Carbon relaxation in randomly fractionally 13C-enriched proteins

13 Cβ-Valine and 13 Cγ-Leucine Methine Labeling To Probe Protein Ligand Interaction

Precise information regarding the interaction between proteins and ligands at molecular resolution is crucial for effectively guiding the optimization process from initial hits to lead compounds in early stages of drug development. In this study, we introduce a novel aliphatic side chain isotope-labeling scheme to directly probe interactions between ligands and aliphatic sidechains using NMR techniques. To demonstrate the applicability of this method, we selected a set of Brd4-BD1 binders and analyzed 1 H chemical shift perturbation resulting from CH-π interaction of Hβ -Val and Hγ -Leu as CH donors with corresponding ligand aromatic moieties as π acceptors.

Late metabolic precursors for selective aromatic residue labeling

In recent years, we developed a toolbox of heavy isotope containing compounds, which serve as metabolic amino acid precursors in the E. coli-based overexpression of aromatic residue labeled proteins. Our labeling techniques show excellent results both in terms of selectivity and isotope incorporation levels. They are additionally distinguished by low sample production costs and meet the economic demands to further implement protein NMR spectroscopy as a routinely used method in drug development processes. Different isotopologues allow for the assembly of optimized protein samples, which fulfill the requirements of various NMR experiments to elucidate protein structures, analyze conformational dynamics, or probe interaction surfaces. In the present article, we want to summarize the precursors we developed so far and give examples of their special value in the probing of protein-ligand interaction.

Measuring Entropy in Molecular Recognition by Proteins

Molecular recognition by proteins is fundamental to the molecular basis of biology. Dissection of the thermodynamic landscape governing protein-ligand interactions has proven difficult because determination of various entropic contributions is quite challenging. Nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation measurements, theory, and simulations suggest that conformational entropy can be accessed through a dynamical proxy. Here, we review the relationship between measures of fast side-chain motion and the underlying conformational entropy. The dynamical proxy reveals that the contribution of conformational entropy can range from highly favorable to highly unfavorable and demonstrates the potential of this key thermodynamic variable to modulate protein-ligand interactions. The dynamical so-called entropy meter also refines the role of solvent entropy and directly determines the loss in rotational-translational entropy that occurs upon formation of high-affinity complexes. The ability to quantify the roles of entropy through an entropy meter based on measurable dynamical properties promises to highlight its role in protein function.

Anthranilic acid, the new player in the ensemble of aromatic residue labeling precursor compounds

The application of metabolic precursors for selective stable isotope labeling of aromatic residues in cell-based protein overexpression has already resulted in numerous NMR probes to study the structural and dynamic characteristics of proteins. With anthranilic acid, we present the structurally simplest precursor for exclusive tryptophan side chain labeling. A synthetic route to ¹³C, ²H isotopologues allows the installation of isolated ¹³C-¹H spin systems in the indole ring of tryptophan, representing a versatile tool to investigate side chain motion using relaxation-based experiments without the loss of magnetization due to strong ¹J_CC and weaker ²J_CH scalar couplings, as well as dipolar interactions with remote hydrogens. In this article, we want to introduce this novel precursor in the context of hitherto existing techniques of in vivo aromatic residue labeling.

Bacterial production of site specific 13C labeled phenylalanine and methodology for high level incorporation into bacterially expressed recombinant proteins

Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy studies of ever larger systems have benefited from many different forms of isotope labeling, in particular, site specific isotopic labeling. Site specific ¹³C labeling of methyl groups has become an established means of probing systems not amenable to traditional methodology. However useful, methyl reporter sites can be limited in number and/or location. Therefore, new complementary site specific isotope labeling strategies are valuable. Aromatic amino acids make excellent probes since they are often found at important interaction interfaces and play significant structural roles. Aromatic side chains have many of the same advantages as methyl containing amino acids including distinct ¹³C chemical shifts and multiple magnetically equivalent ¹H positions. Herein we report economical bacterial production and one-step purification of phenylalanine with ¹³C incorporation at the Cα, Cγ and Cε positions, resulting in two isolated ¹H-¹³C spin systems. We also present methodology to maximize incorporation of phenylalanine into recombinantly overexpressed proteins in bacteria and demonstrate compatibility with ILV-methyl labeling. Inexpensive, site specific isotope labeled phenylalanine adds another dimension to biomolecular NMR, opening new avenues of study.

