Molecular pathways to parallel evolution: I. Gene nexuses and their morphological correlates

Emerging Frontiers in the Study of Molecular Evolution

A collection of the editors of Journal of Molecular Evolution have gotten together to pose a set of key challenges and future directions for the field of molecular evolution. Topics include challenges and new directions in prebiotic chemistry and the RNA world, reconstruction of early cellular genomes and proteins, macromolecular and functional evolution, evolutionary cell biology, genome evolution, molecular evolutionary ecology, viral phylodynamics, theoretical population genomics, somatic cell molecular evolution, and directed evolution. While our effort is not meant to be exhaustive, it reflects research questions and problems in the field of molecular evolution that are exciting to our editors.

Highly conserved elements discovered in vertebrates are present in non-syntenic loci of tunicates, act as enhancers and can be transcribed during development

Co-option of cis-regulatory modules has been suggested as a mechanism for the evolution of expression sites during development. However, the extent and mechanisms involved in mobilization of cis-regulatory modules remains elusive. To trace the history of non-coding elements, which may represent candidate ancestral cis-regulatory modules affirmed during chordate evolution, we have searched for conserved elements in tunicate and vertebrate (Olfactores) genomes. We identified, for the first time, 183 non-coding sequences that are highly conserved between the two groups. Our results show that all but one element are conserved in non-syntenic regions between vertebrate and tunicate genomes, while being syntenic among vertebrates. Nevertheless, in all the groups, they are significantly associated with transcription factors showing specific functions fundamental to animal development, such as multicellular organism development and sequence-specific DNA binding. The majority of these regions map onto ultraconserved elements and we demonstrate that they can act as functional enhancers within the organism of origin, as well as in cross-transgenesis experiments, and that they are transcribed in extant species of Olfactores. We refer to the elements as 'Olfactores conserved non-coding elements'.

Parallel evolution controlled by adaptation and covariation in ammonoid cephalopods

Background

A major goal in evolutionary biology is to understand the processes that shape the evolutionary trajectory of clades. The repeated and similar large-scale morphological evolutionary trends of distinct lineages suggest that adaptation by means of natural selection (functional constraints) is the major cause of parallel evolution, a very common phenomenon in extinct and extant lineages. However, parallel evolution can result from other processes, which are usually ignored or difficult to identify, such as developmental constraints. Hence, understanding the underlying processes of parallel evolution still requires further research.

Results

Herein, we present a possible case of parallel evolution between two ammonoid lineages (Auguritidae and Pinacitidae) of Early-Middle Devonian age (405-395 Ma), which are extinct cephalopods with an external, chambered shell. In time and through phylogenetic order of appearance, both lineages display a morphological shift toward more involute coiling (i.e. more tightly coiled whorls), larger adult body size, more complex suture line (the folded walls separating the gas-filled buoyancy-chambers), and the development of an umbilical lid (a very peculiar extension of the lateral shell wall covering the umbilicus) in the most derived taxa. Increased involution toward shells with closed umbilicus has been demonstrated to reflect improved hydrodynamic properties of the shell and thus likely results from similar natural selection pressures. The peculiar umbilical lid might have also added to the improvement of the hydrodynamic properties of the shell. Finally, increasing complexity of suture lines likely results from covariation induced by trends of increasing adult size and whorl overlap given the morphogenetic properties of the suture.

Conclusions

The morphological evolution of these two Devonian ammonoid lineages follows a near parallel evolutionary path for some important shell characters during several million years and through their phylogeny. Evolution of some traits (involution, umbilical lid) appears to be mainly driven by adaptation to improve the hydrodynamic properties of the shell, whereas other characters (sutural complexity) evolved due to covariation with features that play a central role in the morphogenesis of mollusc shells. This example provides evidence that parallel evolution can be driven simultaneously by different factors such as covariation (constructional constraints) and adaptation (natural selection).

Molecular analysis and characterization of zebrafish keratocan (zKera) gene

Corneal small leucine-rich proteoglycans play a pivotal role in maintaining corneal transparency and function. In this study, we isolated and characterized the zebrafish (Danio rerio) keratocan (zKera) gene. The human keratocan sequence was used to search zebrafish homologues. The zKera full-length genomic DNA and cDNA were generated via PCR of zebrafish genomic DNA and reverse transcription-PCR of total zebrafish eye RNA, respectively. The zKera spanning 3.5 kilobase pairs consists of two exons and one intron and a TATA-less promoter. The zKera encodes 341 amino acids with 59% identity to its human counterpart and 57% identity to that of mouse keratocan. Like mouse and chick keratocan, zKera mRNA is selectively expressed in the adult cornea; however, during embryonic development, zKera mRNA is expressed in both the brain and the cornea. Interestingly, it is expressed mainly in corneal epithelium but also in the stroma. A pseudogene was proved by introducing a zKera promoter-driven enhanced green fluorescence protein reporter gene into fertilized zebrafish eggs. Using morpholino-antisense against zKera to knock down zKera resulted in a lethal phenotype due to massive caspase-dependent apoptosis, which was noted by a significant increase of active caspase-3 and caspase-8 in the developing forebrain area, including the eyes. This is different from mouse, for which keratocan-deficient mice are viable. Taken together, our data indicate that mammalian keratocan is conserved in zebrafish in terms of gene structure, expression pattern, and promoter function.

