A pulse-chase-competition experiment to determine if a folding intermediate is on or off-pathway: application to ribonuclease A

Differentiating between the sequence of structural events on alternative pathways of folding of a heterodimeric protein

Distinguishing between competing pathways of folding of a protein, on the basis of how they differ in their progress of structure acquisition, remains an important challenge in protein folding studies. A previous study had shown that the heterodimeric protein, double chain monellin (dcMN) switches between alternative folding pathways upon a change in guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) concentration. In the current study, the folding of dcMN has been characterized by the pulsed hydrogen exchange (HX) labeling methodology used in conjunction with mass spectrometry. Quantification of the extent to which folding intermediates accumulate and then disappear with time of folding at both low and high GdnHCl concentrations, where the folding pathways are known to be different, shows that the folding mechanism is describable by a triangular three-state mechanism. Structural characterization of the productive folding intermediates populated on the alternative pathways has enabled the pathways to be differentiated on the basis of the progress of structure acquisition that occurs on them. The intermediates on the two pathways differ in the extent to which the α-helix and the rest of the β-sheet have acquired structure that is protective against HX. The major difference is, however, that β2 has not acquired any protective structure in the intermediate formed on one pathway, but it has acquired significant protective structure in the intermediate formed on the alternative pathway. Hence, the sequence of structural events is different on the two alternative pathways.

Protein folding in vitro and in the cell: From a solitary journey to a team effort

Correct protein folding is essential for the health and function of living organisms. Yet, it is not well understood how unfolded proteins reach their native state and avoid aggregation, especially within the cellular milieu. Some proteins, especially small, single-domain and apparent two-state folders, successfully attain their native state upon dilution from denaturant. Yet, many more proteins undergo misfolding and aggregation during this process, in a concentration-dependent fashion. Once formed, native and aggregated states are often kinetically trapped relative to each other. Hence, the early stages of protein life are absolutely critical for proper kinetic channeling to the folded state and for long-term solubility and function. This review summarizes current knowledge on protein folding/aggregation mechanisms in buffered solution and within the bacterial cell, highlighting early stages. Remarkably, teamwork between nascent chain, ribosome, trigger factor and Hsp70 molecular chaperones enables all proteins to overcome aggregation propensities and reach a long-lived bioactive state.

Kinetically trapped metastable intermediate of a disulfide-deficient mutant of the starch-binding domain of glucoamylase

Refolding of a thermally unfolded disulfide-deficient mutant of the starch-binding domain of glucoamylase was investigated using differential scanning calorimetry, isothermal titration calorimetry, CD, and (1)H NMR. When the protein solution was rapidly cooled from a higher temperature, a kinetic intermediate was formed during refolding. The intermediate was unexpectedly stable compared with typical folding intermediates that have short half-lives. It was shown that this intermediate contained substantial secondary structure and tertiary packing and had the same binding ability with beta-cyclodextrin as the native state, suggesting that the intermediate is highly-ordered and native-like on the whole. These characteristics differ from those of partially folded intermediates such as molten globule states. Far-UV CD spectra showed that the secondary structure was once disrupted during the transition from the intermediate to the native state. These results suggest that the intermediate could be an off-pathway type, possibly a misfolded state, that has to undergo unfolding on its way to the native state.

Effects of tyrosine mutations on the conformational and oxidative folding of ribonuclease a: a comparative study

Ribonuclease A (RNase A) undergoes more rapid conformational folding with its disulfide bonds intact than during oxidative folding from its reduced form. In this study, the effects of the mutants Y92G, Y92A, and Y92L on both the conformational and oxidative folding pathways were examined to determine the role of native interactions in different types of conformational searches for the biologically active structure of a protein. These mutations did not affect the overall conformational folding pathway of RNase A. However, in the mutants Y92G and Y92A, a key structured disulfide-bonded species, des-[65-72], involved in the oxidative folding pathway of RNase A, was destabilized. These results demonstrate the importance of native interactions in the folding process, namely, protection of a native (40-95) disulfide bond by a nearby tyrosyl-prolyl stacking interaction, when disulfide bonds are allowed to undergo SH/S-S reshuffling.

