Lysis of autologous human melanoma cells by in vitro allosensitized peripheral blood lymphocytes

Inhibition of Human Melanoma Growth in Nude Mice by Autologous, Alloactivated Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes

Peripheral blood lymphocytes of melanoma patients were stimulated in vitro by a pool of allogeneic lymphocytes and shown to be cytotoxic against autologous melanoma cells. To evaluate the in vivo antitumor activity of the cytotoxic alloactivated autologous peripheral blood lymphocytes, tumor neutralization (Winn) assay was carried out by injecting such lymphocytes admixed with autologous melanoma cells in athymic BALB/c nude mice. In 3 of 6 cases, complete inhibition of tumor growth was obtained at lymphocytes to tumor cells ratio of 10:1 and in one case also of 5:1. In all cases the appearance of tumors was delayed and the growth rate was significantly reduced in a dose-dependent fashion as compared to control mice injected with tumor cells alone. We conclude that in vitro alloactivated peripheral blood lymphocytes can inhibit and/or impair the growth of autologous melanoma cells in nude mice.

Killer cells induced by stimulation with allogeneic tumor cells and subsequent culture with recombinant interleukin-2

Peripheral blood lymphocytes were cultured for 5 days with allogeneic tumor cells (allogeneic mixed lymphocyte/tumor cell culture), and subsequently cultured with recombinant interleukin-2 for 12 days. These cultured cells were found to be cytotoxic to autologous tumor cells. Results of two-color analysis using monoclonal antibodies to cell markers showed that more than 80% of their cultured cells were CD3+ cells, and CD4+ cells showed a higher distribution than CD8+ cells. However, CD8+ cells had a much higher killing activity with autologous tumor than did CD4+ cells, when estimated by an elimination study using monoclonal antibodies to T cell phenotypes and complement. The "cold-target" inhibition test showed that the cytotoxicity of these cells for autologous tumor cells was inhibited by unlabeled autologous tumor cells but not by unlabeled stimulator cells. Furthermore, about 40% of the cytotoxicity was suppressed by blocking of HLA class I antigen with a monoclonal antibody on autologous tumor cells. Thus, cytotoxic activity of lymphocytes to autologous tumor restricted by target cell HLA class I antigen is possibly induced by allogeneic tumor-stimulation.

Chromosome abnormalities and fragile sites in human melanoma

Chromosome analysis in short-term lines of three primary and seven metastatic malignant melanomas showed aneuploid karyotypes with recurrent abnormalities of chromosomes 1 (five cell lines), 6 (nine cell lines), and 7 (six cell lines). The breakpoints observed on the rearranged chromosomes frequently coincided with loci of known oncogenes and fragile sites. Two of the cell lines were analyzed after xenograft into nude mice and showed the presence of the same chromosomal changes observed in the parental cell lines, indicating the stability of the karyotype. A tendency toward an increased chromosomal fragility in peripheral blood lymphocytes was observed in five melanoma patients compared to ten normal individuals. However, there was no increased level of expression of specific fragile sites corresponding to the breakpoints observed in melanoma cells.

High incidence of chromosomal lesions involving C-heterochromatin in four human melanoma lines

Cytogenetic analysis of early in vitro cultures derived from human melanomas, two primary tumors (Me 10538, Me 1402) and two metastatic lesions in the same patient (Me 665/1, Me 665/2) showed non-random involvement of C-heterochromatin in clonal chromosome rearrangements. Marker chromosomes with C- and DA-Dapi-positive bands were identified in one of the metastases, Me 665/1 (m1) and in the two primary tumors, Me 10538 (m2) and Me 1402 (m3). C-positive fragments predominated in the other metastasis, Me 665/2, which lacked C-regions intercalated in rearranged chromosomes, and were also detected with appreciable frequency in the Me 665/1 and Me 1402 cells. The frequencies of marker chromosomes and their mean number per cell allowed m2 and m1 to be considered as early markers of tumor formation and m3 as a marker of tumor progression. Dissection of chromosome structure, including the origin of the intercalated C-band, has so far been achieved only with the m2 chromosome of the primary tumor Me10538. This was the only cell line which displayed few C-fragments and a narrow chromosomal distribution with a well defined mode. A gradient of malignancy could be detected in the four cell lines, by local and disseminated tumor growth in xenotransplanted mice, with the two primary melanomas 10538 and the 1402 cells at the lowest and upper extremes. This gradient closely parallels the increase in cytogenetic heterogeneity and C-heterochromatin lesions from the 10538 to the 1402 cells.

