages (P=0.02). Despite the use of limited data, conservative surgery combined with a sentinel lymph node procedure, followed by adjuvant radiotherapy could be proposed to patients with early FIGO stage in the absence of validated management. c-KIT negativity by immunochemistry appears to be a poor prognosis marker in terms of locoregional recurrences but not for metastatic spread nor survival. Further assessment of the role of c-KIT expression in this disease is thus mandatory to select patients for targeted therapy.

Primary Malignant Melanoma of the Vagina: A Retrospective Clinicopathologic Study of 44 Cases

Objective

This study aimed to identify prognostic factors of survival and improve treatment strategies in women diagnosed with primary malignant melanoma of the vagina.

Methods

Between December 2002 and August 2011, 44 patients with lesions confined to the vagina and diagnosed with melanoma at Fudan University Shanghai Cancer Center were evaluated retrospectively. Prognostic factors were analyzed by Kaplan-Meier method.

Results

With a median follow-up time of 18.9 months (range, 6.0–94.3 months), 30 (68.2%) patients developed recurrences, whereas 21 (47.7%) died of disease. Median progression-free survival (PFS) was 14.4 months and median overall survival (OS) was 39.5 months. Depth of invasion (DOI) was significantly associated with OS (P = 0.023), and there was an obvious tendency toward improved OS with a negative lymph node status (P = 0.063). The DOI was significantly associated with lymph node status (P = 0.047). The extent of surgery (wide local excision vs radical excision) was not associated with differences in PFS or OS (P = 0.573 and P = 0.842, respectively). Longer PFS was observed in patients who received adjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy (P = 0.038).

Conclusions

The prognosis of primary vaginal melanoma is dependent on the DOI and lymph node status in our study. Surgical resection of disease, especially wide local excision, should be considered as the optimal treatment when complete removal of tumor with a negative margin is possible. Adjuvant therapy may be associated with a longer PFS.

Melanoma of the female urethra

Melanoma is a malignant tumor that can affect any area of the anatomical economy. Its appearance in the female urethra is extremely rare, with approximately 121 cases in indexed literature since 1966. The subject to be described is an 86-year-old woman who seeks assessment for intermittent macroscopic hematuria with blood clots of 3 months progression. On physical examination, there are no suspicious lesions detected on the surface of the skin. On external genital examination, it is observed a friable lesion at the level of the urethral meatus, with heterogeneous digitations, dark brown to black, and irregular polycyclic borders. No inguinal adenomegalies were palpated. Cystourethroscopy and biopsy of the lesion confirm the diagnosis. Melanoma of the female urethra is an extremely infrequent pathology. Due to lack of published case reports and the absence of prospective randomized trials on treatment outcomes, treatment must be directed using the same anatomical and surgical criteria for female urethral tumors, adding also the concepts of treatment of mucosal melanoma, even though its prognosis is different from the before mentioned.

Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina

OBJECTIVE

To describe the clinical and pathologic features of vaginal melanoma and to determine predictors of outcome in patients with this disease.

METHODS

Thirty-seven women with clinical and radiographic stage I vaginal melanoma treated at one institution between 1980 and 2009 were included in this retrospective study. Treatment modalities were assigned to one of three categories: pelvic exenteration, wide excision, and nonsurgical (primary radiation therapy, chemotherapy, or both). Overall survival and progression-free survival were calculated from the date of the surgical diagnosis.

RESULTS

The median age was 60.6 years. Eighty-four percent of patients were white. Vaginal bleeding was the most common presenting symptom. Lesions were located in the distal third of the vagina in the majority (65%) of patients. Initial management included a wide local or radical excision (76% of patients); pelvic exenteration (14%); and radiotherapy, chemotherapy, or radiotherapy and chemotherapy (10%). At a median follow-up of 17.4 months, 33 women experienced disease recurrence. Recurrence was local only in seven patients (22%), distant only in 20 (63%), and both in five (15%). The most common sites of distant recurrence were lungs and liver. Median progression-free survival was 11.4 months, and median overall survival was 19 months. The 5-year progression-free and overall survival rates were 9.5% and 20.0%, respectively. Patients treated surgically had significantly longer survival than those treated nonsurgically (P=.01). Radiotherapy after wide excision reduced local recurrence risk and increased survival from 16.1 months to 29.4 months, although the increase was not significant (P=.46).

CONCLUSION

Malignant vaginal melanoma, even when localized at presentation, has a very poor prognosis. Patients treated surgically have longer survival than those treated nonsurgically. Radiotherapy after wide excision reduces local but not distant recurrences.

