A deadly game of musical chairs: survival of cells transplanted for myocardial repair

Cardiac remodeling and failure: from molecules to man (Part III)

Given the lack of a unified theory of heart failure, future research efforts will be required to unify and synthesize our current understanding of the multiple mechanisms that control remodeling in the failing heart. Matrix remodeling and the associated activation of inflammatory cytokines and MMPs have emerged as key pathways in the development of heart failure. As such, attempts to understand the integrated control of ECM homeostasis with the bioactivation of inflammatory cytokines may be of particular relevance to the development of effective anti-remodeling approaches. Notably, the implantation of isolated populations of cells in failing myocardium has a profound and consistent anti-remodeling effect that limits the progression to CHF. These observations were consistently identified in numerous studies using diverse experimental animal models and varied cell types. Accordingly, multicenter clinical trials are underway, and the preliminary data in patients with CHF are encouraging. Despite the enormous promise of cell transplantation to restore and regenerate failing myocardium, the mechanisms underlying these profound biological effects are not understood. An improved understanding of the myocardial response to cell implantation, particularly on parameters of matrix remodeling, may help unify our current understanding of the progression of heart failure and optimize the development of this technique for its evolving therapeutic use. The following review outlines recent advances in medical and surgical approaches to control the remodeling process that underlies the progression of heart failure.

Engineering skeletal myoblasts: roles of three-dimensional culture and electrical stimulation

Immature skeletal muscle cells, or myoblasts, have been used in cellular cardiomyoplasty in attempts to regenerate cardiac muscle tissue by injection of cells into damaged myocardium. In some studies, muscle tissue within myoblast implant sites may be morphologically similar to cardiac muscle. We hypothesized that identifiable aspects of the cardiac milieu may contribute to growth and development of implanted myoblasts in vivo. To test this hypothesis, we designed a novel in vitro system to mimic some aspects of the electrical and biochemical environment of native myocardium. This system enabled us to separate the three-dimensional (3-D) electrical and biochemical signals that may be involved in myoblast proliferation and plasticity. Myoblasts were grown on 3-D polyglycolic acid mesh scaffolds under control conditions, in the presence of cardiac-like electrical current fluxes, or in the presence of culture medium that had been conditioned by mature cardiomyocytes. Cardiac-like electrical current fluxes caused increased myoblast number in 3-D culture, as determined by DNA assay. The increase in cell number was due to increased cellular proliferation and not differences in apoptosis, as determined by proliferating cell nuclear antigen and TdT-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling. Cardiomyocyte-conditioned medium also significantly increased myoblast proliferation. Expression of transcription factors governing differentiation along skeletal or cardiac lineages was evaluated by immunoblotting. Although these assays are qualitative, no changes in differentiation state along skeletal or cardiac lineages were observed in response to electrical current fluxes. Furthermore, from these experiments, conditioned medium did not appear to alter the differentiation state of skeletal myoblasts. Hence, cardiac milieu appears to stimulate proliferation but does not affect differentiation of skeletal myoblasts.

Development of abnormal tissue architecture in transplanted neonatal rat myocytes

BACKGROUND

Most myocardial cell transplant studies focus on demonstration of improved function; however, such improvement depends on the development of appropriate tissue structure. Thus, our aim was to assess the architectural changes that occurred after cell transplant into normal and infarcted myocardium.

METHODS

Male neonatal cells (1 to 2 days old) were injected into the left ventricular free wall of adult female rats. The tissue was examined 0 to 1 days and 1 to 2, 4 to 6, and 12 weeks later in noninfarcted hearts and 6 months after transplant into infarcts. In histologic sections, we assessed the cells' retardation of polarized light (to measure development of contractile elements), two-dimensional cell orientation, cell nuclear morphology, and collagen content.

RESULTS

The transplant cells' retardation of polarized light gradually increased to 81% of that of host cells after 6 months (p < 0.001). The transplant cells were disorganized and although their nuclei increased in size, they always had a rounded appearance. Collagen content in the transplant was 210% to 430% higher than in host tissue (p < 0.01). In addition, scar collagen always separated transplant and host cells.

CONCLUSIONS

One architectural feature, the rounded nuclei, provided a distinctive marker to identify transplanted cells. Nevertheless, the transplants' inhibited muscle development together with disorganization, separation from the host muscle, and a substantial increase in collagen resulted in a structure unlikely to play an active role in systolic function.

The role of stem cells in skeletal and cardiac muscle repair

In postnatal muscle, skeletal muscle precursors (myoblasts) can be derived from satellite cells (reserve cells located on the surface of mature myofibers) or from cells lying beyond the myofiber, e.g., interstitial connective tissue or bone marrow. Both of these classes of cells may have stem cell properties. In addition, the heretical idea that post-mitotic myonuclei lying within mature myofibers might be able to re-form myoblasts or stem cells is examined and related to recent observations for similar post-mitotic cardiomyocytes. In adult hearts (which previously were not considered capable of repair), the role of replicating endogenous cardiomyocytes and the recruitment of other (stem) cells into cardiomyocytes for new cardiac muscle formation has recently attracted much attention. The relative contribution of these various sources of precursor cells in postnatal muscles and the factors that may enhance stem cell participation in the formation of new skeletal and cardiac muscle in vivo are the focus of this review. We concluded that, although many endogenous cell types can be converted to skeletal muscle, the contribution of non-myogenic cells to the formation of new postnatal skeletal muscle in vivo appears to be negligible. Whether the recruitment of such cells to the myogenic lineage can be significantly enhanced by specific inducers and the appropriate microenvironment is a current topic of intense interest. However, dermal fibroblasts appear promising as a realistic alternative source of exogenous myoblasts for transplantation purposes. For heart muscle, experiments showing the participation of bone marrow-derived stem cells and endothelial cells in the repair of damaged cardiac muscle are encouraging.