Proliferative and/or cytotoxic activity of lymphocyte clones to autologous human melanoma

Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of a patient with metastatic melanoma were cultured with autologous melanoma cells (Auto-Me) and recombinant interleukin 2 (IL-2) (MLTC-PBL). Thirty-five days later, when no cytotoxicity against Auto-Me or K562 was detectable, MLTC-PBL were cloned in the presence of Auto-Me, IL-2 (25 U/ml) and Daudi cells as feeder. Eighty-one growing clones were simultaneously screened for proliferative and cytotoxic activity to Auto-Me. Twenty-two clones proliferated in the presence of Auto-Me only, 29 in the presence of IL-2 only and 41 in the presence of Auto-Me plus IL-2; 12 clones showed cytotoxic activity against Auto-Me. Six clones expressed both cytotoxic and proliferative activity to Auto-Me. The phenotype of 6 proliferative clones tested was CD3+, CD4+, WT31+, CD8-, CD16-, Leu19-, whereas that of 2 cytotoxic-proliferative clones tested was CD3+, CD8+, Leu19+, WT31+, CD4-, CD16-. Specificity analysis of proliferative response of 6 clones and of cytotoxicity of 7 clones, tested on a panel of 14 different target cells, revealed a complex pattern of reactivity, each clone expressing a peculiar specificity. Our results suggest the possibility of isolating, from melanoma patients' PBL, T-cell clones with proliferative activity to Auto-Me and Auto-Me plus IL-2, and T-cell clones which apparently express both proliferative and cytotoxic activity to Auto-Me.

Lack of suppressive activity of human primary melanoma cells on the activation of autologous lymphocytes

Previous studies have indicated that primary but not metastatic melanomas were able to stimulate the proliferation of autologous (Auto) peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in 73% of cases. On the other hand, 57% of the metastatic melanomas were shown to be suppressive when melanoma cells (Me) were admixed with Auto-PBL stimulated with allogeneic (Allo) PBL or interleukin 2 (IL-2) at the beginning of a 6-day incubation period. Here, we report that the suppressive activity of Me is a functional characteristic associated with a particular stage of the disease. In fact, we found that none of the 11 primary tumors tested were able to inhibit the proliferative response of Auto-PBL to Allo-PBL or IL-2 at all the doses of tumor cells used. The generation of lymphocytes cytotoxic against Auto-Me or K562 was also not inhibited. Of the 11 primary tumors checked for suppression, 8 were able to stimulate Auto-PBL in a primary mixed lymphocyte tumor culture. We conclude that opposite functions, stimulation and inhibition of autologous lymphocyte responses are characteristics of primary and metastatic Me, respectively.

Melanoma cell lysis by human CTL clones: differential involvement of T3, T8 and HLA antigens

Three lymphocyte clones, derived by micromanipulation from peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of a melanoma patient and expressing a broad pattern of reactivity against different target cells, were analyzed for the involvement of T-cell markers and HLA antigens in the lysis of target cells by blocking experiments with a panel of monoclonal antibodies (MAbs). The clones lysed autologous melanoma cells (Me 28) and 18 out of 22 allogeneic targets including neoplastic and normal cells of different histological origin. Anti-T3 and anti-T8 MAbs strongly inhibited the cytotoxicity of the lymphocyte clones against Me 28, 3 allogeneic melanomas and 3 carcinomas, but failed to affect the lysis of K562. Anti-HLA class-I MAb (w6/32) produced a significant enhancement of the lysis of Me 28 by the 3 clones without modifying cytotoxicity against one allogeneic melanoma or against K562 cells. Anti-HLA class-II MAb (D1.12) did not affect the lysis of the same targets by the 3 clones. These results thus indicate that some anti-melanoma CTL clones may interact with autologous tumor cells by the T3 and T8 structures in an HLA class-I unrestricted manner.