Pressure-jump-induced kinetics reveals a hydration dependent folding/unfolding mechanism of ribonuclease A

Pressure-jump (p-jump)-induced relaxation kinetics was used to explore the energy landscape of protein folding/unfolding of Y115W, a fluorescent variant of ribonuclease A. Pressure-jumps of 40 MPa amplitude (5 ms dead-time) were conducted both to higher (unfolding) and to lower (folding) pressure, in the range from 100 to 500 MPa, between 30 and 50 degrees C. Significant deviations from the expected symmetrical protein relaxation kinetics were observed. Whereas downward p-jumps resulted always in single exponential kinetics, the kinetics induced by upward p-jumps were biphasic in the low pressure range and monophasic at higher pressures. The relative amplitude of the slow phase decreased as a function of both pressure and temperature. At 50 degrees C, only the fast phase remained. These results can be interpreted within the framework of a two-dimensional energy surface containing a pressure- and temperature-dependent barrier between two unfolded states differing in the isomeric state of the Asn-113-Pro-114 bond. Analysis of the activation volume of the fast kinetic phase revealed a temperature-dependent shift of the unfolding transition state to a larger volume. The observed compensation of this effect by glycerol offers an explanation for its protein stabilizing effect.

Extensive Misfolding in the Refolding Reaction of Alkaline Ferrocytochrome c

This work describes an extensively misfolded kinetic intermediate in the folding of horse ferrocytochrome c. Under absolute native conditions, the alkali-unfolded protein liganded with carbon-monoxide exhibits misfolding. The misfolded product, apparently an off-pathway intermediate, requires large-scale unfolding in order to have a chance to fold correctly to the native state. The rate of unfolding of the misfolded intermediate limits the overall rate of protein folding. The high level of observed misfolding possibly results from a failure of the polypeptide chain to achieve by stochastic search the transition state relevant for successful folding. Such misfolding may be analogous to the failure of a sizable set of proteins in the intracellular milieu to fold to the functionally active native state.

Folding kinetics of the S100A11 protein dimer studied by time-resolved electrospray mass spectrometry and pulsed hydrogen-deuterium exchange

This study reports the application of electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) with on-line rapid mixing for millisecond time-resolved studies of the refolding and assembly of a dimeric protein complex. Acid denaturation of S100A11 disrupts the native homodimeric protein structure. Circular dichroism and HSQC nuclear magnetic resonance measurements reveal that the monomeric subunits unfold to a moderate degree but retain a significant helicity and some tertiary structural elements. Following a rapid change in solution conditions to a slightly basic pH, the native protein reassembles with an effective rate constant of 6 s(-)(1). The ESI charge state distributions measured during the reaction suggest the presence of three kinetic species, namely, a relatively unfolded monomer (M(U)), a more tightly folded monomeric reaction intermediate (M(F)), and dimeric S100A11. These three forms exhibit distinct calcium binding properties, with very low metal loading levels for M(U), up to two calcium ions for M(F), and up to four for the dimer. Surprisingly, on-line pulsed hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) reveals that each of the monomeric forms of the protein comprises two subspecies that can be distinguished on the basis of their isotope exchange levels. As the reaction proceeds, the more extensively labeled species are depleted. The exponential nature of the measured intensity-time profiles implies that the rate-determining step of the overall process is a unimolecular event. The kinetics are consistent with a sequential folding and assembly mechanism involving two increasingly nativelike monomeric intermediates en route to the native S100A11 dimer.

A protein folding pathway with multiple folding intermediates at atomic resolution

Using native-state hydrogen-exchange-directed protein engineering and multidimensional NMR, we determined the high-resolution structure (rms deviation, 1.1 angstroms) for an intermediate of the four-helix bundle protein: Rd-apocytochrome b562. The intermediate has the N-terminal helix and a part of the C-terminal helix unfolded. In earlier studies, we also solved the structures of two other folding intermediates for the same protein: one with the N-terminal helix alone unfolded and the other with a reorganized hydrophobic core. Together, these structures provide a description of a protein folding pathway with multiple intermediates at atomic resolution. The two general features for the intermediates are (i) native-like backbone topology and (ii) nonnative side-chain interactions. These results have implications for important issues in protein folding studies, including large-scale conformation search, -value analysis, and computer simulations.

