Reactive metabolite screen for reducing candidate attrition in drug discovery

Prioritization of anti-malarial hits from nature: chemo-informatic profiling of natural products with in vitro antiplasmodial activities and currently registered anti-malarial drugs

BACKGROUND

A large number of natural products have shown in vitro antiplasmodial activities. Early identification and prioritization of these natural products with potential for novel mechanism of action, desirable pharmacokinetics and likelihood for development into drugs is advantageous. Chemo-informatic profiling of these natural products were conducted and compared to currently registered anti-malarial drugs (CRAD).

METHODS

Natural products with in vitro antiplasmodial activities (NAA) were compiled from various sources. These natural products were sub-divided into four groups based on inhibitory concentration (IC50). Key molecular descriptors and physicochemical properties were computed for these compounds and analysis of variance used to assess statistical significance amongst the sets of compounds. Molecular similarity analysis, estimation of drug-likeness, in silico pharmacokinetic profiling, and exploration of structure-activity landscape were also carried out on these sets of compounds.

RESULTS

A total of 1040 natural products were selected and a total of 13 molecular descriptors were analysed. Significant differences were observed among the sub-groups of NAA and CRAD for at least 11 of the molecular descriptors, including number of hydrogen bond donors and acceptors, molecular weight, polar and hydrophobic surface areas, chiral centres, oxygen and nitrogen atoms, and shape index. The remaining molecular descriptors, including clogP, number of rotatable bonds and number of aromatic rings, did not show any significant difference when comparing the two compound sets. Molecular similarity and chemical space analysis identified natural products that were structurally diverse from CRAD. Prediction of the pharmacokinetic properties and drug-likeness of these natural products identified over 50% with desirable drug-like properties. Nearly 70% of all natural products were identified as potentially promiscuous compounds. Structure-activity landscape analysis highlighted compound pairs that form 'activity cliffs'. In all, prioritization strategies for the NAA were proposed.

CONCLUSIONS

Chemo-informatic profiling of NAA and CRAD have produced a wealth of information that may guide decisions and facilitate anti-malarial drug development from natural products. Articulation of the information provided within an interactive data-mining environment led to a prioritized list of NAA.

High-resolution chromatography/time-of-flight MSE with in silico data mining is an information-rich approach to reactive metabolite screening

Electrophilic reactive metabolite screening by liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) is commonly performed during drug discovery and early-stage drug development. Accurate mass spectrometry has excellent utility in this application, but sophisticated data processing strategies are essential to extract useful information. Herein, a unified approach to glutathione (GSH) trapped reactive metabolite screening with high-resolution LC/TOF MS(E) analysis and drug-conjugate-specific in silico data processing was applied to rapid analysis of test compounds without the need for stable- or radio-isotope-labeled trapping agents. Accurate mass defect filtering (MDF) with a C-heteroatom dealkylation algorithm dynamic with mass range was compared to linear MDF and shown to minimize false positive results. MS(E) data-filtering, time-alignment and data mining post-acquisition enabled detection of 53 GSH conjugates overall formed from 5 drugs. Automated comparison of sample and control data in conjunction with the mass defect filter enabled detection of several conjugates that were not evident with mass defect filtering alone. High- and low-energy MS(E) data were time-aligned to generate in silico product ion spectra which were successfully applied to structural elucidation of detected GSH conjugates. Pseudo neutral loss and precursor ion chromatograms derived post-acquisition demonstrated 50.9% potential coverage, at best, of the detected conjugates by any individual precursor or neutral loss scan type. In contrast with commonly applied neutral loss and precursor-based techniques, the unified method has the advantage of applicability across different classes of GSH conjugates. The unified method was also successfully applied to cyanide trapping analysis and has potential for application to alternate trapping agents.

Approaches for minimizing metabolic activation of new drug candidates in drug discovery

A large body of circumstantial evidence suggests that metabolic activation of drug candidates to chemically reactive electrophilic metabolites that are capable of covalently modifying cellular macromolecules may result in acute and/or immune system-mediated idiosyncratic toxicities in humans. Thus, minimizing the potential for metabolic activation of new drug candidates during the drug discovery and lead optimization stage represents a prudent strategy to help discover and develop the next generation of safe and effective therapeutic agents. In the present chapter, we discuss the scientific methodologies that currently are available to industrial pharmaceutical scientists for assessing and minimizing metabolic activation during drug discovery, their attributes and limitations, and future scientific directions that have the potential to help advance progress in this field. We also propose a roadmap that should help utilize the armamentarium of available scientific tools in a logical way and contribute to addressing metabolic activation issues in the drug discovery-setting in a rapid, scientifically appropriate, and resource-conscious manner.