Role of MHC class-I antigens and the CD3 complex in the lysis of autologous human tumours by T-cell clones

Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of 4 patients with malignant effusions were stimulated for 6 days with purified autologous tumour cells, before isolation of the lymphoblasts and cloning by limiting dilution in interleukin-2 (IL-2). Forty-five clones were analyzed for cytotoxicity (CTX) against autologous, allogeneic tumour and erythromyeloid K562 cells of known status with respect to expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens, estimated by reaction with the W6/32 (anti HLA, -A, -B, -C monomorphic) and TDR 31.1 (anti HLA-DR) monoclonal antibodies (MAb). All 45 clones were CD3+. Twenty-five (56%) of them were cytotoxic for at least one target; 24 were autoreactive (restricted in 7); 17 were alloreactive; 16 were K562 reactive. Under comparable conditions autoreactivity was partially blocked by W6/32 in 12/20 effector:target combinations; alloreactivity in 8/13 and K562 reactivity in 0/14. Modulation of effector cell surface CD3 antigens by OKT3 monitored by flow cytometry reduced autoreactivity in 9/14 combinations, alloreactivity in 2/6 and K562 reactivity in 0/4. W6/32 blocking and T3 modulation of cytotoxicity were almost invariably concordant against the same target. The data suggest that, to accomplish lysis of autologous and allogeneic tumour targets, certain clones require MHC recognition and a functional CD3 complex, while for others with similar target cell repertoires, there is no such requirement. It is possible that T-cell clones responding to a tumour-associated antigen (TAA) in the context of self MHC antigens can also respond to an allogeneic class-I product in the absence of TAA, and/or that aberrant class-I antigen expression on autologous tumours accounts for the alloreactivity.

Production of stable cytolytic T-cell clones directed against autologous human melanoma

We have attempted to optimize the production of stable human cytolytic T lymphocyte clones directed against autologous melanoma cell lines. MLTC were restimulated every week with irradiated melanoma cells in medium containing human serum and IL-2. After 21 to 35 days, in 5 out of 6 patients, these cultures expressed a preferential cytolytic activity against the autologous melanoma cells, as compared to autologous EBV-B cells or NK target K562. Limiting dilution of MLTC responder cells was performed at times varying from days 7 to 28, in medium containing IL-2 and allogeneic EBV-B cells as feeders. Approximately 1% of these responder cells gave rise to CTL clones that lysed the autologous melanoma cells, but did not lyse K562 or autologous B cells. It was possible to maintain in culture for several months a large number of CTL clones that retained this specificity with high activity, and multiplied more than 5-fold every week. Some of these CTL clones were dependent on the presence of the autologous melanoma cells for their growth. With one melanoma, the use of autologous CTL clones made it possible to identify 3 different antigens on the tumor cells.

