Isolation of high-affinity RNA ligands to HIV-1 integrase from a random pool

Multimodal Functionalities of HIV-1 Integrase

Integrase is the retroviral protein responsible for integrating reverse transcripts into cellular genomes. Co-packaged with viral RNA and reverse transcriptase into capsid-encased viral cores, human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1) integrase has long been implicated in reverse transcription and virion maturation. However, the underlying mechanisms of integrase in these non-catalytic-related viral replication steps have remained elusive. Recent results have shown that integrase binds genomic RNA in virions, and that mutational or pharmacological disruption of integrase-RNA binding yields eccentric virion particles with ribonucleoprotein complexes situated outside of the capsid shell. Such viruses are defective for reverse transcription due to preferential loss of integrase and viral RNA from infected target cells. Parallel research has revealed defective integrase-RNA binding and eccentric particle formation as common features of class II integrase mutant viruses, a phenotypic grouping of viruses that display defects at steps beyond integration. In light of these new findings, we propose three new subclasses of class II mutant viruses (a, b, and c), all of which are defective for integrase-RNA binding and particle morphogenesis, but differ based on distinct underlying mechanisms exhibited by the associated integrase mutant proteins. We also assess how these findings inform the role of integrase in HIV-1 particle maturation.

Selection of 2'-Deoxy-2'-Fluoroarabino Nucleic Acid (FANA) Aptamers That Bind HIV-1 Integrase with Picomolar Affinity

Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment (SELEX) is the iterative process by which nucleic acids that can bind with high affinity and specificity (termed aptamers) to specific protein targets are selected. Using a SELEX protocol adapted for Xeno-Nucleic Acid (XNA) as a suitable substrate for aptamer generation, 2′-fluoroarabinonucleic acid (FANA) was used to select several related aptamers to HIV-1 integrase (IN). IN bound FANA aptamers with equilibrium dissociation constants (K_D,app) of ∼50–100 pM in a buffer with 200 mM NaCl and 6 mM MgCl₂. Comparisons to published HIV-1 IN RNA and DNA aptamers as well as IN genomic binding partners indicated that FANA aptamers bound more than 2 orders of magnitude more tightly to IN. Using a combination of RNA folding algorithms and covariation analysis, all strong binding aptamers demonstrated a common four-way junction structure, despite significant sequence variation. IN aptamers were selected from the same starting library as FA1, a FANA aptamer that binds with pM affinity to HIV-1 Reverse Transcriptase (RT). It contains a 20-nucleotide 5′ DNA sequence followed by 59 FANA nucleotides. IN-1.1 (one of the selected aptamers) potently inhibited IN activity and intasome formation in vitro. Replacing the FANA nucleotides of IN-1.1 with 2′-fluororibonucleic acid (F-RNA), which has the same chemical formula but with a ribose rather than arabinose sugar conformation, dramatically reduced binding, suggesting that FANA adopts unique structural conformations that promote binding to HIV-1 IN.

Artificially Expanded Genetic Information Systems for New Aptamer Technologies

Directed evolution was first applied to diverse libraries of DNA and RNA molecules a quarter century ago in the hope of gaining technology that would allow the creation of receptors, ligands, and catalysts on demand. Despite isolated successes, the outputs of this technology have been somewhat disappointing, perhaps because the four building blocks of standard DNA and RNA have too little functionality to have versatile binding properties, and offer too little information density to fold unambiguously. This review covers the recent literature that seeks to create an improved platform to support laboratory Darwinism, one based on an artificially expanded genetic information system (AEGIS) that adds independently replicating nucleotide “letters” to the evolving “alphabet”.

CLIP-related methodologies and their application to retrovirology

Virtually every step of HIV-1 replication and numerous cellular antiviral defense mechanisms are regulated by the binding of a viral or cellular RNA-binding protein (RBP) to distinct sequence or structural elements on HIV-1 RNAs. Until recently, these protein-RNA interactions were studied largely by in vitro binding assays complemented with genetics approaches. However, these methods are highly limited in the identification of the relevant targets of RBPs in physiologically relevant settings. Development of crosslinking-immunoprecipitation sequencing (CLIP) methodology has revolutionized the analysis of protein-nucleic acid complexes. CLIP combines immunoprecipitation of covalently crosslinked protein-RNA complexes with high-throughput sequencing, providing a global account of RNA sequences bound by a RBP of interest in cells (or virions) at near-nucleotide resolution. Numerous variants of the CLIP protocol have recently been developed, some with major improvements over the original. Herein, we briefly review these methodologies and give examples of how CLIP has been successfully applied to retrovirology research.

HIV-1 Integrase Binds the Viral RNA Genome and Is Essential during Virion Morphogenesis

While an essential role of HIV-1 integrase (IN) for integration of viral cDNA into human chromosome is established, studies with IN mutants and allosteric IN inhibitors (ALLINIs) have suggested that IN can also influence viral particle maturation. However, it has remained enigmatic as to how IN contributes to virion morphogenesis. Here, we demonstrate that IN directly binds the viral RNA genome in virions. These interactions have specificity, as IN exhibits distinct preference for select viral RNA structural elements. We show that IN substitutions that selectively impair its binding to viral RNA result in eccentric, non-infectious virions without affecting nucleocapsid-RNA interactions. Likewise, ALLINIs impair IN binding to viral RNA in virions of wild-type, but not escape mutant, virus. These results reveal an unexpected biological role of IN binding to the viral RNA genome during virion morphogenesis and elucidate the mode of action of ALLINIs.