Intelligent design and biological complexity

Before any intelligence can appear, a world endowed with the potential for being experienced as a body of phenomena has to be existent. Indeed, if there is to be an intelligence, there first has to be something intelligible. Hence, when an intelligence is present, "creation" must already have taken place. Nevertheless, biological complexity has been deemed by some to be one of the privileged points of insertion of a supernatural intelligence endowed with temporal and causal primacy. In the course of a critical review, it is pointed out that the spectacle of nature's spontaneous tinkering with the structures and performances of informational macromolecules and with interactive connections among these molecules suggests that intelligence and design are absent from evolution. Nor is intelligent design required for explaining biological complexity, which can increase spontaneously as a byproduct of combinatorial intermolecular gambles and of the restoration of molecular damage wrought by mutations. One of the possible molecular pathways to spontaneous evolutionary increases in complexity is described.

Regulatory network for cell shape changes during Drosophila ventral furrow formation

Rapid and sequential cell shape changes take place during the formation of the ventral furrow (VF) at the beginning of Drosophila gastrulation. At the cellular level, this morphogenetic event demands close coordination of the proteins involved in actin cytoskeletal reorganization. In order to construct a regulatory network that describes these cell shape changes, we have used published genetic and molecular data for 18 genes encoding transcriptional regulators and signaling pathway components. Based on the dynamic behavior of this network we explored the hypothesis that the combination of three recognizable phenotypes describing wild type or mutant cell types, during VF invagination, correspond to different activation states of a specific set of these gene products, which are point attractors of the regulatory network. From our results, we recognize missing components in the regulatory network and suggest alternative pathways in the regulation of cell shape changes during VF formation.

Adaptive evolution of cytochrome c oxidase: Infrastructure for a carnivorous plant radiation

Much recent attention in the study of adaptation of organismal form has centered on developmental regulation. As such, the highly conserved respiratory machinery of eukaryotic cells might seem an unlikely target for selection supporting novel morphologies. We demonstrate that a dramatic molecular evolutionary rate increase in subunit I of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) from an active-trapping lineage of carnivorous plants is caused by positive Darwinian selection. Bladderworts (Utricularia) trap plankton when water-immersed, negatively pressured suction bladders are triggered. The resetting of traps involves active ion transport, requiring considerable energy expenditure. As judged from the quaternary structure of bovine COX, the most profound adaptive substitutions are two contiguous cysteines absent in approximately 99.9% of databased COX I sequences from Eukaryota, Archaea, and Bacteria. This motif lies directly at the docking point of COX I helix 3 and cytochrome c, and modeling of bovine COX I suggests the possibility of an unprecedented helix-terminating disulfide bridge that could alter COX/cytochrome c dissociation kinetics. Thus, the key adaptation in Utricularia likely lies in molecular energetic changes that buttressed the mechanisms responsible for the bladderworts' radical morphological evolution. Along with evidence for COX evolution underlying expansion of the anthropoid neocortex, our findings underscore that important morphological and physiological innovations must often be accompanied by specific adaptations in proteins with basic cellular functions.

Pax 6: mastering eye morphogenesis and eye evolution

Pax 6 genes from various animal phyla are capable of inducing ectopic eye development, indicating that Pax 6 is a master control gene for eye morphogenesis. It is proposed that the various eye-types found in metazoa are derived from a common prototype, monophyletically, by a mechanism called intercalary evolution.

Evolutionary dissociations between homologous genes and homologous structures

Phenotype is encoded in the genome in an indirect manner: each morphological structure is the product of many interacting genes, and most regulatory genes have several distinct developmental roles and phenotypic consequences. The lack of a simple and consistent relationship between homologous genes and structures has important implications for understanding correlations between evolutionary changes at different levels of biological organization. Data from a variety of organisms are beginning to provide intriguing glimpses of the complex evolutionary relationship between genotype and phenotype. Much attention has been devoted to remarkably conserved relationships between homologous genes and structures. However, there is increasing evidence that several kinds of evolutionary dissociations can evolve between genotype and phenotype, some of which are quite unexpected. The existence of these dissocations limits the degree to which it is possible make inferences about the homology of structures based solely on the expression of homologous genes.