Control of human melanoma growth in nude mice by autologous allo-activated peripheral blood lymphocytes

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were activated in vitro by means of a pool of allogeneic PBL from normal donors and then evaluated for in vivo activity against human melanoma cells xenografted in splenectomized and irradiated athymic (nude) mice. The subcutaneous (s.c.) growth of human melanoma cells was inhibited by intravenous (i.v.) injection, 2 hr later, of such allo-activated, autologous and allogeneic PBL in 7/8 and in 6/9 mice respectively. Unstimulated PBL were ineffective. When allo-activated patients' lymphocytes were administered 3 days after s.c. implantation of autologous melanoma cells, inhibition of tumor growth was observed in 1/6 mice. A significant delay in tumor appearance was noted in the remaining animals. Unstimulated as well as allo-activated, lymphokine-releasing helper-enriched human PBL had no effect on melanoma xenografts, indicating that the tumor inhibition by tumor-cytotoxic allo-activated PBL was not due to recruitment of murine immuno-competent cells by human lymphokines. These results indicate that allo-stimulated, tumor-cytotoxic human PBL given i.v. to nude mice can circulate and inhibit the growth of autologous or allogeneic human melanoma cells implanted s.c.

Phenotypic profile of clones from early cultures of human metastatic melanomas and its modulation by recombinant interferon gamma

Fifty-six tumor clones isolated by cloning in soft agar from early cultures (before the 10th in vitro passage) of two different human metastatic melanomas (Me9229 and Me28) were characterized by FACS analysis for surface expression of class-I and class-II HLA antigens and of melanoma-associated antigens (MAA) with a panel of 15 monoclonal antibodies (MAbs). A marked phenotypic heterogeneity involving MAA and/or HLA markers was observed among the clones derived from both tumors. The differences among the tumor clones and between them and the uncloned melanoma were qualitative and quantitative for each antigen considered. Clones derived from Me9229 expressed the same HLA profile as the parental culture (class I+, class II-) while strong heterogeneity was observed for MAA expression. Clones from Me28 presented a marked heterogeneity for class-I and class-II HLA antigens but were more homogeneous for MAA. The phenotype of the clones was repeatedly checked over the first month in culture and found to remain generally unchanged and not linked to the cell cycle. However, major changes in antigenic expression of the clones could be observed upon treatment with recombinant interferon-gamma (rIFN-gamma): class-I and -II HLA antigens could be induced or augmented while a moderate inhibition was seen on MAA expression. Furthermore, an apparent hierarchy in expression and/or induction of class-II antigens by rIFN-gamma was observed among the tumor clones. DR antigens were more frequently expressed (Me28 clones) and upon treatment with rIFN-gamma reached higher levels than DP and DQ products. Taken together these results indicate that antigenic heterogeneity for MAA and HLA antigens can be detected in cells isolated from early cultures of human metastatic melanomas and suggest that the original uncloned tumor might be considered as a complex mixed population made up of a number of neoplastic cells each expressing a distinct phenotype which can be modulated by lymphokines such as IFN-gamma.

Infusion of Autologous Alloactivated Lymphocytes in Melanoma Patients: Toxicity and Immunologic Monitoring

Previous work has shown that infusion of autologous helper-enriched, alloactivated lymphocytes in melanoma patients may induce, in addition to other mild signs of toxicity, a transient but sharp elevation of blood pressure. To avoid such a disturbing symptom, the in vitro protocol of peripheral blood lymphocyte activation has been modified. In the present study we show that such a modification has led to a lower toxicity of autologous lymphocyte infusion in 4 melanoma patients; in particular, hypertension was no longer observed. In addition, an immunologic monitoring was carried out in these patients. In 1 of 4 patients the treatment enhanced the in vitro cytotoxic activity of peripheral blood lymphocytes against autologous tumor cells. Other parameters such as NK activity and T4/T8 ratio did not show significant trends. The possible implications of these findings for clinical trials of adoptive immunotherapy with lymphocytes are discussed.

