The composition and function of the pulmonary surfactant system during metamorphosis in the tiger salamander Ambystoma tigrinum

Evolution, Development, and Function of the Pulmonary Surfactant System in Normal and Perturbed Environments

Surfactant lipids and proteins form a surface active film at the air-liquid interface of internal gas exchange organs, including swim bladders and lungs. The system is uniquely positioned to meet both the physical challenges associated with a dynamically changing internal air-liquid interface, and the environmental challenges associated with the foreign pathogens and particles to which the internal surface is exposed. Lungs range from simple, transparent, bag-like units to complex, multilobed, compartmentalized structures. Despite this anatomical variability, the surfactant system is remarkably conserved. Here, we discuss the evolutionary origin of the surfactant system, which likely predates lungs. We describe the evolution of surfactant structure and function in invertebrates and vertebrates. We focus on changes in lipid and protein composition and surfactant function from its antiadhesive and innate immune to its alveolar stability and structural integrity functions. We discuss the biochemical, hormonal, autonomic, and mechanical factors that regulate normal surfactant secretion in mature animals. We present an analysis of the ontogeny of surfactant development among the vertebrates and the contribution of different regulatory mechanisms that control this development. We also discuss environmental (oxygen), hormonal and biochemical (glucocorticoids and glucose) and pollutant (maternal smoking, alcohol, and common "recreational" drugs) effects that impact surfactant development. On the adult surfactant system, we focus on environmental variables including temperature, pressure, and hypoxia that have shaped its evolution and we discuss the resultant biochemical, biophysical, and cellular adaptations. Finally, we discuss the effect of major modern gaseous and particulate pollutants on the lung and surfactant system.

The pattern of surfactant cholesterol during vertebrate evolution and development: does ontogeny recapitulate phylogeny?

Pulmonary surfactant is a complex mixture of phospholipids (PLs), neutral lipids and proteins that lines the inner surface of the lung. Here it modulates surface tension, thereby increasing lung compliance and preventing the transudation of fluid. In humans, pulmonary surfactant is comprised of approximately 80% PLs, 12% neutral lipids and 8% protein. In most eutherian (i.e. placental) mammals, cholesterol (Chol) comprises approximately 8-10% by weight or 14-20 mol% of both alveolar and lamellar body surfactant. It is regarded as an integral component of pulmonary surfactant, yet few studies have concentrated on its function or control. The lipid composition is highly conserved within the vertebrates, except that surfactant of teleost fish is dominated by cholesterol, whereas tetrapod pulmonary surfactant contains a high proportion of disaturated phospholipids (DSPs). The primitive Australian dipnoan lungfish Neoceratodus forsterii demonstrates a 'fish-type' surfactant profile, whereas the other derived dipnoans demonstrate a surfactant profile similar to that of tetrapods. Homology of the surfactant proteins within the vertebrates points to a single evolutionary origin for the system and indicates that fish surfactant is a 'protosurfactant'. Among the terrestrial tetrapods, the relative proportions of DSPs and cholesterol vary in response to lung structure, habitat and body temperature (Tb), but not in relation to phylogeny. The cholesterol content of surfactant is elevated in species with simple saccular lungs or in aquatic species or in species with low Tb. The DSP content is highest in complex lungs, particularly of aquatic species or species with high Tb. Cholesterol is controlled separately from the PL component in surfactant. For example, in heterothermic mammals (i.e. mammals that vary their body temperature), the relative amount of cholesterol increases in cold animals. The rapid changes in the Chol to PL ratio in response to various physiological stimuli suggest that these two components have different turnover rates and may be packaged and processed differently. In mammals, the pulmonary surfactant system develops towards the end of gestation and is characterized by an increase in the saturation of PLs in lung washings and the appearance of surfactant proteins in amniotic fluid. In general, the pattern of surfactant development is highly conserved among the amniotes. This conservation of process is demonstrated by an increase in the amount and saturation of the surfactant PLs in the final stages (>75%) of development. Although the ratios of surfactant components (Chol, PL and DSP) are remarkably similar at the time of hatching/birth, the relative timing of the maturation of the lipid profiles differs dramatically between species. The uniformity of composition between species, despite differences in lung morphology, birthing strategy and relationship to each other, implies that the ratios are critical for the onset of pulmonary ventilation. The differences in the timing, on the other hand, appear to relate primarily to birthing strategy and the onset of air breathing. As the amount of cholesterol relative to the phospholipids is highly elevated in immature lungs, the pattern of cholesterol during development and evolution represents an example of ontogeny recapitulating phylogeny. The fact that cholesterol is an important component of respiratory structures that are primitive, when they are not in use or developing in an embryo, demonstrates that this substance has important and exciting roles in surfactant. These roles still remain to be explored.