Vaginal melanoma: a current review

Vaginal melanoma is rare, accounting for less than 3% of primary vaginal tumours. It principally affects postmenopausal women, however no risk factors have been identified. Patients frequently present with vaginal bleeding, but the tumour is locally advanced at presentation. Surgery is only the potential cure. The relative merits of radical surgery-vaginectomy and iliac or inguinal lymphadenectomy-versus wide local excision with prompt treatment of recurrences remains uncertain. High dose external radiotherapy and regional chemotherapy trials have been encouraging, although there is no definite survival advantage. Patients should be offered excisional therapy with the opportunity to participate in trials of adjuvant therapy. Prognosis is poor with a five-year survival of 5-21%. Effective screening measures are required enabling earlier diagnosis.

Management of melanomas of the female genital tract

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The significant increase in cutaneous melanomas over the past 30 years has led to studies resulting in advances in their diagnosis, staging, surgical treatment, and adjuvant therapies. Similar approaches have been investigated in patients with far rarer malignant melanomas of the female genital tract. This review will summarize the current state of knowledge on the incidence, causes, presenting symptoms, prognostic factors, therapeutic approaches, and outcomes, site-by-site, for primary melanomas of the vulva, vagina, urethra, ovary, and the uterine cervix.

RECENT FINDINGS

Surgery remains the initial treatment of choice for localized melanomas of the female genital tract, with less radical, organ function preserving resections demonstrating similar control rates compared with more radical surgical approaches in vulva and possibly vaginal melanomas. Radiation therapy may play a role in the treatment of patients with close resection margins, regional nodal metastasis, or unresectable tumors. Sentinel lymph node studies, positron emission tomography and computed tomography scans for staging and evaluation of response, and adjuvant chemo or biochemotherapy warrant further investigation.

SUMMARY

The results of treatment for female genital tract melanomas remain poor. Although surgery remains the initial treatment of choice for localized disease, adjuvant local-regional, and systemic therapies are needed.

[Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina--case report and review of the literature]

The primary malignant melanoma of the vagina is a very rare tumor with less than 300 cases reported worldwide. Metastatic melanomas of the vagina are even rarer and only 5 cases have been reported so far. We describe the case of patient with a melanoma of the left side of the vagina with a tumor size of 6 cm and a tumor invasion of 2.5 cm. At the time of diagnosis there were no signs of nodal metastases in the positron emission tomography. In the literature, wide local excision with adjuvant radiotherapy is recommended, and radical surgery with adjuvant radiotherapy as second-line therapy. Both procedures show similar 5-year survival rates. To reduce the risk of metastases, we had planned an immunotherapy with interferon-alpha, which has been shown to improve relapse-free and overall survival in patients with high-risk cutaneous melanoma. Unfortunately, the cancer was found to have heavily metastasized 6 months later; the patient therefore received a palliative chemotherapy with dacarbazine and thalidomide.

Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina: a case report and review of the current treatment options

A case with primary malignant melanoma located in the posterior lower third of the vagina was encountered and treated by surgery, postoperative immunotherapy and chemotherapy. The tumor was close to the anal sphincter and posterior exenteration was done to achieve tumor-free surgical margins. The need for such radical treatment prompted us to review the literature and discuss our case with the rarest localization of the tumor in the vagina. We focused on the treatment options and the possible complication that may arise during the treatment of the primary malignant melanoma of the vagina. The need for radical surgery was discussed and the current treatment options were reviewed.

Vaginal malignant melanoma: a case report and literature review

Vaginal melanomas are rare genital malignancies occurring mainly in the 6th and 7th decades of life. In general, they have a worse prognosis than cutaneous melanomas. In the past, various treatment modalities have been recommended including radical pelvic surgery. However, the prognosis is poor in spite of such radical approaches. More recently, more conservative treatment in the form of wide local excision combined with adjuvant chemotherapy, high-dose radiotherapy, and immunotherapy seem to have promising results. We describe a patient with vaginal malignant melanoma treated with conservative local excision as well as adjuvant radiotherapy, chemotherapy, and interferon.

Nodal detection in malignant melanoma of the vagina using laparoscopic ultrasonography

BACKGROUND

Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina is a rare variant of melanoma. It has worse prognosis compared to nongenital melanomas or other vaginal malignant neoplasms.

CASE

A 40-year-old Chinese was diagnosed vaginal melanoma. Laparoscopic ultrasonography (USG) was used to search for abnormal pelvic and abdominal lymph nodes. Two metastatic pelvic lymph nodes were detected and excised. The vaginal tumour was removed by hysterectomy and partial vaginectomy. Despite a clear surgical margin and adjuvant radiotherapy, the patient died shortly after the operation.