Distribution and Redistribution of HIV-1 Nucleocapsid Protein in Immature, Mature, and Integrase-Inhibited Virions: a Role for Integrase in Maturation

During virion maturation, HIV-1 capsid protein assembles into a conical core containing the viral ribonucleoprotein (vRNP) complex, thought to be composed mainly of the viral RNA and nucleocapsid protein (NC). After infection, the viral RNA is reverse transcribed into double-stranded DNA, which is then incorporated into host chromosomes by integrase (IN) catalysis. Certain IN mutations (class II) and antiviral drugs (allosteric IN inhibitors [ALLINIs]) adversely affect maturation, resulting in virions that contain "eccentric condensates," electron-dense aggregates located outside seemingly empty capsids. Here we demonstrate that in addition to this mislocalization of electron density, a class II IN mutation and ALLINIs each increase the fraction of virions with malformed capsids (from ∼ 12% to ∼ 53%). Eccentric condensates have a high NC content, as demonstrated by "tomo-bubblegram" imaging, a novel labeling technique that exploits the susceptibility of NC to radiation damage. Tomo-bubblegrams also localized NC inside wild-type cores and lining the spherical Gag shell in immature virions. We conclude that eccentric condensates represent nonpackaged vRNPs and that either genetic or pharmacological inhibition of IN can impair vRNP incorporation into mature cores. Supplying IN in trans as part of a Vpr-IN fusion protein partially restored the formation of conical cores with internal electron density and the infectivity of a class II IN deletion mutant virus. Moreover, the ability of ALLINIs to induce eccentric condensate formation required both IN and viral RNA. Based on these observations, we propose a role for IN in initiating core morphogenesis and vRNP incorporation into the mature core during HIV-1 maturation.

IMPORTANCE

Maturation, a process essential for HIV-1 infectivity, involves core assembly, whereby the viral ribonucleoprotein (vRNP, composed of vRNA and nucleocapsid protein [NC]) is packaged into a conical capsid. Allosteric integrase inhibitors (ALLINIs) affect multiple viral processes. We have characterized ALLINIs and integrase mutants that have the same phenotype. First, by comparing the effects of ALLINIs on several steps of the viral cycle, we show that inhibition of maturation accounts for compound potency. Second, by using cryoelectron tomography, we find that ALLINIs impair conical capsid assembly. Third, by developing tomo-bubblegram imaging, which specifically labels NC protein, we find that ALLINIs block vRNP packaging; instead, vRNPs form "eccentric condensates" outside the core. Fourth, malformed cores, typical of integrase-deleted virus, are partially replaced by conical cores when integrase is supplied in trans. Fifth, vRNA is necessary for ALLINI-induced eccentric condensate formation. These observations suggest that integrase is involved in capsid morphogenesis and vRNP packaging.

High-affinity RNA Aptamers Against the HIV-1 Protease Inhibit Both In Vitro Protease Activity and Late Events of Viral Replication

HIV-1 aspartyl protease (PR) plays a key role in virion morphogenesis, underscoring the effectiveness of protease inhibitors (PI). Despite their utility, side effects and drug-resistance remains a problem. We report the development of RNA aptamers as inhibitors of HIV-1 PR for potential use in anti-HIV gene therapy. Employing Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment (SELEX), we isolated four unique families of anti-HIV-1 PR RNA aptamers displaying moderate binding affinities (K_d = 92–140 nmol/l) and anti-PR inhibitory activity (K_is = 138–647 nmol/l). Second-generation RNA aptamers selected from partially randomized pools based on two of the aptamer sequences displayed striking enhancements in binding (K_ds = 2–22 nmol/l) and inhibition (K_is = 31–49 nmol/l). The aptamers were specific in that they did not bind either the related HIV-2 protease, or the cellular aspartyl protease, Cathepsin D. Site-directed mutagenesis of a second-generation aptamer to probe the predicted secondary structure indicated that the stem-loops SL2 and SL3 and the stem P1 were essential for binding and that only the 3'-most 17 nucleotides were dispensable. Anti-PR aptamers inhibited HIV replication in vitro and the degree of inhibition was higher for second-generation aptamers with greater affinity and the inhibition was abrogated for a nonbinding aptamer variant.

Efficient HIV-1 inhibition by a 16 nt-long RNA aptamer designed by combining in vitro selection and in silico optimisation strategies

The human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) genome contains multiple, highly conserved structural RNA domains that play key roles in essential viral processes. Interference with the function of these RNA domains either by disrupting their structures or by blocking their interaction with viral or cellular factors may seriously compromise HIV-1 viability. RNA aptamers are amongst the most promising synthetic molecules able to interact with structural domains of viral genomes. However, aptamer shortening up to their minimal active domain is usually necessary for scaling up production, what requires very time-consuming, trial-and-error approaches. Here we report on the in vitro selection of 64 nt-long specific aptamers against the complete 5′-untranslated region of HIV-1 genome, which inhibit more than 75% of HIV-1 production in a human cell line. The analysis of the selected sequences and structures allowed for the identification of a highly conserved 16 nt-long stem-loop motif containing a common 8 nt-long apical loop. Based on this result, an in silico designed 16 nt-long RNA aptamer, termed RNApt16, was synthesized, with sequence 5′-CCCCGGCAAGGAGGGG-3′. The HIV-1 inhibition efficiency of such an aptamer was close to 85%, thus constituting the shortest RNA molecule so far described that efficiently interferes with HIV-1 replication.

The allosteric HIV-1 integrase inhibitor BI-D affects virion maturation but does not influence packaging of a functional RNA genome

The viral integrase (IN) is an essential protein for HIV-1 replication. IN inserts the viral dsDNA into the host chromosome, thereby aided by the cellular co-factor LEDGF/p75. Recently a new class of integrase inhibitors was described: allosteric IN inhibitors (ALLINIs). Although designed to interfere with the IN-LEDGF/p75 interaction to block HIV DNA integration during the early phase of HIV-1 replication, the major impact was surprisingly found on the process of virus maturation during the late phase, causing a reverse transcription defect upon infection of target cells. Virus particles produced in the presence of an ALLINI are misformed with the ribonucleoprotein located outside the virus core. Virus assembly and maturation are highly orchestrated and regulated processes in which several viral proteins and RNA molecules closely interact. It is therefore of interest to study whether ALLINIs have unpredicted pleiotropic effects on these RNA-related processes. We confirm that the ALLINI BI-D inhibits virus replication and that the produced virus is non-infectious. Furthermore, we show that the wild-type level of HIV-1 genomic RNA is packaged in virions and these genomes are in a dimeric state. The tRNA^lys3 primer for reverse transcription was properly placed on this genomic RNA and could be extended ex vivo. In addition, the packaged reverse transcriptase enzyme was fully active when extracted from virions. As the RNA and enzyme components for reverse transcription are properly present in virions produced in the presence of BI-D, the inhibition of reverse transcription is likely to reflect the mislocalization of the components in the aberrant virus particle.