Nucleophile addition of reduced glutathione on 2-methyl-2-nitroso compound: a combined electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy and electrospray tandem mass spectrometry study

Mass spectrometry (MS) was used in conjunction with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) to characterize products arising from reactions between reduced glutathione (GSH) and 2-methyl 2-nitroso propane (MNP) in an oxidative medium, to evaluate the reactivity of this tripeptide as a nucleophile toward a nitroso compound. Depending on the experimental conditions, different radical species could be detected by EPR, which allowed some structural assumptions. These samples were then submitted to electrospray ionization, in both positive and negative ion modes, for structural elucidation in tandem mass spectrometry. Although the primary nitroxide products could not be detected in MS, structurally related compounds such as hydroxylamine and O-methyl hydroxylamine could be fully characterized. In the absence of light, a S-adduct was formed via a Forrester-Hepburn reaction, that is, a nucleophile addition of MNP onto the thiol function in reduced glutathione to yield a hydroxylamine intermediate, further oxidized into nitroxide. In contrast, irradiating the reaction medium with visible light could allow an inverted spin trapping reaction to take place, involving the oxidation of both MNP and GSH before the nucleophilic addition of the sulfenic acid function onto the nitrogen of MNP, yielding a so-called O-adduct. It was also found that dilution of the reaction medium with methanol for the purpose of electrospray ionization could allow nitroxides to be indirectly observed either as hydroxylamine or O-methyl hydroxylamine species.

Mass defect filter technique and its applications to drug metabolite identification by high-resolution mass spectrometry

Identification of drug metabolites by liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) involves metabolite detection in biological matrixes and structural characterization based on product ion spectra. Traditionally, metabolite detection is accomplished primarily on the basis of predicted molecular masses or fragmentation patterns of metabolites using triple-quadrupole and ion trap mass spectrometers. Recently, a novel mass defect filter (MDF) technique has been developed, which enables high-resolution mass spectrometers to be utilized for detecting both predicted and unexpected drug metabolites based on narrow, well-defined mass defect ranges for these metabolites. This is a new approach that is completely different from, but complementary to, traditional molecular mass- or MS/MS fragmentation-based LC/MS approaches. This article reviews the mass defect patterns of various classes of drug metabolites and the basic principles of the MDF approach. Examples are given on the applications of the MDF technique to the detection of stable and chemically reactive metabolites in vitro and in vivo. Advantages, limitations, and future applications are also discussed on MDF and its combinations with other data mining techniques for the detection and identification of drug metabolites.

Rapid screening and characterization of drug metabolites using multiple ion monitoring dependent product ion scan and postacquisition data mining on a hybrid triple quadrupole-linear ion trap mass spectrometer

Multiple ion monitoring (MIM)-dependent acquisition with a triple quadrupole-linear ion trap mass spectrometer (Q-trap) was previously developed for drug metabolite profiling. In the analysis, multiple predicted metabolite ions are monitored in both Q1 and Q3 regardless of their fragmentations. The collision energy in Q2 is set to a low value to minimize fragmentation. Once an expected metabolite is detected by MIM, enhanced product ion (EPI) spectral acquisition of the metabolite is triggered. To analyze in vitro metabolites, MIM-EPI retains the sensitivity and selectivity similar to that of multiple reaction monitoring (MRM)-EPI in the analysis of in vitro metabolites. Here we present an improved approach utilizing MIM-EPI for data acquisition and multiple data mining techniques for detection of metabolite ions and recovery of their MS/MS spectra. The postacquisition data processing tools included extracted ion chromatographic analysis, product ion filtering and neutral loss filtering. The effectiveness of this approach was evaluated by analyzing oxidative metabolites of indinavir and glutathione (GSH) conjugates of clozapine and 4-ethylphenol in liver microsome incubations. Results showed that the MIM-EPI-based data mining approach allowed for comprehensive detection of metabolites based on predicted protonated molecules, product ions or neutral losses without predetermination of the parent drug MS/MS spectra. Additionally, it enabled metabolite detection and MS/MS acquisition in a single injection. This approach is potentially useful in high-throughout screening of metabolic soft spots and reactive metabolites at the drug discovery stage.