Ontogeny of the pulmonary surfactant and antioxidant enzyme systems in the viviparous lizard, Tiliqua rugosa

The antioxidant enzyme (AOE) system protects the lung from oxidative damage. The pulmonary surfactant (PS) system lowers the interfacial pressure within the lung, improving lung compliance and aiding lung clearance. In mammals, the AOE and PS systems develop in tandem during the final 10%-20% of gestation. Here, we investigated the development of these systems in the viviparous skink, Tiliqua rugosa. The content of total phospholipid (PL), disaturated phospholipid (DSP), and cholesterol (Chol) increased in lung washings from foetal lizards with advancing gestational age. Similarly, the relative saturation of the PLs increased throughout gestation, with mid-stage 40 foetuses having a DSP/PL equivalent to newborns and adults. Maternal lizards had significantly less total PL, DSP, and Chol than nongravid and newborn lizards; however, the relative composition did not differ from nongravid animals. This presumably results from compression of the lungs under the bulk of the developing foetus. The Chol/PL and Chol/DSP ratios declined early in development such that mid-stage 40 embryos had comparable ratios to both newborns and adults. Thus, it appears that the PS system matures in a similar manner in skinks and in mammals. However, the composition of surfactant is complete some weeks before parturition, probably to enable improved survivorship of the precocial young in the event of premature birth. Unlike the surfactant lipids, the AOEs, catalase, superoxide dismutase, and glutathione peroxidase did not differ appreciably throughout gestation. It appears therefore that like the surfactant lipids the AOE system is in readiness for air breathing throughout the latter stages of gestation, possibly in preparation for premature birth. Unlike mammals, the PS and AOE systems develop independently from one another.

The pulmonary surfactant system matures upon pipping in the freshwater turtle Chelydra serpentina

Pulmonary surfactant (PS), a mixture of phospholipids (PL), neutral lipids and surfactant proteins (SP), lowers surface tension within the lung, which increases lung compliance and improves the removal of fluid at birth. Here, we have examined the expression of thyroid transcription factor-1 (TTF-1) and the surfactant protein SP-B, and also the composition of pulmonary surfactant lipids in the developing lung of the turtle Chelydra serpentina. Lavage and lung tissue were collected from late embryonic, pipped and hatchling turtles. TTF-1, a regulator of gene expression of surfactant proteins and cell differentiation in mammals, was detected using immunohistochemistry in epithelia of the gas-exchange area and conducting airways during late development. Expression declined in hatchlings. SP-B was detected in subsets of cells within the respiratory epithelium at all stages sampled. The same cell types also stained for TTF-1. Turtle surfactant lipids matured toward the end of incubation. Maximal secretion of both total phospholipids and disaturated phospholipid (DSP) occurred at the time of pipping, coincident with the onset of breathing. The DSP/PL ratio increased after pipping, whereas cholesterol levels (Chol) increased prior to pipping. This resulted in a decrease in the Chol/PL and Chol/DSP ratios after pipping. Thus, TTF-1 and SP-B appear to be highly conserved within the vertebrates. Maturation of surfactant phospholipid content occurred with the commencement of pulmonary ventilation.

Development of the pulmonary surfactant system in the green sea turtle, Chelonia mydas

This study describes the developmental changes in pulmonary surfactant (PS) lipids throughout incubation in the sea turtle, Chelonia mydas. Total phospholipid (PL), disaturated phospholipid (DSP) and cholesterol (Chol) harvested from lung washings increased with advancing incubation, where secretion was maximal at pipping, coincident with the onset of pulmonary ventilation. The DSP/PL ratio increased, whereas the Chol/PL and the Chol/DSP ratio declined throughout development. The phospholipids, therefore, are independently regulated from Chol and their development matches that of mammals. To explore whether hypoxia could elicit an effect on the development of the PS system, embryos were exposed to a chronic dose of 17% O2 for the final approximately 40% of incubation. Hypoxia did not affect incubation time, absolute, nor relative abundance of the surfactant lipids, demonstrating that the development of the system is robust and that embryonic development continues unabated under mild hypoxia. Hypoxia-incubated hatchlings had lighter wet lung weights than those from normoxia, inferring that mild hypoxia facilitates lung clearance in this species.