Establishing homology criteria for regulatory gene networks: prospects and challenges

One of the most remarkable discoveries to emerge from the field of developmental genetics is the observation that many regulatory genes and segments of their interactive networks (pathways) appear to have been conserved in several metazoan phyla. Determining whether these conserved regulatory networks are homologous, i.e. derived from an equivalent network in the most recent common ancestor, is critical to understanding comparisons between model system studies, and the evolution of metazoan body plans. To this end, I outline some of the evolutionary properties of regulatory networks, and propose both similarity and phylogenetic criteria that can be used to test the hypothesis that two regulatory networks are homologous. Furthermore, I propose that genetic networks can be treated as a distinct level of biological organization, and can be analysed together with other hierarchical levels, such as genes, embryonic origins and morphological structures, in a comparative framework. Examples from the literature, particularly the genetic regulatory networks involved in patterning arthropod and vertebrate limbs, are examined using the proposed criteria and hierarchical approach.

When is homology not homology?

Although genes have specific phenotypic consequences in a given species, this functional relationship can clearly change during the course of evolution. Many cases of evolutionary dissociations between homologous genes and homologous morphological features are now known. These dissociations have interesting and important implications for understanding the genetic basis for evolutionary change in morphology.

The sperm nuclear basic proteins (SNBPs) of the sponge Neofibularia nolitangere: implications for the molecular evolution of SNBPs

We have isolated and characterized for the first time, the SNBPs from an organism (Neofibularia nolitangere) of the phylum Porifera (Sponges). We have shown that these proteins consist of histones which, as expected, exhibit an amino acid composition very similar to that of other eukaryotic histones. The finding of histones in the sperm of these primitive organisms provides support to the notion that histones (SNBPs of the histone, H, type) were the proteins present at the onset of SNBP evolution. In contrast, a discrete number of alternative SNBP types (protamine-like, PL; protamine, P, types) seem to have appeared later on in the course of evolution and are found in both protostomes and deuterostomes, most likely as a result of processes of parallel evolution.

Squid Pax-6 and eye development

Pax-6 in vertebrates and its homolog eyeless in Drosophila are known to be essential for eye development. Here we investigate the role of Pax-6 in eye development in another major systematic group, molluscs. We demonstrate that alternatively spliced RNAs derived from a single Pax-6 gene in the squid (Loligo opalescens) are expressed in the embryonic eye, olfactory organ, brain, and arms. Despite significant sequence differences between squid Pax-6 and Drosophila eyeless in the region outside the paired- and homeodomains, squid Pax-6 is able to induce the formation of ectopic eyes in Drosophila. Our results support the idea that Pax-6 related genes are necessary for eye and olfactory system formation throughout the animal kingdom.

Neutral and nonneutral mutations: the creative mix--evolution of complexity in gene interaction systems

Random drift, while indifferent to the functionality of the molecular features on which it acts, may nevertheless affect evolving molecular mechanisms. It can lead to functional novelty in either gene structure or regulation. In particular, a nearly neutral (in the sense of Ohta), somewhat deleterious mutation can result in a loss of efficiency in gene regulation, and this loss is expected at times to be compensated by a selected event of a particular type: the use of an additional regulatory factor. An accumulation of additional regulatory factors, implying a combination of events of drift and selection, can permit regulatory systems to achieve an increase in both specificity and complexity as mere byproducts of a particular repair process. Nearly neutral mutations thus may, at times, constitute a required pathway for increases in gene interaction complexity. The process seems to point to an inbuilt drive-built into the gene interaction system itself-toward the evolution of higher organisms. This is a matter worthy of experimental exploration, since the general foundations for the evolution of "higher" from "lower" organisms seems so far to have largely eluded analysis.

Chicken homeobox gene Prox 1 related to Drosophila prospero is expressed in the developing lens and retina

Prox 1 is the vertebrate homolog of Drosophila prospero, a gene known to be expressed in the lens-secreting cone cells of fly ommatidia. Chicken Prox 1 cDNAs were isolated from 14 day embryonic chicken lenses, and a complete open reading frame encoding an 83 kDa protein was elucidated. The homeodomains of chicken and mouse Prox 1 are identical at the amino acid level and are 65-67% similar to the homeodomains of Drosophila and C. elegans prospero. The homology between these proteins extends beyond the homeodomain. There is 56% identity between chicken Prox 1 and Drosophila prospero in the C-terminal region downstream of the homeodomain, whereas there is little similarity upstream of the homeodomain. Prox 1 is expressed most actively in the developing lens and midgut and at lower levels in the developing brain, heart, muscle, and retina. cDNA sequencing has established that there are alternatively spliced forms of the single Prox 1 gene, which probably account for the two abundant RNAs of about 2 and 8 kb and two less abundant RNAs close to 3.5 kb in length in the lens. In the lens fibers, only the shortest mRNA was present, whereas, in the epithelial cells, both short and long mRNAs were detected. By using in situ hybridization, expression of the Prox 1 gene was first detected at stage 14 in the early lens placode and slightly preceded the expression of delta 1-crystallin, the first crystallin gene expressed in the developing chicken lens. At later stages of development, Prox 1 mRNA was observed throughout the lens, but it appeared more abundant around the bow region of the equator than in the anterior epithelium or the fibers. In the retina, expression of the Prox 1 gene was detected mainly in the inner nuclear layer during later stages of histogenesis. The conserved pattern of Prox 1/prospero gene expression in vertebrates and Drosophila suggests that Prox 1, like Pax-6, may be essential for eye development in different systematic groups.