Screening and characterization of reactive metabolites using glutathione ethyl ester in combination with Q-trap mass spectrometry

The present study describes a new analytical approach for the detection and characterization of chemically reactive metabolites using glutathione ethyl ester (GSH-EE) as the trapping agent in combination with hybrid triple quadrupole linear ion trap mass spectrometry. Polarity switching was applied between a negative precursor ion (PI) survey scan and the positive enhanced product ion (EPI) scan. The negative PI scan step was carried out monitoring the anion at m/z 300, corresponding to deprotonated gamma-glutamyl-dehydroalanyl-glycine ethyl ester originating from the GSH-EE moiety. Samples resulting from incubations in the presence of GSH-EE were cleaned and concentrated by solid-phase extraction, followed by the PI-EPI analysis. Unambiguous identification of GSH-EE-trapped reactive metabolites was greatly facilitated by the unique survey scan of the anion at m/z 300, which achieved less background interference, in particular, from endogenous glutathione adducts present in human liver microsomes. Further structural characterization was achieved by analyzing positive MS(2) spectra that featured rich fragments without mass cutoff and were acquired in the same liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) analysis. The effectiveness and reliability of this approach was evaluated using a number of model compounds in human liver microsomal incubations, including acetaminophen, amodiaquine, carbamazepine, 4-ethylphenol, imipramine and ticlopidine. In addition, iminoquinone reactive metabolites of mianserin were trapped and characterized for the first time using this method. Compared to neutral loss (NL) scanning assays using GSH as the trapping agent, the results have demonstrated superior selectivity, sensitivity, and reliability of this current approach.

An algorithm for thorough background subtraction from high-resolution LC/MS data: application for detection of glutathione-trapped reactive metabolites

A control sample background-subtraction algorithm was developed for thorough subtraction of background and matrix-related signals in high-resolution, accurate mass liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) data to reveal ions of interest in an analyte sample. This algorithm checked all ions in the control scans within a specified time window around the analyte scan for potential subtraction of ions found in that analyte scan. Applying this method, chromatographic fluctuations between runs were dealt with and background and matrix-related signals in the sample could be thoroughly subtracted. The effectiveness of this algorithm was demonstrated using four test compounds, clozapine, diclofenac, imipramine, and tacrine, to reveal glutathione (GSH)-trapped reactive metabolites after incubation with human liver microsomes supplemented with GSH (30 microM compound, 45-min incubation). Using this algorithm with a+/-1.0 min control scan time window, a+/-5 ppm mass error tolerance, and appropriate control samples, the GSH-trapped metabolites were revealed as the major peaks in the processed LC/MS profiles. Such profiles allowed for comprehensive and reliable identification of these metabolites without the need for any presumptions regarding their behavior or properties with respect to mass spectrometric detection. The algorithm was shown to provide superior results when compared to several commercially available background-subtraction algorithms. Many of the metabolites detected were doubly charged species which would be difficult to detect with traditional GSH adduct screening techniques, and thus, some of the adducts have not previously been reported in the literature.

Application of stable isotope-labeled compounds in metabolism and in metabolism-mediated toxicity studies

Stable isotope-labeled compounds have been synthesized and utilized by scientists from various areas of biomedical research during the last several decades. Compounds labeled with stable isotopes, such as deuterium and carbon-13, have been used effectively by drug metabolism scientists and toxicologists to gain better understanding of drugs' disposition and their potential role in target organ toxicities. The combination of stable isotope-labeling techniques with mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, which allows rapid acquisition and interpretation of data, has promoted greater use of these stable isotope-labeled compounds in absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (ADME) studies. Examples of the use of stable isotope-labeled compounds in elucidating structures of metabolites and delineating complex metabolic pathways are presented in this review. The application of labeled compounds in mechanistic toxicity studies will be discussed by providing an example of how strategic placement of a deuterium atom in a drug molecule mitigated specific-specific renal toxicity. Other examples from the literature demonstrating the application of stable isotope-labeled compounds in understanding metabolism-mediated toxicities are presented. Furthermore, an example of how a stable isotope-labeled compound was utilized to better understand some of the gene changes in toxicogenomic studies is discussed. The interpretation of large sets of data produced from toxicogenomics studies can be a challenge. One approach that could be used to simplify interpretation of the data, especially from studies designed to link gene changes with the formation of reactive metabolites thought to be responsible for toxicities, is through the use of stable isotope-labeled compounds. This is a relatively unexplored territory and needs to be further investigated. The employment of analytical techniques, especially mass spectrometry and NMR, used in conjunction with stable isotope-labeled compounds to establish and understand mechanistic link between reactive metabolite formation, genomic, and proteomic changes and onset of toxicity is proposed. The use of stable isotope-labeled compounds in early human ADME studies as a way of identifying and possibly quantifying all drug-related components present in systemic circulation is suggested.