The roles of cholesterol in pulmonary surfactant: insights from comparative and evolutionary studies

In most eutherian mammals, cholesterol (Chol) comprises approximately 8-10 wt.% or 14-20 mol.% of both alveolar and lamellar body surfactant. It is regarded as an integral component of pulmonary surfactant, yet few studies have concentrated on its function or control. Throughout the evolution of the vertebrates, the contribution of cholesterol relative to surfactant phospholipids decreases, while that of the disaturated phospholipids (DSP) increases. Chol generally appears to dominate in animals with primitive bag-like lungs that lack septation, in the saccular lung of snakes or swimbladders which are not used predominantly for respiration, and also in immature lungs. It is possible that in these systems, cholesterol represents a protosurfactant. Cholesterol is controlled separately from the phospholipid (PL) component in surfactant. For example, in heterothermic mammals such as the fat-tailed dunnart, Sminthopsis crassicaudata, and the microchiropteran bat, Chalinolobus gouldii, and also in the lizard, Ctenophorus nuchalis, the relative amount of Chol increases in cold animals. During the late stages of embryonic development in chickens and lizards, the Chol to PL and Chol to DSP ratios decrease dramatically. While in isolated lizard lungs, adrenaline and acetylcholine stimulate the secretion of surfactant PL, Chol secretion remains unaffected. This is also supported in isolated cell studies of lizards and dunnarts. The rapid changes in the Chol to PL ratio in response to various physiological stimuli suggest that these two components have different turnover rates and may be packaged and processed differently. Infusion of [3H]cholesterol into the rat tail vein resulted in a large increase in Chol specific activity within 30 min in the lamellar body (LB) fraction, but over a 48-h period, failed to appear in the alveolar surfactant fraction. Analysis of the limiting membrane of the lamellar bodies revealed a high (76%) concentration of LB cholesterol. The majority of lamellar body Chol is, therefore, not released into the alveolar compartment, as the limiting membrane fuses with the cell membrane upon exocytosis. It appears unlikely, therefore, that lamellar bodies are the major source of alveolar Chol. It is possible that the majority of alveolar Chol is synthesised endogenously within the lung and stored independently from surfactant phospholipids. The role of cholesterol in the limiting membrane of the lamellar body may be to enable fast and easy processing by maintaining the membrane in a relatively fluid state.

The comparative biology of pulmonary surfactant: past, present and future

Richard E. Pattle contributed enormously to the biology of the pulmonary surfactant system. However, Pattle can also be regarded as the founding father of comparative and evolutionary research of the surfactant system. He contributed eight seminal papers of the 167 publications we have located on this topic. In particular, Pattle produced a synthesis interpreting the evolution of the surfactant system that formed the foundation for the area. Prepared 25 years ago this synthesis spawned the three great discoveries in the comparative biology of the surfactant system: (1) that the surfactant system has been highly conserved throughout the enormous radiation of the air breathing vertebrates; (2) that temperature is the major selective condition that influences surfactant composition; (3) that acting as an anti-adhesive is one primitive and ubiquitous function of vertebrate surfactant. Here we review the literature and history of the comparative and evolutionary biology of the surfactant system and highlight the areas of comparative physiology that will contribute to our understanding of the surfactant system in the future. In our view the surfactant system is a neatly packaged system, located in a single cell and highly conserved, yet spectacularly complex. The surfactant system is one of the best systems we know to examine evolutionary processes in physiology as well as gain important insights into gas transfer by complex organisms.

Development of the pulmonary surfactant system in non-mammalian amniotes

Pulmonary surfactant (PS) is a complex mixture of phospholipids, neutral lipids and proteins that lines the inner surface of the lung. Here, it modulates surface tension thereby increasing lung compliance and preventing the transudation of fluid. In mammals, the PS system develops towards the end of gestation, characterized by an increase in the saturation of phospholipids in lung washings and the appearance of surfactant proteins in amniotic fluid. Birth, the transition from in utero to the external environment, is a rapid process. At this time, the PS system is important in opening and clearing the lung of fluid in order to initiate pulmonary ventilation. In oviparous vertebrates, escape from an egg can be a long and exhausting process. The young commence pulmonary ventilation and hatching by 'pipping' through the eggshell, where they remain for some time, presumably clearing their lungs. This paper relates changes in the development of the pulmonary surfactant system within the non-mammalian amniotes in response to birth strategy, lung morphology and phylogeny in order to determine the conservatism of this developmental process. Total phospholipid (PL), disaturated phospholipid (DSP) and cholesterol (Chol) were quantified from lung washings of embryonic and hatchling chickens, bearded dragons (oviparous), sleepy lizards (viviparous), snapping turtles and green sea turtles throughout the final stages of incubation and gestation. In all cases, the pattern of development of the pulmonary surfactant lipids was consistent with that of mammals. PL and DSP increased throughout the latter stages of development and Chol was differentially regulated from the PLs. Maximal secretion of both PL and DSP occurred at 'pipping' in oviparous reptiles, coincident with the onset of airbreathing. Similarly, the amount of DSP relative to total PL was maximal immediately after the initiation of airbreathing in chickens. The relative timing of the appearance of the lipids differed between groups. In the oviparous lizard, surfactant lipids were released over a relatively shorter time than that of the sleepy lizard, turtles, birds and mammals. Thus, despite temporal differences and vastly different lung morphologies, birth strategies and phylogenies, the overall development and maturation of the PS system is highly conserved amongst the amniotes.