Multimodal mechanism of action of allosteric HIV-1 integrase inhibitors

Integrase (IN) is required for lentivirus replication and is a proven drug target for the prevention of AIDS in HIV-1-infected patients. While clinical strand transfer inhibitors disarm the IN active site, allosteric inhibition of enzyme activity through the disruption of IN-IN protein interfaces holds great therapeutic potential. A promising class of allosteric IN inhibitors (ALLINIs), 2-(quinolin-3-yl) acetic acid derivatives, engage the IN catalytic core domain dimerisation interface at the binding site for the host integration co-factor LEDGF/p75. ALLINIs promote IN multimerisation and, independent of LEDGF/p75 protein, block the formation of the active IN-DNA complex, as well as inhibit the IN-LEDGF/p75 interaction in vitro. Yet, rather unexpectedly, the full inhibitory effect of these compounds is exerted during the late phase of HIV-1 replication. ALLINIs impair particle core maturation as well as reverse transcription and integration during the subsequent round of virus infection. Recapitulating the pleiotropic phenotypes observed with numerous IN mutant viruses, ALLINIs provide insight into underlying aspects of IN biology that extend beyond its catalytic activity. Therefore, in addition to the potential to expand our repertoire of HIV-1 antiretrovirals, ALLINIs afford important structural probes to dissect the multifaceted nature of the IN protein throughout the course of HIV-1 replication.

Aptamers: multifunctional molecules for biomedical research

Aptamers are single-stranded oligonucleotides that fold into well-defined three-dimensional shapes, allowing them to bind their targets with high affinity and specificity. They can be generated through an in vitro process called "Systemic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment" and applied for specific detection, inhibition, and characterization of various targets like small organic and inorganic molecules, proteins, and whole cells. Aptamers have also been called chemical antibodies because of their synthetic origin and their similar modes of action to antibodies. They exhibit significant advantages over antibodies in terms of their small size, synthetic accessibility, and ability to be chemically modified and thus endowed with new properties. The first generation of aptamer drug "Macugen" was available for public use within 25 years of the discovery of aptamers. With others in the pipeline for clinical trials, this emerging field of medical biotechnology is raising significant interest. However, aptamers pose different problems for their development than for antibodies that need to be addressed to achieve practical applications. It is likely that current developments in aptamer engineering will be the basis for the evolution of improved future bioanalytical and biomedical applications. The present review discusses the development of aptamers for therapeutics, drug delivery, target validation and imaging, and reviews some of the challenges to fully realizing the promise of aptamers in biomedical applications.

Rapid identification of cell-specific, internalizing RNA aptamers with bioinformatics analyses of a cell-based aptamer selection

Background

The broad applicability of RNA aptamers as cell-specific delivery tools for therapeutic reagents depends on the ability to identify aptamer sequences that selectively access the cytoplasm of distinct cell types. Towards this end, we have developed a novel approach that combines a cell-based selection method (cell-internalization SELEX) with high-throughput sequencing (HTS) and bioinformatics analyses to rapidly identify cell-specific, internalization-competent RNA aptamers.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We demonstrate the utility of this approach by enriching for RNA aptamers capable of selective internalization into vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs). Several rounds of positive (VSMCs) and negative (endothelial cells; ECs) selection were performed to enrich for aptamer sequences that preferentially internalize into VSMCs. To identify candidate RNA aptamer sequences, HTS data from each round of selection were analyzed using bioinformatics methods: (1) metrics of selection enrichment; and (2) pairwise comparisons of sequence and structural similarity, termed edit and tree distance, respectively. Correlation analyses of experimentally validated aptamers or rounds revealed that the best cell-specific, internalizing aptamers are enriched as a result of the negative selection step performed against ECs.

Conclusions and Significance

We describe a novel approach that combines cell-internalization SELEX with HTS and bioinformatics analysis to identify cell-specific, cell-internalizing RNA aptamers. Our data highlight the importance of performing a pre-clear step against a non-target cell in order to select for cell-specific aptamers. We expect the extended use of this approach to enable the identification of aptamers to a multitude of different cell types, thereby facilitating the broad development of targeted cell therapies.

Knockdown of the cellular protein LRPPRC attenuates HIV-1 infection

HIV-1 exploits numerous host cellular pathways for productive infection. To identify novel factors involved in HIV-1 replication, HIV-1 integrase and matrix protein complexes were captured at 4 hours post infection for proteomic analysis using an affinity purification system. Leucine-rich PPR-motif containing (LRPPRC) protein, a cellular protein involved in mitochondrial function, cell metabolism, and cell-cycle progression was identified as one of the candidate HIV-1 factors. Co-immunoprecipitation RT-PCR experiments confirmed that LRPPRC associated with HIV-1 nucleic acids during the early steps of virus infection. To establish if LRPPRC was critical for HIV-1 infection, three independent LRPPRC knockdown cell lines were constructed (2.7, 3.6, and 4.1). Subcellular fractionation of these cell lines revealed differential knockdown of LRPPRC in subcellular compartments. LRPPRC was knocked down in the insoluble/cytoskeletal fractions of all three cell lines, but the 3.6 and 4.1 cells also showed a reduction in nuclear LRPPRC. Additionally, several cellular factors were downregulated and/or disrupted by loss of LRPPRC. HIV-1 infection was reduced in all three cell lines, but virus production and RNA encapsidation were unaffected, suggesting that LRPPRC was critical for the afferent stage of virus replication. Two of the three cell lines (3.6, 4.1) were refractory for murine leukemia virus infection, a virus dependent on cellular proliferation for productive infection. Consistent with this, these two cell lines exhibited reduced cellular growth with no loss of cellular viability or change in cell cycle phenotype. The early steps of virus infection were also differentially affected among the cell lines. A reduced level of preintegration complex formation was observed in all three cell lines, but viral DNA nuclear import was reduced only in the 3.6 and 4.1 cells. Combined, these data identify LRPPRC as a HIV-1 factor that is involved in HIV-1 replication through more than one mechanism.

The guanine-quadruplex aptamer 93del inhibits HIV-1 replication ex vivo by interfering with viral entry, reverse transcription and integration

BACKGROUND

We have previously identified the guanine-rich oligonucleotide (ODN) 93del as a potent inhibitor in vitro of HIV-1 integrase. Moreover, low nanomolar concentrations of ODN 93del have been shown to inhibit HIV-1 replication in infected cells.