Dual negative precursor ion scan approach for rapid detection of glutathione conjugates using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry

Screening for conjugates formed by the tripeptide glutathione with new chemical entities is an essential step during the drug discovery process, as the formation of these conjugates serves as an indicator for the presence of reactive electrophilic intermediates. To increase the selectivity and throughput of this analysis, various mass spectral scan types have evolved over time. Historically, samples were analyzed under positive ionization conditions for the neutral loss of m/z 129 (loss of the pyroglutamic acid moiety from glutathione); however, more recently, negative precursor ion scanning for the loss of m/z 272 (deprotonated gamma-glutamyl-dehydroalanyl-glycine from glutathione) has emerged as a more selective tool. Further increasing the selectivity, we report on an extension of this methodology by incorporating a simultaneous dual negative precursor ion scan for two commonly observed ion fragments from glutathione conjugates, m/z 272 and 254 (the dehydrated form of m/z 272). This negative dual precursor ion scan methodology was first validated using substrates known to undergo metabolic bioactivation (diclofenac, carbamazepine, and 3-methyl indole) and has then been applied to the routine analysis of proprietary compounds undergoing active lead optimization. In comparison to alternative scan methodologies, the increased selectivity offered by this simultaneous dual precursor method results in a reduction in the generation of false positive results as well as reduced data interpretation time.

Structure–activity relationship study of novel NR2B-selective antagonists with arylamides to avoid reactive metabolites formation

A novel potent NMDA-NR2B selective antagonist without the reactive metabolites formation issue was identified. Through this study, a close correlation between reactive metabolites formation and calculated HOMO energies of parent compounds was found.

Analytical strategies for identifying drug metabolites

With the dramatic increase in the number of new chemical entities (NCEs) arising from combinatorial chemistry and modern high-throughput bioassays, novel bioanalytical techniques are required for the rapid determination of the metabolic stability and metabolites of these NCEs. Knowledge of the metabolic site(s) of the NCEs in early drug discovery is essential for selecting compounds with favorable pharmacokinetic credentials and aiding medicinal chemists in modifying metabolic "soft spots". In development, elucidation of biotransformation pathways of a drug candidate by identifying its circulatory and excretory metabolites is vitally important to understand its physiological effects. Mass spectrometry (MS) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) have played an invaluable role in the structural characterization and quantification of drug metabolites. Indeed, liquid chromatography (LC) coupled with atmospheric pressure ionization (API) MS has now become the most powerful tool for the rapid detection, structure elucidation, and quantification of drug-derived material within various biological fluids. Often, however, MS alone is insufficient to identify the exact position of oxidation, to differentiate isomers, or to provide the precise structure of unusual and/or unstable metabolites. In addition, an excess of endogenous material in biological samples often suppress the ionization of drug-related material complicating metabolite identification by MS. In these cases, multiple analytical and wet chemistry techniques, such as LC-NMR, enzymatic hydrolysis, chemical derivatization, and hydrogen/deuterium-exchange (H/D-exchange) combined with MS are used to characterize the novel and isomeric metabolites of drug candidates. This review describes sample preparation and introduction strategies to minimize ion suppression by biological matrices for metabolite identification studies, the application of various LC-tandem MS (LC-MS/MS) techniques for the rapid quantification and identification of drug metabolites, and future trends in this field.