Alzheimer's Aβ40 Studied by NMR at Low pH Reveals That Sodium 4,4-Dimethyl-4-silapentane-1-sulfonate (DSS) Binds and Promotes β-Ball Oligomerization

The Alzheimer's Abeta40 peptide forms soluble oligomers that are extremely potent neurotoxins and strongly impede synapses function. In this study the formation and structure of the large, soluble, neurotoxic Abeta40 oligomer called "beta-ball" were characterized by two-dimensional NMR, circular dichroism, fluorescence spectroscopy, hydrogen exchange, and equilibrium sedimentation. In acidic aqueous solution, half the Abeta40 molecules are in the beta-ball state; the remainder are monomeric. The equilibrium between the two states is slow as judged by NMR linewidths and is stable for months. The kinetics of beta-ball formation from monomer are biphasic with tau1 = 7 min and tau2 = 80 min with no transient helix formation. Monomeric Abeta40 is essentially devoid of stable secondary structure, although the central, Leu17-Ala21, and C-terminal, Gly29-Val40, hydrophobic regions show propensity toward adopting extended structure, and residues 22-25 tended to form a turn. We found that sodium 4,4-dimethyl-4-silapentane-1-sulfonate (DSS) binds to the central hydrophobic region of monomeric Abeta40. DSS binds beta-balls more strongly and caused them to double in size. Plausible micelle-like models for the beta-ball structure with and without bound DSS are presented.

Monitoring protein folding at atomic resolution

Elucidation of the mechanisms by which proteins fold from disordered conformations to their unique native conformations is one of the most challenging tasks facing structural biologists. Understanding the mechanism(s) of protein folding involves the characterization of all structural species that occur in the protein-folding reaction. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a powerful and versatile technique that provides an avenue to investigate the structures of the various conformational states at the residue level along the protein-folding reaction coordinate. In this Account, we provide a comprehensive review of the recent progress on the applications of NMR to monitor equilibrium and kinetic conformational states of the protein-folding reaction.

Hidden intermediates and levinthal paradox in the folding of small proteins

It has long been suggested that existence of partially folded intermediates may be essential for proteins to fold in a biologically meaningful time scale. Although partially folded intermediates have been commonly observed in larger proteins, they are generally not detectable in the kinetic folding of smaller proteins (approximately 100 amino acids or less). Recent native-state hydrogen exchange studies suggest that partially folded intermediates may exist behind the rate-limiting transition state in small proteins and evade detection by conventional kinetic methods.

Protein-folding kinetics and mechanisms studied by pulse-labeling and mass spectrometry

The "protein-folding problem" refers to the question of how and why a denatured polypeptide chain can spontaneously fold into a compact and highly ordered conformation. The classical description of this process in terms of reaction pathways has been complemented by models that describe folding as a biased conformational diffusion on a multidimensional energy landscape. The identification and characterization of short-lived intermediates provide important insights into the mechanism of folding. Pulsed hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) methods are among the most powerful tools for studying the properties of kinetic intermediates. Analysis of pulse-labeled proteins by mass spectrometry (MS) provides information that is complementary to that obtained in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies; NMR data represent an average of entire protein ensembles, whereas MS can detect co-existing protein species. MS-based pulse-labeling experiments can distinguish between folding scenarios that involve parallel pathways, and those where folding is channeled through obligatory intermediates. The proteolytic digestion/MS technique provides spatially resolved information on the HDX pattern of folding intermediates. This method is especially important for proteins that are too large to be studied by NMR. Although traditional pulsed HDX protocols are based on quench-flow techniques, it is also possible to use electrospray (ESI) MS to analyze the reaction mixture on-line and "quasi-instantaneously" after labeling. This approach allows short-lived protein conformations to be studied by their HDX level, their ESI charge-state distribution, and their ligand-binding state. Covalent labeling of free cysteinyl residues provides an alternative approach to pulsed HDX experiments. Another promising development is the use of synchrotron X-rays to induce oxidation at specific sites within a protein for studying their solvent accessibility during folding.

Submolecular cooperativity produces multi-state protein unfolding and refolding

Hydrogen exchange experiments show that cytochrome c and other proteins under native conditions reversibly unfold in a multi-step manner. The step from one intermediate to the next is determined by the intrinsically cooperative nature of secondary structural elements, which is retained in the native protein. Folding uses the same pathway in the reverse direction, moving from the unfolded to the native state through relatively discrete intermediate forms by the sequential addition of native-like secondary structural units.

Mechanism of fast protein folding

An explosion of in vitro experimental data on the folding of proteins has revealed many examples of folding in the millisecond or faster timescale, often occurring in the absence of stable intermediate states. We review experimental methods for measuring fast protein folding kinetics, and then discuss various analytical models used to interpret these data. Finally, we classify general mechanisms that have been proposed to explain fast protein folding into two catagories, heterogeneous and homogeneous, reflecting the nature of the transition state. One heterogeneous mechanism, the diffusion-collision mechanism, can be used to interpret experimental data for a number of proteins.