NMR Methods to Study Dynamic Allostery

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy provides a unique toolbox of experimental probes for studying dynamic processes on a wide range of timescales, ranging from picoseconds to milliseconds and beyond. Along with NMR hardware developments, recent methodological advancements have enabled the characterization of allosteric proteins at unprecedented detail, revealing intriguing aspects of allosteric mechanisms and increasing the proportion of the conformational ensemble that can be observed by experiment. Here, we present an overview of NMR spectroscopic methods for characterizing equilibrium fluctuations in free and bound states of allosteric proteins that have been most influential in the field. By combining NMR experimental approaches with molecular simulations, atomistic-level descriptions of the mechanisms by which allosteric phenomena take place are now within reach.

A 13C labeling strategy reveals a range of aromatic side chain motion in calmodulin

NMR relaxation experiments often require site-specific isotopic enrichment schemes in order to allow for quantitative interpretation. Here we describe a new labeling scheme for site-specific (13)C-(1)H enrichment of a single ortho position of aromatic amino acid side chains in an otherwise perdeuterated background by employing a combination of [4-(13)C]erythrose and deuterated pyruvate during growth on deuterium oxide. This labeling scheme largely eliminates undesired contributions to (13)C relaxation and greatly simplifies the fitting of relaxation data using the Lipari-Szabo model-free formalism. This approach is illustrated with calcium-saturated vertebrate calmodulin and oxidized flavodoxin from Cyanobacterium anabaena . Analysis of (13)C relaxation in the aromatic groups of calcium-saturated calmodulin indicates a wide range of motion in the subnanosecond time regime.

Isotope labeling methods for relaxation measurements

Nuclear magnetic spin relaxation has emerged as a powerful technique for probing molecular dynamics. Not only is it possible to use it for determination of time constant(s) for molecular reorientation but it can also be used to characterize internal motions on time scales from picoseconds to seconds. Traditionally, uniformly (15)N labeled samples have been used for these experiments but it is clear that this limits the applications. For instance, sensitivity for large systems is dramatically increased if dynamics is probed at methyl groups and structural characterization of low-populated states requires measurements on (13)Cα, (13)Cβ or (13)CO or (1)Hα. Unfortunately, homonuclear scalar couplings may lead to artifacts in the latter types of experiments and selective isotopic labeling schemes that only label the desired position are necessary. Both selective and uniform labeling schemes for measurements of relaxation rates for a large number of positions in proteins are discussed in this chapter.

A surprising role for conformational entropy in protein function

Formation of high-affinity complexes is critical for the majority of enzymatic reactions involving proteins. The creation of the family of Michaelis and other intermediate complexes during catalysis clearly involves a complicated manifold of interactions that are diverse and complex. Indeed, computing the energetics of interactions between proteins and small molecule ligands using molecular structure alone remains a great challenge. One of the most difficult contributions to the free energy of protein-ligand complexes to access experimentally is that due to changes in protein conformational entropy. Fortunately, recent advances in solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxation methods have enabled the use of measures-of-motion between conformational states of a protein as a proxy for conformational entropy. This review briefly summarizes the experimental approaches currently employed to characterize fast internal motion in proteins, how this information is used to gain insight into conformational entropy, what has been learned, and what the future may hold for this emerging view of protein function.

Isotope labeling for solution and solid-state NMR spectroscopy of membrane proteins

In this chapter, we summarize the isotopic labeling strategies used to obtain high-quality solution and solid-state NMR spectra of biological samples, with emphasis on integral membrane proteins (IMPs). While solution NMR is used to study IMPs under fast tumbling conditions, such as in the presence of detergent micelles or isotropic bicelles, solid-state NMR is used to study the structure and orientation of IMPs in lipid vesicles and bilayers. In spite of the tremendous progress in biomolecular NMR spectroscopy, the homogeneity and overall quality of the sample is still a substantial obstacle to overcome. Isotopic labeling is a major avenue to simplify overlapped spectra by either diluting the NMR active nuclei or allowing the resonances to be separated in multiple dimensions. In the following we will discuss isotopic labeling approaches that have been successfully used in the study of IMPs by solution and solid-state NMR spectroscopy.

