A functional map of the nopaline catabolism genes on the Ti plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58

Lifestyle of the biotroph Agrobacterium tumefaciens in the ecological niche constructed on its host plant

Agrobacterium tumefaciens constructs an ecological niche in its host plant by transferring the T-DNA from its Ti plasmid into the host genome and by diverting the host metabolism. We combined transcriptomics and genetics for understanding the A. tumefaciens lifestyle when it colonizes Arabidopsis thaliana tumors. Transcriptomics highlighted: a transition from a motile to sessile behavior that mobilizes some master regulators (Hfq, CtrA, DivK and PleD); a remodeling of some cell surface components (O-antigen, succinoglucan, curdlan, att genes, putative fasciclin) and functions associated with plant defense (Ef-Tu and flagellin pathogen-associated molecular pattern-response and glycerol-3-phosphate and nitric oxide signaling); and an exploitation of a wide variety of host resources, including opines, amino acids, sugars, organic acids, phosphate, phosphorylated compounds, and iron. In addition, construction of transgenic A. thaliana lines expressing a lactonase enzyme showed that Ti plasmid transfer could escape host-mediated quorum-quenching. Finally, construction of knock-out mutants in A. tumefaciens showed that expression of some At plasmid genes seemed more costly than the selective advantage they would have conferred in tumor colonization. We provide the first overview of A. tumefaciens lifestyle in a plant tumor and reveal novel signaling and trophic interplays for investigating host-pathogen interactions.

Structural Basis for High Specificity of Amadori Compound and Mannopine Opine Binding in Bacterial Pathogens

Agrobacterium tumefaciens pathogens genetically modify their host plants to drive the synthesis of opines in plant tumors. Opines are either sugar phosphodiesters or the products of condensed amino acids with ketoacids or sugars. They are Agrobacterium nutrients and imported into the bacterial cell via periplasmic-binding proteins (PBPs) and ABC-transporters. Mannopine, an opine from the mannityl-opine family, is synthesized from an intermediate named deoxy-fructosyl-glutamine (DFG), which is also an opine and abundant Amadori compound (a name used for any derivative of aminodeoxysugars) present in decaying plant materials. The PBP MotA is responsible for mannopine import in mannopine-assimilating agrobacteria. In the nopaline-opine type agrobacteria strain, SocA protein was proposed as a putative mannopine binding PBP, and AttC protein was annotated as a mannopine binding-like PBP. Structural data on mannityl-opine-PBP complexes is currently lacking. By combining affinity data with analysis of seven x-ray structures at high resolution, we investigated the molecular basis of MotA, SocA, and AttC interactions with mannopine and its DFG precursor. Our work demonstrates that AttC is not a mannopine-binding protein and reveals a specific binding pocket for DFG in SocA with an affinity in nanomolar range. Hence, mannopine would not be imported into nopaline-type agrobacteria strains. In contrast, MotA binds both mannopine and DFG. We thus defined one mannopine and two DFG binding signatures. Unlike mannopine-PBPs, selective DFG-PBPs are present in a wide diversity of bacteria, including Actinobacteria, α-,β-, and γ-proteobacteria, revealing a common role of this Amadori compound in pathogenic, symbiotic, and opportunistic bacteria.

Agrobacterium uses a unique ligand-binding mode for trapping opines and acquiring a competitive advantage in the niche construction on plant host

By modifying the nuclear genome of its host, the plant pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens induces the development of plant tumours in which it proliferates. The transformed plant tissues accumulate uncommon low molecular weight compounds called opines that are growth substrates for A. tumefaciens. In the pathogen-induced niche (the plant tumour), a selective advantage conferred by opine assimilation has been hypothesized, but not experimentally demonstrated. Here, using genetics and structural biology, we deciphered how the pathogen is able to bind opines and use them to efficiently compete in the plant tumour. We report high resolution X-ray structures of the periplasmic binding protein (PBP) NocT unliganded and liganded with the opine nopaline (a condensation product of arginine and α-ketoglurate) and its lactam derivative pyronopaline. NocT exhibited an affinity for pyronopaline (K_D of 0.6 µM) greater than that for nopaline (K_D of 3.7 µM). Although the binding-mode of the arginine part of nopaline/pyronopaline in NocT resembled that of arginine in other PBPs, affinity measurement by two different techniques showed that NocT did not bind arginine. In contrast, NocT presented specific residues such as M117 to stabilize the bound opines. NocT relatives that exhibit the nopaline/pyronopaline-binding mode were only found in genomes of the genus Agrobacterium. Transcriptomics and reverse genetics revealed that A. tumefaciens uses the same pathway for assimilating nopaline and pyronopaline. Fitness measurements showed that NocT is required for a competitive colonization of the plant tumour by A. tumefaciens. Moreover, even though the Ti-plasmid conjugal transfer was not regulated by nopaline, the competitive advantage gained by the nopaline-assimilating Ti-plasmid donors led to a preferential horizontal propagation of this Ti-plasmid amongst the agrobacteria colonizing the plant-tumour niche. This work provided structural and genetic evidences to support the niche construction paradigm in bacterial pathogens.