METHODS

To investigate the ex vivo mechanism of ODN 93del inhibition, we analysed its antiviral effects on the early steps of HIV-1 replication such as viral entry, reverse transcription and integration using quantitative PCR.

RESULTS

In addition to the effect on viral entry previously described for other guanine-quadruplex ODNs, transfection experiments showed that ODN 93del severely affects the proviral integration step independently of the effect on viral entry. Moreover, incubation of viral particles with ODN 93del revealed a potential microbicide activity of the aptamer.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data point to an original multimodal inhibition of HIV-1 replication by ODN 93del, strongly suggesting that targets of guanine-quartet-forming ODNs involve entry as well as other intracellular early steps of HIV-1 replication.

Retroviral vectors for gene therapy

Since their first clinical trial 20 years ago, retroviral (gretroviral and lentiviral) vectors have now been used in more than 350 gene-therapy studies. Retroviral vectors are particularly suited for gene-correction of cells due to long-term and stable expression of the transferred transgene(s), and also because little effort is required for their cloning and production. Several monogenic inherited diseases, mostly immunodeficiencies, can now be successfully treated. The occurrence of insertional mutagenesis in some studies allowed extensive analysis of integration profiles of retroviral vectors, as well as the design of lentiviral vectors with increased safety properties. These new-generation vectors will enable us to continue the successful story of gene therapy, and treat more patients and even more complex diseases.

Convergent evolution to an aptamer observed in small populations on DNA microarrays

The development of aptamers on custom synthesized DNA microarrays, which has been demonstrated in recent publications, can facilitate detailed analyses of sequence and fitness relationships. Here we use the technique to observe the paths taken through sequence-fitness space by three different evolutionary regimes: asexual reproduction, recombination and model-based evolution. The different evolutionary runs are made on the same array chip in triplicate, each one starting from a small population initialized independently at random. When evolving to a common target protein, glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD), these nine distinct evolutionary runs are observed to develop aptamers with high affinity and to converge on the same motif not present in any of the starting populations. Regime specific differences in the evolutions, such as speed of convergence, could also be observed.

Aptamers as therapeutics

Aptamers are single-stranded oligonucleotides that fold into defined architectures and bind to targets such as proteins.

In binding proteins they often inhibit protein–protein interactions and thereby may elicit therapeutic effects such as antagonism.

Aptamers are discovered using SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment), a directed in vitro evolution technique in which large libraries of degenerate oligonucleotides are iteratively and alternately partitioned for target binding. They are then amplified enzymatically until functional sequences are identified by the sequencing of cloned individuals.

For most therapeutic purposes, aptamers are truncated to reduce synthesis costs, modified at the sugars and capped at their termini to increase nuclease resistance, and conjugated to polyethylene glycol or another entity to reduce renal filtration rates.

The first aptamer approved for a therapeutic application was pegaptanib sodium (Macugen; Pfizer/Eyetech), which was approved in 2004 by the US Food and Drug Administration for macular degeneration.

Eight other aptamers are currently undergoing clinical evaluation for various haematology, oncology, ocular and inflammatory indications.

Aptamers are ultimately chemically synthesized in a readily scalable process in which specific conjugation points are introduced with defined stereochemistry.

Unlike some protein therapeutics, aptamers do not elicit antibodies, and because aptamers generally contain sugars modified at their 2′-positions, Toll-like receptor-mediated innate immune responses are also abrogated.

As aptamers are oligonucleotides they can be readily assembled into supramolecular multi-component structures using hybridization.

Owing to the fact that binding to appropriate cell-surface targets can lead to internalization, aptamers can also be used to deliver therapeutic cargoes such as small interfering RNA.

Supramolecular assemblies of aptamers and delivery agents have already been demonstrated in vivo and may pave the way for further therapeutic strategies with this modality in the future.

Aptamers are oligonucleotide sequences that are capable of recognizing target proteins with an affinity and specificity rivalling that of antibodies. In this article, Keefe and colleagues discuss the development, properties and therapeutic potential of aptamers, highlighting those currently in the clinic.

Nucleic acid aptamers can be selected from pools of random-sequence oligonucleotides to bind a wide range of biomedically relevant proteins with affinities and specificities that are comparable to antibodies. Aptamers exhibit significant advantages relative to protein therapeutics in terms of size, synthetic accessibility and modification by medicinal chemistry. Despite these properties, aptamers have been slow to reach the marketplace, with only one aptamer-based drug receiving approval so far. A series of aptamers currently in development may change how nucleic acid therapeutics are perceived. It is likely that in the future, aptamers will increasingly find use in concert with other therapeutic molecules and modalities.

Mapping of RNA-protein interactions

RNA-protein interactions are important biological events that perform multiple functions in all living organisms. The wide range of RNA interactions demands diverse conformations to provide contacts for the selective recognition of proteins. Various analytical procedures are presently available for quantitative analyses of RNA-protein complexes, but analytical-based mapping of these complexes is essential to probe specific interactions. In this overview, interactions of functional RNAs and RNA-aptamers with target proteins are discussed by means of mapping strategies.

Methods for selection of aptamers to protein targets

Aptamers are synthetic single-stranded RNA or DNA molecules capable of specific binding to other target molecules. In this review, the main aptamer properties are considered and methods for selection of aptamers against various protein targets are described. Special attention is given to the methods for directed selection of aptamers, which allow one to obtain ligands with specified properties.

Antiviral aptamers

Aptamers are rare nucleic acid ligands, which can be concocted in the laboratory from the randomized pool of molecules by affinity and amplification processes. Aptamers have several properties as they can be applied complementarily to antibodies and have several advantages over antibodies. In the past, several aptamers have been selected with a view to develop antiviral agents for therapeutic applications. This review summarizes potent antiviral aptamers and their strategies to prevent the viral replication.