Surfactant proteins and cell markers in the respiratory epithelium of the amphibian, Ambystoma mexicanum

The respiratory tract is lined by diverse epithelial cell types whose morphology, gene expression and functions are highly specialized along the cephalo-caudal axis of the lung. Pulmonary gas exchange, surface tension reduction, host defense, fluid and electrolyte transport are functions shared by various vertebrate species, each organism facing similar requirements for adaptation to air breathing. Consistent with this concept, we have identified distinct respiratory epithelial cell populations in the amphibian, Ambystoma mexicanum, using morphologic, histochemical and immunochemical techniques. Thyroid transcription factor-1 (TTF-1), a homeodomain nuclear transcription factor critical to lung formation, and surfactant protein B (SP-B), an amphipathic polypeptide required for surfactant function, were detected in the peripheral respiratory epithelial cells of the axolotl lung, in cells with characteristics of Type II alveolar epithelial cells in mammals. beta-Tubulin and carbohydrate staining identified distinct subsets of ciliated and goblet cells. SP-D, a member of the collectin family of innate host defense proteins, was also detected in peripheral epithelial cells of the axolotl lung. Pulmonary surfactant and host defense proteins are shared across diverse phyla supporting the concept that pulmonary structure and function have evolved from common ancestors.

Development of the pulmonary surfactant system in two oviparous vertebrates

In birds and oviparous reptiles, hatching is often a lengthy and exhausting process, which commences with pipping followed by lung clearance and pulmonary ventilation. We examined the composition of pulmonary surfactant in the developing lungs of the chicken, Gallus gallus, and of the bearded dragon, Pogona vitticeps. Lung tissue was collected from chicken embryos at days 14, 16, 18 (prepipped), and 20 (postpipped) of incubation and from 1 day and 3 wk posthatch and adult animals. In chickens, surfactant protein A mRNA was detected using Northern blot analysis in lung tissue at all stages sampled, appearing relatively earlier in development compared with placental mammals. Chickens were lavaged at days 16, 18, and 20 of incubation and 1 day posthatch, whereas bearded dragons were lavaged at day 55, days 57-60 (postpipped), and days 58-61 (posthatched). In both species, total phospholipid (PL) from the lavage increased throughout incubation. Disaturated PL (DSP) was not measurable before 16 days of incubation in the chick embryo nor before 55 days in bearded dragons. However, the percentage of DSP/PL increased markedly throughout late development in both species. Because cholesterol (Chol) remained unchanged, the Chol/PL and Chol/DSP ratios decreased in both species. Thus the Chol and PL components are differentially regulated. The lizard surfactant system develops and matures over a relatively shorter time than that of birds and mammals. This probably reflects the highly precocial nature of hatchling reptiles.

The influence of temperature, phylogeny, and lung structure on the lipid composition of reptilian pulmonary surfactant