An ecological niche is defined, in a given environment, by the availability of nutritive resources, which can be specifically assimilated by certain living organisms to promote their proliferation. The bacterial pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens is able to engineer an ecological niche in the infected host via the transformation of the plant genome and diversion of the plant metabolism towards production of the opine nutrients. In this work, we quantified the selective advantage conferred to a member of the phytopathogenic species A. tumefaciens which is able to assimilate the opine nopaline. This opine is a condensate of arginine and α-ketoglurate that is produced both under linear and cyclic forms in the plant tumour environment. We further determined at the molecular and atomistic levels how A. tumefaciens is able to sense the nopaline molecules, and which metabolic pathways are activated in response. Overall, this work deciphered some key molecular events in the niche construction of the pathogen A. tumefaciens that is unique among living organisms and used to develop bioengineering tools.

Concerted transfer of the virulence Ti plasmid and companion At plasmid in the Agrobacterium tumefaciens-induced plant tumour

The plant pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58 harbours three independent type IV secretion (T4SS) machineries. T4SST-DNA promotes the transfer of the T-DNA to host plant cells, provoking tumour development and accumulation of opines such as nopaline and agrocinopines. T4SSpTi and T4SSpAt control the bacterial conjugation of the Ti and At plasmids respectively. Expression of T4SSpTi is controlled by the agrocinopine-responsive transcriptional repressor AccR. In this work, we compared the genome-wide transcriptional profile of the wild-type A. tumefaciens strain C58 with that of its accR KO-mutant to delineate the AccR regulon. In addition to the genes that encode agrocinopine catabolism and T4SSpTi , we found that AccR also regulated genes coding for nopaline catabolism and T4SSpAt . Further opine detection and conjugation assays confirmed the enhancement of nopaline consumption and At plasmid conjugation frequency in accR. Moreover, co-regulation of the T4SSpTi and T4SSpAt correlated with the co-transfer of the At and Ti plasmids both in vitro and in plant tumours. Finally, unlike T4SSpTi , T4SSpAt activation does not require quorum-sensing. Overall this study highlights the regulatory interplays between opines, At and Ti plasmids that contribute to a concerted dissemination of the two replicons in bacterial populations colonizing the plant tumour.

The ntrC gene of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58 controls glutamine synthetase (GSII) activity, growth on nitrate and chromosomal but not Ti-encoded arginine catabolism pathways

The ntrC locus of Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58 has been cloned using the Azorhizobium sesbaniae ORS571 ntrC gene as a DNA hybridization probe. Transposon Tn5 mutagenesis of the cloned ntrC locus was carried out and one Tn5 insertion within the region of highest DNA homology with A. sesbaniae ORS571 ntrC was used for gene replacement of the wild-type C58 ntrC gene. The A. tumefaciens ntrC::Tn5 mutant was found to be unable to grow on nitrate as sole nitrogen (N) source, to lack glutamine synthetase (GSII) activity and to be unable to use arginine (or ornithine) as sole N source, unless the Ti-encoded arginine catabolism pathway was induced with small amounts of nopaline. Thus the A. tumefaciens ntrC regulatory gene is essential for (transcriptional) activation of the GSII and nitrate reductase genes, as well as for the chromosomal but not the Ti-borne arginine catabolism pathways.