SELEX--a (r)evolutionary method to generate high-affinity nucleic acid ligands

SELEX stands for systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment. This method, described primarily in 1990 [Ellington, A.D., Szostak, J.W., 1990. In vitro selection of RNA molecules that bind specific ligands. Nature 346, 818-822; Tuerk, C., Gold, L., 1990. Systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment: RNA ligands to bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase. Science 249, 505-510] aims at the development of aptamers, which are oligonucleotides (RNA or ssDNA) binding to their target with high selectivity and sensitivity because of their three-dimensional shape. Aptamers are all new ligands with a high affinity for considerably differing molecules ranging from large targets as proteins over peptides, complex molecules to drugs and organic small molecules or even metal ions. Aptamers are widely used, including medical and pharmaceutical basic research, drug development, diagnosis, and therapy. Analytical and separation tools bearing aptamers as molecular recognition and binding elements are another big field of application. Moreover, aptamers are used for the investigation of binding phenomena in proteomics. The SELEX method was modified over the years in different ways to become more efficient and less time consuming, to reach higher affinities of the aptamers selected and for automation of the process. This review is focused on the development of aptamers by use of SELEX and gives an overview about technologies, advantages, limitations, and applications of aptamers.

Methods developed for SELEX

SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) is a process that involves the progressive purification from a combinatorial library of nucleic acid ligands with a high affinity for a particular target by repeated rounds of partitioning and amplification. With the development of aptamer technology over the last decade, various modified SELEX processes have arisen that allow various aptamers to be developed against a wide variety of molecules, irrespective of the target size. In the present review, the separation methods used in such SELEX processes are reviewed.

Aptamers come of age - at last

Nucleic-acid aptamers have the molecular recognition properties of antibodies, and can be isolated robotically for high-throughput applications in diagnostics, research and therapeutics. Unlike antibodies, however, they can be chemically derivatized easily to extend their lifetimes in biological fluids and their bioavailability in animals. The first aptamer-based clinical drugs have recently entered service. Meanwhile, active research programmes have identified a wide range of anti-viral aptamers that could form the basis for future therapeutics.

RNA aptamers: from basic science towards therapy

The SELEX technique (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) provides a powerful tool for the in vitro selection of nucleic acid ligands (aptamers) from combinatorial oligonucleotide libraries against a target molecule. In the beginning of the technique's use, RNA molecules were identified that bind to proteins that naturally interact with nucleic acids or to small organic molecules. In the following years, the use of the SELEX technique was extended to isolate oligonucleotide ligands (aptamers) for a wide range of proteins of importance for therapy and diagnostics, such as growth factors and cell surface antigens. These oligonucleotides bind their targets with similar affinities and specificities as antibodies do. The in vitro selection of oligonucleotides with enzymatic activity, denominated aptazymes, allows the direct transduction of molecular recognition to catalysis. Recently, the use of in vitro selection methods to isolate protein inhibitors has been extended to complex targets, such as membrane-bound receptors, and even entire cells. RNA aptamers have also been expressed in living cells. These aptamers, also called intramers, can be used to dissect intracellular signal transduction pathways. The utility of RNA aptamers for in vivo experiments, as well as for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes, is considerably enhanced by chemical modifications, such as substitutions of the 2'-OH groups of the ribose backbone in order to provide resistance against enzymatic degradation in biological fluids. In an alternative approach, Spiegelmers are identified through in vitro selection of an unmodified D-RNA molecule against a mirror-image (i.e. a D-peptide) of a selection target, followed by synthesis of the unnatural nuclease-resistant L-configuration of the RNA aptamer that recognizes the natural configuration of its selection target (i.e. a L-peptide). Recently, nuclease-resistant inhibitory RNA aptamers have been developed against a great variety of targets implicated in disease. Some results have already been obtained in animal models and in clinical trials.

Aptamers to Escherichia coli core RNA polymerase that sense its interaction with rifampicin, sigma-subunit and GreB

Bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) is the central enzyme of gene expression that is responsible for the synthesis of all types of cellular RNAs. The process of transcription is accompanied by complex structural rearrangements of RNAP. Despite the recent progress in structural studies of RNAP, detailed mechanisms of conformational changes of RNAP that occur at different stages of transcription remain unknown. The goal of this work was to obtain novel ligands to RNAP which would target different epitopes of the enzyme and serve as specific probes to study the mechanism of transcription and conformational flexibility of RNAP. Using in vitro selection methods, we obtained 13 classes of ssDNA aptamers against Escherichia coli core RNAP. The minimal nucleic acid scaffold (an oligonucleotide construct imitating DNA and RNA in elongation complex), rifampicin and the sigma70-subunit inhibited binding of the aptamers to RNAP core but did not affect the dissociation rate of preformed RNAP-aptamer complexes. We argue that these ligands sterically block access of the aptamers to their binding sites within the main RNAP channel. In contrast, transcript cleavage factor GreB increased the rate of dissociation of preformed RNAP-aptamer complexes. This suggested that GreB that binds RNAP outside the main channel actively disrupts RNAP-aptamer complexes by inducing conformational changes in the channel. We propose that the aptamers obtained in this work will be useful for studying the interactions of RNAP with various ligands and regulatory factors and for investigating the conformational flexibility of the enzyme.

Inhibition of an activated Ras protein with genetically selected peptide aptamers

Mutant alleles of Ras maintain an activated, GTP-bound conformation and relay mitogenic signals that cannot be turned off. A genetic selection in Saccharomyces cerevisiae was used to identify peptide aptamers that suppress the growth arrest phenotype of an activated Ras allele. Peptide aptamers were expressed as C-terminal fusions to glutathione-S-transferase. Modifications that alter the coding capacity of the peptide aptamer indicate it is necessary for Ras2-Val19 suppression. Aptamer expression also reduces the elevated levels of cAMP and suppresses the heat shock sensitivity characteristic of Ras-activated yeast cells. The peptide aptamer retains suppressor activity when fused to thioredoxin. The peptide aptamer expression strategy described here indicates that aptamers presented as unconstrained peptides have functional capacity in vivo.