Fast and slow intermediate accumulation and the initial barrier mechanism in protein folding

Do stable intermediates form very early in the protein folding process? New results and a quantity of literature that bear on this issue are examined here. Results available provide little support for early intermediate accumulation before an initial search-dependent nucleation barrier.

Folding of horse cytochrome c in the reduced state

Equilibrium and kinetic folding studies of horse cytochrome c in the reduced state have been carried out under strictly anaerobic conditions at neutral pH, 10 degrees C, in the entire range of aqueous solubility of guanidinium hydrochloride (GdnHCl). Equilibrium unfolding transitions observed by Soret heme absorbance, excitation energy transfer from the lone tryptophan residue to the ferrous heme, and far-UV circular dichroism (CD) are all biphasic and superimposable, implying no accumulation of structural intermediates. The thermodynamic parameters obtained by two-state analysis of these transitions yielded DeltaG(H2O)=18.8(+/-1.45) kcal mol(-1), and C(m)=5.1(+/-0.15) M GdnHCl, indicating unusual stability of reduced cytochrome c. These results have been used in conjunction with the redox potential of native cytochrome c and the known stability of oxidized cytochrome c to estimate a value of -164 mV as the redox potential of the unfolded protein. Stopped-flow kinetics of folding and unfolding have been recorded by Soret heme absorbance, and tryptophan fluorescence as observables. The refolding kinetics are monophasic in the transition region, but become biphasic as moderate to strongly native-like conditions are approached. There also is a burst folding reaction unobservable in the stopped-flow time window. Analyses of the two observable rates and their amplitudes indicate that the faster of the two rates corresponds to apparent two-state folding (U<-->N) of 80-90 % of unfolded molecules with a time constant in the range 190-550 micros estimated by linear extrapolation and model calculations. The remaining 10-20 % of the population folds to an off-pathway intermediate, I, which is required to unfold first to the initial unfolded state, U, in order to refold correctly to the native state, N (I<-->U<-->N). The slower of the two observable rates, which has a positive slope in the linear functional dependence on the denaturant concentration indicating that an unfolding process under native-like conditions indeed exists, originates from the unfolding of I to U, which rate-limits the overall folding of these 10-20 % of molecules. Both fast and slow rates are independent of protein concentration and pH of the refolding milieu, suggesting that the off-pathway intermediate is not a protein aggregate or trapped by heme misligation. The nature or type of unfolded-state heme ligation does not interfere with refolding. Equilibrium pH titration of the unfolded state yielded coupled ionization of the two non-native histidine ligands, H26 and H33, with a pK(a) value of 5.85. A substantial fraction of the unfolded population persists as the six-coordinate form even at low pH, suggesting ligation of the two methionine residues, M65 and M80. These results have been used along with the known ligand-binding properties of unfolded cytochrome c to propose a model for heme ligation dynamics. In contrast to refolding kinetics, the unfolding kinetics of reduced cytochrome c recorded by observation of Soret absorbance and tryptophan fluorescence are all slow, simple, and single-exponential. In the presence of 6.8 M GdnHCl, the unfolding time constant is approximately 300(+/-125) ms. There is no burst unfolding reaction. Simulations of the observed folding-unfolding kinetics by numerical solutions of the rate equations corresponding to the three-state I<-->U<-->N scheme have yielded the microscopic rate constants.

Protein folding intermediates and pathways studied by hydrogen exchange

In order to solve the immensely difficult protein-folding problem, it will be necessary to characterize the barriers that slow folding and the intermediate structures that promote it. Although protein-folding intermediates are not accessible to the usual structural studies, hydrogen exchange (HX) methods have been able to detect and characterize intermediates in both kinetic and equilibrium modes--as transient kinetic folding intermediates on a subsecond time scale, as labile equilibrium molten globule intermediates under destabilizing conditions, and as infinitesimally populated intermediates in the high free-energy folding landscape under native conditions. Available results consistently indicate that protein-folding landscapes are dominated by a small number of discrete, metastable, native-like partially unfolded forms (PUFs). The PUFs appear to be produced, one from another, by the unfolding and refolding of the protein's intrinsically cooperative secondary structural elements, which can spontaneously create stepwise unfolding and refolding pathways. Kinetic experiments identify three kinds of barrier processes: (a) an initial intrinsic search-nucleation-collapse process that prepares the chain for intermediate formation by pinning it into a condensed coarsely native-like topology; (b) smaller search-dependent barriers that put the secondary structural units into place; and (c) optional error-dependent misfold-reorganization barriers that can cause slow folding, intermediate accumulation, and folding heterogeneity. These conclusions provide a coherent explanation for the grossly disparate folding behavior of different globular proteins in terms of distinct folding pathways.