CONCLUSION

Patient with vaginal melanoma has grave prognosis, especially when metastatic disease presents. Radical surgery appears unjustified as a routine, it is essential to exclude lymphatic and distant metastases before embark to radical surgery. This report presents the first case of laparoscopic ultrasonographic detection of metastatic pelvic lymph nodes in patient with vaginal melanoma.

Outcome of Surgical Treatment for Primary Malignant Melanoma of the Female Urethra

PURPOSE

We evaluate tumor characteristics, recurrence and survival following surgical treatment for female urethral melanoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A review of the records of all female patients with primary localized urethral melanoma (11, mean age 68 years) who underwent partial urethrectomy or radical extirpation from 1950 to 1999 was performed to determine disease specific survival and/or tumor characteristics correlating with survival. Clinical and pathological stage, tumor location, nodal status, adjuvant therapy and tumor pathological components including depth, width, necrosis and vascular/lymphatic invasion, were evaluated. Overall disease recurrence, crude and disease specific survival rates were calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

Malignant melanoma occurred in the distal urethra in all 11 cases with local extension into the vagina (T3) in 7. Mean depth of invasion was 6.1 mm and mean tumor width was 2.0 cm. No vascular/lymphatic invasion or tumor necrosis was seen pathologically. No patient had received adjuvant therapy at the time of initial surgery. There were 7 recurrences (6 of 7 within 1 year postoperatively). Of the 7 cases of partial urethrectomy, urethral recurrence (1 with concurrent lung metastasis) developed in 5 and none had bladder recurrence. Those who underwent radical surgery had recurrence in the pelvis and lungs and inguinal lymph nodes. Crude and disease specific survival +/- standard error at 3 years was 27 +/- 15% and 38 +/- 19%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary female urethral melanoma is associated with a rapid and high local recurrence rate (60% at 1 year). Overall and cancer specific survival at 3 years is 27% and 38%, respectively. Local failure may in part be due to inadequate resection.

Mucosal melanoma of the female genital tract is a multifocal disorder

OBJECTIVE

This is a retrospective analysis of malignant melanoma of the female genital tract, focusing on the high local recurrence rate of this tumor.

METHODS

All women treated for malignant melanoma of the genital tract were identified through the archives of the Hadassah University Hospital. The medical records and the pathological specimens were reviewed and reevaluated.

RESULTS

From 1986 to 2002, nine cases were diagnosed and treated at Hadassah. Seven had vulvar melanoma and two had vaginal melanoma. Sixty-six percent (6/9) of the patients had more than one focus of melanoma, either apparent at their initial diagnosis (3/9) or developed during follow up (3/9). Most of the recurring lesions were melanoma in situ. In one patient multiple nodular melanomas were detected. Atypical melanocytic hyperplasia was found in an otherwise normal mucosa in four patients. Three had experienced multiple recurrences. All patients were treated by radical local excisions with (3/9) or without (6/9) elective groin lymph node dissection. Three patients with locally recurring melanoma within the genital tract required two to five sessions of repeated surgical excisions.

CONCLUSION

It is suggested that melanoma of the genital tract is the result of a multifocal disorder of the melanocytes within the mucosa. The increased local recurrence rate reflects an inherent abnormality of melanocytes. It is not attributed to surgical failure in controlling the disease. Insistent and even radical surgical excision is recommended, especially for patients whose prospects for prolonged survival are improved.

Primary malignant melanoma of the urethra: a clinicopathologic analysis of 15 cases

The clinical and pathologic features of 15 primary urethral melanomas occurring in patients (nine women and six men) age 44 to 96 years (mean age, 73 yrs) are described. In the men the tumor involved the distal urethra. In eight women it involved the distal urethra, usually the meatus; both the distal and proximal urethra were involved in one woman. The tumors were typically polypoid and ranged from 0.8 to 6 cm (mean, 2.6 cm) in maximum dimension. A vertical growth phase was present in all tumors, with a prominent nodular component in seven of them. A radial growth phase was seen in nine tumors. The depth of invasion ranged from 2 to 17 mm. The tumors had diffuse, nested, storiform, or mixed growth patterns. The neoplastic cells typically had abundant eosinophilic cytoplasm, large nuclei with prominent nucleoli, and brisk mitotic activity. Melanin pigment was seen in 12 tumors but was conspicuous in only six. At the time of diagnosis, 13 tumors were confined to the urethra and two patients had lymph node metastasis. Nine patients died of disease 13 to 56 months after initial diagnosis and treatment, and one patient had a local recurrence at 4 years and subsequently died of sepsis 1 year later. Three patients were alive and well at 11 months, 23 months, and 7 years. One patient died at the time of the initial operation, and one died of a ruptured aortic aneurysm at 3 years without evidence of melanoma at autopsy. Primary malignant melanomas of the urethra, one fifth of which are amelanotic, must be included in the differential diagnosis of a number of primary neoplasms that involve the urethra, including transitional cell carcinoma, sarcomatoid carcinoma, and sarcomas. Conventional prognostic factors, such as depth of invasion or tumor stage, do not seem to play as important a role in predicting survival as the mucosal location and the nodular growth present frequently in these tumors.