Genetic analysis of the agrocinopine catabolic region of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmid pTiC58, which encodes genes required for opine and agrocin 84 transport

The acc region, subcloned from pTiC58 of classical nopaline and agrocinopine A and B Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58, allowed agrobacteria to grow using agrocinopine B as the sole source of carbon and energy. acc is approximately 6 kb in size. It consists of at least five genes, accA through accE, as defined by complementation analysis using subcloned fragments and transposon insertion mutations of acc carried on different plasmids within the same cell. All five regions are required for agrocin 84 sensitivity, and at least four are required for agrocinopine and agrocin 84 uptake. The complementation results are consistent with the hypothesis that each of the five regions is separately transcribed. Maxicell experiments showed that the first of these genes, accA, encodes a 60-kDa protein. Analysis of osmotic shock fractions showed this protein to be located in the periplasm. The DNA sequence of the accA region revealed an open reading frame encoding a predicted polypeptide of 59,147 Da. The amino acid sequence encoded by this open reading frame is similar to the periplasmic binding proteins OppA and DppA of Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium and OppA of Bacillus subtilis.

Dynamic structure of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmids

Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58F is a variant of strain C58 which generates a high proportion of avirulent mutants in the presence of the virulence (vir) gene inducer acetosyringone. These mutants are altered in the Ti plasmid and do not respond to the acetosyringone signal (C. Fortin, E. W. Nester, and P. Dion, J. Bacteriol. 174:5676-5685, 1992). The physical organization of the Ti plasmid was compared in strain C58 and its variant. One feature distinguishing pTiC58F from its parent plasmid was the presence of the insertion element IS426. Three copies of this element were detected in the strain C58 chromosome, whereas two additional copies were found in strain C58F, including one copy in the Ti plasmid. This particular copy of IS426 was associated with the region of arginine and nopaline catabolism of pTiC58F. Most of the avirulent mutants recovered following growth of strain C58F in the presence of acetosyringone were complemented by clones carrying either virA or virG. Element IS426 was no longer found in the arginine and nopaline catabolism region of the Ti plasmids from the virA and virG mutants, but it resided in the particular KpnI fragment containing the modified vir locus. Behavior of a strain C58F derivative, which was inactivated in a chromosomal component required for the response to acetosyringone, was consistent with the possibility that vir gene induction is essential to the massive production of avirulent mutants.

Physical map of the vitopine Ti plasmid pTiS4

Within the Agrobacterium vitis group the vitopine strains represent a special subclass. Vitopine bacteria carry Ti plasmids with little or no homology with the well-characterized T-DNAs of Agrobacterium tumefaciens or Agrobacterium rhizogenes. The 262-kb Ti plasmid of the vitopine strain S4 was cloned and mapped. Homology studies with the octopine Ti plasmid pTiAch5, the nopaline Ti plasmid pTiC58, and the agropine/mannopine Ri plasmid pRiHRI identified several regions of homology. The origin of replication was localized to within 2.5 kb.

Opine transport genes in the octopine (occ) and nopaline (noc) catabolic regions in Ti plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The occ and noc regions of octopine and nopaline Ti plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens are responsible for the catabolic utilization of octopine and nopaline, respectively. Opine-inducible promoters, genes for regulatory proteins and for catabolic enzymes, had been identified in previous work. However, both regions contained additional DNA stretches which were under the control of opine-inducible promoters, but the functions were unknown. We investigated these stretches by DNA sequence and functional analyses. The sequences showed that both of the catabolic regions contain a set of four genes which are transcribed in the same direction. The occ and noc region genes are related, but the arrangement of the genes is different. The deduced polypeptides are related to those of binding protein-dependent transport systems of basic amino acids in other bacteria. The comparison suggested that three of the polypeptides are located in the membrane and that one is a periplasmic protein. We constructed cassettes which contained either the putative transport genes only or the complete occ or noc region; all constructs, however, included the elements necessary for opine-induced expression of the genes (the regulatory gene and the inducible promoters). Uptake studies with 3H-labelled octopine showed that the putative transport genes in the occ region code for octopine uptake proteins. The corresponding studies with 3H-labelled nopaline and the noc region cassettes indicated that the uptake of nopaline requires the putative transport genes and additional functions from the left part of the noc region.