Systemic administration of autologous, alloactivated helper-enriched lymphocytes to patients with metastatic melanoma of the lung. A phase I study

A phase I study was carried out to test the feasibility and toxicity of infusing large numbers of autologous, alloactivated helper lymphocytes into patients with metastatic melanoma. Patient peripheral blood lymphocytes (Pt-PBL) obtained by lymphopheresis and expressing the helper phenotype BT5/9 were separated and stimulated for 48 or 72 h with a pool of PBL from four to six healthy donors. Patients were then infused with such activated lymphocytes over a 2-3 h period. A total of 4 phereses and infusions (2/week for 2 weeks) were carried out for each cycle in each patient. Of the five patients treated, two received a second round of infusions. Infusion of autologous PBL stimulated in vitro for 48 h caused chills, fever, headache, and increased blood pressure. All symptoms disappeared in 2-3 h and were easily controlled by appropriate therapy. When lymphocytes were given after 72 h of allostimulation, no or very mild toxicity was observed. Serum chemistry, coagulation, autoimmunity, and urine analysis showed no gross abnormalities during therapy or follow-up of the patients. Immunological parameters (OKT4/OKT8 ratio, NK activity and cytotoxic T cell activity to autologous melanoma) were evaluated before starting the therapy, during its course and during the 3 to 6 months follow-up. The OKT4/OKT8 ratio increased significantly but transiently soon after the first course of infusions in one of the two patients tested. NK activity increased after 75-100 days in the three patients tested and in one of them it was high even after 180 days. No correlation between NK activity and prognosis was apparent. Cytotoxicity to autologous tumor was assessed in two patients, only of one of whom exhibited an increased activity from 75 to 180 days, which was associated with a prognosis better than that of the negative patient. Five patients were treated: two had progressive disease, two had stable disease for 5 and 6 months, respectively. In the first of these patients, a new cycle of lymphocyte infusions was carried out which caused a measurable reduction of lung tumor nodules whose growth, however, resumed 4 months later. This patient died 14 months after the onset of therapy. The fifth patient had a partial regression of pulmonary and intracranial metastases after therapy, but eventually died 3 months later. These results indicate that infusion of a high numbers of autologous, allostimulated helper PBL is a feasible and safe procedure, which could therefore be used in future studies of adoptive immunotherapy of cancer.

Adoptive immunotherapy of cancer with immune and activated lymphocytes: experimental and clinical studies

Recent studies of passive adoptive immunotherapy of experimental tumors indicate that histologically different neoplasms can be cured by this procedure in mice, rats and guinea pigs. In this paper two main approaches of adoptive immunotherapy with lymphocytes are considered. One which makes use of specific tumor-immune cells and is applicable to immunogenic tumors, and the other which uses activated (allostimulated and/or IL-2-activated) lymphocytes and is applicable to immunogenic and non-immunogenic neoplasms. Experimental models of both approaches and results provided by them are reviewed. These studies indicate that transfer of tumor-reactive lymphocytes with or without the combined administration of IL-2 into syngeneic tumor-bearing animals can lead to the eradication of a disseminated neoplasia when certain conditions are met. In particular, it was found that high tumor burdens, delay of treatment and low number of transferred lymphocytes can adversely affect the results. It has also been shown that the therapeutic effect of treatment with anti-cancer drugs or irradiation may be significantly improved by the addition of adoptive immunotherapy. The successful treatment of immunogenic tumors often requires the inhibition of suppressor lymphocytes by Cy or irradiation. Non-immunogenic tumors can be successfully treated only by providing activated lymphocytes and high doses of IL-2. Recent findings of few available human studies of adoptive immunotherapy are also reviewed, and the problems of toxicity and possible therapeutic effects of infusion of autologous, activated lymphocytes and IL-2 are discussed.