Primary malignant melanoma of the vagina: long-term remission following radiation therapy

OBJECTIVE

To describe the characteristics and clinical course of patients with primary vaginal melanoma treated at three large Austrian institutions.

METHODS

The medical records of 14 patients treated at the Departments of Obstetrics and Gynecology of the Universities of Graz and Vienna and the Salzburg Women's Hospital between 1982 and 1996 were reviewed.

RESULTS

The median age at diagnosis was 73 years. Presenting symptoms included vaginal bleeding in all patients. Three of seven patients (43%) with tumors < or = 3 cm survived longer than 5 years compared to none of seven patients with a tumor size > 3 cm. Three of nine patients (33%) who received radiotherapy either in addition to surgical excision or as primary treatment, survived for 5 years. Other potential prognostic factors such as age, location, FIGO stage, depth of invasion, Chung level, histology, cell type, mitotic count, vessel involvement, ulceration, p53 accumulation, type of surgery, type of radiotherapy, or chemotherapy did not seem to correlate with the patients' outcome. The median overall survival was 10 months (range 1-153). The 5-year disease-free and overall survival rates were 14 and 21%, respectively. All three long-term survivors recurred locally.

CONCLUSION

All three patients who had long-term survival had lesions < or = 3 cm and received either primary radiotherapy (n = 2) or adjuvant radiotherapy after complete excision of the primary lesion (n = 1). In view of the poor overall survival rates, regardless of treatment, radiotherapy may be a limited valuable alternative or adjunct to surgery in patients with primary malignant melanoma of the vagina < or = 3 cm in diameter.

Primary vaginal melanoma: thirteen-year disease-free survival after wide local excision and review of recent literature

OBJECTIVES

We present a case report of a woman who has survived 13 years after conservative treatment with wide excision for vaginal melanoma and review and evaluate the literature on this disease since the last metaanalysis in 1989.

STUDY DESIGN

A database literature search along with cross referencing from related articles uncovered 66 patients who were reported to have vaginal melanoma since 1989 with adequate information for our analysis. We add to this one original case reported by us. Where information was available, we analyzed outcomes on these cases on the basis of patient age, tumor thickness, tumor size, and treatment.

RESULTS

The patient we describe is only the eighteenth reported patient to survive vaginal melanoma 5 years and only the third to survive for 10 years. Of the 67 patients in our overall review, mean age at the time of diagnosis was 62 years. Patients with tumor size < 3 cm had a mean survival of 41 months compared with 12 months for those with tumor size > or = 3 cm (p < 0.0024). Tumor thickness did not significantly affect patient survival at any of the depths analyzed, although there was a tendency toward significance at depths > 8 mm (p < 0.0778). There also was no significant difference in patient outcome among five treatment groups: (1) wide excision, (2) radical surgery, (3) radiation therapy, (4) wide excision plus radiation therapy, and (5) other.

CONCLUSION

Tumor size appears to affect survival in patients with vaginal melanoma. Tumor thickness, at least at the levels at which vaginal melanomas are currently being diagnosed, does not seem to affect survival. Because no single treatment is clearly preferable, we suggest conservative resection where possible. We find it difficult to support radical surgery as primary treatment for vaginal melanoma unless necessary to achieve clear tumor margins. Radiation therapy appears to offer results comparable to those of surgery.

Neovaginal malignant melanoma following surgery and radiation for vulvar squamous cell carcinoma

The causal link between therapeutic irradiation and malignant melanoma has not been firmly established. The authors report a novel case of a malignant melanoma arising from a therapeutically irradiated neovagina reconstructed from skin flaps following radical vulvectomy with inguinal lymph node dissection 16 years earlier. The diagnosis was established by light microscopy and immunohistochemical staining. Reports of melanoma arising from sites of previous radiation therapy are reviewed. Our observations suggest that therapeutic radiation may be a factor in the development of malignant melanoma, particularly in non-sun-exposed areas, including the genital tract.