HIV-1 integrase and RNase H activities as therapeutic targets

The retroviruses are a large, diverse family of enveloped RNA viruses defined by their structure, composition and replicative properties. The hallmark of the family is its replicative strategy, essential steps of which include reverse transcription of the viral RNA and the subsequent integration of this DNA into the genome of the cell. These steps are performed by two viral-encoded enzymes, reverse transcriptase (RT), which possesses DNA polymerase and ribonuclease H (RNase H) activities, and integrase (IN). These enzymes are excellent targets for retroviral therapy since they are essential for viral replication. Numerous substances capable of inhibiting the DNA polymerase activity of HIV-1 RT are available, while few specific inhibitors of RNase H activity have been described. IN is absolutely necessary for stable and productive infection of cells. Some IN inhibitors have been recently reported and are available demonstrating the potential of IN as an antiviral target. This paper is an overview of the inhibitors of RNase H and IN and describes the most promising inhibitors.

Sequestering of Eu(III) by a GAAA RNA tetraloop

The site-specific binding of metal ions maintains an important role in the structure, thermal stability, and function of folded RNA structures. RNA tetraloops of the "GNRA" family (where N = any base and R = any purine), which owe their unusual stability to base stacking and an extensive hydrogen bonding network, have been observed to bind metal ions having different chemical and geometric properties. We have used laser-induced lanthanide luminescence and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to examine the metal-binding properties of an RNA stem loop of the GNRA family. Previous research has shown that a single Eu(III) ion binds the stem loop fragment in a highly dehydrated site with a K(d) of approximately 12 microM. Curve-fitting analysis of the broad luminescence excitation spectrum of Eu(III) upon complexation with the tetraloop fragment indicates the possibility of two microenvironments that do not differ in hydration number. Binding of Eu(III) to the loop was accompanied by positive enthalpic changes, consistent with energetic cost of removal of water molecules and suggesting that the binding is entropically driven. By comparison, binding of Mg(II) or Mn(II) to the RNA loop, or Eu(III) to the DNA analogue of the loop, was associated with exothermic changes, consistent with predominantly outer-sphere coordination. These results suggest specific binding, most probably involving ligands on the 5' side of the loop.

Mutations that confer resistance to template-analog inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 reverse transcriptase lead to severe defects in HIV replication

We isolated two template analog reverse transcriptase (RT) inhibitor-resistant mutants of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 RT by using the DNA aptamer, RT1t49. The mutations associated, N255D or N265D, displayed low-level resistance to RT1t49, while high-level resistance could be observed when both mutations were present (Dbl). Molecular clones of HIV that contained the mutations produced replication-defective virions. All three RT mutants displayed severe processivity defects. Thus, while biochemical resistance to the DNA aptamer RT1t49 can be generated in vitro via multiple mutations, the overlap between the aptamer- and template-primer-binding pockets favors mutations that also affect the RT-template-primer interaction. Therefore, viruses with such mutations are replication defective. Potent inhibition and a built-in mechanism to render aptamer-resistant viruses replication defective make this an attractive class of inhibitors.

Intramers as promising new tools in functional proteomics

Aptamers are valuable tools for studying numerous aspects of biological processes, opening up new experimental opportunities to analyse the function of a wide range of cellular molecules. Functional RNA molecules can be rapidly selected in vitro from complex combinatorial mixtures of different sequences. Recently, it was shown that in vitro selection processes can be automated: the first generation selection robots will soon mean aptamers for several targets can be isolated in parallel within days rather than weeks. Aptamers not only exhibit highly specific molecular recognition properties but are also able to modulate the function of their cognate targets in a highly specific manner by agonistic or antagonistic mechanisms. These properties prompted the development of novel technologies to exploit the use of aptamers to modulate distinct functions of biological targets. Recent controlled expression of aptamers inside cells demonstrated their impressive potential as rapidly generated intracellular inhibitors of biomolecules. Intracellularly applied aptamers are also called 'intramers'. Here we discuss recent developments and strategies for intramer-based technologies that have the potential to greatly facilitate characterisation of unknown protein functions in the context of their natural expression status in vivo. Thus, intramer-based technologies offer many promising applications in functional genomics, proteomics and drug discovery.

Substrate sequence selection by retroviral integrase

Integration of retrovirus DNA is a specific process catalyzed by the integrase protein acting to join the viral substrate DNA (att) sequences of about 10 bases at the ends of the long terminal repeat (LTR) to various sites in the host target cell DNA. Although the interaction is sequence specific, the att sequences of different retroviruses are largely unrelated to one another and usually differ between the two ends of the viral DNA. To define substrate sequence specificity, we designed an "in vitro evolution" scheme to select an optimal substrate sequence by competitive integration in vitro from a large pool of partially randomized substrates. Integrated substrates are enriched by PCR amplification and then regenerated and subjected to subsequent cycles of selection and enrichment. Using this approach, we obtained the optimal substrate sequence of 5'-ACGACAACA-3' for avian sarcoma-leukosis virus (ASLV) and 5'-AACA(A/C)AGCA-3' for human immunodeficiency virus type 1, which differed from those found at both ends of the viral DNA. Clonal analysis of the integration products showed that ASLV integrase can use a wide variety of substrate sequences in vitro, although the consensus sequence was identical to the selected sequence. By a competition assay, the selected nucleotide at position 4 improved the in vitro integration efficiency over that of the wild-type sequence. Viral mutants bearing the optimal sequence replicated at wild-type levels, with the exception of some mutations disrupting the U5 RNA secondary structure important for reverse transcription, which were significantly impaired. Thus, maximizing the efficiency of integration may not be of major importance for efficient retrovirus replication.

Repair of gaps in retroviral DNA integration intermediates

Diverse mobile DNA elements are believed to pirate host cell enzymes to complete DNA transfer. Prominent examples are provided by retroviral cDNA integration and transposon insertion. These reactions initially involve the attachment of each element 3' DNA end to staggered sites in the host DNA by element-encoded integrase or transposase enzymes. Unfolding of such intermediates yields DNA gaps at each junction. It has been widely assumed that host DNA repair enzymes complete attachment of the remaining DNA ends, but the enzymes involved have not been identified for any system. We have synthesized DNA substrates containing the expected gap and 5' two-base flap structure present in retroviral integration intermediates and tested candidate enzymes for the ability to support repair in vitro. We find three required activities, two of which can be satisfied by multiple enzymes. These are a polymerase (polymerase beta, polymerase delta and its cofactor PCNA, or reverse transcriptase), a nuclease (flap endonuclease), and a ligase (ligase I, III, or IV and its cofactor XRCC4). A proposed pathway involving retroviral integrase and reverse transcriptase did not carry out repair under the conditions tested. In addition, prebinding of integrase protein to gapped DNA inhibited repair reactions, indicating that gap repair in vivo may require active disassembly of the integrase complex.