Clonal analysis of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response to autologous human metastatic melanoma

Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from a melanoma (Me) patient, previously shown to be unable to react against the autologous tumor (Me 28) after mixed lymphocyte-tumor culture (MLTC), were cultured in vitro with the autologous tumor in MLTC and/or with IL-2-containing supernatants. T-cell clones were then obtained by limiting dilution and by micromanipulation. Eleven clones, selected for autologous tumor (Auto-Tu) cytotoxicity, were tested for specificity on a panel of 17 cell cultures of normal and neoplastic origin, revealing a complex spectrum of lytic activities. Three groups of clones could be identified depending on the patterns of cytotoxicity. One clone (B11.12) lysed Me28 and expressed a borderline reactivity against one allogeneic Me. A second group of clones (A4, A4.18, H10, E12, C9) lysed the Auto-Tu and allogeneic Me. The last group of clones (A4.2, A4.3, A4.4, A7, B7) expressed a broader pattern of reactivity with significant cytotoxicity against targets of different histologic origin. Furthermore, the second and third groups of clones lysed K562 while B11.12 did not. The Auto-Tu-restricted reactivity of clone B11.12, confirmed by a further test on 13 allogeneic Me and on autologous IL-2 cultured lymphocytes, suggests the recognition of antigenic structures preferentially expressed on Me28. Blocking studies, performed with monoclonal antibodies (MAb), revealed that an anti-HLA class I MAb (w6/32), but not two anti-DR MAbs (L243, DI.12), could inhibit the cytotoxic activity of clones B11.12 on Me28. A significant blocking effect by w6/32 on Me28 was achieved also with clones A4.4 and H10 but not with clones A4.2, A4.3 and A7. The phenotype of all clones was T3+, T4-, T8+, HNK-I-, suggesting that the anti-tumor effectors were of the T-cell lineage. Taken together, these data indicate that it is possible to isolate anti-tumor CTL-clones after MLTC from a PBL population of a metastatic melanoma patient. Furthermore, we present evidence suggesting a role of class-I antigens in the interaction of some cloned effectors with the autologous tumor target.

Autologous cellular immune response to primary and metastatic human melanomas and its regulation by DR antigens expressed on tumor cells

Evidence for heterogeneity of several biological features of human malignant melanoma (Me) like morphology, cytogenetics, oncogenes activation, antigenic expression, metastatizing capacity and procoagulant activity are briefly reviewed in an attempt to distinguish findings related to primary vs. metastatic lesions. In our own studies monoclonal antibodies were used to study expression of MHC class I, class II products and of Me-associated antigens (MAA) on primary and metastatic Me cells. High expression of class I antigens was found in a high percentage of both primary and metastatic tumors, whereas DR and MAA showed a significant variation (from 3 to 90% of cells) in expression both in primary and in metastatic Me. When autologous cell-mediated immune responses were evaluated, it was found that Me cells from primary tumors but not those from lymph node metastases were able to stimulate autologous lymphocytes to proliferate and become cytotoxic for autologous Me. Clonal analysis of cytotoxic lymphocytes was then carried out in order to see whether the lack of lymphocytes reactivity to metastatic cells was due to the absence or to a low frequency of cytotoxic cells in the unstimulated PBL. CTL clones cytotoxic for autologous Me (Auto-Me) cells were indeed isolated. Three classes of CTL clones were identified: 1) one which is cytotoxic for Auto-Me; 2) a second one which lyse Auto-Me and allogeneic Me; and 3) a third one which is cytotoxic for Auto-Me and allogeneic normal and neoplastic cells. Metastatic Me cells, however, had the ability to suppress the stimulation of autologous PBL by alloantigens or IL-2. This effect was dose-dependent and was not due to absorption of IL-2 by Me cells. Since it has been reported that Me cells express class II MHC antigens, we investigated whether there was any correlation between autologous immune responses and DR expression on Me cells. Autologous lymphocytes stimulation was found to occur only with DR+ Me cells from primary lesions, whereas metastatic cells, either DR+ or DR-, did not stimulate autologous PBL. Moreover, the suppressive effect of metastatic Me cells was associated with their expression of DR antigens. The modulation of DR antigens on Me cells by Interferon-gamma correlated positively with their suppressive capacity. Thus, it appears that primary Me can behave differently from the metastatic one in their interactions with the immune system of autologous host. These findings suggest that DR antigens on Me cells may have an important role in the regulation of autologous immune responses.