Investigating the in vitro metabolism of fipexide: characterization of reactive metabolites using liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry

The in vitro metabolism of the nootropic drug fipexide was studied using different liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) techniques. This drug has been withdrawn from the market due to toxic effects. No previous reports have investigated the possible involvement of reactive metabolites in the toxicity of fipexide. The hydrolysis of this drug leads to the formation of two potentially toxic species, 3,4-methylenedioxybenzylpiperazine (MDBP) and 4-chlorophenoxyacetic acid (4-CPA). Here, we investigate the in vitro metabolism of fipexide in human, rat, mouse and dog, as well as of MDBP and 4-CPA in human and rat, while focusing on the formation of reactive metabolites. A combination of LC/MS analyses on a hybrid quadrupole-linear ion trap instrument and accurate mass data from QqTOF measurements was employed for the characterization of these metabolites. Microsomal metabolites of fipexide were MDBP, 4-CPA, fipexide N-oxide or hydroxyl, demethylenated fipexide and other minor ones, all of which were investigated by tandem mass spectrometry. Reactive metabolites were detected using several trapping procedures with small molecules such as glutathione, its ethyl ester derivative and N-acetylcysteine. The demethylenated metabolite, a catechol, formed its corresponding ortho-quinone, which readily reacts with these nucleophiles. MDBP was studied in a similar manner, due to its ability to form an analogous catechol. Because of its acidic nature, 4-CPA was assessed for possible acylglucuronide and acyl-CoA thioester metabolites, which could also be involved in bioactivation pathways. Several important metabolites were identified as potential mediators of toxicity via protein binding.

Determining protein adducts of fipexide: mass spectrometry based assay for confirming the involvement of its reactive metabolite in covalent binding

Fipexide is a nootropic drug, withdrawn from the market due to its idiosyncratic drug reactions causing adverse effects in man. Previous work on its metabolites has identified several potential reactive metabolites which could be implicated in protein binding. Here, we investigated the formation of these metabolites in rat and human hepatocytes. Based on these results, the o-quinone of fipexide (FIP), formed via the demethylenation reaction through a catechol intermediate, was chosen for further investigation. Studies were then pursued in order to relate this metabolite to protein binding, and thus better understand potential mechanisms for the toxicity of the parent compound. An assay was developed for determining the fipexide catechol-cysteine adduct in the microsomal protein fractions following in vitro incubations. This method digests the entire protein fraction into amino acids, followed by the detection of the Cys-metabolite adduct by liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS). We have designed a strategy where drug metabolism taking place in microsomal incubations and involved in protein binding can be assessed after the proteins have been digested, with the detection of the specific amino acid adduct. In this study, the structure of the fipexide adduct was hypothesized using knowledge previously gained in glutathione and N-acetylcysteine trapping experiments. Acetaminophen was used as a positive control for detecting a drug metabolite-cysteine adduct by LC/MS. This approach has the potential to be applicable as a protein-binding assay in early drug discovery without the need for radioactive compounds.

Detecting and characterizing reactive metabolites by liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry

Metabolic activation of a drug leading to reactive metabolite(s) that can covalently modify proteins is considered an initial step that may lead to drug-induced organ toxicities. Characterization of reactive metabolites is critical to designing new drug candidates with an improved toxicological profile. High performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) coupled with mass spectrometry (MS) predominates over all analytical tools used for screening and characterization of reactive metabolites. In this review, a brief description of experimental approaches employed for assessing reactive metabolites is followed by a discussion on the reactivity of acyl glucuronides and acyl coenzyme A thioesters. Techniques for high-throughput screening and quantitation of reactive metabolite formation are also described, along with proteomic approaches used to identify protein targets and modification sites by reactive metabolites. Strategies for dealing with reactive metabolites are reviewed. In conclusion, we discuss the challenges and future needs in this field of research.

Applications of cytotoxicity assays and pre-lethal mechanistic assays for assessment of human hepatotoxicity potential

While drug toxicity (especially hepatotoxicity) is the most frequent reason cited for withdrawal of an approved drug, no simple solution exists to adequately predict such adverse events. Simple cytotoxicity assays in HepG2 cells are relatively insensitive to human hepatotoxic drugs in a retrospective analysis of marketed pharmaceuticals. In comparison, a panel of pre-lethal mechanistic cellular assays hold the promise to deliver a more sensitive approach to detect endpoint-specific drug toxicities. The panel of assays covered by this review includes steatosis, cholestasis, phospholipidosis, reactive intermediates, mitochondria membrane function, oxidative stress, and drug interactions. In addition, the use of metabolically competent cells or the introduction of major human hepatocytes in these in vitro studies allow a more complete picture of potential drug side effect. Since inter-individual therapeutic index (TI) may differ from patient to patient, the rational use of one or more of these cellular assay and targeted in vivo exposure data may allow pharmaceutical scientists to select drug candidates with a higher TI potential in the drug discovery phase.