The role of constrained self-organization in genome structural evolution

A hypothesis of genome structural evolution is explored. Rapid and cohesive alterations in genome organization are viewed as resulting from the dynamic and constrained interactions of chromosomal subsystem components. A combination of macromolecular boundary conditions and DNA element involvement in far-from-equilibrium reactions is proposed to increase the complexity of genomic subsystems via the channelling of genome turnover; interactions between subsystems create higher-order subsystems expanding the phase space for further genetic evolution. The operation of generic constraints on structuration in genome evolution is suggested by i) universal, homoplasic features of chromosome organization and ii) the metastable nature of genome structures where lower-level flux is constrained by higher-order structures. Phenomena such as 'genomic shock', bursts of transposable element activity, concerted evolution, etc., are hypothesized to result from constrained systemic responses to endogenous/exogenous, micro/macro perturbations. The constraints operating on genome turnover are expected to increase with chromosomal structural complexity, the number of interacting subsystems, and the degree to which interactions between genomic components are tightly ordered.

Lens crystallins of invertebrates--diversity and recruitment from detoxification enzymes and novel proteins

The major proteins (crystallins) of the transparent, refractive eye lens of vertebrates are a surprisingly diverse group of multifunctional proteins. A number of lens crystallins display taxon-specificity. In general, vertebrate crystallins have been recruited from stress-protective proteins (i.e. the small heat-shock proteins) and a number of metabolic enzymes by a gene-sharing mechanism. Despite the existence of refractive lenses in the complex and compound eyes of many invertebrates, relatively little is known about their crystallins. Here we review for the first time the state of knowledge of invertebrate crystallins. The major cephalopod (squid, octopus, and cuttlefish) crystallins (S-crystallins) have, like vertebrate crystallins, been recruited from a stress protective metabolic enzyme, glutathione S-transferase. The presence of overlapping AP-1 and antioxidant responsive-like sequences that appear functional in transfected vertebrate cells suggest that the recruitment of glutathione S-transferase to S-crystallins involved response to oxidative stress. Cephalopods also have at least two taxon-specific crystallins: omega-crystallin, related to aldehyde dehydrogenase, and omega-crystallin, related to a superfamily of lipid-binding proteins. L-crystallin (probably identical to O-crystallin) is the major protein of the lens of the squid photophore, a specialized structure for emitting light. The use of L/omega-crystallin in the ectodermal lens of the eye and the mesodermal lens of the photophore of the squid contrasts with the recruitment of different crystallins in the ectodermal lenses of the eye and photophore of fish. S-and omega-crystallins appear to be lens-specific (some S-crystallins are also expressed in cornea) and, except for one S-crystallin polypeptide (SL11/Lops4; possibly a molecular fossil), lack enzymatic activity. The S-crystallins (except SL11/Lops4) contain a variable peptide that has been inserted by exon shuffling. The only other invertebrate crystallins that have been examined are in one marine gastropod (Aplysia, a sea hare), in jellyfish and in the compound eyes of some arthropods; all are different and novel proteins. Drosocrystallin is one of three calcium binding taxon-specific crystallins found selectively in the acellular corneal lens of Drosophila, while antigen 3G6 is a highly conserved protein present in the ommatidial crystallin cone and central nervous system of numerous arthropods. Cubomedusan jellyfish have three novel crystallin families (the J-crystallins); the J1-crystallins are encoded in three very similar intronless genes with markedly different 5' flanking sequences despite their almost identical encoded proteins and high lens expression. The numerous refractive structures that have evolved in the eyes of invertebrates contrast markedly with the limited information on their protein composition, making this field as exciting as it is underdeveloped. The similar requirement of Pax-6 (and possibly other common transcription factors) for eye development as well as the diversity, taxon-specificity and recruitment of stress-protective enzymes as crystallins suggest that borrowing multifunctional proteins for refraction by a gene sharing strategy may have occurred in invertebrates as did in vertebrates.