Protein dynamics and conformational disorder in molecular recognition

Recognition requires protein flexibility because it facilitates conformational rearrangements and induced-fit mechanisms upon target binding. Intrinsic disorder is an extreme on the continuous spectrum of possible protein dynamics and its role in recognition may seem counterintuitive. However, conformational disorder is widely found in many eukaryotic regulatory proteins involved in processes such as signal transduction and transcription. Disordered protein regions may in fact confer advantages over folded proteins in binding. Rapidly interconverting and diverse conformers may create mean electrostatic fields instead of presenting discrete charges. The resultant "polyelectrostatic" interactions allow for the utilization of post-translational modifications as a means to change the net charge and thereby modify the electrostatic interaction of a disordered region. Plasticity of disordered protein states enables steric advantages over folded proteins and allows for unique binding configurations. Disorder may also have evolutionary advantages, as it facilitates alternative splicing, domain shuffling and protein modularity. As proteins exist in a continuous spectrum of disorder, so do their complexes. Indeed, disordered regions in complexes may control the degree of motion between domains, mask binding sites, be targets of post-translational modifications, permit overlapping binding motifs, and enable transient binding of different binding partners, making them excellent candidates for signal integrators and explaining their prevalence in eukaryotic signaling pathways. "Dynamic" complexes arise if more than two transient protein interfaces are involved in complex formation of two binding partners in a dynamic equilibrium. "Disordered" complexes, in contrast, do not involve significant ordering of interacting protein segments but rely exclusively on transient contacts. The nature of these interactions is not well understood yet but advancements in the structural characterization of disordered states will help us gain insights into their function and their implications for health and disease.

Protein proton-proton dynamics from amide proton spin flip rates

Residue-specific amide proton spin-flip rates K were measured for peptide-free and peptide-bound calmodulin. K approximates the sum of NOE build-up rates between the amide proton and all other protons. This work outlines the theory of multi-proton relaxation, cross relaxation and cross correlation, and how to approximate it with a simple model based on a variable number of equidistant protons. This model is used to extract the sums of K-rates from the experimental data. Error in K is estimated using bootstrap methodology. We define a parameter Q as the ratio of experimental K-rates to theoretical K-rates, where the theoretical K-rates are computed from atomic coordinates. Q is 1 in the case of no local motion, but decreases to values as low as 0.5 with increasing domination of sidechain protons of the same residue to the amide proton flips. This establishes Q as a monotonous measure of local dynamics of the proton network surrounding the amide protons. The method is applied to the study of proton dynamics in Ca(2+)-saturated calmodulin, both free in solution and bound to smMLCK peptide. The mean Q is 0.81 +/- 0.02 for free calmodulin and 0.88 +/- 0.02 for peptide-bound calmodulin. This novel methodology thus reveals the presence of significant interproton disorder in this protein, while the increase in Q indicates rigidification of the proton network upon peptide binding, confirming the known high entropic cost of this process.

Measuring 13Cbeta chemical shifts of invisible excited states in proteins by relaxation dispersion NMR spectroscopy

A labeling scheme is introduced that facilitates the measurement of accurate (13)C(beta) chemical shifts of invisible, excited states of proteins by relaxation dispersion NMR spectroscopy. The approach makes use of protein over-expression in a strain of E. coli in which the TCA cycle enzyme succinate dehydrogenase is knocked out, leading to the production of samples with high levels of (13)C enrichment (30-40%) at C(beta) side-chain carbon positions for 15 of the amino acids with little (13)C label at positions one bond removed (approximately 5%). A pair of samples are produced using [1-(13)C]-glucose/NaH(12)CO(3) or [2-(13)C]-glucose as carbon sources with isolated and enriched (>30%) (13)C(beta) positions for 11 and 4 residues, respectively. The efficacy of the labeling procedure is established by NMR spectroscopy. The utility of such samples for measurement of (13)C(beta) chemical shifts of invisible, excited states in exchange with visible, ground conformations is confirmed by relaxation dispersion studies of a protein-ligand binding exchange reaction in which the extracted chemical shift differences from dispersion profiles compare favorably with those obtained directly from measurements on ligand free and fully bound protein samples.