METABOLIC ACTIVATION OF PIOGLITAZONE IDENTIFIED FROM RAT AND HUMAN LIVER MICROSOMES AND FRESHLY ISOLATED HEPATOCYTES

Pioglitazone is in the class of compounds known as the thiazolidinediones and is used to treat type 2 diabetes mellitus. The first in its class compound, troglitazone, was withdrawn from the U.S. market in 2000 due to a high incidence of hepatotoxicity and drug-induced liver failure. Reactive ring-opened products of troglitazone have been identified and evidence suggests that these reactive intermediates might be a potential cause of hepatotoxicity. The present work shows that pioglitazone has a reactive ring-opened product which was trapped by glutathione and positively identified by high performance liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry accurate mass measurements. The novel thiazolidinedione ring-opened products of pioglitazone were identified in rat and human liver microsomes and in freshly isolated rat but not human hepatocytes.

A high-throughput liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry method for screening glutathione conjugates using exact mass neutral loss acquisition

Chemically reactive metabolites may cause hepatotoxicity and as a result liver failure or other adverse side reactions. Therefore, this is a vital topic of interest because early reactive metabolite screening may prevent compound failure at a later stage. In order to address this issue, a screening assay has been developed to detect the formation of reactive metabolites by using glutathione as a trapping reagent, which will allow us to search for phase I metabolites and also glutathiones during in vitro metabolite screening using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) with exact mass. Glutathione conjugations when fragmented by the mass spectrometer give a common loss corresponding to the pyroglutamic acid moiety, which can be monitored. Until recently, this work has been carried out with triple quadrupole technology using nominal mass. The advantage of the hybrid quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer is the selectivity and sensitivity that can be achieved. Exact neutral loss detection is achieved via sequential low- and high-energy MS acquisitions. After detection of the loss of the pyroglutamic acid moiety, using a window of +/-20 mDa on the high-energy scan, MS/MS is carried out on the parent mass of interest to confirm the common neutral loss.

Application of stable isotope labeled glutathione and rapid scanning mass spectrometers in detecting and characterizing reactive metabolites

The formation of reactive metabolites from a number of compounds was studied in vitro using a mixture of non-labeled and stable isotope labeled glutathione (GSH) as a trapping agent. GSH was labeled by incorporating [1,2-(13)C(2),(15)N]glycine into the tripeptide to give an overall increase of 3 Da over the naturally occurring substance. Detection and characterization of reactive metabolites was greatly facilitated by using the data-dependent scanning features of the linear ion trap mass spectrometers to give complimentary and confirmatory data in a single analytical run. A comparison was made by analyzing the samples simultaneously on a triple-stage quadrupole mass spectrometer operated in the constant neutral loss mode. The compounds studied included 2-acetamidophenol, 3-acetamidophenol, 4-acetamidophenol (acetaminophen), and flufenamic acid. GSH adducts for each of these compounds produced a characteristic pattern of 'twin ions' separated by 3 Da in the mass spectral data. This greatly facilitated the detection and characterization of any GSH-related adducts present in the microsomal extracts. Furthermore, characterization of these adducts was greatly facilitated by the rapid scanning capability of linear ion trap instruments that provided full-scan, MS/MS and MS(3) data in one single analysis. This method of detecting and characterizing reactive metabolites generated in vitro was found to be far superior to any of the existing methods previously employed in this laboratory. The combination of two techniques, stable isotope labeled glutathione and linear ion traps, provided a very sensitive and specific method of identifying compounds capable of producing reactive metabolites in a discovery setting. The complimentary set of mass spectral data (including full-scan, MS/MS and MS(3) mass spectra), obtained rapidly in a single analysis with the linear ion trap instruments, greatly accelerated identification of metabolically bioactivated soft spots on the molecules. This in turn enabled chemists to rapidly design out the potential metabolic liability from the back-up compounds by making appropriate structural modifications.