Chemically modified nucleic acid aptamers for in vitro selections: evolving evolution

Combinatorial library selections through the systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) technique identify so-called nucleic acid aptamers that bind with high-affinity and specificity to a wide range of selected molecules. However, the modest chemical functionality of nucleic acids poses some limits on their versatility as binders and catalysts, and, furthermore, the sensitivity of pure RNA- and DNA-based aptamers to nucleases restricts their use as therapeutic and diagnostic agents. Here we review synthetic chemistries for modifying nucleotides that have been developed to enhance the affinity of aptamers for targets and to increase their stability in biological fluids. Implementation of in vitro selections with modified nucleotides promises to be an elegant technique for the creation of ligands with novel physical and chemical properties and is anticipated to have a significant impact on biotechnology, diagnostics and drug development. The current molecular designs and applications of modified nucleotides for in vitro selections are reviewed, along with a discussion of future developments expected to further the utility of this approach in both practical and theoretical terms.

Aptamers as tools in molecular biology and immunology

We have listed and described recent promising developments in the field of aptamer research. The properties and the application potential of aptamers propose an exciting future for aptamers either in the clinic or as research tools for various purposes. We have reviewed exciting examples in which the SELEX technology was applied to obtain promising tools that may help to facilitate our understanding of biological processes and to interfere at distinct points in signal transduction cascades. High affinities and specificities of aptamer/target-interactions can now routinely be achieved. Furthermore, a wide spectrum of chemical modifications of nucleotides is known which greatly increase the stability of RNA molecules in biological materials, considerably enhancing their application potential. The aptamer technology shows that the combination of organic synthesis and molecular biology can contribute to interesting and promising new drug leads, which may very soon find their way into daily clinical practice or onto the laboratory benches of many researchers in the life sciences.

Coupled integration of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 cDNA ends by purified integrase in vitro: stimulation by the viral nucleocapsid protein

Integration of retroviral cDNA involves coupled joining of the two ends of the viral genome at precisely spaced positions in the host cell DNA. Correct coupled joining is essential for viral replication, as shown, for example, by the finding that viral mutants defective in coupled joining are defective in integration and replication. To date, reactions with purified human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) integrase protein in vitro have supported mainly uncoupled joining of single cDNA ends. We have analyzed an activity stimulating coupled joining present in HIV-1 virions, which led to the finding that the HIV-1 nucleocapsid (NC) protein can stimulate coupled joining more than 1,000-fold under some conditions. The requirements for stimulating coupled joining were investigated in assays with mutant NC proteins, revealing that mutations in the zinc finger domains can influence stimulation of integration. These findings (i) provide a means for assembling more authentic integrase complexes for mechanistic studies, (ii) reveal a new activity of NC protein in vitro, (iii) indicate a possible role for NC in vivo, and (iv) provide a possible method for identifying a new class of inhibitors that disrupt coupled joining.

Inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus integrase

Integration of the viral DNA into a host cell chromosome is an essential step for HIV replication and maintenance of persistent infection. Two viral factors are essential for integration: the viral DNA termini (the att sites) and IN. Accruing knowledge of the IN structure, catalytic mechanisms, and interactions with other proteins can be used to design strategies to block integration. A large number of inhibitors have been identified that can be used as leads for the development of potent and selective anti-IN drugs with antiviral activity.

Conformational aspects of HIV-1 integrase inhibition by a peptide derived from the enzyme central domain and by antibodies raised against this peptide

Monospecific antibodies were raised against a synthetic peptide K159 (SQGVVESMNKELKKIIGQVRDQAEHLKTA) reproducing the segment 147-175 of HIV-1 integrase (IN). Synthesis of substituted and truncated analogs of K159 led us to identify the functional epitope reacting with antibodies within the C-terminal portion 163-175 of K159. Conformational studies combining secondary structure predictions, CD and NMR spectroscopy together with ELISA assays, showed that the greater is the propensity of the epitope for helix formation the higher is the recognition by anti-K159. Both the antibodies and the antigenic peptide K159 exhibited inhibitory activities against IN. In contrast, neither P159, a Pro-containing analog of K159 that presents a kink around proline but with intact epitope conformation, nor the truncated analogs encompassing the epitope, were inhibitors of IN. While the activity of antibodies is restricted to recognition of the sole epitope portion, that of the antigenic K159 likely requires interactions of the peptide with the whole 147-175 segment in the protein [Sourgen F., Maroun, R.G., Frère, V., Bouziane, A., Auclair, C., Troalen, F. & Fermandjian, S. (1996) Eur. J. Biochem. 240, 765-773]. Actually, of all tested peptides only K159 was found to fulfill condition of minimal number of helical heptads to achieve the formation of a stable coiled-coil structure with the IN 147-175 segment. The binding of antibodies and of the antigenic peptide to this segment of IN hampers the binding of IN to its DNA substrates in filter-binding assays. This appears to be the main effect leading to inhibition of integration. Quantitative analysis of filter-binding assay curves indicates that two antibody molecules react with IN implying that the enzyme is dimeric within these experimental conditions. Together, present data provide an insight into the structure-function relationship for the 147-175 peptide domain of the enzyme. They also strongly suggest that the functional enzyme is dimeric. Results could help to assess models for binding of peptide fragments to IN and to develop stronger inhibitors. Moreover, K159 antibodies when expressed in vivo might exhibit useful inhibitory properties.

NMR structure of the bacteriophage lambda N peptide/boxB RNA complex: recognition of a GNRA fold by an arginine-rich motif

The structure of the complex formed by the arginine-rich motif of the transcriptional antitermination protein N of phage lambda and boxB RNA was determined by heteronuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. A bent alpha helix in N recognizes primarily the shape and negatively charged surface of the boxB hairpin through multiple hydrophobic and ionic interactions. The GAAGA boxB loop forms a GNRA fold, previously described for tetraloops, which is essential for N binding. The fourth nucleotide of the loop extrudes from the GNRA fold to enable the E. coli elongation factor NusA to recognize the N protein/RNA complex. This structure reveals a new mode of RNA-protein recognition and shows how a small RNA element can facilitate a protein-protein interaction and thereby nucleate formation of a large ribonucleoprotein complex.