The inhibition of lymphocyte stimulation by autologous human metastatic melanoma cells correlates with the expression of HLA-DR antigens on the tumor cells

Previous studies indicated that peripheral blood lymphocytes from patients (Pt-PBL) with lymph node metastatic melanomas proliferated in vitro and developed into tumor-restricted cytotoxic lymphocytes in response to alloantigens or interleukin 2 (IL-2). However, Pt-PBL were not stimulated by irradiated autologous metastatic melanoma (Auto-Me) cells. In the present study we report that the lack of stimulatory activity of Auto-Me cells may be due to a suppressive effect exerted by Auto-Me cells on the responder lymphocytes. In fact, we found that in 62% of cases examined, the addition of 5-10% Auto-Me cells to Pt-PBL cultures strongly inhibited both proliferation and the generation of tumor cytotoxic lymphocytes induced by alloantigens or IL-2. The inhibition was dose-dependent and tumor-restricted, and was not due either to toxicity, medium depletion or IL-2 absorption by Auto-Me cells. Normal fibroblasts, K562 cells and autologous E-lymphocytes were not suppressive. Auto-Me cells were able to inhibit Pt-PBL responses only when added during the first 24 h of culture and not later. Phenotypic analysis of Auto-Me cells using monoclonal antibodies directed against HLA-A,B,C, HLA-DR and melanoma-associated antigens revealed that the expression of high levels of DR antigens on Auto-Me cells was associated with an elevated suppressive activity. Conversely, Auto-Me cells with low or undetectable levels of DR antigens were not inhibitory. Furthermore, the increased expression of DR antigens on Auto-Me cells obtained by in vitro treatment with human interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) also resulted in an increased suppressive activity. We conclude that HLA-DR+ metastatic melanoma cells can interfere with the generation of an anti-tumor immune response, thus potentially favoring the escape of the tumor from the host's control mechanism.

Passive adoptive immunotherapy of low-immunogenic BALB/c lymphoma by syngeneic alloimmune T lymphocytes

The virus-induced BALB/c lymphoma YC8 is known to be lysed in vitro by syngeneic lymphoid cells immune to non-H-2 antigens of B10.D2 and DBA/2 backgrounds. This tumor is weakly immunogenic in vivo and kills 100% of syngeneic mice with 1 X 10(3) cells given either intravenously (i.v.) or intraperitoneally (i.p.). We show here that i.v.-injected YC8 cells grow preferentially in the liver, where colonies become microscopically visible after 7-10 days, and, less frequently, in the kidneys and spleen but not in the lung. Passive adoptive immunotherapy of this tumor was carried out with alloimmune BALB/c anti-B10.A, anti-pool (donors were immunized with lymphocytes from 5 different strains), anti-A and anti-DBA/2 splenic and lymph node cells. When administered i.p. 1, 3 or 5 days after tumor cells had been given i.p. and with a schedule of 5 subsequent daily inocula, anti-DBA/2 lymphocytes cured 100%, 80% and 60% of animals respectively. A weaker effect was obtained with anti-pool immune cells whereas anti-B10.A and anti-A lymphoid cells had not therapeutic effects. When given i.v., the anti-DBA/2 immune lymphocytes were able to cure both i.v. and i.p. tumor-injected mice. A significant effect was observed also when the onset of immunotherapy was delayed until 7 or 10 days after tumor injection. By depleting the BALB/c anti-DBA/2 immune cells with appropriate monoclonal antibodies and complement, it was found that Lyt 1+ 2-cells played the major role in eradicating the neoplasm. in vitro phenotypic and functional analysis showed that the immune cell population included 70% of Thy 1+, 38% of Lyt 1+ and 18-20% of Lyt 2+ cells. Immune lymphocytes were not cytotoxic in vitro to YC8 or DBA/2 targets whereas they proliferated after restimulation with DBA/2 but only weakly with YC8 cells. This shows that it is possible to cure mice bearing a disseminated lymphoma which expresses non-immunogenic antigens recognized by BALB/c anti-DBA/2 immune T lymphocytes. These immune lymphocytes had no cytotoxic activity in vitro and their major effector cell subpopulation displayed the Thy 1+, Lyt 1+ phenotype.