The lungs of all air-breathing vertebrates contain a form of pulmonary surfactant that lines the alveolar air-water interface where it modifies the interfacial surface tension. These pulmonary surfactants all consist of varying amounts of phospholipids (saturated and unsaturated) and cholesterol. The extent of variation between vertebrate groups and between species within a vertebrate group has been attributed to differences in factors such as phylogeny, body temperature, habitat, and lung structure. The influence of these factors on amphibian surfactant composition and function has been studied, but the reptiles, which comprise a polyphyletic group of vertebrates, have never been critically examined. The surfactant lipid composition from species belonging to the three groups of reptiles, the Archosauria (crocodiles), Lepidosauria (snakes and lizards), and Anapsida (turtles), has been determined. New data is presented in conjunction with already published data to create an evolutionary framework that concentrates particularly on the influence of phylogeny, body temperature, and lung structure on the composition of the surfactant lipids. Large amounts of pulmonary surfactant were found in all species of reptiles. All species lavaged at 23 degrees C (except C. atrox) demonstrated DSP/PL ratios of 23-33%. Animals with multicameral lungs exhibited an elevated CHOL/DSP ratio compared with species with unicameral lungs. In all groups, phosphatidylcholine (PC) was the dominant (60-80%) phospholipid. Phosphatidylserine and phosphatidylinositol (PS/PI) and sphingomyelin (S) represented the other phospholipids, while phosphatidylglycerol (PG), lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC), and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) were occasionally observed. In two species of lizards (C. nuchalis and P. vitticeps), the saturated fatty acid, palmitic acid (16:0), was the dominant tail group on the phospholipids. Oleic acid (18:1) was the dominant monounsaturated fatty acid, whereas polyunsaturates comprised about a fifth of the total fatty acid profile. Short-term (4 h) changes in temperature did not affect the relative proportions of the fatty acids in either species. Comparison of the current data with previously published literature suggests that phylogeny and habitat do not significantly influence surfactant lipid composition, but body temperature and to a lesser extent lung structure are important determinants of reptilian surfactant lipid composition.

Factors affecting opening and filling pressures in the lungs of the lizard Pogona vitticeps

We have previously reported that levels of pulmonary surfactant in the lungs of the lizard Pogona vitticeps increase with increasing body temperature. Static lung compliance decreases with increasing body temperature, and is only marginally affected by the presence of surfactant. Here, we examined the effects of surfactant, temperature, ventilatory pattern and autonomic neurotransmitters on opening and filling pressures. Isolated lungs were ventilated at either 18 or 37 degrees C at low, intermediate and high ventilatory regimes. The effects of acetylcholine and adrenaline were examined using an isolated perfused lung preparation at 27 degrees C. Changing ventilatory pattern or experimental temperature had no effect on either filling or opening pressures. Removal of surfactant increased both opening and filling pressures. Adrenaline administration reduced opening and filling pressures. Normal variations in surfactant levels, which occur with changes in body temperature, do not affect either opening or filling pressures. A critical amount of surfactant may be necessary to prevent adhesion of epithelial surfaces in the lungs of Pogona vitticeps. The anti-glue function of pulmonary surfactant may be more important at 18 than at 37 degrees C.

The composition and function of reptilian pulmonary surfactant

In mammals, the surface tension of the fluid lining the inner lung greatly contributes to the work of breathing. Surface tension is modified by the secretion of a mixture of surface active lipids and proteins (termed pulmonary surfactant). A disaturated phospholipid (DSP), predominantly dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), can eliminate surface tension under high dynamic compression. Cholesterol (CHOL) and unsaturated phospholipids (USP) promote respreading upon inflation by converting DPPC to the disordered liquid-crystalline state. It appeared to us that a surfactant rich in DPPC, which has a high phase transition temperature of 41 degrees C, is likely to be of only limited use in the lungs of reptiles, many of which have preferred body temperatures between 20 and 30 degrees C. We review here the presence and composition of surfactant in species from the three subclasses of the Reptilia and relate these to lung structure and function, phylogeny and environmental selection pressures such as body temperature. We also discuss the function of reptilian surfactant and the factors which control surfactant turnover. Large amounts of pulmonary surfactant have been found in all reptiles so far examined. In general, warmer reptiles have greater amounts of surfactant which is also relatively enriched in DSP. Cold lizards (18 degrees C) have significantly elevated levels of surfactant cholesterol. As in all vertebrates, PC is always the dominant phospholipid (60-80%). Unlike mammals, phosphatidylglycerol (PG) is absent, with the exception of one species. The remaining phospholipid groups are present to varying degrees. The saturated fatty acid, palmitic acid (16:0) is the dominant acyl group, oleic acid (18:1) is the dominant mono-unsaturated fatty acid, and polyunsaturates comprise only about 20% of the total fatty acid profile. For two species of dragon lizards, short term changes in temperature do not affect the fatty acids, but protracted periods of cold significantly decrease the presence of 16:0 in turtle lavage (Lau and Keough, Can.J. Biochem. 59: 208-219, 1981). Surfactant appears to function as an antiglue in most reptiles, serving to lower opening pressure, and decrease the work of breathing. However, surface tension forces generally do not influence reptilian lung compliance, suggesting that the primary functions of mammalian surfactant are not necessarily relevant to reptiles.