An amino acid code for protein folding

Direct structural information obtained for many proteins supports the following conclusions. The amino acid sequences of proteins can stabilize not only the final native state but also a small set of discrete partially folded native-like intermediates. Intermediates are formed in steps that use as units the cooperative secondary structural elements of the native protein. Earlier intermediates guide the addition of subsequent units in a process of sequential stabilization mediated by native-like tertiary interactions. The resulting stepwise self-assembly process automatically constructs a folding pathway, whether linear or branched. These conclusions are drawn mainly from hydrogen exchange-based methods, which can depict the structure of infinitesimally populated folding intermediates at equilibrium and kinetic intermediates with subsecond lifetimes. Other kinetic studies show that the polypeptide chain enters the folding pathway after an initial free-energy-uphill conformational search. The search culminates by finding a native-like topology that can support forward (native-like) folding in a free-energy-downhill manner. This condition automatically defines an initial transition state, the search for which sets the maximum possible (two-state) folding rate. It also extends the sequential stabilization strategy, which depends on a native-like context, to the first step in the folding process. Thus the native structure naturally generates its own folding pathway. The same amino acid code that translates into the final equilibrium native structure-by virtue of propensities, patterning, secondary structural cueing, and tertiary context-also produces its kinetic accessibility.

Folding kinetics of phage 434 Cro protein

Folding kinetics for phage 434 Cro protein are examined and compared with those reported for lambda(6-85), the N-terminal domain of the repressor of phage lambda. The two proteins have similar all-helical structures consisting of five helices but different stabilities. In contrast to lambda(6-85), sharp and distinct aromatic (1)H NMR signals without exchange broadening characterize the native and urea-denatured 434 Cro forms at equilibrium at 20 degrees C, indicating slow interconversion on the NMR time scale. Stopped-flow fluorescence data using the single 434 Cro tryptophan indicate strongly urea-dependent refolding rates and smaller urea dependencies of the unfolding rates, suggesting a native-like transition state ensemble. Refolding rates are slower and unfolding rates considerably faster at pH 4 than at pH 6. This accounts for the lower stability of 434 Cro at pH 4 and suggests the existence of pH-dependent, possibly salt bridge interactions that are more stabilizing at pH 6. At <2 M urea, decreased folding amplitudes and nonlinear urea dependencies that are apparent at pH 6 indicate deviation from two-state behavior and suggest the formation of an early folding intermediate. The folding behavior of 434 Cro and why it folds 2 orders of magnitude slower than lambda(6-85) are rationalized in terms of the lower intrinsic helix stabilities and putative charge interactions in 434 Cro.

Kinetic evidence of an on-pathway intermediate in the folding of lysozyme

By means of a kinetic test, it was demonstrated that one of the folding intermediates (Ialpha) of hen lysozyme with alpha-domain folded and beta-domain unfolded is on the folding pathway under the classical definition. Ialpha folds to the native (N) state directly (unfolded (U) <==> Ialpha <==> N) without having to unfold to U and then refold to N through alternative folding pathways as in Ialpha <==> U <==> N.

Salt-induced detour through compact regions of the protein folding landscape

In several cases, inorganic salts have been used to induce partly structured states in protein folding. But what is the nature of these states: Do they represent key stepping stones in the folding process, or are they circumstantial pitfalls in the energy landscape? Here we report that, in the case of the two-state protein S6, the salt-induced collapsed state is off the usual folding routes in the sense that it is prematurely collapsed and slows down folding by several orders of magnitude. Although this species is over-compact, it is not a dead-end trap but may fold by alternative channels to the native state.

Kinetic evidence for an on-pathway intermediate in the folding of cytochrome c

An early folding event of cytochrome c populates a helix-containing intermediate (INC) because of a pH-dependent misligation between the heme iron and nonnative ligands in the unfolded state (U). For folding to proceed, the nonnative ligation error must first be corrected. It is not known whether I is on-pathway, with folding to the native state (N) as in U <-->INC <--> N, or whether the I must first move back through the U and then fold to the N through some alternative path (INC <--> U <--> N). By means of a kinetic test, it is shown here that the cytochrome c I does not first unfold to U. The method used provides an experimental criterion for rejecting the off-pathway I <--> U <--> N option.