Primary but not metastatic human melanomas expressing DR antigens stimulate autologous lymphocytes

Lymphocytes from melanoma patients were stimulated in mixed culture with autologous tumor cells (MLTC) in order to evaluate lymphocyte proliferation and subsequent cytotoxicity on autologous melanoma cells. It was found that melanoma cells from lymph node metastases were unable to induce autologous tumor-cytotoxic cells in 21 cases examined, in 15 of which MLTC also failed to induce lymphocyte proliferation. Patients' lymphocytes, however, were significantly stimulated by allogeneic irradiated lymphocytes and by interleukin 2. To investigate whether the lack of autologous stimulation was restricted to metastatic cells, the immune response of patients with only primary lesions of malignant melanoma was evaluated. It was found that primary melanoma cells were able to induce proliferation in 7 out of 9 (77%) patients, whereas positive cytotoxicity was obtained in 2 out of 4 patients tested. In order to see whether the presence of DR molecules was important for the stimulatory activity, melanoma cells were examined for the expression of DR antigens by indirect immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibodies. Positive autologous MLTC was found in all of six DR+ primary melanomas, whereas the two DR-tumors were unable to stimulate autologous lymphocytes. An anti-DR but not an anti-DC monoclonal antibody was able to block the proliferation of lymphocytes induced by an autologous primary melanoma. Neither MLTC nor cell-mediated killing was obtained with either DR+ or DR-metastatic melanoma. In 60% of the cases tested, however, DR+ metastatic melanoma cells were able to stimulate allogeneic lymphocytes of normal individuals. Increased expression of DR antigens was induced by in vitro treatment with human gamma-interferon in metastatic tumor cells; this caused an increase in the proliferation of allogeneic but not autologous lymphocytes. These findings indicate that primary but not metastatic DR+ melanoma cells are able to activate the proliferation and cytotoxicity of autologous peripheral blood lymphocytes, suggesting a potential role of DR antigens in regulating tumor-host relationships in melanoma patients.

In vitro elicitation of cytotoxic response against a nonimmunogenic murine tumor by allosensitization

The murine lymphoma (thymoma) PIR-2 of C57BL/6 origin, primarily induced in our laboratory by fractionated X-ray irradiation, has been shown to be nonimmunogenic by its failure to immunize syngeneic mice in vivo or to evoke a cytotoxic response in primary mixed lymphocyte-tumor cell cultures (MLTC) in vitro. We were able, however, to demonstrate the existence of anti-PIR-2 cytotoxic cells among allogeneic-primed C57BL/6 responding lymphocytes using the technique of limiting dilution cultures (LDC). The frequency of anti-PIR-2 cytotoxic cells among C57BL/6 lymphocytes sensitized against BALB/c splenocytes in mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) was 1/20 to 1/40, and the cytotoxic activity of positive LDC wells against PIR-2 reached 60% as determined by a 4-h 51Cr-release assay. The frequency of anti-PIR-2 cytotoxic cells could be increased two- to 10-fold (up to 1/4) by removing nylon-wool-adherent cells from the primed cell population and/or by enriching the primed lymphoblast population on a Percoll density gradient. Anti-PIR-2 cytotoxic cells were found to be Thy1+; Lyt1-2+ cells. Clones isolated from the LDC wells manifested strong cytotoxic activity toward PIR-2 cells and the stimulating BALB/c splenocytes but not against other H-2b tumor lines or C57BL/6 splenocytes. We suggest that the procedure of allostimulation in MLC-LDC is an effective in vitro means of generating highly reactive cytotoxic cells against poorly immunogenic neoplasms.