Rapid detection and characterization of minor reactive metabolites using stable-isotope trapping in combination with tandem mass spectrometry

Stable-isotope trapping combined with mass spectrometry (MS) neutral loss scanning has recently been developed as a high-throughput method for the in vitro screening of major reactive metabolites. In fact, detection and identification of minor reactive metabolites are equally important since the minor metabolites, even though at low levels, may be highly reactive and also play an important role in drug-induced adverse reactions. In this study, 2-acetylthiophene, clozapine, troglitazone and 7-methylindole were selected as model compounds to further validate the advantages of this method for rapid detection and structural characterization of minor glutathione (GSH) adducts derived from reactive metabolites. The utility of the current method was clearly demonstrated by successful identification of novel reactive metabolites at low levels and also minor ones either masked by non-specific responses or co-eluted with other conjugates. In comparison with existing methods, this method is sensitive, efficient, and suitable for rapid screening and more complete profiling of reactive metabolites.

The development of a higher throughput reactive intermediate screening assay incorporating micro-bore liquid chromatography–micro-electrospray ionization–tandem mass spectrometry and glutathione ethyl ester as an in vitro conjugating agent

An in vitro reactive intermediate screening assay, incorporating the use of the close analog of glutathione, glutathione ethyl ester (GSH-EE) as a conjugating agent, was developed to identify compounds that form reactive intermediates in an in vitro metabolite generating system. The biological assay consisted of substrate [s] = 10 microM, human liver microsomes, an NADPH generating system and glutathione ethyl ester. Conjugates were extracted from the biological matrix using a combination of protein precipitation and a semi-automated 96-well plate solid phase extraction (SPE) procedure. A micro-bore liquid chromatography-micro-electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry (microLC-microESI-MS/MS) method detected glutathione ethyl ester conjugates using selected reaction monitoring (SRM) to simultaneously monitor for multiple MH+ to [MH - 129]+ transitions, where the 129 mass unit (Da) represents the neutral loss of the pyroglutamate moiety from GSH-EE. The multiple MH+ to [MH - 129]+ transitions (SRM mass table) were generated for potential reactive intermediates of each compound. Glutathione (GSH) and GSH-EE conjugate standards were used to evaluate MS detection sensitivity. Based on direct comparison of standard curve data, an approximate 10-fold increase in sensitivity was observed for conjugates containing GSH-EE moiety versus GSH. In vitro experiments were conducted using literature substrates acetaminophen, rosiglitazone, clozapine, diclofenac and either GSH-EE or GSH as a reactive intermediate conjugating agent. An increase in detection sensitivity was observed for each GSH-EE conjugate and in the case of acetaminophen-GSH-EE the peak area increase was approximately 80-fold. Twelve drug compounds, each having known biotransformation mechanisms, were used to further test the detection capabilities of the assay and establish a concordance to literature data. When GSH was used in the assay, conjugates were detected for 4 out of the 12 test compounds (33%). When GSH-EE was used in the assay, conjugates were detected for 10 out of the 12 test compounds (83%).

Strategies for dealing with metabolite elucidation in drug discovery and development

Structural information on metabolites can be a considerable asset for enhancing and streamlining the process of developing new drug candidates. Modern approaches that generate and use metabolite structural information can accelerate the drug discovery and development process by eliminating potentially harmful candidates earlier in the process and improving the safety of new drugs. This review examines the relative merits of current and potential strategies for dealing with metabolite characterization.

Addressing the metabolic activation potential of new leads in drug discovery: a case study using ion trap mass spectrometry and tritium labeling techniques

Metabolic activation of drug candidates to electrophilic reactive metabolites that can covalently modify cellular macromolecules may result in acute and/or idiosyncratic immune system-mediated toxicities in humans. This presents a significant potential liability for the future development of these compounds as safe therapeutic agents. We present here an example of an approach where sites of metabolic activation within a new drug candidate series were rapidly identified using online liquid chromatography/multi-stage mass spectrometry on an ion trap mass spectrometer. This was accomplished by trapping the reactive intermediates formed upon incubation of compounds with rat and human liver microsomes as their corresponding glutathione conjugates and mass spectral characterization of these thiol adducts. Based on the structures of the GSH adducts identified, potential sites and mechanisms of bioactivation within the chemical structure were proposed. These metabolism studies were interfaced with iterative structural modifications of the chemical series in order to block these bioactivation sites within the molecule. This strategy led to a significant reduction in the propensity of the compounds to undergo metabolic activation as evidenced by reductions in the irreversible binding of radioactivity to liver microsomal material upon incubation of tritium-labeled compounds with this in vitro system. With the efficiency and throughput achievable with such an approach, it appears feasible to identify and address the metabolic activation potential of new drug leads during routine metabolite identification studies in an early drug discovery setting.