Characteristics of the nopaline catabolic plasmid in Agrobacterium strains K84 and K1026 used for biological control of crown gall disease

Wild-type Agrobacterium radiobacter strain 84 and its Tra- derivative K1026, used for biological control of crown gall disease, each contain the plasmid pAtK84b. It confers incompatibility to tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmids of pathogenic A. tumefaciens, thus preventing transfer of Ti plasmids into K84 and K1026, and the consequent development of pathogens resistant to the specific antibiotic, agrocin 84 produced by K84 and K1026. pAtK84b also resembles one group of Ti plasmids in its capacity for directing nopaline catabolism. A study of the DNA homology among pAtK84b, pTiC58, and pTiAch5 was carried out. pAtK84b was transferred by conjugation to a plasmidless recipient and, after isolation, was hybridized with Ti plasmid DNA. Areas of DNA homology were located on published maps of pTiC58 and pTiAch5, a restriction enzyme map of pAtK84b was constructed, and areas of homology with DNA of known genetic function were located on the map. Strong and extensive (over 50%) homology was found between pAtK84b and pTiC58 (nopaline catabolic, Noc), but much less between pAtK84b and pTiAch5 (octopine catabolic). There was no detectable homology between pAtK84b and the oncogenic T-DNA and virulence (Vir) regions of either Ti plasmid. The size of pAtK84b was 173 kb and the orientation of regions of identified gene function (Noc, incompatability/origin of replication, and conjugal transfer) on pTiC58 was matched by the locations of homologous areas on pAtK84b. It is concluded that pAtK84b may be a deletion product of a pTiC58-type plasmid which has been disarmed in the oncogenic T-DNA and Vir regions.

Arginase of Agrobacterium Ti plasmid C58. DNA sequence, properties, and comparison with eucaryotic enzymes

Agrobacterium nopaline Ti plasmids code for three enzymes of nopaline [N2-(1,3-dicarboxypropyl)-L-arginine] degradation: nopaline oxidase, arginase, and ornithine cyclodeaminase. We describe the DNA sequence of the arginase gene, a comparison of the deduced protein sequence with eucaryotic arginases, and properties of the procaryotic enzyme. The results show that the agrobacterial arginase is related with arginases from yeast, rat liver, and human liver (28-33% identity). The Ti plasmid enzyme revealed several properties which appear common to all arginases, but it does not utilize L-canavanine as substrate, and its Mn2+ requirement is not satisfied by Fe2+, Co2+, or Ni2+. The properties of arginase and ornithine cyclodeaminase are discussed as part of the mechanisms which avoid depletion of L-arginine and L-ornithine pools for biosynthetic reactions during catabolic utilization of nopaline.

A new NAD+-dependent opine dehydrogenase from Arthrobacter sp. strain 1C

A new NAD+-dependent opine dehydrogenase was purified to homogeneity from Arthrobacter sp. strain 1C isolated from soil by an enrichment culture technique. The enzyme has a molecular weight of about 70,000 and consists of two identical subunits with molecular weights of about 36,000. The enzyme catalyzed a reversible oxidation-reduction reaction of opine-type secondary amine dicarboxylic acids. In the oxidative deamination reaction, the enzyme was active toward unusual opines, such as N-[1-R-(carboxyl)ethyl]-S-methionine and N-[1-R-(carboxyl)ethyl]-S-phenylalanine. In the reductive secondary amine-forming reaction with NADH as a cofactor, the enzyme utilized L-amino acids such as L-methionine, L-isoleucine, L-valine, L-phenylalanine, L-leucine, L-alanine, and L-threonine as amino donors and alpha-keto acids such as pyruvate, oxaloacetate, glyoxylate, and alpha-ketobutyrate as amino acceptors. The product enzymatically synthesized from L-phenylalanine and pyruvate in the presence of NADH was identified as N-[1-R-(carboxyl)ethyl]-S-phenylalanine.