Measurement of carbonyl chemical shifts of excited protein states by relaxation dispersion NMR spectroscopy: comparison between uniformly and selectively (13)C labeled samples

Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) relaxation dispersion nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has emerged as a powerful method for quantifying chemical shifts of excited protein states. For many applications of the technique that involve the measurement of relaxation rates of carbon magnetization it is necessary to prepare samples with isolated (13)C spins so that experiments do not suffer from magnetization transfer between coupled carbon spins that would otherwise occur during the CPMG pulse train. In the case of (13)CO experiments however the large separation between (13)CO and (13)C(alpha) chemical shifts offers hope that robust (13)CO dispersion profiles can be recorded on uniformly (13)C labeled samples, leading to the extraction of accurate (13)CO chemical shifts of the invisible, excited state. Here we compare such chemical shifts recorded on samples that are selectively labeled, prepared using [1-(13)C]-pyruvate and NaH(13)CO(3,) or uniformly labeled, generated from (13)C-glucose. Very similar (13)CO chemical shifts are obtained from analysis of CPMG experiments recorded on both samples, and comparison with chemical shifts measured using a second approach establishes that the shifts measured from relaxation dispersion are very accurate.

Fractional 13C enrichment of isolated carbons using [1-13C]- or [2- 13C]-glucose facilitates the accurate measurement of dynamics at backbone Calpha and side-chain methyl positions in proteins

A simple labeling approach is presented based on protein expression in [1-(13)C]- or [2-(13)C]-glucose containing media that produces molecules enriched at methyl carbon positions or backbone C(alpha) sites, respectively. All of the methyl groups, with the exception of Thr and Ile(delta1) are produced with isolated (13)C spins (i.e., no (13)C-(13)C one bond couplings), facilitating studies of dynamics through the use of spin-spin relaxation experiments without artifacts introduced by evolution due to large homonuclear scalar couplings. Carbon-alpha sites are labeled without concomitant labeling at C(beta) positions for 17 of the common 20 amino acids and there are no cases for which (13)C(alpha)-(13)CO spin pairs are observed. A large number of probes are thus available for the study of protein dynamics with the results obtained complimenting those from more traditional backbone (15)N studies. The utility of the labeling is established by recording (13)C R (1rho) and CPMG-based experiments on a number of different protein systems.

Triple resonance experiments for aligned sample solid-state NMR of (13)C and (15)N labeled proteins

Initial steps in the development of a suite of triple-resonance (1)H/(13)C/(15)N solid-state NMR experiments applicable to aligned samples of (13)C and (15)N labeled proteins are described. The experiments take advantage of the opportunities for (13)C detection without the need for homonuclear (13)C/(13)C decoupling presented by samples with two different patterns of isotopic labeling. In one type of sample, the proteins are approximately 20% randomly labeled with (13)C in all backbone and side chain carbon sites and approximately 100% uniformly (15)N labeled in all nitrogen sites; in the second type of sample, the peptides and proteins are (13)C labeled at only the alpha-carbon and (15)N labeled at the amide nitrogen of a few residues. The requirement for homonuclear (13)C/(13)C decoupling while detecting (13)C signals is avoided in the first case because of the low probability of any two (13)C nuclei being bonded to each other; in the second case, the labeled (13)C(alpha) sites are separated by at least three bonds in the polypeptide chain. The experiments enable the measurement of the (13)C chemical shift and (1)H-(13)C and (15)N-(13)C heteronuclear dipolar coupling frequencies associated with the (13)C(alpha) and (13)C' backbone sites, which provide orientation constraints complementary to those derived from the (15)N labeled amide backbone sites. (13)C/(13)C spin-exchange experiments identify proximate carbon sites. The ability to measure (13)C-(15)N dipolar coupling frequencies and correlate (13)C and (15)N resonances provides a mechanism for making backbone resonance assignments. Three-dimensional combinations of these experiments ensure that the resolution, assignment, and measurement of orientationally dependent frequencies can be extended to larger proteins. Moreover, measurements of the (13)C chemical shift and (1)H-(13)C heteronuclear dipolar coupling frequencies for nearly all side chain sites enable the complete three-dimensional structures of proteins to be determined with this approach.