Molecular mechanisms in retrovirus DNA integration

The integrase protein of retroviruses catalyzes the insertion of the viral DNA into the genomes of the cells that they infect. Integrase is necessary and sufficient for this recombination reaction in vitro; however, the enzyme's activity appears to be modulated in vivo by viral and cellular components included in the nucleoprotein pre-integration complex. In addition to integrase, cis-acting sequences at the ends of the viral DNA are important for integration. Solution of the structures of the isolated N- and C-terminal domains of HIV-1 integrase by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and the available crystal structures of the catalytic core domains from human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) and avian sarcoma virus (ASV) integrases are providing a structural basis for understanding some aspects of the integration reaction. The role of the evolutionarily conserved acidic amino acids in the D,D(35)E motif as metal-coordinating residues that are critical for catalysis, has been confirmed by the metal-integrase (core domain) complexes of ASV integrase. The central role that integrase plays in the life cycle of the virus makes it an attractive target for the design of drugs against retroviral diseases such as AIDS. To this end, several compounds have been screened for inhibitory effects against HIV-1 integrase. These include DNA intercalators, peptides, RNA ligands, and small organic compounds such as bis-catechols, flavones, and hydroxylated arylamides. Although the published inhibitors are not very potent, they serve as valuable leads for the development of the next generation of tight-binding analogues that are more specific to integrase. In addition, new approaches are being developed, exemplified by intracellular immunization studies with conformation-sensitive inhibitory monoclonal antibodies against HIV-1 integrase. Increased knowledge of the mechanism of retroviral DNA integration should provide new strategies for the design of effective antivirals that inhibit integrase in the future.

In vitro selection of RNAs that bind to the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 gag polyprotein

RNA ligands that bind to the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) gag polyprotein with 10(-9) M affinity were isolated from a complex pool of RNAs using an in vitro selection method. The ligands bind to two different regions within gag, either to the matrix protein or to the nucleocapsid protein. Binding of a matrix ligand to gag did not interfere with the binding of a nucleocapsid ligand, and binding of a nucleocapsid ligand to gag did not interfere with the binding of a matrix ligand. However, binding of a nucleocapsid ligand to gag did interfere with binding of an RNA containing the HIV-1 RNA packaging element (psi), even though the sequence of the nucleocapsid ligand is not similar topsi. The minimal sequences required for the ligands to bind to matrix or nucleocapsid were determined. Minimal nucleocapsid ligands are predicted to form a stem-loop structure that has a self-complementary sequence at one end. Minimal matrix ligands are predicted to form a different stem-loop structure that has a CAARU loop sequence. The properties of these RNA ligands may provide tools for studying RNA interactions with matrix and nucleocapsid, and a novel method for inhibiting HIV replication.

Equivalent inhibition of half-site and full-site retroviral strand transfer reactions by structurally diverse compounds

In vitro assay systems which use recombinant retroviral integrase (IN) and short DNA oligonucleotides fail to recapitulate the full-site integration reaction as it is known to occur in vivo. The relevance of using such circumscribed in vitro assays to define inhibitors of retroviral integration has not been formerly demonstrated. Therefore, we analyzed a series of structurally diverse inhibitors with respect to inhibition of both half-site and full-site strand transfer reactions with either recombinant or virion-produced IN. Half-site and full-site reactions catalyzed by avian myeloblastosis virus and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) IN from virions are shown to be equivalently sensitive to inhibition by compounds which inhibit half-site reactions catalyzed by the recombinant HIV-1 IN. These studies therefore support the utility of using in vitro assays employing either recombinant or virion-derived IN to identify inhibitors of integration.

In vitro selection of aptamers: the dearth of pure reason

In vitro selection experiments are now routinely used to identify functional nucleic acid residues and structures, and have become a tool for studying molecular recognition, molecular biology, and molecular evolution. Technical innovations that have been made during the past year include the use of modified monomers to increase stability and photocross-linking reagents to improve affinity. These advances should dramatically increase the utility of aptamers in the future.

Monoclonal antibodies against human immunodeficiency virus type 1 integrase: epitope mapping and differential effects on integrase activities in vitro

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) integrase (IN) catalyzes the integration of viral DNA into the host chromosome, an essential step in retroviral replication. As a tool to study the structure and function of this enzyme, monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) against HIV-1 IN were produced. Epitope mapping demonstrated that the 17 MAbs obtained could be divided into seven different groups, and the selection of MAbs representing these groups were tested for their effect on in vitro activities of IN. Four groups of MAbs recognized epitopes within the region of amino acids (aa) 1 to 16, 17 to 38, or 42 to 55 in and around the conserved HHCC motif near the N terminus of IN. MAbs binding to these epitopes inhibited end processing and DNA joining and either stimulated or had little effect on disintegration and reintegration activities of IN. Two MAbs binding to epitopes within the region of aa 56 to 102 in the central core or aa 186 to 250 in the C-terminal half of the protein showed only minor effects on the in vitro activities of IN. Three Mabs which recognized on epitope within the region of aa262 to 271 of HIV-1 IN cross-reacted with HIV-2 IN. MAbs binding to this epitope clearly inhibited end processing and DNA joining and stimulated or had little effect on disintegration. In contrast to the N-terminal-specific MAbs, these C-terminal-specific MAbs abolished reintegration activity of IN.

RNA ligands to human nerve growth factor

High affinity RNA ligands to human nerve growth factor (NGF) were selected from pools of random RNA using SELEX [Tuerk, C. and Gold, L. (1990) Science, 249, 505-510]. Nerve growth factor, which is a protein required for the development of neurons, is not known to bind nucleic acids as part of its natural function. We describe two of the selected RNA molecules in detail. One of them is highly structured, folding into a pseudoknot with an additional hairpin-loop; this structure provides salt-resistant binding to NGF. The other is unstructured and elevated salt concentrations inhibit its binding. These molecules compete with each other for NGF binding. Our RNAs may furnish useful diagnostic tools for the study of an important neurotrophic protein; additionally, they illustrate another example of the potential for nucleic acids to take part in novel binding interactions.