Ornithine cyclodeaminase from octopine Ti plasmid Ach5: identification, DNA sequence, enzyme properties, and comparison with gene and enzyme from nopaline Ti plasmid C58

Octopine and nopaline are two arginine-derived opines synthesized in plant cells transformed with octopine or nopaline plasmids. Utilization in Agrobacterium tumefaciens is mediated by Ti plasmid regions called occ or noc (octopine or nopaline catabolism), and recent experiments showed that noc in pTiC58 codes for a pathway from nopaline to L-proline. The last enzyme is ornithine cyclodeaminase (OCD), an unusual protein converting L-ornithine directly into L-proline. We investigated whether octopine plasmid pTiAch5 also harbors a gene for OCD. The results revealed an ocd gene which is induced by octopine and maps in the occ region. DNA sequence analysis and comparison with the gene from pTiC58 showed that the two genes are related (69% homology in DNA and deduced amino acid sequence), and antiserum against OCD(C58) also reacted with OCD(Ach5). The enzyme activity was characterized, and a comparison with OCD(C58) showed that the properties are similar, but not identical. Differences were detected in the regulation of enzyme activity by L-arginine and L-proline and in the response to varying ratios of NAD+/NADH. It is proposed that this reflects different mechanisms for integration of opine catabolism into general metabolism.

Purification and properties of the gamma-butyrobetaine-binding protein from an Agrobacterium sp

A binding protein for gamma-butyrobetaine was purified from osmotic shock fluid of an Agrobacterium sp. It was a monomeric protein with an apparent molecular weight of 52,000 or 53,000 as determined by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and gel filtration, respectively. The isoelectric point was 4.3, as determined by isoelectric focusing. Amino acid analysis of the protein showed that Asx and Glx were predominant components and that the protein contained no cysteine. The dissociation constant of this protein for gamma-butyrobetaine was found to be 0.7 microM by equilibrium dialysis. Attempts to sequence the amino-terminal end with the Edman method failed, suggesting that this region of the protein is blocked.

Ornithine cyclodeaminase from Ti plasmid C58: DNA sequence, enzyme properties and regulation of activity by arginine

Nopaline, an abundant opine in plant cells transformed with nopaline-type Ti plasmids, is catabolized in Agrobacterium by three Ti-plasmid-coded steps via arginine and ornithine to proline. The last enzyme, ornithine cyclodeaminase (OCD), converts ornithine directly into proline with release of ammonia. We describe the DNA sequence of the ocd gene from Ti plasmid C58, antiserum against an OCD fusion protein overexpressed in Escherichia coli, induction and identification of the gene product in Agrobacterium and enzymatic properties of the protein. The DNA sequence suggests a soluble protein with a stretch of some homology with ornithine carbamoyltransferases from other bacteria. OCD activity is subject to substrate inhibition, is stimulated by NAD+ (presumably acting as a catalytic cofactor) and is regulated by L-arginine which has pronounced effects on the optima for pH and temperature and on the Km for ornithine. The regulation of OCD activity by L-arginine is discussed as part of the mechanisms which integrate the pathway of Ti-plasmid-coded opine utilization with general metabolism in Agrobacterium.

The Noc region of Ti plasmid C58 codes for arginase and ornithine cyclodeaminase

Plant tumors induced by Agrobacterium tumefaciens synthesize a group of substances (opines) which can serve as sole source of carbon and nitrogen for the bacteria. We investigate Ti-plasmid-coded genes and enzymes involved in catabolism of the opine N2-(1,3-dicarboxypropyl)-L-arginine (nopaline) with a novel approach: expression and mapping of protein-coding regions in Escherichia coli minicells, followed by identification of enzyme functions in the heterologous E. coli background. The results show that a specific part of the nopaline catabolism (Noc) region of Ti plasmid C58 is packed with closely spaced protein-coding regions which can be expressed into polypeptides of distinct sizes in E. coli. We identify and map three enzyme activities: nopaline oxidase, arginase and ornithine cyclodeaminase, an unusual protein converting ornithine directly into proline. Nopaline oxidase requires two different Noc-gene-encoded proteins for function and the latter two enzymes are new discoveries in the Noc region. These three enzyme activities together constitute a catabolic pathway leading from nopaline through arginine and ornithine to proline.

Proline biosynthesis encoded by the noc and occ loci of Agrobacterium Ti plasmids

Octopine or nopaline Ti plasmids, or clones encoding their occ or noc loci, allowed proline auxotrophs of Agrobacterium tumefaciens to utilize the appropriate arginyl opine as a proline substitute. Arginine and ornithine substituted for proline only if the occ or noc loci were induced or made constitutive by mutation. These results support a report demonstrating a Ti plasmid-encoded activity in A. tumefaciens which cyclizes ornithine to proline.