Partial 13C isotopic enrichment of nucleoside monophosphates: useful reporters for NMR structural studies

Analysis of the ¹³C isotopic labeling patterns of nucleoside monophosphates (NMPs) extracted from Escherichia coli grown in a mixture of C-1 and C-2 glucose is presented. By comparing our results to previous observations on amino acids grown in similar media, we have been able to rationalize the labeling pattern based on the well-known biochemistry of nucleotide biosynthesis. Except for a few notable absences of label (C4 in purines and C3′ in ribose) and one highly enriched site (C1′ in ribose), most carbons are randomly enriched at a low level (an average of 13%). These sparsely labeled NMPs give less complex NMR spectra than their fully isotopically labeled analogs due to the elimination of most ¹³C–¹³C scalar couplings. The spectral simplicity is particularly advantageous when working in ordered systems, as illustrated with guanosine diphosphate (GDP) bound to ADP ribosylation factor 1 (ARF1) aligned in a liquid crystalline medium. In this system, the absence of scalar couplings and additional long-range dipolar couplings significantly enhances signal to noise and resolution.

Nmr probes of molecular dynamics: overview and comparison with other techniques

NMR spin relaxation spectroscopy is a powerful approach for characterizing intramolecular and overall rotational motions in proteins. This review describes experimental methods for measuring laboratory frame spin relaxation rate constants by high-resolution solution-state NMR spectroscopy, together with theoretical approaches for interpreting spin relaxation data in order to quantify protein conformational dynamics on picosecond-nanosecond time scales. Recent applications of these techniques to proteins are surveyed, and investigations of the contribution of conformational chain entropy to protein function are highlighted. Insights into the dynamical properties of proteins obtained from NMR spin relaxation spectroscopy are compared with results derived from other experimental and theoretical techniques.

Determination of multiple ***φ***-torsion angles in proteins by selective and extensive (13)C labeling and two-dimensional solid-state NMR

We describe an approach to efficiently determine the backbone conformation of solid proteins that utilizes selective and extensive (13)C labeling in conjunction with two-dimensional magic-angle-spinning NMR. The selective (13)C labeling approach aims to reduce line broadening and other multispin complications encountered in solid-state NMR of uniformly labeled proteins while still enhancing the sensitivity of NMR spectra. It is achieved by using specifically labeled glucose or glycerol as the sole carbon source in the protein expression medium. For amino acids synthesized in the linear part of the biosynthetic pathways, [1-(13)C]glucose preferentially labels the ends of the side chains, while [2-(13)C]glycerol labels the C(alpha) of these residues. Amino acids produced from the citric-acid cycle are labeled in a more complex manner. Information on the secondary structure of such a labeled protein was obtained by measuring multiple backbone torsion angles phi; simultaneously, using an isotropic-anisotropic 2D correlation technique, the HNCH experiment. Initial experiments for resonance assignment of a selectively (13)C labeled protein were performed using (15)N-(13)C 2D correlation spectroscopy. From the time dependence of the (15)N-(13)C dipolar coherence transfer, both intraresidue and interresidue connectivities can be observed, thus yielding partial sequential assignment. We demonstrate the selective (13)C labeling and these 2D NMR experiments on a 8.5-kDa model protein, ubiquitin. This isotope-edited NMR approach is expected to facilitate the structure determination of proteins in the solid state.

Insights into the local residual entropy of proteins provided by NMR relaxation

A simple model is used to illustrate the relationship between the dynamics measured by NMR relaxation methods and the local residual entropy of proteins. The expected local dynamic behavior of well-packed extended amino acid side chains are described by employing a one-dimensional vibrator that encapsulates both the spatial and temporal character of the motion. This model is then related to entropy and to the generalized order parameter of the popular "model-free" treatment often used in the analysis of NMR relaxation data. Simulations indicate that order parameters observed for the methyl symmetry axes in, for example, human ubiquitin correspond to significant local entropies. These observations have obvious significance for the issue of the physical basis of protein structure, dynamics, and stability.

Protein complexes studied by NMR spectroscopy

Recent advances in NMR methods now allow protein complexes to be studied in great detail in a wide range of solution conditions. Isotope-enrichment strategies, resonance-assignment approaches and structural-determination methods have evolved to the point where almost any type of complex involving proteins of reasonable size may be studied in a straightforward way. A variety of isotope editing and filtering strategies underlie these powerful methodologies. Approaches to the characterization of the dynamics of protein complexes have also matured to the point where detailed studies of the effects of complexation on dynamics can be studied over a wide range of timescales.